Read the whole magazine - Australian Medical Association (NSW)
Transcription
Read the whole magazine - Australian Medical Association (NSW)
THE NSW THE OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF THE AUSTRALIAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION (NSW) PRINT POST APPROVED PP100000829 VOL 8 - NUMBER 04 - JULY/AUGUST 2016 doctor SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING GET YOUR HEART RACING WITH LUXURY AT SYDNEY CITY LEXUS EXCLUSIVE TO AMA MEMBERS Discover a new level of luxury and smooth performance at Sydney City Lexus. It is with pleasure that Sydney City Lexus offer this incomparable driving experience to you with Lexus Corporate Programme, by providing a service uniquely tailored to our corporate clients. PURCHASING FROM SYDNEY CITY LEXUS WILL NOW BE EVEN MORE REWARDING EARN POINTS* Earn one Qantas Point** for every dollar spent on the purchase of a new Lexus. BENEFITS OF THE LEXUS CORPORATE PROGRAMME INCLUDE: • • • Three year / 60,000km complimentary scheduled servicing* Four year / 100,000km warranty# Reduced dealer pre-delivery fee EXCLUSIVE TO AMA MEMBERS: • • • Earn one Qantas Point** for every dollar spent on the purchase of a new Lexus Priority invitations to Sydney City Lexus corporate events Dedicated Lexus / AMA Member contact person for all enquiries LEXUS CORPORATE PROGRAMME INCORPORATES ENCORE PRIVILEGES: • • • • Complimentary service loan vehicles and pick-up and drop off during servicing Lexus DriveCare providing 24 hour roadside assistance Lexus Exclusive Events Beyond by Lexus Magazine 824 Bourke St, Waterloo NSW 2017 (02) 8303 1900 sydneycitylexus.com.au *Complimentary scheduled servicing expires at 3 years or 60,000km from the date of first registration, whichever occurs first. Conditions apply. See Sydney City Lexus for further details. # Whichever occurs first. **Offer applicable to Private and ABN buyers, who are current members of AMANSW, on all new vehicles purchased between 10th of August 2015 - 30th of June 2016. Sydney City Lexus reserves the right to extend any offer. Excludes demonstrator and pre-owned vehicles. You must be a member of the Qantas Frequent Flyer program to earn and redeem points. Complimentary membership will be offered to customers who are not already members. Membership and Qantas Points are subject to the terms and conditions of the Qantas Frequent Flyer Program available at Qantas.com/terms. To earn Qantas Points, Qantas Frequent Flyers must provide their membership number. Please allow six weeks for the points to be credited to your account. Points can only be awarded on the purchase of an eligible new vehicle between the 10 August 2015 to 30 June 2016. Points paid on total net contract price after discount but before trade-in. Visit http://www.sydneycitylexus.com.au/smallprint/amansw for full terms and conditions. THE NSW doctor THE OFFICIAL PUBLICATION OF THE AUSTRALIAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION (NSW) The Australian Medical Association (NSW) Limited ACN 000 001 614 Street address 69 Christie Street ST LEONARDS NSW 2065 Mailing address PO Box 121, ST LEONARDS NSW 1590 Telephone (02) 9439 8822 Outside Sydney Telephone 1800 813 423 Facsimile (02) 9438 3760 Outside Sydney Facsimile 1300 889 017 Email [email protected] Website www.amansw.com.au The NSW Doctor is the bi-monthly publication of the Australian Medical Association (NSW) Limited. contents Features 09 Future Practice workshops 12 Profile: AMA (NSW) President Printing by A.R. Rennie Printers, Caringbah. Views expressed by contributors to The NSW Doctor and advertisements appearing in The NSW Doctor are not necessarily endorsed by the Australian Medical Association (NSW) Limited. No responsibility is accepted by the Australian Medical Association (NSW) Limited, the editors or the printers for the accuracy of the information contained in the text and advertisements in The NSW Doctor. The acceptance of advertising in AMA (NSW) publications, digital, or social channels or sponsorship of AMA (NSW) events does not in any way indicate or imply endorsement by the AMA. Executive Officers 2014-2015 President Professor Bradley Frankum Vice President Dr Kean-Seng Lim Chairman of Council Dr Michael Bonning Hon Treasurer Dr Danielle McMullen Chair, Hospital Practice Committee Dr Fred Betros Chair, Professional Issues Committee Dr Sandy Jusuf Director Clin A/Prof Saxon Smith Director Dr Andrew Zuschmann DIT Representative Dr Kate Kearney Secretariat Chief Executive Officer Fiona Davies Medical Director Dr Robyn Napier Chief Financial Officer Stephen Patterson Director, Medico Legal and Employment Relations Andrew Took Director, Policy & Industrial Relations Sim Mead Director, Services Kerry Evripidou Editor Andrea Cornish [email protected] Designer Clarissa Cowan [email protected] Advertising enquiries Michelle Morgan-Mar [email protected] 18 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING Regulars 2 President’s word 4 From the CEO 6 DIT diary 10News 32 Careers news 34Medico-Legal 36 Golf events 38 Members & Classifieds 40 Member services amansw.com.au I 1 PRESIDENT’S WORD Time for a national obesity plan The prevalence of obesity and the severity of health implications have steadily increased in Australia over the past 30 years. The time to act is now. Australia has led the way in tobacco control and this has required decades of coordinated, multi-pronged, government-led policies and programs. Taxing cigarettes has been a cornerstone of this success. No sensible person would argue against the importance of measures to decrease smoking, drug abuse, road trauma, and infectious disease transmission. So where is our Federal Government’s comprehensive program to tackle what can only be described as an emergency for our community in the form of obesity, overweight and diabetes? Almost 65% of Australians are obese or overweight. Being overweight has become the new norm. We know that metabolic and cardiovascular risks are but part of the problem, with increasing evidence of mental health issues, reproductive health issues and cancer risks in obese individuals. We also have unacceptably high levels of childhood obesity, with one in four children being overweight or obese – a problem that potentially sets children up for a lifetime of ill health. I am calling for an urgent, comprehensive action plan to tackle this crisis from the newly-elected Federal Government. Funding must be made available for a range of action steps, including: •Much greater public education and awareness campaigns through schools, primary health facilities and media. • Access to exercise and lifestyle programs, not just for those who can afford to pay for private services. • And, the introduction of a tax on sugar-sweetened beverages (SSBs). Evidence is mounting around the world of the value of taxing soft drinks. A number of countries have introduced taxes with evidence of reduced consumption of the product, and changes to the formulation by manufacturers to reduce the sugar content. There is no diet that must contain sugar-sweetened beverages. There is always a healthy alternative. There are no health benefits to sugarsweetened beverages. Revenue raised from a tax on SSBs can be quarantined for use in obesity treatment and prevention plans. The NSW Premier has identified childhood obesity as a priority for his government and a substantial amount of money has been allocated in the State Budget. I am calling on the Prime Minister to respond to this crisis facing Australians of all ages, and to show leadership in tackling the problem with a comprehensive national program. The health and potential economic benefits are enormous, and the time to act is now. dr. • Better design of communities to facilitate active lifestyles. • Access to bariatric services in public hospitals, including surgery for the subset of patients in whom evidence shows clear health benefits. • Ongoing education of health professionals to help them deal better with helping patients who are overweight. [email protected] @bradfrankum www.facebook.com/amansw Prof Brad Frankum President, AMA (NSW) 2 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 Take the pain out of health fund claiming with HealthPoint. Commonwealth Bank now offers Australian Medical Association NSW members on the spot claims, rebates and payments. Commonwealth Bank provides Australian Medical Association NSW members with a new range of market leading health fund claim solutions. Process private health fund rebates, Medicare benefits and gap payments with one easy terminal and get your EFTPOS funds in your Commonwealth Bank account on the same day, every day*. Faster claims processing: • Simplify processing: Process Medicare Easyclaim and private health fund rebates on the spot. No more invoicing or missed payments – just fast, easy card transactions. • Reduce admin: Cut paperwork for your patients and your practice, reducing the load on your staff, freeing them up to focus on higher quality service. • Faster payments: Receive your EFTPOS settlement funds into your Commonwealth Bank business account on the same day, every day*. • Peace of mind: With specialised training and 24/7 phone support for you and your staff, you can be confident that you are in good hands. To take advantage of our special rates and fees, please call Australian Medical Association NSW on 02 9439 8822 or email [email protected] and start saving today. Important Information: *Available to eligible customers with a Commonwealth Bank business transaction account and a linked Commonwealth Bank eligible merchant facility. ‘Same day’ includes all card sales made up to until 10pm (AEST). Third party products not included, which includes payments from Medicare and private health funds for claims processed. Everyday Settlement applies to EFTPOS and gap payments, which are treated as normal credit/debit transactions (for Commonwealth Bank account holders). Funds received by a practice for Medicare and private health funds claims are processed by the relevant organisation (Medicare or private health fund) and are processed according to their timeframes. Applicants for this offer consent to their name and merchant identification being provided to Australian Medical Association NSW to confirm their membership and eligibility for the offer. Australian Medical Association NSW may receive a fee from the Commonwealth Bank of Australia for each successful referral. Referral Fees are not payable on referrals from existing relationship managed customers. This has been prepared without considering your amansw.com.au I are 3 objectives, financial situation or needs, so you should consider its appropriateness to your circumstances before you act on it. Full fees, charges, terms and conditions available on application. Commonwealth Bank of Australia ABN 48 123 123 124. FROM THE CEO Caring for yourself and colleagues The mental and physical health of doctors and medical students remains an ongoing concern for the profession, as doctors face greater risk of mental illness and stress-related problems. This month, we are pleased to bring you a special edition focusing on Doctors’ Health and Wellbeing. For a profession with such a strong focus on caring for others, doctors don’t do so well managing their own physical and mental health. This edition brings together some of the best thinkers on these issues. They offer thoughtful insights into the challenges and the opportunities of caring for your colleagues and for your own health. The focus of this edition was created to celebrate the launch of the expanded Doctors’ Health Advisory Service. The Doctors’ Health Advisory Service has been operating in NSW for more than 30 years. The service has run on the dedication and commitment of an amazing group of volunteer doctors. Under an agreement reached with the Medical Board of Australia last year, the service will be expanded with the provision of annual funding from doctors’ registration fees. This will allow the service to expand and to take on a much broader role in providing both first call immediate assistance and ongoing support for doctors and medical students. We recently held an excellent forum with the DHAS and key representatives from the medical defence associations, local health districts, the Medical Council of NSW, HETI and the HCCC. It was an exciting and inspiring opportunity to discuss how to improve support for doctors and students. We will be reporting further on this project as it develops. of previous President Clin A/Prof Saxon Smith. I welcome our new President, Professor Brad Frankum. I first met Brad over a decade ago during the turmoil of Campbelltown and Camden. Brad has made an exceptional contribution to his hospital and his region (and of course medical education generally through the University of Western Sydney) and we look forward to a busy two years ahead. dr. In this edition, we also introduce you to our new President and Board. I would like to acknowledge the excellent work [email protected] Fiona Davies CEO, AMA (NSW) Caring for Colleagues 2016 A program to help you to help your colleagues. Sunday 28 August 2016 • 9am – 5pm Young or old, GP or specialist, in the public or private sector - all of us, at some time or another, find ourselves with a ‘duty of care’ for colleagues. It may be in our role as a clinician, training supervisor, teacher, mentor or employer. It’s not always easy to do it well and there are important pitfalls to avoid, but we can make a world of difference. An application has been made to the RACGP and ACRRM for approval as an accredited learning activity. For more information and to register for the seminar visit www.amansw.com.au/events/list 4 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 AMA House, 69 Christie Street AMA/DHAS Members $65* Non-members $99* *plus booking fee Experience something special on your next NEW CAR purchase. Save up to 10% on the RRP of most new cars. Avbs AustrAlAsiAn Call 1300 76 49 49 or visit www.avbs.com.au Personalised Service Impartial Advice Right Price No Stress AustrAlAsiAn VEHIclE BUYING SERVIcES Preferred provider This is an exclusive (free) member service and is available on all makes and models amansw.com.au of new cars. I 5 AMAAVBS0001 DIT DIARY Our just awards The experience of UK junior doctors begs the question – what if the same were to happen here? Australian JMOs have watched uneasily as their counterparts in the UK have held signs above picket lines in freezing cold weather, forced to protest unfair changes to their basic contract. First tabled by the NHS two years ago, this proposed contract was repellent. Hard numbers varied according to which side was publishing the analysis, yet whatever way the data was crunched it amounted to more hours for less money. The NHS claimed these cuts would be offset by a 13.5% salary increase; but with extended “normal” daytime hours from 7am to 10pm, and all day Saturday, this was a spurious claim. Annual pay rises were also to be scrapped. The NHS’s intention was to funnel the savings from these cuts into rostering more doctors on weekends and nights, inevitably extending everyone’s working hours in the process. When DITs pointed out the inequity this would impose on anyone with young children or carer’s responsibilities (as well as in general) the NHS responded with an unabashed “what’s good for the one is good for the many” press statement that admitted the new policies disadvantaged women, in particular. Thanks to the tireless negotiating efforts of the British Medical Association, a potential compromise may have been reached. Although it’s not quite what UK DITs had hoped for, the extension of overtime hours is not as diffuse, and new provisions including accelerated training pathways for people with carers’ commitments to catch up make the contract less discriminatory. We won’t know if these changes will be accepted until it goes to a referendum in October. Prior to this last round of talks, UK DITs were considering an indefinite walk out, possibly accompanied by mass resignations. Even if an agreement is reached, social media chatter indicates morale in the NHS 6 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 is at an all-time low and DITs have lost faith in the NHS. Hard-working, idealistic junior doctors have been accused of “showing a regrettable disregard for patient care” by the Department of Health (UK) for attempting to maintain adequate remuneration and a workplace that doesn’t openly discriminate against women and families. UK DITS are, in my opinion, entirely justified in their actions. To borrow a British parlance, the NHS is having a laugh if they think extreme austerity can sustain a health service of any quality. Could this kind of impasse ever develop in Australia? If it did, what would we do about it? It’s not as far off as we might think. Recent years have seen attacks on Medicare, cuts to public hospital funding, and mass resignations of salaried medical officers in Queensland. Doctors have been threatened with jail-time for speaking out about the wellbeing of their asylum seeker patients. We do have one very distinct advantage over our counterparts in the UK though, and that’s The Alliance. Being a doctor is mostly an intellectual pursuit and we’re not used to having to organise and mobilise the way other industries have in the past, but it’s becoming necessary. Having The Alliance already in place to represent our interests is invaluable. Things might not be as bad as they are in the UK (yet), but making sure we are represented and our rights protected will go a long way to prevent us being put in the same position. ASMOF have been reviewing the NSW Public Hospital Medical Officers Award, which is the award that covers most Junior doctors working in NSW. The award has not been updated since 1983 (over two decades) meaning the award is older than I am. ASMOF have been discussing proposed changes with the MOH and have recently sought agreement from the MOH to vary the award to reflect a 2.5% increase whilst also seeking agreement to continue the discussions with regards to the substantive matters which have not yet been agreed to and which significantly affect JMOs. A vote was recently undertaken via survey and the option to accept the 2.5% whilst continuing to discuss proposed changes was overwhelmingly supported by JMOs. Due to the NSW Governments Wages Cap Policy, any changes proposed by ASMOF must be cost neutral. In order to offset ASMOFs proposed changes, the MOH propose to remove ADO’s, remove the higher increment when being seconded to a rural hospital, and increase the time from 10 hours to 12 hours before overtime kicks in. These are just some of the proposed changes and ASMOF will be continuing to meet with members over the coming weeks/months. Make sure you join ASMOF and have your say about the proposed changes. Junior doctors are the foundation of our public health workforce, we must protect our ability to do our jobs properly and safely with adequate compensation or providing quality healthcare to Australia will become impossible. dr. @elizamilliken Dr Eliza Milliken Junior Doctor Doctors-In-Training Awards 7 October 2016 NOMINATE NOW! Do you know an inspiring Registrar, JMO, Teacher or JMO Manager? NSW Minister for Health Registrar of the Year $10,000 cash prize NSW Minister for Health/HETI/Cutcher & Neale JMO of the Year $10,000 cash prize ASMOF (NSW) – Teacher of the Year $5,000 cash prize HETI/ASMOF (NSW) – JMO Manager of the Year $5,000 cash prize Nominate at amansw.com.au/nominations Nominations close 1 September 2016 The awards will be presented by NSW Health at AMA (NSW) / ASMOF (NSW) Alliance Doctors-in-Training Cocktail Party at ‘The Ivy Sunroom’ Level 3, Ivy. 330 George St, Sydney Contact Michelle Morgan-Mar on [email protected] or 9902 8143 General sponsor A joint initiative of AMA (NSW), ASMOF (NSW) and HETI amansw.com.au I 7 COLUMN A tale of two services Jon Fogarty contemplates what makes for good service – particularly when it comes to general practice. It was a tale of two cities or, more accurately, two services, that led me to ponder the service I provide at my practice. “Our serviceman will be there within 45 minutes. He will text you five minutes before he arrives. The cost of a new starter motor is $X. Tale 1: The gutters at my house are leaking. I google “Leaking Gutter Fixing Person” and a dozen names pop up. "Now, is there anything else I can help you with today, Jon?” She was so nice, I was tempted to ask if she could quickly run the vac over the lounge room, but I didn’t. The first number is disconnected, the second “doesn’t do, sort of, fixing gutters mate”, and the third says that Mick will ring me. Mick doesn’t ring and the next day I ring back and am told that my call is important to them and to please stay on the line ... Finally, I contact Nate. “Too easy”, he assures me. I am always nervous when I hear this because my experience is that it nearly always ends up too hard. Nate will be there on Tuesday at 8am. “No worries, mate." By 9am, no Nate. I ring. A bleary sounding Nate says he is “sick as”. Not, fortunately fully spewin’ but clearly crook. Next Tuesday? "Too easy, mate." I ring on Monday night to confirm. On Tuesday he turns up (late) and gives a rather gloomy prognosis for the gutter and agrees to start work next Monday. And … gosh, you’ve already guessed ... no Nate. I phone, no answer. Tale 2: While awaiting Nate, the starter motor on my car dies and I ring the NRMA. Here starts an unpaid promo for the largest road service organisation. The machine asks me if I am safe (press 1), are there children locked in the car? Then I speak to a human. “Can I call you Jon?" Certainly. 8 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 To be brief, a neatly turned out bloke turned up in 45 minutes. He did something mysterious under the bonnet of the car. He was entirely polite and uncomplaining, and charged me the quoted sum. The car and owner have been happy ever since. All of which leads me to think that for reasons of both courtesy and good business, we could all give thought to how well our phones are answered, whether we text patients in advance if we are running late and whether our 75-year-old patient prefers to be called Alice or Mrs Armytage. It also leads me to ask if anyone knows a good gutter fixing person? dr. A Tale of Two Services has been reprinted here with permission. This article was first published in Australian Doctor magazine. FEATURE Future Practice I Following the launch of our Future Practice campaign in May, AMA (NSW) held an extremely successful event for GPs looking to transform their businesses. The Coalition Government’s announcement to extend the Medicare freeze until 2020 was a devastating blow to medical practice in Australia, particularly general practice. If maintained, the freeze threatens to cripple thousands of medical practices and force all Australians to pay more for their healthcare. For many GPs, the announcement was a tipping point. With the freeze potentially stretching out for seven years, many have no choice but to pass on the increased costs of running their practices to patients. For GPs looking at ways to make their practices more sustainable, AMA (NSW) has launched Future Practice – a platform for medical practitioners who are interested in providing quality care in the midst of the Medicare freeze. In conjunction with the campaign, AMA (NSW) launched its Future Practice website (www.futurepractice.com.au) which covers all aspects of creating a quality, patient-centred, economically viable practice, offering a wealth of resources, including case studies, videos, and a community for GPs to share ideas. The Future Practice website also offers general practitioners a free health check, a detailed benchmarking exercise and a fee for service pricing guide. AMA (NSW)’s first-ever Future Practice workshop was one of the best attended events we have held this year – proof that many GPs are looking for ideas on how to build more innovative, sustainable practices. MY GP d 1 rA3_FINAL.ind eMyGP_Poste 0262_FP_ILov QUALITY CARE COSTS The workshop featured What does this mean for a presentation from you? Cathy Baynie, NSW/ACT State President of the Australian Association of Practice Management (AAPM). Ms Baynie has had an extensive career as a practice manager and has joined AMA (NSW) as a consultant to answer any questions AMA members may have about innovating their practice. Ms Baynie’s presentation looked at the current financial challenges for general practice, focusing on the Medicare freeze, as well as the Practice Incentive Program, which is not indexed and is now being "streamlined", as well as the pending introduction of Healthcare Home and voluntary registration model. Ms Baynie emphasised to GPs that the decision to make any change, whether it be to transition from bulk billing, increase fees, or introduce new services, is challenging. She cautioned attendees that before any such changes can be implemented it is imperative practice systems are in place; this includes management systems, IT systems, human resource systems, appointment and recall systems. Her presentation also stressed the importance of benchmarking and the development of KPIs and targets. According to Ms Baynie, practices need to focus on quality care and service delivery in order to "sell" any changes. They also need to be transparent in all QUALITY CARE SAVE S A strong pr im lives and sa ary health care system ves money. has frozen The govern saves your rebate ment until 2020. What will it cost you? am 1/06/2016 11:35 their dealings with patients surrounding any costs, and lastly, GPs need to educate patients as to what Medicare really is – emphasising that Medicare is their insurance and that patients need to fight for higher rebates. Her advice to all practices looking to make a change is, “what will work for one practice may not work for another, so it is important to assess demographic needs and be innovative.” Feedback from the night revealed that some doctors felt that their practice managers were not in a position to implement and manage the practice to a level that was required and were looking for education and resources to assist with these processes. Other concerns that surfaced during the event were the difficulty of maintaining high quality care standards and delivery, whilst sustaining their businesses. Managing chronic disease on a limited budget was also highlighted at the forum. AMA (NSW) will be holding several more Future Practice events in the coming months. Please visit amansw.com.au or futurepractice.com.au for updates. For members unable to attend the workshops, they will also be available as webinars. dr. amansw.com.au I 9 NEWS AMA Awards NSW demonstrated its exceptional work in advocacy and communications – taking home two awards from the National Conference. The AMA National Conference held in May recognised states and territories for their work over the previous year engaging government and the public on prominent healthcare issues and policy areas. AMA (NSW) was recognised for its exceptional achievements in both these areas, taking home both Best Lobby Campaign and Best Public Health Campaign. Best Lobby Campaign – Clinician Engagement Don’t let your sunscreen burn out AMA (NSW) began this long-term project after the Garling Inquiry in 2008 identified the breakdown of good working relations between clinicians and managers in the public hospital system as an impediment to good, safe care for patients. In February 2015, AMA (NSW), the Australian Salaried Medical Officers’ Federation NSW (ASMOF), and NSW Health Minister Jillian Skinner signed a world-first agreement to embed clinician engagement in the culture of the public hospital system, and to measure how well doctors are engaged in the decisionmaking processes of Local Health Districts. The judges commended AMA (NSW) for its persistence, saying the progress in addressing this longstanding issue was a significant achievement in both health policy and the government/ profession relationship. Under the agreed arrangements set out in the Joint Statement, AMA (NSW) and ASMOF (NSW) will conduct an annual survey of senior medical practitioners to gauge their level of engagement in the public health system. Over time, these surveys will build up a picture of clinician engagement within the NSW public health system, as perceived by senior medical practitioners working in the system. 3 Check expiry date 3 Apply generously 3 Reapply every 2hrs 3 Store in a cool place UVA/UVB Broad Spectrum Protection Always stay sun safe REAPPLY often ...and DON’T let your sunscreen burn out UVA/UVB Broad Spectrum Protection http://sunscreen.amansw .com.au/ Best Public Health Campaign – Sunscreen Use AMA (NSW) ran a widely recognised and broadcast educational campaign on sunscreen use and storage in 2015/2016. The campaign attracted good media coverage in the Telegraph, on TV evening news bulletins and on radio. The fact that heat damages sunscreen is largely new information, which generated a high level of interest from print and broadcast media. With its clear message, the campaign drew on new research showing that many Australians do not realise that sunscreen can lose up to 40% of its effectiveness if exposed to temperatures exceeding 25 degrees Celsius. The campaign’s secondary messages were about ensuring people wear enough (40 mL for full body protection), buying 10 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 fresh sunscreen every year, and ensuring that it is reapplied every two hours. The campaign received extra traction with the surprising results of the medical student survey, which found that onethird of medical students still sunbake to tan, despite knowing the skin cancer risk. The judges said while all entries were of a particularly high standard, the AMA (NSW)’s campaign sent a timely reminder to all Australians of the need to be sun smart. This campaign was very relevant to all Australians because skin cancer accounts for 80 per cent of all newly diagnosed cancers and we have one of the highest incidences of skin cancer in the world. About 95 per cent of skin cancer is caused by sun exposure. dr. NEWS The Hope Challenge A 12-hour football marathon to be held in September will honour the memory of two doctors and raise money for The Black Dog Institute. A 12-hour football marathon to be held in September will honour the memory of two doctors and raise money for The Black Dog Institute. Since 2000, the tight-knit community of West Pymble in Sydney’s northern suburbs bonded together on a weekly basis over a social game of touch football. Its members, however, were recently shocked and saddened at the loss of one of their long-standing members, Dr Rick Hope, who worked as a gastroenterologist at Norwest Private Hospital, City West Specialist Day Hospital and Southern Highlands Private Hospital. He also took appointments at Blacktown/Mount Druitt and Westmead hospitals. It’s the second time this small club has faced such a loss – in 2012, another much beloved member, committed suicide. Wishing to make a stand for all those suffering from depression and other mental health issues, the Sunday social group are organising a family-friendly event to raise funds for The Black Dog Institute. It is intended to be held close to the date for RU OK? Day. The Hope Challenge will celebrate life and especially honour the two doctors now lost to the community. As well as raising money for The Black Dog Institute and promoting awareness of mental health, organiser Phillip Ross says the day is intended to demonstrate to those who may be suffering from depression “that their community cares and are willing to help.” Look for more information on how to donate or participate in the next issue of The NSW Doctor. dr. While the date is being finalised, the game will start at 8am and finish at 8pm. SPECIALIST CONSULTING SUITES SAN CLINIC PARKWAY FO RS A FA LE ST -S EL LIN G San Clinic Parkway, Wahroonga - Cnr. Fox Valley Rd & Comenarra Parkway Unique opportunity to purchase individual, architecturally designed specialist consulting suites in a superb working environment. Artist Impression • Convenient hospital access • Walking distance to your operating theatres/inpatients • Suites for sale from 52m2 - 121m2 approx or larger if required • High exposure location • Potential depreciation allowances • Benefit from the San’s massive redevelopment & expansion Grow your practice alongside the San, NSW’s largest private hospital. For further information, please contact Phillip Apelbaum 0419 559 555 Artist Impression 1300 133 885 amansw.com.au I 11 PROFILE 12 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 Fit for the job Professor Brad Frankum stepped up from Vice President to take over the top job at the AMA (NSW) in May. The immunologist/allergist and former Deputy Dean of Clinical Education at WSU proves he’s ready for the challenge. AMA (NSW) President, Prof Brad Frankum stepped into the position on 17 May – just weeks before both the Federal Election and the delivery of the NSW Budget. With the prospect of a continued Medicare freeze and uncertainty over Federal funding for public hospitals, it’s been a baptism by fire for the newly-elected President. Media doorstops, meetings with candidates in swing electorates, and numerous calls from print and broadcast media have dominated his already busy schedule, which involves running his own private practice, as well as serving as a Staff Specialist at Camden and Campbelltown Hospitals and the Executive Clinical Director of the hospitals. In spite of all this, Prof Frankum has handled the increased attention and responsibility with his usual composure and equanimity. The Professor is no stranger to the pressure cooker of life – both professionally and personally. A new convert to Crossfit, Prof Frankum entered his first Masters competition this year at the age of 50. Not only did he win, but he also managed to resuscitate one of other competitors who had a cardiac arrest – “which was really quite stressful, as you can imagine, with about 150 people watching.” An avid sportsman, Prof Frankum complements Crossfit with horse riding and show jumping, which he enjoys on his 24-acre rural property in Camden. While he still competes, Prof Frankum was formally an elite level show jumper who represented Australia in his younger days. The other core focus for his presidency will be Federal funding for public hospitals. “I’m very committed to exercise,” he admits. “And that’s partly my interest in public health and obesity.” “Both the Coalition and Labor have pledged some modest health funding to get us through to the end of the next election cycle. However, the fiscal cliff we were headed for in 2017 has merely been pushed out to 2020. This continued uncertainty over funding continues to throw long-term health planning for how resources will be deployed into question. NSW hospitals need to know they will be able to continue to operate beyond 2020,” he says. In the next two years of his term, Prof Frankum plans to make obesity his top priority. Although he is encouraged by Premier Mike Baird’s $14 million investment to tackle childhood obesity, he believes we need to establish a comprehensive, multi-pronged approach to address this rising epidemic. “In Australia, we’ve been very successful with our public health campaigns, for example tobacco control. The reason we have been successful has been the coordinated approach – education, media, taxation – all of those things combined have led to Australia having the lowest rates of smoking in the industrialised world. So I cannot understand why we are not doing the same for obesity, overweight and diabetes.” In Australia, 65% of adults are overweight and obese, while one in four children also fall into those categories. Like the sword of Damocles, obesity threatens to cripple hospitals’ ability to deal with the downstream effects – particularly, increasing numbers of patients with diabetes, cardiovascular problems, cancer, maternal health issues and more. “We’ve got to do something,” Prof Frankum says. “The growing obesity epidemic presents a lifelong risk of poor health outcomes and spiralling health costs, including increased demands on public hospitals.” Ongoing issues, such as the Medicare freeze, training places for junior doctors and workforce distribution, continue to be challenges and will remain a priority in his presidency. Prof Frankum has faced major political challenges in the past – the Campbelltown Hospital crisis in 2004 was his come to Jesus moment – sparking his involvement with the AMA. “I realised at the time, the absolute necessity of the AMA and what they could do that nobody else could do and also, the need for all of us to be members. Not just because we might need them in a crisis, but because of the great advocacy work that is done. He adds, “Doctors need to be part of every health conversation. If we stand back and let non-medical people make all of the decisions about the health system then we’ve only got ourselves to blame if we don’t like it.” dr. amansw.com.au I 13 PROFILE AMA (NSW)’s Board of Directors On 17 May 2016, AMA (NSW) elected a new board of directors – many of whom are by now familiar to members for being tireless advocates for the profession. In keeping with the theme of this issue, Board members discussed what they identify as the key issues in doctors’ health and wellbeing, as well as their own coping strategies. Q. Dr Kean-Seng Lim Dr Michael Bonning Dr Lim is the 2015 RACGP General Practitioner of the Year and is a member of the AMA (NSW) Council. He also serves on the Professional Issues Committee. Dr Bonning is a GP Registrar in western Sydney and is a serving medical officer in the Royal Australian Navy, a director of Cor Mentes Health Consulting and a passionate advocate for healthcare equity, including Indigenous health. Vice President He is a GP Principal in a group practice in Mt Druitt and a GP Supervisor. He has previously served on the RACGP Faculty Board and WSDGP Board. He is currently the Secretary of the Mt Druitt Medical Practitioners Association. Dr Lim says the pressure on doctors to achieve the best patient outcomes in a fragmented and underresourced system is a major source of stress. Dr Lim makes his own health and wellbeing a personal responsibility. “For me, the foundational element is to take responsibility for what is immediately around you – becoming an active participant in your own destiny. This means changing what you can change and structuring your workplace to provide the best support to all who work in it, but also recognising that there are things beyond our immediate control, which we may have to work in partnership with others to influence.” 14 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 Chair, Council According to Dr Bonning, mental health needs to be addressed in medical school. “It is telling that many of the changes regarding stress occur early in medical school and are then perpetuated during clinical training. Therefore the challenge for doctors and educators is to identify what in our training system affects the students coming in and work to mitigate its impact.” In terms of looking after his own mental health and wellbeing, Dr Bonning relies on three ‘r’s to help him through the day. “There is a really powerful technique from Dr Adam Fraser which uses the transitional times in life – between patients, between meetings, between work and home – to do three things: reflect, rest and reset. Reflect uses specific positively-framed questions, such as ‘what went well’, ‘what did I achieve’, and ‘how do I get better?’ Rest gets you to do something that makes you present in that transition, such as listening to music. Finally, reset asks you to put yourself in the right headspace and focus on what you want to get out of your next interaction.” Dr Danielle McMullen Dr Fred Betros Dr Sandy Jusuf Dr McMullen is a GP registrar practicing in Sydney’s inner west. She graduated from UNSW in 2010, completed a Diploma of Child Health, a Certificate in Reproductive and Sexual Health, and is a graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors. Dr Betros is a general surgeon practicing in western Sydney and the Hawkesbury district in Sydney’s north-west. He has VMO appointments at Blacktown and Hawkesbury Hospitals and a private practice encompassing suburbs from Bella Vista to Windsor. Dr Jusuf is a dual-trainee in emergency medicine and psychiatry, having worked in various metropolitan and rural hospitals in Australia and overseas, including the United Kingdom and the Solomon Islands. Since her prevocational training across a number of rural and metropolitan hospitals, she has undertaken GP training in clinics in NSW and the NT. Dr Betros commented that doctors face several barriers when it comes to seeking help for a mental or physical illness. Hon. Treasurer She advocates passionately on behalf of doctors-in-training and has been chair of the NSW DITC since 2014. She is part of a number of GP and DIT committees both Federally and in NSW. Dr McMullen recognises the need for doctors to take time to reflect in order to cope with pressures of the job. “Doctors face significant health and wellbeing issues – we all know about the long hours and heavy workload in a sometimes isolated environment. But we also share in our patients’ stories every day, some more traumatic than others. Without support, debriefing, and positive coping strategies, these stories can become a heavy weight to bear. “Personally, I try to make time for the things I love – cooking, reading, spending time with friends and family. I find my work with the AMA helps to balance my clinical work. And the odd yoga class to get centred is helpful too!” Chair, Hospital Practice Committee “The reluctance to seek help for fear of being labelled as ‘impaired’ is a huge barrier our profession needs to address. We often work in environments that are difficult at professional, emotional and personal levels. Our biggest hurdle is to create a culture that is supportive and encouraging enough to allow a doctor to actively seek help.” When it comes to maintaining his own wellbeing, Dr Betros feels balance is key. “I’m a firm believer in the adage that you work to live, not live to work. We all aim to put our patients first, but I believe that a balanced work and recreational lifestyle is essential to health and wellbeing. I work with a group of colleagues who are like-minded and recognise that one of us is overwhelmed with a heavy workload, helping each other out is essential. It’s amazing how much a small gesture of help makes a difference. I always take the approach that what goes around, comes around.” Chair, Professional Issues Committee She currently works as a psychiatry registrar in the Northern Sector and an emergency registrar at Canterbury hospital. Dr Jusuf is a graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors and on the Board of the Doctors’ Health Advisory Service NSW. She is passionate about doctors’ health and set up the Health and Wellbeing website for junior doctors. In terms of looking after her own mental health and wellbeing, Dr Jusuf makes an effort to separate work from home life. “I try to leave work at work and switch off when I get home. If something really bothers me, I debrief with others – either colleagues or friends outside of work who know me well. “A work-life balance is very important to me. I schedule in time to myself as well as time with loved ones, including my cute little dog, to relax and do fun things.” amansw.com.au I 15 PROFILE Clin A/Prof Saxon Smith Dr Andrew Zuschmann Dr Kate Kearney Clin A/Prof Saxon Smith graduated from the University of Otago, Dunedin in 2000, holds a Masters Degree in Health Law from the University of Sydney and is a graduate of the Australian Institute of Company Directors and a fellow of the Australasian College of Dermatologists. Dr Andrew Zuschmann has a commitment to teaching and the development of a sustainable workforce. Dr Kate Kearney is a medical registrar, completing physician training at St Vincent’s Hospital in Sydney. She graduated from the University of Sydney in 2012 and completed a Masters of Medicine in Clinical Epidemiology in 2014 from the same institution. Director After interning at the Gold Coast Public Hospital, he worked in various clinical roles in public and private hospitals across NSW, with the Australian Red Cross Blood Service and as a clinical researcher. Clin A/Prof Smith is currently in private practice in Gosford, a VMO dermatologist at Royal North Shore Hospital and a clinical senior lecturer at The University of Sydney. According to Clin A/Prof Smith, all too often doctors put others ahead of their own needs. “I feel the constant pressure of trying to provide care to a large population who have limited access to specialist dermatology care, as well as trying to balance the desire to be the best father, husband, friend, supervisor and mentor, to those in my life. Sadly, like most of us, taking care of myself ends up on the bottom of the daily ‘to do list’. But taking time to simply eat lunch, setting aside time to exercise, as well as time to sit with my son playing Lego or superheroes, makes me a better person and a better doctor. Some things are too important to take for granted.” Director He is a Staff Specialist at Sutherland and St George Hospitals, with a private practice in Miranda. Dr Zuschmann is a Specialist Obstetrician and Gynaecologist and Fertility Specialist. He graduated from the University of NSW in 1996 and completed specialist training in 2005. According to Dr Zuschmann, doctors’ health and wellbeing is about focusing on the micro. “For many, myself included, we tend to focus on the macro – ‘I’m taking Friday off to play golf’ or ‘I’m not on call this weekend so plan on spending time with the kids’. As someone with a young family and a job that features irregular and unpredictable hours on top of the ‘office’ job, the problem I find is focussing on the micro. The challenge is setting aside, or just finding, regular time for reflection, personal time, and exercise. When you’re a small business owner it’s all too tempting to do paperwork, or see an extra patient in that spare hour. We should be more opportunistic and disciplined about our health.” 16 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 DIT Representative She is currently one of the deputy chairs of the AMA Federal Council of Doctorsin-Training, and is a member of the Adult Medicine Division Education Committee of the Royal Australasian College of Physicians. She participates in a number of other committees and working groups across the AMA and RACP. Dr Kearney says there is a need to create healthy workplaces for doctors to better promote health and wellbeing among medical professionals. She also calls for greater support among colleagues and identifies the need for doctors to ask for help when feeling stressed and overwhelmed. Addressing burnout and the factors that lead to it is another key issues, says Dr Kearney. AMA (NSW) Careers Service Need advice about prevocational training, applying for intern, RMO and fellowship positions? M E D I C A L S U I T E S AVA I L A B L E F O R L E A S E BU I L D YO U R P R AC T I C E A N D R E P U TAT I O N AT S Y D N E Y ’ S M O S T P R E S T I G I O U S MEDICAL ADDRESS British Medical Association House Suite 101, Level 1 135 Macquarie Street, Sydney Give yourself the AMA Edge Contact Anita Fletcher on 9902 8158 or [email protected] P: 02 9241 2158 | E: [email protected] W: sydneymedicalspecialists.com.au | sydneymedicalspecialists KDMA 40th Annual Conference SMS002 Quarter Page ad 89x120mm -v2.indd 2 28/04/2016 10:26 AM Join us for one of the most iconic & breath-taking locations… 25th September - 2nd October 2016 Post Conference Tour - Western Front via Canterbury & Paris from 2nd - 9th October 2016 Don’t delay - Seats are filling up fast !! FOR BOOKINGS & ENQUIRIES NORTHSHORE TRAVEL Vivienne & Samantha Shop 35, 767 Pacific Highway Gordon NSW 2072 T: +61 (2) 9418 2546 E: [email protected] ramsaydocs.com.au @RamsayDocs ramsay-health-care amansw.com.au I 17 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING 18 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING Doctors’ health and wellbeing In this special edition of The NSW Doctor, we look at the particular issues affecting doctors’ health and wellbeing and what medical professionals can do to better cope with the unique barriers to treatment that exist for doctors, as well as the stressors associated with the profession. amansw.com.au I 19 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING HOLD ON Medical school in the 1970s was like an express train. Medical courses were being shortened, but medical knowledge was expanding exponentially (with no internet yet to provide a portable memory bank!). As we hurtled through the shortened course, all extraneous “baggage” was ejected, including holidays, non-medical subjects, and “soft” topics like ethics or medical law. Like my peers of the time, fresh out of high school and passively accepting the roller coaster ride of medical training, I was not going to complain. Pathology specimens, anatomy dissections and patient examinations provided plenty of excitement, and we all knew that if we stopped to question the course framework we risked being left behind or asked to exit. Internship and residency were similarly frenetic. Clinical responsibility brought with it the intoxicating blend of confidence and self-doubt. Postgraduate training proved even more intense than undergraduate study. At the same time we were trying to balance other aspects of our lives – getting married, buying homes, having children. No one during my medical training prepared me for the potential negative consequences of a career in medicine. In the rush, there was little time to reflect on the possible consequences of this potent mix of expectation, drive and adrenaline. We were all invincible, and the socialisation into a medical career had made us dismissive of failure or distress. However, years later at graduation reunions the conversation inevitably turns to the boy from our year who jumped from the Harbour Bridge during the second year of our course, with no acknowledgement from the Faculty, and to others who have suffered since. It was during the 1980s, as a young rural GP that I first began to understand that the very career that we loved, that 20 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 we invested so much into, that our patients respected, could also harm us. I was fortunate to be in a large practice with great colleagues, but began to realise that the cumulative grief that I experienced (stillborn babies, teenagers killed in traffic accidents, young mothers dying from cancer) would inevitably affect me if I did not find a way to acknowledge, accept and deal with each loss. The sudden suicide of a young doctor in a nearby town, someone with whom I shared patients, came as a lightning bolt. I have spent a substantial part of the last 30 years studying the health of doctors. Most doctors love what they do, and are valued and respected by their patients. Yet the psychosocial morbidity of doctors SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING is of great concern, as documented in a number of studies in recent years. Why the paradox? There is no simple or single answer, but we can recognise and name a number of factors. As doctors we are altruistic, perfectionistic and anxious; these are the characteristics that got us into and through the competitive world of medical training, and the same characteristics that our patients value. Doctors are also emotionally sensitive, another characteristic that our patients expect and deserve, but these same curricula. There is overwhelming evidence characteristics predict strongly for the that a balanced, happy clinician provides risk of burnout, which itself is predictive of “distress” in the form of poor psychosocial outcomes at a personal and relationship level. a better level of care to their patients, and of course we and our families deserve to be happy and content as well. resilience. These topics are now core Prof Simon Willcock is a Professor of General Practice and Discipline Head at Sydney Medical School and a Senior Staff Specialist at Hornsby. His educational and research interests parts of undergraduate and postgraduate include the health of doctors. dr. I am pleased that the last 20 years have witnessed broad discussion about doctors’ health and strategies to maintain amansw.com.au I 21 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING When your PATIENT is a DOCTOR Dr Narelle Shadbolt advises treating patients who are also doctors the same way you would any other patient – with empathy, respect, confidentiality, thoroughness, and professional objectivity. 22 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING Evidence from around the world suggests that doctors represent an at-risk population. Compared to the population as a whole, they have higher rates of depression and anxiety, stress-related illness and unfortunately, alcoholism, substance abuse and suicide. And yet doctors find it difficult to access appropriate health care – ‘Illness doesn’t belong to us. It belongs to them, the patients.’ Equally, when confronted with another doctor as a patient, the treating doctor may feel uncomfortable and ill equipped. Doctors who have been ill report both anecdotally and via surveys that because they were a doctor, they were inadequately informed about their progress and follow-up, and were not offered enough psychological support. Many doctors report having suffered from a medical condition they would like to have discussed with a clinician but did not do so because they were a doctor. Those contemplating consulting another doctor for their own health, express concern about confidentiality, lack of confidence in a treating doctor and embarrassment about how to behave in the consultation. The internal conversation usually relates to their uncertainty regarding their self-diagnosis – it’s as if they expect to be grilled as they were on ward rounds when they were students. As much as we try to normalise the situation, there is something unique about the therapeutic encounter between a doctor and a doctor-patient. The usual model is: doctor – healthy, wise and trained; patient: sick, naïve and untrained. Both sides of this equation have changed. The treating doctor has no specific training for this encounter and he or she may feel insecure and fearful of criticism. When the patient is a doctor there is a strong sense of identification with their situation, which together with an exaggerated sense of responsibility and a keen sense of needing to be exemplary can result in a loss of objectivity. Sometimes this results in the treating doctor unburdening his or her own issues and fears with the doctorpatient. There may be a reluctance to ask about important but sensitive areas such as drug and alcohol use, sexual problems or mental health issues. There may be a wrong assumption that the doctor-patient would disclose any important symptoms and therefore these may not be specifically asked about. There may be a reluctance to do a thorough physical examination. The treating doctor may feel out of control, take short cuts, ask the doctor-patient to self-diagnose or just simply chat about the latest crisis in the health system and avoid the whole encounter. When a doctor presents for medical attention they are often in crisis. They have often waited too long and there is a need to respond quickly. They may have put up with significant symptoms including pain for some time. They may have partially investigated and treated themselves and fear disclosing this. They may feel isolated and even ashamed – letting the side down by getting sick. We know that doctors like to be in control, and this sense of lack of control is heightened by a fear of illness. Doctors are often obsessive and perfectionist, and as a patient this means they want to get better immediately and may deny or minimise symptoms; they want to please the treating doctor and may not report treatment failures or non-compliance. We know that doctors are more likely to have problems with mental health, particularly anxiety and depression, substance use and issues related to relationships. These problems are the most difficult for which to seek help. If you can’t go and see another doctor for help with a physical illness, how are you going to seek help for a mental illness, an alcohol problem or a sexual problem? These problems may also be associated with a perception of stigma and judgement. Mandatory reporting laws have also created fear in both treating and patient doctors. There is no requirement to report illness where it is being appropriately managed and patient safety is not at risk. Professionalism is paramount – your doctor-patient should be able to rely on you for confidentiality in all circumstances – even when you meet them at a medical conference or private function. So there is learning to be done on both sides. The first step may be to normalise healthcare for doctors – encourage normal healthcare behaviours including regular health checks. Promote the importance of establishing a relationship with a healthcare provider – a GP. As colleagues, we should discourage corridor consultations, self-referrals and management options that are outside of what is usual. As senior doctors, we should model appropriate healthcare behaviours and discuss this with our students and junior colleagues. When your patient is a doctor treat them as any other patient: with empathy, respect, confidentiality, thoroughness, and professional objectivity. Don’t make assumptions and take responsibility for examination, investigation, treatment and follow-up. Give them permission to be in the patient role. Everyone is going to be sick sometime, and everyone – even doctors – need to allow themselves to be a patient, and they are entitled to the very best healthcare. dr. Dr Narelle Shadbolt MB, BS; FRACGP; MFM(Monash) Senior Lecturer, General Practice, Northern Clinical School Joint Head of the Discipline of General Practice Sydney Medical School. amansw.com.au I 23 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING Coping with death The death of a patient is sadly frequent for many doctors. Prof Garry Walter suggests medical practitioners take time to reflect on adverse events. The rewards of medical practice are numerous. Among them is the joy of witnessing many of our patients get better through our efforts. Another is the intellectual stimulation in keeping abreast of the medical sciences that inform our work. The list of rewards is indeed lengthy. Yet a career in medicine is also attended by many challenges, including being the recipient of difficult, patientrelated news: the confirmation following investigations of a terminal illness, a patient suicide, the unanticipated demise of another. In a large number of medical practices, news of this type is not infrequent. How are we, as doctors, affected by such news and how might we respond? Patient adversity will always impact on treating doctors – it is unsurprising, even reassuring, that those drawn to a helping profession are in some way moved by events affecting their patients. However, it is the nature and extent of the impact that may become a source of concern for the doctor, doctor’s family and professional colleagues. Among the factors that determine how an individual doctor will be affected are the following: the type of adverse patient event, the nature of other stressors (e.g. work-related or family) being endured by the doctor, the doctor’s “connectedness” (family and professional), and a personal or family history of previous psychological difficulties. Accordingly, a range of responses may occur. The isolated practitioner with a history of major depression for whom a patient suicide is the most recent in a succession of adverse patient outcomes may understandably struggle to cope, but doctors in other contexts may also be affected by patient adversity, and responses are not always predictable. What steps should be taken? The first step is to not ignore the impact of difficult, patient-related news. Creating opportunity to reflect on such news, and if necessary discussing it through informal and formal networks, is important. Some doctors may require further assistance, and for a few there may be legitimate concerns about their safety. Due attention to work-life balance is always relevant for doctors, but especially at times like this: “Am I allowing sufficient time to unwind and engage in enjoyable activities?”, “Am I allocating adequate time to be with others?”, “Am I obtaining sufficient exercise?” and “Is my diet OK?” are questions that are as important as any others in these situations. A service like the Doctors’ Health Advisory Service (DHAS) can become crucial for those affected. Formed in 1982 with the support of the Medical Benevolent Association of NSW and AMA (NSW), the DHAS provides personal advice to medical practitioners and students facing health difficulties. The advice is mostly in relation to stress and mental health problems encountered by doctors and students, including issues pertaining to problematic drug and alcohol use. In the case of a doctor receiving difficult, patient-related news, the DHAS offers a confidential forum whereby the affected practitioner can discuss the impact of such news and how they are faring overall. The DHAS may then suggest and help organise referral to a GP, psychologist, psychiatrist or other health professional, depending on the circumstances of the case. The DHAS also offers to co-ordinate care and monitor progress. Just as many aspects of medical practice contribute to the satisfaction of a career in medicine, the day to day challenges cannot – and should not – be dismissed. By reflecting on traumas such as difficult, patient-related news and by accessing, as appropriate, informal and formal sources of support, the outcomes can be very positive. Through providing a collegial, professional and responsive service, the DHAS is able to assist doctors and students who might otherwise feel overwhelmed by such events. dr. Professor Garry Walter AM MB BS, BMedSc, PhD, FRANZCP, Cert. Child Adol. Psych. Foundation Medical Director, Doctors Health Advisory Service (NSW/ACT) SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING Health check for junior doctors Dr Sandy Jusuf, creator of JMO Health, a website developed to promote the health and wellbeing of junior doctors, shares her insight into the unique stressors many interns face. Now halfway through 2016, I hope this year’s interns have started settling into their new rotations and life as doctors. Some of you will have taken to it like a duck to water – enjoying looking after patients, applying all those skills acquired over the last few years, as well as the prestige and financial independence that a medical career comes with. Others, however, might have come across some unexpected challenges. Being a junior doctor comes with all the usual pressures of life, but there are also unique stressors: 1. Hierarchy There is still a hierarchy in medicine, and as an intern you are at the bottom. Whilst a lot of work is being done to change the culture and to eradicate bullying and harassment, it still exists and will take time to improve. 2. Training positions With the growing number of medical graduates there is a constant struggle to find enough placements for each of them. Unfortunately, there is fierce competition to get into a desired training program which is causing a lot of angst and stress for junior doctors. The AMA and other organisations have worked for a number of years on this issue and will continue to pressure government to ensure more training positions are created. One thing you can do is join the AMA and get involved. 3. Working hours We know that working excessive hours or nightshifts increases the risk for burnout and depression. Furthermore, working evenings or weekends places a strain on relationships or our social life. 4. Rural placement Being seconded to different hospitals and rotations away from home is a common scenario, but the impact on our social life is often overlooked. Whilst some embrace it as an opportunity to meet new people, others can find it challenging as they miss their partners, family or friends, and are removed from their social network. 5. Personal reasons The factors that motivated us to become doctors (intellectual challenge, altruism, parental pressure) can also become the ones that place us at increased risk of negative effects (perfectionism, poor emotional expression, poor coping skills to deal with stress, self-sacrificing, low tolerance for uncertainty, e.g. diagnostic uncertainty, uncertainty of training positions, or job security in long-term). In addition, there are a number of barriers to seeking help: • Fear of lack of confidentiality or privacy •Embarrassment • Stigma of ill-health in the profession So, if you are feeling stressed, distressed or burnt out, what can you do about it? 1. Ensure you have your own GP. 2. Prevention is easier than treatment. Look after yourself and ensure you have a work-life balance: Serenity: take time out and do something relaxing Exercise: do some regular exercise or your favourite sport Love: stay connected with your friends, family and partner Food: eat well and drink wisely 3. If you have specific issues you are dealing with, you might need to seek more specialised help like finding a psychologist/psychiatrist or seeking a Drug, Alcohol and Gambling Services (DAGS) Counsellor. 4. Further help is available through following websites or organisations: • Perceived impact on colleagues and patients •jmohealth.org.au • Perceived impact on career development •AMA • Perceived implications of mandatory notification • Difficulty of access (lack of time, experienced personnel, geographic isolation) •DHAS • Beyond Blue •Lifeline •EAP More resources can be accessed on the above websites as well. • Expectation that doctors will work while unwell I hope that the rest of 2016 is great for you and the beginning of a satisfying career. Just remember there is help available when needed. dr. amansw.com.au I 25 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING When you are a patient They say doctors make the worst patients, but it doesn’t have to be that hard. Doctors’ Health Advisory Service’s Jill Gordon explains. An article in JAMA in 2011 reported on a study that showed doctors actually recommend different treatments for patients than they would choose for themselves. It suggests that we may be less objective when considering our own health – a finding that backs the old adage that the doctor who treats him/ herself has a fool for a physician. If it makes good sense to consult a trusted colleague about health issues, especially serious ones, why is it that we so often fail to do so? . Dr Margaret Kay, Medical Director of the Doctors’ Health Advisory Service in Queensland has studied the problems that doctors face when they think about being patients. Fears include, embarrassment, reluctance to admit to ‘weakness,’ concerns about confidentiality, and a fear of mandatory reporting. In medical school and later on in our careers we are often rewarded for hiding our ignorance and parading our knowledge. You only have to look at some of the performances that we see in hospital rounds to appreciate how important it is for some people to flaunt their knowledge. Not surprisingly, it is a lot more difficult to admit that we don’t know a lot about a particular condition that may have caught up with us. Being a good patient isn’t that hard – model yourself on those patients whom you like yourself – the ones who are cheerful, succinct, honest, collaborative and appreciative – the ones who really try to do what the doctor ordered! dr. Should you suspect something is wrong, here are some hints on how to approach the situation: 1.Don’t delay. Even if the problem proves to be trivial there’s no point in procrastinating. You’re not so important that your patients can’t manage without you for the time it takes to see a doctor for what ails you. 2.Find a GP that you like and respect. Stick with them and allow them to do their job. If you are trying out a new doctor and you don’t get a sense of rapport, try again. 3.Don’t fear that you might be overly discursive. It’s more likely that you’ll be tempted to cut corners and fail to give a full account of your symptoms. If necessary take some notes into the consultation and don’t apologise for doing so. 4.Don’t hesitate to ask for explanations of anything that you don’t understand and if the problem is serious, consider using your smart phone to record the consultation so that you can listen to it later. It’s not only patients who forget 50% of what is said in a medical consultation; doctor-patients are likely to do the same thing. 5.We all catastrophised in medical school and we often keep on doing it later on. Common things occur commonly, so rather than nursing secret fears, make an appointment. 6.If you need a referral to a specialist, negotiate politely with your GP over the choice of a suitable person and take his or her advice. Your best mate from medical school might not be the right person to see, and your GP will have had feedback from a range of patients with the same condition that you have. 7.Try not to be ashamed of psychological symptoms. Doctors are especially prone to depression, anxiety disorders and to a degree of obsessionality and rumination that can make life miserable. 8.Men in particular can suffer from alexithymia: the inability to experience and express a full range of emotions. The suffering that emerges can be felt as physical symptoms, and the connection with stress is not always clear until you’ve had the chance talk it through – that’s the beauty of medical confidentiality; it’s an opportunity to discuss concerns that may be hard to express. 9.Don’t argue about payment. It may seem old-fashioned but if your doctor adheres to the ethical principle of not charging colleagues accept it with grace. If s/he charges you more than the Medicare rebate, that’s a great pity; s/he has missed the opportunity to demonstrate, in a tangible way, that a medical consultation is much more than a business transaction. 26 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING Sing (and tell the blues so long) Dr Bernard Haylen extols the mental health benefits of singing – it’s cheaper than therapy, healthier than drinking, and more fun than exercise. ‘Sing (and tell the blues so long)’ – so goes the title of one of the most famous songs from the father of Australian Rock n Roll, Johnny O’Keefe. Whilst the lives of musicians can be a roller-coaster – and Johnny’s was as much as any – they are never happier than when they are singing. All of our lives have twists and turns and ups and downs. Those in doctors’ orchestras would tell you about how relaxing it is playing an instrument in that setting – it takes you to another zone, removed from life’s multiple stresses. Singing is no different. There’s been quite a lot written on both the “feel-good” and the health effects of singing, particularly in a choir. Researchers at the University of Gothenburg, Sweden, found that choristers’ heartbeats synchronize when they sing together, bringing about a calming and meditative effect that is as beneficial to our health as yoga. Singing soothes the nerves and elevates the spirits. These benefits have variably been suggested to be the result of the release of endorphins or oxytocin or to lower levels of cortisol. Studies have shown singing lessens feelings of depression and loneliness. Professor Graham Welch, Chair of Music Education at the Institute of Education, University of London, has studied health benefits of singing for 30 years, citing the physical benefits as an aerobic activity increasing oxygenation and exercise of upper body, laryngeal and facial muscle groups, as well as with the psychological benefits, such as an increased sense of community and belonging to a shared endeavour. Singing in groups is one of life’s great natural team activities. A joint Harvard and Yale study showed that choral singing increased the life expectancy of the population of New Haven, Connecticut, concluding that singing promoted both a healthy heart and an enhanced mental state. Another study at the University of California has reported higher levels of immune system proteins in the saliva of choristers after performing a complex Beethoven piece. Other benefits of singing variably cited are: an increase in poise, self-esteem and presentation skills; strengthening of memory and concentration; improved lung capacity and posture; animation of body, mind and spirit; expanding, via singing beautiful lyrics, one’s imagination and appreciation of the world around us; an improved ability to listen; a greater appreciation of the art and talents of great singers or groups; an ageless enjoyment therapeutically, physically and emotionally. It has been said that group singing is certainly cheaper than therapy, healthier than drinking, does not put on calories and is more fun than working out. It is one thing in life where feeling better is pretty much guaranteed. Dr Bernard Haylen belongs to the Sydney Male Choir. If you’re interested in joining you can contact him at [email protected] or Ron Brown at [email protected]. dr. amansw.com.au I 27 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING Farewell to the Father Tim Elliott’s memoir of his father, Dr Max Elliott, details his dad’s heartwrenching battle with mental illness. Tim first published his story in The Sydney Morning Herald’s Good Weekend magazine. The article generated one of the largest reader responses in the paper’s history and sparked his book, Farewell to the Father, which was released in March 2016. As his son, Tim Elliott, describes in his memoir Farewell to the Father, Max was educated at Scots College, where he was instructed to seek achievement above all: ‘Nothing succeeds like success.’ Max became a prefect at Scots, a senior cadet officer and the school swim champion. A talented athlete, Max also played Rugby Union for Australia, travelling with the Wallabies to New Zealand (1952) and South Africa (1953) and played prop in the 1957 Test against the All Blacks in Sydney. Following in his family’s footsteps, Max went on to study medicine at Sydney University where he graduated in 1955 with Second Class Honours. “He was a massive overachiever and a perfectionist,” says Tim. “In everything, there was a nagging feeling that he might not be doing it to the maximum of his ability. If he jogged, he had to jog 10 kilometres a day, if he played rugby, he had to play rugby for Australia… but his quest for perfectionism really destroyed him.” When Tim was 12, his Dad was diagnosed with clinical depression. These days, Max probably would have been diagnosed with bipolar. Tim recalls that his dad’s mood didn’t just swing. As he wrote in an earlier article for The SMH, Tim said: “it careened and “ 28 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 “ Dr Max Elliott, a thoracic physician at Royal North Shore Hospital for more than 20 years, did not do things by half measures. looped, it ploughed through the house like a runaway rollercoaster, smashing down walls, clearing out corridors, unhinging doors. My father on a high was utterly shameless; it was like watching someone make love to the cosmos, on stage, before an ovation of angels.” To his colleagues, he was known as ‘Mad Max’. “They regarded him as slightly off-kilter, with a lot of manic energy and some rather unpredictable behaviour, and I think they did suspect he had mental health issues,” Tim says. “But I don’t think back in that day that they ever would have felt comfortable questioning But underneath his Dad’s relentless, obsessive work ethic, was a real compassion for his patients. SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING The Wallabies on tour in South Africa, 1953 (max, top right) him – I think they let Dad cruise along for quite a while in not such a great state.” As Tim recalls in the book, he didn’t see much of his Dad when he was growing up. Most days, Max would leave the house before the rest of the family was awake and not return until late in the evening. Even then, Max would spend hours at the kitchen table working until midnight. Tim writes in Farewell to the Father: Dad was a romantic: he loved poetry, sunsets; Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata was his favourite piece of music. But when it came to work he was relentless, a haircloth penitent, flogging himself to a bleeding pulp. Mum called him a ‘workaholic’, which I confused with ‘alcoholic’. As a boy, I pictured Dad sitting at his desk, swigging from a bottle. Who knows, maybe he did? He was certainly gone a long time, leaving for work before I got up and returning after I’d gone to bed. Then, because he always had More Work To Do, he would set up office at the kitchen table, dictating his excruciatingly detailed patient histories and examining X-rays, wobbling them up to the wall light and squinting at them through his big, square, gold-framed glasses. This he would do until eleven or twelve, or even one or two in the morning. Sometimes I would wake and wander into the kitchen and give him a hug. Or not, depending on his mood. Then, much later, I would hear him downstairs, roaring like the wolf in ‘The Three Little Pigs’, about to blow our house down. But underneath his Dad’s relentless, obsessive work ethic, was a real compassion for his patients. According to Tim, Max really liked the idea of helping people and he really loved his patients. “His devotion to them was absolute, and they loved him in return,” Tim says. Tim recalls the story of an Italian cake maker, Ross Rocka, who owned a pasticceria in San Souci. Max had saved Mr Rocka’s daughter’s life about the time that Max’s third child, Camilla, was born. So every year on Camilla’s birthday, Mr Rocka would deliver a custom baked birthday cake to their family home – for the next 21 years, until the imagined debt was repaid. In Farewell to the Father, Tim writes: But, God, was he a good doctor. His sentimentality and emotionalism, which was the flip side of his hysteria, afforded him an uncommon depth of compassion. Mum spoke of the almost mystical way in which he could inform a patient of the very worst, sit with them while they absorbed it – waiting as they wept or went blank – and then say something that allowed them to rise from their seat and walk out the door in something other than a state of utter and complete desolation. ‘I don’t know how he does it,’ she would say, as if pondering a piece of conjury. According to Tim, his Dad had many “regulars” – patients that he saw for amansw.com.au I 29 SPECIAL EDITION: DOCTORS’ HEALTH & WELLBEING decades. However, the death of patients tended to agitate Max’s underlying mental health issues. “His emotional palette was really vivid. Anything could tip him over the edge or into a bout of hysterical happiness or hysterical sadness. He had a morose streak anyway, and the deaths definitely exasperated his tendency toward selfloathing, in that perhaps that he didn’t do more.” Tim recalls in his memoir: I suppose there are doctors who can divorce themselves from their work, who go home every night as happy as larks, but Dad wasn’t one of them. Dad didn’t obsess over his patients’ deaths – he wasn’t in awe of death itself. And he didn’t weep over their pain and tribulations. But plenty of people he treated inevitably ended up dying, and when they died, they took a tiny bit of my father with them. It was a slow, cumulative process – like waves chewing away at the base of a cliff – and it gradually eroded his goodwill and love of life, a commodity that with some people, Dad included, appears to be perilously finite. Lust for life, joie de vivre, hope, whatever you want to call it – it’s the fossil fuel of the soul. Once it’s gone, it’s gone. Max never confided in his colleagues about his mental health issues, in large part because he was afraid he might lose his authority, or worse, he might lose his job. However, Tim says towards the end of his Dad’s career, many colleagues became worried about his ability to perform his duties as a senior physician. “He became obsessive with tiny details. And the consultations took so long appointments were backed up 10, 15 “ “ Max never confided in his colleagues about his mental health issues, in large part because he was afraid he might lose his authority, or worse, he might lose his job. patients. The other doctors were looking at him, going ‘what the hell, what are you doing in there?’ They were worried, thinking ‘is he making good decisions, is he in doubt about what he’s doing?’ But he had been pretty damn competent for so long that they were thinking he must have some plan here. However, they never said to him, ‘Hey what’s going on?’ In the end, Max decided to retire from the hospital in 1987 as a Consulting Physician, after almost 30 years of service as a clinician and teacher. In the same year, he closed his private practice. Initially it was a relief, Tim says. But eventually Max didn’t know what to do with all of the physical and intellectual energy that he had devoted to being a doctor. “You forget how to enjoy yourself and inevitably run out of ways to fill your day. So when he stopped he was bit lost. He had a lot of self-worth bound up in that job,” Tim says. Tim writes that his Dad’s depression increased, as did his volatility. “He raged, he ranted, he roared.” The family worried about their Mum’s safety, as Max had attacked her before. They talked about having him committed and when Tim was 16, Max agreed to a short stay in a psychiatric clinic. Max had attempted suicide several times – the first time was when Tim was about eight. As Tim got older, the attempts, which involved pills and medication, intensified. Eventually, after a particularly violent episode, Tim and his mother left (Tim’s older siblings had already moved out). Max took his own life several months later. His family found him on 23 March 1988. 30 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 Tim Elliott , author It took Tim nearly three decades to write about his father – initially publishing an article in The SMH in 2014. He wrote: “Dad is gone, but he is never gone; he is without life but alive. He’s the closest thing I have to an Old Testament God, both vengeful and tender. When he chose death, he placed himself beyond us, leaving behind an unbridgeable distance across which he still stares with those big brown eyes, looking at me and for me, asking to be made whole. For 26 years I’ve searched for the key that might have made him so, that would have unlocked him and healed him. But, of course, there is no key for people like Dad. There is no answer. There is no peace. This is what he understood and I did not. Dad is still with me, and I’m glad of it. I still love him. He’s my father. dr. Lifeline: 13 11 14. Farewell To The Father by Tim Elliott is published by Picador, RRP $39.99 NOTICE Casual vacancies on AMA (NSW) Council Following the AMA (NSW) Annual General Meeting held 10 May 2016, Council passed a Special Resolution allowing the composition of Council to change. Council approved the creation of five additional unrestricted general member positions. The positions are open to any AMA member and will be casual vacancies. From 2017, the positions will be included in the standard Council election process. If you are interested in pursuing any of these positions, please contact AMA (NSW) on (02) 9439 8822. The changes relate to improving diversity and representation of Council and making the process of applying to Council more accessible. AMA (NSW) acknowledges the importance of reflecting the diversity of the medical profession within its Council. The Council of AMA (NSW) is made up of geographic and speciality representatives and six nominated representatives from the unrestricted class, of whom three must be general practitioners. There are 29 positions on Council, plus one student position. While it is recognised that any eligible member can and should stand for election in an appropriate position, in practice, there can often be a reluctance to stand for election where it is perceived that there is already an incumbent in the role. This is particularly notable for groups with less representation on Council, such as women and doctors from overseas backgrounds (either in terms of training or family of origin). The Council of AMA (NSW) is proposing the expansion of the Council to create five additional unrestricted general member positions. While these positions will be open to any AMA member, it is hoped that the additional positions will encourage more members to be involved in AMA (NSW) Council. Council passed these amendments at its AGM: 1.)AMENDING CLAUSE 35.1, 35.1(x), 35.3 COMPOSITION OF COUNCIL • Clause 35.1 to be amended to increase the number of Councillors from 29 to 34; • Clause 35.3 provides for three terms on Council (as opposed to six) and the exemption for time spent serving as an Officer of the Association remains; 2.)AMENDING CLAUSE 36.1, 36.2 – ELECTION OF COUNCIL • Clause 36.1 to be amended to reflect the increased number of Councillors; • Clause 36.1 requires a candidate for Council to be nominated by one member of the Association (as opposed to two or more); • Clause 36.1(g) to be amended to reflect the change of requirements for the candidate information sheets in the event of a contested election for a position or position on Council; • Clause 36.2 to be amended to delete the reference to the Industrial Relations Act 1996, as provisions of the Act referred to do not apply to AMA (NSW). 3.)INSERTING NEW CLAUSE 36A – TRANSITIONAL PROVISION • Clause 36A provides Council with the power to appoint five members to the Unrestricted General Class in 2016. Those persons must vacate office at the 2017 AGM and those persons may nominate for election in 2017. 4.)AMENDING CLAUSE 50 – NOTICES • Clause 50 has been amended to provide for the provision of notices personally, by post, by facsimile, or electronically and by publication in The NSW Doctor. • Clause 35.1(x) to be amended to increase the number of Councillors in the Unrestricted General Member Class from six to 11; amansw.com.au I 31 NEWS Careers Service hits the road AMA (NSW)’s Careers Service has already met with hundreds of doctors in 2016 to offer support and practical advice. Since February, the Careers Service has been going out to hospitals across the State to inform doctors about the careers support available to our members and equip them with practical advice for CVs, applications and interviews. These visits – from Sydney Metro to Wagga, Coffs and New England – have enabled the Service to make face-to-face contact with over 300 doctors. So far, the Careers Service has visited RNSH, St George, Liverpool, RPA, POW, Port Macquarie, Wagga, Manly, Fairfield, Coffs Harbour, Belmont, John Hunter, Maitland, Taree and Tamworth – with more events to come. The Careers Service also enjoyed a lively and impressive fundraising event at Western Sydney University with its very enthusiastic cohort of final year students. TESTIMONIALS “I would like to say thank you for your help with my interview preparation last year for surgical positions. I have since secured two staff specialist positions.” - Bariatric surgeon “Excellent talk – would be great to have this every year.” - Coffs JMO “Highlighting the need to plan and prepare early. Clear and concise presentation.” - Coffs JMO “Highlighted the advantages of joining that I was unaware.” - Fairfield “Excellent delivery, relevant topic. Would have been useful at earlier stages of career.” - Manly May took us to Adelaide for the RACP trainees’ day, (part of the RACP Congress) where we had the opportunity to meet physician trainees from around Australia and New Zealand and share experiences about the often daunting application and interview process. Careers Adviser Anita Fletcher spoke at the Congress and has been invited to take part next year at the RACP Congress’s Bringing Specialists Together Sharing Knowledge, Building Skills event in Melbourne 8-10 May. This activity has meant that word about the Careers Service is getting around and requests for assistance are on the rise. If you would like to benefit from the service, email [email protected] or phone Anita Fletcher on 9902 8158. Members will also have seen an invitation to our Careers Expo at the SMC in Goulburn Street Sydney through email; please see ad on p33 for more details. 32 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 Careers weekend Coffs Harbour Health Campus Careers Service has assisted Interns, SRMOs, consultants and surgeons with CVs, cover letters, interview skills, and pathways across a diverse range of specialties, including: •Physician •GP •Opthalmology •Surgery •Anaesthetics •Emergency •Oncology •Cardiology •Neurology MEDICAL AMA NSW/ASMOF NSW ALLIANCE CAREERS EXPO VENUE SMC Conference & Function Centre 66 Goulburn Street Sydney NSW 2000 REGISTRATION 8.30am – 9am EXHIBITION 9am – 4.30pm DATE Saturday 6 August 2016 ✔ Speak with representatives from the colleges and training organisations ✔ Industry insights and talks from prominent guest speakers ✔ Find out about future vocational training and career opportunities ✔ A great opportunity for graduating medical students and Doctors-in-Training to meet key industry influencers and future colleagues ✔ Equip yourself with necessary application and interview skills, give yourself a competitive edge ✔ A great place to meet influential organisations and network FREE EVENT Registrations/Timetable: amansw.com.au/event/ama-nsw-asmof-nsw-alliance-medical-careers-expo Sponsorship opportunities: [email protected] Enquiries: [email protected] Platinum sponsor amansw.com.au I 33 MEDICO-LEGAL Andrew Took Director Medico-Legal and Employment Relations The Community Network – not so community-minded? Kym Gardner Senior Solicitor Are your broadcast ads reaching your target audience? It can be difficult to measure – unless you have evidence that your audience doesn’t even have a working TV! The AMA NSW Medico-Legal team Such was the case with one advertiser and a company known as The Community Network (currently trading as Multimedia International Services Pty Ltd). Andrew Campbell Solicitor Ivy Tseng Policy and Legal Advisor Sarah Connor Policy and Legal Advisor Sarah Fam Policy and Legal Advisor Eden Weller Paralegal Officer The Community Network (TCN) offers digital advertising services, where they install digital televisions in local businesses and offer advertising slots which are broadcast on these televisions to a range of businesses. The Community Network has been subject to an Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) investigation since 2015 which has culminated in court action with Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Multimedia International Services Pty Ltd [2016] FCA 439. The Federal Court found that TCN had engaged in unconscionable conduct in its dealings with one small business, and making false and misleading representations to two other small businesses and wrongly accepting payment from them. The case revealed that the televisions to display the advertising were not yet installed (nor were they for several months thereafter) when TCN sold the advertising time and the customer had started paying for the time. TCN also refused to release this small business from the contract even though no advertising services had been provided, continuing to use debt collectors, threats of legal action and an adverse credit rating to claim the remaining contractual amount. 34 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 TCN was ordered to pay penalties of $230,000 for breaching the Australian Consumer Law in its dealings with the three small businesses which were the focus of the court case. TCN is also subject to a court enforceable undertaking starting on 27 April 2016 for a period of five years in which TCN has undertaken not to continue certain business practices. Despite this ACCC matter going on, we have had members in very similar situations where they did not receive the services they purchased under a contract signed over 18 months ago, have tried to terminate contracts, and yet continue to receive correspondence chasing payments. dr. Too much of a good thing Do you have any employees who have been with you for eight years, earn lots of time in lieu and have a mountain of annual leave stored up? A recent review of modern Awards has led to some small, but nonetheless important changes to do with granting and taking annual leave. These changes relate to excessive annual leave accruals, cashing out annual leave and granting annual leave in advance. Excessive annual leave occurs when an employee is not a shift worker and has more than eight weeks of annual leave accrued. Concerned you or your employee may have an excessive leave balance? Employers are able to direct employees to take leave if they have an excessive leave balance. However, first they must request a meeting, where the employer and employee genuinely attempt to come to an agreement to reduce or eliminate the excessive leave balance. If you do direct an employee to take leave there a few things to keep in mind: firstly, an employee cannot be directed to take leave for any period less than one week; secondly, an employee cannot be directed to take a leave for any period that will result in their leave balance being less than six weeks; lastly, an employer cannot direct an employee to take leave commencing less than eight weeks after the direction, or more than 12 months after the direction. Remember, employers must be consistent with any leave agreements they have with employees. Alternately, an employee may choose to cash out some of their annual leave if they have an excessive leave balance. In doing this, an employee cannot cash out more than two weeks of annual leave in a 12-month period and cannot cash out any amount of leave which would lead to their remaining balance being below four weeks. In addition, the Commission has decided to include a new term in the Awards for granting leave in advance. This means that employees can now take leave, before they have accrued the entitlement, if agreed upon by the employer. This new inclusion will enable mutually beneficial flexibility for both employers and employees. AMA (NSW) recommends that employers consider the needs of the business and the needs of the employee before granting any leave in advance, cashing out annual leave or before directing an employee to take leave. dr. When the worst happens Nobody wants to think about it, but what happens if you suddenly are unable to practice medicine and have to shut down your practice? No doubt you have income protection insurance or other insurances that cover the financial concerns for your family, but what about the burden of sorting out what to do with the patients’ ongoing needs, your practice and your staff? Obviously this falls to your partners, associates or fellow directors if you are in a group situation, but if not, it becomes an additional concern for your family. Recently our team assisted the daughter of a long term member who had had a stroke. The member was a solo GP with a thriving 30-year-old trusted practice. Unable to deal with the practice, it was left to the GP’s eldest daughter to sort out what needed to be done in her absence. We recommended to the daughter that she keep support staff working for at least four to six weeks, to ring all patients with appointments booked, and to answer the phone for anyone looking for the doctor. The incoming mail needed to be reviewed and where necessary, if clinical in nature, then another medical practitioner would need to review the information and decide where follow up was needed. Ultimately, she would need to work with the support staff to send letters to all current patients advising them the practice had to close due to unforeseen health issues. We advised that ideally the letter should also list other GPs in the area for patients that had any ongoing problems that required regular consultations, and a recommendation to find another primary care provider as soon as possible. The original medical files could then be transferred to the new GP. For those files not moved to alternative practices there is the obligation to store the medical files for seven years, ensuring that there is an identified access point, for example, through a post office box where patients can write to for a copy of their files. Should the worst happen, the obligations are extensive, but the AMA (NSW) is happy to assist where we can in guiding members and their families through this maze. dr. amansw.com.au I 35 GOLF EVENTS President’s Cup 2016 It wasn’t an easy day at the course, but President’s Cup winner Dr Michael Burke came out on top. A crisp, sunny, winter’s morning welcomed 31 players to beautiful Pennant Hills Golf Club for the 2016 President’s Cup. Despite recent severe storms in the area, the course was well presented and played particularly hard as the scores reflected. Winner of the Cup, on a count-back with 40 stableford points, was a very consistent regular Dr Michael Burke, and another regular Mr Dean Lucas in second place. Winners of the 2BBB with 45 points were Drs Ivan Cottom and Ian Meakin, just nudging out Drs Stuart Ludowici and Michael Burke on 44. Nearest the pins went to Dr Jeff Myers and Mr Graeme Lovett. It could be said that the rest of the field put in a sterling effort and it would be politic not to mention some of their scores. A special welcome was extended to "first timers" Dr Lawrie Guitronich, Mr Stephen Patterson and Mr Kerry Evripidou. It was also pleasing to see Mr Michael Henley leading the TressCox team. Runner up Mr Dean Lucas with Dr Robyn Napier A very sincere message of congratulations was extended by Dr Alec Harris to our leader, Dr Robyn Napier on her award of the Order of Australia Medal in the Queen’s Birthday Honours list. Mention was also made that one our great supporters and sponsors, Mr Paul Betar also received an OAM at the same time. Well done to both of them. Our next event is the Spring Cup at Terrey Hills Golf Club on Thursday 1 SPRING CUP // Thursday 1st September Terrey Hills Golf Club INTERNATIONAL SHIELD // 22nd to 30th October New Zealand – Registrations now open BMA CUP // Friday 2nd December NSW Golf Club AMA (NSW) Golf Society Claudia Gillis 9439 8822 Winner Dr Michael Burke with Dr George Thomson & Dr Robyn Napier [email protected] 36 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 September. All doctors and their partners with a recognised golf handicap are welcome to join us. This year’s International Shield will be held in New Zealand 22-30 October. In the meantime, good golfing to all. For any inquiries about the Golf Society please contact Claudia Gillis at AMA (NSW) 02 9439 8822.. dr. Cape Kidnappers Golf Course AMA (NSW) Golf Society 2016 International Shield – New Zealand This year’s International Shield competition will be held in the northern island of New Zealand on some of the most scenic golf courses in the world. Six rounds of golf will be played at Wairakei International Golf Couse, the Kinloch Club, and Cape Kidnappers. Accommodation will be for six nights in the luxurious Hilton Lake Taupo and three nights in Scenic Hotel Te Pania. All transfers are included and nonplaying partners are warmly welcomed. Places are limited, please contact Claudia Gillis 9439 8822 or [email protected] for a full itinerary. dr. 15TH ANNUAL CONTINUING PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION (CPE) SEMINAR This 1½ day seminar covers current developments in medical practice with updates in the treatment of diseases, preventative health issues and is designed to assist experienced practitioners towards meeting the CPE requirements. Date | Saturday, 23 July – 9am-4pm and Sunday, 24 July – 9am-1pm Venue | Y3A Theatre, Macquarie University (enter Balaclava Road) Cost | AMA members $150. Non-members $200. Includes morning teas and lunch on Saturday. This seminar will be submitted for QI&CPD points approval by the RACGP QI&CPD Program. Register online: www.amansw.com.au For more information or to make a booking Jenni Noble phone 02 9902 8140 or email [email protected] amansw.com.au I 37 MEMBERS A warm welcome to all of our new members this month Get more from your membership today and utilise our medico-legal and industrial relations team for advice, our preferred partner advantages, member services and events throughout the year. To find out more phone our membership team on 02 9439 8822. Dr Ahmad Al-Hindawi Dr Julie Argent Dr Benjamin Armstrong Dr Shrivaney Arrudsivah Dr Martiane Bersano Dr Jenna Besley Dr Jill Bukofzer Dr Andrew Cepak Dr Chloe Champion De Crespigny Dr Vimal Chand Dr Joseph Chiha Dr Ping Shu Choi Dr Anne Collins Dr Veronica Corrigan Dr Monique Damasco Dr Omprakash Damodaran Dr Kashmira De Silva Dr Alexandra Draney Dr Victoria Edwards Dr Mohamed El Molla Dr Ahmad Elgendy Fionnuala Fagan Dr Amireh Fakhouri Dr Chitra Fernando Dr Ann Formaz-Preston Dr Christopher French Dr Natasha Gandhi Dr Chris Ganora Dr Michael Gao Dr Emma Gilbert Dr Dharshan Giritharan Dr Leigh Golding Dr Madelyn Gramlick Dr Scott Hahn Dr Chaw Han Dr Richard Hanney Dr Christopher Harrington Dr Sebastian Heintze Dr Phong Ho Dr Patrick Horsley Dr Mirette Ibrahim Dr Mouhannad Jaber Dr Shefali Jani Dr Robert Kalmar Sanjana Kannansud Dr Elizabeth Kennedy Dr Surabhi Khare Dr Haimee Kim Dr Michael Kulisiewicz Dr Melissa Kuo Dr Irena Kyte Dr Ramanathan Lakshmanan Dr Abdul Lathif Dr Sharon Laura Dr Richard Lawrence Dr Philip Le Page Dr Jung Min Lee Dr Jennifer Li Dr Ivy Lien Dr Phoebe Lovett Dr Kwok Ping Low Dr Fatma Lowden Dr Thiri Lwin Dr Trevor Ma Dr Mojgan Mansouri Dr Jyothi Marry Dr Jessie McClelland Dr Georgina McDonald Dr Fortunate Mchechesi Dr Gary McKay Dr Amit Mishra Dr Ferdinand Miteff Dr Perla Moukhaiber Dr Sudhir Mudunuri Dr Adam Najem Dr Sonali Disha Nanayakkara Dr Agnes Ng Dr Chitra Parab Dr Sugeesh Pathirana Dr David Phillips Dr Vasantha Bhanu Yadav Pothala Dr Wijayati Pusparina Dr Ashfaque Quadir Dr Motiur Rahman Dr Jusveer Rakhra Dr Arpita Ray Dr Andrea Rose Dr Jaspreet Saini A/Prof Smita Shah Dr Amirreza Shameli Ganeshwaran Shivapathasundram Dr Arush Singh Dr Brent Skippen Dr Daniel Smoothy Dr Victoria Snaidr Dr Mark Song Dr Paul Stephens Dr Lee Sutton Dr Yasmin Tan Dr James Tester Dr Alexander Treble Dr Ashleigh Udell Dr David Van Der Poorten Dr Carlo Vernier Dr Sameer Viswanathan Dr Hoang Quan Vo Dr Jessica Wade Dr Jordan Webb Dr Phoebe Williams Dr Ka Chun Arthur Wong Dr Mon-Chiao Wu Dr Charlotte Yin Dr Wenjie Zhong Dr Jingjing Zhou The AMA (NSW) offers condolences to family and friends of those AMA members who have recently passed away. Dr Marion Baker Dr Michael Burns Dr Phillip Cappe Dr Robert Evans Dr George Hession Dr Gragery Rasiah Dr Vivienne Schnieden Dr Peter Walters CLASSIFIEDS GP NEEDED IN MOOREBANK FAMILY MEDICAL PRACTICE • VR GP with Partnership available • Immediate Start PT/FT Contact [email protected] • 75% and based earnings guarantee PINNACLE Seeking an Integrative GP HEALTH CLINIC Pinnacle Health has been providing Complementary Medicine services in Western Sydney for over 30 years. We are currently seeking an Integrative GP to come on board and operate their business in a room rental agreement in our private billing clinic. What we offer: Access to an existing client database; Free parking for your clients; Full administrative support (reception, appointment management, supply ordering, health fund rebate management, established pathology arrangements etc); Modern rooms equipped with full telecommunications /internet; Street frontage exposure; Cross referral from other practitioners practicing within the clinic. Terms and conditions are negotiable to benefit a sustainable practice. To discuss options further or to view the premises, email- [email protected]. 38 I THE NSW DOCTOR I JULY/AUGUST 2016 amansw.com.au I 39 MEMBER SERVICES Make your membership more rewarding everyday! Qantas Club ip has its rewards Medico-Legal and Employment Relations advice in Australia. le include awards advice and updates, court representation, A comprehensive range of legal packages and draft contracts e. In addition, below are a list of our member service partners AMA Member Rates (GST inclusive) TressCox Lawyers Joining Fee: $240.00 save Expert legal – advice for $140 the medical profession.$390.60 Members are–entitled a 1 Year Membership: saveto$119.30 unique duty solicitor scheme offering one free consultation (referral required). 2 Year Membership: $697.50 – save $227.50 p has its rewards Link your AMA AMEX to the Qantas rewards program to earn Frequent Flyer AMA Auto Buying Service points faster! A free service specialising in the For more information visit www.ama.com.au/memberservices-qantas acquisition, funding and disposal of all or and models of motor vehicles. phone 02 9439 8822 and ask formakes our friendly member services team. Accountants/Tax Advisers Panel Medico-Legal and Employment Relations advice Australia. petent, Experienced accounting firmsin who To find out more give friendly AMA (NSW) canupdates, assist you our with your personal and eyour include awards advice and court representation, professional accounting and taxation A comprehensive range of legal packages and draft contracts needs. Select the firm most suitable for . In addition, below are a listyour of requirements. our member service partners ty at a cards. (NSW) the most comprehensive Medico-Legal and Em Benefits ofAMA Qantas Clubhas Membership: some of the services • DedicatedJust check-in on most Qantas flights.that are available include awards adv mediation and human resource • Extra checked baggage allowances on selected consulting. Qantas flights. A comprehensive rang are available for members for a nominal fee. In addition, below a • As a Qantas Club member you also have complimentary membership to the to assist you whatever the need. Qantas Frequent Flyer program. • And so much more... AMA (NSW) Member Service P W) Member Service Partners l of all icles. Membership has i Make your flight experience more enjoyable by starting it off in the Qantas Club Lounge and save 32 per cent when you join Qantas Club with your AMA membership discount! Assign Medical members services team a call on 02 9439 8822. Assists members to source competent, friendly and committed staff for your business or practice. Preferred partners AMA (NSW) Member Reward Card Significant savings every year with Commonwealth Bank Commonwealth Bank A special merchant facility at low rates. AMA members pay a New special facilityareateligible a noOffering joining fee. CBAmerchant merchant clients to 6 months freeof terminal rental a free business account low fee 0.68% for and most credit cards. when they sign up their merchant facility with CBA and settle the funds to a CBA account. BOQ Specialist Bank Limited ) Member Service Partners participating restaurants, hotels and ersonal . Finance nts, motor of all property cles. petent, al services our members. n, Risk Insurance y at a cards. ors, on of ge of sonal Finance s, motor property nt) igence ment es, services members. , Risk nsurance tions: BOQ Specialist delivers distinctive banking solutions tourist attractions. to niche market segments. Our focus, experience and TressCox Lawyers dedication to our clients have enabled us to become American Express Expert legal advice for the medical Offering corporate affinity programs and experts in a number of professional niches. We aim to add profession. Members are entitled to a special discounts members for credit value to andtobuild partnerships with our clients and we have unique duty solicitor scheme offering cardsbeen and merchant providingfacilities. specialist banking in Australia for over 20 one free consultation (referral required). years. Auscellardoor AMA (NSW) Wine Accountants/Tax Advisers Panel Society Accountants/Tax Advisers Experienced who Boutique winesaccounting at speciallyfirms negotiated a comprehensive range can Provide assist you withevery yourmonth. personal and of personal and prices for members professional accounting services. professional accounting and taxation needs. StarCard Select the firm most suitable for Caltex ons: Specialist finance to meet the personal and practice needs of members. Finance solutions for practice requirements, motor vehicles, commercial/residential property and overdraft facilities. Consolidate your vehicle fuel expenses your requirements. onto one easy-to-read monthly statement with access to the followingReward fuel AMA (NSW) Member Card discounts: off unleaded, Significant2.5cpl savings every yearVortex with 95 and Diesel andrestaurants, 1.5cpl off Vortex 98.and participating hotels Gow-Gates Group Member services tourist attractions. Complete insurance and financial services with special packages for AMA members. Services include: Riskreduced Virgin Australia – TheWealth LoungeCreation, | Significantly rates with no joiningDoctors’ fee and savings of $100 per year. Management, Practice Insurance and Superannuation. Hertz As the official Express car rental partner for AMA, American American Express | Corporate affinity programs and Hertz offers discounted ratesprograms and a range Offering corporate and credit cards. Whichever discounts on all aaffinity range of six unique ofspecial member benefits year round. discounts to members for credit card you choose you’ll enjoy the special benefits and extra cards and merchant facilities. value we’ve negotiated for you. Qantas Club Discounted rates for AMA members. Auscellardoor AMA (NSW) Wine Save Qantas up to $365 on membership. Club | Discounted rates saves you hundreds Society Fees as dollars follows:on Joining $200; of membership. Joining fee $240, save $140; Boutique winesTwo at specially negotiated One year $265; years $465. one year membership $390.60, save $119.30; two year prices for members every month. membership $697.50, save $227.50. Partner rates (GSTStarCard inclusive) Partner Joining Fee: $200, Partner 1 Year Caltex Membership Fee: $340, Partner 2 Year Membership Consolidate your vehicle fuel expenses ontoFee: one $600. easy-to-read monthly statement MEDPRAC 25% R E B AT E SUPERANNUATION Mercedes-Benz Corporate Programme | Members can enjoy the benefits Prosper Groupof this Programme which includes complimentary scheduled servicing for up to 3 years/75,000 A property advisory (buyer’s agent) km, preferential pricing on selected vehicles and reduced whodelivery can source, due isdiligence dealer charges.perform Also included access to complimentary pick-up drop-off, access to a loan vehicle and negotiate yourand home, investment during car servicing and up to 4 years of Mercedes-Benz properties or commercial premises, Road Care nationwide. mercedes-benz.com.au/corporate saving you time and money. 4www.nswama.com.au Fees as follows: Joining $200; One year $265; Two years $465. Avis Budget | Avis Budget is the official car rental partner for AMA (NSW) offering discounted rates. Contact AMA member services for the details. 25% R E B AT E Introduce a new member to AMA (NSW) and receive a cheque equal to 25% of the Inew member’s 40 I THE NSW DOCTOR JULY/AUGUST 2016 subscription via our Member Get Member program. There are no limits. Medprac Super Fund | Members can enjoy the BMW Corporate Programme benefits of this Programme which complimentary The perfect super fund for includes doctors, scheduled servicing for 5 years/80,000 km, preferential pricing no entry fees. the option of charges. onwith selected vehicles and Have reduced dealer delivery managing your fund using a range of investment managers. with access to the following fuel discounts: 2.5cpl off unleaded, Vortex 95 advice and duty solicitor Introduce a new member to AMA (NSW) and receive TressCox Lawyers | Expert legal s, and Diesel 1.5cpl off Vortex 98. a cheque equal to 25% of theand new scheme with member’s one free consultation (referral required). on of subscription via our Member Get Member e of program. There are Hertz no limits. As the officialCity car rental partner for AMA,can enjoy the benefits Sydney Lexus | Members Hertz offers discounted rates and a range of the Lexus Corporate Programme, including Encore of member benefits all year round. all AMA (NSW) Member Services onAn(02) 9439 8822 Privileges. exclusive offer in conjunction with Qantas t) is available Qantas Club to AMA members - earn one Qantas Point an areas) gence for everyrates dollar on a new vehicle purchase, only at Discounted forspent AMA members. ment City on Lexus. SaveSydney up to $365 membership. es, Investec Experien Other benefits:Call AMA (NSW) member services on 02 9439 8822 or email [email protected]. Visit our websites Receive automatic subscriptions to the following publications: www.amansw.com.au or www.ama.com.au nn AMA List of Medical Services Book benefit from its relationship Disclaimer: AMA and (NSW)Fees may financially nn MEMBER The NSW Doctor with AMA (NSW) or Federal AMA. AMA Products is a separate with Preferred Partners. Please note: AMA Products is not affiliated business entity. nn The Medical Journal of Australia nn Australian Medicine nn AMA Action (e-newsletter) 25 Introduce a cheque e subscripti program. T How we Help you build and preserve wealtH A full range of specialised services n Surgery acquisition strategies n Tax deductible debt strategies n Investment planning n Medical practice structuring n Effective practice service entities n Estate planning n Tailored Superannuation strategies n Cloud-based record keeping n Tax planning A team of medical accounting experts These are the experienced medical accounting specialists who will advise and guide you Jarrod Bramble Partner Specialist Medical Services Shane Morgan Partner Superannuation Juliane Walsh Client Service Manager Nicole Brown Client Service Manager Phil Smith Partner Investment Jodie Walshe Client Service Manager Stuart Chan Director Specialist Medical Services Pauline Smith Client Service Manager Michael Graham Director Cloud Software Cameron Nix Client Service Manager Catherine Parker Client Service Manager Megan Goodwin Client Service Manager Specialists in accounting services to medical practitioners since 1953 PREFERRED ACCOUNTING PARTNER NATIONAL SPONSOR cutcher.com.au T 02 9923 1817 E [email protected] innovative thinking. traditional values. Let your savings do the heavy lifting Grow your business, retirement or personal savings with our 180 day term deposit. Put your money to work with a great interest rate of 3.00% p.a. and enjoy a fixed return with the added benefit of no establishment or account keeping fees. 3.00% p.a. With our 180 day term deposit. This offer is available on new to bank funds deposited by doctors, dentists and vets for AUD savings between $10 000 and $5 000 000. Apply now. Visit boqspecialist.com.au/deposit or call 1300 131 141 The issuer of these products and services is BOQ Specialist - a division of Bank of Queensland Limited ABN 32 009 656 740 AFSL no. 244616 (“BOQ Specialist”). Terms and conditions, fees, charges and eligibility criteria apply. Promotional interest rate of 3.00% p.a. for 180 days term deposits is exclusively available for new funds to bank invested in a term deposit by clients deemed by BOQ Specialist, in its sole discretion, to be engaged in the practice of medicine, dentistry and veterinary sciences. BOQ Specialist reserve the right to cease offering this interest rate at any time without notice.