Frequently Asked Questions
Transcription
Frequently Asked Questions
Has WRMA licensed the Northern Collector Tunnel Project? Frequently asked uestions KENYA’S BIGGEST WATER PROJECT: THE NORTHERN WATER COLLECTOR TUNNEL PROJECT What is the Northern Collector Tunnel? In line with Vision 2030, the Government of Kenya plans to improve water services in Nairobi City, Kiambu and Muranga Counties. One of the key ways of improving water services is through the construction of the Northern Collector Tunnel Phase 1(NCT 1) scheme. Athi Water prepared a water masterplan for Nairobi and 13 Satellite towns in 2012. The masterplan provides a blueprint for progressive and phased development of water sources to meet the demand in those areas upto 2035. The first phase of the masterplan has been implemented while the Nothern Collector Tunnel (NCT 1) is under Phase 2 of the masterplan. Phase 3 includes Maragua dam and transfer of water through a tunnel from South Mathioya River. Phase 4 will be NCT 2 which will transfer water from 3 rivers namely North Mathioya, Hembe and Githugi river to Ndakaini dam and Maragua dam, and Phase 5 will be the construction of Ndarugu 1 dam. NCT 1 will entail the construction of 11.8km raw water transfer tunnel along the Eastern fringes of the Aberdare Conservation Area (60Km North of Nairobi), to divert defined flows from Maragua, Gikigie and Irati rivers into existing Ndakaini dam plant and subsequent transmission through 1200mm diameter pipeline to Kabete water reservoirs via Gigiri to supply the upper zones of Nairobi. The project will improve water supply to Nairobi City by 140,000 cubic meters per day. The tunnel will serve the following purposes: 1. Flood control, and 2. To abstract flood flows to Ndakaini dam. The NCT 1 tunnel will utilize flood waters for domestic and industrial use in Nairobi and neighbouring urban areas. How is the Northern Collector Tunnel Designed? The proposed major elements of the project include diversion and intake structures at those three rivers (Maragua, Gikigie and Irati), an outfall at Githika River near Thika reservoir at Makomboki, and Kaanja Access Adit. Once completed, the supply of water to Nairobi residents will increase by about 140,000 cubic meters per day, reducing the daily shortfall to 60,000 cubic meters per day. The operating principal is such that once Ndakaini Dam is full the tunnel is designed to have shut-offs mechanism to protect the dam and downstream communities. Water is again drawn from the 3 rivers after average normal flows (Q95) has been achieved or exceeded and compensation for downstream users and ecological needs have been prioritized and before any abstraction through the tunnel. The tunnel is designed to draw water from the three rivers, especially during flood periods, and to quickly fill up Ndakaini dam. Once the dam is full, no more water is drawn from the three rivers until designed dam drawdown is achieved. Gikigie Intake/Access Adit Irati River Kaanja Adit Portal Makomboki Outfall Thika Dam Project Area ViewViewofof project area How is the NCT 1 different from the design of Ndakaini Dam to Ngethu Treatment Works system? The design for NCT 1 intakes at rivers Maragua, Gikigie and Irati is different from that which was previously constructed on the existing Ndakaini Dam to Ngethu Treatment works system. Athi Water has been keen to improve on technology and innovation in order to develop systems that take into consideration of social and environmental concerns. The NCT 1 systems have been designed with downstream reserve flows being first priority whereas intakes in the earlier system considered abstraction for supply as the first priority. Also the system did not take cognizance of the water needs for surrounding communities. NCT 1 has provided for construction of community water schemes to supply water to communities at Ndakaini and other parts of Murang’a and will improve provision of clean water by 17,000 cubic meters per day and lay 247km of water pipelines at a cost of KSh. 1.4 Billion. Have consultations been done for the project? Athi Water carried out and has to date continued with stakeholder’s consultation and public engagement. This is a process that was carried out with enthusiasm during the feasibility study and master plan preparation phase, the EIA and resettlement action plan (EIA) preparation phase and the preliminary design and detailed design phase. The concerns of the stakeholders were considered and addressed in the reports. At the implementation phase, stakeholders, key among them Muranga County Government will be involved in monitoring of the project to confirm that the designs including any reviews that would enhance social and environmental safeguards are implemented in the works. Athi Water has continued to regard and keep the minutes of stakeholder’s consultative meetings that were conducted. What is Flood Water? Flood water is generally defined as flows more than Q80 or simply flows that are equalled or exceeded 80% of the time at a particular point in a river. The NCT 1 will abstract flows higher than the average normal flows or Q95 for Maragua and Gikigie Rivers and 1.4Q95 for Irati River. This will ensure that the downstream demands (reserve flows) is sustained to meet requirements of downstream users and the ecology. Has NEMA licensed the Northern Collector Tunnel Project? The Northern Collector Tunnel 1 works have been issued with an EIA Licence by NEMA. And whereas this has been contested in the National Environment Tribunal, Athi Water is keen to adhere to the conditions of the licence and comply to the requirements as a condition process. Athi Water has fast tracked the implementation of the Murang’a community water projects with the understanding of Murang’a County Government that these benefits are to the local community as a result of the NCT 1 project. The projects are Murang’a community project ( includes Kiriciungu treatment works supply, Kahuti phase 2 water treatment works supply, and storage and extension of water network distribution system), Gatanga community water project, Gatango community water project, and Kiruri, Ichichii and Makomboki community water project. The Muranga County Government has granted the no objection to construct the contractor’s camps, sites offices and houses at Kinyona, Mununga and Gikoe dispensaries and to upgrade Gikoe dispensary. The dispensary committees for the three facilities have also given Athi Water authority to proceed with these works. The upgraded dispensary will provide better medical services to the project staff and the community. These facilities, including an ambulance to be brought under the project, will be handed over to Muranga County Government on completion of the project. Irati Intake & Shaft Thika River When will the Murangá Community Water Projects start? Has Murangá County Government Granted Construction of the Site Offices? Maragua Intake Maragua River Gikigie River AWSB has made an application to Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) for water abstraction permits from the three rivers (Muranga, Gikigie and Irati) after receiving the NEMA licence for the Works. Construction works will commence at these sites once the WRMA permits have been issued. The land required for the works at the three rivers has been acquired and compensation to landowners is almost completed. In the meantime due to the high scale of pre-construction work required; Athi Water through a contractor is currently undertaking preparation works including contractor’s camp sites and offices. A contractor camp site, spoils area and access road are also under construction at Makomboki site. Will the tunnel tap into the ground water systems? Athi Water as a public body and state corporation is committed to uphold the rule of law and comply with statutory requirement in undertaking the Northern Collector Maragua River Tunnel and any other project. WET WEATHER FLOW DRY WEATHER FLOW Maragua river facing downstream from the bridge Irati river view upstream from bridge Maragua river view Irati river view (pipe submerged) Who is funding the Northern Collector Tunnel 1 and the Community Water Projects in Murangá? The Northern Collector Tunnel project is one component of the Fourth Nairobi Water Supply Project that will include Kigoro Water Treatment Plant of capacity 140,000m cubic meters per day, 6Km by 1200mm diameter gravity pipeline from Thika Dam to Kigoro and 60Km by 1200mm diameter clean water transmission pipeline from Kigoro to Kabete and finally improvement of the Nairobi Water Distribution System. The Fourth Nairobi Water Supply Project is supported and financed by the Government of Kenya, the World Bank, the French Development Agency (AFD) and the German Government Development Bank (KfW). The World Bank has carried out review of the project documents and continues to review activities by Athi Water that relate to the financing portfolio. With the support of the Government of Kenya and the World Bank, Athi Water is keen to ensure that social and environmental mitigation measures, to prevent adverse social or negative environmental impacts as outlined in the Environmental and Social Impact Assessment (ESIA) report, are implemented. Has Athi Water reached out to Maragua Water Resources What benefits will Murangá residents get for the NCT project? Users Association? Through the implementation of the NCT 1 project, communities in Murang’a will derive benefits through the implementation of community water projects. The community water projects will cost KSh. 1.4 Billion and this has been leveraged on the KSh. 6.8 Billion NCT 1 project (14.7% of the NCT 1 project cost). This projects will improve clean water supply by 17,000 cubic meters per day and extend water supply network by 247Km to benefit more than 600,000 people in Murang’a with improve water services. A map of the areas to benefit is available at the office of the Muranga Water Supply Resident Engineer located opposite the Muranga County Commissioner’s residence, Murang’a town (next to Murang’a University of Technology. Further to this, Athi Water is at the final stages of securing financing amounting to KSh. 1.4 Billion for water services improvement in Ithanga which is a semi-arid and dry area of Muranga County and has over the years had severe water supply problems. Why doesn’t Athi Water Build a Dam Downstream to tap the Flood Water? The NCT 1 tunnel has complete concrete lining to prevent ingress of the ground water into the tunnel. The tunnel will therefore not affect ground water system in any way. Tunnel construction technology is not new and has been used widely especially in developed countries in roads, railways and inter-basin water transfer without any effects on ground water system. By constructing a dam downstream of the tunnel, flood flows will be harnessed and stored for use during the dry spell. This is why Athi Water is preparing the development of Maragua dam on Maragua River to harness the excess flows downstream of the tunnel abstraction point. There is an existing 4Km tunnel conveying water from Ndakaini dam to Chania river that was constructed in the early 1990s under the Third Nairobi Water Supply project. No reports of any negative impace has been reported to date as a result of this tunnel on ground water system even though the tunnel was not fully lined. Murangá County Government would also benefit by constructing dams downstream of the tunnel to ensure water security in the county even in times of prolonged dry weather. This will then ensure that planned irrigation schemes are successfully implemented. Planning for irrigation without construction of dams may not be sustainable even without the NCT 1 project. Athi Water has been in discussion with the upper Maragua Water Resource Users Association in an effort to assist the WRUA’s prepare a catchment management proposal for submission to the World Bank financed Kenya Water Security and Climate Resilience Project at the Ministry of Environment, Water and Natural Resources. The proposal will be submitted to Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) for consideration. Athi Water believes that without protecting the catchment which is heavily degraded and devastation continues each year, thinking of adequate water supply for domestic use, let alone for irrigation, is not realistic. There is need for all stakeholders to work together towards protecting the Aberdare forest water tower. Athi Water is keen to see that the NCT 1 water supply is a sustainable investment for the future of Murangá and Nairobi City County. Why is NCT 1 project important? Currently Nairobi City County faces a water demand to supply gap of over 200,000 cubic meters per day. By developing the NCT1 project this demand gap will be reduced by 140,000 cubic meters per day. Otherwise the Nairobi City County that is an economic hub will face serious water shortage in years to come. Close collaboration between Nairobi City County and Muranga County, not forgetting Nyandarua County where Sasumua Dam is located and Kiambu County where Ruiru Dam is located, is fundamental and imperative for the economic development of the respective county governments. Have detailed studies been done on the Northern Collector Tunnel? At the feasibility study and preliminary design stage, Athi Water undertook detailed social, environmental, extended yield analysis, and ecological studies and prepared reports. These reports were reviewed at the Environmental Impact Assessment Report and detailed design preparation stage. The designed intake structures were revised and adjusted to meet the requirements of the revised hydrological analysis report. The hydrological analysis has been done based on existing regulations and observing requirements by Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) on reserve flows and abstractions. Should Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) recommend other adjustments to the design, Athi Water will consider and review the design. Currently, the hydrological report has considered all water rights (current and future) provided by Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) for to the three rivers. What is the Average Annual Maximum Flow in the 3 rivers? The average annual maximum flow in the 3 rivers (Murangá, Gikigie and irati) is 1,198,368 cubic meters per day while the maximum proposed tunnel abstraction is 513,389 cubic meters per day. This means the flow downstream will be 684,979 cubic meters per day against an analysed reserve flow of 110,333 cubic meters per day. This scenario is evident during the rainy seasons when the water level is high in all three rivers. This is the flow that the NCT 1 targets in order to quickly replenish the draw down in Thika dam. When the normal flows are restored, the NCT 1 project will only draw water from the rivers once the compensation flow are achieved and there is surplus flow to flow into the tunnel draw off chamber. This means: 1. Total average annual maximum flow = 437,404,320 cubic meters per year. 2. Proposed NCT abstraction (maximum) = 187,386,912 cubic meters per year 3. Balance flow downstream = 250,017,408 cubic meters per year 4. Instream Flow Requirements/Reserve flow (estimated) = 40,271,545 cubic meters per year Will the rivers dry up? There is no time that the flow downstream of the abstraction points will be zero (except in the extreme condition where no water is flowing from upstream of the tunnel abstraction point). The design is such that the first priority is reserve flow (compensation flow and ecological flow requirements) and once this are met, the tunnel will receive water at the intake. The tunnel has been designed with proposed maximum amount of water that can be abstracted at each river (Muranga 3m3/sec, Gikigie - 0.975m3/sec and Irati - 1.967m3/sec). This will ensure that on average (annually), a maximum of 250,017,408m3/year will flow downstream of the tunnel abstraction point (94,608,000 m3/year - Maragua, 30,747,600 m3/year - Gikigie and 62,031,312 m3/year Irati). Will there be water for the future generations of Murangá residents? Water allocation guidelines by the Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA) have been observed in the NCT project design. In estimating the water demand requirements for Muranga, Athi Water accessed information from the Water Resources Management Authority (WRMA), Muranga office, relating to current water rights and those that have been received by the office. The NCT 1 has taken into consideration reserve flows for future water demands and water rights downstream of the tunnel.