MARK BUCHANAN - Willow Creek Association

continued from front flap
T
hat was the startled cry, circa 50 AD, from a
hastily assembled mob in Thessalonica. Paul and
Silas had been arrested for preaching the gospel. They
were viewed as revolutionaries, dangerous men who were upsetting
“Mark Buchanan has been in the foxhole
of church ministry for more than twenty
years. He knows the landscape of the
church and the kingdom. His new book,
Your Church Is Too Safe, is a clarion call
for the rest of us to wake up before it’s too
late. Artistically written, beautifully told,
arresting to the heart, jarring to the soul,
yet filled with hope and promise. You’ll
love Mark’s invitation to join him in the
foxholes for kingdom causes.”
—Stephen W. Smith,
author of The Lazarus Life
—Nancy Beach,
author of Gifted to Lead
the status quo and inciting riots.
But they were just two ordinary men, walking in the power of God,
sharing a simple message of his love and grace. It’s been a while since
we’ve seen the likes of this.
Your Church Is Too Safe calls the church back to being the God-established church.
With surprising insights from Scripture, author and pastor Mark Buchanan shares
how the church of today can recover the power and boldness of the early church,
taking risks to love, serve, and communicate the life-changing message of the gospel.
“I don’t think I want to go to the church that Mark Buchanan writes about. It would be too unnerving (sort of like being around Jesus). But Buchanan writes with such verve and is so steeped in
biblical truth, I think he’s convinced me to join that church, because in the end it’s a place where
the unsettling and merciful God is found.”
—Mark Galli, Senior Managing Editor, Christianity Today
RELIGION / Christian Church / General
Cover design: Rob Monacelli
Cover photo: Getty Images / Robert Llewellyn
MARK BUCHANAN
“Don’t read this book without preparing
to be disturbed in all the right ways. Mark
Buchanan calls us out of our safe zones
of comfort to a vision that is transformational—and somewhat terrifying. It’s the
only kind of church that can change the
world. So dig in, wrestle with these biblical
truths, and commit yourself to building a
community that is anything but safe.”
author of
Acts 17:6
YOUR CHURCH IS TOO safe
Mark Buchanan is a pastor, an awardwinning author, and a father of three who
lives with his wife, Cheryl, on the west
coast of Canada. He was educated at the
University of British Columbia and Regent
College, and his work has been published
in numerous periodicals including
Christianity Today, Books and Culture,
Leadership, and Discipleship Magazine.
He is also the author of six books: Your
God Is Too Safe, Things Unseen, The Holy
Wild, The Rest of God, Hidden in Plain
Sight, and Spiritual Rhythm.
MARK BUCHANAN
“These men who have turned the world
upside down have come here also.”
your god is too safe
Ignite Your Church
to Deeper Faith and
Bolder Action
Old preachers used to say the gospel
should afflict the comfortable and
comfort the afflicted.
Mark Buchanan believes there is a visible
gap between the life Jesus offered to us
YOUR
CHURCH
IS TOO
safe
why following christ turns
the world upside-down
USD $18.99
and the life we’re living, between the
church Jesus envisioned and the church
we see today.
What has happened over the years?
God meant his church to be both good
news and bad news, an aroma and a
stench, a disruptive force to whoever or
whatever opposes the kingdom of God
and a healing and liberating power to
those who seek it.
Is it?
Your Church Is Too Safe is a plea, a
celebration, a roadmap, and a manifesto.
It is a tribute to the many churches that
seek to be all God intended them to be …
and your key to igniting your church to
deeper faith and bolder action.
ISBN 978-0-310-33123-0
continued on back flap
COmPOSiTe
0310331234_your_church_is_too_safe_jkt.indd 1
12/22/11 11:15 AM
We want to hear from you. Please send your comments about this
book to us in care of [email protected]. Thank you.
ZONDERVAN
Your Church Is Too Safe
Copyright © 2012 by Mark Buchanan
This title is also available as a Zondervan ebook. Visit www.zondervan.com/ebooks.
This title is also available in a Zondervan audio edition. Visit www.zondervan.fm.
Requests for information should be addressed to:
Zondervan, Grand Rapids, Michigan 49530
ISBN 978-0-310-33123-0
All Scripture quotations, unless otherwise indicated, are taken from The Holy Bible,
New International Version®, NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984 by Biblica, Inc™. Used
by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.
Scripture quotations marked KJV are from the King James version of the Bible.
Scripture quotations marked MSG are taken from The Message. Copyright © 1993,
1994, 1995, 1996, 2000, 2001, 2002. Used by permission of NavPress Publishing Group.
Scripture quotations marked TNIV are taken from the Holy Bible, Today’s New International Version™. TNIV®. Copyright © 2001, 2005 by Biblica, Inc™. Used by permission
of Zondervan. All rights reserved worldwide.
Any Internet addresses (websites, blogs, etc.) and telephone numbers in this book are
offered as a resource. They are not intended in any way to be or imply an endorsement
by Zondervan, nor does Zondervan vouch for the content of these sites and numbers
for the life of this book.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval
system, or transmitted in any form or by any means — ​electronic, mechanical, photocopy, recording, or any other — ​except for brief quotations in printed reviews, without
the prior permission of the publisher.
Published in association with the literary agency of Ann Spangler and Company, 1420
Pontiac Road S.E., Grand Rapids, MI 49506.
Cover design: Rob Monacelli
Cover photo: Getty Images / Robert Llewellyn
Interior design: Matthew Van Zomeren
Printed in the United States of America
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 /DCI/ 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 4
12/28/11 10:11 AM
Chapter fourteen
Wreck the Roof
Your church is too safe.
One sign that it might be so is a roof in good repair. I mean this as
a metaphor.
Sort of.
A roof in good repair is a sign that no one wants so desperately to
get within your walls that they’ll resort to extreme measures. No one
is ready to vandalize the place for the sake of finding ­Jesus inside. No
rumor is afoot that would drive p
­ eople to acts of forcible entry.
They were ready to do that in ­Jesus’ day, according to a well-known
story of an event that occurred in Capernaum, ­Jesus’ neighborhood, his
home turf. The scene and the event:
So many gathered that there was no room left, not even outside the
door, and he preached the word to them. Some men came, bringing
to him a paralytic, carried by four of them. Since they could not
get him to ­Jesus because of the crowd, they made an opening in the
roof above ­Jesus and, after digging through it, lowered the mat the
paralyzed man was lying on. When ­Jesus saw their faith, he said to
the paralytic, “Son, your sins are forgiven.”
Now some teachers of the law were sitting there, thinking to
themselves, “Why does this fellow talk like that? He’s blaspheming!
Who can forgive sins but God alone?”
Immediately ­Jesus knew in his spirit that this was what they
were thinking in their hearts, and he said to them, “Why are you
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 151
12/28/11 10:12 AM
152 • YOUR
CHURCH IS TOO SAFE
thinking these things? Which is easier: to say to the paralytic, ‘Your
sins are forgiven,’ or to say, ‘Get up, take your mat and walk’? But
that you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to
forgive sins . . .” He said to the paralytic, “I tell you, get up, take
your mat and go home.” He got up, took his mat and walked out in
full view of them all. This amazed everyone and they praised God,
saying, “We have never seen anything like this!”1
“He preached the word to them,” is how Mark puts it. Even ­Jesus,
the Word, uses the word. ­Jesus preaches the Bible.
So this is a story about the power of the preached word.
But it is also a story about the limits of its power. It’s a story about
the need for the word to be preached, but also for the Word to be made
flesh and dwell among us. The word preached with power and fidelity draws the world, that’s clear enough. But it’s the Word loosed, the
Word incarnate, the Word speaking our truest names and naming our
deepest wounds and ministering God’s deepest remedy, that transforms
the world. The word preached draws a crowd. But the Word made flesh
makes a church.
But first the roof must be broken.
The irony in this story is an irony present even in some of our best
churches: that the preaching of ­Jesus doesn’t always make us more like
­Jesus. The proclamation of the word does not always translate into our
doing of the word. Here, ­Jesus is both preaching and being preached.
He is both herald and fulfillment of the good news.
­People flock to hear it. ­People fail to heed it.
Because at the heart of the word and of the Word is welcoming the
stranger. It’s loving the least of these. It’s becoming those who bring
shalom to those who lack it.
This church couldn’t give a rip. It’s about getting the best seat, damn
all the rest of you. So a man on a stretcher, a woman in a wheelchair,
a woman of the night, a man with a monkey on his back, a kid with
ADHD — ​I’m not going to give up my privileged position for their sake.
If they didn’t have the good sense to get here on time, that is not my
problem. I’m here to hear a good sermon, and if that single mother can’t
keep her kid quiet — ​that’s what medication’s for, honey — ​the ushers
should escort them out.
A young lady in our church moved to another city to attend university. I knew of a good church in that city — ​the word was preached
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 152
12/28/11 10:12 AM
Wreck the Roof • 153
there — ​a nd I recommended she try it. Her first Sunday, she arrived
early and took a seat near the front. A few minutes later, a ­couple walked
in and stood over her. She looked up and asked if she was in their seat.
“Yes.”
She got up and moved three rows back. The next person just told
her straight up, “You’re sitting in my seat.” She moved again, this time
to the other side of the sanctuary and farther back. Shortly, another
­couple came, sat in the pew directly in front of her, and turned and
glowered at her.
“Am I in your seat?”
“Yes, you are. That has been our seat for forty years.”
She got up, sat in the balcony, and thereafter never returned.
The good news: I know the pastor of that church and contacted him
about what happened. The following Sunday, he put on his prophet hat
and called the church to do better. And I told the story in our church,
names disguised, and said to the ­people, “If ever someone is sitting in
‘your’ seat, consider it divine appointment: God’s given you a lunch
date.” Afterward, several ­people told me how that one challenge opened
up new friendships.
But I wonder about that c­ ouple who have sat for forty years in the
same pew. This is a church renowned for its pulpit ministry. As far as I
know, they’ve never had a mediocre preacher. All the pastors I’ve known
who held that pulpit — ​I’ve known four — ​were or are masterful homileticians. They’ve handled the word of God correctly, and declared the
word of God with vigor and passion.
Forty years of that. Forty years of the word preached. Forty years of
gospel proclaimed. Forty years, Sunday upon Sunday, of sermons that
must have declared God’s scandalous welcome to the stranger among
us. Had they not, many times, heard John 4 (­Jesus meets a woman at
the well) or Luke 7 (a woman anoints his feet with her tears) or Matthew 25 (­Jesus divides us, as sheep from goats, based on whether we
welcomed the stranger)?
Forty years, and still they’d not heard.
  
A church will cease to be a church if the word of J­ esus is not preached.
But a church will fail to become a church if the Word made flesh does
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 153
12/28/11 10:12 AM
154 • YOUR
CHURCH IS TOO SAFE
not appear among us, and we touch him, and see him, and he us. And
sometimes, that happens only when someone has the gall, the audacity,
the desperation to break the roof open.
So some friends come with a paralyzed man. Some friends, indeed.
­ eople who have sat in
But they can’t find a seat. They can’t get past the p
that pew for forty years. They can’t even get through the door. ­People
­ eople must have an inkling why they’re here, what
must see them. P
they’re hoping. They must be able to intuit that these men have shown
up for something other than a good sermon. Perhaps that’s the problem:
they do intuit exactly that. They reckon that, should these men get
through the crowd, the sermon will abruptly end, and other matters
will leap to center stage. They’re preempting interruption, watching for
drunks and squalling babies and men in wheelchairs, and other sundry
distractions.
Which leaves it to some friends to choose from two courses of
action. One is to leave. They tried. They get points for trying, surely.
It’s Miller time.
The other is to commit an act of holy vandalism. If legal means fail,
find illegal ones. If politeness and decorum fall short, resort to rudeness
and disruption. If the kingdom comes near and there’s no neat tidy way
to get in, come up with a messy havoc-wreaking way.
And that’s what they do.
They break the roof. They clamber up and, bare fisted, tear tile
and thatch, strut and truss. They make a gaping hole, large enough to
wangle down a man in his gurney. Daylight cascades through the opening, blazing up the room like a theophany, and dust and rubble tumble
down the light shaft. All eyes turn upward. From below, the broken
roof, raggedy edged, drinks the sky. A huge angular shadow appears in
that opening, eclipsing the sun. It’s a silhouette of sorrow and longing.
Faces stare down from the edges. Down it comes, this shadow, this
silhouette, until everyone sees what it is: a gaunt and motionless man,
wild eyed with hope.
­Jesus has stopped preaching. The silence in the room swells to fill
the farthest corners. You can hear the drumming of your own blood.
The seesawing of your own breath. ­Jesus looks at the man and says,
“Son, your sins are forgiven.”
Which is an interesting way to begin. Does J­ esus not get it? This
man has just fallen from the sky. He’s a parachutist entangled in his
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 154
12/28/11 10:12 AM
Wreck the Roof • 155
ropes. He’s a puppet on a string. He’s a moth in a spider’s web. He’s desperate to be set free from this snare. He wants to walk again. He wants
to will his arms to move, and for his arms to obey. He wants to hold his
wife, and toss his daughter in the air and catch her, and drink coffee
with friends without their having to hold the cup to his lips. Sin? When
did you think I had time and opportunity for that, ­Jesus?
Clearly, something else is going on here. Some other threat, worse
than physical brokenness, stalks this man’s life. ­Jesus deals with that
greater threat first.
Which lights a firestorm in the room. “Now some teachers of the
law were sitting there, thinking to themselves, ‘Why does this fellow talk like that? He’s blaspheming! Who can forgive sins but God
alone?’ ”2 A wider drama is taking place here. This is not just about
preaching or healing or being kind to vandals. This is about authority.
With what authority does ­Jesus speak and act? Preaching is one thing,
forgiving quite another. That’s God’s bailiwick. That’s God’s exclusive
territory, and to enter it is to cross a line. J­ esus claims more power than
a mere mortal is permitted to wield. Human forgiveness is always and
only personal. I hurt you, let’s say — ​took your money, insulted your
children, broke your roof, some awful evil thing — ​a nd you, with or
without my saying I’m sorry, forgive me. Only you can decide that. Not
even God can decide that for you.
But ­Jesus here is not offering personal forgiveness (“You bumped my
head on your fall from the sky, but I forgive you”). No, ­Jesus is issuing a
decree. He’s ruling on cosmic matters. He declares that, start to finish,
every twisted thought and nasty deed and poisoned word that ever came
out of this man is, here and now, washed away. Scrubbed clean. Dead
and buried. It is finished. These things no longer defile him, define
him, or bind him. The whole weight of a whole lifetime of getting it
wrong is lifted from him. He can walk free.
And that shocks and angers p
­ eople who know better.
So then J­ esus heals the man simply to vouch for his authority to forgive the man. “Immediately ­Jesus knew in his spirit that this was what
they were thinking in their hearts, and he said to them, ‘Why are you
thinking these things? Which is easier: to say to this paralyzed man,
“Your sins are forgiven,” or to say, “Get up, take your mat and walk”?
But I want you to know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to
forgive sins.’ So he said to the man, ‘I tell you, get up, take your mat and
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 155
12/28/11 10:12 AM
156 • YOUR
CHURCH IS TOO SAFE
go home.’ He got up, took his mat and walked out in full view of them
all.”3 Clearly, it’s easier to say to the paralyzed man, to anyone, in fact,
“Your sins are forgiven.” Words like that are cheap, unless they’re not.
A pronouncement like that, when made generally and not personally,
to cover all sin and not just this sin, is impossible to verify. Who will
know? How can anyone check? You can’t hack into God’s computer to
find out whether there’s still a “Sin” file with the guy’s name on it, or
whether that’s been erased from the hard drive.
It’s easier to speak forgiveness, but harder to enact it. Forgiveness
is harder to authorize. Healing is the other way around. With healing,
the proof is in the walking, the authority in the results, which can be
verified empirically and immediately. It can be tested in the shop. To
command a paralyzed man to “get up” demands instant validation. A
demonstration must ride the heels of the pronouncement, or else we’re
dealing with a charlatan.
­Jesus heals the man to prove he has the authority to forgive the
man. He does that which is harder to say and easier to do — ​heal him
completely, head to toe — ​to establish that he has also done that which
is easier to say and harder to do — ​forgive him completely, head to toe.
  
But I want to go back to that broken roof.
A broken roof is maybe the only door the desperate have to get into
your church. It’s what they resort to when all polite efforts fail, when
they’re not welcomed through the front entrance, and not at the side
door either. But if ­Jesus is actually in the building, some desperado and
his buddies will figure that out and finagle a way in.
I want you to see what happens when that happens. Prior to the sick
man’s getting himself to ­Jesus, that church had good preaching. The
best: ­Jesus himself. Imagine such a thing: the Word made flesh declaring, interpreting, applying the word. That must have been a feast for
mind and heart.
But after one sick man gets into the center of things, the word
becomes flesh. The gospel is not just preached — ​always a good thing — ​
but unleashed, set in motion. Through that unleashing, five radical
acts are committed: radical welcome, radical forgiving, radical healing,
radical confrontation, and radical worship. I’m using the word radical in
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 156
12/28/11 10:12 AM
Wreck the Roof • 157
its root sense, literally: radix, “roots, foundations, the stuff underneath.”
That which holds up and gives life to everything else.
It begins with radical welcome. The first word out of J­ esus’ mouth
is “Son.” This is spoken in the same breath forgiveness is pronounced,
but it is prior to that pronouncement, almost the coil spring of it. We
know, if we’re careful theologians, that the right to become children of
God follows, rather than precedes, “receiving Christ.”4 In other words,
first we receive ­Jesus, believe in him, are forgiven by him, and then
we become sons and daughters. But isn’t that what this man is doing,
receiving ­Jesus, receiving him in his wildly inelegant fashion, bumbling,
tumbling, roof-wrecking his way to ­Jesus? Isn’t that what his crashing
the party is all about? Isn’t he like so many others whom ­Jesus radically
welcomes and accepts, who find out they’re forgiven only after they
step full into the embrace of Christ’s acceptance? That Christ has first
forgiven them (did any of them ask?) may very well be the basis on
which ­Jesus now accepts them, but in real time his acceptance seems to
release his forgiveness. At the very least, it announces it. I’m thinking of
the woman at the well, or the woman caught in adultery, or the woman
who anoints ­Jesus’ feet with her tears, or Zacchaeus: all ­people who first
received ­Jesus’ radical welcome, and then only after discovered that, ipso
facto, they’d also received his radical forgiveness. It was a package deal.
“He welcomes me as his own and he forgives me.” He forgives my marital disasters. He forgives my adultery. He forgives my years of turning
tricks and burning bridges. He forgives my dastardly unscrupulousness,
my stealing bread from children’s mouths.
I’m accepted. I’m forgiven. That’s all they know, and not one of
them seems theologically vexed about which came first.
  
So there’s radical welcome. And radical forgiveness. When the roof
opens, when the word becomes flesh, radical forgiveness rushes down
in the waterfall of acceptance. “Son, your sins are forgiven.” Never mind
that the paralyzed man didn’t ask for this. Never mind that he has other
matters on his mind. He’s likely not theologically vexed about which
came first, acceptance or forgiveness, but I’m guessing he’s vexed that
forgiveness is on offer at all. What about this picture, J­ esus, are you not
getting? I’m P-A-R-A-L-Y-Z-E-D!
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 157
12/28/11 10:12 AM
158 • YOUR
CHURCH IS TOO SAFE
But, of course, paralysis is not this man’s most pressing problem.
He only thinks it is. Which puts him in good company, or at least
in common company, with the rest of us. Most of us think our most
pressing problem is something other than sin. It’s financial or relational
or vocational. It’s that I have a poor self-image, or others are routinely
mean to me, or I never got the same breaks my younger brother got.
­Jesus, fix that. Heal that. Take that away. Give me something else
instead.
Say what? My sins are forgiven? What about the drunk driver who
put me in this place? What about the negligent medical team who, had
they handled me with greater skill and care, it might have meant only a
short stint in a neck brace, not this infernal, eternal sentence of memorizing every last inch of every last ceiling I’ve ever lain beneath? Huh?
What about my wife, who couldn’t take having a cripple for a husband
and hightailed out of here with her office manager three months after
the accident? You want a list of ­people needing forgiveness, I’ll write
you one.
Well, I’m making this up. But something akin to that very well
could be swirling around inside his head.
I think in general we don’t take sin seriously. We cheapen it, and
so cheapen forgiveness. In fact, clear evidence that we don’t take either
seriously — ​sin or forgiveness — ​is the massive amount of unforgiveness
among otherwise Bible-believing Chris­tians. Unforgiveness is itself a
terrible sin. It is a prison, dark and cold, we put ourselves and others in.
That so many hold on to it so tenaciously is a sign they don’t even see it
as sin. It’s a right. Bitterness is the collateral they’re owed until they get
their pound of flesh.
But when the roof gets broken, radical forgiveness breaks out. It has
to: the kind of ­people who come in the roof hole, tumbling down from
the sky, are not, generally, garden-variety sinners. They’re spectacular
sinners. They’re hothouse varieties. They come in exotic strains. Their
sexual escapades, their history of violence, their carnivorous tendencies,
their appetite for illegal substances, their skill at working every angle,
means that patness and vagueness won’t cut it. Mere forbearance won’t
touch what really aches in them. They need something bone deep and
heartwrenching. They need to know that this forgiveness — ​Christ’s
forgiveness enacted by Christ’s community — ​goes all the way down,
even to that.
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 158
12/28/11 10:12 AM
Wreck the Roof • 159
Not long ago, I visited a church in my town to hear a good friend
preach. He was speaking on how the truth of God makes us feel unworthy and so makes us want to run from him, but the grace of God lets
us know we’re accepted and so we want to run to him. A lady in front
of me began weeping almost at the start, and by the end was sobbing
loudly, almost wailing. When my friend invited p
­ eople to come up to
the front for prayer, she flew up there. She crumpled on the steps, heaving with her sobbing, thanking ­Jesus. I have no idea who she is. But I’m
guessing she’s no garden-variety sinner. I’m guessing she has a past that
they don’t make medication strong enough or therapy deep enough to
banish. I’m guessing she’s done things so indelibly staining, no self-help
manual can even lighten them a tone. Only the blood of Christ can
make them white as snow. I’m guessing she loves much because she’s
been forgiven much.
I was so moved by how her church embraced her, I started wondering if somewhere there was a hole in the roof.
  
And then this story takes a dark turn, sounds a bleak note. The Pharisees don’t like this talk of forgiveness. They resent it. The religious spirit
we talked about in the last chapter wakes up howling, except silently,
only on the inside. These men are too cowardly to say what they’re
thinking. They’ll save that for the church parking lot, after the ser­vice.
But it’s already too late: they’re outed by their inner dialogue. With
­Jesus in the room, to think a thing is the same as speaking it. “Immediately ­Jesus knew in his spirit that this was what they were thinking
in their hearts.”
What happens next is one of the most important parts of this story:
­Jesus confronts them. He stands them down.
Now listen. If you should choose to make your church more
­dangerous — ​choose to let your roof be broken, sometimes even aid the
breaking of it — ​you will arouse the religious spirit. That’s a promise. It
will, as we talked about earlier, be sly at first, hard to catch, all murmurs
and rumors, taking cover beneath pious questions. It will keep to the
shadows until it’s gained enough momentum to mount a frontal attack.
And as I have said, this spirit is harder to expel than Beelzebub
himself, which is why it’s his favorite tactic, why he loves to take
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 159
12/28/11 10:12 AM
160 • YOUR
CHURCH IS TOO SAFE
c­ hurchgoers “captive to do his will.”5 But regardless of that, this spirit
must be confronted. Left to breed in the shadows, it does more damage than hauled into the light. Unchallenged, it multiplies. Exposed, it
rarely backs down, but it does lose much of its credibility or power to
intimidate. Resisted, it will flee.
  
And then radical healing takes place. This healing is one of the ways
J­ esus confronts the religious spirit. This isn’t the first or the last time
­Jesus will heal someone in open defiance of religious rules, in the face
of fierce but veiled opposition. He will also heal a man with a withered hand and a woman with a hunchback. But what’s to be noted is
that ­Jesus’ confrontation is not just mere words: it’s active. The story I
opened the book with — ​from Mark 9, in which ­Jesus’ disciples get in
an argument with the teachers of the law over a boy afflicted by an evil
spirit — ​reminds us of the uselessness of confrontation without action.
When we do not act on our deepest convictions, only speaking them, we
are no better than those we confront. Indeed, according to that story, it
was his disciples’ failure to act that frustrated J­ esus the most: “O unbelieving generation. How long will I put up with you?” Anytime we dare
to confront the religious spirit, we should be prepared to back our words
with a demonstration of the Spirit’s power. We can’t accuse religious
­people of not loving the poor, for example, if we’re not living sacrificially
for the sake of the poor, or denounce them for not caring for the creation
if our own carbon footprint is only a half size smaller than anyone else’s.
Confrontation is worse than useless if it’s just accusing words.
We also see that though physical healing and spiritual healing don’t
always come conjoined like they do in this story, “getting up and walking” is always a sign that we’ve been forgiven. Forgiven ­people “prove”
they’re forgiven by walking in newness of life. They walk in the light,
walk by faith, walk by the Spirit. Forgiveness sets us in motion. It acts
upon us to make us act. It gets us up and gets us going. It does not
indulge one more minute of lying around waiting for things to happen, waiting for others to do something, blaming others for the way
I am. “Get up, take your mat, and go home.” This getting up, taking
our mat — ​once the symbol of our inability to move at all — ​and going
home in full view of everyone is what every forgiven man and woman
is supposed to do every day.
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 160
12/28/11 10:12 AM
Wreck the Roof • 161
When we’re new creations, we act like it.
We need more of this — ​this active response to the good news of
what God has done for us — ​in most of our churches. Holes in the roof
help by adding a sense of urgency to the matter. When there are no
holes in the roof of our church, no one desperate for the touch of J­ esus,
our church becomes nothing more than a country club where we while
away a few hours each week, swapping gossip and sizing each other up.
But when someone comes among us who desperately needs to know
that ­Jesus forgives and heals, that life can start afresh, the urgency of
walking out our faith in full view is instantly heightened. There is a
fresh urgency for elders and pastors and Sunday school teachers and
worship team members to get up, every day, pick up their mats, and
walk, always in the direction of home. That’s church.
  
One last thing breaks out once the roof breaks open: radical worship.
“This amazed everyone and they praised God.” Everyone. Even, we’re
led to believe, the grumblers. That itself is amazing: that faultfinders
become praise givers.
Again, a hole in the roof heightens the urgency of this. Anyone who
has ever been restored even a little bit to the fullness of their humanity
has been so because they learned to truly worship. It’s why ­Jesus takes
as much time as he does with the woman at the well to explain true
worship to her. It’s why Gideon’s first act after tearing down his father’s
idols is to “build a proper kind of altar to the Lord your God on the
top” of the ruins.6 It’s why Paul tells us, “in view of God’s mercy,” to
offer ourselves “as living sacrifices,” because the promise is that when
we do, we will be transformed by the renewing of our minds.7 No one
continues to walk in newness of life without a life of radical worship.
All these are the blessings of having a hole in your roof. It almost
makes you want to make a few holes yourself.
  
A number of years ago I was attending a conference in another part of
the country, and was invited to speak at a nearby church for Sunday
worship. I arrived at the place half an hour before the ser­vice began,
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 161
12/28/11 10:12 AM
162 • YOUR
CHURCH IS TOO SAFE
only to find the place locked up. So I drove down the main drag. It
was a small community right beside a lake. The street was thick with
­people. It was a party. The town was hosting a marathon, and hundreds
of runners and their well-wishers were out in force. Everyone was in a
festive mood. Dancing tempos pulsed from speakers lining the street,
and tempting aromas wafted from food vendors’ kiosks. There must
­ eople.
have been, all told, three thousand p
I got back to the church ten minutes before the ser­vice began, and a
deacon had just arrived, alone, to open the door. He seemed surprised to
see me. When I explained that someone in the church had booked me
to speak there that morning, he said, “Well, it wasn’t me, and nobody
told me.”
Two other deacons showed up, and we went into the photocopier
room to pray. Only, no one prayed. All three deacons groused bitterly.
The Friday before, the church parking lot had been freshly paved, the
final touch on a major building renovation. Sometime between Friday
night and Saturday, someone had driven an RV onto the lot — ​the men
speculated it was “one of this riffraff come to run in the marathon” — ​
and had left a thick crease in the soft asphalt. We all walked out to look
at it. It seemed to me nothing that a handyman with a blowtorch and
a piece of plywood couldn’t repair in a blink. But they were infuriated.
We walked back into the building and the ser­vice was starting, so we
skipped the prayer.
At exactly the hour, about thirty-five unsmiling ­people shuffled into
the sanctuary and sat near the back. We endured fifteen minutes of
listless singing. There were some announcements. And then I was up.
I had twenty minutes.
I there and then decided to change my text. I can’t recall what I had
planned to speak on, but on the spot I changed my mind and read the
story of the paralyzed man. I talked to the congregation about all the
­people in their town today who didn’t seem at all interested in coming
through the door of their church, let alone breaking through the roof.
I complimented them on their recent building renovations, but then
asked, “Are you willing to see this building beat up a little — ​stains on
the carpet, scuffs on the wall, gouges in the asphalt — ​in order to see a
few of the ­people on the street here with you?”
It didn’t go over well. No one talked to me afterward — ​well, one
person did, but they just wanted to know if I knew so-and-so from the
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 162
12/28/11 10:12 AM
Wreck the Roof • 163
community next to the one I lived in. The rest emptied out in less than
five minutes, as unsmiling as they came, maybe more so. The deacon
who opened the door was standing at the door, ready to lock it, when
I exited. No one thanked me. I was, it probably goes without saying,
never invited back.
That was a long time ago. One can only hope that, somewhere along
the line, someone broke the roof.
0310331234_churchtoosafe_int_cs5.indd 163
12/28/11 10:12 AM