FRANSE SHOPPER IN TUINCENTRUM WIL MEER STRUCTUUR
Transcription
FRANSE SHOPPER IN TUINCENTRUM WIL MEER STRUCTUUR
FRANSE SHOPPER IN TUINCENTRUM WIL MEER STRUCTUUR Onderzoek onder Franse shoppers van kamerplanten in een tuincentrum PT 2012-04, februari 2012 FRANSE SHOPPER IN TUINCENTRUM WIL MEER STRUCTUUR Onderzoek onder Franse shoppers van kamerplanten in een tuincentrum Auteur Functie Telefoon e-mail Remy Vermeire sen. projectleider marktonderzoek 079-3470648 [email protected] Productschap Tuinbouw, Postbus 280, 2700 AG Zoetermeer Telefoon 079 – 347 07 07 email [email protected] internet www.tuinbouw.nl Alle rechten voorbehouden. Niets uit deze uitgave mag vermenigvuldigd en/of openbaar gemaakt worden door middel van druk, fotokopie, microfilm of op welke wijze dan ook zonder toestemming van de uitgever of auteur. Inhoudsopgave 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Inleiding Key insights and actions Store environment is experienced confusing and messy Houseplants have a very strong emotional dimension Consumers choose their plants with living areas in mind Consumers seldom notice and understand POS communication Information about pricing and plants is not optimal Four different consumers profiles can be distinguished Most choices are made by means of type (size) and color 4 7 11 22 34 42 47 53 62 Samenvatting Franse shoppers van kamerplanten in het tuincentrum hebben behoefte aan meer structuur Franse shoppers van kamerplanten in het tuincentrum hebben vaak moeite om een structuur in de kamerplantenafdeling te herkennen, wat het navigeren over de afdeling bemoeilijkt. Dit blijkt uit onderzoek van het Productschap Tuinbouw. Grote en kleine planten staan door elkaar en tussen de planten is weinig ruimte. Als een Franse shopper op zoek gaat naar een kamerplant staat vaak al vast of het een bloeiende of groene kamerplant moet worden en de grootte van de plant. De plaats waar de plant in huis moet of kan staan, bepaalt namelijk de grootte van de plant. Een duidelijke, heldere indeling van de afdeling helpt de Franse shopper een beslissing te nemen tijdens het koopproces. Het zorgt er ook voor dat de shopper zich sneller laat verleiden tot het kopen van een onbekende plant of tot een extra aankoop. Daarnaast is het belangrijk dat de afdeling een verzorgde indruk maakt. Dit heeft een positief effect op de kwaliteitsperceptie van de shopper. Vermijd een supermarktsfeer Franse consumenten voelen een sterke emotionele binding met kamerplanten. Een liefdevolle wijze van presenteren, die eer doet aan de planten, is daarom voor de Franse shoppers van groot belang en een sfeer die de shopper ook zoekt en verwacht in het tuincentrum. Een duidelijk onderscheid met de wijze waarop Franse super- en hypermarkten kamerplanten verkopen, is gewenst. De kwaliteit van de planten in het tuincentrum, een goed verzorgd uiterlijk en een afdeling waar aandacht is besteed, dragen bij tot dit onderscheid. Product displays en POS materiaal dienen voor de shopper ook als inspiratiebron. 1 Samenvatting Zorg voor een huiselijke sfeer Shoppers lopen door de kamerplantenafdeling met in hun achterhoofd de plaats in het huis voor de plant. Een huiselijke sfeer op de afdeling ondersteunt dit denkproces. Effectiviteit POS materiaal kan beter Shoppers zijn in eerste instantie vooral op het product gericht. De opstelling van POS materiaal in de tuincentra houdt hier onvoldoende rekening mee waardoor slechts weinig shoppers het materiaal opmerken. Daarnaast moet de boodschap direct helder en duidelijk zijn. Vormgeving en kleurstelling moeten matchen met de sfeer van de afdeling. Informatievoorziening kan beter Franse shoppers hebben vaak een bepaalde prijsrange in het hoofd waarbinnen de aankoop moet vallen. Hoewel de prijs zeker niet leidend is in het koopproces, verwacht de shopper duidelijke prijsinformatie. Moeilijk vindbare prijsinformatie of het ontbreken van prijsinformatie leiden tot irritaties en frustreren het koopproces. Ook gemakkelijk toegankelijke en begrijpbare verzorgingsinformatie vindt de Franse shopper belangrijk. Hierin is nog een verbeterslag te maken. Shoppers geven aan dat informatiekaartjes niet altijd gemakkelijk te vinden zijn en soms te kleine letters bevatten zodat de informatie niet leesbaar is. Beschikbaar en deskundig personeel op de afdeling wordt daarom door de shoppers erg gewaardeerd. 2 Samenvatting Grote (groene) planten meer een bewuste keus Het kopen van een grote plant ervaart de Franse shopper als een bewuste keuze en is minder snel een spontane aankoop. Deze planten vragen ruimte in huis en vaak is ook de prijs wat hoger. Dit maakt dat naast emotie ook rationele factoren het koopproces bepalen. Een barrière tijdens dit koopproces is een voor de shopper onlogische indeling van de planten gecombineerd met een gebrek aan kennis. Een clustering van de planten naar grootte, standplaats (zon/schaduw) en verzorgingsbehoefte faciliteert veel meer het keuze- en koopproces van de shopper. Nog veel potentie tot verleiding Bijna 30% van de shoppers laat de keuze van de plant geheel afhangen van wat hij of zij ziet in het tuincentrum. De overige 70% heeft al enig idee. Hierbij is vooral de kleur (groen of bloeiend) en de grootte van de plant al redelijk vastomlijnd. Alle andere zaken staan in meer of mindere mate nog open en worden op de winkelvloer beslist. Slechts 30% heeft een exact budget in het hoofd. Vrijwel iedere shopper met een koopintentie voor een plant doet een aankoop. Van de shopper die geen concrete aankoopplannen hadden liet bijna de helft zich verleiden tot een aankoop. 3 1 Inleiding Waarom shopperonderzoek Het tuincentrum is in Frankrijk voor de aankoop van kamerplanten een belangrijk aankoopkanaal. In 2010 had het tuincentrum een marktaandeel van circa 25% in de bestedingen aan kamerplanten. Consumenten kopen kamerplanten bij het tuincentrum vooral vanwege de grote keus en de vrijheid die men heeft om een keuze te maken. We willen graag de shopper van kamerplanten, specifiek in het tuincentrum, beter leren kennen. Wat gebeurt er daadwerkelijk op de winkelvloer. Daarbij is de uitdaging om steeds meer te ontrafelen wat er in het hoofd van de shopper (de black box) gebeurt tijdens het koopproces. Wat ziet de shopper (niet), wat ervaart de shopper (niet), wat triggert de shopper, wat stimuleert de shopper of wat houdt de shopper juist tegen op de kamerplantenafdeling van een tuincentrum. Doel van het onderzoek Doel van het onderzoek is meer inzicht te krijgen in de factoren die een rol spelen bij en tijdens het kopen van kamerplanten door Franse shoppers in een tuincentrum: • Achterhalen van factoren (triggers en barrières) die de koopbeslissing op de winkelvloer van de kamerafdeling beïnvloeden. • Inzicht krijgen in de effecten van instore media op het shoppergedrag 4 Methode van onderzoek In het aankoopproces kunnen we drie fases onderscheiden: Dit onderzoek concentreert zich op wat er op de kamerplantenafdeling in het tuincentrum allemaal met de shopper gebeurt. Hiervoor zijn twee verschillende onderzoeksmethodieken ingezet: 1. VOOR BEZOEK TUINCENTRUM 2. IN HET TUINCENTRUM 3. NA BEZOEK TUINCENTRUM Verdiepende interviews gecombineerd met camerabril 15 potentiële kopers van kamerplanten hebben met een camerabril op één of meerdere kamerplanten gekocht. Door de camera wordt vastgelegd waar de shopper naar kijkt, hoe zijn shopping trip verloopt etc. Na de shopping trip zijn de shoppers uitgebreid geïnterviewd waarbij men geconfronteerd is met de beelden van zijn eigen aankoopgedrag. Dit geeft meer inzicht in de bewuste en onbewuste factoren die een (positieve of negatieve) rol spelen tijdens het koopproces. De 15 diepte-interviews zijn gehouden in 3 verschillende Franse tuincentra in en rondom Lyon. In alle drie de tuincentra was de kamerplantenafdeling direct na de entree gelegen. Dit is bij veel tuincentra in Frankrijk het geval. 5 Villaverde Jardiland Botanic Exit interviews Exit interviews zijn ingezet om meer inzicht te krijgen in de conversietrechter bij het kopen van kamerplanten in een tuincentrum. Bepaald wordt hoeveel van de potentiële kopers daadwerkelijk tot een aankoop zijn over gegaan en of deze aankoop ook aansluit bij hun initiële plan met betrekking tot soort en te bestede bedrag. In totaal zijn 150 exit interviews gehouden eveneens verdeeld over de 3 tuincentra. Aan het onderzoek hebben zowel mannen als vrouwen deelgenomen in de leeftijd van 18 t/m 65 jaar. Leeswijzer In de volgende hoofdstukken worden de onderzoeksresultaten weergegeven zoals het onderzoeksbureau deze heeft gerapporteerd. Hoofdstuk 2 bevat de belangrijkste conclusies (key insights) die vervolgens in de hoofdstukken daarna worden toegelicht. 6 2 Key insights and Actions 7 Key Insights (1) Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. Store environment is experienced as „confusing and messy‟ Make sure that you meet the basic rule for retailing: a tidy well organized store. Furthermore, reorganize your store in such a way that remove one of the most important sales and conversion barriers: confusion! If you design a new lay out you should test it in order to see if it is improved. 2. Houseplants have a very strong emotional dimension and consumers are looking for inspiration Your whole store experience should be in line with this and it should inspire consumers (POS communication, product display, environment etc). A Garden center should not adopt the codes of supermarkets in promoting their products! 3. Consumers chose their plants with the different living areas in mind You can facilitate this process by showing plants in different living areas (this will optimize conversion: buy more & faster) 8 Key Insights (2) Growth Insights 4. Consumers seldom notice and understand in store communication and POS communication Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. 2. Make sure you place your communication in such a way that consumers have the opportunity to see! Redesign the look and feel of your communication in line with the meaning of house plants 5. Information about pricing and plants is not optimal and hard to read and find for consumers 6. We found 4 different consumer profiles You can capitalize on the different needs the different segments have by creating different experiences for each need. E.g. create and surprise impulsivity for the „design freaks 7. Most choices are made by means of type (size) and color When reorganizing your store, keep this in mind. E.g create small well defined islets, presentations like „at home‟, highlight and decorate product offer for easier navigation et cetera. 9 Where should you start when establishing priorities? Start with the things which are relatively easy to influence such as: 1 Store environment (make sure the store is tidy = precondition) 2 Improving POS communication (price tags, product info etc) 3 Improving in-store communication (flags, boards, displays etc) 4 Improving store lay out. Reorganize. However this will have much more impact because designing and implementing a total new lay out can have a lot of impact (time, money, effort). 10 3 Store environment is experienced confusing and messy 11 Observed barrier: neglect and untidy presentation Neglect, lacking care, tattered and wet papers “Knowing that plants need gentle care, I want it to be well-kept, when you buy them” Untidy, presence of a garden hose may be perceived as a negligence “it looks neglected” A vegetal wall with faded leaves, a „neglected‟ Bonzaï presentation on the shelf In opposition to the regular care that should be provided to plants Taking care of the plants is essential to fit the home plants‟ universe 12 Observed barrier: Jumble look Jumble look, a heap of plants (Vs choice) Spatial concentration and denying access inhibits exploration “it should be more airy, the bonsai were tightly put all together, idem for the orchids, it looks like mass production, you have the impression that everything has to be sold out on one day, it reminds me the pasta shelf of Auchan (big French supermarket)” Large volumes in front hiding small objects in the back (pots) Bring comfort into the purchase process: space, aeration, in order to improve the products‟ visibility (especially for the big green plants) 13 Observed barrier: lack of categorization Lacking apparent logical structure is disturbing Heterogeneous sizes, colours, plant categories, lack of homogeneity, that obliges the shopper to go back and forth or to create himself his own points of reference “when you see all the plants like this, all ones against the others, you cannot get a clear idea about the volume of the plant and if I like it or not” ”I felt like having gone back and forth many times, everything was clumped together, the green plants were in the back of the shop” Increase legibility and clarity. Suggestion: a plant clustering by size, regroup by colours. The shelf has to evoke curiosity and stimulate desire 14 Observed trigger: airy and organized lay-out Dedicated areas, well defined universes by plant family: orchids, cactus, bonsais, cyclamens, snail plants …..in touch with the exposed plant universe “they have created quite nice families for the orchids, the flecked ones, the tall ones and in front the very small ” (Vs green plants less well highlighted, packed all together = an offer less well understood and explored) “the green plants look more like a mess” Airy and bright areas, that allows a good visibility of the plants and the different colors (Vs heap and half light) “An airy area with a capital, there are only 50.000 plants, yes, this makes me feel like having a closer look at it” Creating a logic increases comfort and add visual clues allowing easy discrimination, to increase the probability of purchase 15 If no point of reference is available: customer sticks to familiar plants Without any point of reference, the shopper is lost in the product offer and shows different strategies for orientation: • Some areas are explored only superficially, when passing by: no stops, no product investigation, no selection • The shopper falls back on products he already knows (purchased or already noticed) Reinforced support and guidance are necessary here! 16 Shopper show difficulty locating the product offer, especially for green plants However, shoppers show difficulties to discriminate and locate the remaining product offer, which is mainly due to : • Lacking knowledge and expertise among consumers, more or less pronounced within the profiles • Lacking logical organization of the product offer (size, price, sun/shadow, care, condensed) Especially for the green plants, where orientation and selection may be tedious and discouraging: A universe the shopper usually does not know well Requires extra discrimination efforts (sizes, leaves,) vs. visible and distinct color discrimination for the flowery plants (++ tall green plants with “common” shapes) Often voluminous plants that requires more space at home, making the purchase process more rational Especially for taller green plants: more expensive, thus requiring a higher financial investment 17 We observe better performance for…. 1 2 Small well defined islets (Orchids, Cactuses, Cyclamens … ) without too clear divisions and proposing a circle route vs. straight floor route, boring (only partial view of the offer). Division into “intimate” and “protected” mini areas – easier to approach and understand, invites to spend time to explore the product offer vs. square areas, with a too dense and badly aerated product offer, that makes exploration more tiring and complex. 3 Highlighted and decorated product offer that makes navigation easier and friendlier. For example plants presented in colored pots and presentations like “at home”: a bed or a lamp or a table or a sideboard, via a declination of pot colours or flowers or wooden presentations. 4 Avoid multiple locations of the same offer (annoying, upsetting…) reducing the comfort during de purchase process 18 Actions to better guide the customer through the offer and tempt him to buy The POS environment should allow the shopper to feel at ease and invite him to go for a gentle walk, to roam and purchase (cozy atmosphere, soft music, clear and visible signage, trim presentation of the plants, clear, may be even interactive information…) • Create a logical progression between green plants and flowers : especially in the beginning of his shopping visit, the shopper needs visual guidance to the plant category he searches. Then, especially the green plant section requires a clear structure of the product offer : organized by size (from small to tall) and span, in order to give the shopper the feeling of an organized “jungle”. • Create areas separated by family (ex cactus, orchid, cyclamens ….) that allow a good readability of the offer and induces appeal • Make the offer clearer and simpler: introduce families with vulgarized names (ex elephant plant…) • Strive for a careful and neat presentation by proposing healthy looking plants (vs. faded, damaged or yellowed leaves…) 19 Actions to improve green plant section • • • For the green plants: create a meaningful and logical offer: Segment and clarify the green plant product offer (discouraged by lack of information about plants, the shopper does not explore the area thoroughly leads to “dead” i.e. non-visited areas) Create clear separations between the families and sub families/categories (ex. one category by islet) with display of a photo per category Create different visual angles for the green plants, in order to increase the visibility of each plant (or family): they have to be visible from a great distance • Air the presentation, • Propose a vertical distribution (stair-step or pyramidal) « the tall plants are not visible enough. You should put them on a stair step so that they can be seen from a great distance, and so that they do not hide behind the other plants” • Regroup by size (key organizer), it also improves the visibility from large and small distances 20 Main insight: Store environment is experienced as „confusing and messy‟ Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. Neglect and untidiness obstruct the purchase process. Make sure that you meet the basic rule for retailing: a tidy well-kept store. 2. Not well categorized plant sections create confusion. Organize your store by clustering by size and regroup by colors. 3. If the customer is not guided, he/she will stick to the familiar plants. Create a logical progression between green plants and flowers and add visual clues. Segment and clarify the green plant product offer, as green plants are more difficult to discriminate and locate. 21 4 Houseplants have a very strong emotional dimension 22 In France house plants are considered to be more special Before talking about the point of purchase, it is important to mention an significant characteristic of the French market that differentiates it from the Dutch market. • In Holland, plants are overall very much considered as “every day“ and “normal“, whereas we feel that in France plants have a slightly different role. • They are more “special “, less every-day and are truly appreciated for their decorative dimension. • If one owns less plants, the ones possessed are often cherished. We even believe that some plants have a cultural dimension. 23 Be aware of the difference in image between garden center and supermarket in France • In France the visit to a garden center is to be clearly distinguished from the visit to a supermarket. In the latter one buys everyday products and tries to save money; one goes there out of necessity. The visit to the garden center on the other hand is a pleasure, an enjoyable outing. • This observation is important because it conditions also the expectations for the place where one buys one‟s plants: a garden center should NOT adopt the codes of supermarkets in promoting their products. • We think that overall POS materials, actions etc, should be in line with the values attached to buying and owning plants. Be aware of the difference in image between garden center and supermarket in France (feelings of well being, serenity, warmth etc… ) and should stay away from codes used in the supermarket. Hence communication in general should stay close to codes of naturalness/ authenticity, warmth/ comfort to present and promote products. Optimizing P.O.S materials We think that this is an important reason why the POS materials shown in the 3 shops were very poorly appreciated: they are too close to supermarket universe. When communication and promotion materials are designed, ideally these should contribute to the beauty / authenticity of the environment and make sense. Today's shopper believes there are a lot of nice / beautiful plants however elements do not stand out enough (an example from the research: elephant plant, considered as an innovation/ interesting, use elements that evoke it‟s natural environment, why this name, use «elephant « decoration/imagery…). NB It remains that the shopper is also interested in promotional actions that offer an immediate price advantage 24 Visit of a botanic store has to nourish A visit to the garden center needs to create a state of well being and relaxation A visit is rather associated with a idyllic country walk than a store visit and is in strong contrast with routine purchases at the supermarket . A strong pleasure dimension during the visit: an exploring and inspiring activity without time constraints that may be present for routine activities The purchase place has to nourish, even sublimate the reflection about the plant choice. “it gives me energy before or after work : The visit here is just like a leisure activity or a sports activity, a moment of discovery and calm” The botanic store : a resourceful place and welcomed “green” break vs. stressful daily life 25 Observed barrier: store lay-out often too close to a supermarket atmosphere A creeper that is not Pots are not well emphasized “it looks like a storage” “you should group them by color, it looks like they have been just put there” well emphasized “plants you can suspend are not visible enough, you have to put them at man’s-high” A meaningful element (the water fountain) in a cold zone, not integrated at the core heart of the plant section Atmospheres should be created, products high lightened and emphasised with link to the Life. Example: exposition of plants with pots (more aesthetical and appealing vs. pot stacking under the shelf) 26 In a garden center reminiscences of the customers‟ personal history is activated The strong emotional dimension plays an important role in the purchase process • The plants and decoration in the store activate reminiscences of the consumer‟s personal history. • …and may orient his choice ex. : The presence of teddy bears activate the mother’s thoughts of her child ex: A specific flower may be associated to a beloved/hated person “I noticed the decoration with the bed and the teddy bears, I found this lovely, and it made me think of my children, it’s a bit cocooning, the plants are part of our family’s life” “when I see Anthurium, I think of my mother in law, and I don’t like Anthurium, because my mother in law has some, she has many of these flowers, and it upsets me” 27 House plant fulfills three types of values and purposes in a customer‟s life The house plant as a comfort and connection to loved ones The houseplant as a symbol of life SERENITY / WELL BEING The house plant for pleasure REASSURANCE / RECOMFORTING PLEASURE / SENSORIALITY Thanks to its symbolic dimensions, the house plant allows the owner to give sense to his housing environment and root himself in this environment. 28 The houseplant as a symbol of life The cycle of nature and life : birth – life – death, seasonality, passing time, resurrection Our interior nature, authenticity, with its specific and unchangeable rhythm in contrast to the superficial and frenetic outside social world. The image of the green plant to be more robust/long-lasting than flowers, more evanescent. “A house without plants is a little bit empty, like dead, even if furniture is in it” “It is nature, you can see them evolve throughout the seasons, it reminds me of my garden that I miss” “Plants create a certain kind of balance, like a cat or a dog, plants are an important part of life” “When I was young, I gave a small Yucca cutting to my mother. The cutting grew into a big tree and now she gave me a cutting from this tree that makes me think of my mother” Creates: SERENITY / WELL BEING 29 The house plant as a comfort and connection to loved ones Symbolizes the presence of a beloved person The presence of a “living element” allows to better overcome difficult personal turning points (divorce, children leaving home, death of a beloved person) Creates: REASSURANCE / RECOMFORTING “The amaryllis is a beautiful plant, it makes me recall my husband’s grandmother. A plant can provide you with plenty of memories” “I have a Christmas rose, I love it very much, because my grandmother gave it to me” “I cannot imagine my house without plants, I have recently divorced, I have moved on with my daughter and so I purchased plants immediately. The thought of an empty house was unbearable for me” 30 The house plant for pleasure “it brings joy to your home” A strong sensorial dimension: colours, sizes, perfumes, shapes textures… Botanic and decorative dimension : aesthetic, contributes to achieve a balance in interior architecture and design, allows to nicely enrich the environment Brings a touch of joy into life offers “an escape” from every day life “I put flower plants inside my home to create a balance with the green exterior” PLEASURE / SENSORIALITY 31 Consumer‟s state of mind during their visit of a botanic store An open-minded consumer, strongly permeable to his environment: all his senses are receptive The store should pay special attention to its general atmosphere & the product display and should highlight: In line with the plant‟s symbolic values: nature, life cycle, springs, glass roof Make sense to the consumer: respect each plant‟s specific personality and natural environment Pleasure and well-being dimension: link with the interior design universe, creation of specific visual (Asian universe) or sound atmospheres 32 Main insight: houseplants have a very strong emotional dimension and consumers are looking for inspiration Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. The French consider house plants to be special. The ones possessed are often cherished. This makes the garden center also a special place, very different from a supermarket which sells everyday products: A visit to the garden center is an enjoyable outing. Make sure the atmosphere, presentation and P.O.S material is in line with the special value of a house plant, create naturalness and warmth. Delineate from a supermarket atmosphere. The purchase place has to nourish. 2. House plants have a strong emotional dimension: as a symbol of life, a connection to loved ones and as a source of pleasure. The store should pay special attention to its general atmosphere and the product display. P.O.S material and presentation must be in line with the three emotional dimensions. 33 5 Consumers choose their plants with living areas in mind 34 Customer continuously imagines what the plant will look like at home A mental journey : • Consumers ceaselessly imagine, how the plants, they see in the store, could fit with/in their home. • Thus, consumer‟s mental activity during the store visit oscillates between the store and his home (the plant‟s destination place) A special mental state between reality and dream 35 Plant choice for the living room depends highly on personal taste The living room Personalizes, makes it different, unique A living area, a place where one spends much time A place with a strong self expression dimension, where you can express the image you want to give others (being unique, exceptional, having a good taste) Welcoming dimension of the place, conviviality A cozy place of social ritual that links us to our ancestors A highly symbolic place for the attention and care we take of others Plant choice depends highly on personal preferences: green and/or flowers “a flower plant should be in a place where you spend a lot of time, you cannot put it everywhere, I need to see it “ “plants embellish the living room, it does not matter whether you are lying on the sofa or whether you invite guests” 36 No plants in the bedroom, plants that represent the source of life are suited for the bathroom The bathroom An intimate place dedicated to body care and beauty, to relaxation and personal well being Often dark, damp and wet Back to the source of life, in balance with oneself via green plants like ivy and succulent plants The bedroom “I chose a small ivy plant for my bathroom, I was attracted by the leafs that were hanging, it reminded me my bathroom and I bought it” An intimate place, out of sight The majority of respondents do not put plants in this area (CO2 release during night, caring may be constraining?) Exception: Ornamental plants for the guest room (welcoming function) 37 Plants that bring life are suited for the entrance, plants with a strong emotional dimension for the kitchen The kitchen A place to prepare food, to be creative A place to care for the beloved Plants act as a catalyst for creativity and sensorial joyfulness Plants present in the kitchen : Have a strong emotional dimension, respondents like Flowery plants like orchids or cyclamens or cactus “I have tiny little plants in my kitchen, it’s beautiful, I’ve chosen small colored pots, I put them next to my working area, I like them to stay next to me, when I’m working” The entrance and floor • A passage, transit place Often a dark place, that lacks warmth, liveliness and personality. Plants bring the place to life thanks to their original shape or color (yucca, palm tree) 38 Observed trigger: create a homey atmosphere, help the customer visualize the plant in his house A trim and aesthetical presentation, product highlighting that embellishes the purchase process and that allows the shopper to project himself into a cozy and friendly universe the fern foliage creates a specific atmosphere “they try to create a home universe and I like that, it looks friendlier” A clear and decorative product presentation (wooden, wicker pots, colored pots Clean, aesthetic, visual pleasure, injects dynamism to the self and the product offer Create a pleasure universe, warm and cosy “like being at home”, where the shopper feels cherished and feels like purchasing something today or coming back soon 39 Presentation should be a mix of logical display and a decorative/ homey atmosphere Shoppers navigate on the basis of global preferences concerning the types of plants they are most interested in (color, size). A shop presentation that takes this principle into account offers an aid to the shopper to find his way around the shop and so help him or her to keep control of his/ her visit*. In addition, the shopper appreciates a “mise en scene” that will help him imagine what “a plant can do“ and how “it can look like“ once it will be in his or her home. Hence the shop presentation needs to be a subtle mix between a logical / pedagogical display of the offer and playful / decorative elements that rhythm the presentation and add interest and variety. * This does not mean that the shopper will so deliberately block out parts of the shop. One‟s there for one‟s pleasure and one likes to discover, see, but it remains up to the shopper how he/she wants to spend the time in the shop… 40 Main insight: consumers chose their plants with the different living areas in mind Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. The customer goes through a mental journey in which he visualizes the house plant in his own house. You can facilitate this process by creating a homey atmosphere in garden center. P.O.S. material must be adjusted to stimulate his imagination. 2. Each room had a different emotional value and atmosphere which -partlydetermines the customers‟ choice for a certain kind of plant. Adjust the presentation and signs of plants to the different room atmospheres, which they are linked to. For example green plants like ivy are suitable for the bathroom: create signage or a bathroom showcase to highlight this. 41 6 Consumers seldom notice and understand POS communication 42 Negative reactions: consumer seldom notices and understand the communication “blue campaign” / tombola – present in all three shops A “blue sign” not seen nor understood (color as well as type of communication more evocative of super markets) In the exit interviews only 5% of customers remembers the signs being present. Half of them found it appealing, half evaluated it to be neutral. A blue color that doesn‟t fit with the codes of the universe “a flashy blue, it has nothing to do here in a botanic shop, it is not neither the color of a plant or a flower, should be greener” “for my, it is a bit aggressive, the blue aggresses me, and it does not fit well with the rest” “it could be an advertisement for an aquarium but not for plants” 43 Negative reactions: consumer seldom notices and understands the communication “blue campaign” / tombola – present in all three shops The message was neither read nor understood “You do not understand that it is about a book, it is for tourists or a card-game” “you don’t see the book title” “you can win something but why and how?” Once decoded, the communication isn‟t very interesting: drawing lots that induces the fear of inaccessibility “it looks like a game, but I’m not interested in” “I understand that it is about drawing lots, but I’m not fond of this kind of games, because I’m not sure of winning something and I prefer getting a reward immediately” The slogan “Ma plante et moi”: well understood and more positive reactions “it is about attachment” A campaign that could be optimised, by respecting the environmental colours, bearing a simple and short message, clarifying the benefits 44 Negative reactions: consumer does not notice the communication Campaign “cédez à la plantation “ A campaign that is hardly noticed: Shoppers do not look up If probed: it seduces with its simple and humorous tone, an appealing play on words. Appealing campaign that could be optimised, by making it more noticeable 45 Main insight: consumers seldom notice and understand in store communication and POS communication Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. Current campaigns are not noticed by the customers Make the campaign more noticeable by putting the signs on eye level. 2. Campaigns are not understood by customers The massage should be short, simple and clarifying the benefits. 3. Color scheme of the campaign is important: blue is not associated with plants and to much linked to a supermarket atmosphere Stick to the garden center atmosphere. The color scheme must be associated with plants and warmth. 46 7 Information about pricing and plants is not optimal 47 Observed barrier: price not clearly visible Price display problems (lacking price labels or price not immediately visible lack of price harmony = obliges the shopper to lift the pot to search the price “you cannot see the prices, that is annoying me, you have to lift the pots in order to see the prices” “the price is located under the plant, that’s not convenient” Price for a plant behind vs. plants in the front Increase comfort during the purchase process: visibility and readability of the prices 48 Price should be easy to find The price: to a certain extent not so important The shopper has in mind an approximate price range, he may exceed for a very favorite/ impulsive purchase Perception of the prices Not expensive: a plant between 10€-15€ The purchase of a plant that costs more than 40€-50€ becomes a rational purchase and justifies different store visits / differed purchase However, the passionate/experts are more flexible and may give in to a more costly / impulsive purchase Price: information that should be easy to find 49 Observed trigger: a clear and immediate product description Improve comfort and convenience of purchase by proposing product sheets (technical sheets) / complete prices, clear, illustrated and immediately understandable (iconography, pictograms) Selection criteria “I went to the palm trees and there was a complete technical sheet with all the details I needed : where to put them, the size of the tree, maximum temperature, watering, I look for plants I can put in my living room and hop, that’s good timing, I saw the pictogram for the living room” A clear and distinctive price Harmonious price indications (different color codes : standard price, promotion and loyalty offer) Increase the visibility and readability of the prices and technical data. Format A4, colour + visible typography (Vs small sheet hidden in the pot or on the plants that require the use of glasses 50 Information about care should be well visible During the shop visit, shoppers try to check systematically the following information, when a plant attracts their attention: Information concerning the plant‟s characteristics : The color, The size, The exposure/ sensitiveness to light / shadow (defines the exact location of the plant in the house/apartment) , The temperature (ex. for a Bonzaï) The care to be provided to the plant: watering frequency, clear indicators of efforts and time that has to be spent for the plant‟s maintenance (no special care needed, or repotting, specific care, fertilizer, cutting and flourishing periods) The novelty, originality of the plant (shape, name) “For the Ficus (Bonsai), I looked at the temperature of 15°, it means I can put the plant also outside during the month between May and August, but the leaves has to be pruned” Characteristics and information about care: Important information, looked at systematically and that should be easily identified and quickly read (hence short &visual) 51 Main insight: Information about pricing and plants is not optimal and hard to read and find for consumers Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. Price tags are sometimes difficult to find, which annoys customers To overcome this barrier, make sure prices tags are clearly visible when plants are on the shelf. Don‟t put the prices tags on the bottom of the plant. 2. A product description and extra information about care are important to the customer and should be easy to read/ understand Make use of product sheets containing instantly understandable information. The letters must be large enough to read without glasses. Add pictograms for a quick and clear understanding of the care conditions. 52 8 Four different consumer profiles can be distinguished 53 Main insight: we found 4 different consumer profiles Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 1. The first category of customers, the Newbie, has a practical approach towards the purchase of house plants. They mostly renew their plants and fear the unknown. The Newbie should get clear information, and pedagogical guidance. The decision process will be enhanced by visible and simple pictograms that clearly announce the plant‟s category. Furthermore this category will seek for ready-to-purchase offers (plants + pot), so make sure this is available. 2. The second category of customers that can be delineated, the Pragmatic, has a rational approach towards the purchase of house plants. They are plant lovers, but are relatively inexperienced. In addition they like to discover new things and may react on impulse. The Pragmatic scans the area and therefore needs clear signage and arrangement by size and shape. In that way he/she is able to quickly find uncommon plants and new plants. Product highlighting can be used to maneuver him/ her towards a certain type of house plant. 54 Main insight: we found 4 different consumer profiles Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 3. The third category of customers, the Design Freak, has an aesthetical approach towards the purchase of house plants. They regularly visit the garden center, purchase on decoration value of a plant and mix artificial and real plants. The Design Freak needs a large supply to choose from, including novelties. There must be new plants available on a regular base, as this type of customer visits the garden center often. Highlight the novelties to attract his attention. The presentation of the plants has to be sophisticated, as this shopper finds aesthetics really important. 4. The fourth category, the Passionate, perceives plants as an indispensable part of life. They own many plants, which they love taking care of and visit the garden center on a regular base. They feel at home at the garden center and don‟t need much guidance. They like a home atmosphere and good presentation and decoration . 55 Shopper profiles of the customers We identified four* distinct profiles that shape the shopper's exploratory behavior during his shopping visit : The Passionate The Design Freak The Pragmatic The Newbie * Later on in the report these four types are linked to the two consumer types: naturalistic intellectuals and cultivated performers 56 Shopper Profiles – The Newbie A practical approach : Renewing already known plants Fears the unknown Occasional store visits / once per season (four times a year) State of mind in store: Exploring is rather difficult Difficulties to understand the product offer, complicated/barbarian names, Attracted in the store by the plants he already knows. Any pedagogical help or product high lightening acts as a purchase trigger for new products Selection criteria: Often green plants that don‟t take up much space Robust, solid, not fragile plants (vs. orchid), requiring only basic care (bamboos, banana tree) Expectations/Needs: Easy and clear information, pedagogical guidance : small leaflets vs. big book, information about the plant visible at one glance vs. small labels hidden in the flowerpot Help in decision making : visible and simple pictograms, vulgarized names, photos that clearly announce the plant‟s category Sensitive to : Ready-to-purchase offers (plants + pot) Advice, simplicity and clarity of the point of sale However, will not proactively seek help (fear not to be an expert) “I don’t buy plants I don’t know, because I don’t know how to care for them” , the mini trees attracted me”, “I look for things with easy care”, “I do not want it to be a constraint for me, to think about watering, and I do not want a too fragile plant”, “I was interested in the bonsais, but they need a lot of care” 57 Shopper Profiles - The Pragmatic A rational approach : Plant lover, but relatively inexperienced, knows partly what he wants to buy, likes to discover new / uncommon things may react on impulse, if product offer is well high lightened punctual visits State of mind in store: Logical, rigorous, methodological exploration per plant segment Purchase process often “quick”, but scan the whole area to discover potentially more interesting offers. Accurate discrimination of the price logic (normal price, promotion, fidelity advantage) via the color code Pays attention to the signage and store information. Lack of perceptible logic in the way the offer is structured, may inhibit his orientation. Selection criteria : Robust, solid, not fragile plants, requiring only basic care (ex. Spathypillum) Prices and promotions are important keys (also look at the promotional leaflets) Expectations/Needs: A profile close to the Newbie, wants simple and appealing names Find quickly uncommon plants and new plants (shape, size) Sensitive to : Signage Clear prices Product highlighting “promotions are in red, loyalty promotions are in violet and the normal prices in green”, “I like orchids, but I do not buy them, because I do not know how to care for them, the few times someone offered me some, they did not survive at my home”, “I was attracted by the 14.02 and then I saw 15%” “I do not remember the names, I do not care about it” 58 Shopper Profiles – The Design Freak An aesthetical approach, Regular shop visits, at least once a month Purchase logic very close to the decoration/design universe May mix genuine and artificial plants State of mind in store: Very open-minded in the store and shows strong exploratory behavior, but his strong sense of aesthetics and harmony makes him often hesitate for a while, before choosing a plant He likes exploring and finding hidden treasures that seduces with their originality and stylish shape Selection criteria : Aesthetical criteria: the shape of the trunk, twisted, shape and color of the leaves Aesthetical and uncommon or unusual plants, less well known Furniture and general interior design has to highlight the plants Expectations/Needs: Big choice, regular new plants, highlight the novelties, The shopping environment has to suggest the plant‟s stylish usage, sophisticated presentation Sensitive to : Decoration and suggestion for the plants‟ presentations: vegetal wall Impulsive purchase, open to very favorites Logic of the presentation : par theme, color scheme, color themes “it is an exiting moment, because you do not know what you will find”, “I would like to create something with a dark red color” “There were some beautiful plants, hanging like big pompoms” “today I did not have a favorite, because the product offer is too dense, I have difficulties projecting them into my home” 59 Shopper Profiles – The Passionate The passionate gardener : Plants are an indispensable part of life and of the balance of human life. Pays much attention to them, loves taking care for them Regular shop visits, once a week to once a month Their apartment/house often shelters many green and flowery plants The plants are chosen for their aesthetics and the plants‟ needs (environment, care) are taken into consideration during the selection process. State of mind in store: Long purchase process, likes to stay hours in the store, the pleasure to discover new plants, or a variety the shopper does not know. Open minded and strong exploratory behavior: investigates thoroughly and patiently each corner of the store, frequent stops and tactile contacts with the plants, reads the labels, asks for information. Comes first to walk and locating/discovering before purchasing Good orientation, without difficulty in the shop, feels at home in the shop. Selection criteria : Green and flowery plants for color and size harmony Expectations/Needs: Reinforce the visibility of the green (tall) plants, better discriminate the different plant sizes Sensitive to : The presentation, decoration and natural highlights However, this profile copes the best with lacking shop organization and product highlights “they say I have a green hand”, “I put my orchids in the water every 10/15 days”, “I drip them and when there are no flowers anymore, I cut them, I repot them, when the roots are ugly; I put some orchid compost…”, “the big green plants are not visible enough, you should be able to discriminate them from the entrance“ 60 Shopper profiles meet consumer segmentation Design freak = The cultivated the other profiles = Naturalistic performer intellectual The cultivated performer is on the look out of a somewhat different offer, needs to be provided with somewhat different information to make him/ her interested in a special plant. Plants need to have high decorative value, be special in a certain way, have something that makes them outstanding. The other profiles value the “living” aspect of the plant more and will hence be more focussed on practical information how to take care of the plant. 61 9 Most choices are made by means of type (size) and color 62 Choice of the channel All respondents go to a variety of stores Shoppers choose the store with regard to their purchase motive (animal, general plant or specific plant, interior vs. exterior plants) and also to vary the shopping experience The passionate respondents mix different channels: garden centers, but also flower shops and markets. Triggers to visit the garden center vs. other channels are : A place that optimizes the purchase process: a larger plant choice, but also the possibility of multiple purchases (plants, animals, decoration), importance of special offers A place prone for inspiration and creativity A place for relaxation and well being : ideal to visit alone during lunch break or to stroll around with the family Thanks to the huge variety of plants, a pedagogic place, where you can learn a lot about botanic The exit-interviews show that 55% of customers chooses a certain garden center because of its location (nearby). Also the variety of supply the garden center in question offers is often motive for visiting (17%) Most customers do not visit a garden center very frequent: 38% visits the garden center between one and three times a year ( “on Sundays, I come here with my husband and my children”, “we come sometimes just for strolling around, when my son was younger, I came here with the stroller : for the plants, the animals, the fishes” “for me, it is a moment of relaxation vs. the supermarket where the visit is stressful, here you can have a break, unwind, sometimes I come just for having a look around, without the intention to purchase something”. “waoh, the plant eats flees” 63 Choice for house plant section • • • Out of the customers that were interviewed at the exit of the house plant department , 74% came especially for this department to the garden center. Out of these customers, 68% wanted to visit this department – quite logical - because they need an indoor plant. However the atmosphere is also a reasonable important motive for a visit (16%) as is the large supply (15%). 67% of customers expressed in the exit interview an intention to buy a house plant 64 Key purchase criteria: decision before entering the store At the exit interviews only 28% of the interviewees had not made any decisions regarding the house plant they wanted to buy previous to their visit. The remaining 72% had made the following decisions regarding the plants they wanted to buy: 38% 26% 12% 28% 28% 6% The specific types(s) of plants (e.g. Ficus, Orgid) Green or flowering indoor plant Size of indoor plant The number of indoor plants Amount to spend on indoor plant None of these 65 Outline shopping behavior quantitative Intention to buy 67% intention to buy 97% eventually bought Eventual buy Pre-made decisions regarding plant 38% specific type of indoor plant 28% amount to spend on indoor plant 26% amount of indoor plants 12% flowery or green plant 6% size of indoor plant 28% decides nothing in advance 33% no intention to buy 46% eventually did buy Bought extra : 5%* Spent more: 7%* Bought extra: 8%* Bought extra : 17%* Bought extra: 17%* *results are indicative due to the low number of respondents. 66 Reasons (not) to buy a house plant Main reasons for buying a house plant, when the customer did not plan to do so… … I could not resist …I was tempted by the display/ I found them nice … the price was interesting/ it was not expensive Main reasons for customers not to buy a house plant… … I came for something else to the garden center …I just wanted to have a look around or came to the garden center for a enjoyable outing … I felt that I did not need a house plant 67 Purchase motives Different purchase motives influence the shopper‟s expectations and needs during his visit : Intention / Motive Selection criteria TO PLEASE Excellent quality – price ratio The gift for friends or a person at hospital The little plus or personalized touch that will make the difference “Rather than buying chocolates or cut flowers that will not last long, I always offer plants, this is a long lasting attention” Decorative efforts / highlight the product offer FOR PLEASURE The gentle discovery walk, experiencing the POS, enjoying the decoration and atmosphere BARGAIN For a special offer or an impulsive purchase Neat and original presentation: the composition, the wicker pot or ornamental flowerpot or basket Getting inspired May lead to a purchase but not necessary Importance of the reductions and special offers INDEPENDANCE Immediate and autonomous purchase EFFICIENCY Programmed purchase, like renewing a vanished plant A structured and clear product offer 68 Perception of the product offer at first glance The plants‟ organization in the store induces an intuitive knowledge and orientation. At a first glance, shoppers clearly recognize three big families, when entering the store: Green plants Flowers Creepers/climbers 69 Perception of the product offer at second glance At a second glance and in the course of the visit, specific families emerge to the shopper‟s conscience and become appealing areas (passages, stops, purchases) : Cactus Orchids Bonsais Carnivore plants (minor) Familiar looking plants c: Azaleas, Cyclamen, Yuka, Palm tree Three reasons for this increased visibility: The specificity of plant (shape, color) The special visual presentation and highlights (pots, colours, atmosphere) The familiarity of certain plants 70 Key purchase criteria: family and size are important When entering the store, many shoppers have a more or less an idea of what they want. All of the shoppers that were interviewed qualitative had a clear idea about : The plant‟s family /category : A strong selection key: Green plants or flowery plants Areas that mix both categories seem to be less efficient and may be disturb the purchasing process The plant‟s size : A strong key entry, because depending on the dedicated space at home Especially for large plants: areas that mix different sizes make the product choice more difficult and complex for the shopper “I was attracted to the orchids because of their colours, there was an amazing blue, really uncommon, the white and the pink are more common”, “I was immediately attracted to the cactus because of its colours. 71 Structuring flowery and green plants For flowery plants : The color is a key entry into the universe: respondents usually know what kind of colours they are looking for. Structuring the product offer with a chromatic logic/ color declination is strongly appealing, mixed colours may disturb the shopper For green plants : Shoppers usually know what caliber and shape they want (rangy vs. bushy) A green plant section with plants of different caliber and shapes packed together makes the purchase process more complicated A green plant section that separates rangy plants from bushy plants improves the shopper‟s comfort during the purchase 72 The personnel is viewed as competent and professional The personnel was viewed as: Pleasant, available and attentive to the client‟s wishes • A warm contact: attentive, heartily • Available without delay, never far away. These were key elements in the client relationship. It was perceived as important to be able to rapidly find the sales staff • Competent and professional: these were expected qualities which were highly appreciated for a garden center • Advice that was well adapted and precise. This contributes to the client purchase decision A satisfying commercial relationship - perceived by the client as pleasant, efficient and enhancing 73 The personnel provides assistance during the entire purchase process A contact across all different phases of the purchase decision and process Orientation: finding one‟s way in the store ( if orientation signs are absent): a need to be guided at the start of one‟s search: to find a specific type of plant) Assistance in making the decision: The personnel provides additional information related to the characteristics of the plant: • The uncommon/ “exceptional” plants. A member of the personnel mentions the exceptional characteristics of the plant (the example of the name “elephant plant” that serves as a purchase trigger). • The way to take care of the plant: frequency of watering, sun exposure, it‟s sensitive to light, any other environmental conditions, the costs are the issues that are most frequent when additional information is asked. I found a plant that’s a bit different, I asked the price, it’s name, how to take care of it, she told me not to water it too much, no direct sun exposure and to put it in a well lit environment • An advice that is well adapted to the clients needs, will allow the customer to actually make his or her purchase. For example, a customer verifies with a member of staff the final size and width of a plant once it will have finished to grow. Personnel that is readily available for the client during the whole purchase process (beyond the plant: pot, earth type…etc) 74 The final choice: plant needs to look healthy In order to choose between to options, the shopper usually takes the product out of the shelf, lifts it in the daylight and has a closer look at it. By doing this, he/she checks : The size and caliber of the plant Variations/nuances of : Color (depending on his project of decoration) The shape of the leaves (round, stretched, sharp), checked by touching the leaves The harmonious development The plant‟s physical fitness: The plant, a living being that has to look healthy! The condition of the leaves: damaged or not (flecks, yellow, faded) The condition of the roots: exterior roots (orchids) The condition of the ground: a balanced humidity “I have to like the plant immediately, it should not be damaged , it should be healthy” 75 The final choice The level of development/ maturity: expanding, growing or achieving maturity For flowery plants : the plant should have open flowers (in order to see her beauty) as well as un buds (sign of growth) For green plants : touching the leaves is very important and gives the shopper clues about the plant‟s characteristics : a thick leave may inform about the plant‟s solidity or about its growth The presence or not of an ornamental flowerpot 76 Observed trigger: create a surprise and impulsivity Highlight novelties or uncommon/original plants (twisted trunk, elephant plant…) in order to activate impulsive purchase or a very favorite bought on the next store visit, in order to strengthen the shopper‟s bond to the brand (avoid brand switch) Increase the efficiency of the moment of visual and tactile contact with the plant (also during exploratory stops) 77 Main insight: Most choices are made by means of type (size) and color Growth Insights 1. Reasons for customers to visit a garden center oppose to other channels are the larger plant supply, the experience of the visit being an enjoyable outing and the garden center as an pedagogical environment. 2. The majority of customers has a certain plan concerning what they wanted to buy. In the exit interviews many knew exactly which type they wanted to buy, in the qualitative interviews their plans seemed more general: size and category were fixed. Actions you should undertake to drive growth Create a large supply including novelties. Make sure the presentation is beautiful and enough signage and staff is present to fulfill the pedagogical role. Categorize on family and size to simplify the orientation of the customer and the purchase process. 78 Growth Insights Actions you should undertake to drive growth 3. Customers differentiate between three types of plants at first glance: green plants, flowers and climbers. Subsequently the specificity of plants, special visual highlights and familiarity of certain plants are important in the selection process. Make use of visual highlights to lead customers to new types of plants, otherwise they would often be attracted to the ones they already know. 4. Personnel fulfills two functions in the path to purchase of the customer. Firstly, they are an important aid for customers in their navigation through the garden center. Secondly, well adapted and precise advice contributes to the customers‟ purchase decision. The personnel is perceived competent and professional. Maintain this high standard. For personnel to contribute to the purchase decision of customers, it is important that they are well informed, easy to approach and able to give tailored advice. 5. After deciding on the specific type of plant, the final choice is based on physical fitness of the plant, a harmonious growth, the maturity and the presence of a flower pot. Make sure all plants are well kept and all finished flowers are removed. Always present a part of the plants in a flower pot, as some customers are looking for this package deal. 79