The Clarinet in 19th Century Naples
Transcription
The Clarinet in 19th Century Naples
Ferdinando Sebastiani, Gennaro Bosa and the Clarinet in Nineteenth-Century Naples Author(s): Ingrid Elizabeth Pearson Source: The Galpin Society Journal, Vol. 60 (Apr., 2007), pp. 203-214, 112-115 Published by: Galpin Society Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/25163902 . Accessed: 22/09/2013 01:04 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. . Galpin Society is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The Galpin Society Journal. http://www.jstor.org This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions INGRID ELIZABETH PEARSON Ferdinando Sebastiani, the Clarinet inNineteenth-Century Gennaro Until recently, the virtuoso clarinettist Ferdinando Sebastiani had (1803-1860) embouchure the of reed-above, confirms existence the One area in which historical clarinettists have been insufficiently assiduous is that of embouchure or reed position. Described as 'themost important since the playing technique eighteenth century' this subject has received only scant or the maxillary, of a 'golden by a standardisation In the of various This institute the became institute part became of the Collegio Napoletano as the Conservatorio known embouchure of Niccol? focus to Naples.5 source and aspects of in connections and Italian century, between the clarinettists.4 research into the symphonic 1720 and 1840, particularly the Zingarelli, narrows the Italian the importance Acknowledging material France other of the twentieth explicit works of with development.3 Rey M. Longyear's repertoire between in earlier epochs. This state of affairs has arisen partly as a result of the exigencies of globalisation in 1826, in comparison latter part reed-above elements, which did not obtain at the appropriate historical periods. For example, a limited range of historical instruments is routinely copied, denying the modern listener the range of timbres evident 1 attention instrument's scholars made The current vogue for historical performance has characterised in development age' of this technique amongst nineteenth-century Italian players, particularly those from the south. been Naples style. di San Pietro a Majella).1 Sebastiani later held the at the Teatro San Carlo of clarinet positions principal as well as teaching and Reale Cappella Palatina, at the Conservatorio. He died in Naples, five years after the publications of his M?todo per clarinetto? use and and the discipline imposed by the microphone. These observations apply as much to instrumental technique as to historical equipment and musical been all but forgotten since his death. Born in the southern Italian town of Capua, he studied at the Real Collegio inNaples (later the Conservatorio Sebastiani's Bosa from outside Austria, an constructing Germany understanding of the clarinet in the Romantic period, a later study by Longyear provided the catalyst for research trips to in 1817. Moving di San Pietro a to the monastery of San Pietro see Teresa Chirico, Majella-, a Majella 'La scuola di m?sica del Real Orfanotrofio e le istituzioni Provinciale di Reggio Calabria musicali Nuova Rivista napoletane', Musicale XXII Italiana (1988), p. 482. 2 Ferdinando M?todo Sebastiani, per clarinetto 1855). (Naples, 3 Nicholas ofWestern art music; Shackleton, ?11, 4 (ii): The clarinet The mouthpiece 'Clarinet, and reed', The New Grove Dictionary and Musicians ed. S. Sadie and J.Tyrrell ofMusic (2001). 4 See Raymond du d?veloppement '? propos au d?but du dix-neuvi?me de l'instrumentation Meylan, si?cle', Acta 42 (1970), p. 71, n. 1. had held the position of principal flute in the orchestra of the Pomeriggi musicologica Meylan inMilan Musicali between November 1954 and October 1958. At that time the was clarinettist Ferruccio principal also Professor at the Conservatorio in Parma. Gonizzi Gonizzi, reed-above and Meylan remembers his soft played staccato in the finale ofMendelssohn's No. 4 in A [Italian], with Raymond Meylan, Symphony private correspondence January 1999. 5 Rey M. Longyear, 'Introduction', The Symphony 1720-1840. Series A (New York, 1980) VIII: 203 This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions p. xviii. 204 The Galpin Society Journal Naples in 1996 and 1998.6 The present author's PhD research into organological, and iconographical near documentary evidence confirms that despite its extinction the today, reed-above was embouchure REED formative the years.7 to wishing reconstruct the collaboration with the Neapolitan maker Gennaro Bosa, probably during the 1830s.8 The appearance of various types of clarinet with thirteen keys marked a significant stage in the instrument's organological development. Iwan M?ller's thirteen-keyed clarinet a certainly achieved pioneering eventual such century, were A made In well-documented.10 nineteenth-century 7 'Clarinet Longyear, Pearson, Ingrid of Sheffield, University 8 Sebastiani, Sonorities Clarinet Romantic that the for either method. to obliged presents subsequently preferring the amongst these Chief Therefore being than on top.13 rather reed-below lip. It is only a matter a beautiful timbre and well without less, M?ller reasons embouchure.14 embouchure assists reed-below is the claim the player in operating the key-work for the right thumb which enabled the player to slur between f/c" and g#/d#", and between Times The Musical Music', in Theory the of to rest and Practice: e/b' and f/c#",possibly CXXIV the Forgotten (1983), Art the p. 225. of Reed-Above, PhD thesis, 2001. M?todo, in my in Early Embouchure the reed below three century. 6 put from the clarinet play the way whether or lower produce articulation can None sources in the light of the Bosa/ organological Sebastiani this article offers some collaboration, remarks concerning a hitherto neglected aspect of the development of the clarinet in the nineteenth can one that the quality in the mouth, the upper for one excellent and documentary advanced upon depends tonguing the mouthpiece of habit, material evaluating are mistaken of people and the reed near in Lyons, J.G.C. Bischoff in Darmstadt, in Mainz B. Schotts S?hne and Griessling and Schlott in Berlin. The organological development of M?ller's thirteen-keyed clarinet, however, has from timbre holding Brelet been more a on embouchure with players12. large number of in Paris, of Gentellet reed-below of clarinets pour la nouvelle Clarinette ? 13 of cl821, M?ller himself Clefs et Clarinette-Alto offers the following comments on the issue of clarinet reed position: the M?ller instruments in the 1820s in the workshops THIRTEEN-KEYED In his M?thode prominence during the early part of the system.9 Developed nineteenth as the number dilettante and accomplishment, THE keywork suggests that this technique found favour more quickly with professional players.11 This thesis is confirmed in reports by Christian Friedrich Michaelis and Gottfried Weber which call for the adoption of the reed-below technique amongst reed-above embouchure, Sebastiani's M?todo provides evidence of his use of a clarinet with thirteen keys.Moreover, this instrument was the result of Sebastiani's was of portrayal far greater In addition to functioning as an important source for players AND Beginning with the publication ofM?llers Gamme pour la nouvelle Clarinette invent?e par lui in cl812, in fact themore popular of the two reed positions used in the clarinet's POSITION CLARINET 17-26. pp. historical A reproduction in The clarinets' chapter 'Playing 2000), p. 46. 9 of this clarinet The earliest depiction lui (Bonn, cl812). See also Martin Harlow, of the illustration Early in Iwan M?ller, appears 'Two Early Concertos of Sebastiani A Practical Clarinet: Gamme and Guide pour his la nouvelle for Iwan M?ller's clarinet first appeared Lawson by Colin Clarinette Thirteen-Keyed (Cambridge, invent?e Clarinet', par Galpin (2006), pp. 29-42. Society Journal LIX 10 See Nicholas Shackleton and Albert France', (cl812) 11 See in of M?ller's clarinet 'C?sar Rice, Janssen and the transmission 13-keyed De La Clarinette and more 'M?ller's Gamme Galpin Society Journal LII (1999), pp. 183-194 recently Albert Rice of The Thirteen-key and the Development Clarinet', pp. 181-184. Galpin Society Journal LVI (2003), those charts cet cl814); (London, avec facilit? instrument Bassetthorn', Caecilia within contained the Clarinet Franz et perfection... Gamme-, c. (Mainz, A New John Hopkinson, de Blatt, Methode complete Gottfried 1827-28); and clarinette Weber, Preceptor for ? jouer de apprendre ?ber Clarinett und 'Einiges Complete pour 11/41 (1829), pp. 35-57 and Philippe Berr,M?thode de Clarinette ? 6 et ? 13 Clefs d'apr?s celle de Vanderhagen... 1831). (Paris, 12 Friedrich Michaelis, Christian '?ber ?ber Clarinett 385-391 and Weber 13 M?ller, M?thode 14 'For preferring M?ller, Thadd?us 'Einiges pour the reed la nouvelle supported die Klarinette', und Clarinette Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung 10 (1808), Bassetthorn. ? 13 Clefs by the lower et Clarinette-Alto lip', M?ller, (Paris, cl821), M?thode. This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions p. 23. cols. 369-375, Pearson? most infers of his feature controversial He design.15 reed-above that more are players reliant on the thumb of the right hand to support the instrument, and therefore have difficulty in a reliable playing posture whilst maintaining this negotiating the use of such keys.16 Despite the opinion, reed-above confirms example, capable certainly In this light,M?llers below of practitioners, salient were thumb-keys in nineteenth-century documented is a of presence of is somewhat embouchure Sebastiani's that existing by these features and reed-below the similar not by then as widespread century provides embouchure feature is well as has been previously illustrated player experienced (Paris, 16 A by practitioners 1836), p. 2. in his method, Fr?d?ric of either Berr provides reed position; C?sar makers, was Janssen particularly of the keys, controlled by the little fingers of both hands, to assist the little fingers in sliding between these keys. This Baumann.23 in a clarinet was Possibly themost sophisticated use of thumb-keys was made by the Simiot firmwith their 'hinge' keys for the notes f#/c#"and less often, e/b'. The presence later, the reed-below incorporating to the M?ller-system Janssen's modifications instrument included removing the thumb-keys. He replaced them with moving rollers at the extremity by assumed.18 15 This the the thirteen-keyed clarinet important viable, the subject of a study by Nicholas Shackleton and Albert Rice.22 and operate the thumb-keys.17 His remark that at least half of all German clarinettists were still using the reed-above embouchure at the beginning of the that resemble however, in making cites the supposed problem of reed-above players being unable properly to both support the clarinet evidence tutor, the placement and configuration of the thirteen keys and their tone holes, or the use of the key and branch for the right-hand thumb.21Amongst himself. Backofen second quarter of the nineteenth reed-above either and may draws inM?ller's instrument Backofens discussion Johann Georg Heinrich of reed position in his 1824 tutor also centres on instrument, the advocated depicted in Sebastiani's M?todo. clarinets Not all M?ller-system by less-experienced to those of M?ller were players confirmation of this embouchure.20 Organological is manifest in the thirteen-keyed clarinet by Bosa clarinet the M?ller-system sources documentary clarinettists. conclusions reed-above able to cope with keywork thus positioned, given that the majority of contemporary French-language simultaneously. ambiguous that suggests workshop clarinets methods which of a thumb-lever for the e/b' key on amid-nineteenth century clarinet in B\> from the Simiot and Brelet plea for the use of the reed have been heeded most well on 205 GennaroBosa see M?ller, evidence on survives feature two clarinets is also influence Janssen's evident in B^ by Gentellet.24 Granted that evidence by M?ller himself clarifies documentary his intention that these thumb-keys be used with reed-below the was embouchure, was Janssen catering for players who still used the reed-above embouchure? In the light of his period of study with the less, some p. 1, figs. 1-2. None that the difficulties associated M?thode, see Fr?d?ric Berr, Trait? Complet de with these la Clarinette fifteen keys had ? quatorze years been Clefs tutor published in Paris in c. 1836 suggests that M?ller himself may have had to bite into the mouthpiece in to support see the clarinet whilst these 8. Berr, Trait?, p. operating thumb-keys, zur Klarinette, Heinrich nebst kurzen Abhandlung ?ber das Basset-Horn Backofen, Johann Georg Anweisung 1824), p. 6. (Leipzig, 18 see T. Eric in the 18th century', Early 'Clarinet reed position Backofen, 1824); Anweisung (Leipzig, Hoeprich, order 17 Music 19 12/1 (1984), See Nicholas pp. 48-55. Shackleton and Albert 'C?sar of M?ller's in clarinet Rice, Janssen and the transmission 13-keyed France', Galpin Society Journal LII (1999), pp. 183-194. 20 Shackleton collection, UK, NJS 206. Cambridge/Edinburgh, 21 Private with Albert In fact very few specimens Rice. survive with this last feature, see Shackleton correspondence and Rice, 'C?sar Janssen', p. 189. It should also be mentioned here that with the advent of the clarinet, thirteen-keyed arose the of the thumb-rest, which was added to the back of the lower joint to assist the popularity player in supporting the instrument's extra key-work. An on the of the thumb-keys illustration in his clarinet appears M?ller-system see Iwan M?ller, M?thode, method, p. 1, figs. 1-2. 22 and Rice, op.cit, Shackleton pp. 189-190. 23 Shackleton collection, Cambridge/Edinburgh, No. W201. 24 No. 70:605. Edwardsville, Illinois, U.S.A., U.K., NJS 473 and Fiske Museum, Claremont, This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions California, U.S.A., 206 The Galpin Society Journal Xavier Lef?vre at the Paris Conservatoire, it is highly probable that Janssen was himself a reed-above practitioner. Given this proclivity, his version of the use to other makers made reed-above players. Other century Italy, embouchure Italian the reed-below embouchure from the 1830s by players trained at the Paris Conservatoire, particularly more flexibility inmoving between registers, a more precise staccato, better projection of sound and the ability to control the altissimo registerwith accuracy. Whilst tongued articulation was clearly the most used as occasional The during the tenure of Fr?d?ric Berr, professor of clarinet, between 1831 and 1838.30 The subsequent popularity of the reed-below position is reflected in French-language methods also subsequent earliest Italian-language mention of reed to this writer is found in the anonymous M?todo Facilissimo per Imparare a ben in Florence in Suonare il Clarinette.., published known position clearly illustrates the reed in both fingering charts. In embouchure details are articulation concerning implies 25 M?todo 26 M?todo Facilissimo per Imparare pp. 2-5. Facilissimo, bear replication of Lef?vre's for the reed-above preference instructions embouchure.33 Italian editions of Lef?vre's tutor were to witness Busoni, il Clarinetto, sources documentary too literally. Only works with of embouchure practices. and Romeo Orsi, and this of preservation the father of the composer/pianist reed-above con Quelle Intelligenze Necessarie... Ferruccio, (Florence, 1816). one should avoid taking reed position, to reed position and illustrative reference to ascertain both textual representations as indicators reliable truly 27 et Raisonn?e la clarinette... Nouvelle Amand M?thode pour Vanderhagen, 28 en deux parties Methode de Clarinette Nouvelle Vanderhagen, Including von A. Vanderhagen and Claude-Fran?ois in zwei Abtheilungen cl836) (Leipzig, LeF?vre celle compos?e (Paris, 1836). par Xavier 29 de Clarinette Xavier Lef?vre, M?thode (Paris, 1802). illustrative with Contemporary technique amongst a predominantly Italian body of players.34 Later advocates included Ferdinando from a ben Suonare for clarinet published of Berr.31 published by Benedetto Carulli etRaison?e In using a Subsequent explicit translated Amand Vanderhagen's M?thode Nouvelle his However, support of this embouchure, the text instructs the player to cover the teeth with the lips, 'the upper lip should be more folded over the teeth since it is required to control and press the reed'.26More those charts forboth six- and eleven-keyed clarinets and his text refrains from explicitlymentioning reed position. 1816.25 This document above to Sebastiani's M?todo, Luigi Bassi published possibly the earliest Italian-language edition of Lef?vre.32 Bassi's depiction of reed position is ambiguous on the means. articulatory players.29 The decline of the use of the reed-above technique in French-speaking areas began with the adoption of allowed the chest and throat were above.27 particularly in Italy, suggesting something of the lineage of reed-above playing passing from French to practitioners more closely to imitate the human voice. Advocates of the technique claimed it gave the player a greater variety of tongued articulation, desirable method, methods, be published throughout the nineteenth century, in French issued during the including sources 1830s.28 The influence of Lef?vre's 1802 M?thode de Clarinette was felt throughout the century, French CLARINET REED-POSITION IN ITALY From a purely theoretical standpoint, in nineteenth reed-above in 1785, including the mentioned in the use of the technique, Despite works for the reed-above embouchure continued to including Lef?vre, Baumann and Simiot also thirteen-keyed clarinets without thumb-keys. the of mixed a decrease thirteen-keyed clarinet may well have been motivated by a deliberate attempt tomake the instrument more accessible la clarinette, published pour (Paris, par A. cl785), pp. Vanderhagen/ M?thode Buteux, any are ii-iii. Clarinettenschule de clarinette d'apr?s 30See Fr?d?ric Berr, Trait? (1836) andM?thode Compl?te de Clarinette (Paris, c. 1836). 31 Enn?s Berr,Nouvelle M?thode de Clarinette ? 6 et 13 Clefs (Paris, 1839); X. Schneider and Detouches, Including J. M?thode Nouvelle ? anneaux (Paris, mobiles; 1844) de Clarinette et de and Klos?, celle M?thode (Paris, c. 1840); ? 13 cl?s... (Paris, de Clarinette Hyacinthe Klos?, M?thode pour servir ? l'enseignement de la Clarinette la Clarinette ?l?mentaire pour Kastner, M?thode Jean Georges mobiles ? 6 et ? 13 cl?s, et ? anneaux 1843); d'apr?s F. Berr. Revue et modifi?e par H. Klos? (Paris, cl880). augment?e 32 per clarinetto espressamente composto Luigi Bassi, M?todo di Milano R. Conservatorio (Milan, cl855). 33 Bassi, M?todo, p. 6. 34 Benedetto Carulli, M?todo cl860) (Milan, per Clarinetto per il Conservatorio and Romeo di Parigi Orsi, M?todo per This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions da Lef?vre Clarinetto e adottato (Milan, dal cl890). motion pivot medium f#/c#" fixed in and flatter in of hole, joint e/b'keys, separate isrelocated than touchpiece back of to lower touchpiece lower down key which but and 4 metal, place key than horizontal between for RH 3 and mount, e/b' f#/c#" shorter length rod longer pillar C in 531 No. 13 boxwood style cursive No. C in 530 13 S boxwood style cursive hole raised flatter separate in A No. 529 13 S boxwood style cursive flatter separate hole raised in Bb 528 No. No. in 527 Bb No. Eb in 522 boxwood 13 S flatter including style side mouthpiece beak separate hole cursive raised motion pivot andkeys, in e/b' touchpiece and key f#/c#" but than than rod key medium horizontal betweenf#/c#" e/b'longer NA mount, length shorter pillar motion pivot medium andkeys,shorter between in e/b' than touchpiece and key but than rod horizontal f#/c#"key NA e/b' f#/c#" mount, length longer pillar medium-length touchpiece, branch plus for by RH thumb rod operationand mount, key than e/b'but between e/b' f#/c#" and shorter longer than motion pivotin key keys, f#/c#" NA NA medium mount, andf#/c#" keys, in e/b' touchpiece and motion pivot horizontal key but than rod key between than NA e/b'longer f#/c#" pillar length shorter NA cursive style boxwood 12 S joint profile,motion little LH profile into mounted cursive style, mouthpiece flatter holeintegrated including side joint into expanded finger pivot operation NA beak separate longtouchpiece, lower vertical expanded A No. in 263 11 boxwood No. A in 136 y/ 13 boxwood style cursive style cursive medium touchpiece length ebony 13 No. Bb in 21 upper-case style NA NA NA NA NA f#/c#" NA NA NA NA NA joint profile, little LH profile into mounted motion flatter integrated lower joint pivot vertical integral into expanded operation NA hole longtouchpiece, expanded finger flatter separate hole raised NA horizontal pillar boxwood 13 S flatter integral hole raised NA and between e/b'keys,shorter than than motion pivotin key f#/c#"key longer mount, andpillar rod horizontal but e/b' joint profile,motion profile touchpiece, into mounted short andf#/c#" lower joint keys,operated in e/b' holeintegrated separate thumb pivot vertical between saltspoon byRH into expanded for use by RHthumb expanded ebony 13 specimen NA joint profile,motion profile into mounted touchpiece, short andkeys, in e/b' f#/c#" thumb joint integral holeintegrated pivot vertical between operated byRH into expanded RH for by usethumb lower saltspoon expanded M?todo feature material keys mouthpiece stamps design pad barrel f/c" modus operandi key f#/c#" front g#/d#" key thumb rest g#/d#" side brille key This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 208 The Galpin Society Journal whose 'LASCUOLANAPOLETANA AND FERDINANDO SEBASTIANI Scuola di Perfezionamento per il Clarinetto appeared in 1883, and Carlo Delia Giacoma, who, in 1904 published hisM?todo per clarinetto.35 One of the earliest monographs to the clarinet was published Gandolfi.36 Aware of Fr?d?ric Berr's reform of reed position in France, Gandolfi suggests that Giovanni Bimboni was amongst the first Italian clarinettists to the German system of the inverted mouthpiece with the reed below', conforming to evidence presented by Bimboni's tutor.37 Likewise 'adopt Charles Day's of musical catalogue instruments in 1890 at the Royal Musical Exhibition, mentions both reed positions, remarking thatmany Italian and Spanish players were still employing the exhibited reed-above In on 1943 Temistocle and the clarinet a providing A link between articulation and reed-position was firstmade by Roeser in 1764, then implied by Lef?vre in 1802 and some eight years later by Joseph Fr?hlich.44 In extensive Pace's saxophone source This overview reliable of the reed-above accounts He clarinets.40 the for Ferdinando M?todo per Scuola Busoni, clarinetto Gandolfi, Busoni the Appunti 1887). (Florence, 37 Gandolfi, Appunti cl850). (Florence, 38 Charles Russell Intorno, Clarinetto not unlike Day, Descriptive 1890 (London, (Naples, edn, Offenbach, that of his 1886), pp. al Clarinetto considerable the 12-13. See own demonstrate associations ad Uso Bimboni, M?todo delle as abilities and 1883) 24 Tibia Delia pp. 605-611. (1999), e Progressivo recently exhibited di Firenze Clarinetto per at Giacoma, ?ber Vater seines del R. Istituto Musicale Scuole clarinet a player were Carlo der Klarinette Graduato Instruments for compositions that his embouchure, Carl although Baermann. he a more portrays See Labanchi, Sib, the Royal Military Clarinett-Schule... Vollst?ndige and Temistocle Pace, Ancie Battenti, Baermann, chart were a concerto and he performed the works 8; p. 1. Amongst F?tis, Biographie, see Weston, More Clarinet Virtuosi, Rossini; p. 236. 47 Universale dei Musicisti See Carlo 1938), p. 491. Schmidl, Dizionario (Milan, advanced M?todo thumb per rev. 1864-75; lever on this Musikschule f?r 'An historical note a set of variations This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions of model Progressivo (Frankfurt, p. 42. The 1917), unpaginated fingering an alternative for f#/c#". instrument fingering provides 43 7. M?todo, Sebastiani, p. 44 and Fr?hlich, 'Clarinett-Schule', Lef?vre, M?thode Theoretisch-praktische Vollst?ndige Joseph, 2: pp. 7-35. Instrumente... alle beym Orchester (Bonn, 1810-11), wichtigere gebr?uchliche 45 in Rey M. Longyear, in 1830 appears of Naples to the musical climate An excellent background 247-254. Man II Music and from a musical backwater: 1830', (1978), pp. Naples 46 his performance.47 Sebastiani's Compilati contemporary Carl Sebastiani's 1943). reed-above reed-below reed-above However, In addition, acclaim.46 for Sebastiani's of the Musical Catalogue 1891), p. 102. (Florence, famous are with the composers Fioravanti and Mercadante to their of solos have composition inspired reported increasing p. 7, see Giovanni London, Exhibition, 39 Temistocle Pace, Ancie Battenti 40 Pace, Ancie Battenti, p. 113. 41 Pace, ibid., p. 114. 42 tutor also favours Labanchi's clarinet, north.45 prosperous il Clarinetto di Perfezionamento per (Hamburg, von See Ingrid Pearson, 'Verfolgt Klang im Italien des 19. Jahrhunderts', und die Klarinette Intorno more his 1904/R1998). (Todi, Ferruccio Blatt-Position, 36 Riccardo to in Paris and Vienna in 1828, during appearances which he performed his own compositions, met with popularity of the reed-below embouchure during the nineteenth century in terms of aesthetics.41 35 contrast contemporary Ernesto Cavallini, Sebastiani made few tours, spending most of his career in the south of Italy, where opportunities were fewer than in commentary appeared.39 technique as used in Italy. Pace cites the launeddas, with itsupward-facing idioglot reed, as the historical inclination of the precedent for the reed-above earliest Teatro San Carlo and the Conservatorio di San Pietro a Majella.42 Whilst Sebastiani mentions both reed positions, he links the use of the reed-above embouchure with a greater degree of 'colouring (of articulation) that gives the clarinet its beauty'.43 embouchure.38 contains themost thorough biographical account of the various schools of Italian clarinet playing during the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, as well as of a 'golden age' of reed-above playing is reflected in those didactic works published by the Neapolitan virtuoso clarinettists Sebastiani, and Gaetano Labanchi, his successor at both the Evidence devoted exclusively in 1887 by Riccardo on a theme by Pearson? certainly on a par with those of Cavallini. a composing his most remains in manuscript. includes three uvre His concertos with for solo for clarinet the reed below, the tongue and quick execution. With comes to play only on the tip of the mouthpiece, and acts on the tip of the reed with hardship and without works other orchestra, and music clarinet of Sebastiani's stable is certainly the upper lip, more lips, which to any movement. It is clear that the not subject role in the sound tip of the tongue plays an important a more natural its flexibility enables of the clarinet, the Despite of works numbers considerable instrument, with orchestra based on themes by Rossini, operatic fantasias on works by Rossini, Verdi and Bellini with and for clarinet as as well accompaniment piano several one can the reed below only achieve staccato not picchettato, and the other types of colourings of articulation which give the clarinet piano. to continuing the legacy of Lef?vre, legacy reed position is possibly the most M?todo Sebastiani's part, important its beauty. oscillations a marks significant and deliberate attempt to preserve his pedagogical beliefs, as well as a codification of the reed-above technique. At the time of its publication, in 1855, Sebastiani's M?todo reports thatmany of his pupils 'have, both in public and in private, shown that the standard of playing ... in Naples is in a state of splendour, comparable with that of other European conservatoires'.48 of his Much Amongst the concerning the mouthpiece the wear and but tear explicit are that it is a big mistake on your teeth both Besides, mouthpiece. the because and the for a good vocal timbre teeth touch neither the reed it is above clear or below. I am persuaded for by the reed above I present the most reasons....It is convincing that the reed is weaker than the mouthpiece, therefore itmust be consigned 48 Sebastiani, M?todo, 49 cit. p. 5. Op. 50 cit., p. 7 Op. 51 cit. p. 5. Op. 52 Raffaele Liberatore, 1836), p. 79. 53 William Waterhouse, (London, 1993), to the strongest part of and when by anything the reed to allowed means below leaning the entire be placed in which of the palate Therefore impediment. without cavity the reed above.50 espousal of a clarinet with thirteen keys is conservative for its time. In recounting the Sebastiani's the number of design to deal with To method. added. of this care I take he writes: history, Finally clarinets these and thirteen, keys became are now quite used. widely in the present this model thirteen these However, of the thirteen would some keys not be aforementioned which show will I have appear the advantages advised can others be the equivalent serve and would keys, In fact, I directed the execution... only to facilitate G. Bosa manufacturer of Naples the indispensable nor the on the to decide It is necessary mouthpiece. best method of holding the mouthpiece, with the reed which it has of clarinets, The mouthpiece, covered by the reed is introduced cover both sets of teeth, between the lips, which must or them from the mouthpiece preventing touching I have known rest the reed. who their teeth people of freely. Having should directions following remarks: on obstructed to oscillate of other clarinettists, embouchure reed-above are not vibrate above profit from this passive instruction; when then they will be acknowledged, also as masters, I they try to teach in a way to be sure the people can learn, to still Sebastiani's become on the fleshybits of the mouth but if the reed is others to play the clarinet can be gleaned from the following remark: 'For the time being I am satisfied by the enjoyment of my beloved pupils, to whom I dedicate the present method. I am sure that theywill consult the optimal methods especially that of Lef?vre'.49 a sound with its the reed produces more sonorous when they Finally, which instrument's to teaching approach With speed.... battuto miniatures In addition of whose 209 GennaroBosa the in the construction him of the modifications in the fingering charts, where I obtained them.51 with Iwill GENNARO BOSA AND HIS CLARINETS FOR SEBASTIANI evidence Documentary activities the concerning of the musical-instrument maker life and Gennaro is scant. According to the 1836 edition of Liber atores De'saggi delle Manifatture Napolitane Esposti nella Solenne Mostra Bosa was Bosa Raffaele active as a maker in Naples, at 9 Calata di S. Tommaso from working premises d'Aquino.52 His reputation extended further south, as the 1836 consignment of wind instruments for the Royal Orphanage inReggio Calabria testifies.53 The 1834 edition of Liberatore's commentary on Neapolitan manufacturers equates p. 4. De'saggi The New d?lie Manifatture Napolitane Index: A Dictionary Langwill Esposti ofMusical nella Wind Solenne Mostra Instrument p. 41. This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions del Makers 1836 (Naples, and Inventors 210 The Galpin Society Journal r**4 Figure 1. Sebastiani's M?todo the quality of clarinets by Bosa with in Vienna, London or Paris.54 Given Forma those made Liberatore's mention in clarinet design by of developments M?ller, Janssen and Guerre, it could be assumed that Bosa had been making clarinets since the 1820s. Bosa's collaboration with Sebastiani, known at the time as a clarinettist of repute, was certainly at the time of Liberatore's report.55 well-established Liberatore also describes a clarinet in B|, by Bosa 54 55 56 Liberatore, Liberatore, Instruments 57 Waterhouse, 58 Waterhouse, De'saggi delle Manifatture op. cit., p. 88. This by Bosa Napolitane are rare, but a flute with The New ibid.. The Langwill cor Index, anglais similar e composto', pezzi p. 26. from ebony with an ivory mouthpiece, ivory rings and shell-shaped keys made of silver.56 Another player to influence Bosa's craftsmanship was the oboist Giovanni Battista Belpasso, one of made performing and teaching colleagues in more is known about Bosa although Little Naples.57 other surviving instruments include flutes, an oboe Sebastiani's and a cor anglais.58 Documentary Esposti nella is also mentioned collaboration e di questi del Clarinetto shell-like Solenne in Pace keywork was Mostra Ancie in evidence del 1834 (Naples, 1834), of p. 87. p. 41. Battenti, offered support for sale in the U.S.A. inMay 2006. loc.cit.. is in the collection of the Royal College of Music, London; This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions RCM 326 CA/2. the Pearson? survival in Naples of clarinets by Bosa appears in Ettore Santagata's 1930 catalogue //Museo Storica di San Pietro a Majella.59 Musicale Santagata lists origin, from specimens the is an four Neapolitan these and Capuana The thesis Santa offered few obstacles presented that above, Entitled thumb-keys the use parts. of a metal 'The structure of the clarinet and M?ller's ligature. In contrast with on a 59 Ettore information 1960, 60 61 visit Renato Meucci Sebastiani, reports practices stamping Given time.64 of reed-above the clarinet various amongst status playing as a of Naples in nineteenth collaboration such marks were more commercially e/b', produce the middle one is an alternative key for The instrument g#/d#",and the other a key for f#/c#" on were 3rd edn, a cursive instrument, driven than indicators of performing practices. Figure 6 (see colour section) presents three views of the keys operated by the left-hand little finger and right-hand thumb. From left to right, the keys the material several //Museo Storico Musicale Santagata, is also appears in Lyndesay Graham rev., enlarged the shorter century Italy, the presence of a stamp on the beak side of two of themouthpieces (Nos. 522 in E^ and 528 in B^) confirms that by the time of the Bosa/Sebastiani in themid 1830s.62 to Naples in at this centre the ad hoc selection of clarinets examined recent to the previous irregularities makers THE NAPLES CLARINETS Amongst also in C. Herbert Heyde has suggested something of the of this development, the clarinet depicted in the M?todo leaves the hole E.61 Sebastiani's preference for mouthpieces made fromwood, ebony or grenadilla, contrasts notice clarinets, style stamp appears on the other eight instruments examined. Figure 5 (see colour section) shows this design of stamp as it appears on the bell of a clarinet The majority of thirteen-keyed clarinets from the mid-nineteenth century include a key for f/c". Although both Bosa and Sebastiani were aware reportedly used by Bosa Bosa M?todo, therefore, intended primarily for students or players with less need to utilise the tuning adjustments facilitated by a separate barrel? finger. This design enables the player to slur between e/b' and f#/c#", using keys A (left-hand little finger) and B (right-hand thumb), as well as between f/c" and g#/d#"by alternating hole E (rh little finger) and key C (lh little finger). Sebastiani also recommends the use of key C, rather than key D, as a trill key. of ivory or metal, remarks. preliminary theM?todo touchpiece for the f#/c#"key.Whilst an an instrument with depicts integral barrel, only two of the surviving Naples instruments display this characteristic. Is the instrument portrayed in the Bosa's design includes a shortened touchpiece so that the right-hand thumb can operate the key for f#/ c#" (B in Fig. 1) as well as an additional key forg#/d#" (C), which appears to have been able to be operated either by the right-hand thumb or the left-hand little instead as thirteen-keyed in is noticeable influence detailed second holes. Figure 3 (see colour section) presents a similar view of the lower joint, showing clearly the extra g#/d#"key, a feature on all of the surviving the four pieces ofwhich it is composed', the clarinet is shown, from left to right, in superior, posterior and lateral views, followed by superior views of the four component more occasion, Figure 2 (see colour section) shows the frontview of this instrument's lower joint, including the maker's stamp between the first and evidence of the Bosa/ Sebastiani collaboration. Figure 1 is from Sebastiani's M?todo. this Sebastiani's M?todo.63 practitioners, in the organological ismanifest On Itwas somewhat surprising to find, inNaples, only one instrument corresponding to that portrayed in di Loreto. to reed-above instruments. offered conservatoires; Maria examined; observations are not possible due to the shortage of time spent with the instruments as well as their current condition. None the less, the following are Poveri di Ges? Cristo, Piet? dei Turchini, San Onofrio a Porta were clarinets in EK two in C, and three each in B^ and A. Table 1 presents a summary of the features of of amalgam of nine total one the Naples Conservatorio.60 Founded in 1925, the collection houses about 140 instruments, mainly and A designs. eleven clarinets, including eight with thirteen keys. Of these instruments, nine survive in the recently collection at reconditioned Museo Storico Musicale of Western-European 211 GennaroBosa 1972), different di San the left, also shown previously, Pietro An Langwill's a (Gianinni, Majella Index ofMusical Wind 1930), pp. Naples, Instrument Makers, p. 16. that a fire in 1976 destroyed part of the Naples collection. Personal 124-6. Conservatorio in The New Di San Langwill Pietro a Majella, Index, W. Waterhouse No. communication. 21. (London, This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 1993), This (Edinburgh, op. cit., p. 26. 62 Sebastiani, op. cit., p. 6. 63 Museo Storico Musicale, Naples, 64 Herbert 'Makers' Heyde, stamps' to corresponds the depiction in Sebastiani's M?todo. The similarity between the length of the touchpieces on the two pp. xiii-xxviii. 212 The Galpin Society Journal boxwood specimens suggests that all three keys can be operated by the left-hand little finger. The middle specimen has a thumb branch on the f#/c#"key, the only Naples instrument with this feature, shown in Figure 7 (see colour section). A change in the design of keywork is evident by comparing the 'saltspoon' pads on Nos. 21 in B^ (Figure 4, see colour section) and 263 inA and 522 in E^ with the remaining clarinets, which seem to be more aware of of the espousal reed-above contemporary this elusive practice. remains whether, within the question context of performing practices of the nineteenth the century, its developments in clarinet manufacture, see Figure 9 (see colour section). The inclusion of this feature contrasts Sebastiani's preference for the use of the f/c" hole. conscious technique is retrospection in conservative merely or whether it permits expressive possibilities which would unavailable. above Such evidence to remind current fetish for standardisation climate of historically-informed Bosa? Or is the variety amongst the Bosa instruments indicative of a similar diversity amongst themaker's client base? eras? instrument, despite it being made from boxwood, lighter than ebony? Does the sophistication of the keywork suggest that this is the latest clarinet by the us, with be reed our located within a performance, of the richness and diversity we seem all too willing to jettison. Indeed, what degree of historical awareness informs our music making ifwe are rigidly selective in our willingness to embrace the techniques of past ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS CONCLUSION the well-documented survival of the Considering reed-above embouchure in Italy into the nineteenth century, the Bosa/Sebastiani relationship provides vital organological evidence. The significance of their collaboration inheres in its position as one of few extant otherwise concerning serves embouchure Is the thumb rest contemporary with the keywork or was it added to help the player in supporting the very embouchure can only fullybe understood through an investigation of the instrument he used, which brings us closer to an understanding, in both theory and practice, of specimens. recently-made was Sebastiani's The A brille on the lower joint of one of the C clarinets provides confirmation of Liberatore's report that Bosa associated with a known virtuoso player. The use of thumb-keys by Italian reed-above virtuosi such as Sebastiani contradicts beliefs that this embouchure was not compatible with such keywork. Indeed, clarinets Italian nineteenth-century Iwish to thank The Galpin Society for the Research Award which enabled me to undertake this research. Thanks also to Tiziana Grande, Mauro Amato, Francesco Melisi, Maestro Vincenzo De Gregorio, AI Rice, William Waterhouse and Colin Lawson. This article isdedicated to thememory of Professor Sir Nicholas Shackleton. BIBLIOGRAPHY Backofen, Johann Georg Heinrich, Anweisung [sic] -Horn (Leipzig, cl803/R1986) _Neue theoretisch prachtische Basset-Horn (Vienna, 1812) zur Klarinette, [sie] Klarinett Baines, Anthony, Woodwind Bassi, Luigi,M?todo per Clarinetto (London, 2/1962) (Milan, cl855) Berr, Fr?d?ric, Trait? Complet de la Clarinette ? quatorze Clefs (Paris, 1836) _M?thode Compl?te de Clarinette Berr, J.Enn?s, Nouvelle M?thode ?ber das auf die in neuerer Zeit beigef?gten Klappen (Frankfurt, 1864-75; rev. edn, Offenbach, Instruments and theHistory ?ber das Basset Schule nebst Einer kurzen Abhandlung _Anweisung zur Klarinette, mit besonderer Hinsicht (Leipzig, 1824) Baermann, Carl, Vollst?ndige Clarinett-Schule... nebst kurzen Abhandlung (Paris, cl836) de Clarinette ? 6 et 13 Clefs (Paris, 1839) This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 1917) Pearson? de Clarinette ? 6 et ? 13 Clefs... (Paris, 1831, 2nd rev. edn, c. 1852) Berr, P[hilippe], Nouvelle M?thode Bimboni, Giovanni, M?todo 213 GennaroBosa e Progressive per Clarinetto Sib, (Florence, cl850) Graduato Blatt, Franz Thadd?us, Methode complete de clarinette pour apprendre et perfection... (Mainz, cl827-28) facilit? Busoni, Ferdinando, Scuola di Perfezionamento per ilClarinetto (Hamburg, 1883) de Clarinette d'apr?s celle Compos?e par Xavier LeF?vre... Buteux, Claude-Fran?ois, M?thode Canti, Antonio, M?todo ? jouer de cet instrument avec con Estensione per Clarinetto limitata per uso di Banda Op. 401 (Milan, cl865) Chirico, Teresa, 'La scuola di m?sica del Real Orfanotrofio Provinciale di Reggio Calabria Italiana XXII (1988), pp. 462-491 musicali napelotane', Nuova Rivista Musicale Joseph, 'Clarinett-Schule', Vollst?ndige Theoretisch-praktische Musikschule Orchester gebr?uchliche wichtigere Instrumente... (Bonn, 1810-11), 2: pp. 7-35 Gandolfi, Riccardo, Appunti Intormo al Clarinetto Compilati di Firenze (Florence, 1887) Giacoma, Carlo Delia, M?todo per Clarinetto Harlow, Martin, 'Two Early Concertos LIX (2006), pp. 29-42 Heyde, Herbert, xxviii for Iwan M?llers El?mentaire pour la Clarinette (London, 1993), pp. xiii Langwill, Lyndesay, An Index ofMusical edn, 1972 Liberatore, Rey Morgan, Research 'The Banda Napolitane Esposti nella Esposti nella Solenne Mostra wind from a musical note 'A preliminary word' pp. palco: (Edinburgh, 1960, rev., enlarged 3rd (Paris, 1802) Napolitane sul ? Anneaux Mobiles... (Naples, 1886) in bands 13/2 (1978), pp. 25-40 _'An historical pp. 247-254 (Paris, 1844) Instrument Makers, delle Manifatture _De'saggi delle Manifatture Longyear, Wind de Clarinette Raffaele, De'saggi (Naples, 1834) (London, cl814) (Paris, cl880) Progressivo per Clarinetto Lef?vre, JeanXavier, M?thode 12/1 (1984), pp. 49-55 pour Servir ? l'Enseignement de la Clarinette _M?thode de Clarinette ? 6 et ? 13 Cl?s... Labanchi, Gaetano, M?todo backwater: Solenne Mostra in The Symphony 1720-1840 Mendel, Hermann in Early Romantic Music', opera', 1830', Music Series A, Vol. VIII ed., Conversationslexikon TheMusical 1834 del 1836 (Naples, 1836) nineteenth-century Naples, del Journal and Man of Band II (1978), (New York, 1980), ix-xx _'Clarinet Sonorities beym Thirteen-Keyed Clarinet', Galpin Society Journal John,A New and Complete Preceptor for the Clarinet Klos?, Hyacinthe Eleonore, M?thode (Paris, 1843) alle (Todi, 1904/R1998) 'Makers' stamps' in TheNew Langwill Index, ed.W. Waterhouse Kastner, Jean-Georges, Methode f?r ad Uso delle Scuole del R.Istituto Musicale Hoeprich, T. Eric, 'Clarinet reed position in the eighteenth century', Early Music Hopkinson, e le istituzioni Instruments recently exhibited at the Royal Russell, Descriptive Catalogue of theMusical 1890 London (London, 1891) Military Exhibition, Day, Charles Fr?hlich, (Paris, 1836) Times 124 (1983), pp. 224-226 (Berlin, 1870-79) This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 214 The Galpin Society Journal M?todo Facilissimo per Imparare a ben Suonare il Clarinetto, (Florence, 1816) Raymond, ? propos du d?veloppement Acta musicologica 42 (1970), pp. 71-72 Meylan, Michaelis, M?ller, de l'instrumentation Intelligenze Necessarie... au d?but du dix-neuvi?me Christian Friedrich, '?ber die Klarinette', Allgemeine musikalische Zeitung 385-391 375, Iwan, Gamme pour laNouvelle Clarinette Invent?e par si?cle', 10 (1808), cols. 369 lui (Bonn, cl812) _M?thodepour laNouvelle Clarinette ? 13 Clefs et Clarinette Alto... _M?thodepour laNouvelle Clarinette ? 13 Clefs (Milan, cl824) Pace, Temistocle, Ancie Battenti Pearson, con Quelle (Paris, cl821) (Florence, 1943) 'The Reed-above Ingrid Elizabeth, 2/2 Saxophone (1999), pp. 8-13 embouchure: Fact or Fallacy?', Australian Clarinet and - ?ber _'Verfolgt von Klang der Klarinette seines Vater Blatt-Position, Ferruccio Busoni und die Klarinette im Italien des 19. Jahrhunderts', Tibia 24 (1999), pp. 605-611 historical in The Early Clarinet: clarinets', (Cambridge, 2000), pp. 41-62 _'Playing A Practical _T8th- and 19th-century Iconographical Representations XXV/1-2 (2000), pp. 87-96 _Clarinet Embouchure in Theory and Practice: thesis, University of Sheffield, 2001 Rendall, Francis Geoffrey, The Clarinet Guide, theForgotten Art ofReed-Above, unpublished Santagata, Ettore, IIMuseo Storico Musicale Schmidl, Carlo, Dizionario Universale dei Musicisti di San Pietro a Majella Schneider, X. and Detouches, Nouvelle M?thode Nicholas J., 'Clarinet, ?11, 4 Rice, 'C?sar (ii): The clarinet (Naples, 1930) (Paris, cl840-45) ofWestern and Musicians art music; the transmission Jean,M?thode Nouvelle _NouvelleMethode de Clarinette of M?ller's 13-keyed The New Langwill Waterhouse, William, Inventors (London, 1993) et Raisonn?e pour la Clarinette enDeux Parties Index: A Dictionary reed', clarinet in France', (Paris, cl785) ofMusical Wind Instrument Makers 11/41 (1829), pp. 35-57 Pamela, Clarinet Virtuosi of thePast (London, 1971) _More Clarinet Virtuosi of thePast and (Paris, cl836) Weber, Gottfried, 'Einiges ?ber Clarinett und Bassetthorn', Caecilia Weston, mouthpiece to theClarinet ed. Colin Lawson Galpin Society Journal LII (1999), pp. 183-194 Vanderhagen, Amand The ed. S. Sadie and J.Tyrrell (2001). in The Cambridge Companion and Janssen of The Thirteen-key (Naples, 1855) ofMusic _'The Development of the Clarinet' (Cambridge, 1995), pp. 16-32 _and Albert PhD (Milan, 1938) de Clarinette per Clarinetto The New Grove Dictionary inArt (London, 1954; rev. 3rd edn by P. Bate, 1971) De La Clarinette {c. 1812) and the Development Clarinet', Galpin Society Journal LVI (2003), pp. 181-184 Shackleton, Lawson of Clarinet Reed Position', Music Rice Albert R., 'M?llers Gamme Sebastiani, Ferdinando, M?todo by Colin (London, 1977) This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions and 112 The Galpin Society Journal INGRID ELIZABETH PEARSON Ferdinando Sebastiani, Gennaro Bosa and theClarinet inNineteenth-Century Naples. Figure 2. Clarinet showing maker's the illustration in Er, no. 21, stamp. This in Sebastiani's lower joint, frontal view to instrument corresponds 1855 tutor. Figure g#/d# " 3. Clarinet key and in Fr, no. 21, shorter lower joint, touchpiece This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions forf#/c# showing " key. extra Colour Section Figure 4. Clarinet note in Er, no. 21, upper joint, frontal view, 'saltspoon'pads. This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions 113 114 The Galpin Society Journal Figure Figure 6 (above). 5. Clarinet stamp L to R, Clarinets in Er, nos. 21, 528 and 527, showing,from left to right, " keysfor e/b',g#/d# andf#/c#". in C, no. 530, on bell. This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions cursive-style 115 Colour Section Figure 8. L to R, Clarinets in C, nos. 530 and 531, comparing lower joint key work. This content downloaded from 216.87.207.2 on Sun, 22 Sep 2013 01:04:06 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions