Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium
Transcription
Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium
Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium Page 1 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Advisory Board Corporate Plans: Bernie Knobbe, Vice President, Global Benefits Corporate Total Rewards, AECOM Cathleen deOrnelas, Financial Benefits Manager, Apple, Inc. Carolyn Wood, Director of Retirement Benefits, Bimbo Bakeries USA, Inc. Kevin McRaith, Manager, Retirement Plans, Cargill Inc. Cindy Cattin, Director, Investment Operations & Risk Management, Exelon Corporation John Casey, Director, Global Financial Strategy and International Benefits, Google, Inc. Pete Apor, Director-Retirement Services, Fujitsu America, Inc. Dale Neibert, Investment Officer & Analyst, H-E-B Brand Savings & Retirement Plan Jim Farrell, Director, Global Benefits & Trustee, Retirement Plan, McKinsey & Company Chad Ryan, Director, Retirement Plans, PepsiCo, Inc Marc Keenan, Director, Pension Benefits & Investments, Pfizer, Inc. Thomas C. Foster, Director Pension & Trust Investments, Pinnacle West Capital Corporation Government Plans: Michael Charette, Senior Investment Officer and Portfolio Manager, Municipal Employees' Retirement System of Michigan Patricia J. Davis, Member Services Bureau Chief, Montana Public Employees Retirement Administration Diane S. Kaiser, Manager, Choice 401(k) Plan, Public Employee Retirement System of Idaho Sponsoring Organizations Aon Hewitt American Century AQR BlackRock Capital Group Franklin Templeton Janus Capital Institutional JP Morgan MSCI Prudential Schroders State Street Global Advisors Voya Investment Management Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design While the structural blueprint for successful participant-funded retirement plans may not be uniform, one fact remains clear: plan sponsors know what the finished product should like look for their participant populations. “Successful retirement outcomes” may not have a one-size-fits-all definition, but the path to that goal looks similar across industries and firm size. Structural plan improvements such as streamlined and diversified menu options, effective communication strategies that not only reach, but educate participants, and basic mechanisms that stimulate participant savings behavior, are a few of the many hallmarks that make sound foundations for positive long term results. By exercising outcome-driven decisions, plan sponsors are demanding higher standards, not only for their plans, but for their participants with whom they partner and share this important responsibility. This year’s Defined Contribution Symposium endeavors to explore the factors defining the end goal of successful participant retirement outcomes—and to purposefully retrace our steps from there to build the best plan possible. Through panel sessions, debates, roundtable discussions, workshops and special guest speakers, we will explore a broad range of topics that DC plan sponsors must concern themselves with in order to successfully set participants on a path towards an attainable, positive result. Throughout the Symposium, we will hear from both providers and plan sponsors in order to obtain a wide range of views, opinions and actionable solutions to share and evaluate experiences, objectives and outcomes. Topics for discussion include: Participant behavior-driven portfolio construction Examining the balance between menu simplification and adequate investment diversification Annuities and retirement income solutions for the participant de-cumulation phase What’s happening in Washington—Upcoming policy implications The resources—human and financial—involved in implementing plan features (auto-enrollment, advisory tools, etc) The limits (or extents) of fiduciary duty Innovative risk management, reducing participant risk exposure Pinning participant health and wellness to retirement outcomes Opportunities in alternatives: private equity, commodities, real estate Leveraging plan resources for maximum affect: scale, partnerships and fees Global differences and lessons learned from non-US retirement markets Page 3 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium Tuesday, September 16, 2014 7:45 am Registration and Continental Breakfast Salon III Foyer 8:25 am Chairman’s Welcome & App Tutorial Salon III App Tutorial: Kip Miller, Director, Institutional Investor Forums Symposium Chairman: Bernie Knobbe, Vice President, Global Benefits Corporate Total Rewards, AECOM 8:30 am Benchmarking Session Salon III Session Moderator: Bernie Knobbe, Vice President, Global Benefits Corporate Total Rewards, AECOM What are the issues, concerns and primary interests of your peers – senior plan sponsors for the larger US plans? In this opening session and in subsequent sessions, attendees will be polled on a number of high-interest topics using an anonymous, interactive electronic response system. By doing this, we will provide all attendees with useful benchmarks and unique insight into the concerns of plan sponsors and their participants. 8:45 am Moderated Group Discussion Pushing the Industry Forward: How Do We Get There From Here? Salon III Moderator: Drew Carrington, Senior Vice President and Head of Defined Contribution – Institutional, Franklin Templeton Investments In a rapid-fire format, select members of the audience will be called upon to provide an update on the one retirement issue they believe to be of critical importance, the one most in need of immediate industry collaboration and problem solving. The catch is that the respondents must also offer their perspectives on how this issue should be addressed—including tangible solutions—for real impact that will lead to a stated positive outcome. 9:15 am Presentation Actionable Steps Toward Participant Financial Wellness Salon III Presented by: Rob Austin, FSA, EA, Director of Retirement Research, Aon Hewitt Alison Borland, Vice President, Retirement Solutions & Strategies, Aon Hewitt How can plans help their participants achieve greater overall financial wellness now, with the long term goal of developing solid foundations for retirement? What are the implications of the seemingly small decisions that participants can make now that will have a long term root impact on their financial futures? Additional topic for discussion: Page 4 The pros and cons of participants staying in plan through retirement Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium 9:45 am Panel Discussion Revision or Reconstruction: Ensuring That Your Investment Menu Matches Your Reality Salon III Moderator: William Ryan, Director, Client Relations Services, University of California Panelists: Toni Brown, CFA, Senior Defined Contribution Specialist, Capital Group John Galateria, Head of North America Institutional, J.P. Morgan Asset Management Brett Hammond, Managing Director and Head of Index Applied Research, MSCI Fredrik Axsater, Senior Managing Director and Global Head of Defined Contribution, State Street Global Advisors Today’s most forward thinking investment menus are more than just investments—they also serve as essential building blocks for a participant’s financial future. Strategically speaking, the core menu can provide both a retirement savings vehicle and an active nudge towards specific participant savings behaviors. While such objectives may be noble, does your plan match either in reality? This session will discuss how to evaluate whether a plan is truly equipped to meet participant needs and in turn, productive steps toward further revision or, where necessary, reconstruction. 10:30 am Coffee Break Salon III Foyer 11:00 am Concurrent Workshop Series I Workshop A Managing Downside Risk in Retirement Miramar I Workshop Leader: Hillary Bolton, Senior Managing Director, Janus Capital Institutional As plan sponsors look to enhance and customize their investment offerings with alternatives, should additional investments be considered among traditional assets? One of the plan participants’ prominent needs is to limit volatility across the investment horizon. While hedge funds, real estate, and private equity have the potential to aide in volatility reduction, there are traditional investment offerings specifically focused on managing volatility that are missing from most asset allocations, yet are deemed to add value. This breakout session will examine the potential impact these long-only managed volatility strategies can have on your participants’ retirement success. Workshop B What Drives Retirement Outcomes for Target Date Investors? Miramar II Workshop Leader: Frank van Etten, Managing Director, Deputy Chief Investment Officer, Multi-Asset Strategies and Solutions, Voya Investment Management This workshop will explore how to define retirement success within the construct of a target date fund, using examples to illustrate the key drivers of that outcome. Key-input variables such as savings rates, market assumptions and labor income assumptions will be Page 5 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium demonstrated in an intuitive way. The session will also demonstrate how plans can model an optimal glide path after modeling the keyinput variables. 11:45 am Concurrent Workshops Series II Workshop C Why Does a Simplified, Diversified Plan Line-Up Matter? Miramar I Workshop Leader: Sri Reddy, Senior Vice President, Head of Full Service Investments, Prudential This workshop session will explore behavioral insights and approaches to simplifying investment plan lineup in today's environment— and why it’s important to do so. Topics for discussion include investor behavioral biases and top concerns, as well as how the industry should proactively address these issues to leverage optimal outcomes. Workshop D The Ins and Outs of Income: A Plan Sponsor’s View Miramar II Workshop Leaders: Stephen Bozeman, Director of CoRI Product Strategy, BlackRock Paul A. Visconti, Manager of Retirement Benefits, Advance Publications The Retirement Crisis has sharpened interest in helping participants understand and build retirement income. While not a panacea, retirement income has been shown to increase retiree confidence and create clarity during the critical pre-retirement phase. This session will explore the ins and outs of income, from efforts to simplify income solutions, to steps that plan sponsors can take to help participants understand how retirement income can help them build better retirements. 12:30 pm Lunch Navio Restaurant 2:00 pm Concurrent Workshops Series III Workshop E Designing a Smoother Ride: Risk-Based Diversification in TDFs Miramar I Workshop Leader: Dan Villalon, CFA, Vice President, U.S. Head of Portfolio Solutions Group, AQR Capital Management Target-date funds (TDFs) have become the preferred long-term investment vehicle for many defined-contribution plan sponsors and their participants. However, we find that these funds generally do not consider short- to medium-term risks on the path to retirement—risks that may impair an investor’s ability to stay invested for the long-term. This workshop session will explore an alternative way to view the riskiness of target-date portfolios and proposes solutions designed to improve both intermediate and longterm outcomes. Workshop F Maximizing the Levers for Participant Success Miramar II Page 6 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium Workshop Leader: Toni Brown, CFA, Senior Defined Contribution Specialist, Capital Group Defined contribution plans have grown more and more complex. Today, it’s easy for plan sponsors to be overwhelmed by all the variables they have to consider — fiduciary responsibility, employee demographics, automatic plan features, market risk, longevity and more. This workshop seeks to simplify matters by narrowing the conversation down to two key levers for enhanced retirement readiness: contributions and investment results. Focusing primarily on the latter, this session will outline action steps that plan sponsors can take to improve participant allocations and get the most from their plan’s target-date option. 2:45 pm Concurrent Workshops Series IV Workshop G Brain Surgery with Stone-Age Tools? Miramar I Workshop Leader: Drew Carrington, Senior Vice President and Head of Defined Contribution – Institutional, Franklin Templeton Investments Congratulations! You have successfully implemented auto-enrollment and aggressive auto-escalation features for your plan, but is it enough to secure your participants’ retirement? What if you were able to help your entire pool of participants accumulate adequate savings at retirement, but a substantial minority ended up scraping by on Social Security in the last years of their lives? Outdated and overly simplistic fixed income investment options fail to adequately provide participants with the information and tools they need to succeed in retirement. This interactive session will: Test whether accumulation-oriented tools are sufficient to ensure retirement security Explore how novel thinking about the existing fixed income toolset can engender opportunity Address how plans can re-orient themselves to deliver robust, lower-risk solutions that can help improve retirement outcomes for your participants. Workshop H Navigating Today’s Landscape for Government Plans Miramar II Workshop Leader: Michael Charette, Senior Investment Officer and Portfolio Manager, Municipal Employees' Retirement System of Michigan In this government plan “potpourri” session, we will explore some of the biggest issues facing public plans. From plan communications and retirement income strategies, to gauging participant retirement readiness, where are government plans focusing their attention and what are the next big steps to improving participant outcomes? 3:30 pm Coffee Break Salon III Foyer 3:55 pm Benchmarking Survey of Plan Sponsors Salon III As a follow-up to our earlier benchmarking sessions, we will use an electronic polling system to anonymously survey attendees as to their perspective and opinions on a range of issues plan sponsors are dealing with, the strategies they are considering, and the areas getting most of their attention. The session leader will offer highlights from the survey to provide a snapshot of the industry at this point in time. Page 7 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium 4:00 pm Presentation Reflections in the Mirror: Participant Perspectives on Saving and Investing for the Future Salon III Presented by: Diane Gallagher, Vice President, DCIO Practice Management, American Century Investments Experience is an important teacher. This session will uncover findings of a national study on attitudes and insights of defined contribution plan participants from early career to pre-retirement. Hear how these respondents feel about what they have done, what they are doing and what they wish they had done to save and invest for the future. In addition, what are some thoughts for plan sponsors moving forward? 4:30 pm Panel Discussion Demanding More From Future Generations of Target Date Funds Salon III Moderator: Brett Hammond, Managing Director and Head of Index Applied Research, MSCI Panelists: Robert Capone, Managing Director, Head of Defined Contribution, AQR Capital Management Frank van Etten, Managing Director, Deputy Chief Investment Officer, Multi-Asset Strategies and Solutions, Voya Investment Management Lesley-Ann Morgan, Head of Global Strategic Solutions, Schroders If the future is Target Date Funds, where are they leading us? The shift from off-the-shelf to customized products is revealing both the demand and motivation for tailored investment solutions that address some of the most vexing participant savings problems. But are— or can—TDFs be all that they’re cracked up to be? This session will take a critical look at where TDFs are headed and provide an objective analysis of how this savings vehicle can better serve a greater number of participants. 5:15 pm Plan Sponsor Case Study Earning Internal “Buy-In” for Plan Overhauls Salon III Cindy Cattin, Director, Investment Operations & Risk Management, Exelon Corporation After completing a merger with Constellation Energy, Excelon Corporation moved forward with a major plan overhaul, one that ultimately aimed to leverage its large scale. The new plan features a streamlined core menu to increase value, diversification and significant fee savings for participants. While the end result has been positive—both from an administrative and participant perspective—making a convincing case for overhaul without a proven track record was in some ways more challenging than the actual implementation. How can plan sponsors win internal “buy-in” when it comes to making significant changes to the plan? 5:30 pm Plan Sponsor Case Study Introducing a DB Investment Philosophy Into Your 401(k) Plan Salon III Dale Neibert, Investment Officer & Analyst, H-E-B Brand Savings & Retirement Plan The H-E-B Brand Savings & Retirement Plan is an actively managed 401(k) plan administered by the Texas based H.E. Butt Grocery Corporation. This unique plan is overseen by an in-house investment team that employs a pension plan philosophy through actively Page 8 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium managed balanced hybrid funds. Notable emphasis is placed on alternatives including various hedge fund strategies, oil and gas, private equity, commodities and real estate. By emphasizing ‘best of class’ investment strategies and capital preservation alongside a low correlation mandate, overall portfolio risk has been kept to a minimum, resulting in long term net positive returns with comparatively low risk exposure. This case study will explore the plan philosophy and discuss steps that sponsors can take to incorporate more “DB characteristics” into their plan administration. 5:45 pm Time At Leisure 6:15 pm Cocktail Reception & Dinner Miramar Please join old friends and colleagues for cocktails and dinner, enjoying views of an expansive and rugged stretch of the Pacific shoreline at sunset. Wednesday, September 17, 2014 7:45 am Breakfast Discussion Groups Boardroom At peer-moderated tables of 8-10 participants, plan sponsors will share their opinions and compare notes on a number of important issues identified by the Advisory Board as worthy of discussion. Plan sponsors will be asked to contribute to the overall discussion with the intention of sharing information and learning from others’ experiences. Participants will have the opportunity to change discussion groups at the 30-minute mark, if they choose. Table 1: Taking a Magnifying Glass to Fees Discussion Leader: Patricia J. Davis, Member Services Bureau Chief, Montana Public Employees Retirement Administration From investment management fees to the oft ignored “fairness” issues surrounding revenue sharing, what are plans doing to keep fees appropriate for the plan and for participants? Plan sponsors play the essential role in critically monitoring fee sources and, where it makes sense, redirecting investment strategies to engage in cost-savings (while maintaining high quality investments for participants). This plan sponsor will share some of the questions her plan is asking and will draw in perspectives from the audience. Table 2: Do We “Get” The Extent of Fiduciary Liability? Discussion Leader: Peter G. Dunphy, Treasurer, Michelin North America, Inc. As a sponsor, do you fully grasp the extent of your fiduciary liability? Not all plans may understand the scope of their liability, from the importance of plan communications to the role of company stock options in the 401k line-up. Where are the biggest pitfalls for plans and how can you go about securing them to strengthen your participants’ futures? Table 3: Is There a Place for Liquid Alternatives? Discussion Leader: James E. Farrell, Director, Global Benefits & Trustee, Retirement Plan, McKinsey & Company This table discussion will explore questions about the role of liquid alternatives in a 401k plan line-up. From fees to daily valuation and immediate liquidity, how do alternative investments compare with actively managed equities or actively managed fixed income options? Is there a place for alternatives in Target Date Funds? Table 4: How Does Your Plan Benchmark Participant “Success?” Discussion Leader: Page 9 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium Colin Orr, Benefits Manager, Genentech What is—or should be—the definition of participant “success?” Is it possible to use actual data measurement or analytics to determine positive participant retirement outcomes? And finally, what is the role of participant feedback in the overall scheme of benchmarking? 8:30 am Presentation Retiring From Work – Participating in Life Salon III Presented by: Hillary Bolton, Senior Managing Director, Janus Capital Institutional Plan sponsors are keenly focused on helping their participants achieve financial security in retirement. Given the low account balances of many current retirees, and considering resource limitations, where should plan sponsors and investment managers focus their efforts? Faced with these constraints, meaningful solutions must meet the varied needs of plan participants including liquidity, capital preservation, and income generation. Innovative solutions should also be easily provided in the construct of a qualified plan. During this session, we will examine how, as an industry, we can continue to partner with plan sponsors in this endeavor. 9:00 am Panel Discussion Translating Retirement Readiness to Retirement Income Salon III Moderator: Steven Olson, Managing Director, Institutional Investor Forums Panelists: Chip Castille, Managing Director, Head of US Retirement Group, BlackRock Sri Reddy, Senior Vice President, Head of Full Service Investments, Prudential Nate Miles, CFA, Vice President and Head of US Defined Contribution, State Street Global Advisors So much focus has been placed on preparing participants for retirement: encouraging increased savings rates, educating around ageappropriate asset allocations and helping participants with the interplay of other benefits like HSAs. But what about what comes after the accumulation phase? This session will focus on what plan sponsors are doing to not only help participants reach an adequate level of retirement readiness, but also to successfully draw down their savings. 9:45 am Concurrent Workshop Series V Workshop I Essentials of Target-Date Design and Analysis Miramar I Workshop Leader: Scott Wittman, CFA, CAIA, Chief Investment Officer, Asset Allocation & Quantitative Equity, American Century Investments As target-date funds play an increasingly central role in plan defaults, selecting an appropriate solution for your participant base is even more important. Investment consideration goes well beyond selecting between "to" versus "through" strategies. In this session, we will explore five key principles for evaluating target-date funds including sequence of returns risk and abandonment risk, as well as how equity allocation is an inadequate proxy for risk. Learn how these elements may help you evaluate suitable solutions to help your participants achieve the highest likelihood of success. Workshop J Page 10 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium Global Lessons For the Accumulation Stage: Managing the Journey—And the Outcome Miramar II Presented by: Johanna Kyrklund, Head of Multi-Asset Investments, Schroders This workshop will outline lessons that DC plans have learned from their DB plans by embracing both greater diversification and dynamism in the management of the default option. Using a case study from the UK as an example, this session will explore how considering the market environment is just as important for DC as it is for DB investors when setting asset allocation (and not to just set-and-glide). 10:30 am Coffee Break Salon III Foyer 10:55 am Benchmarking Survey of Plan Sponsors Salon III As a follow-up to yesterday’s benchmarking sessions, we will use an electronic polling system to anonymously survey attendees as to their perspective and opinions on a range of issues plan sponsors are dealing with, the strategies they are considering, and the areas getting most of their attention. The session leader will offer highlights from the survey to provide a snapshot of the industry at this point in time. 11:00 am Case Study Discussion Achieving Better Outcomes Through Menu Consolidation and Implementation: Applying What We’ve Heard Salon III Panelists: Alison Borland, Vice President, Retirement Solutions & Strategies, Aon Hewitt Cindy Cattin, Director, Investment Operations & Risk Management, Exelon Corporation Fred Reish, Partner, Drinker Biddle John Galateria, Head of North America Institutional, J.P. Morgan Asset Management This case study will discuss the steps plan sponsors can take to create a more effective DC plan that achieves better outcomes for participants. The session will examine Exelon Corporation’s comprehensive redesign of their defined contribution plan. This process consisted of implementing a custom glide path solution and simplifying the core line up, while providing increased levels of diversification, conducting a re-enrollment and harmonizing managers across DB and DC plans. 11:45 am Panel Discussion Putting the Pieces of Participant Education & Financial Wellness Together Salon III Moderator: Bernie Knobbe, Vice President, Global Benefits Corporate Total Rewards, AECOM Panelists: Kim Dwyer, Vice President of Benefit Services, Advocate Health Care Carolyn Wood, Director of Retirement Benefits, Bimbo Bakeries USA, Inc. Page 11 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA Institutional Investor Forums – Defined Contribution Symposium Jon E. Lara, Senior Director, Benefits Finance, DIRECTV Neil F. Krus, Senior Manager, Benefits Retirement Plans, United Airlines With the DC philosophy of “pure financials” behind us, many plan sponsors are engaged in a push towards more holistic approaches to participant engagement and education. How can plan sponsors help their employees connect the dots when it comes to engaging them in the plan, educating them about savings behaviors, or leveraging other benefits like HSAs? Additional topics for discussion include: Implementing comprehensive targeted communications strategies Planning for healthcare expenses in retirement Retirement income illustrations Auto-features that not only engage but encourage quality savings behaviors 12:30 pm Moderated Group Discussion What Is Your Best Takeaway? Moderator: Plan Sponsor to Be Invited Over the past day and a half we have listened to thought leaders, industry experts and our peers. What are some of your best and brightest takeaways gleaned from the Symposium—and some of the challenges you foresee in carrying them forward? 1:00 pm Lunch & Guest Presentation The Biggest Actions in Washington Likely to Affect Your Plans Miramar Presented by: Fred Reish, Partner, Drinker Biddle Looking forward, which near-term Washington policy actions are slated to have the biggest impact on plans and their participants—and why? This session will explore a range of topics from recent legal decisions to anticipated DOL regulation on retirement income projections to how demographic trends like longevity risk will impact plan administration. How should plan sponsors plan and act accordingly? 2:15 pm Program Concludes Page 12 Pursuing Outcome-Driven Approaches to Plan Design September 16-17, 2014 | The Ritz-Carlton | Half Moon Bay, CA