Residence Hall Renewal Plan - University of Wisconsin

Residence Hall Renewal Plan
Introduction
University of Wisconsin-Stout Housing has a renewal plan set in place to renovate student housing
by 2025. The renewal plan started in 2009 and will
be complete by 2025.
In the Residence Hall Renewal Plan booklet that
Scott Giresbach gave to us it states, “ Remodeling
these buildings and replacing outdated windows,
heating systems, mechanical systems, plumbing
and electricity will result in substantial energy savings. In today’s dollars, the department will save
an estimated $127,000 per year when the entire
project is completed, or over $5,000,000 over the
next 40 years”.
Here is a breakdown of the estimated cost per
building and the renewal plan’s project time line:
2011
2012
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
2024
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Wigen Round 1 | $2,120,000
Fleming | $6,370,000
North A/B | $8,820,000
North C | $4,430,000
South A/B | $9,550,000
South C | $4,560,000
Curran-Kranzusch | $9,830,000
Tustison-Oetting | $9,330,000
Antrim-Froggatt | $10,800,000
McCalmont | $6,540,000
Hansen-Keith | $11,390,000
Milnes-Chinnock | $11,030,000
Wigen Round 2 | $6,220,000
Project Time line
Here is our project time line:
2/14 | Present overview of initial plan of attack
2/16-28 | Project work
3/1 | Progress report to class - Stage 1
How does the process currently work?
3/6 | Project work
3/8 | Present possible proposals and plan
3/13-27 | Project work
3/29 | Grogress report to class - Stage 2
How feasible are the proposals?
4/3-10 | Project work
4/12 | Progress report - Stage 3
Update on proposal analysis
4/17 | Project work
4/19 | Hand in draft project report
4/24-5/1 | Project work
5/3 | Project report due
5/8 | Final Presentation to client
Current Conditions
We are looking into
the current conditions
of HKMC. The layout
of the cubes is functional but has room
for possible changes.
11
11
11
132
133
134
135
11
136
11
11
11
137
11
11
138
11
11
11
11
125
124
123
122
129
121
11
128
127
126
120
11
119
11
11
11
11
11
11
11
112
11
111
11
110
11
118
11
117
11
11
11
116
113
114
115
11
11
11
11
-
-
-
109
11
-
80
11
(See Image 1)
11
131
130
81
82
84
11
85
11
86
11
11
83
88
11
89
11
90
11
91
11
87
11
93
94
95
11
11
96
11
108
97
92
11
11
11
11
11
107
11
98
11
99
11
100
We plan on focusing
mainly on the amount
Image 1
of natural light, the
electricity usage, the furniture, materials and finishes, and indoor recycling.
11
106
11
105
101
102
103
104
11
11
11
11
11
In the residence halls, most of the furniture is
residential. (See Image 2) The materials and finishes could be
changed based
on durability and
sustainability,
and the recycling
is located on the
outside of the
building.
Image 2
Through our research on this particular space we
will come up with solutions to create a space that is
comfortable, functional, and overall sustainable for
future residents.
Project Proposal
We are proposing to change the residential furniture
to commercial for a longer, more durable lifespan.
After consulting with Housing’s design team our
findings were the residential
furniture may last 2.5-4 years
where as commercial furniture may last at least 10+
years. We are proposing to
use the KI - Sela collection.
KI has a 10 year warranty on
their furniture. (See Image 3)
Image 3
If the style changes over time we would also like
to propose reupholstering instead of buying new
furniture.
For Lighting we are working with John Paulus for
bench marking for energy use and cost effectiveness. Once data is collected we have a clear view
on which light fixtures will be best.
For materials and finishes we consulted with the
housing design team and found out that they are
staying with broadloom
carpeting (See Image 4)
in the dorm rooms and
putting carpet tile (See
Image 5) in all of the public
areas. For paint we will
like to propose zero VOC
Quality overhead lighting is essential to every office
and industry, but the energy costs and frequent replacement of ordinary fluorescent lights bring down
the bottom line. Our LED replacement for fluorescent tubes lasts three times longer than ordinary
T8 lamps but uses less than half of the energy,
making the move to LED troffer lighting a smart
and sustainable business choice.
•Direct replacement for linear fluorescent lamps
•Uses less than half the energy of traditional fluorescent
•Lasts up to three times as long as ordinary linear
lamps
•Suitable for cold environments
•Easy and safe to upgrade by following installation
instructions carefully
Image 4
Image 5
Paint instead of the regular
commercial paint. It gives
you the opportunity to paint
with people around and it
gives the space a better air
quality.
Summary and Recommendations
Lighting
While researching for this project and coming up
with a solution for lighting replacements, it seemed
that our best choice was to propose LED lighting
throughout the existing space. That would mean
replacing the bulbs that currently exist with Retro
fitted tube lights. As specified below:
Product Specifications for LED Retro Fitted Tube
Light replacements source: (http://www.retrofitledlights.com/led-replacement-for-fluorescent-tubesled-troffer-lighting)
Bring bright, high-efficiency, low-maintenance lighting to all your linear overhead fixtures with our LED
replacement for fluorescent tubes. Each 4-foot
lamp is a direct fit replacement for ordinary fluorescent lamps, providing a quick and easy upgrade to
LED troffer lighting.
Economic, environmental, and social factors and
impacts:
Looking into the overall comparisons of the current
conditions versus the proposed lighting it is concluded that LED is the better choice over time. The
tables below show energy efficiency and energy
costs, environmental impact, general facts, and
light output.
Table 1
Table 2
Table 3
Table 4
Doing basic research like this wasn’t going to
give me all of the answers I needed to make a
conclusion. The next part was basic benchmarking and further calculations. For benchmarking
I went around and counted the interior lighting
of the dorm rooms, hallways, lounge areas, and
stairwells. This led me to do rough calculations on
wattage and Lighting Power Density per space (IES:
Illuminating Engineering Society). Below are the
numbers in a chart form:
Through these findings I was able to look into what
was being used and what is ultimately needed to
update this space to create a better environment
for these students. Using the proposed LED tube
lights as a replacement will create energy and cost
savings.
Further lighting suggestions from Cooper Lighting:
Exterior Lighting
•Rugged die-cast aluminum housing and door in
bronze powder-coat paint
•Captive, single-point
stainless steel hardware closure point
•Impact resistant borosilicate prismatic glass
hinged, removable door
•Highly reflective anodized reflector provides optimized illumination
•Patent pending, energy saving LED technology
with electronic driver
•Ballast/LED driver are secured
to housing for optimal heat sinking
•Options include selectable
housing finishes and dimming
ballast
•Models include up to 400W
metal halide, HPS and compact
fluorescent
•Optional integral egress options
and battery packs available
http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/public/en/lighting/products/outdoor_wall_mount_lighting/_181834.solutions.lighting!led!wall_mount.html
Interior Can Lighting
•Color variation within 3-step MacAdam ellipses
•Two-stage reflector system produces smooth
beam
•Available with narrow beam, medium beam and
wide beam distributions
•Flexible disconnect for easy LED engine replacement and installation
•Remodel plaster ring accommodates up to 1”
ceiling thickness1-1/2” die-cast aluminum collar
accommodates various ceiling materials
•Downlight reflectors are wet
location listed
•Available for new construction, remodel or International
installation
http://www.cooperindustries.
com/content/public/en/lighting/products/recessed_specification_downlighting/_6_
inch/_165890.solutions.lighting!led!recessed.html
Hallway Lighting
•Use FMR with hard-lid ceilings for areas that require a robust fixture
•Prismatic acrylic, polycarbonate or tempered
glass
Image 6
•Use FMR with hard-lid
ceilings for areas that
require a robust fixture
•Prismatic acrylic, polycarbonate or tempered
glass
•LEDs provide energy efficient, high CRI illumination
•Dimmable driver standard
•LEDs mounted to reflector for high efficiency and
protection
•16-gauge housing standard, 14-gauge optional.
12-18-gauge door
•Swing-out brackets or yoke mounting frames available for installation
•Stainless-steel brushed or painted finish optional
•Wet location optional
the lounge room, hallway and the dorm rooms. Carpet tile can also be sent back to the manufactures
to be recycled whereas broadloom has 15-20%
waste during installation and you can’t send it back
to the manufacture. In Dunn County they have a
fee for disposing carpeting. The fees are $55.00/
ton at the Transfer Station or $20/Cubic yard for
small loads. Even though carpet tile is more expensive, you will be saving in installation fees and later
on during the time of disposal. You will also save
money because you don’t have to buy more than
what you need.
http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/public/en/lighting/
products/recessed_linear_lighting/troffer/_135091.solutions.
lighting!led!confinement.html
This will be used in the lounge area. They have
an adhesive called
Tac Tiles that are like
a very strong tape
that is very easy to
install and very easy
to remove the carpet
tile as well. It has 0
calculated VOCs.
Dorm Lighting
•Linear LED suitable for
cove, casework and niche
applications
•May be ordered in 6”
increments up to 72”
•Best-in-class color consistency; three-step McAdam
Binning and 80+ CRI
•50,000 hour rated life;
ambient temperature not to exceed 120°F
•Three mounting options: surface, side surface and
field adjustable
•Three lumen outputs for white light and four color
options available24V driver, fixed and dimmable
outputs in 120V and 277V input supply
•LED Output Power (watts/ft.) - Standard: 1.80;
Mid: 3.96; High: 5.65Anodized-aluminum finish is
standard; custom finishes available
http://www.cooperindustries.com/content/public/en/
lighting/products/indoor_ceiling_wall_mount_lighting/wall_
mount/_283252.solutions.lighting!led!specialty.html
Materials & Finishes
Right now housing is spending $13.50- $17.00 per
square yard for broadloom and $23.75 -$32 per
square yards.
For carpeting we are going with carpet tile for it has
0 waste and very easy to install. It will be used in
The company that we are going with is Interface
FLOR. One of the designs is called A Peeling style
#12645 Color #102778 (Patina). (See Image 6)
Paint can be any
color but it has to
have 0 VOC in it. This is a plus because it can be
used when people are in the building. For Paint we
are going with the brand Scuffmaster, who’s paint
contributes toward
LEED credits and
complies with all
environmental
standards. We are
going to use the
Scrubtough style
which is ideal for
the kitchen area
and dorm rooms
for it repels scuffs
and stains and it
Image 6
can withstand regular cleaning and keeps
walls looking their best. It comes in different colors
to choose from.
We are also going
to use wall tile for a
backsplash in the
kitchen area and in
the bathroom. It is
going to be made
from recycled glass
tiles to give it a cool
effect. (See Image 7)
Lastly the table shows where each piece is manufactured. KI is out of Green Bay Wisconsin. University Housing uses many different residential
brands. This specific brand is Lazyboy and it is
manufactured out of Monroe Michigan.
Image 7
Furniture
The KI commercial furniture the University would
only have to buy one chair over the 10 years due
to the warranty that comes with buying the chair.
There would be a savings of $905.
The Residence Hall furniture currently is residential grade. It is very low grade furniture. In HKMC
the furniture is breaking apart from the amount of
residence using it. (See
Image 8)
The table below show
commercial vs residential furniture. (See table
5) I chose the KI Sela collection to use
in the residence halls. KI has a 10 year
warranty on the Sela collection where
the residential furniture that University
Housing buys does not have any warranty at all.
It also shows the estimated lifespan of
the commercial and residential chairs.
The KI chair has an expected life span
of over 10 years due to the warranty
KI has. The residential furniture at
UW-Stout Housing last anywhere
around 2.5-4 years before they have
to replace it.
Table 6 shows the life span and how much it will
cost over 10 years. This is an estimate of the life
span but it gives a good idea of cost over time. As
you can see University Housing has to buy new
furniture on average every 3 years. This adds up to
a total of $2,188 over 10 years.
Image 8
Furniture Type
Dun County Solid Waste Division has a disposal
cost which is $5 for a standard chair and $8 for a
couch. So to dispose of the four residential chairs
it would cost an extra $20. This would make the
grand total of $925 over the course of 10 years.
Also think about all of those chairs now in the landfill.
Year 1
Life Span
Warranty
Manufactured
Location
Fabric Non Contrast:
$1283
10+ Years
10 Years
Green Bay
Wisconsin
$547
2.5 - 4 Years
No warranty
Monroe
Michigan
Commercial | KI - Sela
Residential
Table 5
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
Year 7
Year 8
Year 9
Year 10
$1,283
$547
Total
$1,283
$547
$547
$547
Savings
$2,188
($905) Table 6
References
Information to come!
Appendices
Date: February 14, 2012
Contacted Scott Griesbach for the first time about
meeting
Date: Tuesday February 21, 2012
Meeting with Scott to introduce the project and ask
questions
Date: March 20th
Meeting with Scott to go over specifics on Interior
portion-parts split up Katey-furniture Allison-lighting
Alysha-Finishes
Date: March 29th 2012
Meeting with John Paulus about lighting for HKMC.
Started benchmarking
Date: April 17, 2012
Meeting with Zenon to go over lighting and construction
More to come! Gathering Information!