March 2014 - Harris County Deputies` Organization
Transcription
March 2014 - Harris County Deputies` Organization
The Harris County Star Official Publication of The Harris County Deputies’ Organization March 2014 www.hcdo.com The Voice of Harris County Law Enforcement Vol. 26, No. 3 New World Trade Center Memorial Gives University Of Houston Special Honor Pipers from the Houston Fire Department and members of Texas Task Force 1, who deployed to New York after the September 11th attacks, were part of the dedication ceremony outside the newly renovated University Center. UH is the first and only university in Texas that has a piece of the World Trade Center on its campus. Harris County Sheriff Adrian Garcia, who was part of the Task Force, says it’s the right place for the 3,888pound steel beam. “We should always work together to ensure that nothing of this magnitude ever happens here again. And for young people who are coming to this institution to build on their education and on their vision for the future, I think this is one of the most appropriate places where such an artifact could be at.” The university applied for a piece of the World Trade Center to the New York and New Jersey Port Authority in 2009. A student brought up the idea to the Student Government Association, which then worked with UH Chancellor Renu Khator on the application. Kenneth Fomunung was the student body president at the time. “That was kind of like the initial seed that we planted and then it would take three administrations of the Student Government Association of the University of Houston to finally see that come to birth.” The beam piece arrived in Houston in the fall of 2011 and was stored in the UH Energy Research Park until a location could be identified. Chancellor Khator says placing the memorial in front of the student center made the most sense. “Because this is the heart of the campus here. More people walk from here than any other part of the campus, and I just hope as they walk from here, they’ll look at this piece and they’ll remember, they’ll grieve, but at the same time they will also double their resolve that they will never, ever allow this kind of act of terrorism to take place in this country.” Jene Malixi, a sports administration major at UH, says 9/11 made a huge impact on him and having the memorial here on campus means a lot. But he says he’s worried about possible vandalism of the dark gray nearly 6foot long beam. “I doubt somebody is going to try and steal it but I’m just worried that somebody is going to spray-paint it and say, that was an inside job or any ridiculous thing like that.” To avoid that eventuality, UH Police will pay extra attention to the area. In addition, cameras around the new University Center should serve as a deterrent for potential vandals. KUHF 5 of 61 nabbed in Harris County prostitution sting had long criminal records Undercover prostitution stings happening across Harris County have netted 61 arrests. The stings took place near Interstate 45 and FM 1960, Aldine Bender Road and U.S. 59, and Interstate 10 at Freeport, according to information from the Harris County Sheriff’s Office. In all, 48 men – including a Precinct 4 constable’s deputy – and nine women were arrested on prostitu- tion charges over the course of eight days. The Harris County Sheriff’s Office released five mugshots of arrested individuals who carried with them extensive criminal records. Some had prior charges of robbery, burglary, drunk driving, prostitution, evading arrest, and indecency with a child in Harris County. There was no word on whether or not they had charges outside of Harris County. Four other people encountered by deputies during the sting were arrested on charges ranging from drug possession to driving without a license, the department reported. “News flash to those who think prostitution is a victimless crime: It’s a greedy industry that thrives on (Continued on page 12) Call Us Anytime... Want to reach this special market of We’re Your Organization! police professionals? ADVERTISE in The Harris County Star Don’t wait….time is money For information on ad rates or deadlines, please call: EXECUTIVE BOARD MEMBERS Robert Goerlitz, President 713-659-0005 [email protected] Eric Batton, Vice President 281-387-9040 [email protected] Stuart Campbell, Secretary/Treasurer 713-444-8178 [email protected] Cathy Hill at 713-659-0005 ext. 1 Or e-mail inquiries or ad copy to [email protected] BOARD MEMBERS Pos. 1 Jeremy Thomas [email protected] Pos. 2 Curtis Brown [email protected] Your Harris County Star Any member of the Harris County Deputies’ Organization is allowed and encouraged to submit articles for publication in this newspaper. Opinions, events, family announcements, war stories...all are welcome and enjoyed by all Deputies. Submissions will only be edited as necessary to protect your organization from legal liability. The Harris County Star is published by the Harris County Deputies’ Organization and is not copyrighted. Other police organizations are encouraged to reprint material which originates with The Star. We require only that you give credit to the author and this paper when reprinting. All articles are subject to review by the editorial committee. Letters and/or guest articles appearing in the editorial section of The Star are the sole opinion of the author, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions or views of the Board of Directors or membership of the Harris County Deputies’ Organization. The Star encourages Organization members and other readers of the publication to submit letters for publication on the editorial page. The HCDO reserves the right to refuse to print any submission not deemed in the best interest of the Organization. Notice: All articles and photos for The Harris County Star must be submitted prior to the 5th of each month preceding deadline. Any articles submitted after this date will appear, space permitting, in the next issue of The Star. Thank you for your cooperation. Articles can be submitted at the HCDO offices or by e-mail. To submit articles directly to the editor, send to: [email protected]. The Harris County Star is administered by Sgt. G.L. “Buddy” Williams, Lone Star Publishing Co. under the direction of the Board of Directors of the Harris County Deputies’ Organization. 281-960-6582 713-826-1831 YOUR REPRESENTATIVES PATROL: Stuart Campbell DIST.2 6A-2P Daniel Wareham DIST.4 10P-6A Frank Garcia DIST. 1 Bryan Cross DIST. 1 10P-6A Sgt. Tim Fite DIST. 1 2P-10P Norman Fitts DIST. 4 10P-6A CONSTABLES: James Grohman PCT. 4 7A-3P Sgt. Matt Walker PCT. 4 10P-6A DETECTIVE BUREAU: Curtis Brown HOMI. 1P-9P David Cuevas I.P.C.: Open positions all shifts COURTS: TRANSPORTATION DIVISION: Brian Merritt 10P-6A 1301 BAKER: Arthur Ramirez 2P-10P Carlos Arguelles 701 2P-10P 701 JAIL: Open positions all shifts CHAPLAINS: Shannon Bowdoin Virginia Howell COMMUNICATIONS: Traci Mullins 6A-2P Rosalyn Wiley Kristin Chambers Elizabeth Barber 2P-10P COMMUNITY SERVICES BUREAU: Open positions all shifts PARKS: 713-744-8178 281-814-3246 713-299-8026 281-830-9162 281-705-5380 281-658-3027 832-868-1714 281-734-4904 713-826-1831 832-250-1716 715-566-5074 832-483-9197 713-545-4341 936-776-6537 281-770-7607 713-816-8508 832-324-4335 281-914-6017 281-796-8926 Open positions all shifts Your Harris County Star Staff YOUR OFFICE STAFF Cathy Hill Publisher………………..Buddy Williams Composition Editor…..Shaun Harpstrite Staff Writer.…………….Stephen Skinner Distribution…………….Garrett Hardin Organization Office: 1314 Texas Ave, Suite 2000, Houston, TX 77002 Main Office: 713-659-0005 Legal Dept.: 713-659-0017 Fax No.: 713-750-0070 The Harris County Deputies’ Organization And We Are YOUR Board www.hcdo.com Page 2 www.hcdo.com The Harris County Star President’s Corner Do you know what your organization officers are doing? Would you like to know with whom they are meeting and the results of those meetings as they happen? Would you like to be on a mailing list to receive regular updates from the organization? If so send Bob an email and he will put you on the list to receive regular updates. His email address is [email protected] by Robert Goerlitz President, HCDO Harris County Law Harris County has always been unique in the application of state law, not only on the criminal side, but also on the civil side of things. Just the mention of such things as probate and other civil matters will make attorneys who work in different jurisdictions across the state cringe when they are told the matter is in Harris County. It is an understatement to say things are done a little differently here than anywhere else in Texas. Walk into the District Attorney’s Intake section to file a charge, and if you don’t have your probable cause already written out, you are looked at like a leper. Let’s look at one particular interpretation of the law that not only affects us but also how we should be doing our jobs in serving the public. Over a year ago, I filed a grievance pertaining to Section 614.023 in that I never received a copy of the signed complaint, as the law states, “shall be GIVEN to the officer or employee within a reasonable time after the complaint is filed.” The law goes on to say no disciplinary action can be taken against an officer or employee unless a copy of the signed complaint is given to the officer or employee. In the hearing we had in front of the Civil Service Commission, I was told the form our department fills out to begin the investigation is now considered the signed complaint. Section 614.023 is a critical law for law enforcement across the state, but it is not followed as stated in Harris County. During this same hearing, I was told an employee can be shown the actual signed complaint but not allowed to retain it or a copy to refer back to in the preparation for the statement they are ORDERED to give or face immediate termination. I was told this was the interpretation by the County Attorney’s Office, and this is how the Sheriff’s Office proceeds with that interpretation of the wording “shall give.” They show it to you and take it back. Since the Sheriff’s Office is following this interpreta- The Harris County Star tion, then we should follow this interpretation in other matters also. In the Code of Criminal Procedure under Title 1, Chapter 5, specifically Sec 5.04, it states peace officers shall advise and GIVE written notice to adult victims of family violence. If we are following the interpretation of the County Attorney’s Office, as they have stated on the record, then we shall follow it in all matters. What do you think would happen if we gave them our statement in the same manner, allowing them to read it but not allowing them to retain it? I doubt they would stand for it, and neither should we. That would go over like a lead balloon. Be very cautious of what paperwork you sign for if and when you get called in to give a statement. One of the boxes asks for you to initial that you have received a copy of the complaint. In my case, I could not initial that box since I was never given a copy of the complaint and initialing that I did would be a lie on an official document. These are the kinds of things we put people in jail for. This “complaint,” that I have yet to see a signed copy of to this day, was found to be inconclusive, but it is still a sticking point in the manner in which the process is clearly flawed and is a flagrant abuse of the few rights we have as employees at the Sheriff’s Office. Field Notes The new policy regarding the retention of our field notes has been a hot topic throughout the troops since it came out. Hearing the concerns from the membership, we set up a meeting with the District Attorney herself to get it straight from the source as to the intent. After that meeting, it was clear our department has made a misinterpretation of the intent of what was asked. The District Attorney’s Office sent out an order to all of the law enforcement entities in Harris County for them to come up with a system with their respective departments to retain any and all field notes taken in criminal matters. The purpose for this was to conform to the state law that allows for the criminal defense representative to ask for those notes in preparation of their defense. After the District Attorney was informed these notes were being made a part of the initial report, she stated that was not the intent. The intent was for them to be available upon request and not given up front. As attachments they are available up front which is a direct contradiction. The field notes are intended to be made available for discovery motions. As this article is being written at the beginning of the month, it is still unknown if the Sheriff’s administration will correct another one of their errors. New Fleet Policy A new fleet policy has been put into effect, and it centers around the monetary costs of damages. This was something we asked for many years ago that has come to fruition. One part that was not included, which we would like to see, would be the mitigating factor of if the employee involved has some type of a “rider” policy to cover the damage. The county is looking at this from a monetary point of view, and I can understand that. Everything revolves around the costs involved. We contend that since the main purpose seems to be the amount of costs the department is at a loss for, then the repayment of that cost should be a factor, as well, if it is covered by a supplemental policy the employee may www.hcdo.com have. Another point to be made with the estimate of these costs is what the actual bill amount is rather than the estimate. In the past, the estimate would be far more than what the actual cost was. For example, I had a person kick out the window of my patrol car many years ago. The estimate given was in the range of $1200, but when I picked up the vehicle, I happened to speak with the glass company who had just finished making the repair. The actual cost was around $250. An estimate is just that, an estimate and not the actual cost. Crime Victims Compensation Many of us don’t realize we can also be victims of crime when those actions result in some type of injury to ourselves. For years, I didn’t realize this, and it wasn’t something that had ever been spoken about much. As an added benefit to the membership, we will now be helping with getting that paperwork filed for those who qualify under this act. I am constantly looking for ways to improve the things we can do for the membership as a whole, and this is just another step that has been long in coming. These are just a few of the things we have been working on during this last month. There is more to come in the next month as we work towards the upcoming legislature next year. HCDO Membership Meetings March 4 and April 1 Page 3 From the Chaplain’s Pen DANIEL: Jurors may donate jury pay to Crime Stoppers Why a Critical Incident Stress Management (CISM) Team? Stafford Police Officer Ann Carrizales took two bullets, including one through her cheek, during a routine traffic stop Oct. 26. The gutsy, courageous former Marine – and mom – nonetheless got back into her cruiser and pursued the suspects for 20 miles until the suspected shooter was arrested. The two other men in the car escaped on foot. Crime Stoppers of Houston offered a $10,000 reward for information about the men. Anonymous tips were called in to Crime Stoppers, and five days after the shooting, the pair that escaped were arrested and charged with aggravated assault on a peace officer. In Crime Stoppers, we have the best crime prevention-anonymous tipster operation in the U.S., and I am proud that the organization is one of eight non-profits to which people who perform jury service may donate their jury pay. During the coming months, I will use these columns to describe the mission and accomplishments of each of these worthy non-profits. Crime Stoppers has helped solve so many crimes since its inception in 1981 that it has become the darling of the local law enforcement officials. Harris County Sheriff Adrian Garcia said, “I cannot say enough how fortunate area law enforcement is to have Houston Crime Stoppers as a key partner in the fight against crime. Its existence has helped us solve many crimes that might have otherwise gone unsolved. Without Houston Crime Stoppers, our job of tracking down persons responsible for crime in our community would be much more difficult than it already is.” Since its launch, tips to Crime Stoppers have led to arrests of about 25,000 people suspected of committing nearly 32,000 crimes. In 2012, arrests based on tips to Crime Stoppers totaled 750. Last year, it was 712, including 16 suspects charged with capital murder and 16 others charged with murder, manslaughter or attempted murder. Rania Mankarious, executive director of Crime Stoppers, said the organization has perfected its system of protecting tipsters’ identities. A police officer answers calls to Crime Stoppers’ number – 713-222-TIPS – and there is no caller ID or tracking. The officer gives a tipster an ID number, and By Chaplain Virginia Howell HCSO Employees are subjected to many events outside of their control, whether it is a traumatic event at work or a crisis in our personal lives. Over time, if we care to admit it, these events can have an impact on us and our families. We can feel dazed and confused by what life throws at us. Sometimes it’s a bit much! Occupations requiring frequent exposure to critical incidents and highly traumatic situations often create a deep level of psychological debt. We rush to someone else’s aid, but who rushes to ours? We constantly serve others but who comes alongside us to prop us up? We tell ourselves we’ll think about it/talk about it with a friend or trusted co-worker, but most often that day never comes. Sometimes, even in careers recognized as dangerous, high risk and stress-filled, many professionals find themselves dismayed, and can use some encouragement to effectively deal with the mental byproduct of their service. As an ex FBI employee said “ we tend to compartmentalize our issues. We have a box over here for family things, another for a traumatic event, another box for interpersonal conflicts, etc. We stuff things down for a long time…The only problem is sometimes our boxes get really full… then what do we do?” We all have times we can be overwhelmed. The HCSO CISM team is made up of fellow law enforcement peers available at all times. Whether it’s a bad accident, a severe illness, a family crisis or an on duty incident, the team stands by willing to provide information, support, or referrals to those impacted by acute trauma or serious loss. Active listening is critical, as well as offering unconditional acceptance and reassurance. Offering this kind of nonjudgmental support during a crisis can help reduce stress and improve coping. The HCSO CISM Team is recognized by the International Critical Incident Stress Foundation and includes Sgt Don Savell, Sgt J. Brook Viningre, and Chaplain Virginia Howell. Several other peers, a professional counselor, and law enforcement chaplains also cooperate in lending a hand. We stand ready to provide emergency assistance to all employees of HCSO whenever it is deemed necessary. iWatchHarrisCounty App users send more than 60 to jail with 50 Tips With over 50 tips, users of the iWatchHarrisCounty mobile app have led HCSO investigators to the arrest of more than 60 suspects since its launch in September 2011. The latest tip was cleared on Friday, January 10, 2014, in the 3200 block of Candlepine Dr. in north Harris County and resulted in the arrest of a family of five. The arrests bring to 65 the total number of arrests made thanks to iWatch tips since September 2011 when the free mobile phone app was launched by Sheriff Adrian Garcia. In April 2013 an iWatch tip led deputies to a drug seizure worth over $2 million and the arrest of two individuals at two marijuana growth houses in northwest Harris County. In July 2013 an iWatch tip led Page 4 deputies to a 4-acres marijuana field in south Harris County. About 1,500 tips are received per year through iWatchHarrisCounty from the more than 12,000 current users. Twenty-three percent of those tips are drug related. The rest are about suspicious persons/activity and quality of life complaints such as loud music, etc. In October of last year, the HCSO partnered with the Houston Independent School District to extend iWatchHarrisCounty to allow students, parents, and teachers to report crimes in and around their campuses via the app directly to the HISD Police Department. Similar partnerships are in the works with various other area school districts. Bellaire Examiner www.hcdo.com Crime Stoppers and police never learn their names – even after arrests are made. If Crime Stoppers’ board authorizes a reward payment, tipsters are given another number and the address of a bank, Mankarious said. They go through the drive-through and provide a teller with their ID numbers. They are then paid in cash. Rewards can be for as much as $5,000 except for tips that lead to the arrests of suspects charged with wounding or killing law enforcement officers. Rewards then may rise to $10,000. (The 100 Club helps boost the rewards in cases of fallen officers. It so happens that The 100 Club, which provides financial help to the families of fallen law enforcement officers and firefighters, is one of the eight nonprofits to which people may donate jury pay.) Crime Stoppers has paid nearly 21,000 tipsters more than $10.4 million in rewards since 1981. State District Judge Katherine Cabaniss, former executive director of Crime Stoppers, said, “It was a privilege to lead Crime Stoppers, the most productive organization of its kind in the country. The tip line is effective, and it keeps people safe where they live, work, and play.” Mankarious said Crime Stoppers shouldn’t win plaudits solely because it helps solve crimes. The public needs to know, she said, that tipster lines are cost-effective crime fighting tools. “It costs law enforcement about $1,500 to solve a crime based on a Crime Stoppers’ tip,” she said. “It costs them $30,000 to $90,000 to solve other crimes. We help save tax dollars.” Crime Stoppers’ free app can be found on Google apps. Tipsters can text in a tip or send photos or video. Crime Stoppers has broadened its mission to include crime prevention. More than one million area middle and high school students have gone through the group’s Safe School Program, learning how to handle issues of bullying and guns on campus and how to rely on Crime Stoppers’ tip line to anonymously report suspected criminal activity. As a result, authorities have confiscated more than 200 guns in schools since Crime Stoppers launched the the program in 1997. (Continued on page 6) The Harris County The Helfman Family Of Fine Automobiles WE SALUTE TEXAS PEACE OFFICERS Capt. Alan Helfman River Oaks Chrysler Jeep Dodge 713-524-3801 The Helfman Family Of Fine Automobiles WE SALUTE TEXAS PEACE OFFICERS Harris County Sheriff’s Mounted Patrol delivers rodeo invitation to capitol HOCKLEY, TX – For the past 65 years, the Governor and Lieutenant Governor of Texas get invited to the Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo. No, not by phone, and not in an email. In true Texas fashion, the Harris County Sheriff’s Mounted Patrol delivers the invitation personally on a pony express style ride from Houston to Austin. Forty horses and riders participated on this 112-mile ride, and this year Seargent Chris Adolph was the first. They headed out of Hockley at 8 a.m. and arrived at their destination around 5 p.m. Eleven different governors have received this invitation over 65 years, but that’s about all that’s changed. This year’s invitation goes to of course Governor Rick Perry and Lieutenant Governor David Dewhurst. But both will surely be dawning their ten gallon hats for the Houston livestock show and rodeo that starts March 4th and runs through the 23rd. Giddy-up y’all! NewsFix.com Steven Wolf, Helfman Dodge Chrysler Jeep 713-533-6100 The Helfman Family Of Fine Automobiles WE SALUTE TEXAS PEACE OFFICERS Jeff Smith Helfman Ford 281-240-3673 The Harris County Star www.hcdo.com Page 5 Dispatchers: Unsung heroes and a 'lifeline' for LEOs There is a special connection between police dispatchers and police officers By Karen L. Bune, PoliceOne.com Those who work in the public safety and law enforcement realm are committed, dedicated and usually passionate about what they do. They work in a reality-based environment comprised of situations and events that most in the civilian world have never been exposed to. There is a special connection between police dispatchers and police officers. Strong bonds evolve from partnerships and the allegiance that develops as a result of the interconnected working relationships. The radio is a cop’s steadfast companion. It is a vital connection to the dispatcher who plays a critical role in keeping the officers on the street safe. Dispatchers can provide the necessary information to all units and to those responding to the scene of a specific call and incident. Dispatcher’s Ear The dispatcher’s job is highly stressful. Dispatchers have to possess keen listening skills and be excellent communicators. They must have a “dispatcher’s ear” — listening to what is going on in the background. Moreover, dispatchers must be able to do several things at once. Due to the stressful nature of the job, dispatchers must possess effective coping skills to be able to handle the pressure. Dispatchers have a close link to police officers and often they feel responsible for them. Padty MayhewDavis has served as a dispatcher for 15 years and is a Communications Training Officer for the Alexandria (Va.) Police Department. She always wanted to be a cop but due to a knee injury was unable to pursue that career path. She became a dispatcher instead. “This is one way I can still help people,” Mayhew said. She recognizes the importance of maintaining her emotional equilibrium while working. “You can’t let your emotions affect or cloud what you’re doing in your job because it could impede the outcome to citizens or officers,” Mayhew said. Mayhew is known to be very concerned about all the officers she works with. If an officer is injured on duty during her shift, she remains on high alert. Page 6 “I deal with the situation until it is over,” she said. After the incident is over, Mayhew insists she must talk to the officers involved. “I have to know for myself they are OK. I get teased for being over-protective,” she said. Mayhew has frequently been out on the street. “I used to do a lot of ridealongs, and I loved it. You get to see what they (the officers) are doing,” she said. Keeping Officers Safe Jill Price, currently a Communications Facility Coordinator for the Department of Public Works in Milwaukee and a former Telecommunications Specialist and Dispatcher for the Milwaukee Police Department, agrees with Mayhew. Her motivation was fueled by knowing that her actions assisted in keeping officers safe, and she liked helping them. “I was able to provide the resources. I was a lifeline for the officers on the street,” she said. “Some officers don’t realize how important they are to dispatchers. It is a big deal to us,” said Celeste Anne Smelser Baldino, a supervisor in Public Safety Communications for the UVAAlbemarle County Emergency Communications Center in Charlottesville, VA. She serves as a working supervisor and rotates through all the posts within the center. Stacy Starkloff, a police dispatcher for the Baltimore, MD 911 Center, recalled a time when an officer did not answer the radio, and his car was abandoned. No one knew where he was, and the helicopter was dispatched to search for him. “It was really scary for a while — not knowing where he was at,” Starkloff said. It was subsequently discovered that he experienced a medical emergency and was in the back of an ambulance being treated. Starkloff acknowledged that dispatchers hear a lot of things that would be difficult for most to hear. “You have to have a backbone,” she said. Michael Slater, a State Police Dispatcher II and Supervisor of the Dispatch Center for the Massachusetts State Police, has been a dispatcher for 30 years. Well versed in his specialty, he is keenly attuned to the challenges law enforcement officers face daily. When he was a line dispatcher from 1986-1999, he particularly enjoyed the (Continued on page 12) Melissa Martin Exclusive Allstate Agent and wife of a former Harris County Sheriff Deputy, L. B. Martin - 20 years of service Allstate Financial and Allstate Benefits are available by Payroll deduction or Bank draft and include the following products. LIFE INSURANCE DENTAL & VISION CANCER CRITICAL ILLNESS HOSPITAL INDEMNITY HEART AND STROKE ANNUITY, 401K ROLLOVERS HOME , CONDO, RENTERS, AUTO, BOAT, MOTORCYLCLE MORTGAGE INSURANCE Allstate Exclusive Agent Melissa Martin 832-497-5479 Allstate Benefits Specialist Gwen Taylor 281-217-3298 Allstate Financial/Life Specialist Gary McGuire 713-539-2409 Crime Stoppers (Continued from page 4) Crime Stoppers’ Safe Community Program and its Mothers Against Crime program focus on ways to prevent crime in communities. Still, Crime Stoppers remains best known for its tip line – and with good reason: The results just keep coming. In part based on a Crime Stoppers’ tip, www.hcdo.com a woman was charged Feb. 6 as the driver who hit and killed Chelsea Norman, 24, as she was bicycling home on Waugh Dec. 1. Harris County District Clerk Chris Daniel staffs 76 courts with clerks, maintains records for these courts and oversees jury service. Friendswood Journal The Harris County Star Highlands: 500 Citizens seek Crime answers, Sheriff questioned After experiencing a high number of murders in this community last year, the citizens of Highlands decided that something more had to be done to put a stop to the killings. Five killings have happened since last January 2013, and two remain unsolved. As a first step, they asked their local law enforcement officers to meet with the public, and this forum, organized by Highlands resident Mike James, was the result. James is deeply involved because one of the victims of murder this year was his father. Otis James was murdered in his house on 4th Street, allegedly by a neighbor, Randy Segura, who has been charged with the crime. Otis James pickup truck was stolen after the murder. The meeting, billed as a “Crime Watch” session, was held at the First Baptist Church on Magnolia Street. The sanctuary of the church was filled to capacity, with at least 500 persons in attendance. Also attending were Sheriff Adrian Garcia, and from his staff Major Stephen Marino and Capt. Joel Inocencio. Pct. 3 Constable Ken Jones was present, and from his staff were Chief Deputy David Franklin, and Capt. Jasen Rabalais. Throughout the audience were other officers, including Capt. John Moore and Lt. T. J. Gainey. The evening started with welcoming remarks from pastor Tim Edwards, and then moderator Mike James introduced the speakers from the Sheriff’s office and the Constable’s office. He also asked that everyone present sign registration cards, so that they could be included in future meetings and crime fighting actions. Sheriff Garcia spoke first, and outlined the history of his governance of the department since 2009. He mentioned budgets and staffing, pointing out that until 2011 the county had a hiring freeze, and he lost many deputies. Now he is able to hire, and has added over 100 deputies through cadet classes and transferring jailers to patrol and other duties. Also he said there are over 83 new deputies in training at the present time. In response to questions and criticisms about the effectiveness of his department, he pointed out that due to a large number of calls for service, the HCSO must prioritize incoming calls, and answer the most serious and life threatening calls first. He suggested that many burglary calls and similar The Harris County Star crimes could be reported online on the website, without the need for an onsite deputy’s call. The Sheriff also pointed out that he has a youth program, the Explorers, that is introducing young boys and girls age 14 to 21 to the procedures of a sheriff’s department. The goal is to help them avoid criminal activities, and to hire some of them as deputies in the future. Constable Jones reported that his department, in conjunction with the Sheriff’s office, had formed a “Task Force” to proactively respond and investigate crimes. It is staffed by 3 constables and 8 sheriff’s deputies, he said. In Highlands alone, he pointed out that in the last 45 days they have made 18 felony arrests, suggesting that this would seriously reduce the incident of crime. He suggested the importance of the public informing authorities through tips, including using Facebook. At this point, the floor was opened for questions or comments from the public. Several persons asked how to set up a Crime Watch program. It was noted that this meeting was promoted as a learning session for this purpose, but instead it consisted mainly of comments from both sides of the crime subject. However, the authorities offered to help set up small Crime Watch groups in any neighborhood that was interested, and said that the Constable’s office, through Lt. T.J. Gainey, would come out to instruct citizens on the process. A question was whether Highlands could get a sheriff’s substation back, as it had several years ago. The Sheriff was somewhat evasive on the answer, noting legal problems that no one seemed to want to resolve. However, a location in Woodforest Bank was mentioned. The Sheriff said one of the benefits of a storefront would be a visible sign on Main Street, as a deterrent to criminals. A citizen complained about a recent burglary, where the two juveniles had been identified, but not prosecuted. Deputy Rabalais stated that Texas law made it more difficult to prosecute juveniles than adults, and that the district attorney’s office sometimes advised against it. Pastor Phillip Morris said that the power of prayer would help the crime situation in the community, and urged the community to embrace that idea. His church, Restoration Church on Jones Road, will hold prayer sessions with that goal. The question was asked how many deputies are staffed to watch the Highlands area. Captain Inocencio explained that this is District 3, Section B (not A or C), and that it covers Highl a n ds , C r os b y, B a yt o wn , a nd Lynchburg. For those areas, there are usually 2 to 4 patrol deputies assigned at any one time. However, there are other Sheriff’s specialized deputies working the area at the same time, including task force, crime control unit, high risk officers, undercover, and others. Major Marino added that 5 new deputies are being added to those assigned to this area. Also, a helicopter has just become available, he said. Capt. Rabalais said that since February of last year, his Task Force has made 300 arrests. Speakers from the audience, and from the platform, differed on the facts on whether crime was down, or increased. Jones and Garcia argued that a large number of arrests are being made, indicating effective policing. Citizens, including Jutta Mayfield of Pig Supply, differed vehemently. She noted that her business had been burglarized 3 times in the last year, with- out arrests. Carl Cooper and Calvin Hobbs complained about known drug activities and derelict houses occupied by non-tenants, in the Clear Lake and San Jacinto Street neighborhoods, and no police action on these. The Sheriff said “tell us the details and we will act,” so these two cited addresses of the problem houses. It has been announced by Mike James that there will be a follow-up meeting scheduled in the near future, to further deal with these problems but also to help neighbors set up the Crime Watch programs near them. It was noted that Crosby’s Newport subdivision would also be having a crime watch meeting in the near future. This meeting will introduce the use of Nextdoor.com, a social networking program on the internet, as a means to implement neighborhood crime watch programs in an effective method. See the article above on this page. Interviews in the days after the meeting with Highlands residents indicated to the Star-Courier that they were not satisfied with the results of this meeting, believing that authorities did not listen and did not have the motivation to act to reduce crime. Highlands Star-Courier ATTENTION HCDO MEMBERS: WE NEED YOUR STORIES! We want to hear from you. The Harris County Star is setting aside pages for you to let us know what is going on in your workplace. We will be looking for someone from every district, every jail, and each Constable Precinct, along with Baytown and the Port, to write a few lines. You can let us know about major arrests, benefits for fellow officers or send out an "Atta -Boy" for one of your fellow deputies or supervisors. Just make sure we hear from you. Send your articles to [email protected] or you can contact HCDO office at 713-659-0005 ext. 1 www.hcdo.com Page 7 National News Beat Dorner, one year later: 7 lessons learned from a murderer The next Chris Dorner may already be out there plotting — what are you doing to prepare? By Lt. Dan Marcou, PoliceOne.com It’s been a year since Christopher Dorner killed two police officers and wounded three more. He also deliberately ambushed and killed the beloved daughter of a retired police captain, whose only offense was to serve as counsel to Dorner. Hard lessons can be (and should be) learned from this terrible tragedy. 1.) Your Potential Adversaries Are Training Hard and Often — Are You? Dorner had been highly trained in the use of firearms and tactics during his service in the United States Navy, as well as during his brief tenure on the Los Angeles Police Department. He arrogantly predicted success in his impending killing spree when he wrote, “I know your TTP’s (Tactics, techniques and procedures.).” Too many police officers are satisfied to train at entry level and then only follow up on that training when their department pays them to do so. Your goal at training should not be to qualify on the range, but to prepare to prevail in the real world against threats like Christopher Dorner. Make an investment in your personal survival. Supplement your departmental training by training on your own dime and on your own time. 2.) There is a Need for Courageous Supervision A field training officer told Dorner in advance that he would be receiving a substandard performance evaluation from the FTO. The evaluation identified areas he needed to improve upon. Instead of look ing toward self improvement, Dorner filed a retaliatory complaint against his field training officer. The investigation triggered by Dorner’s complaint revealed he had lied about his field training officer in the complaint, and this lie ultimately resulted in Dorner’s termination. The investigation after Dorner’s appeal on Page 8 his termination sustained his firing. An independent investigation after Dorner’s killing spree reaffirmed Dorner’s firing. Using 20/20 hindsight, a reasonable person would have to conclude that Dorner’s killing spree sustained the concerns of the field training officer. The majority of officers in this profession honor the badge they are wearing. There are a few who possess a flawed character, and yet they manage to successfully navigate through a maze of background checks and written, physical, and psychological tests to infiltrate the profession of law enforcement. The Dorner case shows that every member of this profession needs to be vigilant of those within our ranks who would dishonor law enforcement. All officers need to be aggressive caretakers of our shared professional honor. All must have the courage and perseverance to come forward and identify those among us that are unworthy of the badge they are wearing, as did Dorner’s courageous field training officer. Proceed with caution in doing this, however, for as we saw in the case of Dorner, there exist a very few among us who are wolves in sheepdogs’ clothing. 3.) Hate + Lack of Empathy = Dangerous Mass killers often have something in common. They possess an unreasonable hate coupled with a lack of empathy, which allows them to kill in large numbers. Hate is the motive in many a homicide and suicide. Learn to recognize unreasonable hate as the major danger sign that it is, and use extreme caution during any investigation of someone who possesses such a hatred of a person or persons. 4.) Train for the Ambush Most officers train for an anticipated confrontation 180 degrees to their front. Few mentally and physically prepare for the unexpected ambush from the 360-degree world. Christopher Dorner demonstrated that the tactic of choice of the criminal who sets out to kill police officers will probably be the ambush. Here are few general guidelines for ambush survival: 1.) Strive to constantly scan and process. 2.) Always be aware of the cover availability in the environment you inhabit. 3.) Wear your vest no matter your assignment. 4.) Train your sudden movement skills. Have the ability to move laterally, forward, backward, up and down quickly. Movement makes you a harder target to hit. 5.) Train in quickly exiting your squad. 6.) Train in exiting kill zones with your squad. 7.) Train in quickly accessing and firing all weapons systems. 8.) Train in self-treating wounds, and carry a treatment option with you at all times. 9.) Train in officer and citizen rescues as well as emergency care. 10.) Physically train. Strive to be in better condition when you retire than when you were hired. 11.) Believe that an ambush can happen to you. 12.) I say it again: believe that an ambush can happen to you! 5.) Look for and Believe “The Manifesto” When you are in the evidencegathering mode, remember to look for the written evidence of homicidal intent. Even though that writing may take a variety of forms, it often is documented by those who intend to kill in a rambling “manifesto.” This was true in the case of Christopher Dorner. In Dorner’s manifesto, he not only explained why he intended on killing black, white, Asian and Hispanic police officers, he also took the time to give a shout-out to Charlie Sheen. He actually wrote, “Charlie Sheen. You’re effin awesome.” Manifestos have become a common road map through the twisted minds of mass killers. Remember, however, a map is more effective when utilized before the journey starts, rather than at its end. Lives can be saved by finding the manifesto before the event and, when you do, by proceeding as if you believe it. 6.) Have a Tactical Option for the www.hcdo.com Barricaded Gunman Every officer in the nation should have the capability of calling out a fully equipped tactical team, including negotiators, to deal with the barricaded gunman. 7.) Prepare, Prepare, Prepare! Abraham Lincoln once said, “Give me six hours to chop a tree and I will spend the first four sharpening the axe.” Are you sharp enough to face the likes of a Christopher Dorner? Prepare, prepare, prepare! It's Now A Federal Crime For You to Attend a Dog Fight By Dain Fitzgerald, Politix.Topix.com In news that's slipped beneath the radar but deserving of praise, it is now illegal to attend a dog fight, cock fight, or any other cruel pitting of beast against beast in the United States. It was of course already against the law to host such "games." Opposing Views reports on one important component of the recently passed federal farm bill: President Obama signed the Farm Bill into law, [which] includes a provision making it a federal crime to attend or bring a child under the age of 16 to any animal fighting event. U.S. Sen. Maria Cantwell (DWash.) is credited with successfully working to pass this important legislation. It will also now be a federal crime to be a spectator at an animal-fighting event. "Cantwell's legislation will fortify the federal law and help law enforcement, quash illegal dog fighting and cockfighting, and forbid adults from bringing children to these spectacles of violence," said Mark Makarian of the Humane Society. "The spectator admission fees and gambling dollars finance these criminal operations and make dog fighting and cockfighting profitable." Cantwell's been honored by the Humane Society before. In 2012 she received the organization's "Legislative Leader" award for her work in helping to protect endangered apes. (Continued on page 9) The Harris County Star National News (Continued from page 8) "We thank Sen. Cantwell for her outstanding work to ensure that our federal laws reflect the core humane values and attitudes of American society," said Makarian at the time. Brotherly bond united deputies in Dorner manhunt Ryan and Alex Collins are brothers and San Bernardino County sheriff's deputies; Alex was wounded by Dorner By Tami Abdollah, Associated Press Alex Collins. Photo courtesy San Bernardino Co. Sheriff's Department SAN BERNARDINO, Calif. — Det. Alex Collins was speeding down a mountain road, closing in on ex-copturned-killer Christopher Dorner and his phone was buzzing. In rapid succession, his two brothers — also San Bernardino County sheriff's deputies — called to warn the baby of the family to be careful. Dorner, a former Los Angeles policeman, vowed to kill as many officers as possible to avenge his firing from the department. A few nights earlier, the brothers discussed Dorner's chilling online manifesto and the risk of encountering him. "We had no delusions," Sgt. Ryan Collins said. "It was not going to end well for whatever deputy it was who found him." When Ryan heard a dispatch last Feb. 12 that officers had been shot, he frantically tried calling Alex again and again. The phone was dead. For the swarms of police who hunted Dorner last year, the manhunt was more than just a matter of public safety — it was personal; he was targeting their brethren. For the Collins brothers, however, it was even more The Harris County Star so. Dorner, 33, was wanted in the Feb. 3 murder of the daughter of a retired Los Angeles Police Department captain and her fiance in Orange County. Dorner said the former captain had poorly represented him before the discipline board that recommended his firing. In a rambling rant on Facebook, Dorner, who was black, also complained about racism at the LAPD, and vowed to unleash "unconventional and asymmetrical warfare" against those who wronged him and their families. On Feb. 7, he opened fire on an LAPD cruiser, grazing an officer sent to guard one of his targets. Later, he ambushed a Riverside patrol car, killing one officer and seriously wounding another, police said. Then, he disappeared. Ryan Collins, now 39, had briefed officers in Big Bear Lake, in the snowy San Bernardino Mountains east of Los Angeles, to be on the lookout for Dorner. It seemed trouble elsewhere had a way of rippling into the ski resort town. Sure enough, hours later Collins went to investigate a report of a car fire, and discovered Dorner's smoldering pickup. Collins said he and another deputy eyed each other, faces white as ghosts. Dorner was on their mountain. "We knew there was probably a good chance we were in somebody's crosshairs," he said. As Ryan helped coordinate the manhunt, Det. Matt Collins, now 37, hiked through a snowstorm with other SWAT members to search hundreds of cabins looking for footsteps or anything suspicious. Their little brother, Alex, joined in the search, too, coming back early from leave after his wife, Lila, gave birth to their first child, Benjamin, some three weeks earlier. Everyone figured it was only a matter of time before Dorner emerged. The call came after noon on the sixth day of the mountain search: "We've been tied up by Dorner," a woman told the 911 dispatcher. "He's taken off with our Nissan Rogue." Karen Reynolds and her husband Jim had gone to check on the condo they rent to guests and were surprised by the hulking Dorner who bound, blindfolded and gagged them. Alex Collins and his partner Det. Jeremy King followed a hunch he would take the back road off the mountain. As they sped there, they got word that Dorner had carjacked a white pickup, had shot at game wardens and was headed down a side road near boarded-up summer cabins. Matt was racing to the scene a few minutes behind Alex while Ryan helped the Reynoldses. Both brothers called Alex, knowing he was nearest to Dorner. Be careful. Don't go in alone. Wait for us, for SWAT, to get there. "But that's Alex," Matt said, his voice choked with emotion as he relived the conversation for the first time. "He's a go-getter." Dorner had ditched the pickup down an embankment behind some bushes and had broken into a nearby cabin. His tire tracks seemed to just disappear into the snow. Alex, armed with a rifle, began sidestepping along the road, thinking it was impossible for a truck to just vanish. Tink. Tink. Tink. The sound of a silenced high-power rifle was followed by a burning wallop as a bullet entered his left nostril, pierced the roof of his mouth, split his tongue and burst through his jaw. Shots to his chest and forearm knocked the rifle from his hands. His leg was hit. Bullets skipped along the road as he ducked behind an SUV's rear wheel. He was showered by glass as the back windows were blown out. Starting to choke on blood and teeth and in terrible pain, he tried to call his wife to say he loved her and was sorry; he didn't think he'd be coming home. He reached in his chest pocket and found his phone shattered by a bullet. He tossed it in disgust. He thought he was going to die. "OK, God, I'm ready," he thought as he closed his eyes. He remembered from the police academy that he needed to muster the will to survive. It was up to him. Minutes later, Det. Jeremiah MacKay was fatally shot nearby. "Two deputies down," the radio blared. "Automatic fire inbound ... deputies still down in the kill zone." Matt Collins was drawn into the chaotic firefight when he arrived. He could see deputies on the ground a couple dozen yards away, but couldn't tell if one was his brother. He had a bad feeling and tried to call Alex. It went straight to voicemail. Ryan Collins heard the dispatch, and he started calling Alex. He called at least 10 times. As Ryan sped to the firefight, he got a call from Matt. "Is it Alex?" Ryan asked. "I don't know, I don't know, but I don't see him down here," Matt said. Under a smoke screen as officers fired at the cabin, two SWAT officers dragged MacKay and Alex to safety. King, who'd taken cover nearby to return fire, told Ryan by phone that his brother was shot, but that Alex had given the thumbs-up sign as he was carried away. Alex, now 27, spent a month in the hospital, returning for roughly 20 surgeries, including multiple bone grafts. He'd regain color, become more mobile, then undergo another surgery and (Continued on page 10) 249 COLLISION COLLISION IS OUR SPECIALTY Paint & Bodywork Lifetime Warranty SON TRAN 6615 Breen Houston, TX 77086 (281)448-1010 (281)448-5777 (fax) www.hcdo.com www.249collision.com Page 9 Snapshots National News (Continued from page 9) A snap-shot is a unique phenomenon. It freezes in time what people see at the moment. Sometimes snapshots capture good things, good deeds, or excellent leadership. Sometimes snapshots capture ugliness, retaliation, and bad management. These are the snapshots our members reported to us this month. Snapshot #1 It took the administration a year to decide where to move all their captains, and boy did they screw that up. They told Captain Warren, a man who has spent nearly his entire career in Patrol and Traffic, he was returning to Traffic. No problem, he would have been an excellent choice there. But at the last minute they realized he is 66 years old and sent him to IPC instead, a place he has never worked. Some folks think the administration is trying to force him into retirement. That tactic worked on Sergeant Gorby recently. He retired rather than transfer to District 3. That tactic works on some people, too, but it did not work on Captain Wrobleski or Radabaugh. Then they sent Captain Coons to District 1. It looks like they are done punishing him for reporting his subordinate’s misconduct to IAD. And they sent Captain Ricks to Traffic. Never mind he has never worked in Traffic. Captain Coleman, who has worked Traffic, went to District 4. The question of the day is whether retaliatory transfers violate the Sheriff’s own ethics rule. We believe it does: “I will never act officiously or permit personal feelings, prejudices, animosities or friendships to influence my decisions.” This obviously does not apply to non-civil service administrators. We welcome and will print their response. Snapshot #2 Thinking about promoting? Take a good look at snap-shot #1 and see if you really want to be treated like a chess pawn. Snapshot #3 Kudos to the Sheriff for using seizure funds for new-hire training. Reopening our own training would be better, but this is better than nothing. Snapshot #4 Lesson of the month: “While it seems that change is slowly beginning to occur, undoubtedly, it will not come soon enough for some. Until that day, Transgendered prisoners’ position behind bars, underneath the weight of so much oppression, makes their everyday survival of a series of heroic acts, a heroism that defines the transgender movement.” (Source: LGBTI mandatory HCSO training) “Heroism?” Really? No murder charge for man who fatally shot Texas deputy Deputy was shot after entering a home with other officers looking for guns and marijuana By Nomaan Merchant, Associated Press DALLAS — A Central Texas man who shot and killed a sheriff's deputy entering his home will not be charged with capital murder, attorneys said. A local grand jury declined to indict Henry Goedrich Magee for the Dec. 19 death of Burleson County Sgt. Adam Sowders, who was part of a Page 10 group of investigators executing a search warrant for Magee's rural home. Sowders and other officers entered the home about 90 miles northwest of Houston without knocking just before 6 a.m. Authorities were looking for guns and marijuana. Magee's attorney, Dick DeGuerin, said his client thought he was being burglarized, reached for a gun and opened fire. (Continued on page 15) be back in a wheelchair, sallow with dark circles around his eyes. Several months after the shooting, Alex took his wife and infant son to the evergreen forest where he was shot and where Dorner killed himself as the cabin burned to the ground. It wasn't an emotional visit. He wasn't ready to relive the experience. He pointed to where he lay on the road, the place where he had tried to call home as he thought he wouldn't make it. The destroyed phone, doctors told him, had saved his life. He returned to full duty eight months after the shooting. Today, he has an almost indiscernible limp, a slight heaviness to his speech when he pronounces a hard "T'' sound, a dimple-like scar near his nose, and scars on his chest, forearm and leg. Alex and his brothers still talk daily and have dinner together with their parents every Sunday. They don't discuss the shootout, but each says it's always in the back of their minds. "I couldn't even imagine if something happened to them," Alex said. "And for them, they've been kind of looking out for me my entire life. And they still do." TSA rejects arming officers after LAX shooting The head of the TSA said his agency has officially rejected arming officers in response to a November attack at LAX LOS ANGELES — The head of the Transportation Security Administration said his agency has officially rejected arming officers in response to a November attack at Los Angeles International Airport. John Pistole made the comments after a news conference to announce the opening of a "pre-check" application site for expedited screening at LAX. TSA union officials have called for creating armed officers from the agency to ensure safety at screening checkpoints. But Pistole said virtually every issue is on the table except for arming officers. Introducing more guns is not the solution, he said. J. David Cox Sr., national president of the American Federation of Government Employees representing 45,000 TSA employees, expressed disappointment, calling Pistole's statement www.hcdo.com premature given ongoing investigations. The agency is conducting a review of the shooting that left one officer dead. Authorities say Paul Ciancia opened fire with an assault rifle in an attack targeting the TSA that also wounded two officers and a passenger. The TSA review is separate from an ongoing investigation into the shooting. Pistole said the agency's review will focus on changes to improve communication between the TSA and local law enforcement. It will also look at the response time of airport police, the placement and effectiveness of panic alarms, and whether there are good communication protocols and equipment in place for emergencies. The Associated Press has reported that as terrified travelers dived for cover, TSA officers — who are unarmed — fled the screening area without hitting a panic button or using a landline to call for help. Meanwhile, the two armed airport police officers assigned to protect the terminal had left for breaks minutes before the gunfire and so were unaware of the shooting. It took a call from an airline contractor to a police dispatcher, who then alerted officers over the radio, nearly a minute and a half after the shooting first started. Pistole praised the swift police response, which he said came within two minutes of the radio call to officers. Police officers then took the shooter into custody within 2 1/2 minutes, he said. Pistole also said he wanted to "make sure that the police are actively engaged in terms of patrols, that they are a visible show at and around checkpoints." No final decisions have been made on how working with LAX police may be changed, he said. LAX Executive Director Gina Marie Lindsey said there have been some adjustments to the airport's security, but she would not comment further on officer deployment. More than 30 groups, including law enforcement, airlines and airport operators, have met twice since the shooting to discuss and provide recommendations, Pistole said. The review will be submitted to Congress within 90 days. It's unclear if it will be made public. Associated Press The Harris County Star Researchers want ER docs to focus more on "excessive" force claims By Force Science Institute A newly published study that calls for ER doctors to give more attention to complaints from injured suspects about “excessive force” and “police brutality” has been published in a prominent medical journal. The authors, citing concerns by the ACLU and the World Health Organization about unnecessarily violent police behavior, argue that prisoners’ injuries should be analyzed along guidelines similar to those used to assess child abuse and domestic violence, in an effort to identify cases of unwarranted use of force. Critics with a law enforcement perspective, however, warn that what seems like a reasonable and impartial improvement in reporting protocol may, in fact, lead to inappropriate judgment calls that will harm officers and their agencies. Authors of the study are Jared Strote, MD, associate professor in the Division of Emergency Medicine at the University of Washington Medical School; Erik Verzemnieks, MD, with the Emergency Medicine Dept. at Johns Hopkins University Medical School; and Mimi Walsh, PhD, a strategic advisor in the Office of the Chief of Staff of the Seattle PD. Their study, “Emergency Department Documentation of Alleged Excessive Use of Force,” with Strote as the lead researcher, appears in the American Journal of Forensic Medicine & Pathology. An abstract is accessible free by clicking here. If you’re interested in the full study, it can be downloaded for a fee there as well. Training Vacuum Strote, with various support teams, has argued for years that ER physicians should play a more aggressive role in pursuing and documenting allegations of police abuse. His studies and editorials in medical journals have been reported since 2009 by Force Science News — along with sometimes fervent criticism of his research methods and conclusions by use-offorce and emergency-care experts. Strote points out that while “patients’ complaints of excessive use of force by police occur frequently in emergency departments,” little if any education or guidance is given to ER physicians on how to document these allegations. This, despite the fact that doctors receive “extensive instruction” related to evaluating and reporting “other forms of potential abuse or as- The Harris County Star sault,” such as child abuse, elder abuse, and domestic violence. To determine a sampling of current ER documentation of police-related injuries, Strote and his team analyzed a year’s worth of excessive force complaints made to emergency personnel at the public hospital serving police cases in one major U.S. city, Seattle. Complainant Pool Searching 12 months of police and medical records, the researchers identified 187 individuals who were brought to or came to an emergency department within 24 hours after a force encounter with Seattle cops. After eliminating those who were unable or unwilling to provide a “history” of their injuries and those who had only “psychiatric or nontraumatic medical complaints,” 135 injured suspects were left. The researchers then scoured police and medical records for one or more of the following cues in these patients’ descriptions of their force encounters: “ ‘assaulted,’ ‘beaten,’ ‘excessive force,’ ‘police brutality,’ an intent to pursue legal action, a complaint that the force used was inappropriate for the patient’s behavior, or reference to an action that is clearly not within common use-of-force guidelines (e.g., ‘strangulation’).” In all, the team found a “patient complaint of inappropriate force” recorded in only 13 medical charts, roughly 10 percent of the final pool of subjects. Devil in the Details The researchers found that important specifics were often missing in the physicians’ documentation of the suspects’ complaints, while certain components that the team thought “should be absent” were not. “Notably,” Strote writes, “no charts discussed” whether the doctor’s physical findings were consistent with the subject’s version of events. Nearly 40 percent failed to give a “complete description” of how the injury occurred, and more than 20 percent did not even give a “complete description of the injury” itself. True to the doctor stereotype, over 1 in 5 written descriptions was not entirely legible. In reviewing police records, the researchers found 11 more subjects who had complained of inappropriate force but did not surface at all from medical records. These subjects evidently either failed to beef about their treatment in the ER, or attending doctors failed to record it. By contrast, certain elements that the researchers considered nonos were rife in the complainants’ charts. In more than half, Strote reports, “subjective terminology (e.g., ‘drunk’ rather than ‘altered’)” was used. Nearly 40 percent of the attending physicians assigned “guilt” to the complaining patient, and nearly 54 percent accepted the “police description [of events] as fact” in their documentation. Physicians, Strote writes, “cannot and should not assign guilt or innocence [to] the alleged offender.” Yet “[p]atients brought in after law enforcement encounters are often altered and frequently disruptive” and doctors may “show intentional or unintentional bias against this population.” In s um m ar y, Strote writes , “documentation for patients complaining of EUOF [excessive use of force] did not meet standards for other forms of alleged or suspected assault or abuse.” Yet ER reports “may be the only objective evidence available in alleged EUOF incidents...if a formal complaint is later filed.” He acknowledges that “legally defined excessive force is rare,” but it “clearly does occur, and patients with complaints...have been shown to have injuries consistent with their complaints....” However, there currently are “no legal or professional guidelines on how to document complaints of EUOF in the emergency department.” Corrective Suggestions “Many authors have argued that www.hcdo.com incarcerated patients com prise a...vulnerable population” similar to abused and/or assaulted children, spouses, and elders, for whom “emergency physicians [can] play a critically important role,” Strote writes. “[S]imple educational interventions can dramatically improve documentation in such cases,” he believes, citing “a notable absence” of instruction on “care for prisoners” in current medical education. He believes “it may be useful to develop documentation guidelines similar to those for other alleged abuse presentations.” These would include “complete and objective” descriptions of injuries, “use [of] the patient’s own words,” and an identification of “potential inconsistencies.” Drafting these guidelines, he advises, “should be undertaken jointly by emergency medicine and law enforcement professional organizations to ensure consistent documentation that objectively and accurately describes histories and physical findings while not assigning guilt or innocence or other subjective judgments to either patients or police officers.” Police Concerns Although Strote insists that better documentation will help to “protect” both the police and injured suspects, some law enforcement sources express concern about where his crusade may be headed. Thorough description of a subject’s injuries and an accurate recording of his or her story may be a desirable goal, these sources say, but their concern is that in time this focus will morph into conclusions by physicians that injuries they see equate with evidence of inappropriate force. “Things will be far worse if the rhetoric about better documentation transitions to a hospital or legal mandate requiring medical personnel to report suspected excessive use of force, as has been the case with child abuse, elder abuse, and domestic violence,” attorney Michael Brave, a UOF instructor and litigator, told Force Science News. “LEO force simply is not the same as child abuse or domestic assault, where injuries are not expected and may in fact be revealing in and of themselves. LEOs are entitled to use force within appropriately applied legal standards. This includes a sniper bullet to the (Continued on page 12) Page 11 Excessive Force (Continued from page 11) Dispatchers (Continued from page 6) interaction with the troopers on the road. On the day of the Boston Marathon bombings, Slater was getting ready to leave for the day at the end of his shift. When the incident broke, he rapidly engaged. There was a call-out for explosive and bomb detection duties by K-9, the Feds came in from Rhode Island, and the Boston Police, the State Police and the FBI set up a joint command post at Logan Airport where dispatchers were also needed. All these efforts had to be coordinated through his communications center. “I had dispatchers everywhere. The whole week seemed like one long day,” Slater said. Lasting Impact Heather Hanson — a Communications Technician I for the Tampa Police Department — has worked there since 2009. She has also served as a trainer at the dispatch academy. In 2010 when two Tampa police officers were killed in the line of duty, she worked at the command post, obtaining tips from callers. Page 12 “It made me feel good to do something connected to it — to feel we were helping. It was crucial, I think,” Hanson said. She explained it was the first time that she had a genuine understanding of the thin blue line. “It just blew my mind. Something changed in me,” Hanson said. The lasting impact on her was so profound that she is now making a career transition. She has converted from a fulltime dispatcher to part-time to allow her the opportunity to go through the police academy to become a Tampa police officer. Many dispatchers associate with colleagues in the field during their off time and, consequently develop solid friendships with police officers. The camaraderie solidifies both the professional as well as the personal relationships they share. Dispatchers recognize their crucial role in serving as the lifeline for officer safety specifically, as well as public safety generally. In their joint endeavors, dispatchers and law enforcement officers serve as unsung heroes in the public safety arena. eye. When weapons are used, they almost always cause injury whether misused or not. And ER doctors are rarely if ever present at the application of force to see the context in which it is provoked. “When a medical doctor reports an alleged EUOF, it often has an undeserved aura of authority. Since the doctor has a medical degree, some people, including some prosecutors, judges, and juries take the doctor’s statement as authoritative fact when, in reality, it should not carry that weight. “I have deposed several ER docs in the past couple of years who put a statement of excessive force in the medical records, prompting litigation to commence, in part, based on that conclusion. At deposition so far, every such doctor has completely backed off of their statements. Part of the fun is asking them to define EUOF. Another fun part is asking them to relate the ‘facts’ of the incident.” Dr. David McArdle, a SWAT doc and emergency department physician in Colorado, told Force Science News: “There has been a great deal of discussion in our specialty concerning complaints from patients about possible misconduct by the police. However, emergency physicians do not know the circumstances surrounding the use of force sufficiently to label any injury as due to excessive force. “In the heat of a trauma resuscitation, it has been shown that many physicians cannot even correctly identify a gunshot exit wound from an entrance wound. Much better forensic training is needed.” (Although McArdle is chairman of the Physicians Section of the International Assn. of Chiefs of Police, he made clear that he was expressing his personal views and not speaking as a representative of the IACP or its Physicians Section.) FSI’s Position At the Force Science Institute, executive director Dr. Bill Lewinski says: “We encourage doctors to be thorough in documenting UOF injuries. But their scrutiny should not extend to forming judgments about whether the force used by police was excessive. “In officer-involved shootings where an offender is killed, we advise coroners and medical examiner, ‘Don’t take the body off the table.’ That means report what you find at autopsy but don’t try to reconstruct what happened to determine whether the shooting was justified. The same applies when an arrestee is being treated in the ER.” As a small but telling example of how things can be distorted in the “minefield” of medical interpretation, Lewinski notes Strote’s characterizing a suspect’s report of “strangulation” as something “clearly not within common use-of-force guidelines.” Lewinski says: “What the patient describes as ‘strangulation’ may in fact have been an entirely proper application of LVNR [lateral vascular neck restraint], which can be a trained and legitimate use of force not at all outside of proper guidelines. “Documentation of injuries, if it’s accurate, objective, and thorough, may in the long run help an officer by supporting his account of resistance,” Lewinski says. “But doctors need to resist stepping out of their domain of expertise to pass judgment on an encounter they know nothing about firsthand.” Interesting Factoid In their study, the Strote group cites a United States DOJ special report from 2005 that found that among those who experience force in police encounters, “83 percent consider it excessive.” Prostitution Sting (Continued from page 1) forced labor, drug addiction and sometimes even illegal imprisonment,” Sheriff Adrian Garcia said in a prepared statement. “Many of the reformed prostitutes who came through the Harris County Jail tell us that working the streets led them to using illegal drugs; others tell us they used illegal drugs and turned to prostitution to fi- www.hcdo.com nance their illicit addictions. “So stopping prostitution stops other crimes and emancipates victims. It also fights back against sex slavery and other forms of human trafficking.” The identities of the 61 suspect arrested are not available at this time. Houston Chronicle The Harris County Star Pay the IRS first! Dear Dave, My husband has his own business installing windows. As a result, we now have IRS and state tax debt. We’re managing the payments, but where should these debts be placed in the debt snowball plan? Olivia Dear Olivia, I don’t usually cheat on the smallest to largest progression of the debt snowball, but I’d recommend moving these debts to the top of the list. Both state and federal taxes come with ridiculous penalties and interest rates, and the authorities at either level have virtually unlimited power at their disposal to screw with your life if something bad happens. The IRS can actually take your money without suing you. So, you don’t want to become a blip on their radar screen by being late with payments. Get it cleaned up as quickly as possible, Olivia. You don’t want to mess around with these guys! —Dave Check on the checking account Dear Dave, My husband died eight years ago, and I never closed his bank accounts that were opened when we lived in another state. We lived in Florida before moving to Oregon. I didn’t probate the estate, and he did not have a will. I’m trying to work with the banks to get this settled, but they’re giving me the runaround. Do you have any advice? Melinda Dear Melinda, The first thing you need to do is contact an attorney who handles estate planning. If the accounts were opened in Florida, but you both lived in Oregon at the time of his death, technically the estate would be probated in Oregon. That may be what has to happen. If so, a judge would appoint you as executor. As executor, you can close the accounts and disperse any money to the rightful heir—which is you. Be prepared, though. It may take somewhere between $250 and $500 in attorney fees and court costs to make this happen. If you’re lucky, you might The Harris County Star get a simple motion from the court that would cost you next to nothing. But find a good estate planning attorney who knows Oregon law inside and out. Estate laws and probate laws differ from state to state, and Florida and Oregon both have some weird laws in these areas. This probably seems like a lot of trouble, but you have to remember the banks are simply trying to protect themselves and follow the law. Anyone could walk in with a death certificate (they’re public record), and claim to be an heir. So, they have to have a court document in order to avoid any potential liability. I’m sorry for your loss, Melinda. I know it still hurts after all this time, but you need to address this as soon as possible. I’m sure it’s what your husband would have wanted. —Dave Protect yourself Dear Dave, I’ve heard you say to never give collectors access to your checking account. Does that include payments with a debit card too? Susan Dear Susan, Absolutely! If you’re doing something like scheduling utility payments to come through your debit card or out of your personal checking account, that’s perfectly fine. But collectors are looking to get as much as they can on a bad, late debt. Never, under any circumstances, give them electronic access to your account. I’ve been doing financial counseling for a long time now, and I’ve seen numerous situations where collectors have taken more than the agreed-upon amount from someone’s account once they gained access. This sleazy move left people without the money to pay their rent, the electric bill or even groceries. In fairness, the collection business does have a few good people in it, but it also has a high percentage of people who are scum—especially on the credit card side of collections. Some of them will lie and even make threats. It’s a huge problem. There are other, much safer ways to handle these kinds of situations. Send a money order overnight or wire the cash to them. You can also send a cashier’s check. Some folks have even used a pre-paid debit card that isn’t attached to any of your accounts. This isn’t my favorite way to handle things, but it’s better than giving them the opportunity to clean you out and mess you over! —Dave Diversification and risk Dear Dave, I’m a little worried about investing in the market due to volatility. Are there safer investments? Matt Dear Matt, You’re right; the market is volatile. It’s not a volatile as some things, but you have to remember that anywhere there’s money to be made—including long-term investing—there are ups and downs. For instance, I like real estate. It’s not as volatile as the stock market, but there are no guarantees. We experienced that big dip over the last few years, and it was probably one of largest dips ever in the real estate market, except for the Great Depression. Aside from real estate, I also like mutual funds. When it comes to these, one way to smooth out the volatility of the market is through diversification. That means you spread your money around instead of investing in one or two things. That’s how I handle my mutual funds, and I recommend others do the same. Spread your investments across these four types of mutual funds: growth, growth and income, aggressive growth and international. I can’t say it enough, Matt. There are no guarantees when it comes to long-term investing. But diversification can help make the ride a little bit smoother! —Dave What's so special about $1 million? Dear Dave, I’ve heard you say many times you shouldn’t buy a brand-new car unless you have a net worth of $1 million. What’s so special about a million dollars? Angela Dear Angela, In all honesty, there’s nothing par- www.hcdo.com ticularly special about a million dollars. A brand-new car will lose about 60 percent of its value in the first four years. So, if you’re going to turn a $30,000 investment into $12,000, you’ve got to have a bunch of money. You’ve got to be in pretty great financial shape in order to absorb the blow. If your entire net worth is $100,000, and you put $30,000 of it into a vehicle that will lose 60 percent of its value, you’re just being financially and mathematically stupid. Your income is your largest and most powerful wealthbuilding tool. If you’re buying things that go the wrong way in terms of value, you’re not gaining wealth; you’re losing wealth. There’s really nothing special about $1 million. I could have said $2 million or $900,000, but $1 million is easy to remember. Plus, it’s nothing to sneeze at in terms of an individual’s net worth. When you lose a lot, and it’s a small percentage of a lot, you don’t have to worry so much. But when you lose a lot and you didn’t have much to begin with, that’s a recipe for financial disaster! —Dave Do fewer dumb things Dear Dave, My parents co-signed on government loans so I could go to college. Would my forbearance or non-payment affect their credit if I don’t pay? Tiffany Dear Tiffany, Yes, it would. I’m not trying to lay a guilt trip on you, kiddo, but you’ll be trashing your mom and dad’s credit if you don’t pay the bills on time. If they co-signed for you, they’ll start getting phone calls, too, if you don’t do the right thing and pay back these loans. The truth is, your mom and dad shouldn’t have co-signed for you in the first place. There’s only one reason lenders want a co-signer, and that’s because they’re afraid the person taking out the loan won’t be able to pay back what’s owed. My goal here isn’t to beat you up, Tiffany. It’s to give you information that you—and your parents—need in order to make different, smarter decisions in the future. We all do dumb things sometimes. In the past, I did some (Continued on page 15) Page 13 TRAINING Harris County Sheriff’s Academy The Harris County Sheriff's Academy is certified by the Texas Commission on Law Enforcement Standards and Education and abides by its rules. Training certificates are provided to all students who satisfactorily complete Academy courses, and all training is reported to TCLEOSE. Certain courses require prerequisites (as indicated in the course descriptions) which must be met prior to acceptance for admission. The Academy charges a nominal fee for individuals sponsored by agencies not funded by Harris County: Basic Law Enforcement - $550.00 Advanced Training Classes - $1.00 per contact hour with a minimum charge of $10.00 per course The fee must be paid on the first day of class by cash, cashiers check, agency check or money order made payable to "HARRIS COUNTY". We cannot accept personal checks. Some courses taught by outside vendors require an additional fee. This fee applies to all students, and should be paid according to the instructions listed in the course description. Available February Classes as of February 15, 2013. Please check Academy website for updates: Expandable Baton Re-Certification (2 hours / 9 a.m. – 11 a.m.) – Thursday, March 6, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. NCIC/TCIC For Less Than Full Access Operators (8 hours) – Friday, March 7, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Integrity Centered Leadership (20 Page 14 Hours) – Monday – Wednesday, March 10-12, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Turbo-Charge Your Time for Increased Productivity & Satisfaction (8 hours) – Tuesday, March 11, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Animal Law 101-From Pit Bulls to Rabies (8 hours) – Tuesday, March 11, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Sexual Assault Family Violence Instructor’s Course (SAFVIC) (24 hours) – Tuesday – Thursday, March 11-13, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Public Speaking for the FaintHearted (8 hours) – Wednesday, March 12, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Cultural Diversity (8 hours) – Thursday, March 13, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Crisis Intervention Update (8 hours) – Tuesday, March 18, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Law Enforcement & the Occult (24 hours) – Wednesday – Friday, March 19- 21, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Basic Sign Language (40 hours) – Monday – Friday, March 24-28, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. 2105-Investigation of Child Abuse (24 hours) – Tuesday – Thursday, March 25-27, 2014. Class hours 8 hrs and less will be $10.00 and classes above 8 hrs will be $1.00 added to the $10.00 example 16 hour course is $16.00. We except cash or agency check to pay for the class. Police Search & Recovery Diver Course / Certification (44 hours) - Monday – Friday, May 12-16, 2014. This is a TCOLE recognized certification course for Underwater Recovery – Persons. The course is 44 hours. The classroom portion is the first two days and will be held at the Harris County Sheriff’s Academy. Days 3 thru 5 are held off-site. The off-site location will be given to the students during the classroom portion. Location: 2316 Atascocita Rd. Cost: $65 if funded by Harris County; $109 all others Course requirements: The student must hold a nationally recognized diver certification, advanced diver or higher level (NAUI, YMCA, PADI, SSI, or NASDS). A dive Logbook must be provided showing minimum of 25 open water dives, 12 of which were made in the last 12 months (minimum of 5 of the 25 dives in low visibility water or at night). A current Physical Exam for Diving from a Medical Doctor within past 12 months. The student must be Commissioned Peace Officer (Regular or Reserve) sponsored by a Law Enforcement Agency (EMT’s and/or firefighting personnel also will be accepted with a letter on department letterhead from their supervisor authorizing their participation). Students not holding a peace officer commission must have set of finger prints on file and clear criminal history (CCH). Preferred but not required registered CPR and Multimedia First Aid Technician. Need Extra Cash? HCDO members can earn big commissions by selling or referring advertisers to the Harris County Star. Any business that wants to have Harris County Deputies as customers would love to advertise in The Star so it is as easy as asking them. You can earn hundreds of dollars a month, every month, and help your union out at the same time. Call us for more information or visit the HCDO website at www.hcdo.com The Harris County Star Phone: 713-659-0005 Fax: 713-750-0070 www.hcdo.com The Harris County Star Dave Says What to do if you are involved in a shooting or any other critical incident 1. Call for medical assistance for yourself, other deputies/officers, other citizens and even the suspect if necessary. 2. Call the H.C.D.O. Emergency Assistance number, 713-659-0017 ext. 2. Stay on the line and you will be connected directly to an attorney. 3. Speak to NO ONE until the attorney arrives at the scene, usually only 20-30 minutes. 4. Relax, you joined the H.C.D.O. You’re in great hands and you are protected by a force of thousands. 5. The H.C.D.O. attorney(s) will assist our members in giving any statements and in preparation for any “walk through” at the scene. 6. The attorneys will accompany the member to the appropriate investigating agency where a sworn affidavit will be prepared pertaining to the events giving rise to the shooting. 7. The H.C.D.O. attorney(s) will accompany the member at their Grand Jury appearance. Murder Charge (Continued from page 10) DeGuerin has acknowledged his client had a small number of marijuana plants and seedlings, as well as guns he owned legally. The grand jury did indict Magee for possession of marijuana while in possession of a deadly weapon, a third-degree felony. "This was a terrible tragedy that a deputy sheriff was killed, but Hank Magee believed that he and his pregnant girlfriend were being robbed," DeGuerin said in an interview. "He did what a lot of people would have done," DeGuerin added. "He defended himself and his girlfriend and his home." The longtime defense attorney said he could not immediately remember another example of a Texas grand jury declining to indict a defendant in the death of a law enforcement officer. Julie Renken, the district attorney The Harris County Star (Continued from page 13) really dumb things with very large numbers attached. The goal is to grow, learn, and try to use what we learn in order to do fewer dumb things in the future. —Dave Where to save? Dear Dave, I’m 26, and I just started a new job making $50,000. I’ve also been offered a 401(k) with no match. Should I put money into the 401(k) or open a highyield CD? Crystal Dear Crystal, I’ve got another idea. I’d open a Roth IRA with good growth stock mutual funds inside and fund it up to $5,500 a year. Make sure these mutual funds have been open at least five years—preferably 10 years or more— and have performed well. Mathematically, this investment, growing tax-free, will be superior to a non-matching 401 (k). Then, if you want to invest more than $5,500, you could put some additional money into the 401(k) offered by your company. Again, make sure you’re invested in good growth stock mutual funds with long, successful track records. Congratulations, Crystal. And good luck! —Dave Getting them to stop for Burleson County, said in a statement she thought the sheriff's office acted correctly during events that "occurred in a matter of seconds amongst chaos." "I believe the evidence also shows that an announcement was made," Renken said. "However, there is not enough evidence that Mr. Magee knew that day that Peace Officers were entering his home." Magee is still in custody in neighboring Washington County, but should be soon released on bond since he only faces a marijuana possession charge, DeGuerin said. Renken said her office would "fully prosecute" that case. The 31-year-old Sowders was a native of Somerville who had recently been promoted to a sergeantinvestigator position. Dear Dave, How can I get credit card companies to stop sending us preapproved offers? My wife continues to sign up for these, and now we have $40,000 in credit card debt. Dan Dear Dan, Chances are you’ll never get credit card companies to stop sending stuff, but there a few things you can do that might help slow things down. Access your credit bureau report, and opt out of marketing offers. You can also freeze your credit report, and send direct requests to the credit card companies to take you off their mailing lists. I’ve been telling people not to use credit cards for 20 years and, believe it or not, even I get offers in the mail. The more mailing lists you get on, the more your mailbox will fill up with junk mail. If you have magazine subscrip- www.hcdo.com tions and things like that, your contact information is circulating all over the place. The next thing I’m going to say may sound cruel, but I really don’t mean it that way. You don’t have a junk mail problem, Dan. You have a relationship problem. You two are not on the same page about money. Either she doesn’t feel like you two have enough money, and she’s resorting to credit cards for this reason, or she does this because she’s a spoiled brat who thinks she should always have what she wants when she wants it. Her behavior is destroying your financial lives and driving a wedge between you. My advice would be to sit down and have a gentle, loving talk with her about all this. Try to find out why she feels the need to have all these credit cards, and explain that you’re worried about what it’s doing to your marriage and your finances. That may mean having to spend some time with a marriage counselor, but that’s okay, too. There’s no reason to be ashamed of something like that. The truth is, most of us who have been married more than 20 minutes could use a little help in that area of our lives! —Dave Balance transfers don't do much Dear Dave, I’m trying to pay off my credit card and get out of debt. Do you think I should transfer the balance to one with a lower interest rate while I do this? Kelsey Dear Kelsey, I’m not against this idea, as long as you understand that you’re not really accomplishing much. All you’re doing is moving money around, and maybe saving a tiny bit on interest. If you were planning on keeping the debt around for 30 years it would become a big deal. But if you’re talking about a few months, just until you get it paid off, it’s not that much money. The problem with balance transfers is that you feel like you took a big step forward when you really didn’t. Lots of times this causes people to lose focus on other things they can do to get out of debt, like picking up an extra job or selling a bunch a crap they don’t want or need. That kind of stuff, along with living on rice and beans and a strict written budget, is 98 percent of the battle when it comes to getting out of debt! —Dave Page 15 River Oaks Chrysler Jeep Dodge Call Capt. Alan Helfman 713-524-3801 Captain Alan Helfman Page 16 www.riveroakscars.com www.hcdo.com The Harris County Star