caper 08-09 - City of Salinas
Transcription
caper 08-09 - City of Salinas
City of Salinas FY 2008 – 2009 CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL PERFORMANCE AND EVALUATION REPORT (CAPER) Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) HOME Investment Partnerships Program (HOME) Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) FY 2008-2009 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) Submitted to: San Francisco HUD Field Office U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Community Planning and Development 600 Harrison Street San Francisco, California 94107-1387 Prepared and Submitted by: Community Development Department Housing Division 200 Lincoln Avenue Salinas, California 93901 For more information or to comment on the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER), please contact the Housing Division: 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas, California 93901 (831) 758-7334. The CAPER is also available at http://www.ci.salinas.ca.us/services/commdev/pdf/CAPER_FY_08-09.pdf Mayor Dennis Donohue Council Members Janet Barnes Gloria De La Rosa Steven Villegas Jyl Lutes Tony Barrera Sergio Sanchez City Manager Artie Fields Community Development Director Alan Stumpf Table of Contents Introduction …………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 1 I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI. XII. XIII. Assessment of Annual Performance A. Non-Homeless Needs 1. Housing ……………………………………………………………………………………………………… 2 2. Persons with Special Needs ……………………………………………………………………………… 8 B. Homeless Needs ……………………………………………………………………………………………….…. 13 C. Other Housing-Related Needs …………………………………………………………………………………... 15 D. Non-Housing Community Development Needs ……………………………………………………………….. 16 E. Other Support Services/Facilities/Public Improvements ……………………………………………………… 20 F. Certification that the FY 2008-09 Action Plan carried out the Consolidated Plan………………………….. 24 G. Displacement Activity……………………………………………………………………………………………… 24 H. Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area ………………………………………. 25 Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing …………………………………………………………………………………… 27 Affordable Housing …………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 29 Continuum of Care ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 32 Other Actions 33 A. Program Planning & Implementation………………………………………………………………………….… 33 B. Eliminating Barriers to Accessibility……………………………………………………………………………… 34 C. Overcoming Gaps in Institutional Structures …………………………………………………………………… 35 D. Addressing Lead-Based Paint Hazards ………………………………………………………………………… 36 E. Compliance & Monitoring ………………………………………………………………………………………… 37 F. Areas of Minority Concentration ………………………………………………………………………………… 37 G. Action Plan Amendments ………………………………………………………………………………………… 38 Leveraging ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…… 39 Citizen Comments……………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 41 Self-Evaluation ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….…… 41 Monitoring…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 47 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Narrative 49 A. Housing Needs ………………………………………………………………………………………………….… 49 B. Community Development Needs ……………………………………………………………………………….. 51 C. Other ……………………………………………………………………………………………………………….. 51 HOME Narrative 52 A. Analysis of HOME Funds Distributed to Housing Needs …………………………………………………….. 52 B. HOME Match ………………………………………………………………………………………………………. 56 C. On-Site Inspections of Rental Housing…………………………………………………………………………. 56 D. Assessment of Affirmative Marketing Actions …………………………………………………………………. 57 E. Outreach to Minority-owned and Women-owned Businesses ………………………………………………. 57 ESG Narrative ………………………………………………………………………………………………………….……. 58 Civil Rights Program Related Requirements 60 A. Racial & Ethnic Persons Served ………………………………………………………………………………… 60 B. Geographic Location of Investments ……………………………………………………………………………. 60 XIII. XIV. Appendices A. Maps 1. Capital Improvement Projects (CIPs) and Other Projects 2. Handicap Accessibility Assistance 3. Housing Rehabilitation Assistance 4. Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area (AHNRSA) & CAPSTONE 5. Neighborhood Painting/Fix-Up 6. Census Tract: Low-Mod Population by Tract B. Action Plan Amendments 1. 1st Amendment, December 2, 2008 2. 2nd Amendment, March 31, 2009 3. 3rd Amendment, May 12, 2009 4. 4th Amendment, June 2, 2009 C. Public Hearing Notices D. Federal Forms 1. HUD Form 40107-A HOME Match Report 2. HUD Form 40107 Annual Performance Report – HOME Program E. IDIS Reports 1. PR03 CDBG Activity Summary Report 2. PR06 Summary of Consolidated Plan Projects 3. PR10 CDBG Housing Activities 4. PR19 ESG Statistics for Program Year 2008 5. PR20 ESG Activity Summary for Program Year 2008 6. PR23 Summary of Accomplishments 7. PR26 CDBG Financial Summary for Program Year 2008 8. PR27 Status of HOME Funds 9. PR81 ESG Performance Measures 10. PR83 CDBG Performance Measures 11. PR84 CDBG Strategy Area, CDFI, and Local Target Area 12. PR85 HOME Housing Performance Tables A. Planned Use of CDBG, HOME and ESG Funds ………………………………………………………………. 1 B. Summary of Housing Accomplishments, CDBG, HOME and ESG Funds …………………………………. 32 C. Funds Committed and Expended, and Program Income Received …………………………………………. 40 D. CDBG Activities …………………………………………………………………………………………………… 49 E. HOME Activities …………………………………………………………………………………………………… 53 F. ESG Activities ……………………………………………………………………………………………………... 58 G. ESG Matching Resources ……………………………………………………………………………………… 59 H. Families & Persons Assisted by Race & Ethnicity …………………………………………………………….. 60 I. Geographic Distribution and Location of Investments ………………………………………………………… 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report INTRODUCTION The program Year 2008 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) describes the City of Salinas' affordable housing and community development activities carried out in FY 2008-09 (July 1, 2008 through June 30, 2009). The CAPER also provides the community with a concise statement regarding the federal funds available for activities undertaken, and an evaluation of the City’s progress in carrying out the goals and objectives as stated in the Five Year Consolidated Plan 2006-2010 and the FY 2008-09 Action Plan. Salinas is designated an entitlement community for three funding programs administered by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD): Community Development Block Grant; HOME Investment Partnerships; and Emergency Shelter Grant. The overall goals of the Consolidated Plan are: 1. 2. 3. To strengthen partnerships among all levels of government and the private sector so as to enable them to provide decent housing; To establish and maintain a suitable living environment in the community; and To expand economic opportunities, particularly for very low-income and low-income residents. Table A - Planned Use of CDBG, HOME and ESG Funds for FY 2008-2009 Total CDBG Funds CDBG Activity Name Project Location 1) Program Administration N/A 495,000 2) Housing Services Program Delivery N/A 401,500 3) Affordable Housing City-wide 440,000 4) Housing Rehabilitation City-wide 472,500 5) Public Improvements City-wide 800,000 6) Public Services (maximum 15%) City-wide 375,000 7) Relocation & Contingency N/A 211,000 Total CDBG Proposed 3,195,000 Total HOME Funds HOME Activity Name Project Location 1) Program Administration N/A 175,000 2) Affordable Housing City-wide 575,000 3) Housing Rehabilitation City-wide 300,000 4) Relocation & Contingency N/A 74,700 Total HOME Proposed ESG Activity Name 1) 1,124,700 Project Location Public Services City Wide Total ESG Proposed Total ESG Funds 109,345 109,345 1 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report I. ASSESSMENT OF ANNUAL PERFORMANCE The City of Salinas FY 2008-09 Action Plan addresses Consolidated Plan priorities and goals through the allocation of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), HOME Investment Partnership (HOME), and Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG). Homeless, non-homeless, other housing, and non-housing community development needs addressed during FY 2008-09 are discussed in this section. A. Housing Needs Non-Homeless A1) Housing High priority: Provide more affordable ownership and more affordable rental housing for very low and lowincome households. Housing Market: The previous several CAPER reporting periods had seen phenomenal increases in housing prices in California’s coastal regions, including Salinas. Housing affordability indexes consistently showed the Salinas region as one of the least affordable in the country. Many households apparently felt impelled to jump into the market and purchase homes because it looked like prices could only head one direction. It appears now that a large percentage of these buyers opted to obtain loans with variable interest rates, minimal or no downpayment, and very liberal underwriting standards (e.g., ‘stated income’ loans where applicant income was not verified). Financial institutions secured additional capital to fuel the housing boom by packaging these ‘sub-prime’ loans and selling them on Wall Street. Regulators hamstrung by ‘free market’ rhetoric- remained on the sidelines; even government-sponsored enterprises (GSE) such as FNMA and Freddie Mac jumped on the bandwagon. In 2007-08 the housing boom went bust. As variable rate loans adjusted up from low initial rates, more and more homeowners (both owner-occupants and those who had bought for investment) saw their monthly payments spike and found they were unable to refinance into fixed rate loans at prices they could afford. Loan defaults increased dramatically. In Salinas, throughout California, and in many housing markets across the country, housing prices fell as economists and policy-makers first debated whether the country was in a recession, and then if it would become a depression to rival that of the 1930’s. Credit available to buy homes was reduced to almost nothing; banks and financial institutions began to fail. As the federal government stepped in to support the lenders, the pendulum swung to the other extreme: credit standards were tightened - affecting both the demand for housing and the ability to refinance existing mortgages. In Salinas applications for single family building permits first slowed and then virtually ceased. Multi-family building permit applications also declined, until only affordable housing projects with governmental subsidy remained active. Comparing sales figures for single family houses (as tracked by the Monterey County Association of Realtors ® using MLS data) one sees a 44% drop in the median sales price in Salinas between June 2006 and June 2008. Looking at the three submarkets within the City, for the six months ending June 2006, the median single-family housing price in Salinas ranged from $539,000 in East Salinas, to $625,000 in North Salinas, to $620,000 in South Salinas. When the 2007-2008 CAPER was prepared, the half-year figures were $239,000 in East Salinas, $348,000 in North Salinas, and $365,000 in South Salinas. This showed that the area with the newest homes, and the relatively least expensive homes, East Salinas experienced the greatest price decrease: $300,000 or 56%. By comparison, over January to June of 2009 (see table below), the figures were $165,000 in East Salinas, $202,000 in North Salinas, and $274,500 in South Salinas. This illustrates that the area with the newest homes, and the relatively least expensive homes, East Salinas experienced the greatest price decrease: $374,000 (69%). The 2 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report reader is reminded of the limitations of the source data: (a) only houses listed for sale in the Realtor’s Multiple Listing Service are used to calculate these prices (i.e., not all sales are included); and (b) there are over 22,000 single family houses in Salinas, so the several hundred listed in MLS or sold during the period are only a small fraction of the inventory (therefore these median sales prices may not be a good indicator of affordability of the total housing stock in Salinas because virtually all those not listed are presently occupied). Area East North South Median price June 06 ($) 539,000 625,000 620,000 Median price June 08 ($) 239,000 348,000 365,000 Median Price June 09 ($) 165,000 202,000 274,500 Percentage change June 06 - June 09 69% decrease 68% decrease 56% decrease Using the HUD guideline that a family can afford to put 30% of its income towards housing, a household of four with an income at 75% of the 2009 median income (HUD defines “low income” as the range between 51% and 80% of median) could afford a dwelling costing $192,000. This assumes the family had a 10% downpayment ($19,200) plus closing costs and they obtained a 30 year fixed rate mortgage with an interest rate of 5%. Interest rates have come down since 2008, but, credit criteria remain much more stringent than at the peak of the market (2005-06). This example includes the following in housing costs: mortgage payment, property taxes, hazard insurance, (but neither utilities nor maintenance expenses). With a median price of $165,000 in the least expensive MLS area, some housing prices will be affordable to low income families near the high end of the income range. Annexation of areas to allow for future growth: During this cycle the long process to gain approval to annex some 2400 acres of land situated north and east of East Boronda Road, between Williams and San Juan Grade Roads, was finally completed. This large area has been designated since 2002 as the area most suitable for residential expansion of the City. Given the paucity of vacant land within the City boundaries prior to the annexation, it was critical that these lands be annexed in order to provide for future growth. Implement new Inclusionary Housing Ordinance: While the City’s inclusionary requirements remain in effect, the housing crisis and subsequent recession have drastically curtailed housing production. Production of single family homes essentially came to a halt, with just six building permits issued from January through June 2009. As inclusionary unit production is directly related to overall housing production figures, inclusionary numbers are also down. Several affordable rental projects are in varying stages of development; each will provide inclusionary rental units: Sunflower Gardens Apartments is under construction (3 very low income inclusionary units); Gateway Apartments has all land use entitlements and is awaiting tax credit approval (10 very-low income inclusionary units); and the mixed income Tynan Village Apartments has been completed (21 low income inclusionary units). We reported the last period that land use entitlements had been granted and rough grading had begun for the 53 unit, market-rate Los Laureles Seniors project. This project is presently on hold and so the status of the ten inclusionary units remains unclear. Assuming the overall housing market picks up again, annual production should increase once the Specific Plans are adopted for the recently annexed new growth areas and infrastructure is provided over the coming 42 months. Implement First Time Homebuyer Program: As noted in the 2006-07 CAPER, the City had discontinued its down-payment assistance for first-time homebuyers because the financing gap had become so large that even $60,000 deferred payment seconds were insufficient to help low income families buy homes. 3 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report With the current Real Estate market downturn in this Country especially in California, staff is re-evaluating the cost and benefits of once again funding the program with HUD funds. Staff is in discussions with a Non-Profit Agency that has shown interest in coordinating the City’s first time homebuyer efforts should the program be re-activated. Homebuyer Education: During this period the City has provided some operational funding to Housing Resource Center –HRC- (a merger of MoCHA, a local nonprofit housing counseling agency and the Housing Advocacy Council of Monterey County) to support their first-time homebuyer education program and foreclosure prevention counseling. They also assist in homeless prevention. Last year HRC was awarded $300,000 (over two years) from State CDBG funds; these will enable services to be expanded; three additional housing counselor positions have been added. Support Developers of Affordable Housing: There were virtually no active market-rate development projects in Salinas during the reporting period. Production of affordable multi-family housing, in Salinas and across the State, was really the only housing activity. City support for affordable projects was more critical than ever, due to the intense competition for very limited housing resources: many State programs were on hold and the number of equity investors seeking federal tax credits declined drastically. First Community Housing’s plans to begin construction on its project to provide 52 new affordable rental units in the downtown were stymied when the State’s housing finance agency reneged on a financing commitment - the nonprofit has been working since then to secure alternate financing. This transitoriented, high density project is located at a key entryway to our central business district. Half the units are to be set aside for developmentally disabled adults seeking independent living arrangements. City land use entitlements were granted during FY2007-08 and building permits were issued in anticipation of a Summer 2008 groundbreaking. The project sponsors are now awaiting a decision on their application for federal tax credits. The City continues to support this project; the most recent action was to allow the remaining $1 million of committed HOME funds to be used for pre-development expenses (rather than for construction as originally envisioned). This action helped address a short-term cash flow problem resulting from the delay in obtaining construction financing. Substantial financial support was provided to our premier local housing non-profit: CHISPA, for two projects. CHISPA qualifies as a Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) under the HOME regulations, signifying a commitment to involving local residents on its Board of Directors and in other aspects of its operation. CHISPA’s most recent project is Sherwood Village Senior Apartments, now completed and fully leased up - this award-winning development received $2.2 million in HOME and $350,000 in CDBG support from the City of Salinas. The first pending CHISPA project is the Wesley Oaks subdivision, an infill project that will create homeownership, rather than rental, opportunities for lower income Salinas residents. Ten single family houses will be constructed on a previously developed site in our only Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area. The City provided $800,000 of FY 2007-08 HOME/CHDO funds to CHISPA for development of the Wesley Oaks project, to consist of six (6) single-family homeownership units and four (4) single-family homeownership and/or rental units, with one (1) unit funded through the County of Monterey, using Mental Health Services Act resources. The project will provide first time homebuyer opportunities to at least six low-income farmworker families; these will be the HOME-assisted units. At a minimum, the remaining four units will be affordable to families with household incomes not exceeding 120% AMI. The new single-family homeownership units will include multiple floor plans and elevations consisting of nine (9) three bedroom units and one (1) four bedroom unit, ranging from 1,250 square feet to 1,390 square feet. CHISPA acquired title to the property and successfully relocated the tenants who had been living in substandard apartments on the site; the City supported the relocation with CDBG funds. Construction had been planned to start in January 2009, however the recession and the State fiscal crisis have combined to greatly reduce available financing opportunities for this project. 4 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report As described elsewhere in this report, the second pending CHISPA project is the La Gloria Seniors Apartments. The site for this project was acquired with the use of $425,000 in HOME funding from the City of Salinas. La Gloria is a new construction project that will provide 23 apartments for senior living on a parcel that has been vacant for decades. This project has an application pending for tax credits. Transition Public Housing Residents to Homeownership: The County Housing Authority previously identified 9 scattered site public housing units for sale to tenants of public housing and submitted a request to HUD for approval to remove the units from the stock of public housing. This project was on hold during the reporting period. City HOME funds remained set aside (up to $150,000) for possible use by public housing residents to purchase such units. Medium priority: Larger units at affordable sales prices/rents. Size Standards for Affordable Units: Overcrowding can be addressed by ensuring that units built are of an adequate size and by providing an adequate number of bedrooms. The City’s adoption of the revised inclusionary ordinance addressed both factors by mandating minimum unit sizes under all three developer options. Bedroom count was also addressed by requiring provision of bedrooms proportional to marketrate units under Option 1 and by requiring a minimum of 60% of inclusionary units to contain at least 3 bedrooms under Options 2 and 3 (with a concurrent requirement that no more than 10% of inclusionary housing be one bedroom units). These actions reinforce the existing zoning regulations specifying that 20% of new rental housing contain 3 bedrooms, and that an additional 10% contain four bedrooms (applicable only to projects containing at least 20 units). Affordable rental units completed this period include Tynan Village, a 171-unit mixed income project developed by the Housing Authority. This project contains 98 units (57%) with three or four bedrooms; 62 of the 98 have income restrictions that will remain in place for 55 years. High priority: Increase supply of housing and available land. Future Growth Areas: City planning staff worked with property owners, housing developers, and Local Agency Formation Commission of Monterey County (LAFCo) staff for several years to prepare the necessary plans and analyses required to proceed with annexation of the majority of the Future Growth Areas to the east of the City, as identified in our 2002 General Plan. The City Zoning Code was completely revised last period to better implement the General Plan; this action paved the way for preparation of the Specific Plans required to develop the area following annexation. In an effort to preserve farmland and reduce sprawl the City is requiring an average residential density of nine dwelling units per acre, with up to 25% of the residential area to be built at densities from 16 to 24 units to the acre. Thus development will be significantly more dense than would have occurred under the previous General Plan (see below for additional information on residential densities). The annexation took place during this CAPER reporting period, so the land for new housing is now within the City limits. The 1,300 acres will allow development of some 11,000 new housing units over the 20 year build-out period. Staff estimates that the City inclusionary requirement will compel from 2,300 to 2,900 of these to be restricted at prices/rents affordable to one of the four targeted income groups: very low; low; moderate; and workforce. The recession has caused some development companies to back out of the master planning process to develop and 5 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report adopt Specific Plans for the newly annexed area; remaining developers and landowners are evaluating their options and negotiating with the City for reduced development extractions and alternate methods of inclusionary ordinance compliance. While the negotiations proceed, progress on actual plan preparation has effectively ceased. Second Dwelling Units: Staff will be implementing an effort to encourage developers to include second dwelling units (i.e., “granny flats”) in new developments via the Specific Plans to be adopted for the three Future Growth Areas now undergoing annexation. The City formerly promoted the development of affordable infill second dwelling units on existing properties, with covenants to ensure long term affordability. In 2007, however, the City Council decided to remove the requirement that new second dwellings be rented to lower income households at affordable prices; the Council agreed with a group of builders and business interests who argued that more units would be created in the community if the requirement was lifted and that the increase in housing would more than offset the loss of the guaranteed affordability created under the previous rules. Thus far there has been no increase in new second dwelling units, but, this may change as the recession eases. High priority: Increase supply of housing and available land. Infill Development Strategy: Staff is actively promoting infill projects such as described in the Consolidated Plan. Under the City’s “Infill” housing program, coordinated by the Housing Services staff, the City in Partnership with CHISPA (a local Non-Profit Developer) builds single-family homes on surplus City parcels located throughout the City. CHISPA in turns partners with Hartnell College Construction Technology Department to assist in the construction of these homes. The third of these homes is slated to be completed and advertised for sale by the end of August 2009. Like the prior two homes built under this program, this third home will also be sold and occupied by a low-income “first time homebuyer” household. These homes come with a 30-year resale deed restriction recorded on them. The fourth City parcel, which had some pre-development issues, is currently in the development review process before it can be deed over to CHISPA. Construction on this unit should begin in late September 09. City Staff is searching for other city parcels which might have potential to be developed. Redevelopment Efforts: Agency staff continued to implement plans to improve neighborhoods within the two redevelopment project areas. Recent efforts have been focused upon commercial revitalization, both within the Sunset Avenue project area and in Central City’s “New Chinatown” area. Parcels are being acquired in each area to further the objectives of their respective Redevelopment Plans. In the Sunset area, the East Alisal/East Market Streets retail corridor is the focus of the business owners’ association: SUBA, a group operating with significant support from redevelopment staff. Engineering plans for upgrade of East Market Street (roadway, sidewalk, pedestrian lighting, and utilities undergrounding) have been completed; funding for the undergrounding has been secured through Pacific Gas & Electric. Special CDBG economic stimulus funds of $600,000 have been earmarked for the new street lights. These public improvements are expected to increase retail activity and -over time- lead to increases in tax increment revenue for the Agency, thereby providing additional resources for housing and other activities. Housing projects either underway, or completed during the reporting period receiving Agency financial support include the Gateway Apartments (52 units), Tynan Village (171 units), and Sunflower Gardens (18 units). Gateway and Sunflower will be 100% affordable to very low income; Tynan Village is a mixedincome project with 40% of the units renting at market rates. In the Central City Project Area, a private/public redevelopment effort for the downtown and adjacent government center was initiated this fiscal year: Renaissance Partners is looking to redevelop City- and Agency-owned parcels to provide improved City facilities, expand commercial opportunities and parking, and add needed housing units. Just to the other side of downtown, community efforts to revitalize the lower Soledad Street area (also known “New Chinatown”) are progressing. A multi-year partnership with California State University Monterey Bay (CSUMB) has been supported with HUD funds provided through HSIAC (Hispanic Serving Educational Institutions Assisting Communities) grants. Two planning grants 6 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report have also been received from CalTRANS: the second grant for $207,000 was received this year and will be used to further develop the concepts contained in the 2007 Chinatown Revitalization Plan. The nonprofit Salinas Downtown Community Board helps to coordinate renewal efforts through volunteer “Action Teams” which focus on key aspects such as safety and cultural heritage preservation. The Redevelopment Agency has acquired several parcels in the area, one of these now hosts a community garden. Higher Densities in Future Growth Area: While formal planning studies for the three Specific Plans for the newly annexed northeast Future Growth Area are on hold due to the recession, applicable General Plan policies will ensure higher density development when work starts again. The mix of densities is expected to be: 30-50% at six units to the acre; 35-45% at 7 to 14 units to the acre; and, 15 to 25% at 16 to 24 dwelling units to the acre. This would yield an average residential density of 9 units to the acre across the 1300 acres designated for residential development. New Urbanist principles will be incorporated in the developing Plans. The new inclusionary ordinance promotes the use of multi-family housing formats such as townhomes and condominiums to a much greater extent than the “like-for-like” regulations it replaced. For the last several months staff has been negotiating with FGA landowners and developers in order to find a way to continue planning efforts despite the downturn in the economy. High priority: Improve sub-standard units and maintain adequate living conditions. Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area (AHNRSA): Program staff continues to address substandard living conditions through the use of the low interest rehabilitation loans Citywide, as well as in the AHNRSA. Rehabilitation work on units vary from deferred maintenance (e.g., replace roof coverings and water heaters) to full blown reconstruction. HCD Division staff work with the City’s Code Enforcement staff to assist those homeowners that are found to have housing violations in their homes. The City has allocated a portion of the Measure V Sales Tax proceeds to increase staffing for code enforcement. Staff has increased outreach by giving program presentations to various agencies that assist low-income clientele, and by instituting another round of Public Service Announcements (PSAs) with the local news media. The 2008-09 ACTION PLAN was amended to allocate $425,000 for CHISPA to acquire the site for the La Gloria seniors housing project (described elsewhere in this report); this site is within the AHNRS Area. Pre-development work is proceeding on the ten-unit, single family subdivision: Wesley Oaks, also in the strategy area. The 2009-10 ACTION PLAN contemplates additional funding for the La Gloria development ($320,000 in new HOME funds, supplemented by $400,000 of Redevelopment Agency housing dollars). Jazz-Up Program: This program is a neighborhood painting/fix-up program for commercial and residential properties with exterior painting and minor repairs through the City of Salinas Redevelopment Agency. "Clean up" activities include, but are not limited to: painting, and minor construction for low income families, trash pick-up, sweeping of sidewalks and gutters, weed and debris removal, shrub pruning, and tree well maintenance, graffiti removal, rubbish removal along major corridors, public fences and buildings and vacant land clean up. Commercial buildings are designated eligible under the Redevelopment Plan in designated low-income areas. Work is focused in Census Tract 5, 6, 7 and portions of 8 where the low-income percentage is 70 %+. Beautification and cultural activity projects in the targeted area lead to improved business and neighborhood pride. Objective of program is to improve quality of life by improvements made to the community when maintained and free from garbage and poor maintenance on both public and private properties. Improving the visual impact in older and poor neighborhoods while assisting in the removal of factors contributing to decline. Hours of operation are on a 36-hour workweek, Monday thru Thursday. A total of 12 projects were completed in FY08-09, 6 of which were residential and 6 commercial properties. This activity received CDBG financial support. 7 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report A2) Persons with Special Needs High priority: Develop affordable housing and provide support services for seniors. Sherwood Seniors Village-808 North Main Street-The Community Housing Improvement Systems and Planning Association, Inc., (CHISPA): Although the Sherwood Village Project obtained its Certificate of Occupancy on May 21, 2008 during last years CAPER reporting period, the project received additional HOME and CDBG funds in FY 2008-09 due to increase in project development costs. As stated previously, the property was acquired with financial support from the City (HOME & CDBG). Total development costs was $22,512,586; of which $2,200,000 were provided by the City’s Entitlement HOME program and $350,000 from the Community Development Block Grant program. To date, all units are leased and a waiting list has been established. Project provides 123 units of affordable and safe rental housing for seniors, and with hundred percent (100%) of the units affordable to low or very-low income households. The project is comprised of 43 HOME-assisted units, all affordable to very low-income households with incomes at 50% of Area Median Income. Since its development, Sherwood Village has gained national and local recognition for its incorporation of green features and innovative architectural design. The project consisted of major renovation of a dilapidated and crime-ridden motel. Existing buildings were preserved and converted into stylish studios. The project incorporated several green features such as a state-of-the art bioswale to retain, infiltrate and treat most storm water on site and installation of solar panels. Sherwood Village won Gold in the National Association of Home Builders' 50+ Housing Awards in the Renovated Housing Award category and was also awarded with the Judge’s Special Innovative Award. The project was featured in the April 2008 issue of the Affordable Housing Finance Publication as one of the 32 finalists in the fourth annual Reader’s Choice Awards for Nation’s Best Affordable Housing Developments of 2007-2008. Additionally, the project received a resolution of appreciation from the California Regional Water Quality Control Board for implementing the bioswale to protect the waters of the Central Coast and from BFI Waste Services as one of four winners of the 2008 Curbee Recycling Award for achieving high rates of recycling while building the project. CHISPA recycled motel mattresses by paying St. Vincent to Paul Charity $5 each to pull the foam, cotton steel and wood from each. All motel furniture was donated to Rancho Cielo, an at-risk youth facility near Salinas and all other furnishings went to the local Salvation Army. About 75% of the concrete and demolition waste was recycled with an overall diversion amount of approximately 95%. La Gloria Senior Apartments-531 and 539 East Market Street-CHISPA: Through an amendment of the FY 2008-09 Action Plan, the La Gloria Senior Apartments project was awarded $425,000 of HOME funds. The project consists of acquisition of a half-acre site at 531 and 539 E. Market Street and construction of 22 residential rental units for extremely low and very low-income seniors and one manager’s unit. The two-storey structure will include second story terraces and a community room. The City entered into an agreement with CHISPA on March, 2009, to acquire the property with HOME funds, designating 6 units as HOME-assisted. In addition to HOME funds, the project also received City 8 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Redevelopment funds and California TCAC funds in late August, 2009. TCAC funds make up the bulk of this five million dollar project. CHISPA also applied for additional City funds in early 2009 and was awarded HOME funds in the amount of $500,000 in FY 2009-2010 earmarked for construction costs. Meals on Wheels of Salinas Valley: Delivers meals to homebound seniors and the disabled in the City of Salinas. By receiving this service, these individuals are healthier, their life style and living environments are enhanced. Allowing one to remain in their home during illness allows independence and a happier frame of mind while keeping down medical costs. For some clients, this is the only outside contact with other humans they have in a day. Individuals must be unable to shop for or prepare their own meals, or be adults with disabilities or a disabling disease, verified by their physician. 87% are seniors, age 60 and older, 13% are disabled with 87% being very low/low income. 70% of clients served are at nutritional risk. There has been an increase with the disabled and the low income served. In addition, individuals at-risk for nutrition have risen by 3%. A registered dietitian certifies menus. Deliveries consist of either a fiveday or seven day supply of specially designed frozen main meals and breakfasts. Several meals are delivered at once, so clients are able to choose the meal they would like to eat each day when hungry. Meals are designed to meet special needs diets such as diabetes, hypertension and cardiac restrictions. Volunteers make deliveries twice a week. A total of 167 Salinas residents received nutritious meals/services multiple times in FY08-09 that may not have eaten a balanced meal without this valuable program serving homebound seniors and the disabled in the community. Both this and the following two activities received CDBG public services funding during this fiscal year. Alliance on Aging -Senior Aides Program: Program promotes unsubsidized employment training and part time community service assignment opportunities for very low-income seniors in Salinas. Aides must be 55 years and over and have an annual income below the federal poverty level. Senior Employment promotes the transition to unsubsidized employment and assists some of the City’s poorest seniors by providing them with the training they need to re-enter the workforce. Training or retraining is received with on-the job training provided free of charge to both employers and job seekers. Enrollees are prepared for today’s workforce by building the skills and confidence that will lead to permanent employment. Community agencies provide a supportive environment, supervision and the use of new workplace technology. Senior Aides are paid minimum wage for 20 hours weekly. 75% of applicants to the program are women in their 60s and 70s, often widowed or divorced, who must rejoin the work force out of financial need. Employment Specialists link seniors seeking full or part-time employment in the private sector. The Senior Aides program served 20 very low-income senior adults in FY08-09 multiple times. Alliance on Aging’s, Senior Aides program has experienced difficultly with finding very low-income seniors in this area due to the high cost of living in the Monterey Bay area. Alliance on Aging -Ombudsman: This program monitors the care of residents in nursing facilities and residential care facilities, ensuring care is consistent, professional, ethical and caring, and investigates complaints on behalf of consumers, law enforcement and adult abuse prevention programs. Most of these consumers are physically frail and unable to care for themselves. Advocates are needed for seniors to ensure that dignified treatment is received. OMBUDSMAN represents seniors and assists them in meeting needs with bi-lingual services in both English and Spanish. Hours of operation are weekdays 9:00am-5:00pm with a 24-hour answering machine instructing consumers what to do after hours. Ombudsman served a total of 209 seniors multiple times in FY08-09, which is an increase over 181 seniors served in FY07-08. Medium priority: Develop more affordable housing for low-income farm-worker households. Wesley Oaks Subdivision: The City allocated $800,000 of its FY 2007-08 HOME/CHDO funds to Community Housing Improvement Systems and Planning Association, Inc. (CHISPA) for development of the Wesley Oaks Subdivision project, consisting of six (6) single-family homeownership units and four (4) single-family homeownership and/or rental units, with one (1) unit planned to be funded through the County of Monterey (through the State Mental Health Services Act). Six of the units will be affordable to low-income farmworker families with household incomes not exceeding 80% AMI (these will be 9 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report designated as “HOME-assisted”), and four units will be affordable to families with household incomes not exceeding 120% AMI. On July 3, 2008, CHISPA acquired the property using HOME funds. On December 2008, PSC Industrial Outsourcing, L.P. completed demolition of existing substandard units. However, to date construction has not begun as the project encountered critical development delays during the last six months as result of the freeze in state funding from the State Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), Joe Serna, Jr. Farmworker Housing Grant Program (JSJFWHG) and Building Equity and Growth in Neighborhoods Program (BEGIN). Both funding sources are critical components of the overall construction proformas and are required in order to proceed with development. The project’s financial request to JSJFWHG was placed on hold for several months and to date, funding has not been released. However, on June 30, 2009 CHISPA received a notice of conditional award from HCD for Wesley Oaks project allocating funding in the amount of $400,000. Presently, CHISPA is unaware of HCD’s timeframe for disbursement of funds. Additionally, CHISPA’s has not submitted its application to the BEGIN Program as the first round of BEGIN funding was oversubscribed and there are no remaining funds. HCD plans to release a NOFA during the summer of 2009, this provides CHISPA with an opportunity to submit a project ready application. Currently, CHISPA contacts the BEGIN program representative monthly in order to obtain updates on release of BEGIN funds. At this time, additional funding has not been released. Further, the County’s original proposed funding for the MHSA Supportive Housing Grant was decreased from $600,000 to $299,848 due to fiscal challenges. Currently, application is being reviewed by the California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA); CHISPA expects a response by Mid-August 2009. However, CHISPA is actively seeking alternative funding sources and assessing development costs savings through value engineering. During the reporting period, Wesley Oaks was awarded with a HOME Energy Grant of $250,000 by the U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to provide all 10 newly constructed units as Energy Star Certified housing. Staff is currently preparing the funding agreement for this award. Relocation: Further, the City allocated $240,000 of its FY 2008-09 CDBG funds for relocation. The funding agreement was executed on August 26, 2008. On November 23, 2007, CHISPA entered into a contractual agreement for Professional Relocation Services with Linda A. Norwood, Relocation Consultant. On February 1, 2008 a relocation meeting was held with all existing tenants. On February 15, 2008, the City of Salinas approved the Relocation Plan for Wesley Oaks. To date, all five households entitled to Relocation benefits have been relocated. Of those, two households used their relocation benefits to purchase a single-family home. The Lopez family closed escrow on November 19, 2008 and the Barajas family on May 1, 2009. Presently, the Relocation Consultant is assisting one more household to purchase an affordable single-family home. CHISPA goal is to obtain homeownership for all five families. Construction: Although, all households have been relocated, the construction phase has not commenced. On March 2, 2009, the project was reviewed and approved by the Salinas Design Review Board. On April 1, 2009 the Salinas Planning Commission approved the Planned Unit Development (PUD) and vesting Tentative Map to allow the subdivision and construction of ten detached single-family dwellings, including a 35% Density Bonus. On April 28, 2009, the Salinas City Council approved the PUD and Vesting Tentative Map. 10 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Although, local approvals have been obtained, CHISPA will delay requesting building permits until financing challenges are resolved. However, CHISPA will submit the Final Map by mid-August 2009. Currently, all existing dwelling units have been demolished, all existing tenants have been relocated and required City approvals have been obtained. Again, due fiscal challenges construction is expected to tentatively commence in January 2010. Medium priority: Provide more accessible, affordable housing for persons with disabilities. Sunflower Gardens (formerly Casas del Sol): This project, located at 25-29 Sun Street, is the site of an existing migrant farmworker housing facility owned by the non-profit MCHI and managed by the Housing Authority. In FY 2008-09, Interim, Inc. was awarded HOME funds to develop the site to provide rental housing for very low-income people with psychiatric disabilities and who are at risk of being homeless. The site was previously funded with HOME dollars. Therefore, the City started a “waiver” process submitted to HUD to allow additional HOME funds for the project. However, the City did not receive a timely response from HUD headquarters in Washington, DC, and decided to withdraw the $425,000 HOME funding allocation in FY 2008-09. Instead, CDBG funds were awarded for acquisition costs in the same amount in order for the project to move forward and continue to stay within the scheduled project timeline. Interim, Inc.’s latest project, Lupine Gardens, also serves the same targeted population and continues to maintain a waiting list. The project will consist of fifteen studio units, one 1-bedroom unit (reserved for the property manager), and two 4-bedroom units (each bedroom would be rented out individually to persons who would benefit from the group environment). Fifteen units will be operated as permanent housing and two as transitional housing. An accessory building for administrative and counseling offices, and with space for tenant support services will also be built. As discussed in section X., CDBG Narrative, construction is now in progress and is expected to be complete by April 2010. Gateway Apartments: This 52-unit rental housing project is located at the intersection of West Market Street and Lincoln Avenue, and is being developed by First Community Housing (FCH), a non-profit developer based in San Jose, California. Units will be available to households whose income is 50% of area median income or less. The project also allots 25 units to the developmentally disabled population of Salinas, who typically face higher health expenses and fixed incomes. $450,000 of HOME funds were allocated in FY 2006-07 and additional funds in the amount of $760,000 during FY 2007-08. Construction did not begin in early 2008 as anticipated due to delays related to construction loan closing and the State’s inability to sell bonds. To fill the funding shortfall, FCH has applied for 9% California Tax Credit Allocation Committee (TCAC) funds. They are expecting notification of funding this September. If the project receives the funding, they expect construction to be complete by the summer of 2011. Disabled Housing Needs Assessment: While City resources to conduct an assessment of the housing needs of those with disabilities were not available, a local coalition of agencies concerned with this issue produced a report entitled: “Housing Needs of People with Disabilities Assessment - July 2006.” Staff intends to complete a review of this assessment to determine potential application to the Housing & Community Development Division’s programs and policies. We have already revised Housing Services Program outreach materials in light of the “people first” emphasis contained in the report. “Visitability” Ordinance: Staff has not yet been able to investigate the feasibility of an ordinance mandating features in new housing designed to facilitate access by those in wheelchairs or with otherwise limited mobility. The Disabled Housing Needs Assessment described above may provide support for a recommendation to adopt a ‘visitability’ policy. CHISPA, one of our non-profit housing developers, has been active in this area by adding “universal design” features to their projects. Universal design seeks to incorporate features at the time of construction that will facilitate accessibility throughout the useful life of 11 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report the structure. Several houses recently constructed through the Hartnell College/CHISPA/City partnership for infill housing have incorporated some universal design features (such as widened doorways and halls). Central Coast Center for Independent Living: This program supports and assists disabled residents living in Salinas on how to live independently and productive lives in their own homes and assists with affordable/accessible housing with service coordination, advocacy, information and referral services to other agencies. Clients are taught how to successfully secure housing resources available to residents with disabilities. Counseling, case management, financial, and medical benefits and money management skills are necessary in retaining housing in a difficult economy are offered by CCCIL. For many disabled Salinas residents this is their first stop for assistance with housing accessibility difficulties. Central Coast Center for Independent Living helps those in need by promoting independence and living skills with available, affordable housing, adequate transporting and medical services and assisting the very low to low to moderate-income disabled persons of all ages and ethnicities in the city. The agency received CDBG “public services” funding this period. CCCIL served a total of 64 Salinas disabled residents that would not have had these services without CCCIL’s assistance for FY08-09. Low priority: Provide affordable housing for people living with HIV/AIDS. John XXIII Aids Ministry: Support services include but are not limited to emergency shelter, transitional housing (group), rental/utility assistance, permanent and affordable housing, case management, AIDS drug assistance program enrollment, transportation assistance, USDA food distribution, one-on-one and family emotional support, support groups, friendly visitor program, end-of life services, free HIV testing and free counseling. Consumers are 62% male, 38% female, 49% Hispanic, with the average age being 31-50; 68% speak English. Services are available in both English and Spanish. Drop-in services offering education, prevention and testing services are located on East Market Street which is open three days a week. Office hours of operation are Monday–Friday 9:00am-5:00pm. The City supported the agency with ESG funds during this period. In FY08-09 a total of 121 Salinas consumers were served multiple times. Medium priority: Provide more affordable housing for low-income farm worker households Affordable Farmworker Housing: Following the success of the 50 unit “Salinas Farmworker Family Initiative” earlier this decade, the City has wanted to use that project as a template to provide additional affordable farmworker housing. Two factors have worked against this intent: the shortage of vacant land suitable for such housing and the intense level of predevelopment work required to assemble the complex hierarchy of funding programs (i.e., federal USDA and HUD funds; state HCD funds; County of Monterey funds; Salinas Redevelopment Agency funds, plus loans from both non-profit and conventional lending institutions). Initial hopes to replicate the 50 unit self-help project have given way to a plan to subdivide a site and develop ten single family homes, setting aside the majority of the new units for lower income farmworker families. Known as Wesley Oaks, Salinas provided CHISPA with the funds to acquire the site during the previous reporting cycle. The small scale of the development precludes using a self-help approach. While the relatively high acquisition cost is to be expected for infill sites already served by infrastructure, CHISPA and the City are working hard to secure financing from a variety of sources. Working with CHISPA, the City submitted an application for special HUD-CHDO funds being made available for “green” projects: $250,000 of such funds were approved. (See below for detailed discussion of current status of Wesley Oaks project.) CHISPA used City HOME funds ($320,000) to acquire a site on East Market Street planned for development of a senior housing facility directly across Market from the 25 unit Los Abuelitos seniors project that was completed two years ago. The focus of Los Abuelitos was to provide housing for those retired from agricultural work. The new La Gloria Senior Apartments was initially conceived with the same focus, but, the difficulty in securing appropriate financing (e.g., the State has stopped funding its Joe Serna Farmworker Housing program) may mean the project will lose that emphasis. This project is under consideration for tax credits in the 2009 application cycle. 12 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report City and Redevelopment Agency staff have been working with Pacific West (a for-profit affordable housing developer) on a plan to construct farmworker family rental housing on the last remaining residential site in the Williams Ranch Subdivision. Land use entitlements have been granted for 80 garden-apartment style units, but it has been difficult to assemble financing. In 2008 the project applied for federal tax credits, but, found itself on the waiting list due to insufficient funds. With commitments in hand for both Agency ($400,000) and HOME ($500,000) funds, they have applied for credits in the 2009 funding cycle. It should be noted that, unlike certain other types of ‘special need’ housing, units suitable for occupancy by farmworker households are not physically different from those suitable for other households of similar size. Therefore, activities designed to create and preserve affordable housing in general will benefit our farmworker housing development. Land Use Policies Regarding Farmworker Units: As planned, the City has continued to facilitate the provision of farmworker housing through adopted land use regulations. Over time the demand for housing for transient farmworkers (single adults) has continued to decline as Salinas has become a ‘home base’ for many agricultural workers. Thus, while the policies remain in place, the private market for such development has not been strong. The declining demand for seasonal farmworker housing is evidenced by a declining number of ‘labor camps’ in the area. During FY 2008-09, another labor camp on Sun Street was demolished by its owner, presumably because operational costs exceeded revenues. B. Homeless Needs Medium priority: Seamlessly integrate programs with Continuum of Care. Franciscan Workers of Junipero Serra-Dorothy’s Place: Franciscan Workers have served Salinas since 1982 with a variety of programs, including Dorothy's Place Community Kitchen. Dorothy’s Place offers a day shelter, women’s emergency walk in shelter” Women Alive”, health clinic, free hot meals (breakfast and lunch), food boxes, showers, laundry services, clothing, medical clinic, along with prescription assistance, voluntary prayer groups, mail and phone message service, service referrals needs and counseling, and assistance with utility bills. A computer lab assists with job skills, job search, generating resumes and completing job applications, and general computer literacy. The Women’s Alive Shelter was opened to assist women as they look for permanent housing. The primary objective of the kitchen is to feed the hungry by providing a nutritionally balanced and appealing daily meals to all in need, while respecting the dignity of each individual. The program is open from 8:30am to 2:00pm Mon.- Sat and on Sundays as needed. An average of 200 lunch meals are served daily. In FY08-09, a total of 1,589 homeless residents of Salinas were served multiple times with meals and services by Franciscan Workers. This activity was supported with CDBG funds during this period. Housing Resource Center of Monterey County formerly Housing Advocacy Council: The Housing Resource Center of Monterey County’s (HRC) Security Deposit Guarantee/Rental Assistance Program helps low and very low-income people, some of whom are homeless, enter the rental housing market by providing an alternative to cash deposits. HRC issues a Letter of Credit to landlords, assuring that the tenant will pay the deposit over the next twelve months. With this letter, payment of the deposit is assured. HRC’s homeless prevention activities include an emergency rental assistant program for households and individuals facing eviction as a result of unforeseen circumstances and emergencies. Tenant Education including crisis education with workshops to help with current and future problems. Counseling, case management, financial, and money management skills are necessary in retaining housing in a difficult economy are offered. In FY08-09, HRC served 586 very low/low-income families in Salinas through the rent and deposit program. Hours of operation are Monday-Friday, 9:00am-5:00pm. This activity was supported with ESG funds in FY08-09 along with the other two programs below. Interim, Inc- MCHOME: MCHOME is focused upon providing a full range of services to adults with mental illness on services; a good percentage of the chronically homeless have mental health problems. The purpose of MCHOME (Monterey County Homeless Outreach Makeup Empowerment) is to get mentally ill 13 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report adults off the streets and into housing and employed. Enrolled clients can receive services for as long as necessary, usually up to two years. Once clients are stabilized, case management moves from MCHOME to Monterey County Behavioral Health. Services include emergency housing, psychiatric evaluation and medication, and assistance with obtaining food, clothing and personal need items. Case managers offer counseling, which assists clients in obtaining public benefits. Clients are assisted with obtaining jobs, accessing needed health care and dental services. Staffing assists with enrollment into recovery programs and/or attending DRA (Dual Recovery Anonymous). Staff transport enrolled consumers to service locations as needed. The Program Director and a counselor are on-call after hours to provide emergency support to enrolled clients. Normal business hours are seven days a week. A total of 62 homeless individuals received services during this period. Shelter Outreach Plus- I HELP: Men’s program provides emergency shelter and support services for unaccompanied men including food, transportation to nightly accommodations and emergency medical assistance, laundry services, showers, toiletries, clothing and bedding. Clients have access to supportive services such as resource and referral (mental health and drug treatment), veterans’ services, case management, immigration services, education counseling, voice mail, a mailing address, resumes and job preparation. Nine men have secured employment during this fiscal year. The I-HELP program is an evening program from 5:00pm-7am operating year round (365 days per year). A total of 130 homeless Salinas men were provided overnight shelter multiple times at 25 congregations during FY08-09. Support SRO Housing: Single room occupancy (SRO) housing can serve several roles, for example: as transitional units for those formerly homeless, as temporary housing for lower wage workers, and as permanent housing for seniors. As noted in the Consolidated Plan, a 91-unit SRO housing development (Plaza Grande) was completed in downtown Salinas several years ago. Redevelopment staff are evaluating this project over time to glean additional insight into how such facilities work and how they fit into existing communities; early indications are that minimum parking standards may need to be reviewed due to greater demand than anticipated from SRO residents. This project was the first major SRO to be developed following revisions to City zoning rules designed to encourage SRO projects. An older, smaller SRO facility located next door (Plaza Hotel) has had problems maintaining an occupancy rate sufficient to cover operating expenses, so it is also useful as a source of information as the community continues to grapple with the housing needs of very low-income individuals. Staff has heard that the Plaza Hotel may have been put up for sale by the current owner, but, this has not yet been confirmed. Recent new development (both built and entitled) focus upon serving low and very low income individuals and households. As the downtown continues to redevelop, staff will continue to promote a broad spectrum of housing types, but, with a greater emphasis on units targeting moderate and higher income residents. The recession and the State fiscal crisis have combined to cause funding cuts for post-high school educational programs, such as state-run junior colleges, four year colleges, and state and federal programs providing financial aid to lower income students. This is relevant to this section of the CAPER because there have been inquiries by students seeking subsidized housing such as provided by the Plaza Grande SRO development. Full time students, however, are not eligible to reside in Plaza Grande because it was financed with federal low income housing tax credits, the rules for which preclude occupancy by full time students. Homeless Services Planning: The City continued its role as one of 3 municipalities within Monterey County that serves as a Community Advisor to the Coalition of Homeless Services Providers. This nonprofit umbrella organization of providers works closely with Monterey County, the governmental jurisdiction with primary responsibility for addressing homelessness in the county. During this period, City staff have assisted with various homeless services planning activities, including a staff member continuing to serve as Co-Chair of the Local Homeless Advisory Committee (LHAC). The LHAC meets monthly to provide a forum for service providers & advocates and to provide input and assistance to the County-wide Continuum of Care for homeless services. LHAC provided critical support to the Homeless Census that took place in January 2009; reporting within the limited parameters established by HUD. 14 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report City redevelopment staff have taken the lead regarding municipal involvement with efforts to coordinate the provision of homeless services (and the future of homeless facilities) within the Soledad Street neighborhood. As a result of a grant from the California Department of Transportation, a comprehensive plan for the renewal of this area was prepared: the “Chinatown Renewal Project Plan.” These efforts are being supported by several initiatives under the leadership of the California State University - Monterey Bay, including a community garden project at the corner of Soledad and East Lake Streets. CSUMB’s involvement is supported by a special CDBG educational institution multi-year grant. Addressing the Chronically Homeless: The federal government has identified chronic homelessness as a particularly critical issue, earmarking numerous federal programs and resources in an effort to alleviate long term homelessness. Staff has continued to participate in local discussions on how to balance efforts to fight chronic homelessness with ongoing programs that target other aspects of the homeless problem. ESG funds were allocated with this new federal priority in mind, but, the limited funds available are not sufficient to encourage local providers to design new programs. The City’s ESG funds ($109,345 for FY2008-09) were split about 50-50 between chronic homeless services and other homeless services - once the 30% allocated to prevention activities is subtracted. Local service providers are working to re-tool and adjust their programs to better mesh with this new federal emphasis. This is complicated by the targeting required from other funding sources, for example by the State of California funds (the State’s Mental Health Services Act) now becoming available to address the needs of persons with mental illness and other severe psychological problems. C. Other Housing-Related Needs Low priority: Greater access to federally-subsidized housing Housing Choice Vouchers (Section 8 rental subsidies): The Housing Authority of Monterey County is one of the public housing authorities that has recently had its federal funding for Section 8 cut back, consequently they were forced to lower their payment standard. As a result, the amount of rent that participating Salinas households will be required to pay will increase by 20% effective September 1, 2009. Housing Authority Resident Participation: The City has little direct involvement in the operation of public housing (which in this County is owned and operated by the Housing Authority of the County of Monterey - HACM). The City and Housing Authority have had in place a Cooperation Agreement for over three decades. While there is a good working relationship between the two agencies, at this point, it is not clear how the City would encourage actions by public housing residents. City staff do continue to work with HACM staff to help ensure that public housing activities are in accordance with the City’s Consolidated Plan. Transition Public Housing Residents to Homeownership: Staff has supported HACM plans to sell public housing units to tenants of public housing and has been working with their development staff on this effort. The Housing Authority has identified seven detached single family houses within the City to be transferred to public housing tenants. Salinas has set funds aside ($150,000) for possible use by public housing residents to purchase such units. This project has been delayed while awaiting HUD authorization to dispose of these public housing units. The Housing Authority also operates a Family Selfsufficiency Program (FSS) for its tenants whereby they can accrue funds to be used toward downpayment and other costs of acquiring a housing unit. Funding for Rehabilitation of HACM-managed Housing: Over the past several years, staff has recommended allocations of rehabilitation funds for use on MCHI-owned, HACM-managed units such as 15 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Parkside Manor. During the prior period, funding was provided to rehab eight ‘large family’ rental units using funds from the City HOME grant; this work was completed during this fiscal period. Tynan Village: The City allocated a total of $2.6 million in HOME funds for this 171-unit project developed by HACM in FY 05/06 and 06/07. In addition to HOME funds, the project was subsidized with State of California MHP loan and CalHFA HELP loan. Construction commenced in FY 07/08 and the project was completed in November 2008.. As noted elsewhere, Salinas has also allocated pre-development funding to the Housing Authority’s non-profit partner (MCHI) to encourage the development of additional large family subsidized housing on an existing MCHI site. Low priority: Continue outreach/education on lead-based paint. Lead-Based Paint (LBP) Inspections: As part of the City’s low-interest housing rehabilitation loan program, each unit receives a test for LBP hazards. The program offers a grant wherein if LBP is found in the unit, the owners are allowed a grant of up to $11,000 Citywide (and $14,000 in the AHNRSA). Certified LBP contractors carry out all LBP mediation work. The hazards where work is to occur are removed before the general contractor begins work. Property owners/renters may be relocated using the grant when necessary. Property owners/tenants receive educational materials on the environmental hazards of lead. Six units were tested for LBP hazards; only two received LBP funding totaling $16,063. Lead-Based Paint (LBP) Outreach: Each applicant receives a copy of the pamphlet “Protect Your Family from Lead in Your Home” at the application stage. The homeowner receives a copy of the inspection report and a copy of the clearance report once the work has been completed. If LBP is found in a unit and there are children present, staff recommends to the parents to seek blood-testing assistance from the Monterey County Health Department. Staff also encourages participating general contractors to attend classes/HUD training in dealing with both lead paint and asbestos in existing dwellings. Only Certified contractors are allowed to perform work on city rehabilitation projects. Staff continues to maintain a list of the units where LBP has been detected by the initial LBP inspection/testing report. Staff will be forwarding this information to the Monterey County Health Department on an annual basis. D. Non-Housing Community Development Needs High priority: Services for “at risk” youth. Action Council of Monterey County: “Girls Incorporated” after school program is for girls’ ages 9-18 at eight different school sites in East Salinas. Programs focus on pregnancy prevention, pursuing secondary education, leadership development, avoiding risky behaviors, developing healthy relationships, selfempowerment, resiliency skills and substance abuse prevention. Programs develop goal setting skills, assertiveness, communication skills, decision-making skills, the ability to handle peer pressures (middle & elementary school level), and provide factual information on health, hygiene, contraception, HIV/AIDS, and STD’s. 62% of the girls graduating from the high school program go on to college. Graduates are offered opportunities to return as staff, providing employment, training and experience in program planning, facilitation, public speaking, conflict resolution, mentoring skills and community action. The ECHO program component meets twice a month for a year; Smart Choices component is a week long summer program; the Will Power/Won’t Power program meets for ten weekly sessions; Friendly PEERsuasion is a two part program with 15 interactive workshops and Growing Together meets for five workshops. 976 very low/low-income girls from East Salinas received services in FY08-09 from the agency, which is an increase of 79 very low/low-income girls served in the previous funding cycle. Programs assist girls in creating leadership skills by promoting a safe, vibrant and healthy community by providing recreational activities for young girls. All the activities in this category were assisted with CDBG funds. 16 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Big Brothers, Big Sisters: This program provides one-to-one community based mentoring for children who come from single-parent families or disadvantaged homes in East Salinas. BBBS program is preventative in design to deter at-risk behavior. Children eligible are between the ages of 6-17 (with a priority on grades 4–7 when gang involvement generally begins). Goals of the program are to provide indepth positive relationships, build self-confidence, and to keep kids off the streets, out of gangs and the court system. Outside group activities for participants include bowling, swim parties and the annual picnic. Adult volunteers, who serve as role models, and youth spend approximately four hours a week together. The Salinas Expansion addition of the High School Bigs Program has been a huge success with another kick off at another high school in North Salinas. High school children “Bigs” ages 14 to 16 serve younger children in elementary schools. The “Littles” served are predominately from low-income families and must demonstrate a need for the service in various areas such as poor social skills, few friends, lack adequate support and attention of a stable adult. The benefits of the “Bigs” program is two fold: the Big is empowered and feels good about being a positive role model to a youngster in his/her community, while boosting the “Littles” self confidence, the Little has a positive role model to look up to in his/her community and receives educational assistance. Hours are varied and flexible to meet individual’s needs. A total of 277 Salinas disadvantaged youth were served multiple times in FY08-09 with 30 inquires into the Salinas Expansion addition of the High School Bigs Program. Breadbox Recreation Center: Program activities included TV and video games, movies, billards, arts and crafts, ping-pong, basketball, sports activities on the outside lawn area, and including a library area of books and magazines provided for the readers of the Salinas Library and trips to the library are offered. Teen dances, band nights and various field trips to the Rodeo, Muni Pool and local beaches are held throughout the year. The Breadbox hosted several special events the year including 3-on-3 Basketball Tournaments. The Breadbox Skate Club was established during this period and has given youth an outlet for skating and for participating in trips to skate parks in other cities. Staff has incorporated volunteer opportunities and community services as part of the program. Youth have picked up trash at parks and helped out at various recreation special events teaching youth the importance of giving back to their community. This fiscal year a homework center/computer lab was added by remodeling an old locker room into a study center. This homework club has had a regular attendance of 25 that meets three times a week since it’s opening. The Breadbox Recreation Center is located at 745 N. Sanborn Road in East Salinas and primarily serves low-income "at-risk" youth. The facility averages up to 150 participants per day who take part in the various activities that are offered. This program offers alternatives to gang membership. Hours of operation are 2:30-8:00pm Monday-Friday, 12:00-4:00pm on Saturday, summer hours are Monday-Friday 1:00pm-8:00pm. Vacation and holiday are the same as summer hours. A total of 318 very low/low-income youth were served multiple times with services in FY08-09. Firehouse Recreation Center: Recreational center for at-risk low-income youth and seniors in East Salinas. The center is located in census tract 09 where low-moderate income percentages are 78%+. This program provides a safe place for youth and seniors to come to and have fun to be involved in activities that they would not normally be able to participate in if at home. Program is open six days a week for all ages, Monday-Saturday. The seniors use the facility Monday-Friday (7:30AM-1:00PM) with programs and a daily lunch provided by Alisal Union School District Food Services. Food distribution drop off for at-risk low-income families is held daily to assist with daily nutritional needs. The after school programs are in the facility from 3:00-5:30PM being open on Saturdays from 12:00Noon to 4:00PM. The after school program provides snacks; time to do homework, sports activities, Guitar Hero, arts and crafts projects, games, computer lab, trips and special holiday events. Karate, Aikido, Vocal Techniques Class and Aztec Dance take place in the evenings from 6:30-8:30PM, Monday-Friday nights. A Teen Lounge, upstairs (Station 33) opened this year where teens can come before school (7:00AM until ½ hour before school starts) and after school for a safe, cool, place to hang out nights from 6:00-9:00PM for ages 13-17. 17 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report 209 Salinas seniors and youth were served in FY08-09 with multiple times of service. Attendance has doubled since reopening last year. Hebbron Recreation After School Program: Hebbron Family Recreation Center is located at 683 Fremont Street in Census Tract 05 and serves residents in the surrounding community, which are 70%+ low income households. Youth served are aged 5 to 18 years old. Hebbron Center is open (5) days per week Monday-Friday, 2:30 pm to 6:00 pm. During vacation times the center is open Monday-Friday, 12:00 pm-4:00 pm. Activities include computer lab (M-F, 1:00-5:30PM for schoolwork, a quiet homework area, arts and crafts, cooking, games, sports, table games and snacks plus field trips and special events. Free nutritious lunches and snacks are provided for youth ages 2-18 by the local Alisal Union School District during the summer and through out the year. This center offers activities that low-income youth/families would not normally be able to attend due to transportation and entry costs. Administered by City Recreation staff, this program is designed to reduce the level of drug use, reduce gang participation and to keep kids in school. A Teen Lounge was added to the site for teens to have a safe place to go and relax with other local teens. The Teen Lounge offers pool, Internet access on lap top computers with online tutors, assistance with homework needs and finding jobs. Hours are Monday-Friday before school, 7:00 am- 8:00 am with juice and bagels. After school hours are 3:00 pm-6:00 pm. The Girl Scouts of Monterey Bay (Troop 541) and The Citizenship Project (both with no fees), Karate Arts (minimal fee), Tiny Tots and Circle of Peace meetings provide programs at the site, in addition. BBQ’s, Family Harvest Day, Halloween in the Center, and Community Building Circle meetings are held at the site through out the year. A total of 162 youth were served multiple times this period, which is an increase over the previous year served. Partners for Peace: This program has had problems meeting deadlines along with reporting requirements for fiscal year 08-09. As of this date $1,351.34 has been drawn for the month of July 2008. The remaining balance of $8,648.66 will be re-allocated. The Executive Director for Partners for Peace has stepped down and the agency is operating with an Interim Director. The Program Manager has managed to continue the program and serve local residents. The Strengthening Families Program offers Gang Prevention/Intervention Counseling Services for at-risk families and youth ages 10-14 at the Silver Star Resource Center, Rancho Cielo, local school and faith-based institutions. This is a prevention/intervention supportive program which targets families in East Salinas and families that are at risk of involvement in the juvenile justice system. Program targets the most densely populated are of Salinas in East Salinas in census tracts 5,6,7 and 8 where the majority of violence occurs and where 62% of gang related crime take place. Agency serves at-risk youth between the ages of 10-16. Based on the values of respect, responsibility and compassion. Goal is to change the perception that violence is acceptable inevitable, or necessary. Partners for Peace works with parents, teens, school boards, government agencies, elected officials and other local non-profits. Fostering positive, long-term change and to encourage the community to embrace peace promoting values. A total of ? very low/low income Salinas youth were served numerous times in this fiscal year. Salinas Police Activity League: Salinas Police Activities League's (SPAL) objective is to provide as many youth-oriented programs as possible and develop a bond between police officers and children. Activities offered include karate, bowling, Jr. Giant’s baseball, soccer, basketball, baseball, girl’s softball, archery, ballet, computer, and Internet lab, horseback riding, Bicycle Safety Rodeo, kayaking along with social activities and field trips. SPAL provides positive role models along with a nurturing and safe environment where youth can experience success and gain self-esteem. Youth between the ages of 7 and 18 are eligible to participate. The office is located at 85 Maryal Street in Salinas at the Harden Youth Development Center. SPAL’s office is open Monday-Friday with flexible hours. Hours of operation vary 18 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report depending on the activity provided. A total of 1,735 Salinas youth were served multiple times in FY200809 with various different recreational activities to youth that would not have had this opportunity otherwise. Second Chance: The Second Chance Family & Youth Services offers youth gang violence reduction and prevention, one-on-one counseling, youth group counseling, parent education workshops and training sessions for law enforcement, educators and medical professionals. Second Chance conducts community presentations serving Salinas residents; walk-ins and/or phone referrals. Services included are in-home or office counseling for crisis, grief issues, school expulsion, juvenile offender, and violent aggressive behavior, runaway, and drug and alcohol abuse. Supportive services include awareness training on pre-gang behavior patterns. Office hours are Monday-Friday with hours of operation being 9:00am-5:00pm with alternating Saturdays. All services are bi-lingual in Spanish /English. Second Chance served a total of 146 residents of Salinas multiple times in FY08-09, which is a slight increase over last year’s clients served. Suicide Prevention Services of the Central Coast: This program provides bilingual education and resources aimed at reducing suicidal behavior by teaching coping skills, suicide warning signs, and how to get help for at-risk youth and adults. Participants learn how to recognize dangerous behaviors and how to respond appropriately. Suicide Prevention Services provides individual and group support along with intervention training, materials and resources, a 24 hour multilingual suicide crisis life line with sustaining services for those who are in immediate danger, (the crisis telephone line is not funded with CDBG). Youth ages 11-24 years and survivors are targeted for services. SPS served a total of 1,422 residents of the City of Salinas in FY08-09. YMCA-Alisal Community Friends: Program offers after school care for elementary school students on a first come, first served basis at no charge to families for the Alisal neighborhoods of East Salinas, providing a safe place for youth off the streets. The YMCA recruits, hires, and supervises Alisal Community Friends staff and volunteers to become Alisal Community Friends leaders to assist youth ages 5-12. Acting as role models, the leaders guide each child within a framework of self-empowerment. Each child is given certain activities according to their grade level, including assistance with homework. The participants also explore their creative abilities with arts and crafts, sports, games and more. At each site physical exercise is done for approximately a half hour to encourage healthy lifestyles. Program meets twice per week, to create positive changes in attitudes and behaviors at the following sites: Cesar Chavez Elementary School, Oscar Loya Elementary School, and the Mountain View Town Homes. All program sites are in Census Tract 7 where the percentage of low income is 72.80+. During the FY08-09 a total of 233 youth were served multiple times with services. Medium priority: Improved public parks. General Plan Policies: The current City of Salinas General Plan includes 20 policies relating to the provision of parks, recreation facilities, and recreation services (as referenced in the Consolidated Plan on page 80). The General Plan was adopted in September 2002 and is expected to guide development for twenty years. Some policies may not be implemented during the five-year span of this Consolidated Plan. City staff from a variety of departments are involved in the design, maintenance and operation of these facilities and services. As adopted Council policy, staff is obligated to adhere to these policies. An example of General Plan policies working to see that additional parks and facilities are provided is the Monte Bella subdivision -currently under development- where the Precise Plan calls for the developer to provide a community park site as a condition of development. Staff is presently working to develop a set of park standards that will serve to implement General Plan policies pertaining to the provision of parks in the community - particularly for the new development anticipated within the recently annexed 2400 acres of the north-east “future growth areas.” A long term community effort to replace the obsolete municipal pool has yielded positive results. Groundbreaking for the new Aquatic Center took place on June 2, 2008. The 2008-09 ACTION PLAN allocated $800,000 in CDBG funding to assist with the construction of this public facility. Construction of 19 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report the new pool is complete, with the grand opening scheduled in early September 2009. East Laurel Pocket Park-Replacement of Playground Equipment-City of Salinas: (# 9416) Project was allocated funding in FY 2007-08 Action Plan for removal of the degraded protective surface material and the existing play structures that have become obsolete (replacement parts are no longer available for these structures) and the installation of new ADA compliant play structures, protective surfacing material and safety signs. Project timeline was modified several times due to research of the most advantageous approach for successful awarding of the project. This project is combined with El Gabilan Play Lot project (#9046), also funded with CDBG monies for replacement of play equipment. Project was temporarily placed on hold in February of 2007 due to the city’s focus of prioritizing and initiating several capital improvement projects funded through Measure V as well as previously funded CDBG projects. On August 15, 2007, the on-hold status was lifted and engineering staff initiated a meeting to discuss the various bidding process alternatives. The revised project schedule included request for Council approval of plans and specifications on October 16, 2007; open bids on January 8, 2008, request for Council approval of contract award on January 29, 2008, and installed play equipment during May 2008. ADA ramps were completed during June 2008 with a completion date of July 3, 2008. El Gabilan Play Lot- Replacement of Playground Equipment-City of Salinas: (#9046) Project was allocated funding in FY 2007-08 Action Plan for the removal of the degraded protective surface material and the existing play structures that have become obsolete (replacement parts are no longer available for these structures) and the installation of new ADA complaint play structures, protective surfacing material and safety/information signs. The current play equipment at this location is a combination of old and new. This project is combined with East Laurel Pocket Park project (#9416). Project was temporarily placed on hold in February of 2007 due to the city’s focus of prioritizing and initiating several capital improvement projects funded through Measure V as well as previously funded CDBG projects. On August 15, 2007, the on-hold status was lifted and engineering staff initiated a meeting to discuss the various bidding process alternatives. The revised project schedule included; request Council approval of plans and specifications on October 16, 2007; open bids on January 8, 2008, request Council approval of contract award on January 29, 2008, and installed play equipment during May 2008. ADA ramps were completed during June 2008 with a completion date of July 3, 2008. This project is the same as the East Laurel Pocket Park (#9416) as both sites are combined into one project to achieve economies of scale. E. Other Support Services/Facilities/Public Improvements This category provides a place to incorporate non-housing support services, facilities, and physical improvements that do not fall neatly into one category, but provide services or assistance to a variety of the categories of residents listed in the priorities. Also discussed in this section are projects funded from previous years that are currently underway or that were completed this fiscal year. Super Parents Program-Community Human Services: This program is a supervised parent visitation and parent education program that focuses on child abuse prevention. Super Parents allows affected children to continue a relationship with the non-custodial parent and improve parenting skills. Services are offered on a sliding fee scale depending upon income levels particularly for low and very low-income clients who may pay as little as $20.00 a visit. Services support improved parenting and healthy family relationships decreasing domestic violence, child abuse and juvenile delinquency. Without this program domestic violence would continue to fester in the community and for these young children. It has been proven that children who are abused grow up to abuse their children. Super Parents programs gives parents a better understanding of the responsibilities of parenting while encouraging and building selfesteem. Referrals come from social services and the court systems, interagency referrals from the outpatient mental health and drug treatment programs of Community Human Services. Services are provided in English and Spanish and are available seven days a week with appointments. 20 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Super Parents promotes a safe and peaceful community by decreasing domestic violence within the City allowing children to have a better life. Super Parents served a total of 195 Salinas residents with multiple visits in FY08-09. Conflict Resolution and Mediation Center of Monterey County: This program provides free fair housing activities to low-income Salinas’ residents, dispute mediation, and landlord-tenant education. Housing disputes: disputes regarding security deposits, lease conditions, repairs and habitability, noise, pets, property disputes, insurance issues, evictions, non-payment of rent, discrimination. Conflict Resolution and Mediation Center of Monterey County provides key public services that address quality of life issues for residents at no cost to very low, low and moderate-income residents. Information and education regarding non-discriminatory housing practices are a key aspect of this agency’s services to Salinas. Office hours are 9:00am-12:00pm and 1:00pm-4:00pm, Monday through Friday. Hearings and on-site case development services are provided evening, weekends or during the day at the convenience of the parties involved. Staff and volunteers are bilingual and bicultural. A total of 449 Salinas residents were served in FY08-09. Door to Hope: This program provides a residential substance abuse recovery services for indigent/homeless women over the age of 18 who are homeless due to chronic substance abuse. Door to Hope provides regular medical services with a physician providing support for client’s physical health, including ambulatory detoxification, health screening, evaluations, consultations and referral services. A licensed psychologist provides professional medical, psychological testing, clinical supervision and therapeutic services. Over 70% of women with substance abuse experience have co-existing mental illness, i.e. depression, bi-polar disorders, and trauma disorders, or domestic violence, sexual abuse, and victimization. 78% of the women served are between the ages of 18-35. 62% reside in the City of Salinas. 75% were addicted to methamphetamines. Door to Hope has a 14-bed capacity at its residential recovery center located in Salinas. Staffing is bilingual to assist with the Hispanic community. Hours of operation are treatment services twenty-four hours per day, seven days a week. A total of 90 Salinas women received services multiple times by Door to Hope during FY08-09. Food Bank for Monterey County: This nutritional program distributes food to over 41 non-profit food assistance agencies that serve the working poor, the unemployed, the elderly, the chronically ill, and the homeless population. In addition, food is distributed at 11 different sites in Salinas through two different programs. Member agencies include church food outreach ministries, emergency food pantries, soup kitchens, and services for the homebound, homeless shelters, group shelters, domestic violence shelters, rehab. programs; job training, ad placement programs, residential treatment programs, low-income day care centers, youth programs, after school programs, HIV/AIDS programs, senior centers and the Meals on Wheels of Salinas Valley. Numbers served have greatly increased in the area on a daily basis due to the slump in the economy, consumers served have more than doubled for this time of year. A total of 8,514 very low/low-income Salinas residents were served with nutritious food multiple times in FY08-09. Sunrise House: Drug Prevention/Education Services to high-risk youth and families in Salinas offers counseling, crisis-intervention, presentations and referral services. Full time bilingual staff is located at each high school campus in Salinas. Gang issues, mental & physical abuse, substance abuse, grief and other personal problems are some of the items that a dealt with. The youth alternative violence program is a seven week course offered to youth who are experiencing anger/gang problems. Agency works with other local non-profits and the Mo. Co. Probation Dept., Mo. Co. Behavioral Health Dept., Mo. Co. Housing Authority, Salinas Union High School District (which educates over 74% of local youth) and other local school districts. Hours of operation are seven days a week with service available 24 hours a day, at no cost to consumers in crisis situations. Purpose of the agency is to reduce the use of alcohol and drugs by young people and the misuse & abuse of drugs in the community promoting a family unity. 2,780 youth were served multiple times by the Sunrise House during FY08-09. 21 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Sun Street Centers: The services offered are an alcohol and drug program at Gente del Sol Community Recovery Center on Williams Road in East Salinas. Sun Street provides drop-in counseling, crisis intervention, legal assistance, and information, referrals, pregnancy issues and support groups three nights a week in Spanish for Alanon, Alateen, and Narcotic Anonymous participants. Community members, including those of low and very low-incomes, who utilize the services learn how to take an active role in keeping neighborhoods safe and peaceful. The Safe Teens Empowerment Program (S.T.E.PS.) program teaches teen leaders to provide education and training on the uses of alcohol, drugs, and violence prevention skills to elementary, middle school and high school students, many of which are at-risk youth. The staff at the site is bilingual/bicultural. The center is open six days a week, including evening hours. Sun Street Center served 201 Hispanic very low/low-income Salinas residents with multiple services in FY08-09. VNA Community Services: The Salinas Adult Day Center Program provides care to very low/low-income seniors that are inflicted with senile dementia, stroke and Alzheimer’s. Program operates on a daily basis to give the families who care for the senior a respite to prevent burn out and allowing seniors to remain in their own home or the family home. These types of clients tend to be high risk due to social isolation, decreased mental capacity, lack of support systems, unsafe or unstable home environments, and emotional deprivation compounded by declining financial resources. Activities offered include exercise, crafts, interactive games, thinking games, and music. Bi-lingual program offered in both English and Spanish. Hot nutritious lunches provided daily by Alisal School District. Hours of operation are MondayFriday 9am to 2:30pm. 375 Salinas senior residents were served multiple times in FY08-09, this is an increase over clients served in FY07-08. Salinas Municipal Aquatic Center: (CIP#9761) Project was allocated initial funding in FY 2008-09 Action Plan for construction of a new modern swimming pool complex to accommodate recreational and competitive aquatic sports. New pool facility is adjacent to existing swimming pool to be retired once new Aquatic Center is open. Existing building will be retained and most likely be renovated into a recreational facility. The Aquatic Center is designed to comply with a Certification Level according to the U.S. Green Building Council’s Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) Rating System. Project financing includes: City’s General Funds, proceeds from the sale of Crazy Horse landfill, Federal Grants, State Grants, Developer Annexation fees, State Housing Grants and Salinas Pool Foundation fund raising. On January 28, 2008, the City Council approved the plans and specifications for the Salinas Municipal Aquatic Center and authorized issuance of invitation to bid, with bids to open on March 14, 2008. The project was divided into two base bids (1 & 2) to give the City the flexibility to withhold award of Base Bid 1 for 120 calendar days depending on available funding. Base Bid 1 includes construction of a new pool and all associated work and utilities. Base Bid 2 includes construction of the entry plaza, parking lot, sidewalk, driveway, storm drain system, bioswales, landscaping, and irrigation system. Additive Alternative No. 1 includes installation of a photovoltaic system for the Aquatic Center to use solar cells to convert light into energy. 22 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report On February 20, 2008 a pre-bid information walkthrough was held. On March 14, 2008 a total of three bids were submitted that included BRCO Constructors, Inc., Davis Moreno Construction, Inc., and Gonsalvez & Stronck Construction Co., Inc. BRCO Contractors, Inc. was the apparent low bidder. On April 15, 2008, the City Council adopted a resolution rejecting the apparent low bidder (BRCO) as nonresponsive and awarded the contract to the second lowest bidder, Davis Moreno Construction, Inc. for $7,168,747 (Base Bid 1 only). The Aquatic Center Groundbreaking Ceremony was held on June 2, 2008, various state and local officials attended. On June 17, 2008, the City Council awarded the Base Bid 2 to Davis Moreno Construction, Inc. in the amount of $1,282,018. Total estimated project costs for Base Bid 1 and 2 is $9, 024, 765. On July 8, 2008, the City Council approved Amendment No. 1 to the existing professional services agreement between the City of Salinas and Earth Systems Pacific adding construction support services for the Aquatic Center in the amount of $56,523. Services include geotechnical, special testing, and special inspection services needed during construction. On September 5, 2008, the City of Salinas Memorandum of Record was executed for the FY 2008-09 CDBG allocation of $800,000. During July 2009 project construction remained underway with several punch list items scheduled for completion in early August 2009. Currently, project has 17 Contract Change Orders. A grand opening ceremony was held on July 30, 2009 and a ribbon cutting ceremony was held on September 2, 2009. Attendance at ribbon cutting ceremony included representatives from Congressman Sam Farr's office (17th District of California), Assemblymember Anna Caballero ( 28th Assembly District), and various city and county public officials. While construction is complete and the pool is scheduled to open during the Labor Day weekend, the project needs to be accepted by the City Council for Maintenance and Responsibility and Notice of Completion needs to be issued. Breadbox Recreation Center-Interior Improvements-City of Salinas: (#9043) Project was reallocated funding in FY06-07 with an informal bid process (less than $50,000.) for constructing a separation wall to divide the building in half, to allow the Breadbox Recreation Center to become a more usable, multi-use facility; minor electrical work, adding an exterior emergency exit door to meet code requirements. A former locker room was remodeled to become a computer lab/homework center that was needed for the site. Currently, another non-profit, Alisal Center of the Fine Arts is located on the other side of the Breadbox Wall. Notice to proceed was issued on 2/2/09. Work was completed and recorded at Monterey County on 4/24/09. Projects from Previous Years East Alisal at Towt Traffic Signal-City of Salinas: (# 9044) Project was allocated funding in FY 2007-08 Action Plan for installation of a traffic signal at the intersection of East Alisal and Towt Street which includes; pavement resurfacing, crosswalk striping, left turn storage increase, ADA-complaint push buttons, audible pedestrian signal, and ADA-complaint pedestrian access ramps. In April of 2007, bulbouts were added to the design, resulting in the need for two catch basins. Thus, the timeframe for design completion was extended. Funds to accomplish design and engineering of the signal were provided in the previous year Action Plan. In May of 2007, Landset Engineers performed a survey to provide a topographic of the area that was completed on May 23, 2007. In June of 2007, an additional ADA ramp was included as a result of the added bulb-outs. Design work received department approval on July 13, 2007. On August 14, 2007, the City Council approved the plans and specifications and authorized issuance of invitation to bid, with bids open on September 25, 2007. Project was awarded on August 24, 2007, with completion on June 3, 2008, City Council acceptance on July 8, 2008. East Salinas Area Street Lights Phase 9-City of Salinas: (#9037) Project was allocated funding in FY 2005-06 Action Plan or the installation of fifty five (55) new streetlights in the area of Oregon Street, Washington Drive, Linden Street, Circle Drive, Valencia Street, Dolores Street, Kentucky Street, Myrtle Street, Eucalyptus Drive, 1st Avenue, Joseph Circle, Bellehaven Street and Alma Street. 23 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report As previously reported, Phase 9 CDBG allocation increased from $620,000 to $690,000. This project was reported as completed during the prior CAPER reporting period (FY 2007-08). However, project was completed during FY 2008-09 as on August 19, 2008, the City Council accepted the project (Phase 9,10 & 14) for Maintenance and Responsibility. Project is complete and residents living in the project area have enhanced street illumination and safer neighborhoods. F. Certification that the FY 2008-09 Action Plan Carried Out The Consolidated Plan The City of Salinas' use of funds received from Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), HOME Investment Partnerships, and Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) programs through its FY 2008-09 Action Plan has assisted the furtherance of the City’s goals found in the adopted FY 2006-2010 Consolidated Plan. As has been the case in prior years, Salinas Redevelopment Agency (SRA) resources were also applied to address housing and community development objectives. The planned Gateway Apartments will provide affordable rental housing in downtown Salinas, with a portion of the units set aside for developmentally disabled adults seeking independent living opportunities. The Redevelopment Agency previously provided a $910,000 loan to First Community Housing, Inc. (a non-profit housing developer) to assist with the acquisition of the site on Lincoln Avenue, as well as an additional $300,000 for predevelopment expenses. The State’s failure to honor its financing commitment has increased the costs to develop this project, resulting in a request to increase the financial support from the Agency. The Council’s Housing Subcommittee has recommended approval of this request; formal action by the Agency is anticipated in July 2009. [This project has been allocated HOME funding via the City’s ACTION PLAN.] Agency housing funds are also being considered for allocation to two proposed CHISPA projects: the La Gloria Senior Apartments (new construction on E. Market Street) and Vista de la Terraza (acquisition and rehab of existing affordable apartment complex in Hebbron Heights). As reported in the last CAPER, the Redevelopment Agency is examining the feasibility of expanding one or both of the City’s redevelopment project areas. Progress on this has been slowed by the reorganization of the City offices responsible for redevelopment, planning, housing and community development into one department. An expansion of project areas is likely to increase tax increment revenues, providing additional resources for economic revitalization and for housing development/ preservation. There are two private proposals for redevelopment of commercial areas in Salinas that are under consideration; in each case, it is anticipated that projects will include the provision of new housing units. This coming fiscal year, the Agency’s resources are liable to reduction via State actions to balance the State budget, despite the recent court case confirming that such raids are in conflict with the State’s constitution. The City continues to work cooperatively with agencies such as the Coalition of Homeless Services Providers of Monterey County, the Housing Authority of Monterey County (HACM), Monterey County Housing, Inc. (MCHI), CHISPA, Interim, and others, by providing technical assistance and written support for their various funding applications in support of both construction of new facilities as well as renovation of existing housing. The City also continues to support the Housing Authority’s efforts to address the needs of low-income households through the Section 8 program and the existing stock of public and other assisted housing. G. Displacement Activity During 2008-09, there was displacement as a consequence of acquisition, construction, or rehabilitation activities funded by Salinas using HOME, CDBG, or ESG funds. Relocation assistance was provided to five (5) families residing on the site of the proposed Wesley Oaks Subdivision at the corner of Fremont and Carr Avenues. On November 15, 2007, City staff coordinated a meeting between HUD Relocation staff from San Francisco, Jay Smith, Relocation Specialist and CHISPA (the developer of 24 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Wesley Oaks). The CDBG funding agreement was executed on August 26, 2008. On November 23, 2007, CHISPA entered into a contractual agreement for Professional Relocation Services with Linda A. Norwood, Relocation Consultant. On February 1, 2008 a relocation meeting was held with all existing tenants. On February 15, 2008, the City of Salinas approved the Relocation Plan for Wesley Oaks. To date, all five households entitled to Relocation benefits have been relocated. Of those, two households used their relocation benefits to purchase a single-family home. The Lopez family closed escrow on November 19, 2008 and the Barajas family on May 1, 2009. Presently, the Relocation Consultant is assisting one more household to purchase an affordable single-family home. CHISPA goal is to obtain homeownership for all five families. H. Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area The Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area covers an area approximately 2.5 square miles, or about 12 percent of the City area (a map of the Strategy Area appears in the appendix). The neighborhood includes approximately 6,000 housing units and roughly 20 percent of the City’s population. This area includes some of the most densely populated areas within the City. Establishment of the Strategy Area focused and expanded previous efforts that had been initiated to revitalize the neighborhoods experiencing the greatest social and economic difficulties in the City. All of the Strategy Area was annexed into the City of Salinas during the 1960's, following development under as an unincorporated area under County jurisdiction. As such, development standards were not as rigorous as those in the City and the public infrastructure (e.g., streets, curbs & gutters, storm drains, water lines) typically was inappropriate considering the degree of development that occurred over time. Added to these challenging conditions were high levels of unemployment; the community’s highest level of poverty; and, the highest rate of violent criminal activity. Actions to increase homeownership, stimulate economic development, and improve the neighborhood have been implemented in the years since the designation as a NSRA. Over the years, the City has worked to increase recreational opportunities through the provision of facilities and services (e.g., creation of Chavez Community Park, purchase and operation of the Hebbron Heights Neighborhood Center and the Bread Box recreation center, installation of ADA-compliant restrooms at Closter Park). Furthering efforts to develop a synergy leading to broadscale improvements, the majority of the City’s Sunset Redevelopment District is located within the boundaries of the Strategy Area. This period saw the following activities: (a) continuing assistance to the Salinas’ first CHDO (i.e., CHISPA) as they work to develop a 10 unit single family subdivision despite the much more restricted financing options resulting from the sub-prime lending crisis; (b) the ongoing implementation of a “Weed and Seed” program established through successive U.S. Department of Justice grants; (c) installation of interior improvements in the Bread Box Rec Center to better accommodate the relocated Alisal Center for the Fine Arts; (d) HOME funding to CHISPA to acquire the site for the La Gloria Senior Apartments development; and (e) additional CDBG funding for the design of new streetlights to be installed as part of Phase 11 of the City’s East Salinas Street Lighting Project . Streetlights provided in the NSRA as Phases 9 and 10 of the East Salinas Street Light Project, while physically installed during the prior period, were energized by PG&E this period and are now providing an important deterrent to night-time crime. Redevelopment staff continue to actively work with the Salinas United Business Association (SUBA) to create opportunities and stimulate investment where they will reap the greatest rewards. SUBA is based in the AlisalMarket commercial corridor, in the heart of the Strategy Area. The Agency’s Jazz Up program (partially funded with HUD CDBG funds) provides graffiti abatement and cosmetic improvements to properties in the AHNRSA. 25 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Park Improvement Projects (CIP 9416-East Laurel Pocket Park) Several neighborhood parks serve the Strategy Area, including East Laurel Pocket Park. During this period, CIP 9416-Installation of ADA Play equipment at East Laurel Pocket Park was accepted by the City Council for Maintenance and Responsibility on September 9, 2008. Also, East Salinas Area Street Lights Phase IX, X, XI located within the strategy area were accepted by the City Council for Maintenance and Responsibility on August 19, 2008. The Breadbox Gymnasium Divider Wall, CIP #9043, was accepted by the City Council for Maintenance and Responsibility on March 17, 2009. The traffic signal installation within the Strategy Area (East Alisal and Towt Street), CIP #9044 funded in FY 200708 Action Plan in the amount of $435,000 was accepted by the City Council for Maintenance and Responsibility on July 8, 2008. Upcoming project within the strategy area include the East Salinas Area Street Lights Phase XI, Construction Costs only funded in FY 2009-10 Action Plan for $759,000 will install 51new street lights. On July 21, 2009, the Salinas City Council approved the plans and specifications and issuance of invitation to bid, with bids to open on August 18, 2009. Housing Rehabilitation Program Last year, 5 housing rehabilitation loans were made to owner-occupants within the Strategy Area; this year there were three. These loans are staff-intensive projects; there were also three Housing Accessibility grants provided within the Area. In recent years, many of these grants have been going to residents of mobile homes and there are very few such units within the Strategy Area; this year all grants were on single family dwellings. The costs for these rehabilitation/HAA projects have stabilized or slightly have reduced in cost due to the downturn in the Construction Industry. Staff has added 4 contractors to our contractor’s list. Before After Jazz-Up Program-Neighborhood Fix-Up The Jazz-Up program ($50,000.CDBG funds) is over-seen by the Salinas Redevelopment Agency and provides services in East Salinas to both commercial and residential structures. Program paints, cleans up and does minor repairs to eligible business properties and for low-income homeowners. The Agency has enlisted the aide of the Second Chance program to administer and operate this activity; youth participating in their anti-gang efforts assist by providing volunteer labor. Providing this service enhances neighborhoods and helps to encourage other property owners to upgrade the appearance of their property. In prior years, this activity has also assisted clients receiving rehabilitation services from the City's Housing Services Program; staff has been working with SRA staff to re-establish this relationship. This year the City Housing Services Program merged with SRA. In the FY08-09 funding cycle a total of 9 residences and 6 commercial properties have been painted and fixed up and revitalized. All properties are located in targeted areas of Census Tracts 5,6,7 and portions of 8 in the Sunset Redevelopment area. 26 of 60 City of Salinas II. 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report AFFIRMATIVELY FURTHERING FAIR HOUSING Economic conditions and the shortage of affordable housing continue to be the most significant impediment to fair housing in our community. Prior to the sub-prime mortgage meltdown, the Salinas housing market was regularly ranked as one of the top ten areas in the nation where housing costs were the highest in relation to incomes. In December 2008, the Salinas newspaper carried an article reporting that the one year decline in Salinas housing prices was the largest such decline in the nation: a 29% drop. The same article noted that 9 of the 10 areas with the greatest declines were located in California (source cited: First American CoreLogic). For renters seeking to purchase homes, this price decline is welcome, although tempered by a concurrent tightening of credit and lending standards. For existing owners, for lenders, for jurisdictions dependent upon property tax revenues, this level of home price depreciation is nothing short of a disaster. As evidenced by recent commentary from the Secretary of the Treasury, federal efforts to encourage lenders and mortgage servicers to modify loans and take other steps to reduce the number of foreclosures have been less than successful. Actions undertaken to overcome this impediment include the following: Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice Having long recognized the need to formally update the City’s Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice, the City prepared a new ‘Analysis’ for the 2006-2010 Consolidated Plan period. This section discusses the conclusions found in the Analysis, and City actions addressing identified barriers. Affordability is identified as the “most pressing housing issue” in Salinas. Five specific City actions are identified to help address this issue. The first was to update City Inclusionary Housing requirements: as reported last year, this action has been completed. [As this is written staff has just learned of a challenge to the authority of cities to establish inclusionary housing requirements for rental projects. Unless the case is overturned upon appeal, or there is legislation to confirm the authority, the ability of the City to increase the supply of affordable units will be seriously compromised.] Other actions relating to affordability call for: 1) continued support for developers of affordable housing; 2) continued encouragement of non-City programs addressing affordability for low-income residents; 3) ensuring that affordable unit selection remains an open, public process; and 4) ongoing operation of the City’s First-Time Homebuyer program. The first two of these were successfully undertaken this period. The third was also carried out, however, it should be noted that the decline in housing production meant that most unit selection activity pertained to turnover in existing units, rather than filling newly-built units. The downpayment assistance program was discontinued two years prior, due to spiraling housing cost inflation. With median prices for single family housing above $500,000, and for condominiums around $300,000, the gap between the loans that low income families could afford and market prices would have required individual downpayment loans in excess of $100,000. At the end of this reporting period the City Council adopted the ACTION PLAN for FY2009-10: included was $465,000 in CDBG funding to restart the downpayment assistance program. A second opportunity to help first time buyers should open up this coming fiscal year once the State of California releases federal funds to the City through the first phase of the Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP). It should be noted that the rash of foreclosures on many California housing units has not spread to households that used the City’s first-time buyer downpayment loans, primarily due to the City’s reluctance to participate in aggressive lending practices such as ‘option ARMS’ and ‘no documentation’ loans. Language and lack of fluency in English can contribute to creating a barrier to fair housing. By far the largest nonEnglish speaking group in Salinas is Spanish-speaking. [While the Salinas Valley has areas where recent immigrants from Mexico are fluent only in native Indian languages, it is not believed that there is a significant number in Salinas.] In recognition of this, Salinas is diligent in ensuring that affordable housing opportunities are advertised in local Spanishlanguage print media. Developers are required to advertise the availability of inclusionary units in Spanish through stipulations in Affordable Housing Plans. The City has prepared, and has available at City Hall and in each of the City’s three libraries, brochures in both English and Spanish on the City’s Housing Services Program (home repair and improvement loans), and Housing Accessibility Grants. Five members of the City’s Housing and Community Development Division staff are bilingual in English/Spanish and an additional staff member in English/Tagalog. Nonprofit agencies receiving City funding are encouraged to provide bilingual outreach materials and to employ staff fluent in Spanish. Housing counseling services provided by the Housing Resource Center (the successor agency to the Housing 27 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Advocacy Council and the Monterey County Housing Alliance) and the Conflict Resolution & Mediation Center are each funded by City with CDBG; each agency has bilingual (English/Spanish) staff and provides materials in the two languages. Inadequate means of access to housing for persons with a disability, and for households with family members with a disability, is identified as a barrier. During this period the Housing Services Program provided “Handicap Accessibility Grants” to six low income households allowing them to remove physical barriers within their dwellings. The City also provided First Community Housing with predevelopment funding (HOME) for the Gateway Apartment project in downtown Salinas; about half of these rental units will be set aside for the developmentally disabled. Staff has become knowledgeable with the concept of “universal design” and has employed such techniques on the three units built in partnership with CHISPA and Hartnell College. Future such units will also include these features, which mean that units are constructed in ways that facilitate later modification for accessibility if needed by occupants. An impediment identified in the City’s Analysis of Impediments was that of public transportation. The Monterey Salinas Transit agency periodically reviews its service areas and its routes to better serve its clients; routes are then revised to better meet underserved areas. The revised transit routes benefit the community by creating better linkages from lowincome/high minority neighborhoods in Salinas with health care, employment, shopping and education. Unfortunately, the resources available to the Transit agency to supplement fare box revenue has continued to decline, this sometimes leads to the elimination of routes or reduction of service on existing routes, when an expansion of service would be much more desirable. The City’s General Plan calls for increased density of development in areas identified for growth; over time such increased densities should help make public transportation more feasible. Another factor that impedes housing opportunity is lack of knowledge, both on the part of the community as a whole and by individuals and households seeking to improve their housing situation. During this period CDBG funds were provided to the following organizations to assist them in their mission to inform and educate: Alliance on Aging’s “Ombudsman for Long Term Care” program ($5,000) assisted individuals in nursing homes & similar facilities, as well as their family members; Conflict Resolution and Mediation Center ($10,000) served lower income Salinas households with landlordtenant mediation, fair housing information and other services; and Central Coast Center for Independent Living ($10,000) provides housing services for people with disabilities. Several other public services sub-recipients (described in other sections) also provide important educational services relating to housing and to the elimination of illegal discrimination: John XXIII AIDS Ministry; Interim; and the Franciscan Workers. Housing Resource Center activities are discussed in detail below. Housing Resource Center (HRC) MoCHA was a public/private partnership created to expand mortgage credit opportunities in the Salinas Valley area; the non-profit group subsequently broadened its scope to encompass the entire county - at that time changing its name to: Monterey County Housing Alliance (or MoCHA). The group’s efforts were successful, developing a one-stop homeownership assistance center offering pre- and postpurchase homebuyer education and counseling; financial and debt management counseling; access to community lending mortgage products; and access to homebuyer resources offered by public and private agencies. The Center opened on August 27, 2002; MoCHA was certified by HUD as a Housing Counseling Agency in May 2006. Establishing a base of long term financial support proved difficult. In prior years staff investigated options for adding either HOME or CDBG resources to MoCHA’s mix of funding sources, but found that regulatory constraints within each program preclude their use. The City again provided $10,000 this fiscal year to support the homeownership assistance center’s ongoing activities. The 2009-19 ACTION PLAN allocates $20,000 to the same purpose. The source is program income from a discontinued HUD program (“RRP”). 28 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report The City has long supported the work of another local non-profit: Housing Advocacy Council, with CDBG public services funds. The focus of this organization has been assistance to lower income rental households. The Housing Advocacy Council operated a rental deposit guarantee program and provided other services to help tenants avoid eviction. During this year, after protracted negotiations, the two agencies merged to form the Housing Resource Center of Monterey County (HRC). This merger should help provide greater financial stability for the homeownership center, which is critical due to increasing demand for their services resulting from the housing crisis. HRC has received operational funding from the State Department of Housing & Community Development (through the Monterey County Housing & Redevelopment Department). After responding to the City’s Request for Proposals to use the newly available Homeless Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Program (created by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009), the City selected HRC as the prime contractor for HPRP in Salinas. HRC and the City are awaiting HUD approval of the City’s Substantial Amendment to the 2008-09 ACTION PLAN for $1 million in one-time HPRP funds. Once the Grant Agreement is in hand, HRC will directly provide many of the services HPRP allows - all focusing upon keeping families from becoming homeless and on getting the recently homeless re-housed. HRC will also work cooperatively with other non-profit providers whose clients need this type of assistance; such joint efforts should reduce the administrative costs typically associated with such staff-intensive services Housing Rehabilitation Program The City recognizes that its single greatest source of affordable housing is its existing housing stock. To preserve and enhance this valuable affordable housing resource, the City continues to operate a Housing Rehabilitation Loan and Housing Accessibility Grant Program. Through the loan program, low-interest loans are provided to low-income owner/occupants and to landlords who rent to low-income households for the rehabilitation and enhancement of their property. During this period, one single-family house was rehabilitated for lower income owner-occupants, using a direct rehab loan requiring monthly payments. III. AFFORDABLE HOUSING Table 2A in the City’s 2006-2010 Consolidated Plan (found at page 107) identifies five “high priority” housing needs for our community: small family rental housing (31 to 50% of median); small family rental housing (51 to 80% median); large family rental housing (0 to 30% median); large family rental housing (31 to 50% median); and owner occupied family housing (51 to 80% of median). ‘Medium priority’ housing needs listed includes: elderly renters (0 to 30%, 31 to 50% and 51 to 80% median); small family rental housing (0 to 30% median); large family rental housing (51 to 80% median); owner occupied family housing (31 to 50% median); and special needs population (0 to 80%). As a moderately-sized community with limited resources (and constrained by a State-wide taxation system that precludes some of the revenue generation options available to municipalities elsewhere), the City of Salinas has a three point strategy to address affordable housing needs: • • • aggressive use of police powers (including the use of redevelopment authority) secure all possible federal and state funding promote partnership with other governmental entities, and with both the non-profit and for-profit housing sectors In California, affordable housing is critical to the attraction and retention of employers. Improving the City’s image and reducing violence are two goals enunciated by our City Council that are intricately connected to the quality of life, which is itself very much impacted by the housing in which we live. Households that are forced by high housing costs to take on multiple jobs, or to double up in units, or commute long distances, have little time available for civic involvement. Access to affordable housing is of major importance to the community and its vision. The following paragraphs describe City actions taken during this reporting period to address affordable housing priorities. Due to limited resources, the City has concentrated upon developing housing programs that cut across the priorities. In most cases, our programs and activities are not focused on one unique housing need, but, are designed to address multiple priorities. Thus we have adopted an inclusionary housing ordinance that will provide affordable housing to four targeted income 29 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report groups; there will be both rental and ownership inclusionary units, however, not each type will be available for each income group. Similarly, a portion of inclusionary units provided are required to have 3 or more bedrooms, thereby suitable for larger families. This strategy of ‘broad targeting’ does not preclude the use of programs and funding that is focused upon specific groups within the priority ranking. For example, the City strongly supported INTERIM Inc.’s application for State Mental Health Services Act financing for the 18 unit rental project for single, disabled adults (Sunflower Gardens) that is now under construction. And during a prior year, Salinas provided funding to CHISPA to convert an obsolete motel into affordable senior housing; unexpected costs resulting from ‘surprises’ during renovation, and from imposition of new federal stormwater rules, resulted in a funding shortfall. This cycle the City’s ACTION PLAN committed an additional $350,000 for CHISPA for the Sherwood Village project. A general point is that special needs groups will benefit -both directly and indirectly- from housing production programs that are not specifically targeted to their needs: for example, seniors are not precluded from occupying small family rental housing units and farmworker families (needing no special physical accommodation) can benefit from many different programs that produce affordable units. As more units are produced, especially more that are required to be affordable, special needs groups will indirectly benefit because overall demand for units will decrease. Family Housing Each of the five high priority housing needs falls into the general category of “family housing,” with four needs concerning rental housing (small family very low & low income, and large family extremely low & very low) and one need relating to low income ownership units. The City’s Housing Services Program continues to offer housing rehabilitation services to property owners of multifamily and single-family rental housing. For several decades Salinas has offered rental rehabilitation loans to private owners but with only limited success. Staff believes that continued high demand for rental housing serves as a disincentive to for-profit property owners because properties can be rented at high rates despite needing repair. This remains the case even though it appears there has been an increase in the overall rental vacancy rate in Salinas this period. It has been several years since a rehabilitation loan was provided for use on an apartment project. Low-income owner-occupied units receive housing rehabilitation assistance (inspections, work-writeups, contractor facilitation, and direct or deferred payment loans) through the City’s Housing Services Program. In 2008-09 only one such single family house was rehabilitated; this project also received a grant to cover the costs of lead paint abatement. During the same period six Housing Accessibility Assistance grants were provided to owner-occupants; these grants are used to modify dwellings for those that have mobility challenges (e.g., confined to wheelchair). Typical improvements include entrance ramps, replacement of bathtubs with showers, and widening doorframes. A major component of the City’s strategy to provide housing to these high priority groups is the Inclusionary Housing Program. Adopted in August 2005 pursuant to the City’s police powers, the ordinance now mandates that minimum of 20% of all new projects (containing 10 or more units) be provided at affordable housing prices to four income categories: very low, low, moderate (81-120% of median) and workforce (121-160% of area median income). Rental units are required to maintain affordable rents for a minimum of thirty years. Ownership units will remain affordable for the same period, unless the homeowner opts to sell, however, the equity sharing feature helps ensure that a sufficient portion of the sales proceeds will come to the City to be used to assist other qualifying families. The new ordinance mandates a significant number of inclusionary units contain at least three bedrooms, thereby serving larger households. [low income and very low income small rentals] Of the five identified medium priority housing needs, three pertain to family housing: extremely low income small family rental; low-income large family rental; and very low income ownership units. Of the six Housing Accessibility Assistance grants provided by the City during 2008-09, four (67%) were made to very low income homeowners - a medium priority housing category, one to an extremely low income homeowner, and one to a low income homeowner. An unanticipated effect of the sub-prime housing crisis (and following recession) has been the sharp decline in homeowners willing to pursue Housing Services’ rehabilitation loan programs. During this period only one rehabilitation loan was made, the lowest level of production in the some 30 years of the program; this family is classified as very low income. Rehabilitation loans and Housing Accessibility grants are reported the year that they are granted; actual construction work often continues into the following reporting period. 30 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report The “Sunflower Gardens” apartment project under construction by Interim, Inc. will provide affordable rental housing for very low income individuals with psychiatric disabilities (many of whom are expected to fall into the category of ‘extremely low income’). Interim will be the first entity in Monterey County to secure financing from the new State Mental Health Services Act funding; this effort is being supplemented by additional financial support from a variety of sources, including the Salinas Redevelopment Agency and a contribution to equity from local fundraising efforts by Interim. [extremely low income small rentals] Completed this reporting period, “Tynan Village” is on a six acre site located between downtown Salinas and the Alisal commercial district. A higher density infill project being built on the site of a former lumberyard, Tynan’s 171 apartments feature a mix of sizes (ranging from one to four bedrooms, with 54% having 3 or more bedrooms), as well as a mix of income levels. In addition, some 12,000 square feet of commercial lease space occupies a prominent location at the front of the site. In all, sixty-two percent of Tynan’s units will be provided with restricted rents affordable to lower income households; the remaining 38% will be leased at market rents. [low income large family rentals] Housing For The Elderly Affordable senior rental housing is identified in the Consolidated Plan as a medium priority housing need for three income categories: low, very low, and extremely low income. CHISPA’s Sherwood Village Senior Apartments was completed during the previous reporting period. This project converted an obsolete motel facility adjacent to the City’s Community Center into 124 units of affordable rental housing for seniors. Every unit on site, except the manager’s, is rented at rates affordable to very low income senior households and there is now a waiting list for available units. The City supported this development with both HOME and CDBG funding. CHISPA is in the process of developing another, smaller rental senior development: La Gloria Senior Apartments. As described in greater detail elsewhere, this project is across East Market Street from another new, infill senior apartment project (Los Abuelitos), the development of which was assisted by the Salinas Redevelopment Agency. On December 2, 2008, the City Council approved the First Amendment to the 2008-09 ACTION PLAN which allocated $425,000 (HOMECHDO funds) to CHISPA to be used to acquire the site for La Gloria. This 23 unit project will serve low and very low income seniors and will be able to reduce costs due to economies of scale due to sharing expenses for certain services and management functions with the adjoining 25 unit Los Abuelitos. While not providing housing per se, several organizations that enable seniors to remain in their own homes receive Salinas CDBG funding. These include: Meals on Wheels, Food Bank for Monterey County, Alliance on Aging; each activity is discussed above in Section I, Part A. Also, the Visiting Nurses Association operates an adult day care facility that offers respite to family caregivers which helps to keep the elderly in home, rather than institutional, settings (CDBG public services funds support this activity). In addition, Alliance on Aging has absorbed the nonprofit that provided “ombudsman” services to seniors and disabled residing in convalescent hospitals and group homes; this important activity received $5,000. Special Housing Needs Population The special needs population are groups within the general population with characteristics that may indicate a need for special design features or other accommodations (e.g., supportive services) in order to provide appropriate housing. The Salinas Consolidated Plan includes the following within this category: elderly and frail elderly, persons diagnosed with HIV/AIDS and related diseases; persons with disabilities; and farmworkers. Housing for our special needs population is identified as a medium priority. The City’s Housing Services Program provides both housing rehabilitation loans and accessibility grants to low income households on a citywide basis. During this reporting period: 67% of the accessibility grants were made to seniorheaded households; in every case, these were owner-occupied dwelling units. A combination of HOME, and Redevelopment Agency funding was allocated to First Community Housing, Inc., to assist with both site acquisition and construction of the proposed Gateway Apartments. This downtown rental project will 31 of 60 s City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report provide housing for 52 households, excepting the on-site manager’s unit, 25 apartments will be affordable to extremely low income and 26 to very low income residents. Due to the inclusion of an elevator and other design features, units will be wheelchair accessible. A total of 25 units are to be set aside for occupancy by the developmentally disabled, some of these will have two bedrooms to accommodate a live-in caretaker. Of the 52 units, 16 are planned to be designated as “HOME-assisted” units. The project received its land use entitlements last year and secured its building permits during this period. The inability of CalHFA to honor its financing commitment has caused serious delays in the development of the Gateway Apartments. As this is written, First Community is awaiting word from the California Tax Credit Allocation Committee regarding their application for federal low income housing tax credits. As described elsewhere in this CAPER, the single family houses developed through the Hartnell College / City of Salinas / CHISPA partnership are being designed with “universal” features that allow an easier, more economical conversion in the future should it become necessary to accommodate the occupants. Table B below summarizes housing and transitional housing accomplishments under the 3 income categories: Table B - Summary of Housing Accomplishments Housing (and Transitional Housing) Accomplishments Renter Households Assisted 0 - 30% of MFI 31 - 50% of MFI 51 - 80% of MFI Total No. of Households 4 40 3 47 Owner Households Assisted 0 - 30% of MFI 31 - 50% of MFI 51 - 80% of MFI Total No. of Households 0 1 5 6 Homeless Persons Assisted Non-Homeless Person w/Special Needs Assisted No. of Persons 1813 No. of Persons 64 IV. CONTINUUM OF CARE The Consolidated Plan has prioritized the needs of homeless persons as medium priority and the special needs of nonhomeless persons requiring supportive housing as high and medium priority, respectively. The establishment of priorities are based upon many considerations, including the City’s analysis of its housing stock and market conditions, its assessment of the resources likely to be available over the five-year period, and its analysis of relative housing needs of its very low- and lowincome households. Over the past several years the City of Salinas has made a substantial commitment to provide outreach services to the homeless and to reduce the cycle of homelessness in the community. To that end, the City budgeted the entire $109,345 of its HUD Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) funding for homeless prevention, essential services to the homeless, and shelter operations as described below. All ESG funds were paid out to the service agencies for activities provided between July 1, 2008 and June 30, 2009; due to delays in receipt of funding requests or provision of beneficiary reports, some payments were made on a 'prior year' basis in the first months of the 2009-10 fiscal year. 32 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report In Monterey County, there are three entities that shoulder the burden of planning for a Continuum of Care to address homelessness. These are: (1) the lead governmental agency: Monterey County Department of Social Services (DSS); and two unique local collaborative efforts: (2) the Coalition of Homeless Services Providers (Homeless Coalition) and (3) the Local Homeless Assistance Committee (LHAC). HCD staff participates as a member agency of LHAC; during this reporting cycle City staff member David Swanson served as Co-Chairperson of the LHAC. This working group of nonprofits, City and County staff, and community members met throughout the year. The primary focus during this period continued to be the implementation of a comprehensive, five-year county-wide continuum of care plan entitled “Monterey County Community-Based Homeless Services Plan” (HSP). In addition, Salinas is one of three local cities that serve as "Community Advisors" to the Homeless Coalition. Homeless service providers are discussed in Section XII ESG Narrative (with additional information found in Section VI Leveraging). During this period, City redevelopment staff, with the assistance of the Homeless Coalition and community members, continued to examine issues and needs within a small area that has become a focal point for Salinas’ homeless population. Alternately known as either “Soledad Street” or “Old Chinatown,” this four-block area along upper Soledad and California Streets is home to the Green Gold Inn (site of the Franciscan Worker’s facility). The Green Gold Inn is owned by the Wheel of Hope, Inc., a non-profit founded several years ago by the Buddhist Temple and the Franciscan Workers as part of an effort to address homelessness and other serious issues within the neighborhood. The recently re-energized “Salinas Downtown Community Board” continues to provide advice and recommendations to government agencies and other stakeholders regarding improvements to the quality of life for individuals and business entities located in downtown Salinas. Two grants have been received from the state Department of Transportation (CALTRANS) to assist with planning efforts for the revitalization of this area. The first grant resulted in the “2007 Chinatown Renewal Project Plan.” The City’s redevelopment agency has acquired several parcels within the area that is the subject of the Plan. Neighboring blocks are under consideration for expansion of the Redevelopment Project Area. At the same time, California State University at Monterey Bay (CSUMB) has made the Soledad Street area a focus of its community service education efforts, spearheading the community garden project (on a vacant parcel owned by the Redevelopment Agency) and providing other valuable services in the neighborhood. The City also allocates Community Development Block Grant 'public services' funding towards direct and indirect prevention of homelessness and supportive housing and service efforts. During this program year, $48,000 was so allocated. The agencies and their CDBG allocations are as follows (additional detail can be found in Sections I and VI.): Meals on Wheels ($14,000), Central Coast Center for Independent Living ($10,000), Franciscan Workers of Junipero ($10,000 and Food Bank for Monterey County ($14,000). Other funded public services subrecipients, while not primarily focused on homelessness issues, provide services that in some cases work to help people remain in their present housing. Such agencies, and their CDBG funding for this period, include: Conflict Resolution and Mediation ($10,000.) Visiting Nurses Association ‘adult daycare services’ ($10,000); Door to Hope ‘substance abuse services’ ($5,000) and Alliance on Aging, with two programs: Senior Aides ($10,000) and OMBUDSMAN ($5,000). V. OTHER ACTIONS A. Program Planning and Implementation 1) On April 7, 2009, a reorganization of various City functions was completed with the result that the City again boasts a Community Development Department, bringing together the City’s redevelopment, planning, and housing functions under one administrative structure. Included in this department is the responsibility for the administration of the various HUD grants received by the City - both entitlement (e.g., CDBG) and HUD-administered economic stimulus grants (e.g., NSP, HPRP). It is hoped that the synergy achieved by this reorganization will help to offset the impacts of reduced funding levels due to declining General Fund revenue, State “take-backs” (e.g., loss of tax increment funds to the State), and reduced entitlement grant amounts. 2) The City of Salinas recognizes that the local housing affordability crisis cannot be solved by limited federal grant funds. On September 17, 2002, the City adopted a new General Plan for Salinas, spelling out how the City desires to improve and grow over a twenty- year period. One of the parts of this new General Plan is the Housing Element, which sets forth three over-arching goals for the City’s housing efforts. These goals are: a) Provide a range of housing opportunities to adequately address existing and projected needs of Salinas. 33 of 60 City of Salinas b) c) 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Maintain and improve existing neighborhoods and housing stock. Use public-private partnerships and collaborative efforts to ensure that all segments of the community have access to safe and decent housing that meets their diverse needs. In order to work toward achieving these goals, the Housing Element contains sixteen “programs” describing planned actions. These range from ensuring an adequate supply of vacant land, to addressing the particular housing needs of farmworkers, to fair housing activities. As discussed elsewhere in this report, ‘Program 5 - Inclusionary Housing’ was implemented by the preparation and adoption of a completely new inclusionary housing ordinance increasing the targeting (which will now include a percentage for very low income) and the required percentage of affordable units. The new program provides developers with three options as to the number of units required to be affordable: 20%, 25%, and 35%. The ordinance is structured to include incentives for builders to select the higher percentages. As a result of experience with the previous ordinance, the new program will include “equity sharing” for first-time homeowners. Pursuant to the State regulatory timetable, the City is in the process of revising its Housing Element. Expected to be completed by the end of 2009, the new Element will include information regarding program accomplishments and housing activities that will complement the next CAPER. The new Housing Element will also serve as a key resource when preparing the City’s next Five Year Consolidated Plan. The City, in response to policy direction in the 2002 General Plan, is in the midst of preparing a new Subdivision Ordinance. The first draft was released for public review in March 2008. While major changes to subdivision procedures are unlikely, the ordinance is being revised to better work with the recently adopted zoning rules in order to better implement General Plan policies for the growth of the City. 3) The City’s Redevelopment Agency has partnered with the Coalition of Homeless Services Providers and Cal State University - Monterey Bay to help develop new strategies for serving the area’s homeless population, with a particular focus upon the upper Soledad Street neighborhood. Supported by two grants from the State Department of Transportation, an intensive design/planning process has led to the “Chinatown Renewal Project Plan.” 4) Preliminary planning has begun for a multi-year effort to consider expansion of the Agency’s two existing redevelopment plan areas. The City has also entered into negotiations with a private developer to explore the possible re-use of all City and Agency-owned facilities in the downtown area; one of the goals of this effort is to increase the supply of housing in and near the downtown core. B. Eliminating Barriers to Accessibility In addition to the Handicap Accessibility Assistance grants, CDBG monies were also used for projects to improve accessibility for disabled persons to public facilities and public streets. ADA Access Curb Ramps – The ADA Curb Access project was initiated during FY 1999-00 and continues to modify and improve curbs throughout the City for ease of access to persons of disability. During this reporting period, there was no CDBG funding allotted for the installation of ADA pedestrian ramps. The approved FY 200910 Action Plan does allocate funding for the design of the next phase of curbing improvements. ADA Modifications to City Facilities – The City of Salinas’ ADA Five-Year Plan continues to see positive results. During the early years, major projects have been completed to improve access to City Hall, City Council Chambers and the John Steinbeck Public Library. Construction upgrading access at the Salinas Community Center/Sherwood Hall was completed February 14, 2006. Cesar Chavez Park ADA Restroom Project was completed on December 19, 2006. Central and Closter Park ADA-Compliant Restroom Upgrades was completed on May 13, 2008. The East Laurel Pocket Park and El Gabilan Play Lot Playground Equipment Replacement project was completed on September 9, 2008. During FY 2008-09 Action Plan ADA Modifications to City facilities was not funded, however, staff is expected to recommend using a portion of CDBG stimulus package funds (ARRA-created CDBG-R program) to accomplish ADA improvements at the La Paz Neighborhood Park. Freight Terminal ADA Design - Project was allocated funding in FY 2006-07 to address ADA requirements for the renovation and reuse of the Freight Building. This activity will evaluate the most cost-effective and practical means 34 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report to achieve full ADA functionality and accessibility for the building, given the historic nature of the building, current plans for surrounding transportation related improvements, and potential new use(s) of the building. Projects delays occurred because this activity is connected to a larger public transportation project undertaken in partnership with the regional Transportation Agency of Monterey County (TAMC). There has been no activity during FY 2008-09 because TAMC construction funds have been reprogrammed to FY 2010-2011 as a result of the State’s budget challenges. In addition, the project requires completion of the NEPA analysis for the construction portion of the project. In the next fiscal year, funds from the Central City project will be made available that will be used to proceed with the environmental phase of the project. Staff anticipates CALTRANS approval of the environmental phase to be achieved by December 2009. C. Overcoming Gaps in Institutional Structures Permit Center The Permit Center, established by consolidating at the same location the Building Official’s office with inspection services from other departments (Planning, Fire, Engineering & Development Services) in order to streamline the building permit process, has proven to be a successful approach to addressing the development community’s needs. The permit process is more efficient, and the response from citizens and the business community has been positive overall. Staff has been regularly meeting with a task force of local development and business interests to further streamline permitting procedures. This effort will be continued by improvements in operating efficiencies expected from the consolidation of planning, redevelopment, and housing functions into one department (e.g., Community Development Department) in April 2009. Salinas Valley Enterprise Zone After a period of several years when the City did not have staff formally assigned to Economic Development activities, Salinas now has two staff with these duties. The most notable results from this recently reinstituted effort is the successful application for enterprise zone designation. The Salinas Valley Enterprise Zone received final designation January 30, 2009. It includes most of the Salinas Valley Cities of Salinas, Gonzales, Soledad, Greenfield, and King City, as well as the unincorporated area in Monterey County between those communities along the Highway 101 Corridor. The Enterprise Zone designation provides significant California Income Tax Credits and other financial incentives for businesses located in the Enterprise Zone area boundaries. Additional details regarding this effort, as well as up-to-date news items, are available at: www.salinasvalleyez.com. Housing Opportunity Center Discussed in section II above, MoCHA’s Housing Opportunity Center is now operated by the newly formed Housing Resource Center of Monterey County (HRC). The Center continues to address a key issue in our community: the knowledge gap that hinders individuals and households from finding the resources and taking the necessary steps to become homeowners. Due to the increasing rate of foreclosures, staff was added in order to provide additional counseling services to those in default on their home loans. The Center also assists tenants to become better consumers of rental housing. HRC’s track record with both assistance to first-time homebuyers and to those seeking rental housing made it uniquely qualified to take on the new Homeless & Rapid Re-Housing Program (HPRP) funded by Congress as part of the economic stimulus package, and developed by HUD, to help prevent households from losing their homes and to provide resources to re-house those who have. HRC presented the successful proposal to the City to operate the $1 million HPRP effort in Salinas over the next two years. Coalition of Homeless Services Providers As discussed in the chapter on the Continuum of Care, the leadership provided by the Homeless Coalition has helped to coordinate the area’s previously disjointed homeless services delivery system and to encourage a higher level of planning on a County-wide level. In turn, this has led to increased resources to address homelessness. Examples of this group’s importance has been their success in obtaining federal VISTA Volunteers; the implementation of the new federal HMIS reporting system; and continued operational funding of homeless services through a coordinated effort in grant writing. The Coalition oversees the periodic census of homeless individuals and families within Monterey County that is mandated by the federal government as a condition for receiving funding from a range of federal programs designed to address homelessness. 35 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Mixed Use Zoning Regulations As noted elsewhere in this report, in November 2006 Salinas adopted a new Zoning Ordinance which -following the lead set by the 2002 General Plan- embraces many of the concepts of ‘New Urbanism.’ Some of these concepts have significant implications for housing and community development efforts outlined in the Consolidated Plan. In order to promote more ‘liveable’ neighborhoods and to discourage sprawl (while still accommodating growth), higher-density infill housing is promoted through a variety of methods including changes to allow mixed-use (residential and commercial uses on one site, or in one structure) development. This activity has the objective of increasing the housing stock while requiring less investment in infrastructure. In addition, underserved residential areas could see additional, compatible commercial development. Mixed-use zoning will be a key component in the three Area Specific Plans now being drafted as part of the 1300 acre annexation of lands bordering Salinas to the northeast. The primary purpose of the annexation is to provide sufficient land for growth; employing new urbanist models to new growth should result in more efficient land use patterns and increased densities. In the end, successful efforts to reduce the cost of developing housing, and to increase the supply of housing units, should serve to provide downward pressure on housing prices - both for purchase and rented. Relations with County The City of Salinas has worked for some time to promote cooperation with sister cities in the Salinas Valley. In recognition of the regional impact of local actions, Mayor Donohue has continued this effort and also reached out to cities on the Monterey Peninsula, as well as to Monterey County. The ‘fiscalization’ of land use planning that has resulted from California’s system of taxation can have the effect of pitting local government bodies (cities and counties) against each other as they compete for sales tax and property tax revenues in order to balance budgets. Communication channels established through regional initiatives such as the local Council of Governments (i.e., AMBAG) and 911 system operation have proven useful as cooperative efforts have expanded. These include transportation improvement planning and the review of policy and protocols regarding annexation of County land to the City and regarding growth planned by the County near the City of Salinas. This reporting cycle saw the approval by Monterey County LAFCo of the City annexation request for the Future Growth Areas north of Boronda Road. The City and County have also come together to try to address the impacts of the housing crisis (e.g., housing foreclosures) through an ad-hoc task force comprised of staff from the County and various cities that was originally convened by County Supervisor Simon Salinas. This forum has led to close cooperation as the City and a Countyled consortium of area jurisdictions each developed applications for the first round of Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) funds being made available via two federal stimulus bills (HERA and ARRA). The City has joined together with the County to submit an application directly to HUD for the second round of NSP monies. In addition programs are being designed to be as congruent a possible in order to promote unified outreach efforts and to allow for easier participation by area non-profit housing organizations and by for-profit lending institutions. D. Addressing Lead-Based Paint Hazards The City’s Consolidated Plan incorporates strategies to reduce lead-based paint hazards and prevent childhood lead poisoning, including the following: 1) Inspection of housing units by a certified LBP inspector for units participating in the Housing Services Rehabilitation and First Time Homebuyers Programs for signs of lead-based paint hazards and alerting homeowners of potential hazards. 2) Property owners participating in City rehabilitation loan programs are provided grants to cover the costs of mitigation measures for Standard treatment/abatement of any existing lead paint hazards (grants are capped at $14,000 per unit in the Revitalization Area and $11,000 in other areas of the City). 3) Providing public information and facilitating training, especially for building contractors who remodel and rehabilitate Salinas area housing. 36 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report All participants in Housing Services rehabilitation activities receive a pamphlet (in either English or Spanish language, as appropriate) describing lead-based paint hazards. Staff recommends, when lead base paint in found in units, that owners with young children contact the Monterey County Health Department for additional assistance. Staff is on hand to explain the LBP information and respond to questions. During this reporting period seven units were inspected for LBP. Two units revealed LBP hazards and received total LBP assistance of $16,063. Two, previous year, projects also had LBP expenditures this period. A total of $44,063 was expended for the inspection(s) and treatment of lead based paint hazards during these rehabilitation activities. E. Compliance & Monitoring The City Housing Division (HD) maintains accurate records, both program and financial, pertaining to community development activities, including housing and emergency shelter grant activities. Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) and CDBG-funded public service activities are monitored continuously. Documentation, including activity reports, is required to be submitted with all payment requests. Within the Housing Services Program, outstanding deferred payment rehabilitation loans are reviewed every two years and all loan recipients are monitored annually with regard to required occupancies, hazard insurance, and property tax status. Staff oversees compliance with federal labor standards requirements (e.g., Davis-Bacon) on a project-by-project basis, beginning with contract drafting and preconstruction conferences and proceeding through the necessary contractor submittals. In limited instances, qualified sub-recipients (e.g., the Housing Authority of the County of Monterey) have the resources to oversee federal labor standards with their own staff. The City’s Public Works Compliance Officer continues to work closely with Housing staff on all capital projects where federal labor standards apply due to the use of CDBG funding. Additionally, she will be attending HUD’s three day Federal Labor Compliance Training in July 2009. Also, Housing Division staff will coordinate another in-house (Housing Division with Engineering & Transportation Dept.) labor compliance meeting in the fall of 2009. The previous such in-house labor compliance meeting occurred on June 11, 2008. Meeting objectives included: establishment of best practices for achieving compliance with all applicable Federal Labor Standard provisions by City, general contractor and all subcontractors for CDBG-assisted Capital Improvement Projects, and establishment of an effective communication system between DES and HCD staff. Pursuant to a recommendation made by our regional HUD Community Planning and Development (CPD) representative, we instituted a formal process for making other City departments aware of all the requirements that accompany the use of CDBG funding. On September 5, 2008, City’s Engineering and Development Services executed a Memorandum of Record (MOR) for the Salinas Aquatic Center (CIP# 9761) funded in FY 2008-09. This document serves as an alternate method to a Funding Agreement for ensuring program compliance for federally assisted capital improvement projects. Housing staff continues to regularly assess the components of the various activities it oversees. A key focus during these assessments is compliance with the adopted Consolidated Plan and with the City's Housing Element. Information thus gathered is employed to evaluate progress towards established goals; to confirm compliance with statutory and regulatory requirements of governing federal legislation (e.g., National Affordable Housing Act); to determine possible revisions to City policy and procedure, including the Consolidated Plan and Housing Element; and, to prepare performance reports such as this document. F. Areas of Minority Concentration According to the 2000 Census, 74% of the City population is considered as 'minority' under the Census terms. The largest minority/ethnic group is comprised of Hispanics, making up approximately 64% of the City’s population. Other minority/racial populations in Salinas are as follows: 6% Asian/Pacific Islander, 5% of two or more races, 3% Black, and 1% Native American and Alaska Native. The changes in the treatment of race and ethnicity in the 2000 Census also result in a statistic where over one third (38.7%) of the population identifies with the category: "some other race." 37 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report A comparison of Salinas’ 2000 total minority/ethnic population of 111,784 [using HUD’s 20% formula] against the total minority population for each census tract, reveals that six census tracts out of the City’s twenty-seven tracts were considered to be areas of minority concentration. These census tracts are as follows: CT 05 (85.4%); CT 06 (86%); CT 07 (90.1%); CT 09 (82.4%); CT 10 (83.6%); and, CT 106.02 (88.4%) Map 6 in Appendix A illustrates these tracts. Comparing Salinas' overall Hispanic population figure (65%) to each census tract’s Hispanic population reveals that eight census tracts (38%) contained areas of Hispanic concentration. These census tracts are as follows: CT 05 (78%), CT 06 (83%), CT 07 (86%), CT 08 (75%), CT 09 (73%), CT 10 (79%), CT 13 (70%), and CT 106.02 (79%). (It is noted that CT 10 contained only 500 residents and so the percentage figures are not comparable to the other tracts; the majority of land in the tract is mixed commercial and industrial. Also, in 1990 a good portion of tracts 05 and 106.02 consisted of Carr Lake--a 'dry lakebed' area subject to seasonal flooding and used for farmland.) The above-mentioned census tracts are located in East Salinas and range from 56% to 88% low income. The populations within these census tracts were subject to conditions such as overcrowded housing, limited open space, inadequate public infrastructure, and higher levels of crime and gang violence. To ameliorate these conditions, the City through its CDBG and HOME programs provides a low interest loan program for housing rehabilitation to maintain and upgrade existing housing stock, funds public services activities focused upon these areas and provides assistance to nonprofit housing developers for affordable housing development and preservation activities. HUD’s “CHAS Data Book 2000” revealed that 75% of Salinas’ Hispanic households have a housing problem. A ‘housing problem’ is defined as a cost burden that exceeds 30% of income or overcrowding or living in a unit without complete kitchen/plumbing facilities. This compares to a 55% reporting housing problems for all City households. Also, the City has used Block Grant funding to acquire land for parks to provide recreational open space for residents in the City’s low-income census tracts. CDBG funds have been and continue to be allocated for public improvements in those areas, i.e. streetlights, crosswalks, and traffic signals to enhance public safety. The Firehouse Recreation Center, Hebbron Heights Neighborhood Center, and the Breadbox (recreation center) were developed to serve the residents of these areas. Additionally, in the past and present, CDBG funding has made public services available to the minority/ethnic and low income population with such services as substance abuse counseling in English and Spanish, assistance to victims of domestic violence, child abuse prevention, after school programs, educational/recreational activities, culturally appropriate arts, drama and music programs, and dispute resolution. G. Action Plan Amendments During this fiscal year, there were 4 amendments to the 2008-09 Action Plan (See Appendix B). The City Council approved the 1st amendment on December 2, 2008, wherein $425,000 of HOME funds to Interim, Inc.’s Sunflower Gardens was rescinded (see discussion in section XI, HOME Narrative) and reallocated to the La Gloria Senior Apartments project. Available CDBG funds were then allocated for site acquisition for the Sunflower Gardens project. The second amendment was approved on March 31, 2009, allocating an additional $24,000 of CDBG funds to the East Salinas Streetlights Phase IX project. These funds were earmarked for design costs. $73,000 of CDBG funds were deobligated out of Relocation and Contingencies accounts to cover the said costs. On May 12, 2009, Council approved a resolution for the City to apply for Homelessness Prevention and Rapid Re-housing Program funds. The City received an allocation in the amount of $1,013,978 to provide financial aid services for families and individuals who would become homeless or to provide rapid re-housing assistance for those who are already homeless. The amendment also approves the sub-allocation to the Housing Resource Center of Monterey County to be the lead subrecipient to carry out the program. The last amendment for the fiscal year was approved on June 2, 2009, approving the submittal for CDBG-R funds. The allocation to the City is $663,000 and is proposed for the East Market Pedestrian Lights capital improvement project. 38 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report VI. LEVERAGING A. Leveraging of Other Public and Private Resources Leveraging is a term used to describe a situation where resources are used to obtain additional financial resources. An example is when a privately owned business sells stock. It has financial resources (capital, assets, etc.), which it increases by selling shares, thereby increasing its operating capital with the proceeds from the sale of stock. “Leveraging” in the context of governmental grants typically describes what happens when additional funding is received as a result of the initial grant funding. As an example, if a city has $100,000 to use to rehabilitate housing, it could use the funds to make loans directly to property owners. Or, the same $100,000 could be leveraged by requiring participating property owners to provide half the cost of the rehab, using their own capital or by securing a private loan. In this example, the result is $200,000 of rehabilitation accomplished for the same $100,000. Such leveraging is not always sufficient to obtain owner participation, so such programs need to be carefully designed. [During the early years of Salinas’ housing rehabilitation loan program this format was employed when the City used CDBG funds for interest subsidies to lending institutions so that borrowers obtained below-market interest rates. The City moved away from this approach for two reasons: market-rate lenders became less interested in participating in such programs, and, interest subsidies - once paid - are effectively gone. Changing to a direct loan program results in ‘program income’ from repayments, income that can be recycled over time to assist more families.] A “matching funds” requirement is commonly understood to accomplish leveraging. The federal government generally requires Participating Local Jurisdictions to provide a match for HOME funds. There are exceptions for communities with particular housing factors that exceed a threshold set by HUD; Salinas has not been required to provide a match for HOME funds for several years. While not currently required for HOME, through a variety of sources (particularly Redevelopment Agency housing funds) at this time the City enjoys a surplus of funds that qualify as HOME match funds. In Salinas’s programs the most frequent example of leveraging occurs in the development of new affordable housing projects. In the current economy, the only effective way for non-profit housing developers to construct new projects is to assemble financial resources from a variety of sources. No matter the primary source of funding (e.g., federal Low Income Tax Credits, HUD Section 811 financing, USDA housing programs) none will finance the entire cost to develop housing. Salinas uses both CDBG and HOME funds to leverage the participation of other funders. The flexibility inherent in CDBG rules makes it particularly appropriate for use early on in the development process as critical support for non-profits that often are pressed for pre-development funds. Similarly HOME guidelines emphasize the importance of using HOME to fill in ‘financing gaps’ that often result when projects face more rigid requirements established either by particular loan regulations, or due to the degree of competition for other financing. In the past several years it appears that those designing governmental financing programs are attempting to make their funds go farther (i.e., leverage them more) by requiring higher percentages of OPM (other people’s money) as a condition of providing their own financing. For example, the State’s new Mental Health Services Act funding, as a condition of providing financing to develop permanent housing for mental health clients, calls for a local ‘match’ of as much as 30%. Given that the per-unit cost to develop such units is more than $300,000, housing nonprofits find themselves seeking local funding of up to $100,000 per unit. Thus the local match for even a 20 unit project could run to twice the amount of Salina’s annual HOME allocation. On a smaller scale, an example of leveraging is the Redevelopment Department’s JAZZ-UP activity: this program employs one City employee as a crew supervisor - a position funded 50% by CDBG and 50% by Redevelopment. The leverage occurs when the work crew made up with youth from Second Chance’s gang diversion programs (and other non-paid workers) perform exterior improvements (painting, minor repairs) to properties in the targeted area. There are more subtle forms of leverage. Public investment in a particular neighborhood (upgrading water mains or installing traffic signals or street lighting) can be an inducement for additional investment by area property owners affected by the improvements. Figuring the amount of leverage in this example is much more difficult than the direct leveraging described in the above paragraphs. 39 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report B. Funds Committed and Expended, and Program Income Received Table C Grant Program Funds Committed Funds Expended Program Income Received CDBG 1,380,956 3,188,308 58,897 HOME 758,654 1,419,268 59,651 ESG 109,345 109,345 0 2,248,955 4,716,921 118,548 Total Program Income During this program year, the City received "program income" from activities funded with CDBG and HOME dollars during previous years. Program income is required to be used only for activities that would be eligible if being funded by the original source of funds. Any unanticipated program income is programmed for use during the following fiscal period. There are two typical sources of program income: regular, amortized repayment of loans (e.g., housing rehabilitation loans made to homeowners) and unanticipated repayment of loans in full. The latter typically occur when the property owner either sells the property securing the loan, or refinances the first mortgage. There are other activities that also generate program income, but, these are very rare and did not occur this cycle. As reported last period, the amount of program income from both CDBG and HOME activities exceeded projections in the recent years. The large scale-refinancing trend began during FY01-02 and has continued over the following years. A large portion of program income receipts was received from loan payoffs as result of refinancing and property sales. This period, as discussed in the housing needs section of this report, with the housing market taking a down turn, refinancing and property sales went down drastically. Program income for the second consecutive year also dipped from $187,545 in FY 2007-08 to $118,548 in this period. C. HOME and ESG Matching Funds Both the ESG and HOME grants require leveraging in the form of “matching funds.” The normal ratio for the HOME program is $1 for each 4 dollars of HOME funds. Match funds can accumulate and be carried forward for future program years. Salinas has had an excess of HOME match funds since the late 1990’s. (see attached HUD form 40107-A in the Appendix section) HUD regulations provide that individual jurisdiction’s match requirement be waived when certain economic factors are in effect for the area. Match Analysis for Emergency Shelter Grant Activity Housing Resource Center of Monterey County formerly Housing Advocacy Council The Housing Advocacy Council received $16,100 for a homeless prevention program comprised of Security Deposit and Emergency Rent Programs. The ESG match for Housing Advocacy was fulfilled by $94,568. from the County of Monterey, State of California, foundations, and the United Way of Monterey County. Interim This agency provides emergency housing and other support services for homeless persons with mental illness. Interim was granted $35,000 for the MCHOME program with matching dollars ($632,672) coming from the County of Monterey. 40 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Shelter Outreach Plus Salinas provided $31,959 in ESG funding to Shelter Outreach Plus for the Interfaith Homeless Emergency Lodging Program ('I-HELP') which is a unique overnight emergency lodging program for men whose primary support comes in the form of rent-free shelter provided on a rotating basis by local religious institutions; each night of shelter includes a free dinner prepared and served by the members of the church or synagogue. This agency received over $46,985 in funding from Monterey County, EFSP and Newman’s Own Foundation. John XXIII AIDS Ministry John XXIII AIDS Ministry was granted $26,600 for housing advocacy activities and emergency shelter assistance for persons with HIV/AIDS. The ESG match for John XXIII was met by funding in the amount of $30,584 from Housing Opportunities for People with AIDS (HOPWA). VII. CITIZEN COMMENTS At the City Council meeting of April 6, 2008, the draft 2008-09 Action Plan was first considered and the formal public hearing was held on May 6, 2008. (See Appendix C). At the hearing, 13 agencies spoke in support of their respective programs. One citizen spoke in support of equitable funding for agencies. On September 22, 2009, a noticed public hearing was held by the City Council to receive comment on the CAPER for FY 200809 (this document). Advance notice of this hearing was mailed and emailed to each agency that received funding from the covered programs (CDBG, HOME and ESG) during the report period. Notice was published in the local daily newspaper: Salinas Californian, and in El Sol, a local newspaper published in Spanish (See Appendix C). The draft CAPER was made available for review on the City’s website (http://www.ci.salinas.ca.us/services/commdev/pdf/CAPER_FY_08-09.pdf). Three written comments were received. The first from CHISPA, commented on the importance of HUD funds in Salinas to support development of affordable housing for seniors and as leverage for other funding. A second letter was received from Shelter Outreach Plus, echoing the same sentiment about how HUD funds are used to leverage a larger amount of contributions to the community. A third comment from a representative of the Boys and Girls Club expressed the agency’s appreciation towards Housing staff for support and assistance with keeping their documents organized. In addition, 3 public comments were received at the public hearing including a City resident who spoke about the numerous available foreclosures in the City and that “there’s plenty of affordable housing” to accommodate the city’s needs. He added that there is no need to further build new affordable housing units. Two board members from the Children’s Circle of Friends expressed their appreciation for City Council’s work and commitment to promoting housing for foster care families and abused and neglected children. VIII. SELF-EVALUATION The City’s FY 2008-09 Comprehensive Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) demonstrates the activities the City has undertaken with its CDBG, HOME, and ESG programs, together with “leveraged” funds and “in-kind” services to address the priorities set forth in the adopted 2006-2010 Consolidated Plan. [The format employed in this section is suggested by the questions posed in the HUD/CPD-prepared checklist for reviewing CAPERs.] There are other portions of the CAPER that contain evaluative content as well, for example in the narratives on the CDBG and HOME programs that follow this section. A. Barriers to Accomplishing Goals During the prior reporting period, and now from July 1, 2007 through June 30, 2008, staff has identified six major barriers to the accomplishment of goals identified in the Consolidated Plan. The identified major barriers are largely beyond the control of the city organization; each is briefly discussed below. Two pertain to the agency that administers the three grants: the US Department of Housing and Urban Development. As discussed in the last CAPER, the first of these is the financial reporting system known as IDIS (Integrated Disbursal and Information System), an obsolete “mainframe-style” computer system whose use is required in order to drawdown HUD funds. The system is inefficient and a drain on limited administrative resources (both at the City and presumably at HUD). Long promised improvements (e.g., a change to a PC-based system) have yet to take place. A lesser barrier is the recent emphasis relayed by HUD regarding the elimination of “chronic homelessness” within ten years. This “one size, fits all” attempt to solve a complex, multi-faceted program is negatively impacting ongoing homeless programs in Monterey County. The important issue of homelessness is addressed locally under the direction of the County’s social 41 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report service department and through an established network of largely grassroots organizations. These organizations evolved in response to local homelessness issues. As a result of this federal emphasis on a specific component of a larger problem, local agencies can either watch as funding flows to other regions or they can attempt to modify their programs to chase the federal dollars, very possibly at the expense of alienating their support bases and certainly to the detriment of those homeless populations who do not fit the federal definition of “chronically homeless.” While not called out separately in this report, there is also the ongoing problem homeless services providers (shelter operators, housing providers, social services agencies) have in that federal and state funding for operational costs (as defined from capital costs) fluctuate greatly from year to year, both in amount and in required focus or purpose. Many providers are reluctant to seek federal funds to develop new housing or shelters because of the difficulty in obtaining operational funding for the facilities and for necessary ongoing supportive services. In this county an example of this problem is the closure of a low-income childcare facility (based in a building made available via the McKinney Act when Fort Ord closed down) that closed for two reasons: restrictions of the McKinney Act that stipulate only “homeless” children can be served and the inability to secure adequate funding for ongoing maintenance and operation of the facility. This coming year a group home operated by Unity Care (to house youth who have aged out of the State’s foster care system) will close - again primarily due to difficulty in obtaining operational funding. Due to the current structure of the HUD homeless funding programs provided via the annual “Super NOFA,” the funds that would have been allocated to Unity Care as an annual renewal will be lost to the community. The third relates to HUD as well, but, only in the sense of service as a messenger - relaying Congressional decisions to reduce funding for both HOME and CDBG over the past five years (and again in the coming 2008-09 fiscal year, and then again in 2009-10 assuming funding is only provided via ‘continuing resolution’ because Congress is not able to take timely action on that year’s budget). As discussed in greater depth in the CDBG narrative, reductions in CDBG funding levels cause concern, particularly with regard to the impact on administrative resources and not only for CDBG, but for HOME as well. As HOME admin expenses are capped at ten percent, CDBG admin funds are needed to supplement the HOME funds. Declining CDBG grant amounts are forcing the elimination of one position and the reduction to half time of a second administrative position in the coming (FY08-09) fiscal year - in order to keep admin/planning expenses under the mandated ceiling of twenty percent. In communities such as Salinas -lower income communities that formed the initial focus of the Housing & Community Development Act of 1974- it is not reasonable to expect the community will have the resources to take on the administration of these programs from general funds. The simple reason is that these are resource-poor communities where the primary community focus is -by necessity- on functions such as public safety (police and fire) and general public infrastructure (roads and sewers). In the current times, local resources are facing further strain in this state as the Legislature contemplates (again) reducing the State budget shortfall by taking local revenues such as redevelopment tax increment funds. Three other barriers are more uniquely a result of State and local circumstances. First of these, and as also described in previous CAPERs, the City fiscal situation (precipitated by State actions to reduce traditional municipal revenue sources) led to layoffs and staff vacancies across all City functions. The cuts made to engineering staff negatively impacted the City’s ability to carry out capital improvement projects - including those funded with CDBG. These delays impacted our expenditure rates and threatened to create a “timeliness” problem when each year in May funds on hand are reviewed by HUD. At the same time, public services activities were impacted by the closure of recreation facilities and the termination General Fund-supported “neighborhood services” activities such as graffiti abatement. On a broader level, the magnitude of reductions impacted the overall ability of the organization to coherently address significant issues such as pending annexations, downtown revitalization, neighborhood improvement, and a variety of other areas relating to the goals set forth in the Consolidated Plan. As reported last year, the community dug deep, primarily from concern for threatened library services, and passed a supplementary sales tax. The additional sales tax revenues have allowed library services to be restored and other programs are being re-funded - but not to original levels. Of course, the supplemental sales tax revenues will only amount to two-thirds of the prior loss, and, will sunset in eight years. The last two barriers to be discussed are inter-connected. Astronomic increases in housing prices within the Salinas housing market over the past several years dramatically impacted programs such as “first time homebuyer” assistance and “housing rehabilitation.” Salinas was being ranked consistently within the top ten most expensive housing markets in the country (when measured by the disparity between median prices and median incomes). High prices meant the City could not feasibly provide downpayment assistance to lower income first-time homebuyers - that program ceased in 2007. The high prices indirectly impacted the housing rehabilitation program as general building contractors were in constant demand and lacked incentives to participate in our rehab programs. Even more critically, the unregulated 42 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report housing finance industry inspired a feeding frenzy by offering irresponsible mortgage products including “pick a payment” plans where buyers could pick negative amortization and “no doc” loans where stated incomes did not need verification. Wall Street (and international markets) added to the problem by packaging sub-prime loans and selling them as investments - thereby providing additional capital to mortgage lenders to continue to make dangerous loans. Salinas did not escape the nationwide crash of housing markets and now some neighborhoods are facing very serious rates of default and foreclosure. Prices have fallen to the point where the City will be re-examining the decision to cease its firsttime homebuyer program in the coming year. Our rehabilitation staff are reporting that potential clients are now very hesitant to consider taking on any additional debt to finance rehabilitation of their homes, even deferred payment loans. We suspect that a combination of reduced home values and the news media coverage of foreclosures and evictions are the reason. A local factor in the escalation of housing prices has been the declining supply of vacant land. As noted in the Consolidated Plan, the addition of suitable land is necessary in order to provide needed housing. During this period the annexation of more than 2300 acres was approved by the County Local Agency Formation Commission - a key step in providing additional housing sites. Staff is now working with landowners and the development community to prepare the planning and environmental documents that will allow additional housing production once the cyclical housing market begins its next upswing. Looking to our own ACTION PLAN, we set aside CDBG funds this reporting period for CHISPA to acquire two parcels in Hebbron Heights (within the Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area) to develop a mixedincome single-family subdivision. During the year we evaluated our resources and determined that it would be better to use HOME funds for this particular project; a PLAN amendment was prepared and approved. One other trend which affects the City’s ability to promote housing development has been the sharp decline in both CDBG and HOME program income. In 2007-08 program income amounted to less than half the projected amount. This decline means less resources were available during this period and less in the coming fiscal period. B. Status of Grant Programs The following paragraphs discuss the status of the three grant programs that are the subject of this performance report: CDBG, HOME and ESG. The discussion of the Emergency Shelter Grant program is much less detailed both due to the relative size of the grant and the lack of local discretion as to the use of these funds. As the City operates all three grant programs on reimbursement basis, funds are drawn down from HUD only after expenditures have occurred. Therefore, if there is any difference between actual expenditures and disbursements from the three grant letters of credit, it will be in HUD’s favor as it is because drawdowns from HUD have not yet been requested for expenditures initially made with City funds. Community Development Block Grant-Overall HUD has established a guideline for the timely use of CDBG funds, specifically: each year by May First, grantees should have spent, and drawn down from HUD, enough CDBG funds such that the remaining available balance does not exceed one and one half times the annual grant amount (thus the ratio should not exceed 1.5:1). [This target ratio may not appear to be overly ambitious, but, it was set after considering the complexity of the CDBG regulatory framework, including the need for assessing environmental impact, for enforcing federal labor standards, and for ensuring that expenditures comply with City policies and plans, as well as with a range of federal regulations and Executive Orders. Also a factor is the delay in receipt of the CDBG Grant Agreement from HUD; in recent years often the first month of the fiscal year has passed before this authorization to use funds is received. As an example, FY2009-10 commenced on July 1, 2009, but, the Grant Agreement had not arrived as of August 13.] In the prior period, Salinas’ timeliness ratio was 1.16:1, well below the target figure of 1.5:1; during 2008-09 the ratio was 0.80:1. It has been at least ten years since the May ratio was even as low as one-to-one: Meeting this benchmark should not be taken for granted as it is due to concentrated effort by staff, not only within the Housing Division, but, in other departments (noticeably Engineering & Transportation, and Finance) to ensure that CDBG funds are spent appropriately, and on time. Given the increasing cost and complexity of projects (both housing and capital improvements) the requirement to spend CDBG funds quickly is becoming a much more important factor when choosing which activities to fund. This can mean that the highest priorities identified in the Consolidated Plan 43 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report lose out to lower priority activities because the lower priorities are more easily accomplished within a short timeframe. This tendency is furthered by CDBG regulations prohibiting the allocation of funds for multi-year periods. One area of Community Development Block Grant-funded activities often receives little notice: planning and administration. Such “indirect” activities, while necessary, receive scant press, particularly in the absence of scandals or negative HUD findings. As described in Section I, the 20% cap on the use of CDBG for administration and planning activities has been an increasing source of concern because reduced CDBG grant levels mean reduced administrative funding, not only for CDBG, but for ESG and HOME grant oversight as well. CDBG- Public Services Overall, CDBG funding of public services continued in a fashion similar to prior years. The total public services budget declined from $415,000 in 07-08 to $375,000 in this period, (looking at the 04-05 level of $560,000 illustrates the trend of less public services funding each year over the past few years - this trend is a direct result of both declining annual grant amounts and declining program income.) We know that the trend will continue in 2009-10 as only $375,000 will be available for that period. Changes in the subrecipient selection process accomplished two years ago were moderately successful in that several new activities were funded and the funding ‘floor’ of $10,000 per activity was maintained for the second year in a row. The funding floor was established due to the number of very small public services awards that were being made and the impact upon City staff of administering this large number. Over the past few years the City has been successful in obtaining non-HUD federal funds for activities that complement certain of our CDBG-funded public services. Most notable has been the multi-year Department of Justice “Weed and Seed” Grant, portions of which were used for targeted code enforcement and other activities in a sub-neighborhood of the Alisal NRSA. This cycle a second such Weed and Seed Grant was received, with a geographic focus upon Census Tract 5, which is also (largely) included in the Alisal NRSA. Local complementary resources have also become available through the passage of the (Measure V) supplementary local sales tax - increased library operating hours are a prime example. CDBG-Capital Improvement Projects Much progress was made to finish CDBG-funded CIPs from earlier program years: Seven (7) projects were completed during this fiscal year (2008-09). Included in this list are: CIP#9044, Traffic Signal Installation at East Alisal and Towt St. ($435,000); CIP#9037 East Salinas Area Street Lights Phase 9 ($690,000); CIP#9041 East Salinas Area Street Lights Phase 10 ($401,000); CIP#9042 East Salinas Area Street Lights Phase 14 ($175,000); CIP#9416 East Laurel Pocket Park Installation of ADA Play Equipment ($85,000); CIP#9046 El Gabilan Play Lot Installation of ADA Play Equipment ($45,000); and CIP#9043 Breadbox Gymnasium Divider Wall ($62,881.92). Despite this success, staff remain concerned with two aspects of CDBG-funded capital improvement projects (CIPs). The major concern is the condition of the City’s General Fund, which continues to suffer from revenue reductions at the hands of the State of California. Unfortunately, the State’s financial conditions are not expected to improve during the upcoming fiscal year. As such, this decline in available General Fund money for CIPs will continue to decline and the demand for CDBG funds will continue to escalate. This will also mean some construction-ready projects will be placed on hold due to insufficient funding, and so the community will have to wait to access an improved public facility or upgraded infrastructure. Further, as the City continues to trim departmental budgets that may include personnel or the elimination of previously funded positions, the design and engineering functions of the City will continue to be negatively impacted, experiencing increased design times and reduced ability to develop accurate estimates and to make long term plans for projects. On projects where cost estimates are low, there are few resources available to make up the shortfall - increasing demand for decreasing CDBG funds. This funding concern will continue to escalate as the City prepares to implement its furlough program on July 1, 2009. The second concern is the time period from when CDBG funds are allocated to when project contracts are first let and then funds are actually expended. Delays in the design and bid phases have meant that on some projects planned expenditures are delayed, thereby raising concern with meeting HUD timeliness deadlines. As a result of these concerns, division staff has increasingly sought to break CIP activities into two projects: design and then construction, in order to better estimate actual construction costs (because fund requests are made after detailed engineering is complete and closer to actual bid dates). 44 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report HOME Investment Partnerships Program With a continuing trend in Washington to reduce CDBG funding, and the local maturation of City redevelopment project areas, the City’s annual HOME grant has become the City’s primary source for funding affordable housing activities. The City was allocated $902,216 in HOME funding for 2008-09; an additional $20,000 in HOME program income was anticipated. Reversing the trend for the previous few years, program income was greater than projected: $59,650. [Note: Finance Department has yet to close and balance fiscal records for 2008-09 so there is a chance the final income figure will vary somewhat.] HOME program income comes from loan repayments: housing rehab loans and downpayment assistance loans. The larger than expected amount was due to two early loan payoffs. [Note: For the coming year staff has again made a conservative estimate due to the difficulty of estimating early loan payoffs in this economic climate.] While not as severe as the decline in CDBG, the City’s annual HOME allocations have been declining. At $902,216, Salinas’ 2008-09 allocation represented a 13% percent reduction over the highest previous annual allocation of $1,036,876 in 2004-05. [Note: Next funding period, however, the allocation actually increases to $999,882 - a ten percent increase and the largest amount in the past five years of HOME funding.] HOME Partnership Investment Program funds must be used for housing activities. Unlike CDBG funds, however, HOME monies are subject to a more restrictive hierarchy of program regulations (e.g., maximum unit values, deeper income targeting, specified rent levels) that complicate their use. The economic climate in California (and likely in many other high cost areas) means that affordable housing projects are only feasible with a mix of private financing and public subsidies from multiple programs. As an example, INTERIM’s twenty unit Lupine Gardens project was financed through the HUD Section 811: Supportive Housing for Persons with Disabilities Program. The capital advanced through Section 811, however, was not sufficient to develop the units, therefore, the nonprofit developer needed to assemble a long list of financing ranging from temporary (construction) loans to grants and permanent financing. The funding sources include two City of Salinas programs, three County programs, one State program, six private foundations, and several other donors. Other pending housing projects (e.g., Gateway Apartments, Tresor Apartments, Sunflower Gardens) reflect a similar mix of funding sources. Each of the public financing sources has regulations that must be met and varying timelines; in many cases, the restrictions will overlap, in other cases there is an actual conflict that must be resolved in order to receive funds from all. As a result, for even the most competent nonprofit (such as INTERIM), the development of a 20-unit apartment complex can take five years to complete. Tightened loan standards of private lending institutions, combined with a decline in the private sector demand for federal tax credits, has meant that the demand for governmental assistance such as HOME has increased markedly. A key difference between HOME and CDBG are timing requirements: HOME funds are to be “committed” to projects within two years, and then spent within five years. Funds are not considered committed unless an executed Funding Agreement is in place - when even small projects take five years to complete, it can be difficult to “commit” HOME dollars within two years of making an allocation in an ACTION PLAN, particularly when that allocation process typically starts at least six months before participating jurisdictions (e.g., City of Salinas) even know how much HOME funding will be available. Another complication is that many public funding sources require that developers both control the land (either own it or have a solid purchase agreement) and have land use entitlements in place before submitting applications for funding. The costs, and time required, to achieve this status are extensive, particularly if the project requires discretionary zoning approvals (e.g., conditional use permits, variances, or planned unit development permits). With federal HOME guidance suggesting that construction commence within 12 months of expenditure of funds it becomes virtually impossible to use HOME funds to acquire sites. These HOME requirements are not new, however, during the fifteen years since Salinas began receiving HOME funds, development costs and construction costs have increased greatly, as have the complexities of housing finance - particularly for multifamily housing. The 2008-09 ACTION PLAN allocated funds to be used as capital for housing rehabilitation loans - again for low income households. Both HOME and CDBG funds were allocated to this activity because the HOME limit on maximum after-rehab value on occasion will not work for some specific rehab projects. The HOME allocation was $300,000. First Community Housing, an experienced non-profit housing developer, was allocated $760,000 in the 07-08 ACTION PLAN for predevelopment and construction expenses pertaining to the 52-unit Gateway Apartments project. This allocation supplemented the $450,000 (HOME) that had been allocated the prior year. The Funding Agreement 45 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report committing both allocations was executed February 27, 2008. Since then this project has received its land use entitlements, and obtained its building permits. Unfortunately the project has been delayed due to the State’s fiscal crisis which precluded the State housing finance agency from meeting its financing commitments. First Community has applied for 2009 federal low income housing tax credits as part of its revised financing strategy. The original 08-09 ACTION PLAN set aside $425,000 (HOME) for Interim’s infill apartment project to serve very-low income disabled adults. The site for this project was an obsolete migrant farmworker housing project that had received a minor amount of HOME funding in prior years. As the ‘affordability period’ had yet to expire, the City requested a waiver of the HUD prohibition against the use of HOME funds at a previously assisted site. Despite a positive recommendation from the regional HUD office, the waiver was not approved by HUD in Washington D.C. Consequently the City had to rescind the allocation for Sunflower Gardens. When major planned expenditures of HOME funds do not occur, there is the risk of de-obligation of funds due to nontimely use. This risk is increased when program income received exceeds projections (as was the case earlier in this decade) because program income must be spent prior to drawing down new funds. The inability to use HOME funds on the Interim project also increased the risk that funds would not be obligated in a timely manner. On December 2, 2008, the City Council approved a shift of the $425,000 from the Interim project to a seniors housing development proposed by CHISPA, Inc. The CHISPA project (known as La Gloria Senior Apartments) had received an allocation of City Redevelopment Agency funds. So as not to delay the Interim project, the redevelopment monies were reallocated to it, thus allowing Sunflower Gardens to stay on schedule without delaying the CHISPA project. Sunflower Gardens is currently under construction. The HOME funds were used by CHISPA to acquire the La Gloria site. At this point, commitment and expenditure rates for City HOME funds are within the HUD parameters. Emergency Shelter Grant As noted elsewhere, all Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) funds were allocated and expended during the fiscal period. The complex targeting inherent in ESG rules, when combined with the small amount of funds received, does not promote efficient use of funds. That is, when the total grant is roughly $100,000, then dividing the funds according to the prescribed uses (e.g., 30% for prevention activities) and restrictions (e.g., limited use for staff costs) results in very small amounts spread over several agencies. Some of the eligible activities alone (such as conversion of buildings to shelters) would take much more than several years’ worth of ESG funding. For the sake of comparison, in this county, the annual cost to administer the HUD-mandated HMIS computer data system is much more than Salinas’ entire ESG grant amount. [Note: administrative costs for HMIS will increase in the coming fiscal year due to the need to modify the software and reporting procedures to accommodate the new HPRP records requirements.] C. Goals on Target In the Assessment of Annual Performance section of this report, staff describes progress made with regard to the needs identified in the Consolidated Plan. As can be seen, in some cases actions have been taken as outlined in the Consolidated Plan Strategies and they can be considered complete, in other cases the strategies call for ongoing implementation of items throughout the five year period of the Plan. Also identified are areas where no progress was made; as the period covered is but the fourth year of a multi-year plan, lack of progress on individual items by no means indicates failure or inattention. Overall, staff concludes that the City is on target toward implementing a large majority of the described strategies. Reviewing the listed “Objectives” we are also on track, however, there may be some slippage on specific dates. For example, the objective (5.2.3) to complete the annexation process of Phase I of the Future Growth Area by December 31, 2006: this deadline was not met, however, it was met during this reporting period. As the annexation date was pushed back, other objectives were affected, such as 5.2.1 where 500 inclusionary units are to be constructed by the end of the five-year cycle. The importance of the delayed annexation of new lands pales in comparison to the impact of the sub-prime mortgage crisis and ensuing recession. Many of the housing developers have terminated their plans to participate in the development of the Future Growth Area, and those remaining are proceeding very cautiously. There are also some objectives where it is not yet known if they can be met as staff resources have not yet been allocated to them. CHISPA’s acquisition of property for the Wesley Oaks subdivision marks significant progress toward the goal of developing additional homeownership opportunities for farmworker households. While ‘lease-up’ is ongoing, 46 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report construction is complete at the Housing Authority’s Tynan Village Apartment complex, easily the most ambitious mixeduse, mixed income project to be developed in Salinas. Last year saw the opening of CHISPA’s senior housing project: Sherwood Village, which can be a model for re-use of obsolete developments in town, a model that can reduce sprawl and make efficient use of existing infrastructure. And now Sunflower Gardens is under construction, another example of infill development that will address a special housing need while helping to revitalize an older area. The Consolidated Plan is a “plan” that indicates our best thinking at the time of adoption; it is certain to be modified over time. As strategies are implemented, it is likely that changes will be implemented as new information is considered and as circumstances change. Many of such changes can be accomplished with the annual adoption of Action Plans. D. Status of Performance Measurement System The City of Salinas has implemented HUD’s performance measurement system since program year 2005. “Objectives, outcomes, and indicators” for each funded activity is presented in the 2008-09 ACTION PLAN. Staff developed forms to efficiently capture data from the subrecipients’ programs for entry into the IDIS system. ESG subrecipients are required to use HUD’s Homeless Management Information System (HMIS). Staff continues to work with the Community Technology Alliance to assist with streamlining the agencies’ reporting processes. Staff is also preparing to meet new performance requirements as required by the various Recovery grant programs such as HPRP and CDBG-R. IX. MONITORING Monitoring Consolidated Plan and HUD Program compliance: The primary action in this regard occurs during the review of proposals received as a result of the annual funding RFP. Proposals are evaluated and compared based upon the policies and priorities in place and then staff’s ACTION PLAN allocation recommendations are based upon the results of this analysis. Any proposed amendments to the ACTION PLAN during the program year are also evaluated on this basis. In each case, the various timeliness rules, with respect to commitment and expenditure of funds, are also considered. All funding agreements contain deadlines governing timely use of funds; Salinas has long a standing record of meeting CDBG, HOME, and ESG commitment and drawdown standards. Subrecipient funding agreements require compliance with not only the relevant federal regulations and OMB guidance, but, are drafted to ensure that funded activities are carried out as contemplated in the ACTION PLAN. [The monitoring of such agreements is discussed elsewhere in this report.] Division staff closely monitor the performance of other City departments whenever they receive allocations of the federal funds in question. Following the recommendation of the HUD-CPD representative assigned to the City, we have implemented a Funding Memorandum process with other City departments whereby the appropriate department head acknowledges the need to meet the various reporting requirements as a condition of using CDBG funds. Compliance with housing standards: Compliance with housing standards is on-going and no modifications have occurred to existing procedures. Division staff schedule visits to assisted housing sites following completion of construction or rehabilitation. Recipients of deferred payment rehabilitation loans are evaluated every two years to determine feasibility of conversion to amortized loans; the process includes a site visit. [Note: commencing with fiscal year 2008-09, these evaluations will take place every five years. This change was made after staff evaluated the frequency of changes in financial situations of deferred clients.] Regular desk monitoring reviews of new construction projects are conducted to determine the appropriate intervals for performing site visits; in addition, almost all major projects receive restricted financing from other sources (e.g., federal tax credits, State funds) which typically include rigorous ongoing monitoring requirements. During fiscal year 2008-09 Action Plan a significant change in personnel occurred; a full-time regular position was reduced to a half-time regular position due to successive reductions in the City’s annual CDBG entitlement grant over the past five funding cycles, an overall reduction of 21%. The federal CDBG rules establish a maximum amount that can be used each year for administration; this cap is 20%. Therefore, funding available for administrative expenses declines as the total grant amount declines. In order to reduce the CDBG administrative budget, funding for the vacant Community Improvement Position was eliminated in the prior year. As this was not sufficient to close the gap, a current full-time 47 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report position was proposed for elimination. However, the CD Analyst voluntarily reduced the work schedule to half-time to avoid elimination of a full-time position. The costs savings in salary and benefits, together with some minor reductions in the operating budget, were sufficient to meet the reduced target administration budget figure. As this position is responsible for monitoring CDBG and HOME-assisted projects, the City intends to restore position to full-time upon future availability of administrative funds. Realistically, the earliest this can occur is in fiscal year 2010-11. On May 6, 2008, the Salinas City Council approved the FY 2008-09 Action Plan for CDBG, HOME and ESG. On June 30, 2008 the CD Analyst position transitioned from full-time to part-time. Consequently, during the reporting period monitoring visits declined. Staff did complete full scale monitoring of one multi-family project and one group home facility. (1) Jardines Del Monte received $500,000 of HOME/CHDO funds in fiscal year 1999-00 for project development. The 11-unit development provides affordable rental housing to low and very-low income households, with emphasis on farmworker households and in-home licensed daycare providers. The property contains five HOME-assisted units. (2) Casa Esperanza, was assisted with $260,500 of HOME funds in fiscal year 1993-94 for property acquisition. The single-family residence provides transitional housing to not more than six HIV/AIDS individuals with incomes at or below 80% of Area Median Income (AMI). The property contains five HOMEassisted units. While not subject to a site visit, staff also spent time reviewing the files for the Roosevelt Townhomes project developed by CHISPA in two phases. Additionally, all CDBG and HOME projects that are currently underway are required to submit Quarterly Progress Reports (QPR) with reporting periods as follows; July 1 to September 30; October 1 to December 31; January 1 to March 31; and April 1 to June 30. Also, all CDBG projects are required to submit an Annual Project Narrative following the end of the fiscal year. During fiscal year 2008-09 QPRs were submitted for the following CDBG-assisted projects housing projects: Wesley Oaks Subdivision (Relocation activity) and Sunflower Gardens. Additionally, during the reporting period QPRs were submitted for the following HOME assisted projects: Wesley Oaks Subdivision-Acquisition/ Construction; Gateway Apartments; and Tynan Village Apartments. Public Services: Monitoring of program progress, accomplishments, and compliance with HUD program rules is an ongoing activity conducted by staff by means of thorough review of monthly reimbursement requests, monthly activity reports, and rate of expenditures. In addition, site visits are also conducted. Monitoring standards used are HUD’s forms under CDBG standards “Checklist for On-site Monitoring of a Subrecipient” in the “Managing CDBG, A Guide Book for Grantees on Subrecipient Oversight”. Forms used to complete the monitoring visit are in the “CPD Grantee Monitoring Handbook” under CDBG Entitlement depending upon the type of activity provided. Staff first does a desk assessment and then notifies the agency and requests to conduct a site visit and review of program documents such as but not limited to: agency's payroll ledger, employee's time cards, the most recent financial audit, personnel policies, equal opportunity policy, case files, and client files that support the reported data for Salinas clients (as noted on the monthly Direct Benefit Activity forms). After the monitoring visit, a follow-up letter is sent stating the results of the visit. If there are any issues or signs of non-compliance, it is discussed in detail with the program manager/executive director to assist in bringing the agency in compliance at the exit conference. CDBG-Public Facilities: Public Facility Improvement Projects (where improvements have been completed) are required to annually submit an “Annual Data Collection Form” designed to capture service data such as: the total number of direct beneficiaries, race and ethnicity of each beneficiary, and all data required under HUD’s Community Planning and Development Performance Measurement System. The City’s Housing staff provides each subrecipient with an “Excel” worksheet that allows monthly data input; hence data is automatically transferred to the annual worksheet producing the Annual Data Collection Form. This form is submitted each year to the City by July 31, covering the prior period commencing July 1 and ending June 30. Once received, staff reviews to ensure compliance with appropriate national objectives. Additionally, all CDBG projects that are currently underway are required to submit Quarterly Progress Reports (QPR) with reporting periods as follows; July 1 to September 30; October 1 to December 31; January 1 to March 31; and April 1 to June 30. Also, CDBG projects under construction are required to submit an Annual Project Narrative during the end of the fiscal year. During fiscal year 2008-09 QPRs were submitted for the following CDBG-assisted projects: Salinas Municipal Aquatic Center (#9761); East Salinas Street Lights Phase 11 (#9047)-Design only; Freight Terminal ADA (#9399)-Design only; and Breadbox Interior Wall (#9043). 48 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report CDBG-Capital Improvement Projects-City of Salinas: Staff continues to monitor projects during the design phase, bid opening phase, construction phase and completion phase to ensure compliance with all applicable federal provisions (i.e., Davis-Bacon, Minority Business Enterprise/Women Business Enterprise, Section 3, Executive Order 11246, Executive Order 11063, Title 24 CFR Part 85). The City has developed various tools to assist with project monitoring during these phases. Such tools include: Federal Labor Compliance Checklist; Contractor and Subcontractor Compliance Worksheet; Quarterly Progress Report; and monthly or bi-weekly correspondence with the subrecipient or assigned City of Salinas Construction Inspector. City staff also updated forms in order to improve effectiveness. Additionally, the City continues to use the previously developed standard CDBG-Bid Specification Package that includes all applicable federal forms and provisions. As a result, if a Capital Improvement Project receives a CDBG allocation, the required wording is readily available for Engineering & Transportation Department staff use. This provides prior notice of all applicable federal provisions and requires the completion of all federal forms prior to submittal of bid. This process continues to significantly reduce the amount of staff time previously required to achieve compliance. Labor compliance in Capital Improvement Projects continues to be a high priority for us. The Labor Compliance Officer (hired June 2007) continues to increase her knowledge regarding the Federal labor compliance regulations and is scheduled to attend HUD’s three-day Federal Labor Compliance Training in July 2009, along with staff from the Housing Division. As the City endures fiscal challenges and takes steps to implement of the work furlough program (effective July 1, 2009), staff will continue to explore effective methods to achieve labor compliance given the decline in available staff and reduced working hours. As a result of the furlough policy, all non-public safety City employees will have work hours reduced by 10% (e.g., from a 40 hour work-week to a 36 hour work-week) and many City facilities will close on Fridays. X. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) NARRATIVE Table D – CDBG Activities Activity Name & Description 1) Project Location Sunflower Gardens Construction of rental units for people with mental disabilities 2) Wesley Oaks Construction of affordable homeownership units 1) Sherwood Village Construction of affordable rental housing for seniors 1) Handicap Accessibility Assistance Improve access for homeowners with physical disabilities 3) Housing Rehabilitation Assistance Owner 4) Public Facilities/Improvements Various 5) Public Services Various Total CDBG Funds 27 Sun St. 420,000 Fremont/Carr Ave. 170,353 808 N. Main 200,000 City-wide 129,313 City-wide 112,070 City-wide 914,589 City-wide 394,756 6) Rehabilitation Program Delivery N/A 383,470 7) Planning & Administration N/A 463,756 Total CDBG Activities 3,188,307 49 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report A. Housing Needs Sunflower Gardens-25-29 Sun Street-Interim, Inc.: The project site had 6 existing units housing seasonal farmworkers and is currently owned by the Monterey County Housing, Inc. (MCHI). The project was funded with $119,700 HOME monies in FY 1996-97. The City allocated $500,000 in CDBG funds this period and as discussed in the assessment section of this report, rescinded $425,000 in HOME funds. The project will provide 18 units, housing a total of 23 homeless residents who are very low-income and have major psychiatric disabilities. One unit is provided for the site manager. Other funding sources include MHP-Supportive Housing loan from the State of California, MHSA loan thru CalFHA, State CDBG funds thru the County of Monterey, a deferred loan from the Salinas Redevelopment Agency, and donated funds. In January 2008, the site’s Conditional Use permit was replaced and the City approved a Planned Unit Development permit to allow the proposed demolition, construction and new use. The CDBG funding agreement between the City and Interim was executed on January 28, 2009, with escrow for the purchase of the parcel closing in February, 2009. Before proceeding with demolition work, Interim, Inc. relocated existing tenants as required by HUD. A groundbreaking ceremony was held on April 30, 2009, attended by the City’s HUD CDP representative, Gail Goldman, City of Salinas Mayor Dennis Donohue, representatives from CalFHA, County of Monterey and City Housing and Redevelopment staff. Construction is now in full swing and the project is expected to be completed by April, 2010. Sherwood Seniors Village-808 North Main Street-Community Housing Improvement Systems and Planning Association, (CHISPA): Although the Sherwood Village Project obtained its Certificate of Occupancy on May 21, 2008 (during last years CAPER reporting period), the project received additional HOME and CDBG funds in FY 2008-09 due to an increase in project development costs. As stated previously, the property was acquired with financial support from the City (HOME & CDBG). Total development costs were $22,512,586; of which $2,200,000 were provided by the City’s Entitlement HOME program and $350,000 from the Community Development Block Grant program. To date, all units are leased and a waiting list has been established. Project provides 123 units of affordable and safe rental housing for seniors, and with hundred percent (100%) of the units affordable to low or very-low income households. The project includes 43 designated HOME-assisted units, all affordable to very-low income households with incomes at 50% of Area Median Income. Since its development, Sherwood Village has gained national and local recognition for its incorporation of green features and innovative architectural design. The project consisted of major renovation of a dilapidated and crimeridden motel. Existing buildings were preserved and converted into stylish studios. The project incorporated several green features such as a state-of-the art bioswale to retain, infiltrate and treat most storm water on site, and installation of solar panels. Sherwood Village won Gold in the National Association of Home Builders' 50+ Housing Awards in the Renovated Housing Award category and was also awarded with the Judge’s Special Innovative Award. The project was featured in the April 2008 issue of the Affordable Housing Finance Publication as one of the 32 finalists in the fourth annual Reader’s Choice Awards for Nation’s Best Affordable Housing Developments of 2007-2008. 50 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Additionally, the project was received a resolution of appreciation from the California Regional Water Quality Control Board for implementing the bioswale to protect the waters of the Central Coast, and from BFI Waste Services as one of four winners of the 2008 Curbee Recycling Award for achieving high rates of recycling while building the project. CHISPA recycled motel mattresses by paying St. Vincent to Paul charity $5 each to pull the foam, cotton steel and wood from each. All motel furniture was donated to Rancho Cielo, an at-risk youth facility near Salinas and all other furnishings went to the local Salvation Army. About 75% of the concrete and demolition waste was recycled with an overall diversion amount of approximately 95%. Housing Accessibility Assistance: This program remains an effective tool to assist low-income homeowners (including mobile home units) with eligible disabilities to modify their residences for improved access (e.g., exterior wheelchair ramps/lifts, bathroom modifications). During this period, six homeowners received grants for these disability-related improvements. See Appendix A for map. After Before Housing Rehabilitation Assistance: CDBG funds are used to pay for the delivery of services such as dwelling inspections, work write-ups, bid and construction oversight and application processing/loan underwriting. Rehabilitation loans are provided both to owner-occupants and to rental properties (provided owners agree to rent restrictions). One (1) single-family dwelling unit was rehabilitated through the Housing Services Program this period. Loans incorporated the testing and mitigations for lead base paint, mold and/or asbestos. No rehab loans were processed for rental properties this cycle. B. Community Development Needs Public Facilities/Improvements: One public improvement activity was allocated funding during this period (Salinas Municipal Aquatic Center ($800,000). The Aquatic Center assists the community by providing access to improved public recreational facilities. A detailed description of this activity can be found in Section IE. Public Services: Activities including those focusing on ‘at-risk’ youth and homelessness are discussed in Section I. A total of 25 independent non-profit agencies received public services CDBG funding. In addition, four City activities received support from this component. A total of $375,000 of CDBG funds went to public services activities during this period, which is almost a 10% reduction from FY07-08. This reduction was necessary due to the reduction in the City’s CDBG allocation for HUD. [“Public services” were also supported with ESG funds: see Part XI.] C. Other Planning and Administration: The City has been receiving CDBG funds since July of 1975. The allocation has varied each year, with the largest single year being 2003-04 (see table below) when the grant was just over $3 million. As shown below, the grant amount has declined each year since 2003-04. The reduction over six years amounts to $639,000 (i.e., 21%). (If grant figures are adjusted for inflation, the impact of the decreases becomes even more apparent.) 51 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Annual grant period 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 CDBG grant amount $ 3,081,000 3,004,000 2,839,031 2,550,674 2,537,808 2,441,464 Dollar difference from prior year $ <77,000> <164,969> <288,357> <12,866> <96,344> Percentage difference from prior year 2 ½ % less 5 ½ % less 10 % less 1% less 4% less CDBG regulations limit expenses for planning and administration to no more than 20% (applied against the total of the grant amount and program income). As the grant amount is reduced, the allowable expense for administrative expenses is reduced proportionally. None of the required administrative tasks, however, are reduced simply because the total grant is; and, for some activities, necessary monitoring can go on for 20 or more years. Thus, when grant amounts decline, available administrative funds also decline. The same occurs when program income levels decline, a trend that also applies to Salinas. Not revealed by these figures, however, are the other HUD entitlement grant programs that rely on CDBG funding for administration activities: HOME and ESG. The HOME program is governed by a much more complex set of regulations, yet has an administrative cap that is half of the CDBG cap (i.e., 10%). Therefore, Salinas must augment administrative funding for HOME with CDBG admin funds. ESG limits administrative charges to a total of five percent (5%) of the annual grant amount; thus in 2008-09 the total that could have been used towards administrative expenses was $5,500. Because this sum is completely inadequate to oversee this program, Salinas relies upon CDBG admin funds to administer the ESG program. During the years that these two programs have been added, the planning, recordkeeping, and reporting required by HUD (e.g., IDIS, CAPER, “performance measurement”) has been increasing - thus, even if administrative funding remained constant, we would need to do more with less resources. As described in previous CAPERs, staff levels have been reduced over the past few years. For FY2008-09, the remaining CD Analyst position was reduced to a half-time position. This has been a difficult transition as this person had primary responsibility for compliance with NEPA (i.e., HUD-mandated environmental review) and federal labor standards, as well as for the monitoring of assisted rental housing projects. Inadequate levels of administrative funding are exacerbated during fiscal years when non-annual tasks must be addressed. CDBG rules place both “administrative” and “planning” activities under the same category of “administration” which impacts our ability to hire consultants for planning tasks we are unable to accomplish in house. This situation arises periodically, such as when the Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing is redone or every 5 years when the new Consolidated Plan must be prepared. New this year was the increased administrative burden of no less than three new HUD programs, each created and funded for the first time. Two resulted from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) and one from the prior year stimulus legislation: Housing & Economic Recovery Act of 2008 (HERA). Each program is an increased burden on CDBG administrative funds due to the failure to set admin funding caps at reasonable levels. Enabling Act ARRA ARRA HERA Note: Economic Stimulus Program Homeless Prevention & Rapid Re-Housing CDBG-R Neighborhood Stabilization Program (NSP) Grant Administrative Amount Cap $ 1,013,978 2½% 663,180 10 % 2,621,166 5% NSP set by HUD is 10%, but the State of California is taking five points off the top. XI. HOME NARRATIVE A. Analysis of HOME Funds Distributed to Housing Needs The City’s Consolidated Plan identifies 10 housing needs. These are shown in the table below with comments on the 52 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report distribution of HOME funds to each. Successful development, construction, and rehabilitation of affordable housing require an effort that exceeds the timespan of any individual CAPER. For most major projects, the funding provided by the City is only a minor portion of the overall financing package. Limited conventional financing, increasing land and material costs, and the added expense of State and Federal prevailing wage requirements have combined to add much complexity to the development process for housing, as well as lengthening the time required. Table E – HOME Activities Activity Name & Description 1) Project Location Sherwood Village Senior Apartments 808 N. Main St. 150,000 531-539 E. Market 425,000 Lease-purchase program for foster care families 7 Spoleto St. 75,000 Construction of affordable rental housing 35 Market St. 484,326 2107 Perez St. 12,651 Owner-occupied home rehabilitation City-wide 102,471 Planning and Administration N/A 169,820 Construction of affordable rental housing for seniors 2) 4) 5) 6) 7) 8) Total HOME Funds Expended La Gloria Senior Apartments Construction of affordable rental housing for seniors Foster Care Housing Gateway Apartments City Infill Project Construction of single-family home on infill lot Home Rehabilitation Assistance Total HOME Activities 1,419,268 Sherwood Senior Village: Although the Sherwood Village Project obtained its Certificate of Occupancy on May 21, 2008 -during last years CAPER reporting period- the project received additional HOME and CDBG funds in FY 2008-09 due to an unanticipated increase in project development costs resulting from hidden defects discovered during building conversion, and due to stormwater retention costs. As stated previously, the property was acquired with financial support from the City (HOME & CDBG). Total development costs were $22,512,586; of which $2.2 million was provided by the City’s Entitlement HOME program and $350,000 by CDBG. To date, all units are leased and a waiting list has been established. Project provides 123 units of affordable and safe rental housing for seniors, and with hundred percent (100%) of the units affordable to low or very-low income households. The project includes 43 HOME-assisted units, all affordable to very-low income households with incomes under fifty percent of the adjusted Area Median Income. Wesley Oaks: The City of Salinas allocated $800,000 in FY07-08 HOME/CHDO funds to Community Housing Improvement Systems and Planning Association, Inc. (CHISPA) for development of the Wesley Oaks Subdivision project, to consist of six single-family homeownership units and four single-family homeownership and/or rental units, with one of the latter to be funded through the County of Monterey (via State Mental Health Services Act monies). Six of the 53 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report units will be affordable to low-income farmworker families with household incomes not exceeding 80% AMI (these will be designated as “HOME-assisted”); at a minimum the remaining four units will be affordable to families with household incomes not exceeding 120% AMI. It may be that these four units will also be restricted to lower income households as a condition of yet-to-be confirmed financing. On July 3, 2008, CHISPA acquired the property using HOME funds. On December 2008, PSC Industrial Outsourcing completed demolition of the substandard units on the site. To date construction has not begun as the project encountered critical development delays during the last six months as result of the freeze in state funding (Department of Housing and Community Development, or, HCD) programs: (a) Joe Serna, Jr. Farmworker Housing Grant Program (JSJFWHG) and (b) Building Equity and Growth in Neighborhoods (BEGIN) program. Both funding sources are critical components of the overall construction proforma and are required in order to proceed with development. The project’s JSJFWHG request was placed on hold for several months and to date, funding has not been released. However, on June 30, 2009 CHISPA received a notice of conditional award from HCD for Wesley Oaks project allocating funding in the amount of $400,000. Presently, CHISPA has not been informed of HCD’s timeframe for disbursement of funds. CHISPA has not yet submitted its application to the BEGIN Program as the first round of such funding was oversubscribed and there are no remaining funds. We understand HCD plans to release a NOFA during the summer of 2009; this should provide CHISPA with an opportunity to submit an application. Currently, CHISPA contacts the BEGIN program representative monthly in order to obtain updates on release of BEGIN funds. Moreover, the County’s original planned allocation for the MHSA Supportive Housing Grant was decreased from $600,000 to $299,848 due to fiscal challenges. Currently, an application is being reviewed by the California Housing Finance Agency (CalHFA); CHISPA expects a response by Mid-August 2009. However, the project developer is actively seeking alternate funding sources and working to realize development costs savings through value engineering. During the reporting period, the City was awarded with a HOME Energy Grant of $250,000 for the Wesley Oaks project by the U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) so that all ten units will be developed as Energy Star Certified housing. Staff is will prepare the funding agreement for this award in the coming year. Relocation: As the Wesley Oaks site contained a substandard six unit apartment building, the City allocated $240,000 in FY 2008-09 CDBG funds for relocation expenses. On November 23, 2007, CHISPA entered into a contractual agreement for Professional Relocation Services with Linda A. Norwood, Relocation Consultant. On February 1, 2008 a relocation meeting was held with all existing tenants. On February 15, 2008, the City of Salinas approved the Relocation Plan for Wesley Oaks. To date, all five households entitled to Relocation benefits have been relocated. Of those, two households used their relocation benefits to purchase single-family houses. The Lopez family closed escrow on November 19, 2008 and the Barajas family on May 1, 2009. Presently, the Relocation Consultant is assisting one more household to purchase an affordable single-family home. CHISPA’s goal is to secure homeownership status for all five families. Construction: Although, all households have been relocated, the construction phase has not commenced. On March 2, 2009, the project was reviewed and approved by the Salinas Design Review Board. On April 1, 2009 the Salinas Planning Commission approved the Planned Unit Development (PUD) and vesting Tentative Map to allow the subdivision and construction of ten detached single-family dwellings, including a 35% Density Bonus. On April 28, 2009, the Salinas City Council approved the PUD and Vesting Tentative Map. Although, local approvals have been obtained, CHISPA will delay requesting building permits until financing challenges are resolved. However, CHISPA will submit the Final Map by mid-August 2009. 54 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Currently, all existing dwelling units have been demolished, all existing tenants have been relocated and required City approvals have been obtained. Again, due fiscal challenges construction is expected to tentatively commence in January 2010. La Gloria Senior Apartments: CHISPA received $425,000 in HOME funds to acquire two adjacent infill lots and develop a 23-unit senior rental housing apartment complex. The project will contain one bedroom units to be made available to extremely low and very low-income seniors. The plan also provides for ADA bathrooms, private balconies for each unit, a courtyard, and a residents’ garden. In addition, CHISPA will work with other community organizations such as Clinica de Salud del Valle de Salinas, Salinas Adult School, Alliance on Aging, and Legal Services for Seniors to provide services for residents. CHISPA has already secured other sources of funds including City redevelopment funds and low-income housing tax credits. The project is expected to be completed by March 2011. First Time Homebuyer’s Assistance: No FTHB projects were processed this reporting period; the program is currently not in operation. Staff is looking at bringing the program back, in the near future, now that home values are at prices that are affordable to first time homebuyers. A total of $150,000 continues to be reserved to assist Housing Authority tenants with home acquisitions Home Rehabilitation Assistance No single-family dwelling units were rehabilitated through the Housing Services Program with HOME funds during this reporting period (others were rehabilitated with CDBG funds). Projects from Previous Years Tynan Village: This is a mixed-use affordable housing project that includes development of 171 mixed-income rental apartments and 13,200 square feet of commercial space. Project, developed by the Housing Authority of County of Monterey (HACM), will provide decent, affordable, and safe rental housing for lower income and other households. Out of the total units, 41 are designated HOMEassisted, with 33 of the units provided to very lowincome and 8 to lowincome households. Project received an allocation of $600,000 in FY 2006-07 and $2 million in the prior FY 2005-06. The groundbreaking ceremony was held December 2006 and construction began in August 2007. Construction for the parking structure began in April 2008. Construction is now complete and in December 2008, a grand opening ceremony was held. As of August, 2009, the management company working with HACM, The John Stewart Company has completely leased up all HOME-assisted units. Gateway Apartments: HOME funds were allocated in FY 06/07 in the amount of $450,000 with an additional $760,000 allocated in FY 07-08 for construction of 52 (16 of which are HOME-assisted) affordable rental-housing units to be made available to low and very low-income households as well as some units designated for disabled persons. The project also includes ground-floor commercial space. First Community Housing, Inc. (FCH), the nonprofit developer for the project has worked on securing various funding sources including a $1.29 million loan from the City Redevelopment Agency, CalHFA, Proposition 1C funds, and MHP loan funds from the State of California. Last period, staff completed the HOME funding agreement and funds are now committed. The project experienced delays with the loan closing as discussed in the assessment section of this report. Project design is 100% complete with the bidding process underway; FCH anticipates completion of the project in June of 2011. Foster Care House: Project by Children’s Circle of Friends (CCF), a local non-profit, plans to address the community’s shortage of foster care families via a program to assist low-income foster care provider families to purchase suitable housing. The non-profit acquires the unit, locates a qualified family that wishes to transition from tenant to owner, and then enters into a lease-purchase agreement with the family whereby (after paying rent for a 55 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report minimum of three years) title is conveyed to the family. In FY 2006-07, $75,000 of HOME funds was allocated to assist Children’s Circle of Friends with the initial acquisition of the unit. Last August 2008, CCF acquired a singlefamily, 5-bedroom dwelling unit in the Monte Bella subdivision. For over a year now, CCF has been working with the Department of Social and Employment Services (DESE) to identify a family suitable for the program. However, the economic downturn has affected this process as some of the interested candidates are facing bankruptcy and home foreclosures. CCF is considering modifying its program requirements to allow persons with credit issues to qualify for the program but extend the foster care provision and lease period to five years. The extension will allow the family to repair any credit issues they may have over a longer period and be able to qualify for the purchase at the end of the period. City staff is currently looking into CCF’s request to modify the lease period in relation to HOME regulations. B. HOME Match Requirement During the last five fiscal years, the City received a 100% reduction in meeting the HOME match requirements due to severe fiscal distress. The annual HOME Match report for the program year 2008 is attached in this document (see Appendix D). C. On-Site Inspections of Rental Housing During this fiscal year, there was a decrease in monitoring activity as the Housing Division staff person responsible for this activity was reduced from a full-time to a part-time status. As a result, on-site and desk-monitoring reviews were conducted for rental projects such as: Jardines Del Monte assisted with $500,000 of HOME/CHDO funds in fiscal year 1999-00 for project development; and Casa Esperanza, assisted with $260,500 of HOME funds in fiscal year 1993-94 for property acquisition. Staff focused on monitoring projects funded in earlier years, as the affordability period was either expired or close to expiration. The outcome of the monitoring reviews revealed that one project had successfully completed the terms of the existing funding agreement. Thus, as the funding agreement expired, the City provided correspondence confirming all provisions of the existing agreements had concluded, meaning Subrecipients no longer need to collect and submit the Annual Data Collection Report that provides evidence of services to low-income households. Monitoring of Jardines Del Monte revealed that on-going education is necessary when a project contains an array of funding sources requiring adherence to distinct program regulations. For that reason, the City conducted a joint monitoring visit that included the Housing Division and the Salinas Redevelopment Agency. During the visit program requirements for both funding sources (HOME and SRA) were explained to project management staff. Both projects were found to be in compliance. Staff continues to require the submittal of the Annual Data Collection Form for all CDBG and HOME rental housing projects, and to review the submitted reports. A newly updated form captures all data needed under HUD's Community Planning and Development Performance Measurement System. The ADCF is submitted annually to the City of Salinas Housing Division by July 31, covering the previous period running from July 1 through June 30. Once received, staff reviews to ensure compliance with all HOME and CDBG regulations. During this reporting period staff used HUD’s new guide developed for property owners and Participating Jurisdictions: “Compliance in HOME Rental Projects,” to help ensure project compliance. Additionally, city staff has ordered numerous hard copies of this document to distribute as part of the funding agreement process and to those Grantees experiencing significant staff turnover. In addition, City staff continues to update and improve its in-house 2004 reference guide for monitoring HOME and CDBG rental projects in order to achieve successful compliance by existing rental projects. The objectives of the monitoring guide remain the same: to manage the day to day operations of the City of Salinas HOME and CDBG Program; to ensure compliance with the HOME and CDBG Program and other federal requirements; to ensure HOME-assisted projects are meeting the low-income benefit and long term affordability requirements of the program; and to evaluate organizational and project performance and to ensure production and accountability. The HOME and CDBG monitoring process requires the following: prepare a risk assessment for all projects, prepare a written schedule of the monitoring activity, examine project files (I.e., progress reports, funding agreements, affirmative marketing plan, financial documents, IDIS reports, correspondence, and rent and income verification), and notify grantees selected for an on-site visit. Further, the guide describes: how to commence and conclude an on-site visit; important documents to review during the visit; how to address concerns requiring corrective action; follow up actions and type of written documents required to finalize the on-site monitoring process. A similar 56 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report process applies when performing a desk review. All project documents are reviewed; corrective action is implemented, if applicable; follow-up action is taken; Desk Review Checklist is completed; and a written outcome letter is provided to the property owner/property manager. During the coming fiscal year the focus of the update will be on ways to continue effective monitoring despite reductions in staffing resources. D. Assessment of Affirmative Marketing Actions There are three components to “affirmative marketing” of activities funded by the HUD entitlement grants: 1) outreach regarding program design and administration; 2) marketing of programs operated by the City; and 3) marketing of activities operated by sub-recipients and sub-grantees. According to the 2000 Census, Salinas has a large proportion of residents for whom Spanish is the first or primary language. Consequently, the City’s affirmative outreach and marketing efforts are focused upon that population. The next largest minority group is “Asian” which shows as 6% of the City’s population. Filipinos fall within that definition and the City has traditionally facilitated access by maintaining a list of bilingual City employees fluent in Tagalog. 1) In keeping with the adopted Citizen Participation Plan, notices of Action Plan hearings and of annual Request for Proposals are typically published in Spanish in the local Hispanic newspaper “El Sol”. The City subscribes to the California Relay Service to accommodate TDD (telecommunication devices for the deaf) users; published public notices provide a TDD number. The City also provides notice to: Central Coast Center for Independent Living, Deaf & Hard of Hearing Service Center, and Blind and Visually Impaired Center. These local agencies serve groups that may need notice in a different format. The Draft ACTION PLAN and CAPER were also made available at our local libraries. In addition, Spanish/English translation (using headsets) is typically made available during City Council meetings (and at every hearing regarding ACTION PLANS and other HUD-funded topics). 2) The City’s HUD-funded activities are administered by the Housing Division of the Community Development Department. Of the eight full-time positions allocated to the Division, four are certified by the City as bilingual English/Spanish, including the first point of contact for telephone and walk-in inquiries. An additional staffer, while not certified, speaks Tagalog. Promotional materials are produced in both English and Spanish and whenever marketing is done via newspaper, the information is published in both English and Spanish. From time to time, targeted outreach for housing rehabilitation and first time homebuyer activities is focused upon our Spanish-speaking residents, including information to bilingual realtors and mortgage loan packagers and Spanish language Public Service Announcements to the local news media. This period the response to outreach efforts has not been great. As first reported last cycle: many in the community are leery of making improvements to their houses at this time due to the recession and the negative publicity surrounding the ‘subprime loan crisis.’ In reality, however, our rehab loan program and our Housing Accessibility Assistance (HAA) program will still work for many homeowners, despite the current economic climate. 3) All City funding agreements employing funds from HUD grants require affirmative marketing activities. The City’s monitoring plan includes verification that affirmative marketing is being employed. Many of the funded non-profit agencies routinely provide their services in a bilingual format. City housing activities that are not HUD-funded (e.g. inclusionary housing and density bonus programs) routinely require affirmative marketing to the community. E. Outreach to Minority-owned and Women-owned Businesses Since the closure of the local, federally funded Minority Business Center we have been working to develop other, more direct, ways to reach out to minority and women-owned businesses. Hartnell College (the local junior college) was selected two years ago as a location for a minority business development and outreach program. Our attempts to connect with them have thus far proved fruitless due to their rapid staff turnover. Previously we tried subscribing to the CalTRANS List Of Disadvantaged, Woman & Minority Business Enterprises in order to locate area contractors. Unfortunately, there were very few building trades subcontractors listed for our area, and no general contractors. As the subscription was costly we determined it was not efficient use of funds to continue the subscription. As we have for the past several years, our programs maintain notices at City and County building permit desks inviting contractors to contact us and to bid on construction work financed with HOME and CDBG funds. The local 57 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Salinas Valley Builders’ Exchange publishes the same notice annually in an issue of their bulletin to members, plus they post our notice in their offices. At the end of the report period, the number of approved general contractors on our housing rehab list numbered 28 firms; seventeen (60%) of these are minority-owned firms. We have thus far been unable to locate women-owned building contractors interested in participating in our programs. CDBG-funded capital improvement projects are bid through the City’s Department of Engineering & Transportation (DET). Housing Division staff work with DET’s Public Works Compliance Officer and the Construction Inspectors to ensure all federal labor standards are followed, including Section 3 and the need to reach out to minority and women-owned contractors All HUD-funded CIP contracts contain the required provisions pertaining to nondiscrimination and preference for hiring local residents. XII. EMERGENCY SHELTER GRANT (ESG) NARRATIVE During FY 2008-09, Salinas was allocated a total of $109,345 by Congress via HUD for the Emergency Shelter Grant program. All these funds were allocated by the 2008-09 ACTION PLAN to subrecipients for eligible activities. As the end of the fiscal year (June 30, 2008) corresponds with the end of the funding period established in the subrecipient Funding Agreements. Staff anticipates all ESG funds will be spent and drawndown from HUD prior to the end of July 2009; HUD rules allow for up to 2 years to complete disbursements. The federal regulations governing the Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) program allow funds to be used for activities designed to prevent homelessness; they also set a maximum percentage of each annual grant that can be spent on prevention activities. During the period in question the City supported one homeless prevention activity for a total of $16,150: the Housing Advocacy Council. The maximum amount of ESG funding that can be spent in any one year on homeless prevention is 30%; therefore the maximum allowed for 2008-09 was $32,803.50 Thus the amount spent on prevention activities was less than one half the maximum amount allowed. Four other local service providers received ESG funding in this period: Table F – ESG Activities Activity Name & Description 1) Housing Resource Center of Monterey County formerly Housing Advocacy Council Emergency rent & deposit program 2) Interim, Inc. - MCHOME Emergency housing/aid for mentally ill homeless 3) John XXXIII AIDS Ministry Homeless services for HIV/AIDS population 4) Shelter Outreach Plus - I-HELP Shelter, food and outreach to homeless men Total ESG Activities Project Location Total ESG Funds Expended City-wide 16,150 City-wide 35,000 City-wide 26,000 City-wide 31,595 109,345 Housing Resource Center of Monterey County formerly Housing Advocacy Council: The Housing Resource Center of Monterey County’s (HRC) Security Deposit Guarantee/Rental Assistance Program helps low and very lowincome Salinas individuals, some of whom are homeless, enter the rental housing market by providing an alternative to cash deposits. Housing Resource Center issues a Letter of Credit to landlords, assuring that the tenant will pay the deposit over the next twelve months. With this letter, payment of the deposit is assured to the landlord. Housing Advocacy Council’s homeless prevention activities include an emergency rental assistance program for households and individuals facing eviction as a result of unforeseen circumstances and emergencies. Hours of operation are Monday-Friday from 9:00am-5:00pm. In FY08-09, HRC served 586 low-income Salinas individuals through the rent and deposit programs along with the financial education program. 58 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report Interim, Inc- MCHOME: MCHOME program focuses upon providing a full range of services to homeless adults with mental illness; a large percentage of the chronically homeless have mental health problems. The purpose of MCHOME (Monterey County Homeless Outreach Makeup Empowerment) is to get mentally ill adults off the streets, into housing and employed or at least qualifies to receive benefits. Enrolled clients can receive services for as long as necessary, usually up to two years. Services include emergency housing, psychiatric evaluation and medication, and assistance with obtaining food, clothing and personal need items. Case managers offer benefits counseling which helps clients complete applications to obtain public benefits including veteran’s benefits. Clients are assisted with obtaining jobs, accessing needed health care and dental services. Staff transport enrolled consumers to service locations as needed. The Program Director and a counselor are on-call after hours to provide emergency support to enrolled clients. Normal business hours are seven days a week. A total of 62 homeless unduplicated clients received services in FY08-09. John XXIII Aids Ministry: This program’s mission is to provide bilingual housing programs, supportive services, and emotional/end-of-life services to individuals and families living with HIV/AIDS. John XXIII offers HIV education, prevention and testing intervention service to high-risk communities, such as injection drug users, and high-risk individuals. Education, prevention and testing services are located on East Market Street with a drop-in center open Monday, Wednesday and Friday from 1:00pm-5: 30pm including street outreach. Administration and client services are offered Monday-Friday from 9:00am-5:00pm at the site on Baldwin Street. Unduplicated clients served in Salinas totaled 121 in FY08-09. Shelter Outreach Plus- I HELP: Provides emergency shelter for men and support services including food, transportation to nightly accommodations and emergency medical assistance, laundry services, showers, toiletries, clothing and bedding. Clients have access to supportive services such as: advocacy, resource and referral (mental health and drug treatment), case management, immigration services, education counseling, access to voice mail, a mailing address, resume and job preparation. The I-HELP program is an evening program from 5:00pm-7am operating year round (365 day per year). A total of 89 unduplicated homeless Salinas men received services with overnight shelter at 25 different churches and religious facilities in the area during FY07-08. Homeless Discharge Coordination On May 8, 2007, the Salinas City Council adopted Council Resolution No. 19201 (N.C.S.) establishing a discharge planning policy pursuant to the Emergency Shelter Grant requirements. With this policy in place, City was able to execute each of the specific certifications required as part of the 2008-09 ESG application package. Noting that homelessness is not a desirable condition for any person in our community, the policy notes that those with limited resources are particularly vulnerable to homelessness. The policy calls for publicly funded care systems and care institutions to make every effort to ensure that persons discharged from their facilities have secured a place of shelter in advance of discharge. In addition, it calls for all such institutions to develop and adopt formal discharge planning procedures. ESG Matching Resources Table G – ESG Matching Resources Other Federal State Charitable Activity Name & Description Grants Funds Donations 1) Housing Advocacy Council Emergency rent & deposit program 25,000 2) Interim, Inc. - MCHOME Emergency housing/aid for mentally ill homeless 3) John XXXIII AIDS Ministry Homeless services for HIV/AIDS population 4) Shelter Outreach Plus - I-HELP Shelter, food and outreach to homeless men 38,694 11,000 705,426 154,000 Other Local Funds 25,782 59 of 60 100,476 859, 426 30,584 20,500 Total 30,584 20,000 6,485 46,985 City of Salinas XIII. 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report CIVIL RIGHTS PROGRAM RELATED REQUIREMENTS A. Racial & Ethnic Persons Served In the past few years, public services providers (both non-profit agencies and other City departments) have experienced difficulty with classifying race and ethnicity of beneficiaries. During this period, staff encountered very few inquiries and request for assistance. This is largely due to the detailed training subrecipients receive at the annual training sessions; this focused assistance has now been in place for over 4 years. (Data compiled from IDIS report PR23). Table H – Families & Persons Assisted by Race & Ethnicity RACE White Black/African American Asian American Indian/Alaskan Native Native Hawaiian/Other Pacific Islander American Indian/Alaskan Native & White Asian & White Black/African American & White Am. Indian/Alaskan Native & Black African Am. Other Multi-Racial ETHNICITY Hispanic TOTAL 52,159 1,994 2,493 569 460 92 83 125 35 12,285 70,295 PERCENTAGE 74.20% 2.84% 3.55% 0.81% 0.65% 0.13% 0.12% 0.18% 0.05% 17.48% 51,843 B. Geographic Location of Investments See Appendix A for maps relating to the geographic distribution of HUD assistance. Also included is a map depicting the percentage of residents in each census tract with incomes at or below 80% of median (i.e., “lowmod”) per the federal 2000 CENSUS. Table I - Geographic Distribution and Location of Investments Map Key A B C D Description Housing Rehabilitation Assistance Handicap Accessibility Assistance AHNRSA Neighborhood Painting/Fix-Up Program E Alisal/Towt Traffic Signal Installation East Salinas Street Lights Phase 10 East Salinas Street Lights Phase 14 El Gabilan Play Lot-ADA Play Equipment Census Tract City-Wide City-Wide CT 05,06,07,08,09 CT 05,06,07,08,09 CT 08 CT 08 CT 08, 09 CT 08 Minority/Ethnic Concentrated See Note 1 See Note 1 Yes, See Note 2 Yes, See Note 3 Yes Yes Yes Yes E F G East Laurel Pocket Park-ADA Play Equipment Breadbox Gymnasium Divider Wall East Salinas Street Lights Phase 9 CT 07 CT 106.02 CT 07 Yes Yes Yes NOTES: 1 2 3 As programs are offered throughout the community, outreach is performed city-wide. Neither loans nor grants are made based upon the location; eligibility is based upon the applicant's income and the condition of the dwellings. The Alisal Homeownership and Neighborhood Revitalization Area is comprised of portions of census tracts 05,06, 08, 09—four of which are identified as an area of minority/ethnic concentration; the remaining tract (08) is an area of Hispanic concentration. This area has long been a focal point of City housing rehabilitation efforts and that city-wide program will continue to be promoted here. The Painting Fix-up program is operated by the Salinas Redevelopment Agency and it restricts its activities to the Sunset/Buena Vista Redevelopment Project Area, which includes portions of Census Tracts 05, 06, 09, 10 and a corner of Tract 18. All but Tract 18 have minority/ethnic concentrations. 60 of 60 City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report APPENDIX A – MAPS Capital Improvement and Other Projects Housing Rehabilitation Assistance Handicap Accessibility Assistance Housing Lead-based Assistance Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area (AHNRSA) Neighborhood Painting/Fix-Up Census Tract: Low-Mod Population by Tract ESP IN O SA RD SEL L R D R BO A R D N D SA N O JU AN GR A DE RD HIG HW AY 10 1 RU S N DA RD ID E L AUR EL DR T NS I TU TI O N VD BL DR SH ER WO OD 86.0% 9 RD RN O NB S SA AIR N CO OM PO B RT D LV 82.4% IE LN RD S 10 KI N NT E RL AN E HA R RD RD RD HU ER RD 01 CO CK MS 1 AY HW HIG FO ST E B LA CH LIA RD RD ER HIT IL W AL ST O ST IS AL S M AIN ACI AST TT BO NC T W ST AB W BL A TO ST DA VIS RD JO H N AC 6 N RD E ALI S A L ST L ST W ALISA W 90.1% E MARK ET ST AL AVE CE NTR R BO Y W 5 85.4% ST N SA PK 7 N M T RD RK E ST E AV DO MA SI R DE EE W RO S RI FR W A 88.4% ND RO 106.02 WA Y1 83 BO CO E HI GH DR NA T IV W LAU REL AD RD ST N MAIN IN D EP EN D IN D R RD EN C N E AG ST E ALV D OL E BL V D DA VIS RD E BO RO 83.6% NORTH Salinas City Limits ON R D County of Monterey, California KE LS BL VD RD TI VA R I VER R D RE C S ER SP RI ES Capital Improvement Projects and Other Projects Site Locations FY 2008-2009 HA R R City of Salinas Census Tracts With Minority Concentrations (% Concentration) I:\InfoSys\GIS_Projects\Community Development\CDBG\fy2007_08\AHNRSA_CIP 08 09.mxd SSE LL RD JU A N GR A DE RD HIG H WAY 101 RU BO A RD SA N ND RO NDA RD DE EN R L W LAURE DR VD BL UT IO N RO BO CO T IT NS E E L AUR EL DR NA T IV ID AD RD ST N MAIN IN D EP E ALV IN D NC N E B LV D DA VIS RD E BO RO ND A GH WA Y1 RD HI 106.02 83 DE RI R E AV 88.4% DR N OR NB RD SH ER W 5 85.4% ET ST W TO TS T Y 90.1% 7 W MA RK RO SS I S T PK W M W DO OO D SA EE FR N IL W M LIA S RD 6 86.0% E MARK ET ST CENTR AL AVE E AL ISA L ST RD L W ALISA ST W AC A CI AST RD OR N VD BL 82.4% SA NB ST RD S O T OR D T NC P AIR R AL T BO AB W B LA 9 IS AL S M AIN ST DA VI S JO H N ST E RO MIE LN HIG E B LAN CO CH CO CK 101 AY HW HIT RD RD LA NE 10 IN ER NORTH HA RK HU N T RD S RD 83.6% FO ST ER ON R D Census Tracts With Minority Concentrations (% Concentration) SP RE CK County of Monterey, California RIVER R D EL S RD I AT RV Housing Rehabilitation Assistance Program Site Locations FY 2008-2009 IS SE Salinas City Limits HA RR E R City of Salinas BL VD I:\InfoSys\GIS_Projects\Community Development\Housing\First Time Home\Housing Rehab Loan\HRL 2008-09.mxd SSE LL RD JU A N GR A DE RD HIG H WAY 101 RU BO A RD SA N ND RO NDA RD EN R L W LAURE NA T IV ID AD RD ST N MAIN IN D EP E ALV IN D DE NC N E BL V D DA VIS RD E BO RO DR E L AU REL VD BL T ST I UT IO N RO BO N CO E DR ND A HW AY 1 106.02 83 88.4% RD H IG DE RI R E AV DR SA N OR NB RD FR N SH ET 5 85.4% ST W TO TS T Y MA RK 90.1% 7 W W RO SS I S T PK ER M W DO OO D EE W IL W M LIA S RD 6 86.0% E MARK ET ST CEN TR AL AVE E AL ISA L ST ST RD L W ALISA ST CA C IA ST RD OR N 82.4% VD BL SA NB ST RD S O T OR D T NC P AIR R AL T BO AB W BL A 9 IS AL S M AIN ST DA VI S JO H N WA E RO MIE LN HIG E B LAN CO CH CO CK 101 AY HW HIT RD RD RD LA NE 10 RK IN ER NORTH HA HU N T S RD 83.6% FO ST ER ON R D Census Tracts With Minority Concentrations (% Concentration) SP RE CK County of Monterey, California RIVER R D EL S RD I AT RV SE Handicap Accessibility Assistance "HAA" Program Site Locations FY 2008-2009 IS E Salinas City Limits HA RR R City of Salinas BL VD File: I:\InfoSys\GIS_Projects\Community Development\Housing\First Time Home\Housing Accessibility Asst\HAA_2008_2009.mxd SSE LL RD JU A N GR A DE RD HIG H WAY 101 RU BO A RD SA N ND RO RD DE EN R L W LAURE NA T IV ID AD RD ST N MAIN IN D EP E ALV IN D NC N E B LV D DA VIS RD E BO ROND A DR E L AU REL VD BL TIT UT IO N RO BO NS CO E DR ND A GH WA Y 106.02 18 3 RD HI RI R DE E AV 88.4% DR N SA RN BO RD FR N SH 5 T 90.1% 85.4% ET ST TS W TO Y MA RK 7 W W RO SS I S T PK ER M W DO OO D EE W IL W M LIA S RD 6 E MA RK ET CENTR AL 86.0% ST AVE E AL IS A L ST RD L W ALISA ST WA CA C IA ST RD RN 82.4% SA NB O VD BL RD S O T OR D ST NC P AIR R AL TT BO AB W BL A 9 IS AL S M A IN ST DA VI S J OH N ST E RO MIE LN HIG E B LAN CO CO CK RD RD RD RL AN E 10 83.6% NORTH IN HU N TE HA RK FO ST ER S RD CH 101 AY HW HIT O N R D Census Tracts With Minority Concentrations (% Concentration) SP RE CK EL S County of Monterey, California RI VER R D RD TI VA ER Housing Lead-Based Paint Program Site Locations FY 2008-2009 IS ES Salinas City Limits HA RR R City of Salinas BL VD I:\InfoSys\GIS_Projects\Community Development\CDBG\fy2007_08\Lead_2008_2009.mxd 106.02 88.4% 7 5 90.1% 85.4% 6 86.0% 9 82.4% 10 83.6% City of Salinas Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area FY 2008-2009 County of Monterey, California I:\InfoSys\GIS_Projects\Community Development\CDBG\fy2008_09\AHNRSA 08-09.mxd NORTH Salinas City Limits Census Tracts With Minority Concentrations (% Concentration) Alisal Homeownership & Neighborhood Revitalization Strategy Area VI DA D RD ST N MAIN E L AUR EL VD BL NA TI DR LAUREL TU T EB RD DA ON OR TI NS CO DR N IO 106.02 RI 88.4% R DE E AV DR DO SH ER WO OD RD EE FR N N OR NB SA M T TS W TO PK Y W 7 90.1% 5 85.4% IL L W MS IA RD 6 86.0% E MARKE T ST E ALISA L ST J O HN ST RD D LV 82.4% S ST SA NB OR N RD AL IS AL TT BO AB B RT PO AIR 9 E RO MIE 1 AY HW HIG 01 E B LAN CO LN RD 10 KI N S City of Salinas Neighborhood Painting/ Fix-Up Program Area FY 2008-2009 HA R HU N TE RL AN E RD 83.6% County of Monterey, California 08/22/2006 File: I:\InfoSys\GIS_Projects\Community Development\CDBG\fy2006_07\NeighPaintingFixUp 07-08.mxd NORTH Salinas City Limits Census Tracts With Minority Concentrations (% Concentration) Neighborhood Painting/ Fix-Up Program Areas ES P IN OS A RD SS E L L R D HIGH WA Y 10 1 RU DE RD 43.90 JU AN GR A 105.03 BO A RD SA N ND RO 44.10 E BO RON DA 105.04 30.70 1.03 RD CE B L V D DR 13.50 EN L VIN 106.03 ST N MA IN 27.50 1.04 43.90 2 DR E LA U CO U T IT NS O TI N 4 OD DR N RW O MA RK ET SS I S T RD W TO T T S 37.40 106.05 LL WI ST IA MS RD 75.45 6 52.61 E MARK ET ST 76.55 AV E 13 L ST W ALI SA RD RN BO 7 5 56.60 17 AL CENTR N SA 72.80 70.05 S HE RO VE Y W 59.07 8 E ALI SA L ST 40.66 14 J OH N 106.06 ST ST DA V IS RA W PK W 29.49 16 ID E M O ED FRE 18 R RD 106.02 3 38.06 106.04 A 56.50 18 29.70 75.61 ND AY DR O OR GH W REL EB HI VD BL NA TIV L W LAURE ID AD RD 38.54 3 IN DE P EA DE N N DA VIS RD 35.96 1.02 RD V BL D T 71.85 SA N BO ST RN RT PO D T BO AB 12 RD 9 S W BL AN CO AIR E RO 10 1 RD RD HU N ER RD T ER LA NE Low-Mod Income Percentages Indicated in Red HA FO ST RK INS RD CO CK 10 AY E B L AN CO 80.81 HW HIG 15 CH LN 33.24 11 31.66 HIT M IE R AL 39.90 IS AL S M AIN W A CA C IA ST Percentage of L/M Income Persons by Census Tract, Salinas, CA Source: U.S. Dept. of Housing & Urban Development using 2000 Census Data less than 50% more than 50% City limits 0 0.125 0.25 0.5 R SE RE 1 Miles Census Tracts Indicated in BLACK AT V RD 0.75 R D EC K HA RR IS N IO SP R EL S BL V I:\InfoSys\GIS_Projects\Administration\LM_Income_2003.mxd D City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report APPENDIX B – ACTION PLAN AMENDMENTS 1st Amendment 2nd Amendment 3rd Amendment 4th Amendment City of Salinas Department of Redevelopment Housing and Community Development Division The ACTION PLAN serves as the official City planning document for the use of federal funds provided to address affordable housing and community development needs. The original City Council public hearing for the FY 2008-09 PLAN was held on May 6, 2008. Following a public hearing on December 2, 2008, the Salinas City Council approved the following amendment to the 08-09 ACTION PLAN. First Amendment to the FY 2008-09 Action Plan PROJECT DESCRIPTION LOCATION 2008-09 ORIGINAL PROPOSED REVISED ALLOCATION CHANGE ALLOCATION Affordable housing activities: · Sunflower Gardens 29 Sun Street develop 22 units for lowincome people with disability $425,000 (HOME) Decrease by $425,000 $ 0 Increase by $425,000 $ 425,000 [Developer: Interim, Inc.] · La Gloria Apartments develop 23 rental units for low income seniors 531 East Market St $425,000 (HOME-CHDO) [Developer: CHISPA, Inc.] The $425,000 in HOME funds are hereby designated as HOME-CHDO funds. Note: It is anticipated that Redevelopment Agency funds will be provided to Interim for the Sunflower Gardens Project to offset the loss of HOME funds due to this amendment. City Council Resolution No. _19571__ (N.C.S.) I:\Housing\David\HUD\Action Plan 08-09\amend1.doc City of Salinas Department of Redevelopment Housing and Community Development Division The ACTION PLAN serves as the official City planning document for the use of federal funds provided to address affordable housing and community development needs. The original City Council public hearing for the FY 2008-09 PLAN was held on May 6, 2008. On May 12, 2009, the Salinas City Council approved the following third amendment to the 08-09 ACTION PLAN. Third Amendment to the FY 2008-09 Action Plan (Allocation of Homeless Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing Program Funds) PROJECT DESCRIPTION LOCATION ORIGINAL PROPOSED REVISED ALLOCATION CHANGE ALLOCATION Public Services: · Housing Resource Center of Monterey County 134 E. Rossi St. $ 0 $ 988,629 $ 988,629 · Planning & Administration City-wide $ 0 $ $ 25,349 25,349 Note : This is a ‘major’ amendment to the ACTION PLAN: pursuant to the established Citizen Participation Plan for HUD programs, ‘major’ amendments require a formal public hearing. City Council Resolution No. _19646__ (N.C.S.) I:\Housing\Library\Action Plan\2008-2009\amend3.doc City of Salinas Community Development Department Housing Division The ACTION PLAN serves as the official City planning document for the use of federal funds provided to address affordable housing and community development needs. The original City Council public hearing for the FY 2008-09 PLAN was held on May 6, 2008. On June 2, 2009, the Salinas City Council approved the following fourth amendment to the 08-09 ACTION PLAN. Fourth Amendment to the FY 2008-09 Action Plan (Allocation of CDBG-R Funds) PROJECT DESCRIPTION LOCATION ORIGINAL PROPOSED REVISED ALLOCATION CHANGE ALLOCATION Capital Improvement Project: · East Market Street Roadway and Pedestrian Lighting Installation (CIP# 9085) East Market $ 0 $ 630,000 $ 630,000 · Planning & Administration City-wide $ 0 $ $ 33,180 33,180 Note : This is a ‘major’ amendment to the ACTION PLAN: pursuant to the established Citizen Participation Plan for HUD programs, ‘major’ amendments require a formal public hearing. City Council Resolution No. _19671__ (N.C.S.) I:\Housing\Library\Action Plan\2008-2009\amend4.doc City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report APPENDIX C – PUBLIC HEARING NOTICES Saturday, April 26, 2008 5A SCRAPBOOK www.thecalifornian.com ‘Torch Club’ wins honor Retired teachers award gift County kids receive $500 for recycling efforts Grant made in memory of colleague Logan $1,500 to the Hartnell College Foundation, in honor and memory of Marge Logan, a longtime Salinas teacher, union member and humanitarian. About 60 SVFT retirees were in attendance as the check was presented to Beverly Grova, Hartnell vice president. At a spring luncheon held April 10, the Salinas Valley Federation of Teachers’ Retirees awarded a one-time grant of The Harden Youth Development Center Torch Club received a $500 cash award for its participation in the Torch Club National Project. Boys & Girls Clubs of The Staples Torch Club America and Staples Award for Social RecreFoundation for Learning, ation recognizes proInc. have announced that grams that help club Boys & Girls Clubs of members increase their Monterey County has social skills and learn won a National Award in how to make positive the Staples National Torch use of their leisure time. Club Awards Invitation Torch Clubs across the for “Recycle for Life.” country were invited to participate in the Recycle for Education program. The project enabled Torch Club members to raise the awareness of the “three R’s:” recycle, reduce and reuse in their clubhouse and at home. Torch Club members encouraged staff and parents to recycle used ink toners and cartridges to help their environment. Torch Clubs are chartered, small groups for Boys & Girls Club mem- bers, ages 11 to 13, which focus on the development of character and leadership skills. Under the direction of professional staff advisers, Torch Clubs help young people realize their full potential by fostering positive self-esteem and personal growth; building communication skills; reinforcing academic achievement; and encouraging the development of conscientious citizenship. GROUPS/ORGANIZATIONS The Valley Guild runs the Steinbeck House and Best Cellar in Salinas. PEOPLE Aquarium honors outstanding volunteers Each year the Monterey Bay Aquarium awards the Lucile S. Packard Memorial Award for outstanding volunteer service as part of its annual celebration of National Volunteer Month. The 2008 honorees — Marcia Smullen of Big Sur and Sally Sikes of Carmel — were recognized as individuals “whose dedication and selfless service exemplify Mrs. Packard’s lifelong commitment to volunteerism.” Valley Guild honors its volunteers The Valley Guild has announced the following winners of its monthly volunteer appreciation drawings. n December: Lori DeLeon, a private parties volunteer since January 2001. n January: Eleanor Royal, a volunteer in the Best Cellar since March 1991. n February: Marilyn Mesa, volunteer since September 1994. n March: Susan Shaw, volunteer since May 2004. Winners receive two lunches at The Steinbeck House. Sandy Parker joins Alzheimer’s council The Alzheimer’s Association of Monterey County has announced the addition of Sandy Parker to its Leadership Council. Parker joins Betsy Kashinsky, Lynn Booth-Scanlon, Pat Sippel, Carol Kolb, Lynda Avey, William Bolstad, Kathy Dearing, Cindy Graham, Martha Hatcher, Donna Johnson, Donna Johnston, John O’Brien, Matthew Ottone, LaVonne Rilling, Ann Todd and Marie Woerz. Aquarium commuter wins $1,000 Commute Alternatives, the rideshare program for the Association of Monterey Bay Area Governments has selected George Kassal, an employee of the Monterey County Weekly, as the recipient of a $1,000 cash prize for the month of February. Steve Brorsen, an employee at the Monterey Bay Aquarium, was chosen the the recipient of a $1,000 cash prize for the month of March. Submissions PROVIDED PHOTO Beverly Grova, vice president, Hartnell College foundation director, accepting grant from SVFT retirees from Marge Logan fund. To submit items to SCRAPBOOK, contact Community Editor Katharine Ball by e-mail at kball@thecalifornian. com; by phone at 754-4282; or mail or drop off items to her attention at The Salinas Californian, 123 W. Alisal St., Salinas CA 93901. LOVING SALINAS Tony Diaz Bail Bonds Mario G. Michelle D. Salinas Valley Call the Best Tony Diaz Bail Bonds community church 368 San Juan Grade Rd, Salinas 449-2500 SUNDAY MORNINGS AT 9 & 10:45 svcc.net Don’t make another mistake! Tony D. John C. “WE SELL FREEDOM” FREE BAIL INFO & WARRANT CHECKS 424-2500 or 1-800-434-BAIL (2245) Member of the Better Business Bureau. PROVIDED PHOTO Current executive board SVFT retirees from left, Leanora Shaw, president, Marian Klinger, vice president, Joanne Velman, secretary treasurer. UNIVERSAL STONE & CABINET GRANITE COUNTERTOPS • KITCHEN CABINETS • ALL TYPES OF FLOORING Pickup DONATE TaxFreeWrite-Off We Handle Paperwork YOUR Running or Not CAR - • COUNTER TOPS • • • (Restrictions apply) Cancer Fund of America, established in1983, serving thousands of individuals nationwide. FROM 800 321 3023 (Size 96”x 26”) Vehicles, Real Estate, Lots, Boats, RV’s, and more! Serious Low Back Pain? Bulged or Herniated Disc? $98.00 Hours M-F 9-5 • Sat 10-6 • Sun 10-5 www.ustonecabinet.com Best Prices in Town Guaranteed! 1032 N Davis Road, Salinas CA 93907 510 Lighthouse Avenue, Suite 3, (Kmart Shopping Center) • Tel: 831-757-8888 Pacific Grove • Tel: 831-375-9888 Are you frustrated with the results your present treatment is providing? Are you ready to try something different? For a free consultation to determine if you could be helped with spinal decompression or chiropractic care call 722-3577. Pain & Injury Center of Monterey Bay Charles Strong, DC PUBLIC MEETINGS PROPOSED FY 2008-09 ACTION PLAN FOR HUD FUNDS The City of Salinas anticipates receiving $2,441,614 in Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Funds; $902,171 in HOME funds; and $109,345 in Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) funds for use during the fiscal year that starts July 1, 2008. Activities proposed for funding include housing, public services, public improvements, and services for the homeless. The Salinas City Council is asking for public input on the best way to use these funds. Written comment may be provided in advance of either meeting to the Housing & Community Development Division, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas, CA 93901; the public is also invited to speak at the following. Saturday, April 26th 9 - 10 am 665 Munras Avenue Downtown Monterey • Comprehensive surgical weight losss program • Personalized and expert care from Dr. John Feng, Board Certified Surgeon and Specialty Trained in Minimally Invasive Obesity Surgery • Experienced, Skilled and Compassionate • Modern techniques to optimize recovery • Find out about having your procedure in Monterey. Specializing in the Lap-Band ® Monterey Office PUBLIC HEARING The City Council will receive comments on the draft FY 2008-09 ACTION PLAN at a public hearing scheduled for Tuesday, May 6, 2008, at 4:15 p.m. in the City Council Rotunda. For more information please call 758-7334 or e-mail Grace De Jesus at [email protected]. DISABLED PERSONS REQUIRING ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN THE MAY 6 MEETING SHOULD CONTACT CATHY WILLIAMS AT 758-7381 BY 3 P.M., MAY 2, 2008. TDD USERS MAY CONTACT THE CITY THROUGH THE CALIFORNIA RELAY SERVICE AT 1-800-735-2929. DEPORTES AUTOMOVILISMO BÉISBOL Hamilton busca ganar en España El piloto británico de McLarenMercedes, de la Fórmula Uno, Lewis Hamilton, responde a preguntas de los reporteros, el jueves 24 de abril del 2008, en el autódromo de Catalunia, Montmelo, cerca de Barcelona, España. | AP Por Paul Logothetis | AP BARCELONA — Felipe Massa necesitaba una victoria en Bahrein para revivir su campaña en la temporada de Fórmula Uno, y el piloto de Ferrari la consiguió. Ahora es Lewis Hamilton el que requiere de un buen resultado el domingo en el Gran Premio de España. El piloto de McLaren está bajo presión para recuperarse de dos malos resultados consecutivos después de ganar la primera carrera de la temporada en Australia. Hamilton tuvo su peor resultado en 20 carreras en Bahrein, donde su vehículo se detuvo al comienzo y luego sufrió la pérdida del alerón frontal para terminar en el 14to lugar. Como resultado, Hamilton cedió el liderato del campeonato a Kimi Raikkonen. El piloto de Ferrari encabeza la clasificación con 19 puntos, tres más que el piloto de BMW Sauber, Nick Heidfeld. Hamilton, su compañero Heikki Kovalainen y Robert Kubica (BMW Sauber) les siguen con 14 unidades. Hamilton, quien encabezó el casi todo el campeonato de pilotos del 2007 antes de perder el título en la última carrera del año, asegura que hay tiempo para recuperarse. “Todavía falta mucho”, afirmó el piloto de 23 años. “Vimos el año pasado que Kimi vino de atrás, y demostró que cualquier cosa puede pasar”. “Así que definitivamente no descarto la posibilidad de ganar (el título) este año”, agregó. El británico regresa a la pista donde algunos fanáticos se mofaron de él en febrero por ser el primer piloto negro en la historia de la Fórmula Uno. La FIA presentó el jueves una campaña antiracismo en el mismo circuito. Ferrari sigue como favorito para ganar la carrera a 67 vueltas en el circuito de Cataluña de 4,655 kilómetros. Massa espera repetir la victoria del año pasado, cuando el brasileño ganó el GP de España justo después de coronarse en Bahrein. Raikkonen, segundo en Bahrein tras un primer lugar en Sepang, también ganó en España en el 2005. Todos los equipos tuvieron un breve receso de primavera para realizar mejoras a sus bólidos antes del comienzo del calendario europeo. “Va a ser muy reñida. Todos los equipos realizaron mejoras antes de la primera carrera europea, lo que hace que sea inclu- BALONCESTO Kevin Garnett, elegido como mejor defensor del año de la NBA The Associated Press NUEVA YORK — Kevin Garnett ganó el martes el premio al mejor jugador defensivo de la NBA en la temporada de 2008. El delantero de los Celtics de Boston superó en la votación a Marcus Camby (Nuggets de Denver) y Shane Battier (Rockets de Houston). Garnett atrapó 9,2 rebotes por partido, máxima cifra de su equipo, además de sumar promedios de 18,8 puntos, 1,2 tiros bloqueados y 1,4 robos de balón. Garnett ayudó a Boston a SÁBADO 26 DE ABRIL DEL 2008 | PÁGINA 3B conseguir el mejor récord en la liga (66-16) y marca de 31-10 como visitante. Los Celtics sólo permitieron 90,3 puntos por juego a sus rivales, la segunda mejor marca en la NBA, a diferencia del año pasado cuando permitieron 99,2 puntos. Los Celtics tuvieron la mayor mejoría de un año en la historia de la NBA. Garnett recibió 493 puntos incluyendo 90 votos de primer lugar. Camby, ganador del premio el año pasado, terminó segundo con 178 puntos, y Battier tercero con 175. so más interesante”, indicó Raikkonen. “Hemos ganado las dos últimas carreras y eso puede hacer que nuestros oponentes estén más deseosos de ganar”. BMW Sauber intentará mantener el buen paso con el que es líder del campeonato de constructores con 30 puntos, uno más que McLaren y dos más que Ferrari. Kubica tiene dos segundos lugares consecutivos y Heidfeld llegó tercero en Melbourne. Fernando Alonso ganó en España en el 2006 con Renault, pero esta vez no tiene muchas esperanzas de lograr un podio con un bólido inferior al de los líderes. “Hay muchas cosas que evaluar. Quiero seguir en Renault si conseguimos un vehículo ganador y la verdad es que estamos avanzando en eso”, dijo el español, bicampeón mundial con Renault en 2005 y 2006. “Quiero correr en un vehículo que me de victorias. No quiero seguir peleando por llegar a la tercera clasificación. Es difícil seguir motivándome”. Los equipos tendrán dos sesiones de práctica el viernes y una más el sábado por la mañana antes de la clasificación. La carrera será el domingo a las 12:00 GMT. Sosa sigue sin ofertas, pero aún no se retira The Associated Press SANTO DOMINGO — El jardinero dominicano Sammy Sosa no tiene ofertas para regresar al béisbol de las Grandes Ligas a casi un mes de que comenzó la temporada del 2008, pero se resiste al retiro, dijo su agente Adam Katz. “No estamos en discusión con ningún equipo en estos momentos, pero yo hablo con Sammy todos los días y el tema del retiro no es algo que todavía esté en dis- c u s i ó n ”, dijo Katz, quien se encuentra de visita en República Dominicana, Sammy en una Sosa entrevista con el canal quisqueyano CDN-37. Sosa, de 38 años, jugó con los Rangers de Texas la temporada pasada y conectó 21 cuadrangulares, pero solo ha recibido ofertas para ir a las menores o para tener Gran roles reducidos, lo que ha sido rechazado por el toletero. “Sammy se mantiene entrenando todos los días y está en buenas condiciones. Pero no hemos recibido ninguna oferta que sea lo que estemos buscando por el momento”, agregó el agente. Sosa es uno de apenas cinco hombres con 600 cuadrangulares en la historia de las Grandes Ligas, junto a Barry Bonds, Hank Aaron, Babe Ruth y Willie Mays. A¡LePganamos E RT URA a la competencia! En el negocio de lija y acabado desde 1990 Tenemos el placer deto anunciar la apertura nuestra nueva sala de is pleased announce thedeopening of our localizado en Castroville. newexhibición showroom located in Castroville Sábado y domingo PRECIOS ESPECIALES en azulejo, maderal, alfombra y vinyl de lujo. Tendremos carne asada ambos días y una rifa cada día para una alfombra de pasillo. Tenemos: Madera sólida bordes al gusto Laminados • Entamirados Tablón • Priedra natural Marmol y más Abierto Sábado y Domingo de 8:00 a.m. - 5:00 p.m. 11505 Commercial Parkway #9, Castroville, CA 95012 REUNIONES PUBLICAS PLAN DE ACCION PROPUESTO PARA LOS FONDOS HUD PARA EL AÑO FISCAL 2008-09 La ciudad de Salinas anticipa recibir $2,441,614 en fondos del Paquete de Concesiones para el Desarrollo Comunitario (siglas en inglés CDBG); $902,171 en fondos HOME; y $109,345 en fondos de Concesiones para Vivienda de Emergencia (siglas en inglees ESG) para uso durante el año fiscal que principia el 1 de julio del 2008. Las actividades propuestas para financiar incluyen vivienda, servicios públicos, mejoras públicas y servicios para la gente sin hogar. El Consejo de la ciudad de Salinas está solicitando la opinión pública sobre como usar eficientemente estos fondos. Los comentarios por escrito pueden ser enviados por anticipado a cualquiera de las dos reuniones a Housing & Community Development Division, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas, CA 93901; también se invita al público a comentar en lo siguiente. AUDIENCIA PUBLICA El Consejo de la Ciudad aceptará comentarios sobre el borrador del PLAN DE ACCION para el año fiscal 2008-09 en una audiencia pública programada para el martes, 6 de mayo del 2008, alas 4:15 p.m. en la Rotonda del Consejo de la ciudad. Para más información por favor llame al 758-7334 o envie un correo electrónico a Grace De Jesus [email protected]. LAS PERSONAS DISCAPACITADAS QUE REQUIERAN ACOMODO PARA PODER PARTICIPAR EN LAS REUNIONES DEL 6 DE MAYO DEBEN COMUNICARSE CON Cathy Williams al 758-7381 ANTES DE LAS 3 P.M., DEL 2 DE MAYO DEL 2008. LOS USUARIOS DE TDD PUEDEN COMUNICARSE CON LA CIUDAD POR MEDIO DE CALIFORNIA RELAY SERVICE AL 1-800-735-2929. SPORTS Friday, March 13, 2009 Hartnell cruises to 13-2 home victory Clifton strikes out nine in complete-game win over San Francisco City Staff report Chamberlin Preseason Meet: At Carmel, the Padres had four different individual event winners and King City’s Erica Williams won the high jump and triple jump to highlight the non-scoring MissionTrail Athletic League event. For Carmel, Laura Hendrick won the 200 in 26.60 seconds; Ivy Hunt won the 800 (2:35.50); Jessica Fenton won the 1,600 (5:54.99) and Melanie Hong won the 300 hurdles (52.00). Williams posted jumps of 4 feet, 8 inches and 29-5, respectively. Pacific Grove’s Kelly Prieto won the 100 in 13.0, and Santa Catalina’s Sophia Yu won the 400 in 1:09.5. The Hartnell College baseball team scored early and often en route to a 13-2 home victory Thursday over San Francisco City College. Travis Clifton picked up the win for Hartnell pitching a complete game and recording 10 strikeouts. Mark With provided the offensive spark for the Panthers tallying two doubles while going 4-for-5. Hartnell also had three other Panthers go 3-for-4 at the plate. The Panthers return to action Saturday at home Boys track against Skyline College. Hartnell improves to 12-9 on Salinas 91, North Salinas the year. 44: At Salinas, three Cowboys posted victories in multiple events in thisTri-County Girls track Athletic League dual meet. North Salinas 70, Salinas Alvin Jelks won the 200 66: At Salinas, the Cowboys’ (24.02) and long jump (19-2), had 11 first-place finishers to David Perez won the 800 North Salinas’ five, but the (2:04.50) and 1,600 (4:33.56) Vikings had more top-three and John Prader won the 110 finishers and edged their ri- hurdles (16.22), 300 hurdles valsThursday afternoon. (42.63) and pole vault (13-8). North Salinas’ Aviery North Salinas’ Luis Ramirez took home first Romero won the 3,200 place in 100 and 300 hurdles (1:33.21) and teammate Anfor North Salinas. Roseanna thony Zamora won the shot Ruiz took first place in the put (45-00.5) and discus (130high jump and triple jump for 5). North Salinas Chamberlin Preseason The other two Vikings to Meet: At Carmel, Pacific finish in first place were Grove had its fair share of top Brionna Sullen in the shot finishers Thursday afternoon put and Adrianna Ponce in as well as two first-place the discus. team finishes. Salinas’ Hilary Servatius Pacific Grove’s Chris Odell picked up first place finishes won the 100 with a time of in 100 and 200 meters, while 11.50 seconds, while teamteammate Kelsey Palassou mate Taylor Odell won the picked up wins in 800 and 200 with a time of 23.60 sec1,600 for Salinas. onds. Aimee Sawyer took first King City’s Issac Garcia place in the 400 and Cristina finished second in 100 and Villalobos took first place in 200. 3200 for Salinas. Pacific Grove recorded two first place finishes in the 4x100 meter relay and the 4x400 meter relay. James Palaniuk of York won the 1,600 and 800 recording times of 4:46.10 and 2:08.06, respectively. Baseball Salinas 13, Alisal 3: At Salinas, the Cowboys scored early and late to put the game away against the Trojans Thursday afternoon behind some timely hitting from three Cowboys. Ryan Bangs was perfect at the plate for Salinas recording two RBIs and going 3-for3, while teammate Robert Wayman had a double and went 3-for-4 on the day. Eddie Wright chipped in with a double and two RBIs, while going 3-for-4 at the plate as well. Salinas (7-1, 2-0T-CAL) will return to action at 4 p.m. today at home against Grace Davis High of Modesto. Stevenson 16, St. Francis 8: At St. Francis (Watsonville), the Pirates jumped out to an early lead and kept pouring on the runs in the seventh inning en route to posting their third straight win. Cameron Toler provided the offensive spark for the Pirates, tallying two doubles while going 4-for-4. Nick Halamandaris also recorded two doubles. Stevenson improved to 3-0. Softball Soquel 11, North County 3: At Soquel, the Condors cut the deficit to 5-3 at the top of the fifth inning, but the Knights responded with six unanswered runs. Megan Carrillo went 3-for4 for North County, while teammate Tara Lawley recorded the Condors’ first run. Tori Woods recorded the last two RBIs for North 9A VARSITY CORKBOARD County in the loss. North County (1-4) returns to action at 3 p.m. today at the Sports Complex against Watsonville in the Silver Bracket of the Circle of Champions tournament. Notre Dame 7, St. Francis (MountainView) 1: At Mountain View, Shanae Gasperson went 3-for-4 with a double, a triple and three RBIs to lead the Spirits to the nonleague win. Ashley Madison also went 3-for-4 with a pair of doubles and Sarah Solis gave up one run in five innings of work for Notre Dame. Notre Dame (4-0-1) returns to action in the Circle of Champions tournament at 2 p.m. Saturday against North Salinas. North Salinas-Sobrato: The game has been rescheduled. North Salinas returns to action at 2 p.m. Saturday in the Circle of Champions tournament against Notre Dame. Boys tennis Alvarez 4, Palma 3: At Hartnell, the Eagles managed to win two matches in singles play and two in doubles play to post the team win over the Chieftains. Daniel Chong picked up the win in No. 3 singles play for Alvarez by defeating Palma’s Corey Banks, while teammate Michael Jung picked up the win in No. 4 singles play over the Hunter Johnson. Palma’s Dominic Ottone and Steven Rogalsky posted wins for Palma. Alvarez (5-1 overall, 4-0 TCAL) is back in action today at home against Seaside. Hollister 5, Monte Vista Christian 2: At Monte Vista Christian, the Mustangs’ Ha Le won in the No. 1 singles match and teammate Sean Trando picked up the win in No. 2 singles play. College baseball SFCC 010 010000- 2 5 5 Hartnell 400 621000- 13 21 0 WP-Travis Clifton and Markwith. LPHuerta, Baka (6), Lees (8), and Evans. 3B-Tom, Klauer (H). 2B-Evans (SFCC), With 2. 4H-Markwith 4x5 (H). 3HStumpf 3x4, Andrade 3x4, Tom 3x4, Klauer 3x4 (H). 2H-Morris 2x5 (H). Baseball Alisal 003000- 3 2 4 Salinas 521005- 13 13 1 WP- Jensen, Hilliker (4) and White. LPValdez, Casanova (4), Chacon (6), and Coronado. 2B-Grant (A), Wayman, Wright, Jensen (S). 3H-Bangs 3x3, Wayman 3x4, Wright 3x4 (S). Stevenson 313 031 5- 16 17 6 St. Francis 110 015 0- 8 4 3 WP-Saroyan 5 k’s, Ricci (5), Halamandaris (6), Murphy (7), and Gleason. LP-Gaspar, Martin (5), G. Martin (7), and Donati. 2B-Donati (SF), Ader, Halamandaris 2, Saroyan, Gleason, Tucker, Forbes, Toler 2 (RLS). 4H-Toler 4x4 (RLS), 2H-Donati 2x4 (SF), Ader 2x4, Jaeger 2x6, Halamandaris 2x3, Saroyan 2x3, Gleason 2x4, Forbes 2x5 (RLS). Softball N. County 000 210 0- 3 6 6 Soquel 104 043 0- 11 13 4 LP-Tori Woods, Sanvoval (4), and Skelton. 3H-Carrillo 3x4 (NC). N. Dame 230 200 0- 7 10 1 St. Francis 000 100 0- 1 5 1 WP-Solis, Gasperson (6) and Falconer. LP-Quinn and Kaiser. 3B-Gasperson (ND). 2B-Madison 2 (ND), Gasperson (ND), Pura (ND), Falconer (ND). 3hGasperson 3x4 (ND), Madison 3x4 (ND) Boys tennis Alvarez 4, Palma 3 Singles: 1. Ottone (P) def Vargas (A) 75, 6-0. 2. Rogalsky (P) def Ortiz (A) 1-6, 6-2, 10-7. 3. Chong (A) def Banks (P) 63, 3-6, 10-6. 4. Jung (A) def Johnson (P) 6-4, 2-6, 10-7. Doubles: 1. Hussein/Yates (P) def Contreras/Romig (A) 6-1, 2-6, 10-5. 2. Vo/Moriyama (A) def Tantillo/Ponce (P) 6-1, 6-1. 3. Nanquil/De Luna (A) def Price/Walters (P) 6-3, 6-2. Hollister 5, Monte Vista Christian 2: Singles: 1. Le (MVC) def Barger (H) 26, 6-4, 11-9. 2. Trando (MVC) def Tobias (H) 7-6, 6-1. 3. Schrier (H) def Nissen (MVC) 6-4, 6-0. 4. Pan (H) def Mininni (MVC) 7-5, 6-0. Doubles: 1. Rudouts/Culier (H) def Chong/Jung (MVC) 6-0, 6-0. 2. Jensen/Greenwood (H) def Hwong/Song (MVC) 6-0, 7-5. 3. Bray/Johnson (H) def Speir/Parikh (MVC) 6-0, 6-1. Girls Track North Salinas 70, Salinas 66 100 meter: 1. Servatius (S) 13.14, 2. Olivas (NS) 13.68, 3. Wells (NS) 13.72. 200 meter: 1. Servatius (S) 27.67, 2. Davidson (S) 28.11, 3. Boyd (S) 28.93. 400 meter: 1. Sawyer (S) 63.67, 2. Lee (S) 64.97, 3. Ramirez (NS) 65.52. 800 meter: 1. Palassou (S) 2:30.58, 2. Nava (NS) 2:37.42, 3. Tirado (NS) 2:38.49. 1600 meter: 1. Palassou (S) 5:36.56, 2. Tirado (NS) 5:50.32, 3. Ramirez (S) 6:00.88. 3200 meter: 1. Villalobos (S) 12:58.77, 2. Cabrera (NS) 13:12.64, 3. Ramirez (S) 13:22.21. 100 meter hurdles: 1. Ramirez (NS) 18.24, 2. Grayson (NS) 18.51, 3. Kemper (NS) 18.82. 300 meter hurdles: 1. Ramirez (NS) 52.95, 2. Grayson (NS) 54.01, 3. Osborn (NS) 54.06. 4x100 meter relay: 1. Salinas 52.01, 2. North Salinas 53.50. 4x400 meter relay: 1. Salinas 4:15.99, 2. North Salinas 4:25.76. High Jump: 1. Ruiz (NS) 4-08.00, 2. Papazian (S) 4-08.00, 3. Sidor (S) 4-06.00. Pole Vault: 1. Davidson (S) 7-06.00, 2. Vuong (NS) 700.00, 3. Ackerman (NS) 7-00.00. Long Jump: 1. Lee (S) 14-05.50, 2. Ruiz (NS) 14-02.00, 3. Kemper (NS) 13-11.00. Triple Jump: 1. Ruiz (NS) 31-00.50, 2. Lee (S) 30-10.00. 3. Woo (NS) 3009.50. Shot Put: 1. Sullen (NS) 3408.50, 2. Ponce (NS) 33-10.00, 3. Abbott (NS) 31-09.50. Discus: 1. Ponce (NS) 102-02, 2. Sullen (NS) 99-02, 3. Abbott (NS) 89-01. Boys track Salinas 91, North Salinas 44 100-Heitz (S) 11.67, Crosby (S) 11.87, Almazan (NS) 12.15; 200-Jelks (S) 24.02, Crosby (S) 24.37, Heitz (S) 24.52; 400-Battaglia (S) 53.46, Coleman (S) 55.42, Pratt-Robinson (S) 55.71; 800-Perez (S) 2:04.50, Bell (S) 2:08.86, Trujillo (NS) 2:14.82; 1,600-Perez (S) 4:33.56, Anderson (S) 4:46.36, Ortega (S) 4:48.11; 3,200-Romero (NS) 10:33.21, Anderson (S) 10:36.01, Bell (S) 10:36.59; 110H-Prader (S) 16.22, Sickler (NS) 18.71, Mosley (NS) 19.32; 300H-Prader (S) 42.63, Ruelas (S) 46.23; 400R-Salinas 45.73, North Salinas 46:13, Salinas (B) 46.93; 1,600R-Salinas 3:35.61, Salinas (B) 3:41.55, North Salinas 3:47.67; High jump-Mosley (NS) 5-8, Singley (S) 5-6; Hall (NS) 5-2; Pole vault-Prader (S) 138, Napolitano (NS) 11-0; Long jumpJelks (S) 19-2, Mosley (NS) 19-1, Coleman (S) 18-8.50; Triple jumpMosley (NS) 41-5, Singley (S) 38-7; Benedictos (NS) 37-5; Shot put-Zamora (NS) 45-00.5, Cole (S) 40-11.50, Taueíetia (NS) 40-10.50; Discus-Zamora (NS) 130-5, Vasquez (NS) 116-7; Cole (S) 115-07). Cuba beats Mexico, wins pool B of WBC Mexico’s Foro Sol, located at 2.240 meters above sea level, proved to be a hitters delight, with 28 homers hit in the six games played here. Check Our Daily Specials Like Pozole Verde, Chicken Tinga and The Freshest Ceviche 20% OFF INITIAL WEIGHT LOSS VISIT Bring In This Coupon For 20% Off Your Initial Visit Today. FREE RUDY GARCIA, MD TEETH WHITENING 422-1997 422-1997 - ANY LASER TREATMENT 50% 50% • Botox • Facial • Fillers (Restalyne & Perlane) • Laser (Ipl, Photorejuvenation, Hair Removal) • Mesotherapy - Fat Dissolved • Leg Vein Treatment • www.drrudygarcia.com 162 Fountain Ave Pacific Grove 373 - 7911 9000097808 2 LOCATIONS TO CHOOSE FROM 321 Main Street Oldtown Salinas 424-1047 OFF O FF Valid only for new patients with insurance. Please call for details. Expires: 3/31/09 Offer expires 2/27/09 ARTISTIC IMAGE MEDICAL CLINIC N e w Patients New Patients W Welcome elcome M Most o s t Insurance I n s u r a n c e Accepted Accepted CREEK BRIDGE DENTAL 831-449-3264 1558 Constitution Blvd. Salinas, CA 93905 In the CreekBridge Village Shopping Center Maximize your dental insurance benefit! Minimize your out of pocket payments. 9000097505 Let Our Medical Weight Management Program Help You! Expires 02/28/09 and 22 rebounds, while Eric Devendorf had 22 points and NEW YORK — Syracuse Rautins had 20, all but two on 1187 N. MAIN ST. #101 • SALINAS outlasted Connecticut in the 3-pointers. second-longest Division I game ever, capping a Big East tournament quarterfinal douCITY OF SALINAS bleheader in which the second- and third-ranked teams in the country both lost. PUBLIC MEETINGS Andy Rautins hit a 3-pointer 10 seconds into the sixth Proposed FY 2009-10 ACTION PLAN for HUD Funds overtimeThursday night, giving the 18th-ranked Orange In fiscal year 2008-2009, the City of Salinas received $2,441,614 in Community Development their first lead since regulaBlock Grant (CDBG) Funds; $902,216 in HOME funds; and $109,345 in Emergency Shelter tion and they went on to a Grant (ESG) funds. The City anticipates receiving similar amounts for the next fiscal year 127-117 victory over the that starts July 1, 2009. Activities proposed for funding include housing, public services, public third-ranked Huskies. improvements, and services for the homeless. The Salinas City Council is asking for public input Much earlier in the on the best way to use these funds. Written comment may be provided in advance of either evening, West Virginia beat meeting to the Housing & Community Development Division, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas, CA No. 2 Pittsburgh 74-60, mean93901; the public is also invited to speak at either of the following. ing that instead of a much-anticipated third meeting bePUBLIC MEETING tween teams that held the No. 1 ranking this season in the Public comment will be taken on March 31, 2009 when the Council reviews the draft Action Plan semifinals, it will be sixthfor use of these HUD funds during the meeting starting at 4:00 p.m. in the City Council Rotunda, seeded Syracuse and the sev200 Lincoln Ave, Salinas. enth-seeded Mountaineers. The game finished one PUBLIC HEARING overtime short of the record set in Cincinnati’s 75-73 vicThe City Council will receive comments on the draft FY 2009-10 ACTION PLAN at a public tory over Bradley on Dec. 21, hearing scheduled for Tuesday, May 5, 2009, at approximately 4:15 p.m. in the City Council 1981. Rotunda. If information regarding American Recovery & Reinvestment Act of 2009 funds is There were some staggeravailable in time, the hearing may also include Salinas’plans for these funds. For more information, ing numbers besides the please call 758-7334 or e-mail Grace De Jesus at [email protected]. overtimes. The game started at 9:36 p.m. and ended at 1:22 a.m. DISABLED PERSONS REQUIRING ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE IN Jonny Flynn had 34 points THE MARCH 31 MEETING SHOULD CONTACT Cathy Williams AT 758-7381 BY 3 P.M., and 11 assists for the Orange MARCH 27, 2009. DISABLED PERSONS REQUIRING ACCOMMODATION IN ORDER (25-8), playing 67 of the 70 TO PARTICIPATE IN THE MAY 5 MEETING SHOULD CONTACT Cathy Williams AT 758minutes, the most of any 7381 BY 3 P.M., MAY 1, 2009. TDD USERS MAY CONTACT THE CITY THROUGH THE player. CALIFORNIA RELAY SERVICE AT 1-800-735-2929. Paul Harris had 29 points The Associated Press Handmade Flour & Corn Tortillas Angus Beef / Local Wines EVERYTHING ON SALE! NOW! SPECIAL OFFER COMPLETE ELECTRIC GUITAR PACKAGE 149 $ ALL DRUMS AND PERCUSSIONS 33% OFF! NEW!! KORG KEYBOARDS! 9000099508 Syracuse does enough to get by UConn in marathon a rematch of the 2006 final won by Japan. Freddy Sandoval, Oscar Robles and Karim Garcia hit solo homers for Mexico. 9000098985 MEXICO CITY — Yulieski Gourriel, Ariel Pestano and Frederich Cepeda all homered to help Cuba rout Mexico 16-4 in seven innings Thursday night to secure first place in Group B at theWorld Baseball Classic. Pestano and Cepeda each hit three-run homers in a nine-run seventh inning rally to lead Cuba to a win by the mercy rule. Gourriel hit a twrun homer in a five run fourth and finished with four RBI’s. Yulieski Gonzalez (1-0) gave up one hit and one run, with three strikeouts and two walks in two innings of relief for Cuba. Francisco Campos (0-1) allowed four runs and four hits in 1 2-3 innings. He struck out three and walked one. Cuba finished the first round undefeated in three games, and Mexico dropped to 2-2. Mexico will open the second round on Sunday in San Diego against South Korea, winner of Group A in Tokyo, while Cuba will face Japan in 9000098641 The Associated Press POR E.J. TÁMARA | AP LOS ÁNGELES —Tres años de receso parecen no haber afectado la popularidad del dúo LosTemerarios,cuyos integrantes resaltaron que Estados Unidos es uno de los mercados más importantes para la música latina, por lo que eligieron a este país para comenzar el viernes la segunda etapa de su gira "Si tú te vas". "Estados Unidos es hoy por hoy uno de los países más importantes para la música latina",dijoelmiércolesAdolfoAngel en conferencia de prensa. Pese a la crisis económica mundial, los hermanos mexicanos Adolfo y Gustavo Angel retomarán su gira en esta ciudad con un disco de oro,platino y doble platino por su más reciente disco, "Si tú te vas", lanzado en junio del 2008,y un disco de oro por su último álbum de éxitos "Evolución", que salió a la venta en enero del 2009. Ante esos éxitos de ventas, Adolfo Angel destacó la situación de la industria discográfica en Estados Unidos, comparándola con la de América Latina, donde "la piratería e inseguridad" afectan las ventas. "En estos tiempos... Estados Unidos todavía ... está muy bien, en comparación con Lorena Rojas regresa al quirófano THE ASSOCIATED PRESS MÉXICO — La actriz mexicana Lorena Rojas tendrá que someterse a una nueva operación debido a que, por un error, no le removieron completamente el cáncer de uno de sus senos. Según el diagnóstico original, el cáncer se encontraba sólo en los conductos de leche, y aunque como medida preventiva los doctores habían removido el seno completo, pruebas indicaron que el cáncer también estaba presente en la parte posterior de su pecho y en un ganglio del brazo izquierdo. "Sentíquesederrumbótodo", dijo la actriz a People en Español en una entrevista publicadaenelsitiowebdelarevista. "Quiero llenarme de buena vibra y salir adelante con todo esto", añadió con optimismo. "Voy a pelear contra lo que me quiere quitar la vida". Rojas fue diagnosticada con cáncer en julio de 2008 y operada por primera vez en diciembre de ese año.Tendrá que someterse a quimioterapia por unos cinco meses para completar su tratamiento. "No deja de ser una mutilación, pero gracias a eso estoy viva", señaló la protagonista de telenovelas como "Tentaciones", "Ladrón de corazones", "El cuerpo del deseo" y "Pecados ajenos". México, países latinoamericanos donde ya es complicado vender discos originales", dijo. Los baladistas tienen como invitado al trompetista cubano Arturo Sandoval en el sencillo "Si tú te vas", que ha marcado su retorno. "Cómo se extraña esto ...Qué bonito es regresar", dijo el vocalistaGustavoalaprensaenel Teatro Nokia, donde comenzarán la segunda etapa de la gira que iniciaron el año pasado, cuando dieron cinco presentaciones en Estados Unidos. "Nos sentimos en el camino donde siempre hemos sido felices", agregó Adolfo, segunda voz, y tecladista. El dúo estaba tan contento de regresar luego de tres años que cuando el presentador intentó parar la conferencia, Adolfo le dijo que querían seguir y terminaron al cumplirse media hora, cuando la prensa se quedó sin preguntas. "Apenas está calentando uno aquí", bromeó Gustavo. Aparte de Estados Unidos, la gira "Si tú te vas" incluirá presentaciones en Centro y Sudamérica para terminar en México. "Si tú te vas", escrita por Adolfo,fue elegida este año por la Sociedad Estadounidense de Compositores,Autores y Publicistas como la mejor canción de balada/pop. El tema incluye un solo de trompeta de Sandoval, a quien Adolfo calificó de "fuera de serie". "Es el único músico que puede llegar hasta allí (esas notas)", dijo el productor y compositor de la mayoría de las canciones del dúo. "Su talento, sentimiento y manera de ejecutar es ¡fuera de serie!". "Evolución de amor" incluye "Te quiero", "Te hice mal", "Cómo te recuerdo", "Eres un sueño", algunos de los éxitos logrados por el dúo durante su carrera de tres décadas. _____ En la red: http://lostemerarios.net Paulina Rubio sella acuerdo con fotógrafa y evita juicio POR GISELA SALOMÓN | AP MIAMI — La cantante mexicana Paulina Rubio llegó a un acuerdo extrajudicial con una fotógrafa que la demandaba en un tribunal de Miami por una presunta agresión y evitó así enfrentar a partir de esta semana un juicio, dijeron el lunes fuentes judiciales. El inicio del juicio estaba agendado para el martes en el tribunal civil del condado de Miami-Dade. Sin embargo, tanto la portavoz del tribunal, Eunice Sigler, como la secretaria del juez que lleva la causa, Susan Ruisech, confirmaron a la AP que se canceló por el acuerdo al que llegaron las partes el jueves pasado. "Las partes llegaron a un acuerdo", manifestó Sigler en un correo electrónico. "El juicio fue cancelado". Los detalles del acuerdo, no obstante, aún se desconocen y "podrían pasar varios meses" hasta que las partes se los envíen al juez Allen Leesfield, dijo Ruisech. El proceso judicial se inició en octubre del 2006, cuando Orozco demandó a Rubio por un mínimo de 15.000 dólares en daños y perjuicios, que habría sufrido con los golpes que la cantante supuestamente le propinó cuando ella intentaba tomarle fotografías en el Aeropuerto Internacional de Miami. El presunto altercado habría sido el 10 de septiembre del 2006 a las 11.00 de la mañana. Como resultado del incidente, de acuerdo con el ale- gato de Orozco en la demanda, la fotógrafa resultó herida en la cabeza y el rostro y debió ser atendida por médicos. Además, Orozco "sufrió de angustia mental, perdió la capacidad de disfrutar de la vida, y perdió la capacidad de percibir futuros ingresos monetarios", indica la demanda. Asegura también que el comportamiento de Rubio fue "con premeditación e intencional". La versión que Rubio ofreció ante la justicia, sin embargo, es diferente. En un documento que presentó en marzo del 2007 en el tribunal solicitando que en las audiencias judiciales no se permitiera el ingreso de personas ajenas al caso ni se autorizara la filmación de su testimonio, la llamada "Chica Dorada" definió a Orozco como una "paparazzi". Dijo que acosaba a celebridades como ella para filmarlas o fotografiarlas "en situaciones incómodas, poco favorecedoras o avergonzantes". Rubio,quienalegóqueOrozco se beneficiaba económicamente conesasimágenesvendiéndoselasalaprensa,señalóquelafotógrafalapersiguióporlascallesde Miami, desde su casa hasta el aeropuerto, poniendo en peligro su seguridad y la del público. DONATE Tax Write-Off We Handle Paperwork YOUR Running or Not CAR - • • • • Free Pickup (Restrictions apply) Cancer Fund of America, established in1983, serving thousands of individuals nationwide. 800 321 3023 9000097778 Los Temerarios inician gira en Estados Unidos HOGAR Vehicles, Real Estate, Lots, Boats, RV’s, and more! Se renta espacio comercial en Chualar. Cuatro unidades de 2,000 pies cuadrados cada una. Con acceso y vista a la Autopista 101. Para cualuqier uso, almacén u oficina. Ideales para: • Tienda general • Salon de belleza • Restaurante • Tienda de zapatos y ropa Contrato de arriendo flexible Para mas informacion por favor comuniquese con John al (831) 679-2515 9000097046 PÁGINA 4 | SÁBADO 14 DE MARZO DEL 2009 NEWS Low clouds, then sun Winds: WNW 8-16 mph UV: 8, Very High The higher the AccuWeather.com UV Index™ number, the greater the need for eye and skin protection. Shown is the highest value of the day. MODERATE Tree Pollen: Grass Pollen: LOW Weed Pollen: HIGH Mold Spores: LOW MOONRISE: 11:55 P.M. SUNSET: 8:00 P.M. MOONSET: 2:03 P.M. 4-DAY SALINAS FORECAST 70 55 Oakland 70/56 Mostly sunny and nice Winds: WNW 8-16 mph 69 56 Mostly sunny Winds: W 8-16 mph Highs: Lows: 123,600 37 210 79,475 21 380 Hi Big Sur Carmel Vly. Gonzales Hollister 72 74 80 81 Greenfield 90/55 Arroyo Seco 85/50 City pc pc s s King City Marina Monterey Oakland Hi Lo W 55 54 54 56 City s pc pc pc Pacific Grv. Salinas San Fran. San Jose Hi 66 70 70 78 Lo W 54 55 55 57 City pc s pc s Santa Cruz Seaside Soledad Watsonville STATE TEMPERATURES Today City Hi Anaheim Bakersfield Barstow Bishop Concord Eureka Fresno Long Beach Los Angeles Needles Palm Springs 87 101 105 97 89 65 100 80 84 109 106 Lo W 63 68 73 54 58 49 66 64 64 84 79 pc s s pc pc pc s pc pc pc s Friday Hi 82 94 103 94 86 67 94 79 82 106 105 Lo W 64 65 71 53 57 46 62 63 62 79 75 Today City pc s s s s pc s pc pc t s Hi Paso Robles Redwood City Riverside Sacramento San Diego Santa Barbara Santa Maria Santa Rosa Tahoe Valley Vallejo Yosemite Valley 98 77 93 91 77 74 73 83 78 74 97 City Hi NATIONAL TEMPERATURES Today City Hi Albuquerque Anchorage Atlanta Baltimore Birmingham Boise Boston Buffalo Charleston, W. Va. Chicago Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus, Ohio Dallas Denver Detroit Duluth Fairbanks Fargo Flagstaff Hartford Honolulu Houston Indianapolis Kansas City 86 65 86 81 91 90 73 84 86 86 86 82 86 97 95 84 84 63 92 73 80 87 97 86 92 Lo W 64 53 70 67 70 58 64 62 61 62 61 61 65 76 59 65 61 49 67 50 61 76 74 63 66 t c t t s pc pc s c s s s s pc t s s c s t t c t s s Friday Hi 81 64 85 85 89 79 80 85 87 88 90 87 90 96 84 88 85 67 94 75 86 89 97 87 92 Lo W 63 53 70 66 71 52 67 65 64 65 64 66 68 77 57 67 64 49 70 52 63 76 74 66 70 t r t t t s s s pc s s s s pc t s pc c c t pc s t s s Today Hi Amsterdam Athens Auckland Berlin Bogota Cairo Dublin Geneva Ho Chi Minh Hong Kong Jerusalem London Madrid 72 88 60 72 66 97 64 81 89 90 84 75 92 Lo W 54 72 50 54 45 72 55 58 76 82 61 57 68 pc s sh s sh s pc s t t s pc pc Las Vegas Little Rock Louisville Miami Milwaukee Minneapolis Nashville New Orleans New York City Oklahoma City Orlando Philadelphia Phoenix Pittsburgh Portland, Ore. Rapid City Reno St. Louis Salt Lake City Seattle Spokane Tucson Washington, D.C. Wichita Yuma Friday Hi 68 90 62 71 67 96 64 81 91 90 83 75 91 Lo W 52 73 52 55 43 76 54 57 76 82 64 59 66 105 92 88 90 79 88 90 93 77 96 90 83 100 84 73 98 92 88 93 68 73 89 88 93 103 52 57 62 57 68 57 52 51 40 55 54 Hi Manila Mexico City Moscow Oslo Paris Rome San Juan, P.R. Seoul Sydney Tokyo Toronto Vancouver Warsaw 85 79 71 68 77 86 86 91 67 91 83 67 68 Hi 73 69 82 73 88 78 91 88 75 72 71 85 74 73 94 Lo W Hi 78 65 67 80 64 70 68 76 68 68 74 70 82 62 55 62 58 68 67 53 51 72 70 68 84 s s s t s s s t t s t t t pc sh s s s pc c sh t t s pc Lo W 78 54 54 50 59 68 76 68 46 79 63 55 50 r t pc c c s t pc s pc s c sh Lo W 51 54 55 51 pc pc s s Lo W 49 57 60 57 66 54 51 50 39 51 53 s pc s s pc pc pc pc s pc s Friday 102 94 91 89 84 93 92 93 84 95 91 85 101 86 75 98 86 93 90 71 73 95 86 95 106 Lo W 79 68 69 79 67 72 69 75 73 71 74 72 84 64 55 62 53 71 63 54 50 75 71 70 81 pc s s t s s pc t t pc t t t s s t s s pc pc pc t t pc s Friday Hi 87 75 65 67 81 88 90 93 68 88 82 69 70 Lo W 78 55 48 54 59 68 79 68 48 73 63 56 52 t t r s pc s pc s s r s pc pc Weather (W): s-sunny, pc-partly pc sh sf sn cloudy, c-cloudy, sh-showers, t-thunderstorms, r-rain, sf-snow flurries, sn-snow, i-ice. NATIONAL CONDITIONS FOR THURSDAY Whitehorse 66/45 Shown are noon positions of weather systems. Temperature bands are highs for the day. Iqaluit 46/38 Yellowknife 59/45 Churchill 53/40 St. John's 69/56 Vancouver Calgary 60/44 67/55 Saskatoon 72/50 Seattle Winnipeg 68/53 84/64 Billings 92/61 San Francisco 69/56 Los Angeles 84/64 Denver 95/59 Montreal Toronto 82/64 83/63 Minneapolis 88/70 Chicago 86/62 El Paso Houston 91/70 97/74 Chihuahua 90/66 La Paz Monterrey 102/77 102/75 SALINAS RAINFALL AsAsofof66p.m. Wednesday p.m. Aug. 6: 0.25” Since 1 0.25” SinceJuly July 1: Last date Lastseason season: to 14.28” Normal season to date Normal season 0.00” 0.26” trace 0.07” 15.34” Compiled by Burnett Hartsook, Salinas weather watcher for The Salinas Californian Current weather online The Salinas Californian Web site www.thecalifornian.com Halifax 73/58 Fronts Cold Warm Stationary New York 77/68 Detroit 84/65 Showers Washington 88/70 T-Storms Rain Atlanta 86/70 Flurries Snow Miami 90/80 MOON PHASES Last 1,900 1,800 1,700 A M +1.47% 39.02 15.10 19.65 14.14 61.73 7.92 33.35 54.18 26.40 31.79 29.85 1.40 2.89 24.88 +.91 +.36 +.05 +.21 -.11 +.26 +.61 -.19 -.29 -.19 +.51 -.08 +.31 +.09 J High J A Low 2,015.26 1,600 1,970.25 MARKET WATCH 120.16 28.99 DOW 9,361.61 NASDAQ 1998.72 11.46 0.21 S&P 500 1005.81 DOLLAR 96.23 Go to www.TheCalifornian.com for up-to-the-minute stock prices $10K 1.00% 1.55% $50K 1.00% 1.55% One-year CDs Central Cst FCU Allstate Bank 1.26% 1.85% 1.26% 1.85% Two-year CDs Central Cst FCU Allstate Bank 1.81% 2.25% 1.81% 2.25% The Big Question is an informal daily poll at TheCalifornian.com. Friday Hi s pc s s pc pc pc pc pc pc pc Today City r s r c sh s r s r t s pc pc Lo W Today WORLD TEMPERATURES City 2,000 New Friday 8/14 FILM THE BOOK! — THE MASK OF ZORRO, 7 to 9 p.m., MILLS THE BIG QUESTION San Ardo 94/56 78 66 66 72 THIRD ANNUAL BREASTFEEDING AWARENESS WALK, 11 a.m. to 1 p.m., WIC office, 632 E. Alisal St., Salinas. Walk at noon. Festivities include radio station broadcasts, food demonstrations, farmers market, prizes, children’s activities and 2009 T-shirt for walkers. 2009 PEBBLE BEACH TOUR D’ELEGANCE, 8:30 a.m., Carmel Mission Basilica, 3080 Rio Road, Carmel. Special reception and celebration for Morgan motor cars at Carmel Mission. Departs Polo Field in Pebble Beach for tour and arrives between 10 and 11:30 a.m. at Mission before joining rest of tour in downtown Carmel. 37TH ANNUAL FRIENDS OF THE HARRISON MEMORIAL LIBRARY BOOK SALE, All Saints Episcopal Church, Dolores and Ninth Street, Carmel. Hall and patio. Preview sale for members ($10 membership at door) from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. Thursday. Public sale 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. Friday and Saturday. Hardcover and paperback books, CDs, records, collectibles and tapes. Fundraiser for books and programs at the library. 831-626-8845. BONHAMS’ AUCTION OF EXCEPTIONAL MOTORCARS, 10 a.m. to 4 p.m., Quail Lodge Resort, 8205 Valley Greens Drive, Carmel. Preview 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. Thursday and auction on Friday with collectors’ automobilia, 10 a.m.; jewelry and watches, noon; and collectors’ motorcars, 1 p.m. Catalog available online at www. bonhams.com/quail. Free and open to public; catalog is $80 (available online free). 9,221.02 Six-month CDs Cen Cst FCU Allstate Bank King City 82/58 3.2 5.6 3.1 Lo W 54 53 54 50 Low Today 7,500 These are rates of return on $10,000 and $50,000 certificates of deposit or share certificates available Tuesday. Yield is annual compounded interest. REGIONAL TEMPERATURES FOR FRIDAY City A CD WATCH Gonzales 83/55 3.2 5.4 2.7 0.6 CalifWtr Chiquita ConAgra ConstellA Diageo Gannett GraniteC HSBC Macerich McCorm McGrwH MontGour PacCapB Sysco Hollister 84/56 Soledad 86/55 Today 4:59 a.m. 4:10 p.m. 9:41 a.m. 11:42 p.m. Friday 6:46 a.m. 5:08 p.m. 10:49 a.m. none Lows: Release (cfps) Chualar 80/54 Statistics for Monterey. Heights are given in feet. Highs: % full Salinas 69/57 Carmel Valley 75/51 TIDES Level (af) Prunedale 69/57 Big Sur 75/52 High 9,424.11 LOCAL STOCKS acre feet (af) = volume of water 1 acre by 1 foot deep or 326,000 gallons; Release (cfps) = cubic feet per second 66/55 Pacific Grove Seaside 66/55 70/53 Carmel Monterey 66/55 77/50 J AP Winds: NW 10-20 mph Reservoir San Antonio Wednesday Nacimiento Wednesday Watsonville Winds: 73/53 WNW 6-12 knots Seas: Moss Landing 4-7 feet 64/56 Swell: Castroville WNW 4-7 feet 66/55 Marina J +28.99 Monday Today’s forecast for Monterey Bay. +1.3% Pct. change from previous: WATER STORAGE BOATING M Sunny and breezy 71 54 Santa Cruz 73/53 Pct. change from previous: 1,998.72 Sunday San Jose 79/57 A Nasdaq composite Saturday Half Moon Bay 68/54 8,000 9,361.61 Winds: W 10-20 mph 72 53 8,500 August 12, 2009 Sunny and breezy For complete calendar listings, visit TheCalifornian.com. 9,000 +120.16 Friday San Francisco 69/56 Dow Jones industrials Salinas Allergy Clinic: www.CentralCoastAllergy.com SUNRISE: 6:22 A.M. TODAY’S HIGHS/TONIGHT’S LOWS 9,500 August 12, 2009 First Aug 13 Aug 20 Aug 27 Ice Full Sep 4 Forecasts and graphics provided by AccuWeather, Inc. 2009 Today’s question Do the loud and disruptive tactics used by foes of Obama’s health-care plan at town hall meetings help or hurt their cause? i Help i Hurt i No effect Continued from page 1A Wednesday’s question Family Enterprises shared an address at 375 Market St., Salinas. The auction was another blow to the Mills family, which built its fortunes in Salinas Valley agriculture before entering the real estate business. Operations at Mills Family Farms were suspended in July 2008. In November and December, four Mills properties in Salinas and King City were foreclosed upon after financial struggles at two developments. Later, the luxury Monterra development in Monterey entered the foreclosure Is your family (or those close to you) ready for the new school year? Results of 85 tallied votes: i Yes, we’re ready to go — 28.7 percent i We’re getting there — 20.7 percent i No, we’re behind — 14.9 percent i School?! — 35.6 percent BIRTHDAYS Aug. 13 Rufino Rodriguez of Soledad, 30. Vivian C. Rivera of Soledad, 47. i To submit a name to Birthdays, call 831-754-4260 or e-mail [email protected] in care of Birthdays. Deadline for submissions is noon the day before publication date. Provide first and last name, birthday, age and city of residence. Escape to Hawaii... Mega Millions (Tues.) 6, 12, 15, 32, 42 Mega ball: 40 Jackpot: $124 million (no winner) Fri’s Jackpot: $146 million Fantasy 5 5, 14, 23, 24, 36 Daily 4 2, 1, 2, 5 Daily 3 Day: 4, 6, 0 Night: 4, 5, 6 Daily Derby 1st: 09, Winning Spirit 2nd: 08, Gorgeous George 3rd: 05, California Classic Race Time: 1:40.79 Lottery information: www.calottery.com i Send Calendar items at least two weeks in advance using our online submission form at TheCalifornian.com; by e-mail to [email protected]; by fax to 831-754-4293; by mail to The Salinas Californian, P.O. Box 81091, Salinas CA 93912; or in person to 123 W. Alisal St., Salinas. Questions: 831-754-4260. process, and construction was halted at Mills Ranch in King City. M o n t e r ra b o r rowed heavily from the Trust Deeds Program, part of the city of Salinas’ Employee Deferred Compensation Fund. City workers invest in the fund. In October, the Deferred Compensation Fund issued notices of default on 13 properties owned by the Mills family. A property sales report for the week of June 22-26 listed the sale of a home at 24328 Monterra Woods Road by Tom Kever, the property’s administrator and finance director for the city of Salinas. The sale amount was $1 million. Just 15 minutes from Salinas! Chef’s Creations featuring LOTTERY RESULTS SuperLotto Plus (Wed.) 5-8-29-36-47 Meganumber: 23 Jackpot: $9 million Cesar Chavez Library, 615 Williams Road, Salinas. Twenty years have passed since Don Diego de la Vega fought oppression as the legendary hero Zorro, and now he must find a successor to stop tyrant Raphael Montero, who has a plot to buy Alta California and enslave the population to work in his mines. Based on a story by Johnston McCulley. Rated PG-13. Cesar Chavez Library. MONTEREY BAY SENIOR FRIENDS, 11:45 a.m., Gino’s Fine Italian Foods & Pizza, 54 Highway 68, Salinas. Lunch. New senior friends welcome to attend. Call for reservations. 831-644-9860. BREAST-FEEDING SUPPORT GROUP, 2 to 3:30 p.m., Expressed Luv, 3160 Ocean Terrace, Marina. Focus is on the challenges and joys of breast-feeding your toddler. Babies of all ages are welcome. Playroom available for older children. International Board Certified Lactation Consultant available to answer questions. Free. 831-3847127. FILM NIGHT AT UUCMP, 6 to 8 p.m., Unitarian Universalist Church of the Monterey Peninsula, 490 Aguajito Road, Carmel. “Waging in Living,” chronicles the day-to-day battles of four low-wage earners fighting to lift their families out of poverty, and “Homeless Karaoke” takes you into a musical haven for refugees from the street. Refreshments served. 831-624-7404. TALK AND BOOK SIGNING, 7:30 p.m., Luminata Books and Gifts, 631 Cass St., Monterey. G.M. Weger, author of “East Garrison.” 831-333-1110. Blue Point Oysters on the half shell VOTED BEST NEW STEAKHOUSE Bring in the ad for a HAPPY HOUR BAR ONLY • Mon-Fri 4:00-6:30pm DRINKS $3.00 Well Drinks • $3.00 Margaritas $4.00 Mai Tais • $3.00 All Draft Beers FREE ORDER of HAWAIIAN NACHOS PLEASE CALL FOR DETAILS 831.883.9479 3295 Dunes Rd. • Marina Formerly AJ Spurs www.kula-ranch.com 9000106187 69 57 Low clouds followed by sunshine today, except mostly sunny in the south. Clear to partly cloudy tonight. Sunshine tomorrow and Saturday. CALENDAR A DAY ON WALL STREET ALLERGY ALLERGEYREPORT REPORT VALLEY FORECAST 11A City of Salinas PUBLIC HEARING CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL PERFORMANCE AND EVALUATION REPORT (CAPER) FOR Fiscal Year 2008-09 The City of Salinas has prepared a Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) for submittal to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. The CAPER discusses the City’s use of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), Home Investment Partnerships Program (HOME), and Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) funds for the period of July 1, 2008 through June 30, 2009. The CAPER assesses the City’s activities in relation to the 2006-2010 Consolidated Plan and the FY 2008-09 Action Plan. The purpose of the CAPER is to show how the City has carried out its HUD-funded activities in accordance with the applicable regulations and the priorities identified in the Consolidated Plan. Copies of the CAPER may be reviewed at Community Development Department, Housing Division, City Hall, 200 Lincoln Ave, Salinas, prior to the public hearing before the City Council at 4:00 p.m. on Sept. 22, 2009 in the Council Chambers at 200 Lincoln Avenue. Copies are also available for review at the John Steinbeck Library, El Gabilan Library, and Cesar Chavez Library. Citizen comments are welcomed and may be directed to: David Swanson, City of Salinas, Community Development Department, Housing Division, 200 Lincoln Ave., Salinas, CA 93901 or call 758-7334 or e-mail to: [email protected]. Disabled persons requiring accommodation in order to participate in the hearing may contact the Salinas City Clerk: 200 Lincoln Ave., Salinas, CA 93901; 831-758-7381. TDD Users may contact the City via the California Relay Service at 800-735-2929. 9000106402 Today Thursday, August 13, 2009 MÉXICO Y EL MUNDO PÁGINA 6 | SÁBADO 15 DE AGOSTO DEL 2009 Pide Obama que Antes de fin de año Obama ofrecerá no tergiversen un borrador de reforma migratoria su plan de salud POR ISTRA PACHECO | AP PORTSMOUTH — En un intento de impulsar su plan de reforma al sistema de salud, el presidente Barack Obamaapuntódirectamente al sector de los seguros y dijo que los burócratas no deberían "entrometerse" en la atención médica que reciben las personas. A los asistentes a una asamblea popular con el presidente, Obama les pidió que no escuchen a aquellos que buscan "espantar y engañar al pueblo estadounidense". "Para todos aquellos que usan tácticas de miedo allá afuera, lo que resulta realmente aterrador es que no hagamos nada", dijo Obama en medio de aplausos de un público de 1.800 simpatizantes en una escuela secundaria y ante una audiencia nacional en televisión por cable. La Casa Blanca se había preparado para una recepción hostil de opositores a la reforma a los programas de salud.Sin embargo,no hubo una sola señal de ello,quizás por la forma en que estuvo conjuntado el público o por la tradicional gentileza del pueblo con su presidente. La iniciativa de Obama ocurre en medio de una gira que contempla una serie de reuniones populares en todo el país que han ensombrecido su mensaje y han amenazado con descarrilar sus esfuerzos en el Congreso. De hecho, el demócrata Arlen Specter, quien antes era republicano, enfrentó preguntas hostiles, insultos y abucheos el martes cuando intentó explicar los esfuerzos en una reunión de preguntas y respuestas en Lebanon, Pensilvania. Sin embargo, eso no desanimó a Obama. "Ustedes contarán con su seguro cuando lo necesiten, no sólo cuando paguen las primas", indicó el mandatario en su reunión. En momentos que bajan sus encuestas y crece el escepticismo del público, Obama adecuó su mensaje a las decenas de millones de personas que tienen seguro de salud. Hasta ahora se dirigía a los 46 millones que no están asegurados. "No creo que los burócratas del gobierno deban entrometerse. Pero tampoco creo que los burócratas de las aseguradoras deban entrometerse", dijo Obama. El presidente dijo que aspira a un debate racional y apuntó a los detractores que, según él, tratan de meter miedo a la gente. Exhortó a una discusión vigorosa sobre la atención médica, pero "entre personas que se escuchan, no entre sordos". "Cuando discrepemos, discrepemos sobre realidades, no sobre tergiversaciones que no tienen nada que ver con lo que se propone", dijo Obama, quien acusó a los creadores de crear "fantasmas". Muchos legisladores se encuentran a la defensiva cuando intentan hablar del tema con votantes furiosos, y por eso realizan teleconferencias en lugar de foros públicos donde se presentan manifestantes. Eso sucede en un momento crucial cuando los legisladores, principalmente los demócratas, visitan sus estados durante el receso de agosto y convocan a reuniones para promover el esfuerzo del presidente por reformar el costoso sistema de salud. "Difundamos las realidades. Hagamos (la reforma)", imploró Obama. Norte, que entró en vigencia en 1994. Pero la frontera trae consigo otro tema: el narcotráfico y Obama una vez más respaldó los esfuerzos de Calderón por combatirlo, en momentos en que el Congreso estadounidense discute la posibilidad de retener parte de una asignación millonaria de fondos de la llamada Iniciativa Mérida, por entender que en su lucha contra el crimen organizado, México no se está garantizando los derechos humanos. Obama dijo tener una gran confianza en que bajo la administración de Calderón "los derechos humanos serán atendidos". Calderón señaló que su gobierno tiene un compromiso "absoluto y categórico" con la preservación de esos derechos. El trío apoyó revisar las finanzas del Banco Internacional de Desarrollo, "para asegurar que cuenta con suficiente capacidad de préstamos a corto plazo" en especial para ayudar a países más empobrecidos. Sobre la crisis política en Honduras, Obama catalogó como "hipócrita" pedir la intervención directa de Estados Unidos para resolver el conflicto, aunque además reiteró su condena al golpe de estado en la nación centroamericana, ocurrido el 28 de junio. "Los mismos críticos que dicen que los Estados Unidos no han intervenido lo suficiente en Honduras son las mismas personas que dicen que siempre estamos interviniendo y que los yanquis necesitan salirse de Latinoamérica", declaró el mandatario en rueda de prensa. La semana pasada, durante una visita a México, el depuesto presidente hondureño Manuel Zelaya dijo que Estados Unidos podía acabar con el gobierno de facto "en cinco minutos", por la gran dependencia económica que tiene Honduras de ese país y que las acciones de Estados Unidos en contra del golpe eran "tibias". Los mandatarios también discutieron medidas no especificadas para mitigar la deforestación y reconocieron la importancia del Grupo de Alto Nivel sobre Seguridad y de sus grupos de trabajo, que encabezan tanto la cancillería mexicana como el Departamento de Estado norteamericano. Acordaron que esta instancia sesionará en el curso del año. Alcalde informa sobre grave escasez de agua THE ASSOCIATED PRESS MÉXICO — La capital mexicana tiene un déficit de 71 millones de metros cúbicos de agua en la principal represa de abastecimiento, por lo que el alcalde anunció racionamientos en el servicio a partir del martes y un posible incremento en las tarifas. Los acuíferos del subsuelo también están a la baja por falta de lluvias para su recarga y se considera que es la peor crisis de suministro de agua en la capital en 40 años, dijo el jefe del gobierno capi- talino Marcelo Ebrard. "Me importa mucho que esto lo tengamos todos claro. Mi obligación como jefe de gobierno es informar qué ocurre y tomar las medidas a tiempo, no el año que entra porque para entonces ya no podremos hacer nada", declaró en un acto público en el que anunció la implementación del Sistema de Alerta del Servicio de Agua Potable. "Simple y llanamente no se podrá reponer el agua que no ahorremos porque en los primeros meses de DONATE THAT CAR! Tax Deduction • Free Pickup • No DMV Filing • No Smog Cert • Running or Not* *Restrictions Apply The California Council of the Blind has helped the blind become productive in the workplace since 1934. Cars, Trucks, Vans, Boats, RV’s, Trailers and more JUNTA PUBLICA REPORTE CONSOLIDADO DE CUMPLIMIENTO Y EVALUACION ANUAL (CAPER) PARA el Año Fiscal 2008-09 La Ciudad de Salinas ha preparado un Reporte Consolidado de Cumplimiento y Evaluación Anual (CAPER, por sus siglas en inglés) para presentar al U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. El CAPER discute el uso de la Ciudad de los fondos del Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), el Programa de Home Investment Partnerships (HOME), y Emergency Shelter Grant (ESG) para el periodo del 1 de Julio del 2008 al 30 de junio del 2009. El CAPER evalúa las actividades de la Ciudad en relación al Plan Consolidado 2006-2010 y el Plan de Acción para el Año Fiscal 200809. El propósito del CAPER es demostrar cómo la Ciudad ha realizado las actividades fundadas por HUD de acuerdo con las regulaciones y las prioridades identificadas en el Plan Consolidado. ¡IMAGÍNESE USANDO ESTA MÁSCARA, RECOSTADO QUIETO Y RECIBIENDO RADIACIONES HASTA POR SESIONES DE 45 MINUTOS! 9000106404 Las personas discapacitadas que requieran de adecuaciones para poder participar en la junta pueden comunicarse con la Secretaría del Ayuntamiento (City Clerk): 200 Lincoln Ave., Salinas, CA 93901; 831-758-7381. Los Usuarios de TDD pueden comunicarse con la Ciudad a través del California Relay Service al 800-735-2929. 800-449-8342 ¿Tiene usted un tumor en la cabeza o el cuello que requiere de tratamiento por medio de radiacion? Ciudad de Salinas Copias del CAPER pueden ser revisadas en el Departamento de Desarrollo Comunitario, en la División de Vivienda, ubicado en City Hall, 200 Lincoln Ave, Salinas, antes de la junta pública ante el Ayuntamiento de la Ciudad a las 4:00 p.m. el 22 de Septiembre del 2009 en la Cámara del Ayuntamiento en 200 Lincoln Avenue. Existen copias disponibles también en la Biblioteca John Steinbeck, la Biblioteca El Gabilan, y la Biblioteca César Chávez. Los comentarios de la ciudadanía son bienvenidos y pueden ser dirigidos a: David Swanson, City of Salinas, Community Development Department, Housing Division, 200 Lincoln Ave., Salinas, CA 93901 o puede llamar al 758-7334 o al correo electrónico: [email protected]. 2010 no lloverá", aseguró. ¡EN ADVANCED RADIATION ONCOLOGY CENTER, ESTO SE PUEDE LLEVAR A CABO EN TAN SÓLO 80 SEGUNDOS! ¡Advanced Radiation Oncology Center cuenta con Varian’s RapidArc®, el acelerador lineal tecnológicamente MÁS avanzado entre Palo Alto y Los Ángeles! ¡RapidArc ofrece un rayo dirigido al tumor con velocidad y presición nunca antes visto, en menos de 2 minutos! ¡80 segundos contra 45 minutos! Advanced Radiation Oncology Center es el único lugar en la costa central que cuenta con “On-Board Imaging” lo cual es un escáner CT dentro de la máquina de tratamiento que visualiza el tumor en tiempo real. RapidArc hace posible que los doctores acaben con el tumor de una manera más precisa, lo cual permite salvar más tejido sano. ¡De hecho, es la máquina más precisa hasta el momento! ¡Aquí en Salinas! Advanced Radiation Oncology Center se especializa en IMRT/ IGRT y también trata cánceres incluyendo próstata, pecho, colón, pulmones, cerebro y la piel. 395 East St, Soledad, California 831 - 678 - 9100 Nuestro personal altamente calificado presta un servicio lleno de compasión y de atención experta, bajo la dirección de David Gallardo, M.D., radiólogo oncólogo, certificado por el consejo médico. Direct Cremation $ 895 Traditional Burial $ 1805 Consulte con su doctor sobre este método de terapia innovadora para combatir el cáncer. Affordable Caskets Es rápido. Es preciso. Es simple. Family Owned, Available 24 Hours ADVANCED RADIATION ONCOLOGY CENTER 1115 #B Los Palos Drive in Salinas “State of the art with a heart” 9000103010 FD 2001 ! FDR 2870 ! EMB 9103 ! INS 0G40210 9000097780 POR PHILIP ELLIOTT | AP GUADALAJARA — El anuncio del presidente Barack Obama de presentar antes de terminar el año un borrador de reforma migratoria en Estados Unidos fue el compromiso que deslumbró en la cumbre en la que junto a sus colegas de Canadá y México acordaron trabajar en temas como el cambio climático, la gripe porcina, la recuperación económica y el comercio. La Cumbre de Líderes de América del Norte celebrada en Guadalajara, a unos 450 kilómetros (280 millas) al noroeste de la capital mexicana, produjo pocos acuerdos concretos entre Obama, su contaparte mexicano Felipe Calderón y el primer ministro de Candá Stephen Harper. Quedaron irresueltos temas sensibles, como el nuevo requisito de visas para los mexicanos que viajen a Canadá y la disputa entre camioneros mexicanos que buscan el conflicto del autotransporte en la frontera común. Ambos problemas "continuarán" discutiéndose, dijeron los gobernantes. Sobre la reforma migratoria, uno de los asuntos en los que más tiempo se invirtió durante las conversaciones, Obama señaló que presentará una iniciativa de ley sin tomar en cuenta las consecuencias políticas adversas que algunos críticos auguran para un proyecto de ese tipo. El presidente estadounidense aseguró que reformar el sistema de salud es su prioridad actual y por ello atender la migración ilegal ha debido esperar. "La reforma migratoria va a requerir de la cooperación bipartidista. Habrá demagogos allá afuera que van a tratar de sugerir que cualquier tipo de legalización de aquellos que ya viven en los Estados Unidos es inaceptable", declaró. Los tres líderes dijeron que continuarán invirtiendo en infraestructura en sus respectivas fronteras para facilitar el comercio y el suministro de productos a la vez que se buscará garantizar la seguridad.También le darán seguimiento a la eliminación de procesos burocráticos que podrían atrasar el intercambio comercial entre cada uno. Las tres naciones son socias bajo elTratado de Libre Comercio para América del (831) 757-3006 “Lo más avanzado en tecnología con corazón” Protect steelhead trout, judge rules At issue: Wild fish versus hatchery raised By SAMANTHA YOUNG The Associated Press SACRAMENTO — A federal judge on Monday upheld protections for wild steelhead trout in California rivers, rejecting an argument by forestry groups that argued the success of hatchery-raised steelhead has made the population sufficiently robust. U.S. District Court Judge Oliver Wanger in Fresno disagreed. He said hatchery-raised fish are no substitute for wild steelhead. While science shows that hatchery-fish can be beneficial, they also can be detrimental to wild steelhead, Wanger wrote in his 168page ruling. Steelhead are listed as either threatened or endangered in different parts of California. In a related claim, the judge also rejected a bid by Central Valley farmers to remove steelhead trout from the federal Endangered Species Act. The farmers pointed to an abundance of resident rainbow trout, steelhead that do not migrate to the ocean. The Modesto Irrigation District had argued that rainbow trout are essentially the same species as wild steelhead. Wanger agreed with federal wildlife scientists, who have said wild steelhead are distinct and indispensable to the survival of the species. The rulings signify another victory for federal wildlife agencies and the fishing and conservation groups that had intervened in the cases. It is the third instance in two years in which a federal court has rejected arguments that hatchery fish ought to be counted as part of salmon or steelhead populations, said Steve Mashuda, an attorney at Earthjustice, a nonprofit group that represented the conservation and fishing groups. Studies have shown that while wild and hatchery fish in a river may be genetically the same, they have behavioral differences that make wild fish more successful at surviving. Hatcheries can boost overall numbers of fish in a stream, but the fish they release also have poor reproduction rates and can compete with wild fish for food and mates. In some cases, they can hurt the sustainability of wild fish stocks, scientists have found. Environmentalist have argued that the goal of the Endangered Species Act is to restore steelhead and other struggling species to self-sustaining levels, without intervention from humans. “One day, the act contemplates we would no longer need hatchery fish,” Mashuda said. But the law also complicates efforts by agriculture groups that seek greater access to water and to timber companies that want to log in sensitive habitat. The groups pressing the cases say federal wildlife managers should assess an entire fish’s population — both wild and hatcheryraised — when deciding whether to protect it. “Once you have identified a given population for listing, the ultimate determination of whether you list that population has to be based on the entire population,” said Damien Schiff, an attorney at the Pacific Legal Foundation, which represents agriculture and forestry groups. Schiff said it was too early to know whether the group would appeal the judge’s ruling. A representative with the Modesto Irrigation District could not reached for comment. Tuesday, October 28, 2008 5A CALIFORNIA Motorcycle gang infiltrated Agents had to pass a lie detector test to join detectors as part of its screening of potential new hires. ATF spokesman Mike Hoffman said the polygraph is just one of a slew of tests of a candidate’s background. By THOMAS WATKINS 90 percent accuracy The Associated Press WEST COVINA — Weeks of drinking and carousing to win acceptance in a notorious motorcycle gang came down to a nerve-racking moment for three undercover federal agents: taking a polygraph examination in a room full of armed men. Flunking could threaten what would become a three-year probe into the Mongols Motorcycle Club — not to mention the agents’ own safety. Federal prosecutors say all three Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives agents were prepared for the challenge and passed the tests, critical moments in the investigation that culminated last week in multistate raids and at least 64 arrests on charges including murder, drug trafficking and torture. The Mongols had been infiltrated before, so gang leaders went to extraordinary lengths to test their “prospects,” including running background checks and having a private investigator administer the polygraph tests. The Mongols ratcheted up pressure by standing directly behind the agents while they were hooked up to the polygraph, Assistant U.S. Attorney Christopher Brunwin said. “Is it scarier to see the threat that is facing you, or ... taking a lie detector test while someone is standing behind you with a weapon?” the prosecutor said. “They could be getting ready to shoot.” Polygraph training Each agent had been given all they needed to assume a new life — an apartment away from their family, a new Social Security number and a cover story. They had also been trained to pass the lie detector. “It’s a remarkable undertaking that the agents whose lives were at risk displayed this level of courage,” Brunwin said. In all, four ATF agents were accepted into the Mongols “brotherhood,” though one agent was not required to take a polygraph test. Officials did not say why. John Torres, the ATF agent in charge in Los Angeles, declined to discuss how the three beat the polygraph, but said undercover agents generally compile cover stories that echo their own lives so they can tell them more believably. “Our guys are highly trained and they were pretty much hand selected to do this mission and for their ability to think fast under pressure and beat the box,” Torres said, referring to the polygraph machine. Though the ATF is able to train its agents to pass a polygraph test, the agency still uses lie A straightforward polygraph test is accurate about 90 percent of the time, said Edward Gelb, a Los Angeles-based polygraph examiner and past president of the American Polygraph Association. To beat the odds, people can learn how to control their pulse, breathing rates and other responses, though doing so conTHE ASSOCIATED PRESS vincingly can be tricky. “They would have to The media photographs confiscated motorcycles Oct. 21 belonging to Mongols motorcylearn to control their cle gang at a news conference in Los Angeles. responses without appearing to be controlling them,” Gelb said. California polygraph examiners do not require any state certification, so Gelb wondered how much experience the Mongols’ tester had. The Mongols’ background checks and liedetector tests were not only to prevent a repeat of the 1998 infiltration that led to at least 29 arrests, but to assess aspiring members’ willingness to commit crimes for the gang, prosecutors said. Mongols circulated photographs of undercover agents among the criminal underworld to see if anyone recognized them, Brunwin said. On one occasion, a Mongol grew suspicious after coming across an old photograph of one agent posing with ATF colleagues. “They were telling him, ‘This sure looks like you,’” Brunwin said. “It seemed like he’d been caught.” The agent convinced them it wasn’t him. Thrill of façade Torres said not all agents can handle undercover work. Those that do it feed off the thrill of maintaining a facade. “It is the adrenaline, it’s being able to get one over on the bad guy,” Torres said. Torres said the agents in the Mongols investigation never committed a crime during the investigation, he said, and were still subject to random drug tests. Four women colleagues posed as girlfriends to help in the ruse, providing backup and an excuse that allowed the male agents to avoid having sex with women who hung out with Mongols, Brunwin said. According to the indictment, the Mongols awarded each other special clothing patches, or “wings,” after they engaged in extreme sex acts, like having sex with a woman with a venereal disease. 84-count indictment The 84-count racketeering indictment against the primarily Latino gang lists allegations including murder, attempted murder, racially motivated attacks on black people, torture, and gun and drug offenses. At least THE ASSOCIATED PRESS A wanted poster is shown during an Oct. 21 news conference on the Mongols motorcycle gang in this Oct. 21 photo in Los Angeles. 44 defendants have appeared in court, all of them pleading not guilty. It wasn’t immediately known if they had been assigned defense attorneys. Last week, the government barred Mongols members from wearing clothing displaying the group’s trademarked name or logo in what was called a first-of-its-kind seizure of a gang’s intellectual property. Among those arrested were the gang’s former national president Ruben “Doc” Cavazos and current president Hector “Largo” Gonzalez. The gang is based in Southern California, but federal and local agents arrested members is six states from the West Coast to the Midwest. FREE TEETH WHITENING Valid only for new patients with insurance. Please call for details. Offer expires 10/31/08 New Patients Welcome Most Insurance Accepted CREEK BRIDGE DENTAL 831-449-3264 1558 Constitution Blvd. Salinas, CA 93905 In the CreekBridge Village Shopping Center Maximize your dental insurance benefit! Minimize your out of pocket payments. CITY OF SALINAS PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE Salinas City Council will hold a hearing to obtain comment regarding the proposed F i r s t A m e n d m e n t to 2 0 0 8 - 0 9 A C T I O N P L A N , which is the document governing the use of federal funds provided to address affordable housing and community development needs. The City is proposing to provide $ 4 2 5 , 0 0 0 to CHISPA, Inc., to assist with the acquisition and development of a senior housing project planned for the Hebbron Heights neighborhood. The source of funds is the federal “HOME” grant. City Council may also consider rescinding a previous allocation of $425,000 made to Interim, Inc., for a rental housing project being planned for Sun Street. The hearing will be held on D e c e m b e r 2 , 2 0 0 8 at approximately 4:15 p.m. in the City Council Chamber Rotunda, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas. For further information, contact Grace De Jesus, City of Salinas, Housing and Community Development, City Hall, 200 Lincoln Avenue. Tel: 758-7334 or E-mail: [email protected]. Disabled persons requiring accommodation in order to participate in the public hearing may contact the City Clerk: City of S a l i n a s , 2 0 0 L i n c o l n Av e n u e , S a l i n a s , C A 9 3 9 0 1 ; ( 8 3 1 ) 7 5 8 - 7 3 8 1 . T D D u s e r s m a y c o n t a c t t h e C i t y v i a t h e C a l i f o r n i a R e l a y Service at 1-800-735-2929. NEWS Saturday, February 28, 2009 Obama sets firm Iraq timetable BUSINESS BRIEFS staff reports Fairgrounds to feature Livestock Show ly 30 years. Hayashi & Wayland Accounting & Consulting LLP has announced the promotion of Mike Nolan, CPA, to partner effective Jan. 1. Also joining the Salinas office as a senior tax manager is Aviv Kadosh, CPA. Formerly with BBR in Carmel, Aviv has experience working on a variety of returns, including trusts and estates. Big Sur Land Trust unveils new Web site Chesshire named CEO of trades council The Big Sur Land Trust has launched a new Web site reflecting its reformulated vision outlining a broadened set of initiatives and increased community engagement. The new site captures the natural beauty of Monterey County and the five pillars of focus supporting the organization’s long-term vision: Healthy communities, ecological health, stewardship of resources, youth and education and durable local economy. Online: www.bigsur landtrust.org. Salinas dry cleaner has new owner Perry’s Dry Cleaners at 1223 S. Main St., Salinas, is now owned by Javier Aldape. Aldape is also now offering free pickup and delivery service. Information: 831-7580115, www.perrysdry cleaners.com Salinas Realtor named to Top 5 network Rafael Ramos of Century 21 Action Realty in Salinas was accepted as a charter member of the Top 5 in Real Estate Network(R), an industry achievement.To qualify, each member must first meet a stringent set of criteria, based upon performance, as well as educational and professional skills and service to the consumer. The Network is managed by RISMedia, which has provided the real estate industry with news for near- ‘Combat mission to end by Aug. 31, 2010,‘ President vows Firm announces partner, addition The Monterey Bay Classic Livestock Show will be held May 1-2 at the Monterey County Fairgrounds. Entry forms are due April 1; late entry is May 1. Weigh-in and vet check for sheep and goats is May 1. Heifer registration and transportation forms are due May 1. Livestock exhibitor experience is May 1; the shows are on May 2. Information: www. montereycountyfair.com. The Associated Press CAMP LEJEUNE, N.C. — President Barack Obama consigned the Iraq war to history Friday, declaring he will end combat operations within 18 months and open a new era of diplomacy in the Middle East. “Let me say this as plainly as I can: By August 31, 2010, our combat mission in Iraq will end,” Obama told Marines who are about to deploy by the thousands to the other war front, Afghanistan. Even so, Obama will leave the bulk of troops in place this year, contrary to hopes of Democratic leaders for a speedier pullout. And after combat forces withdraw, 35,000 to 50,000 will stay behind for an additional year and half of support and counterterrorism duties. Just six weeks into office, Obama used blunt terms and a cast-in-stone promise to write the last chapter of a war that began six years ago. It has cost more in lives, money and national stamina than ever envisioned. Like Dwight Eisenhower and Richard Nixon before him, Obama came into office with an inherited war he pledged to end without delay. Eisenhower did, in Korea. Nixon didn’t, inVietnam. Obama says he will. “Iraq’s future is now its own responsibility,” Obama said. Defense Secretary Robert Gates and Adm. Mike Mullen, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, flanked Obama during the announcement. It was a symbolic statement that top military advisers are on board with a strategy some had openly questioned before Obama’s inauguration. More than five years have passed since Bush declared Ron Chesshire has been hired as the chief executive officer of the Monterey/ Santa Cruz Building and Construction Trades Council. He retired from the Carpenters Union in April 2008. The council is an organization of affiliated construction and trades unions established for mutual cooperation, promotion of training within the industry and advocacy of improved wages, benefits and working conditions for all. Clark Savage awarded the CFF Credential Clark L. Savage, a CPA financial forensics expert with Finn & Cohen, CPAs in Monterey, has been awarded the Certified Public Accountants Credential by the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants. Savage met the requirements to earn the credential, which include demonstrating significant business experience in the area of forensic accounting as well as completing educational requirements. Air pollution control officer named The Monterey Bay Unified Air Pollution Control District Board has named Richard Stedman as the district’s air pollution control officer. Stedman comes to the district from the Olympic Region Clean Air Agency in Washington, where he was appointed executive director in January 2001. THE ASSOCIATED PRESS President Obama greets Marines after his speech Friday at Camp Lejeune, N.C. the end of major combat operations in Iraq, a statement that proved false as sectarian violence brought Iraq to the brink of disaster. Best effort Obama did not claim a mission accomplished. Instead, he suggested America accomplished the mission as best it could. “What we will not do is let the pursuit of the perfect stand in the way of achievable goals,”he said.“We cannot rid Iraq of all who oppose America or sympathize with our adversaries. We cannot police Iraq’s streets until they are completely safe, nor stay until Iraq’s union is perfected.” He said: “America’s men and women in uniform have fought block by block, province by province, year after year, to give the Iraqis this chance to choose a better future. Now, we must ask the Iraqi people to seize it.” Obama’s promise to pull home the last of the U.S. troops by the end of 2011 is in accord with a deal that Iraqis signed with former President George W. Bush. Meantime, Obama is accelerating the end of the war by withdrawing roughly 100,000 troops by the summer of 2010. Obama was moving to fulfill in large measure the defining promise of his campaign — to end combat operations within 16 months of taking office. He’s doing it in 19 months instead, and the drawdown will be backloaded to provide security for Iraqi elections late this year. Deaths More than 4,250 Americans have been killed in Iraq, a costly, unpopular enterprise at home that Obama criticized when support for the invasion was strong and few other politicians dared stand against it. He applauded the armed forces for its successes in Iraq, where U.S. deaths and violence in many parts of the country are significantly down. He never credited Bush’s buildup of troops in 2007 as contributing to those improvements. In another break from Bush, Obama promised “comprehensive American engagement” with nations across the Middle East, noting Iran and Syria in particular. The United States has long had a diplomatic frost with both countries over their support for militant groups, among other matters. But they hold great sway in the region, and Obama sees a diplomatic opportunity. Obama called Bush shortly before he gave his speech to brief him on his plans. White House press secretary Robert Gibbs called the chat brief and straightforward. In his speech, Obama said to the military members:“We will leave the Iraqi people with a hard-earned opportunity to live a better life. That is your achievement. That is the prospect that you have made possible.” As Obama spoke, the camouflage-clad Marines seemed to be taking a measure of the man.They politely applauded their new commander in chief at times, and grew more boisterous when he promised to raise their pay and provide more help for their families. SHO WAFFLE Country Cooking P Serving Breakfast & Lunch The Best Waffle Ever HOMEMADE BISCUITS & GRAVY • HEARTY OMELETES • BREAKFAST SKILLETS HOMEMADE SOUP & SALAD • BANQUET FACILITIES AVAILABLE BUY ONE & GET ONE FREE ENJOY 1 FREE ENTRÉE WHEN YOU PURCHASE ANY ENTRÉE & 2 BEVERAGES FROM OUR REGULAR MENU OF EQUAL OR LESSER VALUE. 1 COUPON PER TABLE. PLEASE PRESENT COUPON WHEN ORDERING. NOT VALID WITH ANY OTHER DISCOUNT OR HOLIDAYS. OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK 6AM-3PM • 442-8880 Your One-Stop Shopping Destination! 1465 N. MAIN ST. (EN LA ESQUINA DE N. MAIN Y ALVIN DR., EN ALVIN SQUARE) 9000097936 6A BANKRUPTCY Bedding & Bath • gifts Complete KitChen Dental Care Patio furniture • garden 9000097350 hardware & Paint ATTORNEY AT LAW SINCE 1983 for the FREE CONSULTATION Entire Family PERSONAL SERVICE GET A FRESH START Valerie M. Aoki, DDS 831-333-0313 WWW.MICHAELSCHAD.COM General Dentistry New Patients Welcome City of Salinas 780 E. Romie Lane Suite A, Salinas PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE 9000097181 754-1667 The Salinas City Council will hold a public hearing to obtain comment on the proposed 2nd Amendment to 2008-09 ACTION PLAN that governs the use of federal funds used by the City for housing & community development activities. The City plans to increase by $24,000 the amount of CDBG funds allocated to design/bid prep work for Phase 11 of the East Salinas Street Light Project (CIP 9047). Funds would come from contingency accounts. 9000098456 NO Disabled persons requiring accommodation in order to participate in the hearing may contact the Salinas City Clerk: 200 Lincoln Ave, Salinas, CA 93901; (831) 758-7381. TDD users may contact the City via the California Relay Service at 800-735-2929. 9000098650 The hearing will be held on March 31, 2009 at approximately 4:30 p.m. in the City Hall Rotunda, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas. For further information, contact Grace De Jesus, City of Salinas, Housing & Community Development, 200 Lincoln Avenue. Tel: 758-7334 or E-mail: [email protected]. Look inside for this week’s week s ssmart mart ways ways to to save. 9000097796 Highway 1 South to the Mouth of Carmel Valley Rd. 546 Carmel Rancho Shopping Center • Carmel • 624-8541 • www.brintons.com MICHAEL SCHAD 9000096978 home furnishings • hearth 4A NEWS Tuesday, April 14, 2009 FUGITIVE Continued from page 1A possession of a dangerous weapon. Before he was sentenced, Campos submitted a letter to the court that referred to his juvenile conviction and being placed on probation as an adult with gang conditions. Police said Campos is a Norteño street gang member. “I am a very young man with good intentions, but I know I am not going to make the right decisions all the time,”Campos said in the letter. “(To err is human.)” In 2006, court records show, Campos admitted to inflicting corporal injury on a spouse or cohabitant with a prior enhancement and pleaded no contest to felony inflict- ing of corporal injury to a spouse or cohabitant and possession of a controlled substance. Before his sentencing, his wife wrote a letter to the judge asking for leniency, adding that Campos was an “exceptional father” to his two young sons. For that conviction, he was delivered in July 2006 to the North Kern State Prison in Delano to serve two years. “It is unfair to punish him for being a good person. ...Their whole world revolved around him,” she had written.“They already had to go through a whole year without him. ... We are a very happy family and without Raymond, we will fall apart.” The terms of his probation included unannounced searches of himself and his home, and staying away from gangs, court records REPORT “The Rocky Mountain Institute will bring a lot of Continued from page 1A prestige to the issues,” Lee Lienk said. “But I really feel long supported. In 2007, the that a lot of the ideas are Watershed Institute at Cali- already in place.” fornia State University, Monterey Bay, received a grant of Report’s suggestions $150,000 from the Packard Foundation to help turn the The report suggested that 480-acre dry lakebed in the the creation of a long-term middle of Salinas into a plan for the area would help recreational area. efforts to buy the land. A 2003 plan lays out largely Lee Lienk and other offithe same goals for the area cials meet every two weeks that the new report does, said to discuss the project, she Laura Lee Lienk, co-director said. of the Watershed Institute. Other Rocky Mountain MORGAN HILL Laporte Chapel, Luis St, Salinas Calif. 93901. Services: 1 p.m., Thursday, April 16, at Queen of Heaven Chapel, 18200 Damian Way, Salinas, Calif. 93907. Arrangements: Struve and Laporte Chapel. Online condolences: www.struveandlaporte.com show. Then, on Friday night about 8 p.m., Bardoni said, Deputy Jesse Pinon and his partner, a Salinas police officer also attached to the gang task force, attempted to stop Campos in the parking lot after seeing actions they said were “consistent with that of narcotic activity.” “They [also] knew he was on parole and that’s why he was contacted,”Bardoni said. According to Bardoni: Campos backed his car up with the door still open, trapping Pinon while he continued to drive in reverse. Pinon was dragged along with the moving car, which then ran over his shoulder area. Pinon was flown to a hospital in the Bay Area and is recovering at home from his injuries — a broken Institute recommendations focused on job creation. “We are really trying to put people back to work,” Weir said. The first initiative the report suggests — making government buildings more efficient — will put people to work right away, he said. The report also recommended that governments work together to create initiatives to lure green businesses. Those could include everything from touting the area’s well-trained blue-collar work collarbone and a separated shoulder. Bardoni said Pinon’s partner shot at Campos’car, but he doesn’t know whether Campos was hit. The California Highway Patrol, tipped by 911 calls about a“reckless vehicle,” found the car Campos was driving abandoned near Highway 101 and Market Street. Pinon’s partner has been placed on paid administrative leave, a standard protocol whenever a police officer fires his weapon. A use of force investigation will also be conducted, also standard. His name will be released at a later date. Since Friday’s incident, police have received few tips from the public. Bardoni said he remains hopeful, however, that witnesses will step forward. “We’re not sure if he has left the county or country, but we’re doing everything we can to find him,” Bardoni said.“We’re hoping for the public’s support and help in locating Campos.” In January, Pinon shot an auto body shop owner in the hand on the 1300 block of Dayton Street in Salinas. Lawyers for Carlos Fletes, the business owner, and his friend Jose ManuelVillarreal have said the two were painting the bumper of a car when the incident occurred. They maintain Fletes held a paint spray gun and not a firearm, which Sheriff’s Office investigators reported. The men are awaiting trial on charges of assault with a deadly weapon and other gun-related allegations. force to developing valleywide rules for the creation of wind and solar generation sites, Weir said. Donohue said the region must focus on the new economy, including alternative energy. “We are uniquely positioned to take advantage of such opportunities,”he said. The cities of Gonzales, Soledad, Greenfield, King City and Salinas, as well as RICHARD GREEN/THE SALINAS CALIFORNIAN the Salinas Valley Solid Waste Authority, paid for and New uses for Carr Lake could be part of Salinas’ green future according commissioned the report in to a report issued Monday recommending using the dry lake and catch September. basin as a green corridor. OBITUARIES April 10, 2009, Gardens Rehab center. She was born on April 25, SALINAS 1929, in Montreal, QC Canada. Services: A private Celebration of Life will be held at a later date. Arrangements: Struve and Laporte Chapel, 41 W. San Phyllis Mary Richer, 79, of Luis St. Salinas, Calif. 93901. Salinas, passed away Friday, Online condolences: April 10, 2009, at Windsor www.struveandlaporte.com SALINAS Phyllis Mary Richer PRUNEDALE SALINAS David Joseph Ashworth Gretchen Ann Norton Gretchen Ann Norton, 52, of Prunedale and long time resident of Monterey County, passed away Thursday, April 9, 2009 after a sudden illness. She was born December 31, 1956, in Corpus Christi, Texas. Gretchen was a former Computer Programmer for Capital Insurance Group. Survivors: Husband, Charles “Nick” Schweitzer; children, Elizabeth Doidge of Campbell, Erik Norton of Sandusky, Ohio and brother, Fritz Wiedemann of Austin, Texas. Celebration of life: 1 p.m., Sunday, April 19, at Struve and Laporte Chapel, 41 W. San Luis St., Salinas, Calif. 93901. Arrangements: Struve and Laporte Chapel. Online condolences: www.struveandlaporte.com Arthur E. Henriques, 90, of Salinas, passed away Wednesday, April 8, 2009. Arthur was born May 7, 1918 in Ft. Jones. He resided in Salinas for 10 years and served in the U.S. Army AirCorps. He was a member of the V.F.W. in Milpitas and of Madonna Del Sasso Catholic Church. Following his retirement as an accountant, he opened a pizza restaurant in Capitola. Survivors: Wife, of 55 years, Elizabeth Henriques of the family home in Salinas; daughters, Georgina and Paul Jones of Reno, Nev., Elizabeth Henriques of San Jose; sons, Arthur Henriques and Margaret Cabral of San Jose, John Henriques of Santa Cruz, Mark Henriques and Michaealle Havenhill of Fremont, Matthew and Maryann Henriques of Salinas, Luck Henriques of Salinas; sister, Elvira Henriques of Paradise; brother, Julius "Red" Henriques of Sonora; grandchildren, Samuel and Janet Henriques, Adrienne Cabral, and Melissa Henriques. He is preceded in death by brothers, Ernest and Richard Henriques. Visitation: 1 to 9 p.m., Wednesday, April 15, at Healey Mortuary, 405 N. Sanborn Road, Salinas, Calif. 93905. Rosary: 7 p.m., Wednesday, April 15, at Healey Mortuary. Funeral Mass: 11 a.m., Thursday, April 16, at Madonna Del Sasso Catholic Church, 320 E. Laurel Drive, Salinas, Calif. 93906 Burial: San Joaquin Valley National Cemetery, 32053 McCabe Road Gustine, Calif. 95322. Memorials: Contributions may be made to: V.A. Hospital of Palo Alto, 3801 Miranda Ave., Palo Alto, Calif. 94306 or Madonna Del Sasso Catholic Church 320 E. Laurel Drive Salinas, Calif., 93906. A r r a n g e m e n t s : Healey Mortuary & Crematory/ www.healeymortuary.com Bring out your inner artist and start drawing! Garnette Maxine Johns Contreras Garnette Maxine Johns Contreras, 84, of Salinas, passed away Thursday, April 09, 2009. Garnette was born Aug.10, 1924 in Seymour, Mo. and resided in Salinas for 58 years. During WWII, Garnette worked in the Rochmand Shipyards and was one of the women deemed "Rosie the Riveter", who’s slogan was "We Can Do It". It was in the shipyard where she met her husband, Tony. Survivors: Sons, Jerry Contreras of Vacaville, Ted Contreras of Salinas; sisters, Erma Machon of Vallejo, Ethel Boswell of Salinas; brothers, Robert Johns of Mansfield, Mo., Clyde Johns of Biggs; six grandchildren; 19 great-grandchildren; 4 greatgreat grandchildren; along with numerous nieces, nephews and other loving relatives. She is preceded in death by husband, Tony Contreras and sister, Maggie Reynolds. Memorial Services: 11 a.m., Saturday, April 18, at the Healey Mortuary Chapel, 405 N. Sanborn Road, Salinas, Calif. 93905. Cremation: Has taken place. Contributions: May be made to: Deaf & Hard of Hearing Service Center, Inc., 5340 N. Fresno St., Fresno, Calif., 93710, 559-225-3323/[email protected] A r r a n g e m e n t s : Healey Mortuary & Crematory/ www.healeymortuary.com DONATE Tax Write-Off We Handle Paperwork YOUR Running or Not CAR - • Affordable clean newsprint for just $.50 cents a lbs on rolls. Top deals on wheels for work, family and fun. Come to our lobby The Salinas Californian 123 West Alisal Street www.thecalifornian.com • • • Free Pickup (Restrictions apply) Cancer Fund of America, established in1983, serving thousands of individuals nationwide. 800 321 3023 9000097778 David Joseph Ashworth, 56, of Morgan Hill, passed away on April 11, 2009, surrounded by his loving family and friends at O’Conner Hospital in San Jose. He was born Nov. 14, 1952, and was raised in Salinas attending Madonna Del Sasso grade school and Graduating from Palma High School in 1970. Dave met and married his wife, Jeri Cohn, and in 1984 their beautiful daughter, Allison, came into their lives fulfilling their family. As a young boy he was an athlete playing little league, high school baseball and later on a slow pitch team. Dave enjoyed hunting, archery shoots with his close friends and was a professional archer holding many titles. He was an active member of Salinas Bowmen and honorary member of Mt. Madonna Archery Club for more than 20 years. In 1986, the Ashworth’s moved to Morgan Hill where he was a member of St. Catherine’s parish. He shared his love of sports with his daughter, Allison and always supported by coaching her volley ball and softball teams. He was a loyal 49er fan along with Jeri, Allison and many friends, holding annual season tickets and enjoying the parking lot parties with his famous BBQ foods! Go Niners! Dave was a kind heart, loyal family man with true values and a joyous spirit that will always be missed and remembered by all who where a part of his life. Survivors: Devoted wife, of 31 years, Jeri Ashworth; daughter, Allison Ashworth; son-inlaw to be Josh Messina of Morgan Hill; loving mother, Theresa Ashworth of Salinas; many adoring nieces and nephews and other family members. He was preceded in death by his father David C Ashworth Arthur E. Henriques Vehicles, Real Estate, Lots, Boats, RV’s, and more! City of Salinas Public Notice Request for Proposals (RFP) and Proposed 3rd Amendment to 2008-09 ACTION PLAN for Use of Homeless Prevention and Rapid Re-Housing (HPRP) Funds The City of Salinas is to receive $1,013,978 of HPRP funds for homeless prevention related activities and is soliciting proposals from organizations and agencies for multi-year projects. Request for funding must address the City’s Consolidated Plan goals relating to homeless prevention and qualify as an eligible activity under the HPRP. For more information about the program visit the HUD website at www. hudhre.info or contact the Housing and Community Development (HCD) offices. The RFP is available on the City’s website at www.ci.salinas.ca.us/services/ commdev/hprrp.cfm and may also be obtained from the HCD offices. The deadline for submitting proposals is 4 p.m., April 24, 2009. Class meets Mondays, April 20th, May 4th, May 18th and June 1st from 10 - 12:00 Class Topics: Topics: April 20th: Finding Meaning in Life May 4th: Cultivating Joy May 18th: Being Fully Alive June 1st: Aging As A Spiritual Journey PUBLIC HEARING The City Council will hold a public hearing to obtain comment on the proposed 3rd Amendment to 2008-09 which will allocate HPRP funds. The hearing will be held on May 12, 2009 at 4:00 p.m. in the City’s Community Center (Gabilan Rooms) 940 North Main Street, Salinas. For further information, contact Grace De Jesus, City of Salinas, HCD, 200 Lincoln Avenue. Tel. 758-7334 or E-mail: [email protected]. ca.us. Disabled persons requiring accommodation in order to participate in the hearing may contact the Salinas City Clerk: 200 Lincoln Ave, Salinas, CA 93901; (831) 758-7381. TDD Users may contact the City via the California Relay Service at 800-735-2929. 902 9000100620 Each class includes a Brain Fitness exercise. Join us in exploring the positives of aging and how you can have a healthier, happier life in your later years. CENTRAL COAST LIVING Wednesday, May 20, 2009 5B ‘Dyspepsia’ writes: Mom’s meals are hard to stomach D EAR ABBY: My mother is a wonderful person but is one of the world’s worst cooks. She’ll see a recipe that looks tasty, but if she doesn’t have all the ingredients, she will make substitutions. If the recipe calls for uncooked shrimp, she might replace it with canned tuna. If she doesn’t have bleu cheese on hand, she will use imitation cheese spread instead. I have tried to offer her a few important guidelines. First and foremost, be sure to have all the necessary ingredients on hand before beginning to prepare a new recipe. Understand the basic techniques — dice, shred, simmer, stir-fry. Use the recommended cooking temperatures. If the recipe says“saute,”do not fry it until it’s like shoe leather. Follow the proper cooking time. Fish should not be baked for 90 minutes! Mom may not appreciate the suggestion of cooking classes, and I know about your cookbooklets. I wonder if they are simple enough for Mom to follow. What do you think? — DYSPEPSIA IN DENVER DEAR DYSPEPSIA: My mother will enjoy making it together. It is chilled and ideal for a warm summer evening. JEANNE PHILLIPS Dear Abby recipes are — for the most part — very simple, easy to read and, frankly, delicious. They were collected by two of the most voracious eaters in recent history — my mother and me. Allow me to share a simple salad recipe with you. Perhaps you and your ABBY’S TOMATO SALAD i 12 medium tomatoes, diced (about 8 cups) i 2 large red onions, diced (about 3 cups) i 1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoon finely chopped sweet pickles i 1 cup rice vinegar i 10 to 12 lettuce leaves In a large bowl, combine the first four ingredients. Cover and chill several hours or overnight. Using a slotted spoon, portion salad on individual lettuce leaves, allowing 3/4 to 1 cup per serving for a firstcourse salad. Serves 10 to 12. My cookbooklet set contains more than 100 recipes.. My mother often used them when she entertained and so have I.They are time-tested and not complicated. The booklets can be ordered by sending your name and mailing address, plus check or money order for $12 (U.S. funds) to: Dear Abby — Cookbooklet Set, P.O. Box 447, Mount Morris, IL 61054-0447. Shipping and handling are included in the price. My cookbooklet set not only contains recipes, but also tips on entertaining. Have your mother try the tomato salad recipe. If she can’t make this one work, then from now on she might be better off buying takeout. Dear Abby is written by AbigailVan Buren, also known as Jeanne Phillips, and was founded by her mother, Pauline Phillips. Write Dear Abby at www. DearAbby.com or P.O. Box 69440, Los Angeles, CA 90069. i Nighttime headaches Tips for saving money at amusement parks painful for reader The Associated Press • Whirlpool • KitchenAid • Maytag • Jenn-air • G.E. • Frigidaire and more! Much, much more! PETER GOTT, M.D. Ask Dr. Gott DEAR DR. GOTT: I am writing in regards to your article about the teenage boy with near blackouts. I was diagnosed with ophthalmic migraines and found that as soon as I felt the symptoms come on, I had to sit or lie down for about 15 minutes with my eyes closed to stop the blackness and minimize the headache. I hope you let him know that this could be the cause of his symptoms. DEAR READER: Ophthalmic or ocular migraines don’t cause a headache. Rather, they are considered migraines because they involve the visual warnings signs (aura) that most migraine sufferers experience just before the pain of the migraine headache. Based on the young man’s symptoms of lightheadedness/dizziness and faintness (primarily upon standing), I don’t believe this is his problem. Write to Dr. Gott in care of United Media, 200 Madison Ave., 4th fl., New York, NY 10016. i NEW YORK —Visiting an amusement park for the day with a family of four can add up. But there are ways to cut costs, from discounts on admission to strategies for keeping food spending down. Look for Internet specials and coupons in newspapers, on products, and at gas stations and fast food chains. Six Flags Great Adventure in Jackson, N.J., gives $10 off admission if you buy your ticket online, and coupons printed on Coke cans give two-for-one weekday admission to the park or $15 off weekend tickets. “Also if you plan to visit more than once, a season pass pays for itself in less than two visits,”says Six Flags Great Adventure spokesman Angel Aristone. That’s true of season passes at some other parks as well. If you live near a small regional park or oldfashioned seaside park, these can be considerably cheaper than big theme parks, with much shorter lines. Instead of charging a per-person fee at the gate, parks like those in New York’s Coney Island, Old Orchard Beach in Maine, and the Santa Cruz Beach Boardwalk allow you to buy tickets for individual rides, with options for discount ticket packages or unlimited-ride wristbands. You could hit the Cyclone coaster at Coney Island for $8 and the nearby Wonder City of Salinas Public Notice Proposed 4th Amendment to 2008-09 ACTION PLAN for Use of Community Development Block Grant Recovery Program (CDBG-R) Funds The City of Salinas is to receive $663,000 of CDBG-R funds. These funds, made available under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (ARRA) and administered by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), are intended to stimulate the economy through infrastructure modernization, improvement of energy efficiency, and expansion of educational opportunities and access to health care. HUD strongly urges cities to use CDBG-R funds for hard development costs associated with infrastructure activities that provide basic services to residents or activities that promote energy efficiency and conservation in existing buildings. For more information about CDBG-R visit the HUD website at www.hud. gov/recovery or contact the Housing Division offices. The City’s Housing Division proposes to use CDBG-R funds in the amount of $630,000 for the East Market Pedestrian Lights capital improvement project and $33,000 for City’s planning and administration costs. Written comments may be provided in advance to the Housing Division, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas, CA 93901; the public is also invited to speak at the following: meal. The offer is good through June 30. David Mandt, spokesman for the International Associ- Let Our Medical Weight Management Program Help You! ation of Amusement Parks and Attractions, says you might even call the park to ask about deals if you don’t see one on the Web site. 20% OFF INITIAL WEIGHT LOSS VISIT Bring In This Coupon For 20% Off Your Initial Visit Today. RUDY GARCIA, MD 422-1997 422-1997 - ANY LASER TREATMENT 50% 50% • Botox • Facial • Fillers (Restalyne & Perlane) • Laser (Ipl, Photorejuvenation, Hair Removal) • Mesotherapy - Fat Dissolved • Leg Vein Treatment • www.drrudygarcia.com O OFF FF Expires: 5/31/09 Expires 02/28/09 ARTISTIC IMAGE MEDICAL CLINIC 1187 N. MAIN ST. #101 • SALINAS $69. 00 Per Month! or $2,009 plus tax Purchase Price PUBLIC HEARING The City Council will hold a public hearing to obtain comment on the proposed 4th Amendment to the 2008-09 ACTION PLAN which will allocate CDBG-R funds. The hearing will be held on June 2, 2009 at 4:00 p.m. in the City Council Rotunda. The ACTION PLAN is posted on the City’s website: www.ci.salinas.ca.us or can be viewed at the Housing Division offices. For further information, contact Grace De Jesus, City of Salinas, Housing Division, 200 Lincoln Avenue. Tel. 758-7334 or E-mail: graced@ ci.salinas.ca.us. Disabled persons requiring accommodation in order to participate in the hearing may contact the Salinas City Clerk: 200 Lincoln Ave, Salinas, CA 93901; (831) 758-7381. TDD Users may contact the City via the California Relay Service at 800-735-2929. 9000102350 DEAR DR. GOTT: I recently read a letter from one of your readers who was having terrible headaches at night. About a year ago, I began having bad night headaches. I started with my family doctor, who ordered X-rays and referred me to a local neuro-spine clinic. I was under their care for three months, during which time I was given prescription pain medication, muscle relaxants and steroid injections into my scalp. I also had CT scans and MRIs. I was told it was very important to make sure that there was nothing wrong with my head, such as a tumor or other growth. Nothing they did helped me at all, though. I was then referred to a neurologist in a nearby town, and he immediately diagnosed my headaches as“hypnic.”Based on what he told me and what I learned from the Internet, these headaches happen most often to older females (I am 82), and they always occur at night. There is no cure, and very little research has been done on them.There is hope, however, that they can be controlled. I am currently taking lithium, and my headaches have stopped. I take only half a pill and need to have blood work every three months. I was warned of the side effects of this medication, but so far I have not had any. I hope this helps your reader because she is correct when she says they are very painful. DEAR READER: According to the National Headache Foundation (www.headaches.org), hypnic headaches occur at a consistent time each night. Most sufferers experience them between 1 a.m. and 3 a.m.They generally last 15 minutes to three hours.They begin abruptly and resolve spontaneously. The pain is described as being diffuse and throbbing and generally occurs in the front of the head, but some sufferers may have pain on the sides or entire head.The pain is rarely one sided. Most patients experience headaches four or more nights a week. Despite poor tolerance by most patients, the most common treatment is lithium carbonate. Some may benefit from 40 to 60 milligrams of caffeine (or a cup of coffee) before bed or indomethacin (a nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug). Wheel for $6, and spend the rest of the day at the beach for free. At Santa Cruz and Old Orchard, all the rides are under $5. Some parks have discounts for locals. For Southern California residents, the Summer Fun Pass at Disneyland offers three days admission for $99 between June 1 and Aug. 23. Your employer may also have a corporate discount rate for local parks. AAA offers many theme park and attraction discounts and benefits when tickets are purchased in advance through AAA. Details at www.aaa.com/save. One example for Orlando: Purchase an adult and child (ages 3-9) attraction ticket combination for two days or longer at Disney, Universal or SeaWorld and get a“Kids Eat Free” card good that allows kids 3-9 to dine free at over 100 restaurants in the Orlando area when accompanied by an adult who purchases a 9000099826 BY BETH J. HARPAZ Scratch ‘n Dents • Floor Models • Customer Returns • Closeouts • 1-2-3 of a Kind • First Come... First Sold! Hours: Weekdays 10am-8pm; Sat. & Sun. 10am-6pm MUNDO PÁGINA 6 | SÁBADO 23 DE MAYO DEL 2009 Niño secuestrado en California vuelve a casa Policía que pateó a sospechoso en la cabeza vende "ropa pandilla" EL MONTE — Un policía involucrado en el violento arresto de un pandillero, a quien habría pateado en la cabeza, es propietario de una tienda de ropa del estilo de pandilleros y convictos. Documentosjudicialesseñalan que el policía George Fierro, de 41 años, es dueño de la tienda de ropaTorcido Clothing, que vende por internet atuendos con logotipos y símbolos asociados con los pandilleros y la vida en la prisión. El teniente Dan Burlingham confirmó el viernes que Fierro fue uno de los policías que participó en la golpiza al pandillero, en declaraciones al diario San Gabriel Valley Tribune, que citó fuentes anónimas de la municipalidad que señalaban a Fierro como el policía que pateó al sospechoso. En las imágenes mostradas portelevisión,seveaunagente que golpea al sospechoso en la cabeza y otro que le golpea con una linterna. Enelpasado,Fierrohabía sido cuestionado por un colega por vender ese tipo de ropa y demandó al detec- S A N B E R NA R D I N O — Un niño de 3 años, secuestrado en esta población californiana hace casi dos semanas, volvió a su casa el domingo aparentemente ileso tras ser hallado deambulando en una ciudad fronteriza mexicana. Briant Rodríguez se reunió con su familia después de ser hospitalizado durante la noche para un examen físico y emocional. La policía no lo ha interrogado sobre el secuestro, pero tiene pensado hacerlo en los próximos días una vez que el pequeño haya tenido tiempo para volver a sus rutinas normales en el hogar. "Está bien físicamente. Obviamente estaba cansado", dijo Cindy Beavers, portavoz del departamento del alguacil del condado de San Bernardino, en declaraciones aThe Associated Press. "Estoy seguro que tiene algún tipo de trauma por haber estado separado de su familia durante dos semanas", agregó Beavers, y consideró que su regreso a casa fue un "desenlace sorprendente". Las autoridades dijeron que Briant fue secuestrado el 3 de mayo por dos pistoleros que irrumpieron en la mod- tive por difamación, pero el caso fue desechado. El Departamento del Alguacil investiga si el uso de fuerza en la detención del miércoles voló las normas policiales. El incidente comenzó cuando la policía vio a un presunto pandillero que cometía una ligera falta de tráfico. El hombre, Richard Rodríguez, aceleró su vehículo y escapó atravesando de un pueblo a otro del valle de San Gabriel, dijo la policía. Al final de la persecución, el sospechoso de 23 años se vio acorralado en un patio y se recostó en el suelo con los brazos abiertos, en actitud de rendirse. Fue cuando un policía se le acercó y le pateó la cabeza. La acción del agente ha sido criticada por defensores de los derechos civiles y los expertos han dicho que se usó fuerza excesiva. El abogado del sindicato de la policía en El Monte dijo al diario Los Angeles Times que se justificaba la acción, que calificó como un golpe de distracción en caso de que el sospechoso hubiera estado armado. SHO WAFFLE Country Cooking P Tony D Tony Diaz iaz B Bail ail B Bonds onds Michelle D. No Cometas Otro Error Serving Breakfast & Lunch HOMEMADE BISCUITS & GRAVY • HEARTY OMELETES • BREAKFAST SKILLETS HOMEMADE SOUP & SALAD • BANQUET FACILITIES AVAILABLE LLAME AL MEJOR, TONY DIAZ BAIL BONDS John C. “VENDEMOS “VENDEMOS L LIBERTAD” IBERTAD” 1-800-434-BAIL or 424-2500 Miembro del Better Business Bureau. COMPRE UNO Y EL SEGUNDO ES 9000099721 9000097545 Tony D. INFORMACION GRATUITA DE FIANZAS Y CHEQUES DE AUTORIZACION The Best Waffle Ever GRATIS DISFRUTE UNA ENTRADA GRATIS CUANDO COMPRE UNA ENTRADA Y 2 BEBIDAS DE NUESTRO MENU REGULAR DEL MISMO PRECIO O A UN PRECIO MAS BAJO.† 1 CUPON PER MESA, POR FAVOR.† PRESENTE ESTE CUPON CUANDO ORDENE.† NO ES VALIDO CON OTRO DESCUENTO O EN DIAS FESTIVOS. EXCLUYE BISTEC. ABIERTO SIETE DIAS A LA SEMANA 6AM-3PM • 442-8880 1465 N. MAIN ST. (EN LA ESQUINA DE N. MAIN Y ALVIN DR., EN ALVIN SQUARE) Calexico. Gerardo Franco, portavoz de la procuraduría de justicia del estado de Baja California, dijo que tiene entendido que Millán no se reunió con su hijo en Mexicali porque ella es una indocumentada en Estados Unidos y tenía miedo de cruzar la frontera. El alguacil Rod Hoops no quiso hablar sobre el estatus migratorio de Millán, pero hizo énfasis en que Briant es ciudadano estadounidense. "Nació en un hospital en San Bernardino y tiene todos los derechos para estar aquí", dijo Hoops. "Por eso hemos trabajado tan duro para traerlo de vuelta". Ciudad de Salinas Aviso Público 4ta Enmienda Propuesta al PLAN de ACCIÓN 2008-09 para el Uso de Fondos de Subsidios del Programa de Recuperación del Bloque de Desarrollo Comunitario (CDBG-R, por sus siglas en inglés) La Ciudad de Salinas recibirá $663,000 de fondos CDBG-R. Estos fondos, disponibles bajo el Acto de Recuperación y Reinversión Americana del 2009 (ARRA, por sus siglas en inglés) y administrados por el Departamento de Vivienda y Desarrollo Urbano de los Estados Unidos (HUD, por sus siglas en inglés), tienen la intención de estimular la economía a través de la modernización de la infraestructura, mejoramiento de la eficiencia energética, y la expansión de oportunidades educativas y el acceso a servicios médicos. HUD recomienda fuertemente a las ciudades el uso de los fondos CDBG-R para costos fijos de desarrollo asociados con actividades de infraestructura que proveen servicios básicos a los residentes o actividades que promuevan la eficiencia energética y la conservación en edificios existentes. Para obtener mayor información sobre CDBG-R visite la página web de HUD en www.hud.gov/recovery o comuníquese con la Oficina de la División de Vivienda. La División de Vivienda de la Ciudad propone usar fondos CDBG-R en la cantidad de $630,000 para el Alumbrado Público en East Market proyecto de mejoramiento de capital y $33,000 para la planeación de la ciudad y gastos administrativos. Pueden enviarse comentarios por escrito por adelantado a la Housing Divison, 200 Lincoln Avenue, Salinas, CA 93901; se invita también al público a participar en la siguiente: JUNTA PÚBLICA El Ayuntamiento de la Ciudad llevará a cabo una junta pública para obtener comentarios públicos sobre la 4ta Enmienda Propuesta al PLAN de ACCIÓN 2008-09, el cual asignará fondos CDBG-R. La junta se llevará a cabo el 2 de junio del 2009 a las 4:00 p.m. en la Rotonda del Ayuntamiento de la Ciudad. El PLAN de ACCIÓN se encuentra en la página web de la Ciudad: www.ci.salinas.ca.us o puede ser revisado en las oficinas de la División de Vivienda. Para mayores informes, comunicarse con Grace De Jesus, City of Salinas, Housing Division, 200 Lincoln Avenue. Tel. 7587334 o Correo electrónico: [email protected]. Las personas discapacitadas que requieran de adecuaciones para poder participar en esta junta, pueden comunicarse a la Secretaría del Ayuntamiento de la Ciudad de Salinas (City Clerk): 200 Lincoln Ave, Salinas, CA 93901; (831) 758-7381. : Los usuarios de TDD pueden comunicarse con la Ciudad a través del California Relay Service al 800-735-2929. Presentado por Creative Living Program, Area Agency on Aging, Health Projects Center’s Del Mar Caregiver Resource Center ¡Mayo es el Mes de la Concientización del Agua! ¿Sabía usted que si riega su pasto y jardín temprano por la mañana o después de la puesta del sol puede ahorrar hasta 250 galones de agua por semana? Universidad para Personas que Cuidan de Enfermos Un dia de educacion y compartir sábado 6 de junio 2009 9:00am - 4:00pm Este mes y cada mes, Cal Water le recuerda a los residentes de Salinas, negocios y vecinos... Use el agua sabiamente. Es esencial. Escuela para Adultos de Salinas 20 Sherwood Place, Salinas GRATIS Se proveerá el almuerzo. Visite www.calwater.com para enterarse de cómo usted puede hacerla diferencia. Los siguientes talleres seran conducidos en Español: • Controlando la Demencia • Estrategias para Manejar el Estrés • Como Levantar y Transferir a Su Ser Querido • Cuidado de Adultos Durante el Dia, Este programa es patrocinado por: AARP California, Care From The Heart Home Service, Country Villa Watsonville East Nursing Center, Heartland Hospice, Visiting Angels Living Assistance Services, Windsor Care Centers Orgullosamente sirviendo a Salinas desde 1962 Otras clases disponibles en inglés 9000102413 Para mas información y inscripción llame: 831-796-6920 9000102566 Mario G. esta vivienda de su familia y maniataron a su madre y a cuatro de sus hermanos. Un agente de la policía municipal en Mexicali encontró al niño el jueves por la noche mientras caminaba solo en las calles.Al principio, el agente pensó que el menor vivía en el vecindario y lo llevó a varias casas buscando a su familia, antes de dejarlo en una oficina de la dependencia encargada de la protección a la niñez.Al pequeño le habían rasurado sus largos mechones de cabello. Posteriormente las autoridades mexicanas se pusieron en contacto con sus contrapartes estadounidenses. "Cuando lo entrevisten, en un momento dado podría decirle o no a los detectives cuándo ocurrió eso (el secuestro) y posiblemente quién lo hizo", dijo Beavers, quien agregó que el pequeño será entrevistado por detectives entrenados para hacer preguntas a niños. Agentes del FBI viajaron a Mexicali para hacerse cargo de los papeles migratorios del niño, que tiene tanto la nacionalidad estadounidense como la mexicana. Luego lo llevaron a Estados Unidos, donde el sábado se reunió con su madre, María Rosalina Millán, en 9000101778 THE ASSOCIATED PRESS POR GILLIAN FLACCUS | AP City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report APPENDIX D – FEDERAL FORMS HUD Form 40107-A HOME Match Report HUD Form 40107 Annual Performance Report – HOME Program U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Community Planning and Development Annual Performance Report HOME Program OMB Approval No. 2506-0171 (exp. 8/31/2009) Public reporting burden for this collection of information is estimated to average 2.5 hours per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. This agency may not conduct or sponsor, and a person is not required to respond to, a collection of information unless that collection displays a valid OMB control number. The HOME statute imposes a significant number of data collection and reporting requirements. This includes information on assisted properties, on the owners or tenants of the properties, and on other programmatic areas. The information will be used: 1) to assist HOME participants in managing their programs; 2) to track performance of participants in meeting fund commitment and expenditure deadlines; 3) to permit HUD to determine whether each participant meets the HOME statutory income targeting and affordability requirements; and 4) to permit HUD to determine compliance with other statutory and regulatory program requirements. This data collection is authorized under Title II of the Cranston-Gonzalez National Affordable Housing Act or related authorities. Access to Federal grant funds is contingent on the reporting of certain project-specific data elements. Records of information collected will be maintained by the recipients of the assistance. Information on activities and expenditures of grant funds is public information and is generally available for disclosure. Recipients are responsible for ensuring confidentiality when public disclosure is not required. This form is intended to collect numeric data to be aggregated nationally as a complement to data collected through the Cash and Management Information (C/MI) System. Participants should enter the reporting period in the first block. The reporting period is October 1 to September 30. Instructions are included for each section if further explanation is needed. This report is for period (mm/dd/yyyy) Starting Ending Submit this form on or before December 31. Send one copy to the appropriate HUD Field Office and one copy to: 10/01/2008 HOME Program, Rm 7176, 451 7th Street, S.W., Washington D.C. 20410 Date Submitted 09/30/2009 (mm/dd/yyyy) 09/02/2009 Part I Participant Identification 1. Participant Number 2. Participant Name M-08-MC-06212 CITY OF SALINAS, CA 3. Name of Person completing this report 4. Phone Number (Include Area Code) GRACE ASTON 831 758-7334 5. Address 6. City 200 LINCOLN AVENUE SALINAS 7. State 8. Zip Code CA 93901 Part II Program Income Enter the following program income amounts for the reporting period: in block 1, enter the balance on hand at the beginning; in block 2, enter the amount generated; in block 3, enter the amount expended; and in block 4, enter the amount for Tenant-Based rental Assistance. 1. Balance on hand at Beginning of Reporting Period 247,243.96 2. Amount received during Reporting Period 3. Total amount expended during Reporting Period 52,590.49 4. Amount expended for TenantBased Rental Assistance (44,700.93) 5. Balance on hand at end of Reporting Period (1 + 2 - 3) = 5 0.00 282,133.52 Part III Minority Business Enterprises (MBE) and Women Business Enterprises (WBE) In the table below, indicate the number and dollar value of contracts for HOME projects completed during the reporting period. a. Total A. Contracts 1. Number 2. Dollar Amount B. Sub-Contracts 1. Number b. Alaskan Native or American Indian 1 0 28,428.00 0 2. Dollar Amount 2. Dollar Amount D. Sub-Contracts 1. Number 2. Dollar Amounts 0 0 0 0 a. Total C. Contracts 1. Number Minority Business Enterprises (MBE) c. Asian or d. Black Pacific Islander Non-Hispanic 0 b. Women Business Enterprises (WBE) 1 0 28,428.00 0 0 0 0 0 f. White Non-Hispanic 1 0 0 0 28,428.00 0 0 0 c. Male 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 e. Hispanic 28,428.00 0 0 page 1 of 2 0 form HUD-40107 (11/92) Part IV Minority Owners of Rental Property In the table below, indicate the number of HOME assisted rental property owners and the total dollar amount of HOME funds in these rental properties assisted during the reporting period. a. Total b. Alaskan Native or American Indian Minority Property Owners c. Asian or d. Black Pacific Islander Non-Hispanic e. Hispanic f. White Non-Hispanic 1. Number 2. Dollar Amount Part V Relocation and Real Property Acquisition Indicate the number of persons displaced, the cost of relocation payments, the number of parcels acquired, and the cost of acquisition. The data provided should reflect only displacements and acquisitions occurring during the reporting period. a. Number b. Cost 1. Parcels Acquired 0 0 2. Businesses Displaced 0 0 3. Nonprofit Organizations Displaced 0 0 4. Households Temporarily Relocated, not Displaced 0 0 Households Displaced 5. Households Displaced - Number 6. Households Displaced - Cost a. Total b. Alaskan Native or American Indian 0 0 0 Minority Business Enterprises (MBE) c. Asian or d. Black Pacific Islander Non-Hispanic 0 0 page 2 of 2 e. Hispanic 0 0 f. White Non-Hispanic 0 0 0 0 0 form HUD-40107 (11/92) City of Salinas 2008 – 2009 Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Report APPENDIX E – IDIS REPORTS PR03 CDBG Activity Summary Report PR06 Summary of Consolidated Plan Projects PR10 CDBG Housing Activities PR19 ESG Statistics for Program Year 2008 PR20 ESG Activity Summary for Program Year 2008 PR23 Summary of Accomplishments PR26 CDBG Financial Summary for Program Year 2008 PR27 Status of HOME Funds PR81 ESG Performance Measures PR83 CDBG Performance Measures PR84 CDBG Strategy Area, CDFI and Local Target Area PR85 HOME Housing Performance CDBG FINANCIAL SUMMARY Community Development Block Grant Program US Department of Housing and Urban Development Office of Community Planning and Development Name of Grantee: Salinas, CA Grant Number: B-08-MC-060005 Reporting Period: FY 2008-09 Part I - Summary of CDBG Resources 1. Unexpended CDBG Funds at End of Previous Program Year 2. Entitlement Grant 3. Surplus Urban Renewal Funds 4. Section 108 Guaranteed Loan Funds (principal amount) 5. Current Year Program Income 6. Returns 7. Adjustment to Compute Total Available Entitlement Grant (including reallocated funds) Current Year Program Income Returns 8. Total CDBG Funds Available (sum, lines 1-7) 910,436.03 2,441,464.00 0.00 0.00 58,426.21 0.00 (67,540.67) 0.00 (67,540.67) 0.00 3,342,785.57 Part II - Summary of CDBG Expenditures 9. Disbursements Other Than Section 108 Repayments and Planning/Admin 10. Adjustment to Compute Total Amount Subject to Low/Mod Benefit 11. Amount Subject to Low/Mod Benefit (line 9 plus line 10) 12. Disbursed in IDIS for Planning/Administration 13. Disbursed in IDIS for Section 108 Repayments 14. Adjustment to Compute Total Expenditures 15. Total Expenditures (lines 11 to 14) 16. Unexpended Balance (line 8 minus line 15) 2,208,425.96 613,863.71 2,822,289.67 670,526.38 0.00 (206,770.73) 3,286,045.32 56,740.25 Part III - Low/Mod Credit This Reporting Period 17. Total Expended for Low/Mod Housing in Special Areas 18. Total Low/Mod Credit for Multi-Unit Housing Expenditures 19. Total From All Other Activities Qualifying as Low/Mod Expenditures 20. Adjustment to Compute Total Low/Mod Credit 21. Total Low/Mod Credit (lines 17 to 20) 22. Percent Low/Mod Credit (line 21 divided by line 11) 154,657.44 200,000.00 1,563,197.29 904,434.94 2,822,289.67 100.00% 23. Program Years (PY) Covered in Certification 24. Cumulative Net Expenditures Subject to Low/Mod Benefit Calculation 25. Cumulative Expenditures Benefitting Low/Mod Persons 26. Percent Benefit to Low/Mod Persons (line 25 divided by line 24) 1 2,822,289.67 2,822,289.67 100.00% Part IV - Public Service (PS) Cap Calculation 27. Disbursed in IDIS for Public Services 28. PS Unliquidated Obligations at End of Current Program Year 29. PS Unliquidated Obligations at End of Previous Program Year 30. Adjustment to Compute Total PS Obligations 31. Total PS Obligations (Line 27 plus line 28 minus line 29 plus line 30) 32. Entitlement Grant 33. Prior Year Program Income 34. Adjustment to Compute Total Subject to PS Cap 35. Total Subject to PS Cap (line 32 to 34) 36. Percent Funds Obligated for PS Activities (line 31 divided by line 35) 294,332.18 0.00 0.00 54,934.91 349,267.09 2,441,464.00 150,932.85 (67,540.67) 2,524,856.18 13.83% Part V - Planning and Administration (PA) CAP 37. Disbursed in IDIS for Planning and Administration 38. PA Unliquidated Obligations at End of Current Program Year 39. PA Unliquidated Obligations at End of Previous Program Year 40. Adjustment to Compute Total PA Obligations 41. Total PA Obligations (line 37 plus line 38 minus line 39 plus line 40) 42. Entitlement Grant 43 Current Year Program Income 44. Adjustment to Compute Total Subject to PA CAP 45. Total Subject to PA CAP (line 42 to 44) 46. Percent Funds Obligated for PA activities (line 41 divided by line 45) 670,526.38 0.00 0.00 206,770.73 463,755.65 2,441,464.00 58,426.21 (67,540.67) 2,432,349.54 19.07% CDBG Financial Summary 08-09.xls 1 2 3 4 5 6 3 1 Page 1 of 1 CDBG Financial Summary Name of Grantee : City of Salinas Footnotes Grant Number: B-08-MC-060005 1 Program Income adjustment to reflect amounts received in FY 07/08 but not recorded in IDIS until FY 08/09 and FY 06/07 program income recorded in FY 07/08. 2 Disbursements (other than planning and administration) adjustment to reflect expenditures for FY 07/08 but not drawn in IDIS until FY 08/09 and FY 06/07 expenditures drawn in FY 07/08. 3 Planning and Administration disbursements adjustment to reflect expenditures for FY 07/08 but not drawn in IDIS until FY 08/09 and FY 06/07 expenditures drawn in FY 07/08. 4 Low/Mod disbursements adjustment to reflect expenditures for FY 07/08 but not drawn in IDIS until FY 08/09 and FY 06/07 expenditures drawn in FY 07/08. 5 Public Services disbursements adjustment to reflect expenditures for FY 07/08 but not drawn in IDIS until FY 08/09 and reversal of FY 06/07 expenditures drawn in FY 07/08. 6 Prior Year (FY 07/08) program income adjustment from Part 1 Line 7 of FY 07/08 PR26.