From Cornwall to Eldorado
Transcription
From Cornwall to Eldorado
From Cornwall to Eldorado Peter Prevos and Sue Brewer-Prevos Third Hemisphere Publishing CC Peter Prevos and Sue Brewer-Prevos (2010) Third Hemisphere Publishing, Kangaroo Flat This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.5 Australia Licence (www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.5/au/). You are free to: • Share — to copy, distribute and transmit the work • Remix — adapt the work Under the following conditions: BY: — You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author or licensor (but not in • Attribution any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work). • Share Alike — If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may distribute the resulting work C only under the same or similar license to this one. Typeset in LATEX. Title page design by Luke Brewer. Contact details: Peter Prevos, [email protected], Sue Brewer-Prevos, [email protected]. This book is dedicated to Vince Brewer, who would have celebrated his 100th birthday this year. Contents Preface v 1 Introduction 1 2 William Brewer & Elizabeth Francis Teenager moves to the New World 5 3 William Ellen & Sarah Ann Crack Gold fever in the Victorian hills 10 4 David Brewer & Rosa-Jane Ellen How an accident with an axe destroys a family 15 5 William Henry Gribble & Mary Teresa Grenville Cornish mining family looking for a new horizon 20 6 Ellen Higgins The pressures of family shame and taboo 25 7 George Albert Gribble & Elizabeth Higgins The tragedies of war 30 8 Eldorado 33 References 36 Index of Family Names 37 iv Preface are an important aspect of being human. For the generations before us, family relationships formed the foundation of social reality. Heritage and origins were the main categories in which people were placed and judged. In contemporary society these relationships have lost their meaning as more emphasis is placed on individual achievement than on origin. This is one of the reasons that family history has become so popular in recent decades. Due to the reduced importance of origin and heritage, people are searching for their origins in order to find the answer to the ultimate question: “Who am I?” The development of this family history has its own history. Interest in the origins of the Brewer family was sown in the mid 1990s when Sue received family history information from her cousin Marie Wickenton, which formed the foundation of this family history. A collection of birth, marriage and death certificates and family lore helped to move the research further and deeper. In 1999, while living in the Netherlands, the research became more serious and a lot of information was sourced from the Internet, which is also a great place to meet fellow researchers. Some research was also conducted in a Family History Research Centre in the Netherlands. These centres are managed by the Church of Jesus Christ Latter Day Saints who F take family history so seriously it is actually a part of their religion. Highlight of the research adventure was a two week visit to Cornwall in search of physical traces of the Brewer ancestors. This pilgrimage to the ancestral lands involved exploring church yards, looking for headstones of distant relatives, and delving into paper records and microfilm in the local archives. This book would have been impossible without the help of many other family history researchers, who are also distant relatives. When spending some time in the County Records Office in Truro we accidentally met Paul Brewer, who generously handed us a floppy disk containing his complete Brewer family research. We would also like to thank, in no particular order, Margaret Owens and her sister Marilyn Mapstone, Linda Mackie, Rita Magris, Judy Davis, Bill Gribble, Margaret Campbell and Maria Brandl, Jack Brewer and Alma Brewer and many others. Without these people this book could not have been written. A family history is never complete and many thousands of records are waiting to be discovered in archives in the United Kingdom, Ireland and Australia. This book is only a snapshot of the available information. More information on further generations than described in this book is available on-line at razgirl.prevos.net. AMILY CONNECTIONS v Chapter 1 Introduction describes the immediate ancestors of the Eldorado clan of the Brewer-Gribble family. Their greatgrandparents, great-great-grandparents and great by three grandparents moved from England, Ireland and Scotland to Australia in the middle of the nineteenth century in search of a better life overseas. This book briefly describes their lives and the lives of their descendants. The social situation in England and Scotland during the Victorian era was, despite the great wealth accumulated through the colonies, quite miserable for most people. The novels of Charles Dickens provide an insight into the lives of the common people in those days. People were living in deplorable conditions, with crippling poverty and strict social stratification preventing them opportunities to improve their lives. Immigration was for many the only means to escape these conditions. Many Scottish emigrants were motivated due to the land clearance system, whereby landlords would forcefully eject tenants. Those in Ireland were the worst off. The cruel system of distraint, whereby small farmers would be forced to pay rent with their produce, caused a lot of misery. The tragic Potato Famine of 1836 was, however, the greatest factor to drive immigration. In the Victorian era, that lasted for most of the nineteenth century, around fifteen million T emigrants left the United Kingdom and Ireland and settled mostly in the United States, Canada, and Australia. The ancestors of the Brewer-Gribble family, and the thousands of other people that went before them, were the first wave of economic boat refugees to land in Australia. HIS FAMILY HISTORY § § § Several themes emerge in this family history. Most important driver for the migrant ancestors of the Brewer-Gribble family was the Victorian Gold Rush that erupted in 1852. Several ancestors tried to carve out a living by potholing the landscape in search of the precious metal. The two World Wars are another thread through the lives of these families. Many sons left for Europe and Asia to fight against the axis of evil of the time. Most of them returned, but some lost their lives in the struggle for freedom. The most important theme of this book is the connection between people. Human beings are ‘social animals’ and it is often said the blood runs thicker than water. We prefer to live in groups, enjoying each others emotional and physical support. We are connected through ‘blood’ and cultural origins. Family connections also played a great role in the lives of the Brewer-Gribble ancestors. Shirley Abbott expressed this poetically: 1 We all grow up with the weight of history on us. Our ancestors dwell in the attics of our brains as they do in the spiralling chains of knowledge hidden in every cell of our bodies. This history starts with sixteen of the multitude of brave people from England, Scotland and Ireland that moved to Australia in the nineteenth century. They form the beginnings of the Eldorado clan of the Brewer-Gribble family. This book is divided into three parts. In the first part, the Brewer side of the family is explored. The second part describes the lives of the Gribble side of the family. The end of the journey is a short description of the BrewerGribble family and the town of Eldorado that they consider their family base. One aspect of the importance of family connections is the systematic naming of children so that first names travel through the generations. In the Brewer line of the family there are quite a few Richards and Williams. Names were also frequently ‘recycled’ within the one family. It was not uncommon for a child to be named the same as a sibling that died earlier. This tradition shows strongly in the Nankervis branch of the family. In five consecutive generations, names of deceased children were re-used for younger ones. Eliza Jane Nankervis, who married Elijah Gribble, had two sisters named Mary Ann born in consecutive years. Eliza’s father Thomas had two siblings with reused names. In his family there were two Johns and two Graces. The practice of reusing names slowly died out in the nineteenth century. Due to the fact that parents became more emotionally invested in their young children as the chances of survival increased due to advances in medical science. In our contemporary society, the reusing of names would be unthinkable. Family and origin are important bonding aspects in our social lives. From this family history it becomes apparent that first generation Cornish immigrants preferred the company of other Cornish people. This family was also bound by the taboos of their times. This is no more tragically demonstrated by the misery experienced by the women that give birth to children outside of wedlock. Strachan Harkness Higgins Crack Player Brewer Gribble Nankervis Ellen Grenville Parker Francis Origins of the Brewer-Gribble ancestors The ancestors of the Brewer-Gribble family arrived in Australia from different places in what was then the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. They all congregated in the Beechworth area, attracted by the lure of gold. 2 William Brewer (1846–1927), from a Cornish family of mariners, moved to Australia from Padstow in Cornwall when he was a teenager. He joined his older brothers and sister, who had been in Australia since the gold rush days. He met fellow Cornish immigrant Elizabeth Francis (1841–1918) from Penryn, with whom he had six children (Chapter 2), one of which was David Brewer. Third ancestor that moved to Australia was Sarah Ann Crack (1847–1933), who left Norfolk with her mother and stepfather and arrived in Australia in 1853. Her first husband Charles Godwin died after only seven years of marriage and she married William Ellen (1828–1911), who moved to Australia from Dover in Kent (Chapter 3). Their daughter Rosa-Jane Ellen (1882– 1957) marries the above mentioned David Brewer (1876–1930) and they have eight children (Chapter 4), one of which is Vince Brewer. § § § The Gribble side of the family were Cornish miners that moved to Australia and other parts of the globe after tin and copper mining in Cornwall went into decline. Elijah Gribble (1837–1923) left his native Creegbrawse in 1858 and moved to Beechworth to try his luck in gold mining. His future wife Eliza Jane Nankervis (1847–1923) was ten years younger than Elijah. She moved from Saint Just in Cornwall to Australia in 1857 with her parents Thomas Nankervis (1809–1868) and Elizabeth Ellis (1809–1867) and her younger brothers and sisters. Elijah and Eliza’s son William Henry Gribble (1866–1923) marries Mary Teresa Grenville (1870–1955), who was also born in Australia. Her parents, Thomas Hughes Grenville (1833–1909), a butcher from Brighton, and Elizabeth Mary Player (1837–1915) from London, met in Australia and married in Nine Mile, near Chiltern (Chapter 5). William Henry and Mary Theresa had eleven children, one of which was George Albert Gribble (1897–1967). John Higgins from Dublin (1803–1869) and Tryphena Parker (1827–1898) from Hastings, moved to Australia before the gold rush and originally settled in New South Wales to work on a cattle run, where their oldest son William Thomas Higgins (1842–1924) was born. William marries Mary Strachan (1850– 1917), the daughter of Scottish immigrants John Strachan (born 1840) and Elizabeth Harkness (1816–1881) that moved to Australia from Dumfries, some years before the gold rush started (Chapter 6). Ellen Higgins (1873–1942), daughter of William Thomas and Mary Strachan, had a hard life as she gave birth to three children outside of wedlock. One of these was Elizabeth Higgins (1899– 1970), who marries the above mentioned George Albert Gribble (Chapter 7). They had six children, one of which is Alma Gribble. This family history ends when Vince Brewer and Alma Gribble marry in 1947, thus forming the foundation of this family. More than half a century later, the family is no longer concentrated around NorthEast Victoria, but has moved around Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia. 3 Immigrant ancestors of the Brewer-Gribble family. 4 Elizabeth Ellis David Brewer David Godwin Vincent Brewer Rosa-Jane Ellen Mary Strachan John Elizabeth Strachan Harkness Ellen William James Moore Higgins Elizabeth Higgins Unknown Alma Maud Gribble Mary Theresa Grenville George Albert Gribble William Elizabeth Charles Sarah Ann William William Henry Brewer Francis Godwin Crack Ellen Gribble Tryphena Parker William Thomas Higgins John Higgins Thomas Elizabeth Edward Mary Thomas Maria Jacob Elijah Eliza Jane Hughes Cooke Crack Jessup Gribble Nankervis Grenville Player Thomas Nankervis Chapter 2 William Brewer & Elizabeth Francis Teenager moves to the New World ence to its winding course.1 The river and the ocean into which it flows played an important role in the lives of all Padstonians and particularly William Brewer and his relatives. In those days, the quays of Padstow were bustling with business. Cargo was brought in by sailing ships from across the British Empire and Padstow boasted six shipyards and a packet service. The Padstow shipyards were used to build and repair schooners,2 a versatile type of ship that can be used for ocean voyages, coastal runs and on large lakes. § § § William’s parents, John Brewer and Mary Randall, lived in Stoptide in St Minver when he was born. John Brewer was christened on 19 June 1804 in Padstow and was, just like his father, a mariner and shopkeeper.3 Mary, a farmer’s daughter, was seven years younger than her husband. John captained the ferry from Padstow to Black Rock, which had been in existence since 1337.4 John and Mary married on 22 November 1832 in St Minver5 and had eight children in their sixteen years of marriage. Mary died not long after the birth of their daughter Margaret and was buried on 21 September 1848 in the St Enodoc’s Church yard.6 Margaret did not survive for very long after her mother and died when she was only three months old.7 B REWER side of this Australian family starts with William from the parish of Saint Minver in Cornwall, across the river from Padstow. Cornwall, which forms the tip of the south-west peninsula of the island of Great Britain, is exposed to the full force of the prevailing winds that blow in from the Atlantic Ocean. The rocky coastline gives rise in many places to impressive cliffs and Padstow forms a natural harbour in this rugged landscape. T HE Padstow quay in 1999 In the nineteenth century, Padstow’s prosperity was closely related to the river Camel, which rises on the edge of Bodmin Moor and after about thirty miles issues into the Celtic Sea. The name Camel derives from the Cornish language for ‘the crooked one’, a refer5 John was in need of a mother for his younger children and married a year later to Cecilia Ann Tonkin from the nearby inland town of Bodmin.8 John tragically died on the river that was his main source of income on 9 October 1860.9 Charley Nance, a prolific letter writer from Padstow, wrote about John’s tragic death to his brother William in Cardiff: this mishap a great storm came and wrecked many of the ships in the harbour and threw up the sandbank that caused my ships to sink from then on.12 “Captain Brewer, of Rock, died very suddenly on Monday last while crossing the Ferry from Rock. He left home in the morning very well, and died just as they got to the pier head in Mr Derrick’s arms.”10 Parents of David Brewer Elizabeth Francis William Brewer David Brewer § § § William Brewer was christened in St Minver on 14 February 184613 and moved to Australia, still in his teens. William was, however, not the only member of the Brewer family to move to the other side of the world. Before him, three of his siblings decided to make the move across the ocean to the booming colonies. His two older sisters, Ellen Christian and Mary stayed in Cornwall where they married and had a family. When William’s oldest brother John, born on 17 August 1833 in St Minver,14 was 17 he worked on a ship transporting sheep and cattle from Cornwall to New Zealand. He caught wind of the gold rush in Victoria and relinquished the sea faring life to try his luck at mining gold.15 At first he was in Ballarat, where he was present during the infamous 1854 rebellion by gold prospectors at the Eureka Stockade. This outbreak of violence was prompted by grievances over heavily priced mining items and the behaviour of government officials, the police and the military.16 After the riots he sought his fortune in the Ovens goldfield and moved to Beechworth. He settled down and bought a dairy on the Wooragee Road, about three miles from This was, however, not the first time a member of the Brewer family died on the water. John Brewer’s headstone contains a reference to his son David, who drowned at sea five years earlier: Sacred / To the / Memory / of / John Brewer / Shipowner of Rock in this Parish who / departed this life on the 9th day of Oct[obe]r / 1860 Aged 56 Years. / Also / To the memory of / David / Son of the above who was drowned at / Sea on the 21st day of March 1855 / Aged 17 Years // Shipwrecks were not uncommon around Padstow and the Doom Bar, a treacherous sandbank between Padstow and Rock, has caused over 600 shipwrecks since records began. According to local legend, the Doom Bar is the result of a mermaid’s curse.11 The story goes that a merry mermaid used to watch over the vessels that sailed in and out of Padstow. One day, she was shot by a fisherman and the mermaid’s curse was that the harbour would become desolate from that time on. Shortly after 6 Beechworth. He prospered and bought some valuable properties in Wooragee where he later resided. He owned a stone house and farmhouse with eleven acres of land, plus a 17 acre farm in Beechworth.17 John married Charlotte Warren in Melbourne in 1854, with whom he had nine children. John died after an illness extending over several months at the age of 83 in 1915, one year after the couple celebrated their diamond wedding anniversary. Not long before his death he still personally delivered milk to his customers. John was a pioneer of the Beechworth area and a well respected resident, judging by the detailed obituary in the The Ovens and Murray Advertiser.18 William’s oldest sister, Hannah Jane Brewer, was a housewife born in 1836 in St Minver.19 Hannah Jane was living with her mother until she met her future husband John Waters Blewett, whom she married on 15 October 1861 in St Minver.20 John, son of Gabriel Blewett and Jane Rickard, was a builder and was born about 1824 in Madron, Cornwall. They left England not long after their marriage and arrived, after a journey of twenty weeks, in Melbourne in January 1862 on the Dover Castle.21 Not long after arriving in Melbourne, John contracted double pneumonia and died after eight months of suffering on 18 December 1862 in Fitzroy, aged 38.22 Her first year in Australia was an annus horibilis for Hannah, as her baby boy John, with whom she was pregnant during the journey from England, died in 1863 in Fitzroy.23 Hannah Jane remarried on 4 June 1867 in Beechworth to Walter Paull, a Cornish miner and farmer, born in St Agnes in 1832.24 This was a second marriage for both Walter and Hannah Jane and they raised five sons. Walter died of heart disease on 10 August 1886 in Bethanga and was buried after Wesleyan rites in the Yackandandah cemetery. Hannah Jane died at the age of 79 in Yackandandah in 1915.25 William Brewer (1846–1927) Richard Randall (Randale) Brewer was the third sibling to move to the great southern land. Richard was a vegetable farmer, born 1840 in St Minver.26 In 1875 he married Cassandra Parr from Derby in England27 and had four children. After starting a dairy in Malvern, he moved to Pinedale, a vegetable farm, surrounded by beautiful pine trees, at Leneva, just out of Wooragee.28 Richard died from thyroid cancer on 14 April 1897 in Fitzroy and was buried in Wodonga.29 § § § William Brewer migrated to Australia, following his two brothers and his sister, not long after their father died in the early 1860’s. He eventually owned a seven acre orchard at Wooragee. He grew apples, which he used 7 to store on the loft of his hay shed, and lots of William Brewer, born in Wooragee on 5 Degooseberries. William used to make ‘jim jam’, cember 1871.33 He was married to Jane Eliza a mix of all fruit and berries.30 (Janey) Boyes (Boyce), born around 1868. Family lore holds that William owned a lot of property in Melbourne. One anecdote illustrates that William was a tough man. When his younger brother David (Chapter 4) died, he advised his sister in law to give the younger kids away as they were a poor family. William died at age 84 on 28 February 1956 in Richmond.34 Janey died at the age of 96 in Collingwood. § § § Mary Frances (Minnie) Brewer was born in Beechworth in March 1873. Mary Frances moved to Tasmania to work as a governess and in 1898 married Robert Royden Campbell, sergeant in the Tasmanian Police, from Strahan. Minnie died on 12 March 1958 in Elizabeth Frances (1841–1918) Tasmania. Her husband died four years later at the age of 89.35 On 14 March 1871 William married Eliza§ § § beth Francis, who was also from Cornish de- Ellen (Nellie) Brewer, born 1874 in Beechcent and arrived in Melbourne a year earlier on worth.36 Nellie married Edward Potts Palmer, the Caduceus.31 At that time, William lived on born 1863 in Chewton, died 1928 in Clifton the Yackandandah Road and Elizabeth lived Hill, aged 65. Nellie died in 1952 in Pascoe in Beechworth. Elizabeth was born in 1841 Vale, aged 77. in Penryn, on the south side of the Cornwall § § § peninsula. David Brewer, born on 1 May 1876 in WoorShe was the daughter of master mason and agee (Chapter 4 on page 15). contractor John Francis and Mary Roger, a § § § miller at Helland Mill in Mabe. Elizabeth Brewer, born 1878 in Beechworth,37 Elizabeth died aged 77 on 10 October 1918 died 1951 in Royal Park, Melbourne, aged 73. in Wooragee of senility and influenza and was Elizabeth was married to Andy Reeves, a widburied in Beechworth cemetery. She was one ower. of the twelve thousand Australians that suc§ § § cumbed to the Spanish flu pandemic that killed Anna Jane Francis (Janey) Brewer, born 1881 millions around the world.32 in Beechworth,38 deceased aged 72 1953 in William, an old age pensioner by now, died Beechworth. Married to William James Datof heart failure on 26 October 1927 in Bur- son. wood. They had six children. 8 Notes 29 Copy of death certificate from Val Studd, ref. 2340. Ref. 5100. 30 Gee (2000). 1 Wikipedia, River Camel, en.wikipedia.org/ 31 PROV, Index to Unassisted Inward Passenger Lists wiki/River_Camel. to Victoria 1852–1923, fiche 29, p.3. 2 Morton-Raymont (1989). 32 Wikipedia, ‘1918 flu pandemic’, en.wikipedia. 3 Padstow Baptism. 1773–1810, FP170/1/4. org/wiki/1918_flu_pandemic. 4 Bartlett (1996). 33 E-mail Marion Gogoll (May 2001). 5 St Minver Marriages 1813–1837, FP154/1/4, ref. 34 E-mail Marion Gogoll (May 2001). 149. 35 Ibid. 6 CFHS, Monumental Inscriptions index and St Min36 AVR, Rn 21017. ver Burials 18-13-1848, FP154/1/8, #774, card 2. 37 AVR, Rn 550. 7 CFHS, Monumental Inscriptions index, ref: Card 38 AVR, RN 14168. 2. 8 IGI Ba: P002751 So: Q942.37/C2V26B Pr:1145588. 9 CFHS, Monumental Inscriptions index and St Enodoc Church, Card 3. 10 Morton-Raymont (1989), p. 122. 11 Hunt (1997). 12 Cornwall Guide, Padstow, www.cornwalls.co. uk/Padstow. 13 Census returns for St. Minver (1841–1891) Great Britain Census Office, Family History Library, Film 221056; St Minver Baptism 1834–1900, FP154/1/12, ref. 359. 14 Alpine Heritage List, Dianne Carroll. 15 Shennan (1985). 16 Wikipedia, ‘Eureka Stockade’, http: //en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eureka_stockade. 17 Burke Museum Beechworth, Rates book United Shire of Beechworth 1880–81, nrs. 2013; 2312. 18 ‘Obituary’, The Ovens and Murray Advertiser, 18 August 1915. 19 IGI, Reference B 10 Oct 1973 PV E 29 Nov 1973 PV S 17 Jan 1974 PV Batch/Film No C002352 Serial sheet 0840. 20 St Minver Marriages 1837–1912, FP154/1/5, ref. 197. 21 Correspondence with Linda Mackie (1997). PROV, Index to Unassisted Inward Passenger Lists to Victoria 1852–1923 22 AVR, RN 8406. Death certificate no. 488 of 1862. 23 AVR, RN 3456. 24 AVR, RN 1144. 25 AVR, RN 7260. 26 1851 census return as seen on Film 221056 from LDS. 27 AVR, RN 3706. 28 Gee (2000). 9 Chapter 3 William Ellen & Sarah Ann Crack Gold fever in the Victorian hills pair of ancestors that moved from England to Australia were William Ellen and Sarah Ann Crack, whose daughter Rosa-Jane would later marry David Brewer (Chapter 4), the son of William Brewer and Elizabeth Francis, discussed in the previous chapter. Sarah Ann Crack, sometimes referred to as Krapp, was born on 7 March 1847 and christened on 11 July of that year in East Harling, Norfolk. She was the illegitimate child of 21-year old Maria Crack and Thomas Cooke, a local farmer. Her mother Maria Crack was born on 19 July 1826 in East Harling and was the daughter of Thomas Crack and Sarah Garnham (Garman). T HE SECOND Thomas Cooke Charles Godwin Maria Crack Great Hockham.1 They had two children, James and Thomas. James did, however, not survive past his first year.2 On 22 August 1853 the young family — Edward, Maria, six year old Sarah and one year old Thomas — departed from Liverpool on the Australia to seek a better life in the colonies. Little Thomas did not survive the journey as he died in September due to diarrhoea. After a journey of under three months, Edward, Maria and Sarah arrived safely in Melbourne.3 Edmund Jacob Jessup Sarah Ann William Crack Ellen Rosa-Jane Ellen Migrant ancestors of Rosa-Jane Ellen Maria Crack (1826–1889) with child When Sarah Ann was one year old, her mother married on Christmas Eve of 1848 Conditions aboard the ships transporting in East Harling to Edmund Jacob (Edward) immigrants to Australia were very poor with Jessup, an agricultural labourer from nearby families sharing bunks and very limited san10 itation or privacy. It is not surprising that a baby would become sick in these conditions. Thomas was not the only one to die on board of the Australia. In total, eight of the 471 passengers would not survive to see their new home land. Edward’s brother had also moved to Australia with his young family and they suffered the same fate as their one year old son Hester also died of diarrhoea during the voyage.4 The Jessup family were ‘assisted’ British migrants, meaning that their passage was subsidised by the Victorian Government. In the middle of the nineteenth century, more than 18,000 British people migrated with assistance from the government every year.5 Beechworth post office in 1856 (Hyndman 2000) The family shifted to Beechworth prior to 1857. At that time, Beechworth was a thriving gold mining town in the middle of the gold rush that made it famous. The discovery of gold in Beechworth in 1852 inspired thousands of prospectors to swarm from all over the world to try their luck. The area around Spring Creek was dotted with canvas tents and holes in the ground. Hundreds of men washed earth and stones along the creek in search of treasure.6 An early party of prospectors retrieved a pan of gold weighing about seven kilogram. Another lucky group found approximately 25 kilogram of gold in a week.7 The journey from Melbourne to Beechworth took about three weeks. Most people walked all the way, some with a wheelbarrow as the only means to carry their possessions. In 1855 a coach service between Melbourne and Beechworth commenced that reduced the journey down to several days. This mode of transport would have been unaffordable for most people as fares were more than five pounds.8 § § § The Jessup family moved quite frequently around the area as the address varies a lot; Beechworth, One Mile Creek, Bowmans Forest and Murmungee. Edward Jessup, together with some friends, placed a claim on a spot in Kneebone Gully in Spring Creek to mine for gold. They worked this location for half a year and then transferred the claim to another digger.9 By 1870, Sarah had eleven half-brothers and sisters. After a hard life of raising twelve children, Sarah’s mother Maria died on 2 December 1889 in Beechworth at the age of 63 and was buried in Bowmans Forest cemetery.10 Her stepfather Edmund died eight years later in Myrtleford and is also buried in Bowmans Forest cemetery. § § § When Sarah Ann was 16 years old, she married 18 year older Charles George Godwin, in 1863.11 They had three children, Frances, Florence (Florry) and Charles Godwin. The Register of Claims for Beechworth and 11 every night and tell her that is from dada — and you must consider yourself kissed to any extent you choose to fancy”.13 After seven years of marriage and not much luck in gold mining, Charles Godwin died at the age of 41 in September 1870. § § § Three years later, on 6 May 1873, Sarah marries William Ellen, who was also 18 years her senior, in Beechworth.14 At the time of Charles George Godwin (1829–1870) and Sarah their marriage, William was living at Six Mile Creek and Sarah Ann at Bowmans Forest.15 Ann Crack (1847–1933) It seems that Sarah, who grew up without her natural father Thomas Cooke, was looking Silver Creek shows that Charles was busy try- for a father figure as she marries men almost ing to find gold around Beechworth. Between twice her age. 1864 and 1867 he placed eight consecutive claims to different mines in Kneebone Gully and Bowman’s Forest. Charles was not the only one making claim after claim in search of a lucrative mining spot. By 1857 the heyday of gold mining was over and the records show that many miners made several claims in one year.12 Charles abandons his claims in Spring Creek temporarily and moves to Running Creek to try his luck. He is, however, not feeling well and in 1869 writes to his wife that he is worried about their children as several local children had died of diphtheria. The mining campaign was not successful either. They live in tents and move around to imWilliam Ellen (1828–1911) prove their chances of striking gold. The letter, which he writes on a piece of bark placed on It must have been hard for Sarah having a bucket, shows how much Charles misses his been born before her mother was married. In family: the late nineteenth century, so called illegitimate children faced numerous obstacles, in“Tell Florry I have sent twenty cluding violence, poverty, state intervention, kisses but she must give baba one 12 and identity crises.16 The issue of illegitimacy will be further discussed in Chapter 6 on page 25. William Ellen, son of James Ellen and Jane Plumb (Plum), was born on 25 August 1828 in Kent and arrived in Australia in 1853.17 William was a gold miner in the same area as Sarah’s first husband where William Ellen “& Co.” laid claim on three areas in 1865.18 He must have had some success in mining judging by the fact that he owned a property of 130 acres of grass paddock with a house and garden in Murmungee.19 William Ellen and Sarah Ann Crack had six children. § § § Albert Jacob (Beau) Ellen, born on 6 October 1874 and married to Ethel (Et) Ottry. § § § Clara Maria Ellen, born on 13 April 1877. Married to Eugean Thomas (Owen) Farrelly, born on 31 October 1881. Clara Maria died on 12 July 1955 at the age of 78. Owen died five years later on 7 July 1960, also at the age of 78. § § § Edgar (Ed) Ellen, born in 1880. On 13 April 1921 he married 14 year younger Louisa May Kneebone in the Holy Trinity Cathedral in Wangaratta. Louisa was born on 18 May 1894 in Whorouly. Ed died on 7 September 1963 in Wangaratta and is buried in the Wangaratta Cemetery. Louisa died at the ripe old age of 90 in 1984 and is also buried in the Wangaratta cemetery. § § § Rosa-Jane (Rose-Jane, Rosa-Joan) Ellen, born on 12 November 1882 in Murmungee (Chapter 4 on page 15). § § § Daisy Agnes Ellen, born 1887, married 26year old Walter Charles Wells on 2 December 1910. Walter was born on 21 January 1884 and died on 14 August 1966 at the age of 82. Daisy died on 15 November 1978, 91 years old. § § § Last child of Sarah Ann Crack and William Ellen is William Alfred Ellen. William Ellen died in 1911 in Beechworth.20 Sarah spent her last 22 years as a widow and died at the age of 86 on 21 July 1933. § § § Two members of the Ellen family became successful in show business. Joff (Raymond Charles) Ellen (1915–1999), son of Beau Ellen and Ethel Ottry, was a famous vaudeville entertainer and a pioneer of Australian television. He is specially famous for his work with Graham Kennedy and Bert Newton.21 Joff’s nephew Cliff also earned his strides as an actor. He played in the popular Australian TV series Neighbours and in movies such as Crackerjack.22 13 Notes 1 Marriages: East Harling, Norfolk, ref. 107. Crowley, ‘Family tree takes shape’. 3 PROV, VPRS 14 Register of Assisted British Immigrants 1839–1871, p. 218; 291. Thomas is mentioned on the shipping register. 4 Dawn Crowley, ‘Family tree takes shape’. 5 Price (1987) 6 Hyndman (2000). 7 Woods (1985) 8 Harvey (1994). 9 Burke Museum Beechworth, Register of Claims, Spring Creek-Beechworth 1862–1874, no. 244-10 (18 June 1865). 10 Federation Index Vic 1889–1901, ref. 15178. 11 AVR, ref. 3513. 12 Burke Museum Beechworth, Register of Claims 1862–1874, nrs. 249, 292, 225-2, 73-10, 224, 225, 380 and 381. 13 Marie Walker, Letter from Charles Godwin to Sarah Ann Godwin. 14 Marriage Certificate no. 281, ref. 1885. 15 Ibid. 16 Frost (2003) 17 Marriage certificate, RN. 1835 No. 281. E-mail Cliff Ellen. 18 Burke Museum Beechworth, Register of Claims, nrs 79-12, 101-2 and 192-11. 19 Burke Museum Beechworth, Rate book 1880–81, United Shire of Beechworth. 20 Digger Edwardian Index Vic 1902–1913, reference number: 328. 21 Robert Fidgeon (1999), ‘TV Comic great Joffa Boy dies’, The Herald Sun 31 December 1999. 22 Internet Movie Database, www.imdb.com/name/ nm0253979. 2 Dawn 14 Chapter 4 David Brewer & Rosa-Jane Ellen How an accident with an axe destroys a family B REWER, the second son of William Brewer and Elizabeth Francis (Chapter 2), was born on 1 May 1876 in Wooragee. Woorajay is the Aboriginal name for a peppermint tree. The name was used by Europeans to name the cattle run that was first established there. Wooragee was first surveyed during the Gold Rush in 1856 and was a mining village in the Beechworth district.1 From the records it seems that David had a lot of occupations, he is mentioned as a labourer, woodcutter and a shearer, moving around the district.2 On 12 October 1904 he marries 21 year old Rosa-Jane (Rose-Jane, Rosa-Joan) Ellen in Murmungee. Rosa-Jane (Rose-Jane, Rosa-Joan) was born on 12 November 1882 in Murmungee.3 She was the daughter of William Ellen and Sarah Ann Crack (Chapter 3). By this time the Gold Rush was definitely over and people moved from mining gold to a more agricultural life. Gold mining around the Murmungee reef continued until the late 1930s, mainly by industrial methods such as sluicing, which is the excavation of alluvial deposits through high pressure water jets. David and Rosa-Jane had eight children. Their children’s lives were defined by the Second World War. Two of their sons, Bill and D AVID David Brewer (1876–1930) Vince, were captured respectively by the German and Japanese army and spent considerable time as Prisoners of War. § § § Edna Rosalie Brewer was born on 20 June 1905 in Murmungee. Edna left school at the age of 14 to do domestic work, taking care of a house for a doctor. On 16 June 1923, at the age of 17 she married Tom Goodyer, born in Tasmania. Tom was offered an engineering job on the construction of the Sydney Harbour Bridge, but instead he chose to work in South Africa, presumably as a mining-engineer. While in South Africa, Edna began a rela- 15 tionship with her chauffeur and left her husband. After his wife left him, Tom moved to England with their only son. When Edna had spent all her money, the chauffeur left her destitute and she headed to England to join her son. After Edna arrived in England, Tom headed back to Australia and never saw his son again. Edna died on 29 January 2000 in England at the age of 94. § § § Mabel Isabel Brewer was born on 9 July 1906 in Murmungee and worked as a domestic help in Eldorado and Wangaratta and worked at the Woollen Mills. Mabel was heavily involved in the Country Women’s Association and enjoyed cooking and crafts. She married William Henry (Bill) Bussell, a stonemason and had two children.4 As a stonemason he mainly produced headstones, which made their back yard look like a cemetery. Bill died on 4 July 1978 in Wangaratta Hospital and was interred at the Wangaratta Cemetery. Mabel died of bowel cancer on 7 May 1992 in Wangaratta Hospital at the age of 85. § § § Daisy Francis Ellen Brewer, born on 12 April 1908 in Murmungee. Married about 1930 in Carlton to John (Jack) Bloor Dent, born on 6 November 1903 in Western Australia.5 Two years after their wedding they moved to Eldorado with their first son. Their second son was born in Eldorado. Jack served as a sapper in World War two in New Guinea and after the war Jack worked in a gold mine.6 He died on Remembrance Day in 1985 at the age of 82 and was buried in Eldorado Cemetery. Daisy died after a fall in a nursing home on 11 September 2004 in Wangaratta at the age of 96.7 Rosa-Jane Ellen (1882–1957) David Vincent (Vince) Godwin Brewer was born on 23 April 1910 in Lower Buckland at the base of Mount Buffalo. Vince was working as a labourer in Queensland when he enlisted in the Australian army at Toowoomba on 7 July 1940. After a three day trip from Darwin the Australian battalion group known as ‘Gull Force’ arrived in Ambon on 17 December 1941 in order to assist the Dutch troops in staving off the Japanese. During the Japanese attack he was wounded by shrapnel in his back and buttock. He was eventually captured and spent the rest of the war as a prisoner, enduring the bad treatment of the Japanese.8 After he repatriated to Australia Vince married Alma Maud Gribble in 25 August 1948 in Wangaratta. They moved to Eldorado where Vince worked as a machinist on the dredge. Vince died on 26 October 1975 of a bronchial pneumonia in the Wangaratta Hospital at the age of 65.9 16 When Rosa-Jane was pregnant with their fifth child, the family moved from the Buckland Valley to Eldorado. Eldorado was named by Captain William Baker, a Royal Navy man from Nova Scotia who arrived in Sydney in 1837. Captain Baker moved to the Ovens District in 1840 and settled on a run and successfully applied for the name of his run to be Eldorado.10 The name Eldorado relates to a fictitious country in South America, believed to be abundant of gold. However, the precious metal was not discovered in the region until 1852, so it would seem that Captain Baker predicted the Gold Rush, or maybe he found some nuggets and never made it public knowledge. By the time the Brewer family moved to Eldorado, it was a waning mining town that had seen its peak decades earlier. In the days the Brewers came to Eldorado, Cocks Pioneer was still operating on a large scale, five kilometres west of the township. David Brewer worked at the Cocks Pioneer mine for quite a long time.11 From 1928 onwards, gold mining slowly came to a halt. The large mines in Eldorado closed and only some small companies, working on the Reids and Clear Creeks or treating the Cocks Pioneer mine dumps, and a number of visiting fossickers, victims of the depression, remained in the once bustling mining town.12 § § § William Norman (Bill) Brewer was born in Eldorado on 25 March 1916 and started at Eldorado Primary School in February 1921. At the end of school he worked as a shop assistant for John Colin Angus, a local painter. He migrated to New Zealand and during World War II served in the New Zealand army as a Lieutenant. Bill was held captive as a prisoner of war in Italy and Germany. He was treated much better than his brother Vince. Bill received parcels and mail from Australia. After the war he owned a florist business in Upper Hutt on the South Island. Bill married Beryl Albina Rhind, born on 10 June 1922 in Liverpool. Her father was a Gordon Highlander from Edinburgh and Aberdeen and her mother was English and French, whose parents were the first French furriers to set up in Bold St in Liverpool. They adopted two children. Bill died of cancer on 18 February 1990 in New Zealand. § § § Unus Adala (Uni) Brewer was born on 19 December 1919 in Wangaratta. She married John Edward (Jack) Walker, born on 9 February 1911. They had five children. Unus served in the army and was a municipal councillor. Jack died of cancer on 3 June 1984 at the age of 73 and was interred in the Wangaratta cemetery. § § § Thelma Sarah Doris Brewer, born on 6 May 1922 in Wangaratta. In May 1935 she became very ill and stopped attending school. Only 13 years old, Thelma died of meningitis on 20 June 1935 in the Alfred Hospital.13 Thelma was buried on 21 June 1935 in the Eldorado cemetery. The headstone mistakenly records 1936 as the year of her death. § § § The last child from this family, John Bernard (Jack) Brewer, was born on 10 March 1924 in Wangaratta Hospital. He was a cook in the Army and travelled around the country cooking for shearers and in pubs. At the age of 19, Jack was in the navy and was stationed at a top secret American air base in the Pilbra region. 17 He married Dulcie Eileen Hosking and they had three children. At one stage the family ran the Port Albert pub, in Gippsland. The family also owned racehorses, most well known of these being Oscar’s Luck. Jack died on 30 November 2006 at the age of 82. Jack was buried in the Toora cemetery and the family threw scones into the grave instead of flowers because Jack was famous for making scones. Angus in his store. To supplement their income Rosa-Jane took in three boarders and to accommodate them in the house young Jack and his nephew Bob (Edna’s son) were moved into a tent in the back yard. Jack and Bob were of similar age and grew up like brothers rather than uncle and nephew. Bob was left with his grandmother, as his parents were in South Africa, till he was fourteen. Bob’s mother also sent money for Bob’s upkeep. Rosa-Jane also cooked a hot midday meal for other miners, as well as the boarders, to keep the family financially afloat.15 After a hard life of raising a family by herself, Rosa-Jane died on 5 August 1957 in Wangaratta Hospital at the age of 74 and was buried in Wangaratta cemetery. The Brewer family: Rosa-Jane, David, Edna, Thelma, Jack, Unus and Bobby Goodyer David died from tetanus on 28 March 1930 in Wangaratta after sustaining a leg wound from his axe when cutting wood in the bush.14 He developed tetanus and could have been saved if his leg had been amputated, but he refused and trusted his own ‘self medication’, trying to kill the germs through alcohol, over the doctor’s advice. He subsequently lost his life and was buried in Wangaratta Cemetery. After David Brewer died, Rosa-Jane was left with three young children to support and no income. To bring in some money, fourteen year old Bill left school and was given a job by Colin 18 Notes 1 ‘Wooragee area is one that is rich in history’, The Ovens and Murray Advertiser, 19 October 1988. 2 Buchan (2001), p. 108 3 Extract of Birth Entry - no. 32364, Birth certificate, ref.: 20917/82 4 Buchan (2001), p. 108. 5 Tuohy (2004). 6 Buchan (2001), p. 109. 7 Tuohy (2004). 8 Thelma Woods, Vince’s war. 9 Death Certificate, ref. 25067/75. 10 Eldorado remembers. 11 Buchan (2001). 12 Eldorado remembers. 13 Death Certificate and School Records. 14 Buchan (2001). Victorian Death Index 1921–1985, Monumental Inscription, ref. 3509. 15 Anecdote by Jack Brewer. 19 Chapter 5 William Henry Gribble & Mary Teresa Grenville Cornish mining family looking for a new horizon in this chapter originates from the south western tip of Cornwall, which was one of the cenHE G RIBBLE SIDE OF THE FAMILY were tres of mining activity. Cornish miners, moving to Australia after the mining industry went into decline. For Thomas Elizabeth thousands of years Cornwall was a thriving Nankervis Ellis mining area, predominantly tin and copper. Thomas Elizabeth In the early years of the nineteenth century Elijah Hughes Eliza Jane Maria there was plenty of work for copper miners in Gribble Nankervis Grenville Player Cornwall, but by about 1840 the copper lodes were being worked out and output declined William Henry Mary Theresa dramatically, followed by unemployment and Gribble Grenville crippling poverty. Many miners from Cornwall turned their atGeorge Albert Gribble tention to California and Australia, where gold was discovered around 1850.1 Between 1861 Migrant ancestors of George Albert Gribble. and 1901 an estimated quarter of a million Cornish people, or ‘Cousin Jacks’ as they were William Henry Gribble was the son of Eliknown, migrated to various parts of the world jah Gribble and Eliza Jane Nankervis, who in search of a better life. This mass migration both migrated to Australia around the same is known as the Cornish Diaspora in which time as the Brewer part of the family. miners made up most of the numbers. There § § § is a well known saying in Cornwall: Elijah Gribble was born on 18 December 1837 in Creegbrawse, a small hamlet and busy min“A mine is a hole anywhere in ing area in Cornwall, and was the son of the world with at least one Cornish 2 William Gribble (1812–1876) and Elizabeth man at the bottom of it!” Harvey (1814–1889).4 Elijah had fourteen brothers and sisters of The Gribble family name is commonly found in mid and west Cornwall and is derived which six did not live past the age of thirty, five from cryb-a-bell, Cornish for ‘distant ridge’,3 of which did not even get past fifteen. Only which could be a reference to this family’s six of them lived beyond the age of sixty and mining background. The Gribbles described Elijah was the oldest of the family. T 20 Between 1845 and 1862 Elijah lost six siblings to typhus, a common disease in poverty stricken areas. After Elijah’s baby brother and sister both died of typhus in 1858, he decided to move to Australia.5 The Gribble family is a good example of the Cornish diaspora. His sister Elizabeth (1842–1920) and his brother Cyrus (1844– 1888) moved to the United States. Elijah’s brother Tobias (1846–1891) tried his luck in Peru where he died, supposedly killed by Indians.6 His brother Albert (1851–1883) ended up in Cape Town. According to family lore, he even became the mayor of that beautiful city.7 Elijah’s thirteen year younger brother Edwin Gribble, was born on 1 December 1850 in Creegbrawse. After he married Mary Jane Davey in 1872, they moved to Australia, where Mary died on 24 July 1922 in Wandiligong. Edwin died on 16 July 1925 in North Fitzroy at the age of 74. When 21 year old Elijah arrived in Australia on the Florence Nightingale, he had only half a red blanket and 2 shillings and 6 pence in his pocket.8 Elijah moved to Beechworth, which at that time was a thriving gold mining city. The register of mining claims for Spring Creek lists a claim by Elijah and William Bowen in Madman’s Gully, No. 1 North Rose Reef.9 Some years later, on 16 April 1863, Elijah married the 16 years old Eliza Jane Nankervis in Beechworth. § § § Eliza was born on 15 April 1847 in Botallack, Saint Just in Cornwall. She was the daughter of Thomas Nankervis and Elizabeth Ellis and the second youngest of nine children. Thomas Nankervis was born in Saint Just 22 January 1809.10 Thomas was the youngest of seven children of John Nankervis and Eliz- abeth Eddy, both from Saint Just. Nankervis is a typical Cornish name and comes from nanskervys, which is Cornish for ‘valley of stags’ or deer.11 Thomas Nankervis was a ‘mine captain’ and married on 10 July 1830 in Saint Just to Elizabeth Ellis, born on 25 June 1809 in that town. The name Ellis is the genitive form of the personal name Elli and thus means ‘children of Eli’.12 From this marriage ten children were born, of which nine survived into adulthood. In 1857, the family moved to Australia and arrived in Melbourne on the Red Jacket. Only the five youngest children, John (1839), William (1841), Grace (1844). Eliza Jane (1844) and Mary Ann (1850), joined them and the four oldest children presumably remained in England.13 Thomas Nankervis died on 16 August 1866 in Beechworth at the relatively young age of 57. Elizabeth Ellis died a year later on 13 January 1867 in Beechworth. § § § Elijah and Eliza had eleven children. Their first child, Elizabeth Jane, was born just over nine months after their wedding in Spring Creek. Their last child, Charles Alfred Cyrus, was born in 1891 in Wandiligong. The Gribbles where a religious family. Elijah was a Sunday School teacher and they financially supported the construction of the Methodist church in Wandiligong.14 When the Lunatic Asylum in Beechworth was being built, the Government purchased land from both Elijah Gribble, who received £17.0.0, and Thomas Nankervis, Eliza’s father, who received £80.0.0 for his land.15 Elijah tried his luck at mining gold around Beechworth and in 1862 he placed a claim together with William Bowen for Rose Reef in Madman’s Gully. Three years later “Elijah 21 Gribble & Co” claim another area in Spring Creek.16 His most successful mine was one near the Home Reef, which he and his family mined for over twenty years.17 He retired around 1898 and in 1916 they moved to Bright where they lived on one property and rented out another. After sixty years of marriage, Eliza Jane Nankervis died on 13 August 1923 in Wandiligong at the age of 76.18 Elijah died only three months later, on 12 October 1923 in Bright at the age of 85.19 § § § William Henry Gribble was born on 13 August 1866 in Growlers Creek.20 The name Growlers Creek does not exist anymore because in 1875 the Bright council decided that the locations known as Morses Creek and Growlers Creek from Dougherty’s Bridge southwards be called Wandiligong.21 William opened the Juvenile gold mine near home reef in Wandiligong. Mining would eventually cause his death as he died of miner’s phthisis, caused by accumulation of dust in the lungs, in 1923 at the age of 56.22 William Henry married on 13 August 1890 in Wandiligong to the 20 years old Mary Theresa Grenville. She was born on 29 June 1870 in Growlers Creek and was the daughter of Thomas Hughes Grenville and Elizabeth Mary Player. § § § Thomas Grenville was a butcher, born about 1833 in Brighton in England and was the son of Isaac Grenville and Rebecca Moore. Elizabeth Player was christened on 13 August 1837 in St Martin in the Fields, Westminster and was the daughter of George Player and Jane Rebecca Bowman. Thomas and Elizabeth married on 9 July 1857 in Mr Sutherland’s Restaurant in Nine William Henry Gribble, Mary Theresa Grenville and children Mile.23 They had a dozen children. Thomas died after a nine month illness on 4 July 1909 in Wandiligong.24 Elizabeth died some years later in 1915 in Wangaratta.25 § § § William Henry Gribble and Mary Teresa Grenville had seven children. Their first son, William Henry Elijah Gribble was born on 16 June 1891. In 1915 he was called to arms and joined the 22nd Infantry Battalion and embarked on the HMS Ulysses to Europe.26 William survived the war and married soon after he was repatriated to Australia. At the 22 age of 27 he married Emily Gertrude Pope, born on 22 October 1892, with whom he had three boys. William died on 6 January 1956 in Heidelberg at the age of 64. His wife Emily died twenty years later on 15 July 1976 in Richmond at the age of 83. § § § Joseph (Joe) Frederick Gribble was born on 4 November 1893. Although he had previously been rejected as unfit for service on account of his teeth, he was later approved and dispatched to join the Mediterranean Expeditionary Force in Gallipoli. He was then sent to Egypt for a few months and moved on to the Western Front, where he took part in a raid on German trenches. Joseph was only 23 years old when he was killed in action on 30 June 1916 and buried in Ration Farm Cemetery near Bois Grenier.27 Stanley Thomas Gribble was born on 29 October 1895 in Wandiligong. Also Stanley went overseas to fight in the Great War with his two older brothers and his cousin. It seems that he found love while in Europe as he married on 29 March 1919 in Cornwall to local girl Doris Gwendoline Simmons. Stanley and Doris moved to Australia and had four children. Stanley died on 4 August 1979 in Wandiligong at the age of 83. Doris died nine years later on 18 March 1988 in Wandiligong at the age of 90. § § § George Albert Gribble, born on 12 December 1897 in Wandiligong (Chapter 7). § § § Minnie Clemence Gribble, born on 21 October 1900. Married in 1925 to Charles Edward Gray (Cyril George Gray), with whom she had a boy and a girl. Minnie died on 29 June 1945 at the age of 44. § § § Robert Hughes Gribble, born on 31 May 1905. He married on 12 April 1839 in Wangaratta to Myrtle Gertrude Mull, born on 5 February 1905. They had three children. Robert died on 2 November 1970 in Bright at the age of 65. His wife died on 19 June 1997 in Bright at the respectable age of 92. § § § Victor Clyde Gribble, born on 23 April 1907. He was married to Willemmenia Ruth (Irene) Higgins, born 1912, and they had one child. Victor died on 21 July 1965 in Melbourne at Joseph Frederick Gribble (1897–1916) the age of 58. Willemmenia lived for another The news of his death shocked the town as 22 years as a widow and died on 30 August the flags at the Wandiligong school and Shire 1987. office were flown half mast.28 § § § 23 Notes Mining in Cornwall, en.wikipedia. org/wiki/Mining_in_Cornwall. 2 Wikipedia, Cornish diaspora, en.wikipedia. org/wiki/Cornish_diaspora. BBC, I am alright Jack!, www.bbc.co.uk/legacies/immig_emig/ england/cornwall/article_1.shtml. 3 White (1984), p.32. 4 Correspondence Margaret Owens and Marilyn Mapstone. 5 Lloyd & Nunn (1987). 6 Correspondence Margaret Owens and Marilyn Mapstone. 7 Ibidem. 8 Ibidem. 9 Shennan (1985). 10 IGI - FN. 203 4594. 11 White (1984), p.42; Hopkins (1988). 12 White (1984), p.28. 13 PROV, Unassisted Inward Passenger Lists for British, Foreign and New Zealand Ports 1852–1923, Port B, Fiche 125, p. 4. 14 Bennett (1988). 15 Marilyn Mapstone and Margaret Owens. 16 Burke Museum Beechworth, Register of Claims Spring Creek-Beechworth 1862–1874, nrs. 66 and 2161. 17 Margaret Owens. 18 Margaret Owens, Death Index Vic 1921–1985, ref. 12916. 19 Ibid. 20 Margaret Owens. 21 Bennett (1988). 22 Margaret Owens. Death Index Vic 1921–1985, ref. 12915 23 AVR, Marriage certificate., reference number: 3097. 24 Digger Edwardian Index Vic 1902–1913, Death certificate, ref. 10740. 25 Digger Great War Index Vic 1914–1920, ref. 3335. 26 Australian War Memorial, First World War Embarkation Roll, www.awm.gov.au. 27 National Archives of Australia, World War I Personnel Records. 28 Bennett (1988). 1 Wikipedia, 24 Chapter 6 Ellen Higgins The pressures of family shame and taboo has no English roots. Ellen Higgins’ grandparents migrated to Australia from Ireland and Scotland before the first discovery of gold, a time when Australia’s economy was based on sheep grazing. This is a controversial time in Australian history. With the dispossession of aboriginal tribes from their lands through the establishment of sheep runs, conflict between natives and squatters over resources and land use inevitably occurred. T HIS BRANCH OF THE FAMILY John Higgins Tryphena Parker John Strachan William Thomas Higgins Unknown Elizabeth Harkness Mary Strachan Ellen Higgins Elizabeth Higgins Migrant ancestors of Elizabeth Higgins John Higgins was a miner, born in Dublin around 1803. John Higgins was the son of cobbler James Higgins and Anne Wilde. Ireland was not an independent country, between 1801 and 1912 it formed part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. The nineteenth century was a difficult time for the Irish. They struggled for independence and battled great adversity and poverty. There were also times of great prosperity, specially during the Napoleonic Wars, which occurred when John Higgins was a boy.1 It is not known when John arrived in Australia, but given that his first son was born in 1842, he must have left his native Ireland before the infamous Potato Famine. In 1842, William married Tryphena (Triphena) Parker (Perkins, Harker), who was four months pregnant. Tryphena was born on 11 April 1827 in Hastings.2 She was the daughter of John Wesley Parker, a clergyman, and Hannah Ransom. John and Tryphena had fifteen children, of which only ten survived. The first six were born in New South Wales. During the Victorian Gold Rush, the family moves to Beechworth and later to Indigo and Chiltern, where they have a further four children.3 John Higgins died on 12 May 1869 in Oven’s District Hospital in Beechworth.4 Tryphena died on 16 August 1898 in Rutherglen at the age of 71.5 § § § William Thomas Higgins, the oldest of John and Tryphena’s ten children, was born on 27 July 1842 in the district of Monaro (Maneroo) in New South Wales, between Canberra and the Victorian border. The original inhabitants 25 of this area were the Ngarigo and ‘maneroo’ is the local aboriginal word for ‘plains’.6 When Thomas was born, his parents lived in Gejizrick, which was a squatting run in Monaro. It is the local Ngarigo word for ‘look out’. Aboriginals existed in great numbers in the Manaro region and they were, according to the settlers, peaceful. It was not unusual to see five hundred of them at one time.7 The Monaro people eventually died from diseases introduced by settlers, such as small pox, syphilis, influenza, measles and tuberculosis. The European occupation meant that some Aboriginal people were forced away from their traditional lands as they lost their traditional hunting grounds.8 William Thomas Higgins married Mary Strachan, a servant and daughter of John Strachan, a cattle dealer and carpenter, and Elizabeth Harkness, on 14 October 1867 in Beechworth.9 § § § John Strachan and Elizabeth Harkness (Harkins) married around 1840 in Scotland.10 Elizabeth was born around 1816 in Dumfries, a Scottish market town near the mouth of the River Nith. The name of the town is derived from the Scottish Gaelic, Dùn Phris which translates as ‘Fort of the Thicket’.11 Not long after their marriage they moved to Australia. Poverty, famine and epidemics in Scotland caused the first significant Scottish emigration to Australia. Victoria was the most popular colony in which to settle. Scottish squatters and rural workers established farms in the times before gold was discovered in Victoria.12 John Strachan and Elizabeth Harkness had five children and Mary Strachan was born around 1850 in Black Dog Creek near Chiltern. This area was part of the Wahgunyah cattle run, which was leased by John Ford and John Crisp in 1841. Elizabeth Harkness died on 15 May 1881 in Wooragee, aged 65 and was buried in Beechworth.13 William Thomas Higgins and Mary Strachan William Higgins and Mary Strachan had a dozen children, among which was Ellen Higgins. It seems that William was a tenacious man, as judged by a story told in the family. Because he had a disagreement with the local parish priest William decided to have all further children christened in different faiths. Ellen’s sister Lilian Christina Higgins married William Joseph Bentley and had, just like her parents, twelve children and only one of them was a girl. The girl died in infancy. All eleven boys went to war to fight against the Japanese and the Germans. Through great fortitude, all of Lilian’s sons returned to Australia. Mary was illiterate as evidenced by the cross by which she signed her marriage certificate. She died on 9 March 1917 in Oven’s 26 District Hospital, Beechworth and was buried at Stanley Cemetery.14 William Thomas remarried in Melbourne at the ripe age of eighty in 1919 to Louisa Annie Moreland and died five years later in Porepunkah.15 Ellen (Nelly) Higgins (Eggins) was born on 18 December 1873 in South Wooragee near Yackandandah.16 With Ellen Higgins we come to a dead end in the family history as the father(s) of her first three children are not known. Ellen Higgins (1873–1942) When Ellen was 20 she gave birth to Elsie Higgins, who died after eight days of diarrhoea, only two months old. Five years later, Ellen gave birth to a second illegitimate child, Elizabeth Higgins, born in 21 June 1899 (Chapter 7). Elizabeth lived with her grandparents and was brought up to believe that they were her parents. Elizabeth’s birth certificate, which was registered by Ellen’s sister Alice, does not state the name of Elizabeth’s father.17 Further confirmation of William Thomas Higgins and Mary Strachan not being Elizabeth’s parents can be found on the death certificate of Mary Strachan where Elizabeth is not listed as one of the children. Ellen also gave birth to a third illegitimate daughter called Rose Higgins, who died of malnutrition on 21 July 1902 in Stanley after a short life of only seven weeks. Ellen was most likely in Melbourne when Rose died, which indicates that her parents were also raising her. Rose was buried two days after her death by her grandfather William Higgins and on that same day, Ellen married in Melbourne to bricklayer William James Moore, with whom she had a further five children of which two died at a young age.18 The first of these five children was born nine years after they got married, when Ellen was already 37 years old. Ellen’s extra marital children are not the only in the family. Ellen’s oldest sister Mary Ann gave birth to Emily in 1887 who was born one year before she got married to John Kendall. § § § In nineteenth century Australia, about three percent of births were out of wedlock. In only one in ten cases of children born outside of marriage in the nineteenth century the father is known. In more than half of those cases the father is the boyfriend or fiancé of the mother. Married men, male relatives, employers, strangers and acquaintances are listed as other possible identities.19 Attitudes towards extra marital children has changed considerably over the past decades as terms such as ‘illegitimate’ or ‘bastard’ are no longer used to denote children that are born from unmarried parents. In Ellen’s days, children without a known father were placed in the same category as 27 beggars, thieves and prostitutes.20 These rigid moral codes caused a lot of heartbreak and in some cases mothers even let their children die because of the strain placed on them being unmarried mothers.21 Could this have been the case with Ellen’s first and third child? After their marriage, Ellen and William had five daughters: Nellie, Ellen, Dorothy, Daisy and Mary. The oldest and youngest girls died when they were still children. Ellen Higgins died on 13 August 1942 in Cowra at the age of 68.22 With Daisy we come to another interesting aspect in family history. Daisy married Henry Bentley, who was the son of Edward Bentley and Laura Higgins. Laura was a sister of Ellen and Henry and Daisy were thus first cousins. William Thomas Higgins William Moore Ellen Higgins Daisy Moore Mary Strachan Laura Higgins Edward Bentley Henry Bentley First cousins marrying The marriage of two cousins is in most cultures considered a taboo. Cousin marriages are often highly stigmatised today, but marriages between first and second cousins nevertheless account for over ten percent of marriages worldwide.23 Daisy and Edward were in good company as also many of the influential people in history, such as Albert Einstein, Charles Darwin and Edgar Allen Poe, married their cousin.24 28 Notes Ireland 1801–1923, en.wikipedia. org/wiki/Ireland_1801-1922. 2 Baptism records LDS film, 825419, Hastings, Sussex, England, ref. no. 106 3 Australian Vital Records. 4 Pioneer Index Vic 1936–1988, Death certificate, ref.: 3434 5 Federation Index Vic 1889–1901, Death Certificate, ref. 13857. 6 Cooma-Monaro Shire Council, Culture Map, www. cooma.nsw.gov.au/culturalmap/. 7 Monaro Pioneers, www.monaropioneers.com. 8 Cooma-Monaro Shire Council, Culture Map, www. cooma.nsw.gov.au/culturalmap/. 9 Marriage Certificate, ref. 4077. 10 Death Certificate Elizabeth Strachan. 11 Wikipedia, Dumfires, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Dumfries. 12 Museum Victoria, History of immigration from Scotland, museumvictoria.com.au/origins/ history.aspx?pid=52. 13 Pioneer Index Vic 1936–1988, Death Certificate, ref. 3541. 14 Digger-Great War Index Vic 1914–1920, Death certificate, ref. 308. 15 Digger-Great War Index Victoria 1940–1920, ref. 5667. Online Registry of Births Death and Marriages. 16 AVR, Birth certificate, ref. 28071. 17 Registry of Births, Deaths and Marriages, ref. 13826. 18 Birth certificate of Dorothy May Moore. 19 Swain (2005). 20 Davis (1939). 21 Swain (2005). 22 Letter from Joan Scott 23 Sarah Kershaw, ‘Shaking Off the Shame’, New York Times, 25 November 2009. 24 Wikipedia, Cousin mariage, en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Cousin_marriage. 1 Wikipedia, 29 Chapter 7 George Albert Gribble & Elizabeth Higgins The tragedies of war years. He worked there from the start to the completion of the weir. EORGE A LBERT G RIBBLE , labourer, Elizabeth Higgins died on 2 August 1970 in born on 12 December 1897 in Wangaratta at the age of 71,6 buried in EldoWandiligong.1 Son of William Henry rado Cemetery, Victoria. Gribble and Mary Teresa Grenville (Chapter 5). Died on 5 September 1967 in Wangaratta, Victoria, Australia at the age of 69,2 buried in Eldorado Cemetery. Church marriage at the age of 21 on 23 July 1919 in Bright (Methodist).3 to the 20 year old Elizabeth Higgins, born on 21 June 1899 in Stanley (Chapter 6). George worked in a variety of jobs over the years and they moved quite a bit: Porepunkah, Bright, Cowra, Woodstock, Wyangala, Albury and Wodonga, before settling in Eldorado.4 The family were living in Wodonga at one stage and George got a job in Bright working on the pine plantation. He rode his bicycle to Elizabeth Higgins (1899–1970) and George GribBright every Sunday night and back again ev- ble (1897–1967) ery Friday night to Wodonga. On the weekends he chopped enough wood to last the week From this marriage seven children were and caught up on other jobs before heading off 5 again. Eventually they moved back to Bright. born. This is quite an amazing feat of endurance, his § § § bicycle would not have been state of the art George Frederick Gribble was born on 21 with gears and the roads would not have been September 1920 in Bright. His mother was as good as today. The distance from Bright extremely ill after George’s birth and spent a to Wodonga is almost one hundred kilometres, long time in hospital. She was not recovering and eventually her mother in law, Mary with a lot of uphill grade. George Albert worked at Wyangala on the Grenville from Wandiligong, took her home construction of the Wyangala Dam for six and cared for her. The story goes that if she G 30 Elizabeth Higgins, George Albert Gribble, Muriel, George, Alma, Keith and Eva at Wyangla Dam had stayed in the hospital she may not have survived.7 He was a labourer, but when Australia joined the action in the second World War, George joined the army and was dispatched to New Guinea.8 He was a private in the infantry and went absent without leave. He was found out and sent back to the front where he was killed in action on 15 December 1943 and buried in Lae War Cemetery in New Guinea.9 § § § Alma Maud Gribble was born in Bright three and a half years after George. The family was living at that stage with Keziah (Kizzy) Higgins,10 Ellen Higgin’s sister, in Porepunkah. Elizabeth thought that Kizzy was her sister, but it was in fact her aunt as she was brought up to believe that her grandmother was in fact her mother as described in the previous chapter. § § § Muriel Theresa (Mooie) Gribble, born in 1926. Married to Donald David (Dave) Matheson, born on 29 April 1916. She left Eldorado for a short time from 1 June 1936 to stay with relatives when her younger sister, Betty, was born. In all, Mooie and Donald had eight children. Dave died on 4 March 1997 at the age of 80. § § § Keith William Gribble was born on 13 April 1928. Keith left school for a short time in 1937, to stay with relatives when his younger sister Betty was born. Keith finished school at the age of 14 and started work as a messenger and delivery boy in the store of local artist Colin Angus. Keith married at the age of 24 on 6 December 1952 in Albany, Western Australia, to Mabel (Mae) Shan-Hun, 28 years old. They had five children. He worked as a barman for around twenty years, then as a driver for Canny’s Carriers and worked on roadworks for the Country Roads Board (CRB) until his retirement. Keith and Mae’s marriage ended in divorce. Keith died on 24 October 1998 in Boonah, Queensland at the age of 70, buried there. Mae Shan-Hun died on 3 December 2007 in Wangaratta at the age of 83. § § § Eva Victoria Gribble was a tram conductress in Melbourne, born on 14 April 1930 in Wyangala Dam, New South Wales. She married truck driver Leonard Merrifield, born on 21 August 1929, with whom she had two chil- 31 dren. Notes When her sister Betty was born, Eva spent 1 Federation Index Vic 1889–1901, reference numnearly two months staying with relatives in ber: 7170. Porepunkah. 2 Death Index Vic 1921–1985, ref. 20129. 3 Certificate of Marriage, reference number: No. 7. Eva and her brother in law Arthur Williams 4 Thelma Woods. died from smoke inhalation during a house fire 5 Alma Gribble. in December 1978 in Moyhu, Victoria. Eva 6 MI, Death Index Vic 1921–1985, ref.: 18194. is buried in the Eldorado Cemetery. Leonard 7 Thelma Woods. died on 11 April 1985 in Sydney at the age of 8 Number V124255, ACME 22BN. 9 Australian 55. Died from a massive heart attack. War Cemeteries, www. australiancemeteries.com/war/lae_g.htm , § § § 1A.A.12. Betty June Gribble was born on 7 June 1937 Ref. 10 Thelma Woods. and was a shop assistant. She married Arthur 11 Thelma Woods. Williams, a transport driver, who died in the above mentioned house fire. They had three children. Betty died on 7 October 1995 in Wangaratta Hospital at the age of 58 from cancer and was buried in Hyem cemetery, near King Valley. § § § George and Elizabeth were avid Euchre players and one of their social activities was regular Euchre parties at friend’s homes. They used to play at the Eldorado school and at the dances Euchre was always played in the supper room while the dances were on. One time when it was George and Elizabeth’s turn to host the euchre party, Elizabeth attempted to make a sponge, despite not being renowned as a good cook by any means. She ended up in tears and the sponge ended up buried in the back yard. George saved the day by baking another, successful, sponge and being a real gentleman allowed Gran to be given the praise.11 32 Chapter 8 Eldorado In this story we have followed the lives of William Brewer, Elizabeth Francis, Maria Crack, Thomas Nankervis, Elizabeth Ellis, Thomas Grenville, Elizabeth Player, John Higgins, Tryphena Parker, John Strachan and Elizabeth Harkness. They came from all over the United Kingdom and congregated around Beechworth, lured by the stories of huge gold discoveries. The journey of the Brewer-Gribble ancestors ends when Alma Gribble and Vince Brewer get married in 1947 and started their own family. It is a nice coincidence that a family that came into existence because a group of people was seeking for gold found their home in a town that is named after the mythological city of El Dorado. Vince worked as a machinist on the dredge until it closed down in 1954 after twenty years of service. The hulk of the dredge now lies in its final resting place on the outskirts of Eldorado, surrounded by a beautiful water hole. The dredge hole plays a pivotal role in the stories told by Alma and Vince’s children as they spent their summers swimming in the lake and jumping off the hull of this relic of Eldorado’s golden age. Over the past half century the family has grown steadily, although the families are not as large as in the past. There are children, grandchildren and great grandchildren. The family is no longer concentrated around Beechworth, but has spread its wings all over Australia. This book has been written for their current and future descendants. Vince Brewer and Alma Gribble in 1947 The stories in this book are only scratching the surface of the available information still waiting in archives in England, Scotland, Ireland and Australia. What this succinct book shows is that life was most certainly a lot harder in the nineteenth and early twentieth century. Poverty, disease, social taboos, war and hard labour in search of gold or working the land were part of the daily life of the people in this book. The hard lives of these people put our own fortunate circumstances in perspective and helps to answer the question posed at the start of this book, which is the question that underpins every family history: “Who am I?”. 33 The Brewer-Gribble family in 2004. From left to right: Peter Woods, Thelma Woods, Ann Mullan, Steve Wackrow, Noreen Wackrow, Noel Gribble, Judy Laywood, Joan Gribble, Sue Brewer-Prevos, Peter Prevos, Dean Threadgold, Bobby Brewer, Norman Brewer, Shane Mullan, Joanne Mullan, Jayde Gebbie-Mullan, Tanya Mullan, Chloe Threadgold, Kelly Mullan, Zack Threadgold, Shane Mullan, Jaydn Brewer, Karin Woods, Jasmin Woods, Helen Drury, Beth Drury, Luke Brewer, Nick Threadgold, Alma Brewer, Paul Wackrow, Adam Drury and Kirsten Wackrow. Photo by Mark Drury. 34 Abbreviations AVR Australian Vital Records Index. CFHS Cornwall Family History Society. IGI International Genealogical Index. PROV Public Records Office Victoria. 35 References Bartlett, J. (1996), Ships of North Cornwall, Morton-Raymont, C. (1989), Padstow in the Tabb House. mid-nineteenth century, Lodenek Press. Bennett, C. (1988), Wandilligong — A valley Price, C. (1987), Australians: Historical statisthrough time, Wandiligong Preservation Sotics, in W. Vamplew, ed., ‘Chapter 1: Immiciety. gration and ethnic origin’, Fairfax, Syme & Weldon Associates, pp. 2–22. Buchan, S. (2001), El Dorado . . . an Australian story, James and Sandra Buchan. Shennan, M. R. (1985), Silver threads and golden needles: the early history of Silver Davis, K. (1939), ‘Illegitimacy and the social Creek, Beechworth, M.R. Shennan, Noble structure’, The American Journal of SociolPark. ogy 45(2), 215–233. Frost, G. S. (2003), “‘the black lamb of the Shennan, M. R. (1990), A biographical dictionary of the pioneers of the Ovens and black sheep”: Illegitimacy in the english townsmen of Beechworth, Noble Park. working class, 1850–1939’, Journal of Social History 37(2). Shorter, E. (1977), The Making of the Modern Family, Basic Books. Gee, M. (2000), A long way from Silver Creek. Harvey, R. C. (1994), Background to Beech- Swain, S. (2005), ‘Domestic servants in comparative perspective’, The History of the worth, Beechworth & District Progress AsFamily 10(4), 461–471. sociation. Hopkins, R. (1988), Where now Cousin Jack?, Tuohy, W. (2004), ‘Mrs. daisy frances ellen Bendigo Building Society. dent’, The Eldorado and District Star (107), 10,12. Hunt, R. (1997), Cornish legends, To Mark Press, Redruth. White, G. P. (1984), A handbook of Cornish surnames, Dyllansow Truran. Hyndman, I. (2000), History of Beechworth, Bethel Publications. Woods, C. (1985), Beechworth: A Titan’s Field, Hargreen, North Melbourne. Lloyd, B. & Nunn, K. (1987), Bright gold: the story of the people and the gold of Bright and Wandiligong, Histec Publications. 36 Index of Family Names Angus, 31 Matheson, 31 Merrifield, 31 Moore, 27 Mull, 23 Baker, 17 Blewett, 7 Boyes (Boyce), 8 Brewer, 5–8, 15–17 Bussell, 16 Ottry, 13 Parr, 7 Paull, 7 Plumb (Plum), 13 Pope, 23 Campbell, 8 Cooke, 10 Crack, 10 Randall, 5 Ransom, 25 Reeves, 8 Rhind, 17 Rickard, 7 Roger, 8 Datson, 8 Dent, 16 Ellen, 10, 12, 13 Farrelly, 13 Frances, 15 Francis, 8 Shan-Hun, 31 Simmons, 23 Strachan, 26, 27 Garnham (Garman), 10 Godwin, 11 Goodyer, 15, 18 Gray, 23 Gribble, 20, 22, 23, 30, 31 Thomas, 10 Walker, 17 Wells, 13 Wilde, 25 Williams, 32 Harkness, 26 Higgins, 23, 25–27, 30 Hosking, 18 Jessup, 10 Kendall, 27 Kneebone, 13 37