Bid Evaluation Summary
Transcription
Bid Evaluation Summary
PUNJAB CITIES GOVERNANCE IMPROVEMENT PROJECT Bid Evaluation Report & Recommendation for Award of Contract IBRD Loan or IDA Credit No.: IDA 5153 PK Contract Name: Replacement of Forcemain from Noor Pur Pumping Station to Paharang Drain for Efficiency Improvement by Single Stage Pumping. Identification Number: PCGIP 2014-15/WASA-F / 20 Name of Employer: Water and Sanitation Agency Faisalabad, Govt of the Punjab Date of Submission: ___________________ Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................1 2.0 EXAMINATION FOR COMPLETENESS OF BIDS.............................................3 3.0 DETERMINATION OF SUBSTANTIVE RESPONSIVENESS OF BIDS ...........4 4.0 DETAILED EVALUATION OF BIDS ......................................................................5 5.0 COMPARISON OF BIDS AND DETERMINATION OF THE LOWEST EVALUATED BID ......................................................................................................6 6.0 POST QUALIFICATION EVALUATION. ..............................................................7 7.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS. ....................................................8 APPENDIX 1: ADVERTISEMENT ................................................................................9 APPENDIX 2: BID OPENING RECORD ...................................................................10 APPENDIX 3: COMPARATIVE STATEMENT .........................................................26 Page i Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 Project Background Bid Evaluation Report Introduction The Government of the Punjab has received a credit (Cr No. 5153-PK) from the International Development Association towards the cost of Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project and intends to apply part of the funds to cover eligible payments under the Contract Replacement of Forcemain from Noor Pur Pumping Station to Paharang Drain for Efficiency Improvement by Single Stage Pumping. Since the estimated cost of this work is PKR 54.352 million, therefore, the procurement is processed through NCB method in accordance with World Bank guidelines. 1.2 General The invitation for bids was published in daily Tribune newspaper on 09-12-2014, daily Nawai Waqat Newspaper on 11-12-2014 and on PPRA website on 10-12-2014 (Appendix -1 attached). Following interested contractors acquired the Bidding documents from District Officer Roads Office: M/S Al-Hamad associates Faisalabad. M/S Ch. Farzand ali & Co Chishtian M/S Muhammad Hanif Anjum Toba Tek Singh M/S Rasheed Construction Company, Faisalabad M/S Mansoor & Company M/S Al Fazal Construction, Sahiwal M/S Shad construction Multan M/S Shehzone Engineering Lahore M/S Elcon Associates Faisalabad M/S New Technical Associates, Faisalabad M/S Saleem Engineers, Faisalabad M/S Usmani Associates Karachi M/S Design & Engineering Lahore M/S N.P.I Construction Faisalabad M/S Moazzam Corporation Lahore Page 1 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 1.3 Bid Evaluation Report Introduction Submission of Bids The date and time for submission of bids was fixed on January 17th 2015 at 11:30 AM and bids from Below mentioned Bidders were received on the fixed date and time: 1.4 M/S N.P.I Construction Co, Faisalabad. M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad. Bid Opening Bids were opened on January 17th 2015 at 12:00 P.M in the office of conference room of WASA Faisalabad by the Bid opening Committee in presence of bidders or their representatives. The bidder’s names, the amount of bid prices, the presence or absence of bid security and its amount were announced and recorded. The Record of Bid Opening was prepared soon after the bids were announced and a copy of the Record of Bid Opening is attached as Appendix-2. The Summary of Financial Bid of only bidder as declared at the time of opening of Bids is as follows: BIDDER TOTAL BID AMOUNT (RS.) M/S N.P.I Construction 62979427.00 Co, Faisalabad M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad 1.5 49593688.00 Amount of Bid Security REPRESENTATIVE OF BIDDER PRESENT 1259764 M. Saeed 1020000 M. Javaid Basic Data and Exchange Rates Since the rates quoted are in Pakistani Rupees basic data for exchange rate is not applicable. 1.6 Bid Evaluation The Bid opening committee also evaluated the bids on given parameters mentioned in the documents. Page 2 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Examination for Completeness of Bids 2.0 EXAMINATION FOR COMPLETENESS OF BIDS 2.1 Bid Documents The bids submitted were first examined to check whether the bidders submitted all the documents and information required by the bidding documents. The areas covered by the examination were. Form of Bid and Bill of Quantities Bid Security Propriety of Signature and Power of Attorney Completeness Documents establishing the eligibility of bidders Substantial Responsiveness The bidders have provided the above documents and also bid security. The record of checking for completeness of bid documents is attached. 2.2 Propriety of Signature and Power of Attorney Bid documents were signed by all the Bidders. Page 3 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Responsiveness of Bids 3.0 DETERMINATION OF SUBSTANTIVE RESPONSIVENESS OF BIDS 3.1 Eligibility of Bidders. All the bidders are based in Pakistan and have valid Pakistan Engineering Council (PEC) registration. 3.2 Bidders Qualifications & Determination of Responsiveness of Bid The updated information regarding technical capability of the bidder was examined. The original Bid documents received by the department indicate that the bidders have submitted the bids on prescribed forms with bidding documents which include the prescribed required information. 3.3 Arithmetic Check and Corrections The Bids were checked for arithmetic corrections and corrections have been applied where required. The respective details of the items and areas of corrections have been summarized as following: BIDDER M/S N.P.I Construction BID AMOUNT AT OPENING (RS.) ARITHMATICALLY CORRECTED BID (RS.) Co, Faisalabad 62979427.00 62979428.00 49593688.00 51785403.00 M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad The bidders have not added any items, or made any adjustment and not deviated price. 3.4 Compliance with Commercial Terms and Conditions 3.4.1 Bid Validity and Bid Security The bid validity period of 45 days from the date of bid opening was specified in the bid documents. All bidders have submitted Bid Security with validity. 3.4.2 Time for Completion 3.5 The bidders agreed to complete the work within 120 days from the date of commencement of work as per bid documents. Compliance with Technical Requirements The Bid compliance has been reviewed with the requirements for the submission of bids, which includes the completion of the Bill of Quantities. 3.5.1 Technical Deviations The bids do not contain technical deviations. Page 4 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 4.0 DETAILED EVALUATION OF BIDS 4.1 Selection of Bids for Detailed Evaluation Bid Evaluation Report Detailed Evaluation of Bids As discussed in Section 3 of this Report, the bids submitted by the bidders were examined, found substantially responsive to the bidding documents. 4.2 Clarifications Bidders were not requested for any clarifications to obtain any further information regarding works. Page 5 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Comparison of Bids 5.0 COMPARISON OF BIDS AND DETERMINATION OF THE LOWEST EVALUATED BID 5.1 Lowest Evaluated Bid The bid prices for compliance with the technical requirements as discussed in paragraph 4.3 above were shown in Bid Prices Comparison and detailed item based comparative statement also attached to this Report as Appendix 3. BIDDER ARITHMATICALLY CORRECTED BID (RS.) M/S N.P.I Construction Co, 62979428.00 Faisalabad M/S New 5.2 2nd Lowest 1st Lowest Technical Associates Faisalabad RANKING 51785403.00 Reasonable Price of the Lowest Evaluated Bid The bids were compared with the Engineer’s Cost Estimate and the comparative statement is enclosed. BIDDER ENGINEER’S ESITMATE ARITHMATICALLY CORRECTED BID (Rs.) ABOVE / BELOW ENGINERS ESTIMATE 54352558.00 N/A M/S N.P.I Construction Co, 62979428.00 Faisalabad M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad 51785403.00 8626870 -2567155 The details of bids’ comparison with the Engineers Estimate are given in Appendix 3 of this report. Page 6 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 6.0 Bid Evaluation Report Post Qualification Evaluation POST QUALIFICATION EVALUATION. Since the lowest bidder was not already prequalified, therefore post qualification was done based on the part 2 of the bidding documents. The detail is as under: 6.1 Liquid Assets: The liquid asset detail shows that the contractor’s having more than PKR 15.0 million liquid asset / credit facility net off other contractual commitments. 6.2 Works Completed: The value of same nature work done in last 5 years by the lowest contractor is more than PKR 200 million. 6.3 PEC Registration: The contractor has registered. 6.4 Considering Para 6.1 to 6.3, the qualification of the lowest bidder for the subject work is supported. Page 7 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 7.0 Bid Evaluation Report Conclusions and Recommendations CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS. Based on the detailed evaluation and findings presented in this report, M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad has submitted the lowest evaluated and substantially responsive bid of PKR 51785403.00 which is PKR 2567155 less than the Engineer’s Estimate of PKR 54352558.00. It is recommended that World Bank may notify the Employer of its approval in time to issue the letter of acceptance to the recommended bidder before expiration of the bid validity period. Page 8 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project APPENDIX 1: Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record ADVERTISEMENT Daily Nawa- i - Waqat Page 9 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project APPENDIX 2: Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record BID OPENING RECORD Attendance Sheet of Procurement Committee Page 10 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Bidders Attendance Sheet Page 11 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Minutes of Bids Opening Page 12 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Page 13 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Page 14 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Bid Opening Checklist (To be filled out for each bid as it is read out) Contract Reference: Replacement of Forcemain from Noor Pur Pumping Station to Paharang Drain for Efficiency Improvement by Single Stage Pumping. Bid Opening Date: 17-01-2015 Time: 12:00 PM Name of Bidder: M/S N.P.I Construction Co Faisalabad. (a) Is outer envelope of bid sealed? YES (b) Is bid form completed and signed? Yes (c) Expiration date of bid:45 Days (d) Is documentary authority for signing enclosed? Yes (e) Amount of bid security (if required): (f) Describe any “Substitution,” PKR 12,59,764/“Withdrawal,” or “Modification” submitted_______NIL_____________________________________________________ (g) Value of Liquid Assets as required = Credit Facility of 550.0 Million (h) Describe any discounts or modifications offered:____________________________________________________________________ (i) Value of work done in last five years is according to required: 1012 Million in 2010-11 (j) Name of bidder or representative present: Mr. Saeed (k) Total bid price: PKR 62979427.00/- (list currencies and amounts or percentages) Signature of responsible official: Date: 17-01-2015 Page 15 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Bid Opening Checklist (To be filled out for each bid as it is read out) Contract Reference: Replacement of Forcemain from Noor Pur Pumping Station to Paharang Drain for Efficiency Improvement by Single Stage Pumping. Bid Opening Date: 17-01-2015 Time: 12:00 PM Name of Bidder: M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad. (a) Is outer envelope of bid sealed? YES (b) Is bid form completed and signed? Yes (c) Expiration date of bid:45 Days (d) Is documentary authority for signing enclosed? Yes (e) Amount of bid security (if required): (f) Describe any “Substitution,” PKR 10,20,000/“Withdrawal,” or “Modification” submitted_______NIL_____________________________________________________ (g) Value of Liquid Assets as required = Credit Facility of 15.0 Million (h) Describe any discounts or modifications offered:____________________________________________________________________ (i) Value of work done in last five years is according to required: 220 Million in 2011-12 (j) Name of bidder or representative present: Mr. Javaid (k) Total bid price: PKR 49593688.00/- (list currencies and amounts or percentages) Signature of responsible official: Date: 17-01-2015 Page 16 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Bid Evaluation Standard Forms Table -1 Identification 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 Name of Borrower Loan/Credit number Date of effectiveness Closing date (a) original (b) revised 1.5 Name of project 1.6 Purchaser (or Employer) (a) name (b) address 1.7 Contract number (identification) 1.8 Contract description 1.9 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 Cost estimate1 Method of procurement (check one) Prior review required2 Domestic preference allowed Fixed price contract Cofinancing, if any: (a) agency name (b) percent financed by agency The Govt of the Punjab IDA 5153 PK 30-06-2017 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Water and sanitation Agency, Faisalabad. Opposite Allied Hospital Jail Road Fsd. PCGIP 2014-15/WASA-F/20 Replacement of Forcemain from Noor Pur Pumping Station to Paharang Drain for Efficiency Improvement by Single Stage Pumping 54.352 Million ICB LIB NCB Yes No Yes Yes No Yes No Nil Page 17 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Table-2 Bidding Process 2.1 General Procurement Notice (a) first issue date (b) latest update 2.2 Prequalification, if required (a) number of firms prequalified (b) date of Bank’s no-objection 2.3 Specific procurement notice (a) name of national newspaper (b) issue date (c) name of international publication (d) issue date (e) number of firms notified 2.4 Standard Bidding Document (a) title, publication date (b) date of Bank’s no-objection (c) date of issue to bidders 2.5 Number of firms issued documents 2.6 Amendments to documents, if any (a) list all issue dates (b) date(s) of Bank’s no-objection 2.7 Date of pre-bid conference, if any 2.8 Date minutes of conference sent to bidders and Bank 09-12-2014 N/A Daily Tribune and PPRA Website 09-12-2014 & Daily Nawa-i-Waqat dated 11-12-2014 09-12-2014 09-12-2014 09-12-2014 to 15-01-2015 15 1. 1. 2. 2. 3. 3. Page 18 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Table-3 Bids Submission and Opening 3.1 (a) (b) 3.2 3.3 3.4 3.5 (a) (b) (c) Bid submission deadline original date, time extensions, if any Bid opening date, time Record of bid opening, date sent to Bank Number of bids submitted Bid validity period (days or weeks) originally specified extensions, if any date of Bank’s no-objection, if required1 17-01-2015 Till 11:30PM 17-01-2015 at 12:00PM 19-01-2015 02 45 days Page 19 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Table -4 Bids Prices (As read out) Bidder Identification City/State or Province Name (a) Country Read-out Bid Price(s)1 Currency(ies) Amount(s) or % Modifications or Comments2 (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) Punjab Pakistan PKR 62979427.00 NIL Punjab Pakistan PKR 49593688.00 M/S N.P.I Construction Co, Faisalabad M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad etc. Page 20 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Table-5 Preliminary Examination Bidder Verification Eligibility Bid Security Completeness of Bid Substantial Responsiveness Acceptance for Detailed Examination (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) (g) Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes M/S Construction N.P.I Co, Faisalabad M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad Page 21 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Page 22 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Table-6 Corrections and unconditional Discounts Bidder Read-out Bid Price(s) Corrections Corrected Bid Price(s) Currency(ies) Amount(s) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) = (c) + (d)+ (e) (g) (h) (i) = (f) – (h) Co, PKR 62979427.00 NIL NIL 62979428.00 NIL NIL 62979428.00 M/S New Technical PKR 49593688.00 NIL NIL 51785403.00 NIL NIL 51785403.00 (a) M/S Construction Computational Provisional Errors1 Sums Unconditional Corrected/Discounted Discounts2 Bid Price(s) Percent Amount(s) N.P.I Faisalabad Associates Faisalabad etc. Page 23 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Table 7. Additions, Adjustments, and Priced Deviations Specify Evaluation Currency: PKR Bidder Corrected/Discounted Bid Price1 Additions2 Adjustments2 Priced Deviations2 Total Price (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f) = (b) + (c) + (d) + (e) 62979428.00 Nil Nil Nil 62979428.00 51785403.00 Nil Nil Nil 51785403.00 M/S N.P.I Construction Co, Faisalabad M/S New Technical Associates Faisalabad etc. Page 24 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 2: Bid Opening Record Table-8 Proposed Contract Award 1. 2. Lowest evaluated responsive bidder (proposed for contract award). (a) name (b) address If bid submitted by agent, list actual supplier. (a) name (b) address M/S New Technical Associates, Faisalabad N/A 3. If bid from joint venture, list all partners, nationalities, and estimated shares of contract. 4. Principle country(ies) of origin of goods/materials. Pakistan Estimated date (month, year) of contract signing. February Estimated delivery to project site/completion period. 15-06-2014 5. 6. N/A Currency(ies) 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. Bid Price(s) (Read-out) Corrections for Errors Discounts Other Adjustments Proposed Award Disbursement Category PKR PKR PKR PKR PKR Amount(s) or % 51785403.00 51785403.00 PCGIP Funds Page 25 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project APPENDIX 3: Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement COMPARATIVE STATEMENT NAME OF WORK:- REPLACEMENT OF FORCEMAIN FROM NOOR PUR PUMPING STATION TO PAHARANG DRAIN FOR EFFICIENCY IMPROVEMENT BY SINGLE STAGE PUMPING. Estimated Cost: Rs.5,43,52,558/- Date of opening: 17-01-2015 Estimated Cost S. No . MRS Rates Description Unit Qty Rate (Rs.) Amount Time Limit: 4 Months. 1/2 M/S N.P.I Construction Co, Faisalabad. 2/2 M/S New Technical Associates, Faisalabad. Quoted Rates Amount Quoted Rates Amount 1000.00 82500.00 700.00 57750.00 Sub Head # 1: P/L Forcemain GRP 700mm dia. 1 2 C4/45 C3/42 Dismantling of T.S.T Road 100 Cft 8250.00 781.45 64469.625 Earth work excavation in open cutting for sewers and manholes as shown in drawings including shuttering and timbering, dressing to correct sections and dimensions according to templates and levels, and removing surface water, in all types of soil except shingle gravel and rock. 0-7' depth 7-15' depth 100 0 Cft 100 0 Cft 348705 3560.15 261923 5962.25 1241442.10 6 1561650.40 7 5270.00 1837675.35 3500.00 1220467.50 6000.00 1571538.00 4000.00 1047692.00 Page 26 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 3 N.S Providing and Laying cutting, jointing and testing GRP pipe, filament wound, uniformaly enriched with aggregate resin mortar of silica sand mechanically with bell and spigot joint with 2 rubber rings according to ASTM 2996, AWWA C-950 Class 'C' PN 9 bar complete lay in trenches. 700mm clear internal dia. Class 'C' PN 9 bar Class 'B' PN 6 bar 4 N.S 6 N.S C3/13 C- Per Rft 3985 4626.00 18434610 5373.00 Per Rft 7024.25 4094.00 28757279.5 4497.00 21411405.0 0 31588052.2 5 4750.00 3800.00 18928750.0 0 26692150.0 0 Providing and Fixing GRP pipe, fittings filament wound, uniformaly enriched with aggregate resin mortar of silica sand mechanically with according to ASTM 2996, AWWA C-950 Class 'C' PN 9 bar complete lay in trenches. 700mm clear internal dia. Bend 45° 5 Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement Each 4 45030.00 180120 91000.00 364000.00 45000.00 180000.00 P/Fixing non return valve C.I body having full flow with stainless steel body seat / ring and synthatic imported rubber sheet on other site and imported stainless steel shaft pin openable type complete. 700 mm dia. Per Rft. 1 (I) Rehandling of earthwork lead upto single throw of kassi, pharoah or shoevel. (II) 100 0 Cft 100 Cft 540886. 5 540886. 185315.0 0 185315 600000.0 0 600000.00 185000.0 0 185000.00 765.60 366.20 414102.704 4 198072.636 1000.00 750.00 540886.50 405664.88 1000.00 100.00 540886.50 54088.65 Page 27 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 3/24 7 N.S 8 N.S 0 5 100 0 Cft 3 540886. 5 469.35 253865.078 8 750.00 405664.88 100.00 54088.65 Restoration of T.S.T Road. Each 8250 100.00 825000 140.00 1155000.00 100.00 825000.00 Providing of pit sand, rehandling in trenches, flooding, leveling & dressing complete. Each 23554.6 9 22.00 518203.18 21.20 499359.43 20.00 471093.80 450000.0 0 450000.00 Constructio n of valve non return valve chamber 9 i Compaction of Earth Work (soft ordinary or hard soil). (III) Remaining of Earth Work. Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement 17.1 to 17.5 Excavation in foundation of building, bridges and other structures, including dagbelling, dressing, refilling aroung structure with excavated earth, watering and ramming lead upto one chain and lift upto 5 ft. b.in ordinary 100 Cft 722.5 4118.40 2975.54 3000.00 2167.50 Page 28 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project soil. ii 20.1 Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement 0 Cement concrete brick or ballast 1 1/2" to 2" gauge in foundation and plinth Ratio (1:4:8) 100 Cft 36.13 10642.85 3845.26 9500.00 3432.35 iii 20.1 P.C.C. (1:2:4) 100 Cft 18 19174.30 3451.37 16000.00 2880.00 vi 21.1 to 21.5 Pacca brick work other than building upto 10 ft height (1:4) cement sand mortor. 100 Cft 296.58 17192.40 50989.22 17500.00 51901.50 25.1 to 25.6 Cement plaster 1/2" thick (1:3) thick. 100 Sft 527.25 1473.65 7769.82 1000.00 5272.50 20.4 R.C.C. Slab (1:2:4) Per Cft. 43.84 292.90 12840.74 280.00 12275.20 v vi Page 29 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project vii 851.5 Fabrication of mild steel reinforcement of cement concrete inclduing cutting, bending, laying in position, making joints and fastenings, including cost of binding reinfrocmeent (also includes removal of rust form bars. b) Deformed bars viii 10 Providing/fixi ng 6" thick R.C.C. man hole cover with tee shaped C.I frame 22" dia frame 37.324 kg. and as per standard specification. N.S Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement 100 Kg Each 134.27 11462.50 15390.70 9000.00 12084.30 1.00 4253.80 4253.80 1849.00 1849.00 Providing and installation of M.S welded pipe 700 mm dia 12mm thick, dully painted two coats of epoxy paint on internal and external surface. Cost also included holing in pipe and welding different size of M.S flanged pipe 10mm thick as per shown in attached drawing, cost of dressing coupling 700mm dia is also included in rate complete as per entire surface satisfication of Engineering Incharge. Each 1 260267.8 4 260267.84 470000.0 0 470000.00 260000.0 0 260000.00 Sub Head # 2: Construction of Discharge Chamber and Connection Pipe at Paharang Seepage Drain: Page 30 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project 1 C3/42 Earth work excavation in open cutting for sewers and manholes as shown in drawings including shuttering and timbering, dressing to correct sections and dimensions according to templates and levels, and removing surface water, in all types of soil except shingle gravel and rock. (i) 0 ft to 7 ft. Depth 7-15' depth 2 C6/3b 3 C-6/6 5 C-6/9 C6/27 100 Cft. 0 100 Cft. 0 7981.75 3560.15 28416.23 5270.00 42063.82 3500.00 27936.13 5962.25 4304.74 6000.00 4332.00 4000.00 2888.00 722.00 Cement concrete plain including placing compacting, finishing and curing complete (including screening and washing of stone aggregate) (1:4:8) 100 Cft. 22.56 10642.85 2401.03 15300.00 3451.68 9500.00 2143.20 Providing and laying reinforced cement concrete (including prestressed concrete), using coarse sand and screened graded and washed aggregate, in required shape and design including forms, moulds, shuttering, lifting, compacting,pcuring, renndering and finshing exposed surface, complete (but excluding the cost of steel reinforcement, its fabrication and placing in position, etc.):Base Slab Wall & roof 4 Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement Per Cft. Per Cft. 100.92 439.07 219.90 292.90 22192.308 300.00 30276.00 200.00 20184.00 128603.603 300.00 131721.00 275.00 120744.25 Fabrication of mild steel reinforcement for cement concrete, including cutting, bending, laying in position, making joints and fastenings, including cost of binding wire and labour charges for binding of steel reinforcement (also includes removal of rust from bars):- Providing and fixing 6 in (150mm) 100 kg. 1619.97 11462.50 185689.06 12000.00 194396.40 11000.00 178196.70 Per Rft 90.00 70.80 6372 150.00 13500.00 70.00 6300.00 Page 31 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement wide G.I sheet 18SWG stopper to expansion joint 6 C21/15 a Per Rft. 1.00 4253.80 4253.8 4980.00 4980.00 4000.00 4000.00 Supplying, laying, granular material crushed stone) 1/2" to 1" gauge under pipe line and up to half diameter of pipe. 7 8 Providing/fixing 6" thick R.C.C. man hole cover with tee shaped C.I frame 22" dia frame 37.324 kg. and as per standard specification. C21/4 Each . 2317.03 55.80 129290.274 47.00 108900.41 40.00 92681.20 Providing and Laying R.C.C. pipe sewer moulded with cement concrete 1:1.5:3 conforming to ASTM specification C76-79, Class-III, Wall-B, including carriage of pipe from factory to site of wor, lowering in trenches to correct alignment and grade, jointing with rubber ring, cutting pipes where necessary, testing etc. complete 54" Per Rft 150.00 3344.00 501600 5277.00 791550.00 3300.00 495000.00 C.I Step @ wt. 3kg each in manhole chambers I/c carriage setting the same in work to correct lines and levels. 9 Eac h N.S 10 302.00 3020 350.00 3500.00 250.00 2500.00 Providing of environmental and social management frame work (ESMF). Page 32 Punjab Cities Governance Improvement Project (i) Supply of masks (ii)Supply of Shoes (iii)Supply of Gloves (iv)Supply of First Aid Box (v)Constructi on of safety signs (vi)Supply of Goggles (vii)Supply of Reflaction Tape (vii)Supply of pole hanging waste bins 5 Note: Bid Evaluation Report Appendix 3: Comparative Statement Per No. 50 350.00 17500 100.00 5000.00 300.00 15000.00 Per No. 50 2000.00 100000 2620.00 131000.00 2000.00 100000.00 Per No. 50 700.00 35000 790.00 39500.00 500.00 25000.00 Per No. 4 2000.00 8000 6600.00 26400.00 4000.00 16000.00 Per No. 10 4500.00 45000 3000.00 30000.00 4000.00 40000.00 Per No. 50 500.00 25000 500.00 25000.00 300.00 15000.00 Per No. 30 1000.00 30000 237.00 7110.00 300.00 9000.00 Per No. 10 8000.00 80000 500.00 5000.00 400.00 4000.00 In Item No.7 ESMF items i) to vii) are returnable to WASA Faisalabad store after execution of work. 54,352,558 62,979,428 51,785,403 Page 33