,`,-, t

KoMr4ccr,ruTCX{ <3aropn e23-l>>. Bce 3Tr4 3aBeAoMo rloxHble cBeAeHH-[,orBerrIH
peBvr3kroHHofi
tIocJIe [poBeAeuuofr HcrIIoM peBH3]
xalo6y,
cTankrpaclpocrpaH.srb, a noroM Lr Hafivcafiv
TCX B oxu6pe 2010 f., rAe 6:flnu BbIsBrIeHbIp
@uuaucono-xossficrnenuofi Ae.flTenbHosrr.r
Banyficxofi E.E., KaK npeAceAarerrfl rpaB rrenvrfl,TCX, I{ He3aKonsltfr c6op Hailnr{Hl
iupy*.rufi
r{
eit, ua,npuo6perenne H ycraHoBKy BHAeosa6:EoAeHHq.
.IO, c x(r4Terr
AeHex*{brxcpeAcrn foly6. f
r{To noATBepxAaercfl 3a-flBleHl4eMo c6ope AeHexHbIX cpeAcrB
yKa3aHo B aKTe peBv3vrvr,H
.{ro AeficrBr{rMn Orner'{uxon efi npuuHHeH MopaxbHrtfr npe4
ityrrn.uoeofi M.8.. Irlcreu yKa3aJr,
corJlacHo cr. 151 fK Po. Jorxl
su,,e HpaBcrBeHgbrx vr Snsuuecrcux crpagauuit, roropufi,
BO3MCCTI'ITb
OTBETIII{KI4.
qect?Ib
onposepzHymb ceedeuun, nopoqaulue
Hcmet4 npocum olasamu OmeemrtuKor
qmo, oHa saHuMaemcfl peildepcr;
dOcmouucmlo, denOAyn penymaLflito, ucmqa, o moM
npedcedameneil npanileHufl TC}I{, HaeMHbtM paSomuuKcL\t
ynpa,neHLteM
'npedcedamettnTCII{, cHuJwaem
6 nucbMeHHoM eude, s l''np{
npauneHun TCI{ ycmaHasnunaem 3apruamy,
e Annapam Mepa z.Mocxeut,
iEuprnueo-BocmoqHoe)), e \YI4C pailoua <Eupnneeo-BocmoqHoeD,
ua uuQopntaquoHH
ur$op*ar4uoHHoM co6pauuu ttileHor TCII{, u nucbMeHHoeonposepuceHue
E.8., @edopoeou H'
cmeudax TCII{. Tarccrceucmer4npocum ffidcKamb,6 ee noflb3y, c Banyilcrcoil
1000 p1'5.te[r
B cyJvIA4e
Cutvtouoeoil 7.8., Cuuouoeoil 8.A., KotvneHcaqutoMopanbHozo epeda
py'1'tei, xcr'
B3btcKombc fony6 r.IO. KoMneHcaqurcMoponbHozoepeda 6 pa3rvtepe5000
rcacrcdoeo,
qecmb,
docmouxcttl7(
opzaHusqmopapocnpocmpoHeHunyKa3aHHbtxB ucKe ceedeuuil, nopoqau4Ltx
denoaympenymal4uto ucmqa.
rIacrII IIcKoB
Onpe4eneHneM cyAa or 29.08.201L roAa, rpor43BoAcrBo rlo AenY, B
MoparbHoro Bpe
rpe6onanuft o 3aIIII{Terrecrlr, Aocror,rHcrBar4AenoBofipenyrawr4, KoMrIeHcaI,JxLT
OTKa3OMI{CrUa or llcKoB
K Kocuprr<osofi H.il. vr crpauKo H.lI., flpeKparqeHo, B cBfl3H C
orBerql{KaM.
rpe6onaurtit, K yKa3aHHbIM
vIcTeII noAAep)KanaHcKoBbIerpe6onauuir., npocuna HX yAoB-rIerBopHTb,
B cyle6HoM 3aceAaHvIvr
ilo ocHoBaHHflM,
::
I43IIOXeHHbIM B HCKOBOM 3aflBJIeHVVl.
Baryi1cxax E.E., fory6 f .IO., Oegopona H.A., CtllroHoeaT'8. a c1':edHr
Oreerq1arcu
3AC|e/IAHVTH LICK He
IIpI43HaJIH,
CCbIrIaflCb
[Ia
ro,
rITo
Bce
r{3JIoXeHHbIe
CBeAeHHq
B
xano(
rlpoKypopa P@
rroArrr4cauuofrvrMr4)oi o r.0z.z0rl roAa, HarpaBrressofi B aApec feuepalbHoro
yrpaBJlfler TCX <3arop
Mspa r.Mocxnbr, coorBercrByror Aeficrnr4TeJrbHocrrl, Irlcreq Sarru'recKl{
flpaueu
Z3-1r),frp&BrreHgeTC111pa6oraer rroA pyKoBoAcrBoM Vlc'n7a,I'Icreu npoBoALIr co6paHur
yCTaHaBIrkrB'
C
TCX, pemaer, Kofo raa6parr [peAceAareJreM flpanneur4fl, KO|O CH.flTb AOIX{HOCTH,
HHKorAa He 6u
rapa6orHyro rnary rrpeAceAareJrflMrpaBJreHrar, rJraBHoMy 6yxranrePY, I'Icreq
pr
co6pau
rporoKonax
s
rureHoM rpaBneHus TCX,
[o3roMy B nporoKorax o6qux co6panuft
oHa [poBo.n
flpanneu"" 1CX, He yKa3aHo, qro Irlcreq yqacrBoBaJran co6pa[vrflx, uo (partl{qecKH
,o6putrfl H [pr,rHlrMaer pe[reHrrfl tlo BceMBorlpocaMAe.f,TerlbHocrHTCX.
He rBHrIaCb,O AHe I4 BpeMeHHCny[IaHI'Is A(
oreer.rHx cuuososa E,.A. n cyleSHoe 3ace[a:fFikre
c qeM (
B cB.ff3LI
u3BerueHa,o rrprrr{r{HeHeflBKHn c}A ne coo6qz4rra)or3blBa Ha I,IcKrie npeAcraBkrna,
paccMorpen AeIIo B ee orcyrcrBne, B ;1opqAKecr.167 fnK PO.
3aceAall
llpeAcraBgreJrb 3-ero nuua TCX{ <3aropre 23-1> ForoMorloBa A.B. B cy.ue6HoM
rITo
xaJIO
B
H3JIO)KeHHbIe
cBeAeHLIt'
rroAAepxafla, ccblrra.rrcbHa ro,
rpe6onanux
HCKOBbTe
PO Pr M:
rroAngcalrsbfr Orner.ruKaMlr, HarrpaBrreHsofi Ha nMs, fenepanbHoro rlpoKypopa
uz6pi
X.A'
r.Mocrnbr, B orHorueHuuVlcala, He coorBercrByror AeficrsuTeJlbHoc:ru,[ecnrHHKoBa
'cnou o6sgaHuocrrl' KaKilpeAceAar(
peBrr3uoHHofiKoMuccr,ruTCX <3aropse 23-1 >,
rrpeAceAareJreM
B paMKax cBol{x ilOTIHOMOTI
B coorBercrBHH C 3aKOHOM,
TCX, HCnOJrHser
KOMHCCHU
peBH3HOsUOfr
HHKaKI{X peruenufi,
qrreHoM rrpaBneHr.rflTCxt [eclrHuKoBa nt.A. HlIKorAa He 6una,
o6qero co6pauus qrleHou T!
AeflTenbHocrg TCX, rrpuHsrpre Koropbrx BXoAr4TB KoMrIereHIII{}o
<<3arcpre 23
flpaeneHr,rx TCX, Irlcreq He rrpuHuMaer, rr He Moxter rrpIrHI'IMarb. TCX
3aKoHav ycraBa TC]K
ocyulecrBJrfler cBoro AeflTeJrbHocrbB coorBercrBllu c rpe6on a:IvrflNtlr4
rt),
Ilc
,:
I
l
.{.
: . , 'l
,',-t
i' . I /
t'
'- i'.,
l'.:'
peE
t)j'tr
noc
3aK