Dr. Tatiana Chernysheva, and Prof. Vladimir Korenbaum

Hypothetic physical mechanisms of
electronic homeopathic nosodes action
Dr. Tatiana Chernysheva, M.D.;
Prof. Vladimir Korenbaum, Ph.D.
Functional medicine clinic “Manus” and
Pacific Oceanological Institute of RAS,
Vladivostok, Russia
Introduction
• There are 2 procedures of
preparation of homeopathic
remedies (Towsey M.W.,
Hasan M.Y. Homoeopathy - a
biophysical point of view. Br
Hom J 1995; 84: 218-228.):
• left branch – traditional
dilution/succussion;
• right branch – electronic
homeopathic copying
(“imprinting”) with M. Rae‟s
apparatus.
Introduction
Electronic-homoeopathic
copies (EHCs) or so
named nosodes, made
by “imprinting” the parent
substance onto water
with the help of M. Rae‟s
black box or other
electronic devices (for
example J. Benveniste,
2000), have received a
certain acceptance in
some fields of alternative
medicine.
EHCs are used in modern
homeopathy, in Voll & Schimmel‟s
electro-puncture diagnostics, in
Applied Kinesiology.
Simulator (Metabolics, GB)
a version of M. Rae black box
• Apparatus contains two copper
tubular containers, the right of
which (M) is for the substance
copied, whereas the left one (C)
for the prepared EHP.
• According to Towsey and
Hasan (1995) there is a magnet
under container C in the box.
• In accordance with “radionic”
technique developed by M. Rae
the effect of a substance copied
is to „modulate‟ magnetic field,
which in turn “restructures”
water crystalization.
Subject of the study and objective
• The objective of the study is double blind estimation of
biophysical differences between water-based EHCs and blank
water carrier or placebo (P).
• Two independent investigations were carried out.
• The first one was connected to verification of biomedical
effect of EHC with a biological model.
Study I
• Biohumus fertilizer was chosen as the parent substance
under study.
• Water was used as a carier for electronic-homoeopathic
preparation.
• The tomato seedlings were fed by preparations under study.
• After 38 days they were cut and measured.
• Significance of distinctions between groups fed with studied
preparations was estimated by nonparametric statistics.
One of the plastic boxes
(97х15х14 cm)
with plants
Action of the EHC of biohumus fertiliser on
tomato seedling
• The uniform environmental exposure of plant groups was
achieved by displacing and turning the boxes at a time.
• The plants were fed with the preparations (200-300 ml) once
a week.
• Duration of each experiment was 38 days.
• The mass and growth differences for green part of the plants,
watered by homoeopathic nosode and placebo, proved to be
statistically significant in 3 of 4 experiments.
Results: growth of plants (mm) in experiments
(box & whisker plots)
Results: mass of plants (g) in experiments
(box & whisker plots)
Results:
Significance of difference in mass and
green part growth between groups of plants
fed with EHC of fertilizer and placebo (P)
* - according to Wald-Wolfovitz runs test
Experiment
No. 1
No. 2
No. 3
No. 4
Mass
n/s
p = 0.00016
p = 0.014*
p < 0.0001
Growth
n/s
p < 0.0001
n/s
p = 0.028
Discussion: Direction of EHC action
• Curiously at the same time, the direction of ECP action re P
differs from experiment to experiment. So, in Experiments No.2
and No.3 the EHC intensifies the development of plants re P,
and conversely in Experiment No.4 weakens.
• Such instability of the action on biological species (by the way,
being noted for the traditionally prepared homoeopathic
remedies) can be related to the effect dependent on the initial
state of plants (heating rate indoor and outdoor, year, season,
lunar phase and etc.).
Study II
we investigated absorption spectra of EHC
of 7 names of homeopathic remedies:
• DNA-tox (DNA) – indicator of DNA affection caused by
exposure of organism to toxic agents (Manus, RF);
• Bacteria (B) – superposition of 27 pathogenic bacteria
(Metabolics Ltd, GB);
• Manus (MAN) – harmonizing nosode (Manus, RF);
• Fungus (FUN) - superposition of 17 pathogenic fungus
(Metabolics Ltd, GB);
• Toxic metal (TM) - superposition of 27 salts of heavy metals
and toxic metals (Metabolics Ltd, GB);
• Virus (VIR) – superposition of 25 pathogenic viruses
(Metabolics Ltd, GB);
• Vanilmandelic acid (VMA) – product of noradrenaline and
epinephrine metabolism (Metabolics Ltd, GB).
Preparations
• The carrier was a sterile saline solution (NaCl 9%) in 5-ml
hermetic ampoules.
• 90 arbitrarily chosen ampoules from one factory lot were
numbered from 1 to 90.
• It was prepared by 9 EHC ampules of each denomination (a
total of 63 ampoules), 27 placebo (being hidden control)
ampoules and 5 control ampoules.
• The correspondence of the ampoule numbers with the
homoeopathic remedies or placebo was recorded in the
protocol that had not been opened until the completion of
spectral analysis and the record of spectral files.
The optical spectroscopy
• Absorption spectra were measured using UV – 2101 PC
(Shimadzu, Japan) double-beam apparatus. The wave band
was 800 – 600 nm with interval of 0.5 nm. The values of
optical density – log (1/transmission coefficient) – were written
to the hard disk as a file of spectral readings, the number of
which was appropriate to that of an ampoule.
• Every ampoule of sample was opened just before
measurement, and the specimen were poured in 3 ml cuvette
made of quartz glass (rectangular parallelepiped 4.5 cm in
height, 1 mm wall thickness) with expendable syringe.
• After recording the difference absorption spectrum the cuvette
was flushed out with saline solution, dried, and wiped with an
optical blanket.
• The control cuvette was filled once for every series with a
species from arbitrarily taken control ampoule.
Statiatical analysis
• All spectra were centered by subtraction the mean optical
density in the band of 800 – 600 nm from every spectral
reading to remove possible bias between 2 cuvettes.
• During statistical processing, the spectrum of each EHC
determined was compared with spectrum of each group of
placebo for all spectral readings (wavelengths) using MannWhitney non-parametric U-test.
• The wavelengths with the differences being significant
(p<0.05) were registered.
• Thereupon to enhance significance we selected those
spectral regions in which the significant differences were
observed at least on two adjoining wavelengths and evaluated
the sign of differences re placebo.
The number of spectral regions with significant differences re
placebo / wavelengths (nm), and sign of differences (↑↓)
Placebo 1
Placebo 1
(n=8)
Placebo 2
(n=8)
Placebo 3
(n=9)
DNA
(n=9)
B
(n=9)
MAN
(n=8)
FUN
(n=8)
TM
(n=9)
VIR
(n=9)
VMA
(n=9)
Placebo 2
_____0_____
_____0_____
Placebo 3
_____0_____
_____0_____
_____0_____
_____0_____
_____3_____
783↓, 727↑, 702↑
_____0_____
_____0_____
_____2_____
780↓, 740↑
_____0_____
_____2_____
790↓, 707.5↑
_____1_____
724.5↑
_____1_____
740.5↑
_____0_____
_____1_____
726.5↑
_____0_____
_____2_____
734.5↑, 732↑
_____0_____
_____0_____
_____1_____
742.5↑
_____0_____
_____0_____
_____0_____
_____1_____
779.5↓
_____0_____
_____0_____
Spectral amplitudes of EHCs are higher than spectral amplitudes of
all Placebo groups in the range from 702 to 742.5 nm. While spectral
amplitudes of EHCs are less than spectral amplitudes of all Placebo
groups in the range from 779.5 to 790 nm.
Discussion
• The steady signs (in 2 or even 3 wavelengths) enlarges
significance of differences between spectra of EHCs and
placebo.
• Small number of EHCs studied makes impossible to define if
the wavelengths with differencies are specific for certain EHC
nomination.
• Meanwhile the middle area of wavelengths characterized by
statistically efficient increase of absorption (724-742.5 nm)
lies closely to the domain of overtone and the 4-order
combination frequency of the H–H bonds in H2O molecule
http://www.sbu.ac.uk/water.
• Hence spectral differences revealed may be nonspecific to
EHC nomination feature of change in intermolecular (H–H)
connections occurred during electronic-homeopathic copying.
Question?
• Thus distinctions revealed between EHCs and placebo both in
double blind randomized experiments with biologic model and
in double blind randomized experiments with absorption
spectroscopy points to the reality of the electronichomeopathic copying phenomenon.
• What may follow from these results from biophysical point of
view?
Hypothetic explanation: Water
• The results obtained leave no alternative than to suppose,
agreeing with J. Benveniste that water is able to “memorize”
non-contact electronic actions. In conformity with the data of
recent works this does not seem anymore much incredible in
the context of physics either.
• For example, according to Lo S.-Y. et al (1996), extremely
dilute solutions contain ice-like crystals (groups of water
molecules). Called “IE crystals”, they are stable even at higher
temperatures and form a kind of information matrix for
“memorizing”.
• According to Ponomarev, Fesenko (2000) the dynamic state of
liquid water is determined by the presence of the quasi-particle
field (excitations, dislocations) so named solitons caused by
the relaxation of excited singlet oxygen molecules, which also
makes up a kind of information matrix for “memorizing”.
• But how are the non-contact actions produced by M. Rae‟s
apparatus capable of influence on these information matrixes?
Hypothetic explanation: M. Rae’s apparatus
(Assuming that these actions are due to weak electromagnetic fields)
• Human body is a source of wide-band electromagnetic
disturbances associated with the vital activity of cells and organs
(electrical charge motions). Moreover, all this takes place against
the background of a weakly-varying magnetotelluric field, along
with a field of permanent magnet set in M. Rae‟s apparatus
placed beside the operator‟s body.
• The preparation being copied, interpreted as a some kind of
passive resonator, might modify the field of wide-band
electromagnetic emission of the operator‟s organism or
interaction between this field and the aforesaid magnetic fields.
• In its turn this field, modified in one way or another is
superimposed on EHC information matrix. Thus EHC “commits
to memory” not the self-field of the parent substance but an
operator’s response to it.
• Hence there is the operator‟s personality dependence of the
prepared EHC effectiveness noted early or experimenter‟s effect
of J. Benveniste‟s preparations (Ives, et al., 2006).
Author’s basic publications
•
Korenbaum VI, Chernysheva TN, Apukhtina TP, Shin SN,
Demeniuk VN. Effect of electronic homeopathic copy of
biohumus fertilizer on tomato sprout development. Radiats Biol
Radioecol. 2003 May-Jun;43(3):370-4. (Russian).
•
Korenbaum VI, Chernysheva TN, Apukhtina TP, Sovetnikova
LN. Absorption spectra of electronic-homoeopathic copies of
homeopathic nosodes and placebo have essential differences.
Forsch Komplementärmed 2006. V.13. №5. C.294-297.
•
Korenbaum VI, Chernysheva TN. Study of water-based
electronic-homeopathic nosodes. Abstracts of the 4-th
Conference on Physics, Chemistry and Biology of Water.
October 22-25, 2009, Grand Summit Resort Hotel &
Conference Center, Mount Snow, West Dover, Vermont, USA
www.watercon.org/abstracts.html
THANKS!
Using electronic homeopathic copies of
nosodes in clinical practice under functional
and organic diseases with EEG controlling
Tatiana Chernysheva, MD, PhD
Clinics of Functional Medicine “Manus”
Vladivostok, Russia 2010
25
Study objective
• Using the results indicating that electronic homeopathic
copies are biophysically different from placebo, we tried to
assess the effect of electronic homeopathic copies (EHC) of
nosodes of brain kit in humans.
• Two clinical cases are presented.
• The effect of electronic homeopathic copies (EHC) of brain kit
nosodes was controlled by electroencephalography.
26
Patient P., female
• The patient presented with complaints on gastrointestinal
tract function: abdominal pains, abdominal distension,
eructation, bitter taste in the mouth, unstable stools
(profuse diarrhea). The patient has been treated for 3
years in different clinics with no success.
• Fibrogastroduodenoscopy demonstrated signs of
superficial gastritis. On ultrasound examination diffuse
changes of the pancreas were found, with no increase of
size of the pancreas. The liver was not enlarged. The
gallbladder was unremarkable. Intestinal distention and
abdominal murmur were found during palpation.
Enhanced peristalsis was observed on abdominal
auscultation.
• The above complaints were related to emotional stress.
27
Manual muscle testing with nosodes
• According to the Chr. Smith method, using double therapy
localization on the affected organ (pancreas and duodenum)
we examined the connection with start and end points of the
meridians. Positive TL was found with В1 (decrease of
serotonin) and С1 (increase of norepinephrine).
• Positive reaction to brain kit nosodes:
– Cortex cerebri
– Diencephalon
– Epiphysis
• EEG was performed to confirm psychosomatic origin of the
disease.
28
EEG of patient P. before treatment
“Flat” EEG with low-amplitude α-rhythm. Moderate irritative
processes, increased after hypoxic test. Slight dysfunction of mesencephalic structures.
29
EEG of patient P. after provocation with
water EHС of revealed nosodes
Increase of α-rhythm amplitude. Decrease of irritative processes.
30
Treatment
• Treatment was supplemented with aqueous EHC of the
discovered cerebral nosodes: 25 ml in the morning and in
the evening, during 2 months.
• A repeated EEG was performed in 2 months.
31
EEG of patient P. after treatment
Increase of α-rhythm amplitude up to 60 μV. Decrease of dysfunction of
mes-encephalic structures. Decrease of irritative processes, especially after
hypoxic test.
32
Results
• Noticeable EEG improvement after treatment.
• The patient noted that all the symptoms were gone already
after 2 weeks of EHC treatment, for the first time in 3 years;
she also noted improvement of the general physical wellbeing.
• The patient has been followed for the next 4 years. Her
condition remains stable.
• No gastrointestinal tract disorders were found on functional
examination.
33
Patient E., male.
• Undergoes observation at the clinic from 1994 (since the age of
4). On initial referral: infantile cerebral paralysis, atonic-atactic
type, mental retardation and speech development retardation.
Gait imbalance. Coordination disorder, poor motor skills of the
hands. Autistic behavior.
• The patient was observed at the clinic 2-3 times a year. After
rehabilitation speech and coordination were restored, fine motor
skills improved. The behavior improved.
34
Condition before EHC treatment
• Generally stable tendency to improvement with treatment was
noted on scheduled referral in December 2006.
• However, speech restraint remained; judgment and
behavioral reactions did not correspond to the age.
35
MMT diagnostics with nosodes
• Positive TL to GB1 (decrease of acetylcholine), Li20
(decrease of inhibitory neurotransmitters), CV24
(decrease of dopamine), SP21 (increase of histamine),
L14 (increase of acetylcholine).
• Positive test to brain kit nosodes:
– Cerebrus totalis,
– Cortex cerebri,
– Diencephalon,
– Epiphysis,
– Cerebellum, etc.
• EEG examination was performed to objectify the state of
organic psychopathology.
36
EEG of patient E. before treatment
Residual organic changes with disorganized unstable cortical rhythm with
marked regulatory disorders. Alpha-rhythm with no specific localization,
spreading from caudal to temporal leads. The frequency is 7-11 Hz.
Marked diffuse slow-wave activity. EEG pattern does not comply with
the patient age.
37
Treatment with cerebral nosodes EHC
• Treatment was supplemented with aqueous EHC of the
discovered cerebral nosodes: 25 ml twice a day during 2
weeks.
• EEG was repeated in 2 weeks.
38
Results – subjective observation
• After 2 weeks – abrupt change of behavior. The patient is
more available for contact, answers questions adequately,
speaks logically.
• According to the patient‟s mother, his interests changed:
he started playing more serious computer games,
watching more complicated TV programs, started helping
about the house and showed interest to his mother‟s work.
39
EEG of Patient E. after treatment
Improvement of frequency- and structure-related organization of cortical
rhythm, decrease of regulatory disorders.
40
Objective results of post-treatment
examination
• Frequency- and structure-related organization of the cortical
rhythm improved, while regulatory disorders decreased,
bringing EEG closer to age norm.
• Alpha-rhythm frequency of 8-10 Hz with improved formation of
modulations and location shift to occipital leads.
• Follow-up is going on. The patient completed an individual
program of a general evening school and currently continues
education to become a file clerk.
• Motor function clumsiness and ataxia remain on neurological
examination.
41
Conclusions
• The revealed improvement in EEG pattern of patients treated
with EHC of brain kit nosodes enables to use this method in
the treatment of other patients.
• The use of EHC helps in diagnostics and treatment of
psychosomatic and organic psychopathology of the central
nervous system.
• Studies of the effect of EHC on human body in diagnostics
and treatment should be continued.
42