CITY O F HILLSDALE
Transcription
CITY O F HILLSDALE
Planning Commission 97 North Broad Street Hillsdale, Michigan 49242-1695 (517) 437-6449 Fax: (517) 437-6450 CITY OF HILLSDALE Planning Commission Agenda September 15, 2015 I. Call to Order 5:30 A. B. II. Pledge of Allegiance Roll Call Consent Items/Communications A. Approval of agenda – Action B. Approval of Planning Commission 8.18.2015 minutes – Action C. Minutes from the regular meeting of TIFA – 7.21.2015 D. Minutes from the regular meeting of EDC – 8.20.2015 E. Minutes from the regular meeting of City Council – 8.17.2015 III. Public Comment Agenda items only IV. Site Plan Review A. Final Site Plan for 8 S Manning – Center City Apartments V. Old Business VI. New Business A. R2PC Update – Update VII. Monthly Zoning Ordinance Review VIII. Economic Development Projects in the works around town – Mary Wolfram IX. Public Comment X. Adjournment Next meeting October 20, 2015 at 5:30 pm CITY OF HILLSDALE Planning Commission 97 North Broad Street Hillsdale, Michigan 49242-1695 (517) 437-6456 Fax: (517) 437-6450 PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES REGULAR MEETING CITY HALL, 97 N. BROAD ST. 2nd FLOOR August 18, 2015 at 5:30 PM I. Call to Order 5:31 pm A. Pledge of Allegiance B. Members present: Laura Smith, Mayor Scott Sessions, Jonathan Smith, Sam Nutter, Eric Moore, Amber Yoder C. Others present: Alan Beeker (Zoning Administrator), Mary Wolfram (Economic Development), Travis Berlin, Thomas Novelly (The Collegian) D. Members absent: Kerry Laycock (excused) II. Consent Items/Communications A. Amber Yoder moved to accept the consent agenda as presented. Mayor Sessions seconded, motion passed. III. Public Comment No public comment IV. Public Hearing A. Hillsdale City Master Plan – 2015 Amendment – After months of work, the City’s Master Plan is finally ready to be approved. Chair Smith opened the public hearing. There was no public comment so Chair Smith closed the public hearing and opened discussion with the Commission. With no discussion from the Commission, Sam Nutter moved to recommend the amended Master Plan to Council for adoption. Amber Yoder seconded. Motion passed unanimously. B. HMC Section 36-275 through and including 36-279 – The ordinance codifies the existing sidewalk amenities policy. Chair Smith opened the public hearing, Mr. Novelly from The Collegian asked for a brief synopsis. Chair Smith responded with a brief synopsis. Chair Smith closed the public hearing and opened discussion with the Planning Commission. With no discussion from the Commission, Mayor Sessions moved to recommend the new ordinance to Council for adoption. Jonathan Smith seconded. Motion passed unanimously. V. Site Plan Reviews A. Final Site Plan for Hillsdale College Galloway Parking Lot Expansion – The proposed parking lot is located on the southwest corner of Galloway and N. West Streets. Mr. Beeker gave a quick overview explaining that the Engineer from Fleis & Vandenbrink and the City Department Heads had approved the plans. Mayor Sessions moved to approve the site plan as submitted, Jonathan Smith seconded. Roll call vote. Motion passed 6-0. VI. Old Business A. No Old Business VII. New Business A. R2PC Update – No meeting. VIII. Zoning Ordinance B. Mr. Beeker gave a quick summary of the status of the Landscape and Parking Ordinances. IX. Economic Development Ms. Wolfram informed the Commission of various projects around the City. Hillsdale has been chosen by MEDC to participate in the Rising Tide program. Ms. Wolfram also shared regarding the change in leadership at the Chamber of Commerce. 42 Union is waiting on the Development Agreement. The Microbrewery is still waiting on the deed from the owner. X. Public Comment No public comment XI. Adjournment at 6:00 pm – Amber Yoder moved to adjourn, Mayor Sessions seconded, motion passed. Meeting adjourned. Next meeting: September 15, 2015 at 5:30 pm. CITY OF HILLSDALE Tax Increment Finance Authority TIFA Regular Meeting 3rd Floor City Hall July 21, 2015 I. II. Call to Order at 7:30 am A. Members Present; Chris Sumnar, Mike Parney, Deb Kamen, Saul Giminez, Rob Socha, John Spiteri, Cindy Bieszk, Tim Dixon B. Others present; Alan Beeker (Zoning Administrator), Mary Wolfram (Economic Development), Ruth Brown (County Commissioner) C. Members Absent: Kathy Newell (excused), Chris Bahash A. B. C. D. Consent Agenda Minutes from Regular Meeting 5/19/2015 – draft Minutes: Targeted Development Committee 6/2/2015 – draft Minutes: Targeted Development Committee 6/22/2015 – draft Financial Statements Mike Parney moved to accept the agenda as presented, Cindy Bieszk supported, motion passed. III. IV. Public Comment Ruth Brown commented that she was here to represent the County and the Annex building. Appointments and Elections A. Chair and Vice Chair elections – Deb Kamen moved to nominate Chris Sumnar as Chair and Mike Parney as Vice Chair, Rob Socha seconded, motion passed. B. Appointments – Chris Sumnar moved to recommend to Council the reappointment of Mike Parney to the TIFA Board and moved to set the official number of the TIFA Board at 11 members, Rob Socha seconded, motion passed. C. Mr. Sumnar suggested Leann Creger as a replacement for Keith Miller. V. New Business A. Mary Wolfram introduced City Manager, David Mackie. VI. Committee Reports A. Façade Grant Committee – Saul Giminez, Chair 1. 76 North Street – The owner, Nancy Luetzow, submitted a grant application that included window replacement, new roofing and new exterior cladding and trim and new paint. The estimated cost of the project is $32,917. a. The Board discussed SHIPO rules and the requirement to retain historical significance. This building is listed on the register of national historic places as a contributing building. The main concern was the use of vinyl replacement windows and whether they should be allowed. Due to the cost of the other building improvements, with the window replacement estimate removed, the project still exceeds the $20,000 match amount. Rob Socha moved to approve the grant provided the monies from TIFA do not go toward the window replacements, Tim Dixon seconded. Motion passed. B. Beautification/ Downtown Amenities- Kathy Newell, Chair 1. General Report – multiple large flower pots planted and placed in front of businesses around the downtown. 2. City Hall Sign – The Committee would like to remove the landscaping around the existing city hall sign. MDOT has been contacted to find out what is allowed and construction details for possible screening of the HVAC unit. Deb Kamen suggested that the existing trees be removed and new compact plantings put back. Mike Parney agreed that would be the best approach. Mike Parney moved to remove and replace the existing plantings, Cindy Bieszk seconded, motion passed. C. Development Plan – Chris Sumnar, Chair 1. General Report – Mr. Sumnar would like to include promotion of downtown events in the plan. The Committee will meet before the next regular meeting. D. Targeted Development Committee – Mike Parney, Chair 1. General Report 2. Business Attraction Program (BAP) – Tim moved to accept the BAP with the amendments discussed (see attachment) and to allow Targeted Development to modify as needed. Deb Kamen seconded. Motion passed. 3. 23 & 25 N. Broad St. – TIFA would be interested in looking into the building if it were donated to TIFA. Deb Kamen moved that if the City were to gain control, TIFA would pursue development or demolition of the building. Rob Socha seconded. Motion passed. 4. Microbrewery Update – Roy Finch indicated they are working on a business plan. Kevin Conant indicated that they should be able to close on the building mid-August and will start developing the building plans with the architect the beginning of August. VII. Adjournment – Cindy Bieszk moved, Rob Socha seconded. The meeting was adjourned at 8:40 am Next Meeting: September 15, 2015 at 7:30 am. Business Attraction Program Guidelines All monies available for retail business on first floor only; no professional services Must occupy a currently empty building Available to current building owners who bring in a new business Requires business plan approval All buildings would also be eligible for the $10,000 façade grant Retail business preferred Redundant businesses discouraged Extended operating hours preferred Programs mutually exclusive OWNER ■ Building Improvement Business Attraction □ $30,000 1:1 match directed toward a major building renovation □ Must be a new business to the TIFA district or may be a business that is moving from a leased space to a purchased building □ Secured w/. lien or second mortgage □ Structured as a 5 year forgivable loan; -if the business stays in business for 5 years in the building, the loan is forgiven -if the business goes out of business, the loan is repaid It will be prorated for every year in business, 1/5 of the loan is forgiven ■ Requirements □ Building must be located in the TIFA district on N. Broad St. or N. Howell St. □ TIFA monies are spent on code related building improvements/matching funds may be used for any building improvement □ Acquisition costs are not included as part of the owner’s match □ Based on an acceptable, solid 5 year business plan □ Viable business for min. 5 years □ 5 year lease required. RENTAL ■ Business Attraction/Forgivable Loan □ Up to $10,000 -if the business goes out of business, the loan is repaid It will be prorated for every year in business, 1/3 of the loan is forgiven ■ Requirements □ Startup business □ 3 year lease required □ For any interior building renovations such as flooring, wall covering, mill work. □ Extended hours of operation preferred. □ Improvement receipts must be received within 90 days of business opening □ Renovation plan must be reviewed and approved by the Façade Committee CITY OF HILLSDALE Economic Development Corporation 97 North Broad Street Hillsdale, Michigan 49242-1695 (517) 437-6479 EDC MINUTES REGULAR MEETING CITY HALL, 97 N. BROAD ST., 2ND FLOOR August 20, 2015 at 7:30 am I. Call to Order 7:30 am Members Present: David Loader, Gary Wolfram, Barry Hill, Matt Granata, David Foulke, Dean Affholter, Amanda Janes, Ed Sumnar, Barry Hill, Victoria Bergen Members Absent: J.J. Hodshire, David Foulke Others Present: Alan Beeker (Zoning Administrator), Mary Wolfram (Economic Development), Greg Bailey, Lon King, David Mackie (City Manager), Bruce Sharp (Councilman), Kim Thomas (Assessor) Consent Items/Communications A. B. C. D. E. Approval of Agenda Approval of minutes of the EDC regular meeting – June 18, 2015 Approval of minutes of the Architectural Control Committee –June 30, 2015 Approval of minutes of the Architectural Control Committee –August 14, 2015 EDC Financial Statements Ed Sumnar moved to approve the consent agenda and minutes as amended. Dean Affholter seconded, motion passed. II. Public Comment on Agenda Items No Public Comment III. New Business A. Election of Officers – annual election of EDC officers and member appointment to the Architectural Control Committee (ACC). Mr. Sumnar asked if the members currently in the officer positions wished to continue. Gary Wolfram moved to re-elect the current Chair and Vice-Chair, Ed Sumnar seconded, motion passed. 1. ACC re-appointments – The current members of the committee are Barry Hill, Matt Granata and David Foulke. Dean Affholter moved to retain the committee intact, Ed Sumnar seconded. Motion passed. B. Three Meadows 1. Amendments to the Rights and Restrictions (R&R), esp. Sec. 2.6 & 2.9 – Ms. Wolfram noted that Sidewalks there was one item that did not get into the amendments. i. Ms. Wolfram suggested the removal of the word “Dryvit” and the inclusion of (new definition) ii. Sec. 2.9 - Lon King and Greg Bailey had a question on the sidewalk installation, they feel that the requirement of installing sidewalk by lot should no longer apply since the sales have not been by lot. It should be according to 3 contiguous “properties” not by “lots”. The ACC wanted it left as “lot”. Perhaps it should be a minimum lineal footage or purchased frontage. Change 1 year time frame to 2 years. Remove ACC from taking monies. iii. Change the Sec. 1.7 from 7 days to 21 days. iv. Ask Jack to renumber rather than have 8.10-1. Verify with Jack that there is an appeal process to the Home Owners Association. v. Matt moved to approved as presented with meeting changes, Dean Seconded, motion passed. 2. Lot owners meeting date – cannot set a date until the rights and restrictions document is complete. 3. Collection of Homeowners Association fees, Sec. 4.1 – Now that the R&R is amended, should the fees be collected? The fees would be used to cover maintenance costs. 4. Master plan for the planting of trees, Sec. 2.11 – Gary Stachowicz still needs to design the master plan for tree plantings. 5. Future plans/marketing/business attraction policy – Councilman Bruce Sharp spoke to the need for better accessibility into Three Meadows. There should be a road from Bacon St. into the park for better emergency vehicle ingress and possibly better marketing. EDC will look into the costs of implementing the next phases. C. Tax Abatements 1. EDC oversight, Fee schedule, Scoring system – The EDC is the traditional body to deal with tax abatements. The City Assessor, Kim Thomas and City Manager, David Mackie are asking the EDC to evaluate whether the City should continue charging fees for the processing of the abatement applications. Most communities do not charge the fees or require questionnaires, etc. Ed Sumnar does not like the idea of the fees. He does not feel that the EDC should be involved. Ed Sumnar suggests that the City Manager and the City Assessor should do all of the abatement scoring and send it to Council directly without the involvement of EDC. Dean Affholter asked if the EDC should stay involved in the event that a future City Manager does not agree to allow any tax abatements. Dean Affholter moved to amend and simplify the process and the EDC would recommend to Council. David Loader seconded, motion passed. IV. Committee Reports A. Three Meadows Architectural Control Committee – Barry Hill, David Foulke, Matt Granata 1. Lot purchase update – Two lot sales are pending. 2. HCISD Construction Trades – Chris Eggleston (Trades Instructor) is meeting with the ACC on Aug. 21 to submit plans and samples for approval. B. Manufacturing & Technology Park 1. 911 Emergency Services Purchase – Update – The parcel in the Manufacturing Park has been sold and plans are moving forward with the new office building. 2. Park Certification thru Michigan Economic Developers Association (MEDA) – the inspectors mentioned that the road infrastructure in the park needs improvement. The inspectors also cited that the overall appearance did not indicate prosperity. The Committee will create a list of things that can be done that will improve the park. Ms. Wolfram noted that there is no sign in the park that has contact information regarding the land for sale. Ms. Wolfram suggested that there be pairings with future retention visits and other department representatives. C. Other Projects – Ed Sumnar, Matt Granata, David Loader, Dean Affholter 1. Center for Family Health – construction of the new office building is slated for next year. 2. Advertisements and articles – Ms. Wolfram requested input from the committee regarding advertising options to pursue in the future. V. Economic Development Update/Board Round Table No comment VI. Adjournment at 9:51 am Dean Affholter moved to adjourn, Matt Granata seconded, motion passed. Next Meeting: 7:30 am, October 15 or 22, 2015 Council Chambers Hillsdale City Hall 97 N. Broad St. Hillsdale, MI 49242 August 17, 2015 7:00 p.m. (517)437-6441 www.cityofhillsdale.org CITY COUNCIL MINUTES City of Hillsdale Regular Meeting Call to Order and Pledge of Allegiance Mayor Scott Sessions opened the meeting with the pledge of allegiance. Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Stockford, to excuse the absence of Ward One Councilperson Watkins from the August 17, 2105 meeting. All ayes. Motion carried. Roll Call Mayor Scott Sessions called the meeting to order with the following Council members present: Councilmember Adam Stockford representing Ward One; Councilmember Sally Kinney representing Ward Two; Councilmembers Emily Stack-Davis and Bruce Sharp representing Ward Three; and Councilmembers Mary Beth Bail and Patrick Flannery representing Ward Four. Also present were: City Manager David Mackie, City Clerk Michelle Loren, Kay Freese (HR), Bonnie Tew (Finance), Chief Scott Hephner (HCPD), Chief Kevin Pauken (HCFD), Keith Richard (DPS), Ruth Brown, Eldonna Bernath, Samuel Nutter, Julie Beeker, Shirley VanArsdalen, Josh Colletta, Andy Barrand (HDN), Cindy Bieszk, Chris Sumnar, Penny Swan, Holly Carpenter, Rich Péwé, Mary Wolfram (HPG). 7 Present, 1 Absent Approval of Agenda Councilperson Stockford requested New Business Item F. Diversion Program be added to the August 17, 2015 Agenda. Motion by Councilperson Sharp, supported by Councilperson Davis, to approve the August 17, 2015 Council Agenda as amended. All ayes. Motion carried. Public Comment County Commissioner Ruth Brown reported there would be a County Commissioners meeting regarding the Diversion Program scheduled sometime during the week of August 24th and encouraged attendance by council members. Chris Sumnar expressed his support of the law office of Marcoux Allen for the city attorney appointment. Cindy Bieszk, owner of Hillsdale Filling Station, expressed her support of the passing of the overnight parking ordinance amendment. Consent Agenda A. Approval of Bills from claims of July 30, 2015; Claims of $90,632.29; Payroll of $94,457.70. B. Committee Reports (Pending Approval) C. Council Minutes of August 3, 2015 D. July 2015 Code Enforcement Report Motion by Councilperson Stack-Davis, supported by Councilperson Flannery, to approve the Consent Agenda as presented. Roll call: Councilpersons Stack-Davis – yes; Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Bail – yes. Motion carried 7-0. Communications and Petitions None Introduction and Adoption of Ordinances/Public Hearings A. Public Hearing: Board of Review Ordinance Amendment. Mayor Sessions opened the publics hearing in order to receive public comment; no public comment. Mayor Sessions opened the floor for Council discussion; no comment. Mayor Sessions closed the public hearing. Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Flannery, to adopt Ordinance No. 201511 Amended Board of Review. Roll call; Councilpersons Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilpersons Bail – yes; Stack Davis – yes. Motion carried 7-0. B. Public Hearing; Overnight Parking Ordinance Amendment. Mayor Sessions opened the public hearing in order to receive public comment; no public comment. Mayor Sessions opened the floor for Council discussion. Councilperson Sharp expressed his concern with the Midtown Parking Lot snow removal with the passing of the amended overnight parking ordinance. Motion by Councilperson Stack-Davis, supported by Councilperson Sharp, to adopt Ordinance No. 201512 Overnight Parking Ordinance Amendment. Roll call: Councilpersons Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilpersons Bail – yes; Stack-Davis – yes; Flannery – yes; Motion carried 7-0. Unfinished Business A. Local Streets Maintenance: None B. Code Enforcement. None C. Clerk & Treasurer. None Old Business A. 2015 Uniform Service Agreement. Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Stack-Davis, to authorize the Mayor and Clerk’s signatures on the Arrow Uniform Service Agreement. Roll call: Councilpersons Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilpersons Bail – yes; Stack-Davis – no; Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes. Motion carried 7-0. B. Mayoral Appointment for Legal Services. Mayor Sessions announced his recommendation for the appointment of the law firm Marcoux Allen for City legal services. Mayor Sessions stated he reviewed input by councilmembers from the Special Meeting regarding legal services held on August 11, 2015 as well as held meetings with both Fink and Marcoux Allen. Mayor Sessions based his recommendation on consideration of location, fees, and council consensus. Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Bail, to award legal services to Marcoux Allen. Roll call: Councilpersons Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilpersons Bail – yes; Stack-Davis – yes; Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes. Motion carried 7-0. New Business A. Lot Division Approval for Reconfiguration of Parcels Blackmar & Beebe’s Addition Lots 36-44. Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Stack-Davis, to approve the Lot division of Lots 36-44, Blackmar & Beebe’s Addition. Roll call: Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilpersons Bail – yes; Stack-Davis – yes; Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes. Motion carried 7-0. B. Motion by Councilperson Stack-Davis, supported by Councilperson Bail, to adopt Resolution No. 3237 John & Ginger Mach NEZ Application. Roll call: Councilpersons Bail - yes; Stack-Davis – yes; Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes. Motion carried 7-0. C. Motion by Councilperson Stack-Davis, supported by Councilperson Kinney, to adopt Resolution No. 3238 ISD NEZ application. Roll call: Councilpersons Stack-Davis – yes; Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilperson Bail – yes. Motion carried 7-0. D.. Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Bail, to approve the pur-. chase of BS&A Inventory & Work Order Software and authorize signatures by the Mayor and Clerk. Roll call: Councilpersons Flannery – yes; Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilpersons Bail – yes; Stack-Davis – yes. Motion carried 7-0. E. Motion by Councilperson Stack-Davis, supported by Councilperson Sharp, to approve the Division of Lot 18: parcel 006-237-340-18 and Lot 19: parcel 006-237-340-19 of Three Meadows Subdivision. Roll call: Councilpersons Kinney – yes; Sharp – yes; Stockford – yes; Mayor Sessions – yes; Councilpersons Bail – yes; Stack-Davis – yes; Flannery – yes. Motion carried 7-0. F. County Diversion Program. Councilpersons Stockford stated he would like to see Council step forward in support of the County’s Diversion Program by submitting a letter to the County stating so. Councilperson Stockford, as well as Councilperson Sharp expressed strong support of the program as they had worked with individuals from that program during the Airport Cleanup Project. Councilperson Stockford asked that any councilmember interested in signing a drafted letter of supported should see him. Miscellaneous A. Appointments: Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Stockford, to reappoint Mike Parney to TIFA for a four year term ending July, 2019. All ayes. Motion carried. City Manager Report City Manager David Mackie reported the Recreation Department had been awarded a grant in the amount of $7,700 for the purchase of 100 new football helmets. Mr. Mackie reported the Hillsdale Industrial/Tech Park had been certified, providing another important avenue for marketing. Sunday, August 23rd at 3:00 a Memorial Dedication was to take place at Oak Grove Cemetery. General Public Comment County Commissioner Ruth Brown again spoke in support of the Diversion Program. Holly Carpenter stated the Story Walk installed by her Girl Scouts troop had been stolen/vandalized the day after installation and thanked Councilperson Stockford and City Manager Mackie for their help in restoring it. Council Comment Councilperson Sharp replied to Ms. Carpenter’s comments regarding the Story Walk and stated the community cares about the Girl Scouts. Councilperson Stockford stated “Go Girl Scouts” Discussion regarding eligibility and qualifications for running for council seats. Council members agreed they need to hold further discussion in regard to the possible amendment of charter concerning eligibility and qualifications of council candidates. It was agreed to place it on the agenda for Council discussion. Adjournment Motion by Councilperson Kinney, supported by Councilperson Stack-Davis, to adjourn. All ayes. Meeting adjourned. 8;05 p.m. ____________________ Scott M. Sessions, Mayor _____________________ Michelle Loren, City Clerk EXISTING ONESTORY BUILDING TO BE DEMOLISHED ...\Hillsdale\SD-01.dgn 9/3/2015 10:31:30 AM ...\Hillsdale\SD-02.dgn 9/3/2015 10:32:35 AM ...\Hillsdale\SD-03.dgn 9/3/2015 10:33:10 AM ...\Hillsdale\SD-04.dgn 9/3/2015 10:33:40 AM ...\Hillsdale\SD-05.dgn 9/3/2015 10:34:09 AM ...\Hillsdale\SD-06.dgn 9/3/2015 10:36:08 AM ...\Hillsdale\SLSP-01.dgn 9/3/2015 10:38:09 AM PR.1 Project #: P11605 Date: 9/3/2015 HILLSDALE, MI CITY CENTER APARTMENTS RY A IN N IM FOR TIO L E T C PR NO TRU NS O C EXCEL REALTY PROPOSED EXTERIOR ELEVATIONS