View Details - Haryana State Pollution Control Board

H.ARYAIYA STATE POLLUTION CONTROL
BOARD
\17
HAFGB
Noo.
",,S;]"1;"",YSI; l",T_gXT.l#..-
rrsPcB/2S9l2016/
li:ii"j?,?l"llfltHili;i tij;ij#;,:,ti:i'::";:ti:,,"
0".
Sub Proce.dltrC/ntnutes of the DUbUc consul
-,lirill,iil''tion rHe*rtrsr
P'ohsions or EtA
uDdd the
;
"..'n.,,t"i,
m::.-':;::x;":1.*::"sli##"r.i.;i.","
prolect srte village Lapn. Tehsit
Jaeadh
" ii#,
:llrsl;::x;;:h ji"."#:,:,::l:f{1l::i#J1il:r.YB1:
t
(i)rdtr.reler ro ihe subje.r norcd
abo\...
PLeasc 6nd enctosed heEtrilh
ihe procee
:,-,.i::;,:l
:,;J:'
!;"t;
1',, ;'. -.*l
" "i
";j;ri
r
"r.'-:" .a ,"";-";
"
;
;"":
::_
"l;l"t.li.
ll,"L_.'
"y! [i_]I:i";"f ill" "1,1 " " " " ao ooo","
;.""" ard dh7 re,evu,
0""_.." r". ;i.*.--,,
_;;:;,"il::::_
s..
:""i:i-ehs
e."i.o"-""t.r e.gi,J.,
- r 6rq1
Forcbailnan
(ttB _ Ktgd
q,
r.
.
:::: :: ; ::$:;e"*-7'{
""'t;"1;iir;x;.:;i
-- -s -"'-'- t;..'
n:'.';i". ;;.;;, i\- AA B' \o
' :ill'li,?,,,,**"*" to covt Harlara. Enllronm.nt Depatment,
Endsr..No.
Hspc'/2scl2otor
:l
3
-]
I
7
a
S
The Dnecto. cene.at.
:
Enlronmeri. Hdana
fhe Depnrr Codmissioner yamun. \,41
The lhrmm.I a Frrsh:d, yduna \aear
Munrcinal coun.Lt l Jmund Naear.
Regondl a)fiicer, y@uM Naad He is .equired io
au rhe concerned v rase pdr;hyar ror
li.i"::**" '"
PS to ChairDal
PA to tMedber Sec.erd
-d..o\a.r-a..r poe,J, n..
r uoroJ r'g F pro eFd e o
ueb
.h"
r'" rhe Bod
'
rl M/s Apar tvtines N4maSement senices pyr Ltd. A lo3, Designer pdr
1pa. nr a6. p or No. B o/ |
se {o. 02 \o\ a I
DA/!o y !i P or€ed rs.
----O ",
1'9F..\@--
",.r."o."-.".""i"R-El'q
nesional
officl{6
y S_r1re pouurion ConFol Board
.
'.! v Ne i n,f@Frl,
"
No. LtsPcB
^
^!ql'g
taSadhri
(yM@
/ yMNT-2015/:199...
NaSu), ph
_
0laz 200l'
Dr:..[.2-la4/2016
traryana State polulion Cornrot Boad.
Panchkula
-.fff, '{tiilfl
flii:fri'iii{.1{t-sff rii:[1#El$df;ff
ii?iii_n$--h:l!xrJtr":.:n,.'#T.:"d[r*r*;#;.#
un.rmaEhtp orDr. s.s. phu a t.A.s.. D€pury commts6io";r,
t;.;;;N;;;'
Ptease
let$
to th€ subject noled above.
h ihis
conneclion, ptease nnd enclosed heEMh two copies
of pbceeding /
minutes of Pubtic Headng in odginatheld on 05.04.2016
at O2:oo ptvtar site i.e. Vilaoe
Lapla. Iehsit -Jagadhad, Oistrict-yamuna Nagar undd he
Chaimanship ot Deputv
commissioner,YarnunaNagar'.-.
-- ..
Trc s€ts of soft copy of the
-
- ".. ..
vidoography, pholo Atbuns
alt€ndanc€ b also enctos€d herowith fo. @dy refe€nc€,
&
phoiocopy of
ptase.
submitted tor fudher neoessary actjon, ptease.
**,ffi*
)tr
OFFICE NOTE
l.
HsPcBl20t6/ 5703 _ 5705 darod 26.02,2016
HSPCB/2016/ 5715 _ 5717 dated 26.02.20,1 6
2.
3. HSPCB2016/
4. HSPC82016/
5679
_
5€S1 dated 26.02.2016
t691 _ 5693 dat€d 26.02.2016
prcvrsron or Era Notircation
ff&"f 1""',"Tl"J',ifi ,l;"Jjlg.und€r th.
c_fe,l€ne to puc No, I to 4 the M€mber s€ceiary Haryana
sLaie poltution
----_|n
bodo,had b€en direcied to R6gonat ofiier, y6Duna Nasair" _ni."r
iv"i v
y.mm. Nasar ror tixing tne dar€ and
prurr"
Um;
or
no",irc
i"',
-Lomm$|4er.
*sa,. worrhy Depury commrlsio"", i,"" i""Ju,"ijiJ
:,g:ff 11"?:y;T.""'*"
Sr,
1
2
No. ztFL (A), ModetToMr, Rohrat,
haryana m r$pect of th6 Sind Minor minerat (Rivor Bed
Mrnrno in Virtage cumthata TehsitRad.ur Nonh Bbctd yNR
B_
16'having lenlatile a€a of 44.62 h€ctaEs in dtstnct ya,,rLna
Nasa, Haryatra
publlc [email protected]
04.04.2016al2oOPM
V/s Apar Minss Maragerer't Sdias pvt Lrd, Anm, 04.04,2016
o6;9ner Pan Apamonts ptor No. B 9/1 Sec@r62 Noida,
u.P. in rospecr oi rhe BourdeB. c6v€ts and sano (Minor
mineED (Ou6lds Rivn 8ed Miningl h Viltage Nsndgaft. Tehsit
uhnachraut, Nandgaft Btoctd YNR 8-36 havino lsnt tve aq
hechE in dlslnct Yamuna Naoar, Han€na
lws Apar l,lines Manamenr +oie! Ffr-riJ_ ,l-ror, 05.04.2016
Dsigner Pert Aparhents, ptot No B g/1, Sectol{2, Noitta,
at
11JO
at
O2r0o
at
11:30
oI29.60
3
U.P in resp€ct or the Sand (Mtno! mineEt) (River Bed Mrnins)
inMllago LapE, TehsrtJagaoh , LapE Btoci/ yNR B lOnavng
tentative area of 34.28 hgctaB in disricr yamuna Ndgur,
naryana
[,?s saheranpul Mines rrranagehsas€Mcea-fr:TE;shii 05.04,2016
No, 12, Mukund Market, Janakpur Chowk, Saharanrur, U.p. in
Bpecl ot
Bouldels, GEvel and Sand (Minor minerat)
(ouiside River 8ed Minhg) in vitlase ft4andewata, Tehstl
Chhachrauli, Mandewala Biock/YNR 8,38 having lentalive aea
of 15.00 heclres in district Yamuna Nasar, Hsryana
te
.
Ihe.oiie
Egading the Plblic H€aring was pubtished in teading newspap€,. Tne
Public Heanng was conducled on above said dats and !me, The Gove.nment Offi@6/
Official6 of ihe Disldd Admlnislalio. and tne resident
oi nea.by vlllagsB were prseni
dudng tI€ public heariry al above m6i loned s[63. The headng was also anended by rhe
palhe6 of poject prcponent. The copy ot proce6dinghlnutgs of Pubtic Headng atongwilh
CD/PhologEphs collecl€d dudng ine ijme ol h4ring. lt is submitted tor your kind
consideBtion and approval so that the Finules of lheso hearing alongwi0r CD and
Pholographs can be seni 1o ihe conpetent auihority for lhe apprc'val ol lhe pEjecrs for
/')
'./
sadeer
Wal
Di.
Depuiy com?jssioi',l
)n{
fi
im*l;',,u*rfru"r'';*'u's*n***,,s,*'l:r
The Plbrc consuttalbn {h€anng) was
hed as a mandak
r",*1ff
1..*.:1",:,",,u;"#;i ;"T:ri:ll, :il"me
urder E'A nor,'ica, o-
venue: Ai Site Vilago L.pra, Tehs nagadha
, Disr ct_yamuna Nagar, Haryana.
Chaiman: Or. S.S. phtitia LA.S., Oepury Commissioner, yanuna
Naga..
Oflier / Oftciats pre€nt
L Sh. Sanjev Kumar, Resionat Officer Yamuna
Nagar Region, Haq"na sbte
Pollulion Codrot Boad
2. Sh- Vpin Kumd, AEE, yamuna
Nagar Region, Haryana State po ulion
Conlml
3.
4
5.
6.
7.
Sh. F€Fev, M,ning Oiticer, yamuha Naaar.
Sh. RanbtrSen, APRO, yamuna Naoar:
Sh, On Our, tiining lnspeclor, yamuna Naoar
Sh. KurdE Rah. Superjnlendent GMDTC y;muna Nagar.
Sh RS Yadsv, Envrrcnment ConsLttanr. M/s Varoan Envtronet,
Curqaon.
Bsides govenment oficere/oiticiats ol ihe Djsfict AdministElion
number of peFon frcm vjlage
'.e 45 and d6t ct Yamuna Nagar .nd other nea6y vi aiJes wnec presenr
dunng the pubtic
Pea'ns at the sire Vi as6 Lap€ ror ooposeo p.;"a
n"",i.g *r"
PadneB ol Prciect PrcDonenr
r."
"tro
ft""iioli
(copy of.lhe anendane cD ano photogEphs pcpaeo
durhg fearing arc enclosed
Copy of rho executive summary ot lhe EtA of "yamuna Nagar
mining of Sand (Minor
Mineral)' at Village Lapa, Tehsit - Jagadha.i, Distrjcr_yamuna 1"i",,
n"ry"i" r",
pbPosed minjng were dilt buted to the audience pesent
in lhe hoa nq.
Al the outset, Sh. R.S, Yadav,
Envnonment Corsuflanl (A4/s Vardan Ervnonet, cuqaon)
welcomed ihe Commilte hembeB, ofijeE f6m the Haryana State polution
BoaJ an;
audiene prcsent in lhe lubtic hea ng,
Sanieev Kumar. Rogonat Ofitcer. yamuna Nagdr Regioi. Harysna State polur,on
Convol
B@d, @l@med the Deputy Comm6soner, yamLna Nagar Oft@B ot rhe oEvicr
AdministElio., panches & Salpanches of suirounding area and plbtic present jn the heafing.
He explained aboul the n*ssiry ot the pubtic hearing being hetd undd pbvision or Eti
noiilielion of 2006, amended to date. He detaited its tegat equirement for oblaining ctearan@
under lhe.olilicalion ftom MoEF, Govi. of India. He padtcdarty emphasised thai lhose pesenl
in lhe headng should Ei*d $en quanies/suss*rion/objection esarding any probtem which
may crop aner lle coming of this prcject. He added lhat Haryaia Srare potiurion Conrrol Board
bound ro implengnt in Envionh€ntat Laws i.e. warer AcV Air AcV Ep Act.
Funher fomal pemi$iotr to inaugurate the proess of pubtic hernns was guaEnteed by the
chaiman Dr, S,S, Phutia, LA.s., Depury commjssioner, yamuna Nag3r.
Theeafrer Sanjeev kumar, Regional Ofii@r, - requested prcject consuttant
presenlalion for the pojeci for inioinalion of all the people pr€s€nl,
to mak€
the
The Prcject Consultant while making lhe p€senlalion made a montioned thai the DrcDosed
prcject as a pbposalor hvebed minor minehJ ninins and aroa ot 34.28 ha. in above men oned
)r1
village oi disticl yamuna Nag.r,
tola,
a|so exprain the folowms:
l.
cct
ot lhe
p'je".
4,
Poject Loetion
Satient FearuEs or poject
Descndion of poject
Benefn offt€ pbj€ct
o
Mininq Capacity, Raw materiat and Ay products
ropogEphi€t map
2,
3-
5
sha,t b€ Rs.i 5.5O
qorE.
Consutraqt
*rd rrcrudins Air. water. so,rquariry ard Noise Lever
.: ff::Tll-"-i""-1l."*1
emFson and conlotneasures
9.
Sotid Waste Managemenr
10. Noise Msnag6ment
1r. G@r Dev6lopm6 pt.n
12. Envkonment Managemoni ptan
13. Co.tor Environme llranagement plan
14, Corpo6te Social Responsibitiiy
The details submilted by the consuttanl
@€
r€corded.
Aier the.pe*nbrion Saqeev Klmcr. Regionat Omer, ramlna
Naqar, Haryan!
Porluiion
Conr/or Board Eqoesred tre pubt,c to
6is
rhen
questionvrrgg""i.on,ou;""iion.
-"-
Stare
Dr. S.S. Phulia, l.A.S,, Deputy Comnissioner, yamsna
Nagar, the bdef inlroduciion ega.ding
this pmject has ben givd and also discussed the prcspeclive
and benef s ot ihe Mi;ng o;
Th€ following questions
1.
Nams:
Sh_
1. First
rere 6ised:
Aziz Khan, Sarranch. Villao€_
llpra
ot atl, hs wetcomed ihe Deputy Commissioner and
a
OffbeB oi @ncslned
He suppoded this mining project on bghalf of
viltageB of vllage Lap6 being saDanch
or GEm Panchay?l and rold ihar this nirins project wi
seneEte r\e eriploimeni
opponrniti* ior the vilagec and this mining pmjecl wil nol
proUr", ro
villageB and surcunding environmeDi if tease hotdercompty al ""u"e
"ny
lhe Gove.nment Rutes
.nd RegutatioDs.
2_ He quosrioned thal how much wj[ be rh€ depih or maning?
3. He abo qu*iioned that what is the provision to compensaie ihe land owner whose
land
ae lalling
in this minins prcjeot?
1. The Environment Consultanvlease
hoJder explained thal this is an eco friendty sand
nining pojeci and lhis kind of mining/exevaiion ih nverbed wil prevent rhe iooding
and all4 the rlver to tow smooihty in a channet. In thjs mining prcject about 3OO-400
2.
3.
peBons will bo employed direcl and indirecl both ways in which 53 skil€d and semiskilled manporer witl be deptoyed. About 4045 dumpeG wi be deployed lor
tEnsporlalion tor which 4-5 d.ive6/cleaners/hetpeF per dumper are eqli€d. Small
wo*shops for epair ot vehictes and n.chtn€ries, hotets, Estaubnt, vegerabtos
shops, tea slall wirl be opened nearbythis prcjecl aea. Biitctefts, pr.ounl pe6ons,
Guads, Gadner willalso bo deplor€d. In lhis way The lease holdersssued thar lhe
fFl preterene will be given to lo@l villageB only lof the employm€nl.
The corsultanl explained that 3m depih is pemined in rhis mining prcject by tho
Mining Ooparhont.
The Envjonment consulanttease holder explained lhat berore shn of minins
opeEtion lhe lea* holder will 6etrled ihe compensation in mutualty agEed tinancial
4
1'\
lem6 with tand owne6 ohose rand re falng
unoer ,n $E mnjng poiecl. The
Gov€uDmenl oopannenb uI s@pl th6
mutu-at set emenr w4atev4 fray be
rhe
The consultant subm ted that the teas6 holder
wilt Drovide a budgetof R3. 13.50
Lakhs
ftrr
CSR adrynies every year h *hlch hoatth 6mos
vocstionat iEtnings wilt be
org€nizsd. Schotachrps wilt be pmvrded ro rhe
srud;nb of VllageB. Odnking water
Ecnry Mn a|e bepbvidedto rhe vrlase,s
2,
ilan.: Saniav Kumar. RO. Ha anast t Pollution controt
80ard
Ou6: He questioned tnat:
r. wEt wiit b6 the pEventive measues lo
2,
ln tne rainy s€ason mjnlng
wil be c€ried
1. The Environmenl Consut€nl Sn. RS yaddv reptied hal
rher6 aE n o source ot
porunon: one 6 rlnn;ng oi nachines .n acrive m.njng
aea and
air
se@nd B
lEnsport tion ot vehictes on Kachcha ,oad6, tor wtich jegutar
spdnkting of waler witl
be--@fled our^anrrs 50 KLD wate, per day wirt De Dovded
for rhis puroose.
2.
Other
be p.ovido for rhe ptanEnon and approx loOO Nos
of
pEnrs every year sitt be ptamed on borh
side ot haut road and he* p,anB w:l be
fegurany nairrained by prcvjding manure and water and these
tees *ti te iretptu[o
@ntiol ihe air poitulion. The mjnorat toaded lrucks atso cove.ed
wilh taDaut; and
lrucks qllbe plyng in stow speed. Th6 mDrig opeEtion wrtbe tempo€ry
srspenoed
oumg heary wind flow k) curb theanpoltulron.
Tis clnsultant exptained that the mining wil be caded out only 3OO days ool
of 36s
days h a year and rtis provision atso siven jn appoved t ining ptan
rhis pojecl.
Oudng rairysson nomininq opeEtion wifbe @ded our.
i
3.
Nmo: Or. S.S. Phllia. tAS. Depurv Commi$ton.r. yduna
oi S.S. Phllia,lAS, Oeput Commissioner, yamuna Nagarhas
holder ihat unii wjll conply with a the dnedion/orders ot
Tribunal and other Courls atso.
Reply: Th€
lea*
holder assu€d he wilt compty alt the dieclions/Ord€c of Hon,bte
At last Sanjeev Kuma., Regionat Officer, Yamuna Naga. Regjon thanked rhe plbtic tor
atlending lhe pubric hearing.
The publrc hea ngwas colcluded *irh the vo'e ol Uands to the chai'
R6gion.l
Haryana State Pollutlon Conrtul
Yamuna Nasar Rosron.
Dr. S,g Phulla,1,4
D€Puty Coft ni$ion.rcumrhairman
lw